My heart warms hearing Muslims talking about their "Christian and Jewish brothers and sisters", aknowledging the same roots of their religions. You are rare gems! Me: just some random peace loving evolution theorist.
Forgive me if I'm being or sounding partial , but ! Mr shabbir ally seems to be a very considerate and understanding human being than all of the other muslim scholars and debaters I've witnessed ? He does not condemn or demean or ridicule any of the scriptures of christianity infact he tries to scrutinize n reason out with deep respect and understanding towards the sentiments of the opposite party discussing the issue that is debated ? I respect this human being not because he is any way supportive but he shows mature characteristics that a true person of God should posess toward the truth ?
Thank you for sharing this lovely message and watching Let the Quran Speak! We appreciate your kind words about Dr. Shabir. We will convey your message to him.
They are all good scholars with their own way of teaching righteousness to the believers and especially to Muslim listeners. Righteousness in Islam can be viewed as being firm with non conservative* narrative, it can be kindness to everyone like in this example, but also it can be scholarly integrity without any filters, and this last one is the most praised by Muslims. I think, this is how God protected our scriptures, Quran in particular Peace upon you
75. “And indeed Noah did call upon Us, and the most excellent answerer (of prayer are We).” 76. “And We delivered him and his people from the great distress,” 77. “And We made (only) his progeny the survivors.” 78. “And We perpetuated to him (praise) among the later generations.” 79. “Peace be on Noah among the nations.” 80. “Verily thus do We recompense the doers of good.” 81. “Verily he was (one) of Our faithful servants.” 82. “Then We drowned the others.” Quran 37:75-82
🤺☦🇷🇺Well, that's a first...I didn't know Muslims conform their holy book to the popular theories in science, and change the meaning of their teaching of the history of mankind accordingly...🤔No, actually science claims that human genetics are derived from only ONE man and one woman, while we say that, no, it is derived from THREE brothers - Noah's sons, and that explains the "genetic diversity", that you claim the Bible contradicts. Very disappointed of you, Muslim brother...😪
@@EasternRomeOrthodoxythe Quran doesn't teach that the flood during the time of Noah was a universal flood. It teaches that the flood of Noah was a regional flood, not a global flood.
@@hassanabdur-rahman1559 That's is nonsense. That is only your LATER exegesis and it's not in the Quran. If it was I wouldn't have respect for it, since that destroys the whole point of the story of re-birth of all mankind and God's miraculous divine decree!! Man, I am so disappointed with you Muslims...you sound like the secularists and evolutionists...I mean that interpretation is soo shallow and dumb! You should quit that embarrassment and fast, it only hurts you, how can you NOT see it???🤦
@@EasternRomeOrthodoxy who are you to determine how the Quran is interpreted? The Quran is clear, it doesn't describe the flood of Noah as being universal, but it describes it as being regional to the people of Noah.
@@pebystroll 🤺☦🇷🇺Why? Because God's reasoning is not man's reasoning, and we can't comprehend with our human minds the divine goal! It wasn't a "simple mistake". Tradition teaches us that he was acting in a vile and disrespectful manner when he was exposed to Noah's nakedness, so get education, you have a lot to learn, since you read scripture and interpret it yourself as the heretic Protestant infidels. Well, that's a first...I didn't know Muslims conform their holy book to the popular theories in science, and change the meaning of their teaching of the history of mankind accordingly...🤔No, actually science claims that human genetics are derived from only ONE man and one woman, while we say that, no, it is derived from THREE brothers - Noah's sons, and that is explains the "genetic diversity", that you claim the Bible contradicts. Very disappointed of you, Muslim brother...😪
i dont mean to be off topic but does any of you know a trick to get back into an Instagram account? I was dumb lost the password. I appreciate any tips you can give me
@David Jaxx thanks for your reply. I got to the site thru google and I'm trying it out atm. Looks like it's gonna take quite some time so I will reply here later with my results.
@@saputrasaputra2365 🤺☦🇷🇺Well, that's a first...I didn't know Muslims conform their holy book to the popular theories in science, and change the meaning of their teaching of the history of mankind accordingly...🤔No, actually science claims that human genetics are derived from only ONE man and one woman, while we say that, no, it is derived from THREE brothers - Noah's sons, and that is explains the "genetic diversity", that you claim the Bible contradicts. Very disappointed of you, Muslim brother...😪
I like listening to Jews, Muslims, and Christians talk. Mostly Muslims and Jews, it seems they have better grasp on early history which we all want to learn.
if possible, for the upcoming show, could you provide the two book Qur'an and Bible side by side so the sheikh can point us the line within the Qur'an and Bible for our reference?
Very interesting. I have to say though, in the God gives the wine and He also drinks the wine. Joel 2:19 "The LORD replied to them: “I am sending you grain, new wine and olive oil, enough to satisfy you fully; never again will I make you an object of scorn to the nations." Numbers 15:10 (this is a law) "and also bring half a hin of wine as a drink offering. This will be a food offering, an aroma pleasing to the LORD." In Numbers( a bible book) God requires a drink offering. This is symbolic of drinking the wine. Now, nothing in itself is a sin. But like Jesus said, "if something causes you to sin, cut it off." I really enjoyed this video.
Shame on both of u for not doing anything for the Kashmiris just fighting . When we become free and make are own country watch what we will do we will help are ummah ❤️
Scientists??? What does science have to do with faith? Are some ppl only willing and able to believe in a God that THEY can understand with their human mind. Thank you Father Jesus that your ways are not mine and as high as the sky is over my head is as high as your thoughts are over mine. 🙏🏽🙌🏾👏🏾
I think that the most important fact that we all need to understand is that all prophets were human beings and all have made mistakes. Even the first human beings, Adam and Eve, were the first to sin and bring in corruption to all mankind. Although prophets were entrusted people who represented the Most High, they were still merely humans who were not perfect beings, however the Creator chose them due to whatever He saw beneficial in them to carry out His will. I really respect how this brother uses both books to help all people understand the Creator's message. Thank you 🤗
I understand the idea of the prophets not being perfect and prone to committing some honest mistakes, but come on. They're literally agents of God, specifically chosen because of their sheer determination and unshakable faith. If they're supposed to be leaders of nations, or recipients of divine messages, what kind of role model would they be if they got drunk, committed adultery, murder, sorcery and blasphemy? This is just going too far.
sin is a major theme in hebrew scripture and prophets were not exempt. The quaran does not emphasise the human weakness and the fallen nature. This is a major difference between Jewish/Christian naratives and islamic narratives. The biblical story seems to be more relevant to the current human condition and the historical evidence of ancient vineyards inthe middle east.
@@wasimsheik4654 yep read more now thanks to scholars like Dr Shabir and Dr Naik. Also was fortunate to learn the foundations of both religions. my comment is mainly based on the video and the contrasting narratives. therefore are no rocks just my conclusions
The biblical story reflects the mindsets of those "inspired authors/scribes" than the actual human psyche. It's like if the prophets were superheroes like Superman or Captain America, they turned them into Homelander or Tony Stark to make them "more relatable" simply because they found it too difficult to live up to their set examples.
I want to share Genesis chapter 9 and quote some of the comments of Rashi, a well-known Jewish exegete from the 11th century. The reason why I'm showing this, is because a lot of this is unknown to most people (Christians and Muslims alike), and it's interesting stuff. Note that this is classical exegesis, and that this is from the Jewish tradition. Also note that some of it can be quite shocking. I'll quote a verse and add Rashi's explanation, so it can be seen what they themselves say about prophet Nuh(as). 18. And the sons of Noah who came out of the ark were Shem, Ham, and Japheth; and Ham, he was the father of Canaan. Rashi: "and Ham, he was the father of Canaan" Why was it necessary to say this here? Because the chapter proceeds to deal with Noah’s drunkenness, in which Ham sinned, and because of him Canaan was cursed, and since the generations of Ham were not yet written, and we do not know that Canaan was his son, it was necessary to say here, “and Ham, he was the father of Canaan.” 20. And Noah began to be a master of the soil, and he planted a vineyard. Rashi: "and Noah began" Heb. וַיָּחֶל. [This can be understood as] “he made himself profane”, for he should have first engaged in planting something different. [Gen. Rabbah 36:3. I.e., he should not have planted a vineyard, from which wine is produced, but other trees, instead.] Rashi: "and he planted a vineyard" When he entered the ark, he brought with him vine branches and shoots of fig trees. [from Gen. Rabbah 36:3] 21. And he drank of the wine and became drunk, and he uncovered himself within his tent. Rashi: "his tent" It is written אָהֳלֹה [and not the usual אָהֳלוֹ]. This alludes to the Ten Tribes, who were referred to by the name of Samaria, which was called Oholah [אָהֳלָה] (Ez. 23:4), who were exiled on account of wine, as is written (Amos 6:6): “who drink from basins of wine.” [from Tan. Buber, Noach 21] 22. And Ham, the father of Canaan, saw his father's nakedness, and he told his two brothers outside. Rashi: "and Ham, the father of Canaan, saw" (Gen. Rabbah 36:7) Some of our Sages say: Canaan saw and told his father; therefore, he was mentioned regarding the matter, and he was cursed. Rashi: "saw his father’s nakedness" Some say that he castrated him, and some say that he sodomized him. [from Sanh. 70a] 23. And Shem and Japheth took the garment, and they placed [it] on both of their shoulders, and they walked backwards, and they covered their father's nakedness, and their faces were turned backwards, so that they did not see their father's nakedness. Rashi: "and Shem and Japheth took" Heb. וַיִּקַּח. It does not say וַיִּקְחוּ (the plural form), but וַיִּקַּח, the singular form. This teaches us about Shem, that he exerted himself to fulfill the commandment more than Japheth. Therefore, his sons merited a tallith with fringes, and Japheth merited burial for his sons, as it is said (Ezek. 39:11): “I will give Gog a place there as a grave in Israel.” But Ham, who disgraced his father, it is stated about his seed (Isa. 20:4): “So shall the king of Assyria lead the captivity of Egypt and the exile of Cush, youths and old men, naked and barefoot, with bare buttocks, etc.” [from Tan Buber Noach 16, Gen. Rabbah 36:6] 24. And Noah awoke from his wine, and he knew what his small son had done to him. Rashi: "his small son" The worthless and despicable one, like (Jer. 49:15): “Behold I have made you small among the nations; despised among men.” [from Gen. Rabbah 16:7] 25. And he said, "Cursed be Canaan; he shall be a slave among slaves to his brethren." Rashi: "cursed be Canaan" You have caused me to be incapable of begetting another fourth son (Gen. Rabbah, manuscripts, and early editions read: a fourth son) to serve me. Cursed be your fourth son, that he should minister to the children of these older ones [Shem and Japhet], upon whom the burden of serving me has been placed from now on (Gen. Rabbah 36:7). Now what did Ham see (what reason did he have) that he castrated him? He said to his brothers: “The first man [Adam] had two sons, and one killed the other so as to inherit the world, and our father has three sons, and he still desires a fourth son!” [from Gen. Rabbah ibid. 5, 22:7] End quote. So as you can see, the differences with the Islamic story are greater than one might think when reading this chapter without commentaries. When we include their exegeses, it becomes clear that there's more to it than 'mere' drunkenness. They say that his own son did something to him when he had drunk himself unconscious and taken off his own clothes. According to them, the son either sodomized the father, or castrated him. Now while such a major sinful action doesn't pertain to Noah, but to the son, it still adds significantly to Noah's disgrace, and it means that his supposed drunkenness was the cause for something much worse than the embarrassment of his sons. After all, if these commentaries should be discarded and dismissed as fabrications, then why indeed does Noah curse his son in the story, with such a tremendous curse? Noah asks God, according to the story; "may Canaan be a slave to them", i.e. Ham to his brothers, and the entire people of Canaan slaves to the offspring of Shem and Japhet. And how do Christians interpret the verse "and he (i.e. Noah) knew what his small son had done to him"? What did his son do to him that would cause the father to curse him and his offspring? Was he cursed because he saw him naked? Something must have happened in between the lines, and that is where the Jewish exegetes come in and inform us of what took place, according to their oral tradition. This is what they claim happened to this prophet of Allah. He didn't bother to plant fruits and vegetables, but instead planted 'the world's first vineyard', he produced the wine, became an alcoholic and one night drank himself unconscious. Then one of his own sons either mutilated him, or had his way with him. Imagine that. So if we feel uncomfortable with their books claiming that this prophet(as) was a drunkard, then how are we to deal with the rest of this story? Isn't it blatantly obvious that this is not revelation? Nuh(as) has a tremendous status among mankind, mind you, and this is what they say about him(as)? Astaghfirullah wa a'udhubillah.
I’m not sure why this Jewish mans interpretation, one from many millennia after Noah, should be looked as any more true than the next person’s. Jewish people weren’t even in existence yet in Noah’s time. The man who wrote this opinion is of the same group of people who wrote the Talmud and all the evils that are in that book. Those very same people have the gall to say God goes to the Talmud for wisdom. One should not take those interpretations as truth. Another more reasonable theory is that ham slept with Noah’s wife, his step mother. Not a good thing to do in anyway but slightly less egregious than the other two explanations. Not saying that is 100% the truth, just mentioning it to show there are many other possibilities out there. The second thing is that the Bible never says that Noah planted the vineyard first before he grew any crops. It just mentions that he planted one. As mentioned in gen 8:11, we know that the earth already has vegetation even before Noah steps foot off the ark, seeing how the dove brought back an olive leaf to show the waters were receding. The Bible never hints at a vineyard being the first thing planted nor does it say Noah is an alcoholic. A reason Noah became drunk off possibly just one glass of wine can be explained rather scientifically. We know the ark settled upon a mountain, seemingly very high up in altitude. When someone is in high altitude, there is less oxygen in the blood, hence making it easier for one to get drunk. An individual can feel drunk or tipsy off of just one or two glasses of wine when so high up, especially one who has not drank in quite some time on top of making their own wine possibly for the first time, and maybe mistakenly making it stronger than intended. Not here to say I’m definitely right and the others are wrong. Just offering other options that aren’t so detrimental to Noah’s character as a prophet.
Can someone help me I'm confuse why Yam the fourth Son of Noah is not in the bible but mentioned in Islam? And is also Ham did something wrong to curse the Son Canaan by God that is mentioned in the bible? Thanks
Noah story is one of the main reasons i findout religions are just a human made combination of old legendary stories and some other false claims and lawd
How would pollinating insects survive a flood lasting 150 days? How would flowering plants survive submersion in water for 150 days? Why wouldn't mankind go into the highlands above the tree level?
There's no evidence in the Quran that the food was global, or that it was only few thousand years ago, but the it could have happened at the progenitor bottleneck of human kind
The Bible contains different Scriptures ( Torah, Psalms, Gospel, etc). So, you won’t find the word “Bible” in the Quran but you would find the words Torah, Zabur (Psalms) and Injil (Gospel).
the Quran doesn't teach that the flood during the time of Noah was a universal flood. It teaches that the flood of Noah was a regional flood, not a global flood.
Actually another further research has it that the flood was all over the world with different cultures talking about a tremendous flood...and also Noah was an Antlantis and he witnessed the destruction of a Civilization...this is from Bashar channeled by Darryl Ankar.
The Islamic view of prophets explained here is very wrong with reality. Noah despite being a prophet had his sinful habits. He was not a perfect human being. The only prophet who never sinned was Jesus. The conclusion that because you are a prophet, then you must have lived above sin is what made Muslims to justify and dignify Mohammed's sinful practices and are misleading the unlearned.
If I'm not mistaken, genetic research proved a bottleneck in the human genome and all existing humans have a single father. However, they have more than one mother! In addition, there some geological signs for a wide spread flood which included the Americas.
nope science proves otherwise no worldwide flood....quran got it right noah flood was regional......bible ' noah flood worldwide because fallen angels raped women on earth'..lol idiocy
No brother the bottleneck was 75,000 years ago, while Noah's time was 17 to 18,000 years ago. and there is no evidenace of world wide flood happening in one time
But in surah Nuh Noah said, "My Lord, do not leave upon the earth from among the disbelievers an inhabitant." So does this suggest a world flood or is it that all other nations were monithiestic at this time a part from Noahs?
@@cheicknacamara651 you aren't really a disbeliever if you never got the message I assume. That is also assuming he was the only prophet at the time, as we know there could be multiple at a time for different people. Only Allah knows.
it wasn't a local flood, Quran 37:77 says that the generations of people only came from Noah, and 17:3 says that the generations came from Noah and from the people on the ark who were saved. Therefore, it was a global phenomenon perhaps, please double check...
@@macrodesign The Noah's flood myth is taken from a number of flood stories. One is where Zeus orders the flood. The 12 Tribes or sons of Israel/Saturn are the 12 aspects of Zeus/Jupiter. The first day sign is the Ram (Aries) where we find Gabriel (man-ram). Every year Gabriel toots his horn to announce the escape from Egypt (winter season) as the sun passes over from winter to spring (the Promised Land).
@@harveywabbit9541 What do you want me to say? I really don't see any benefit in agreeing or disagreeing with your belief... How about we talk about something else that Glorifies the Enormous Creations of our Lord....
...buuuuuuuuuuut in the bible it says the flood was global in the quran it says its local and science confirmed in no way it couldve been global... so quran copied the bible but it also has more scientific facts. makes sense
@@harveywabbit9541 I wouldnt say it was copied from pagan myths even tho u right about pagans back in the day basically making stories about floods and all, but historians found out that there couldve been a flood where noah was at but it was local just like the quran states. The bible for sure came from a messenger but it has been corrupted and the original gospel is now lost.
Is it true that in the bible noah tried to just save his family his wife and sons but left others back i just heard it but i dont know if that is the actual statement but in the Quran it says that i mean as i know what i heard that noah tried to preach his peoples and family to accept islam but they turned him back and disbelieved plus his family and he prayed to the god for destroying so as the flood it destroyed everything though he even left his family dying is it correct i just want to know if iam correct!
I'm not a muslim and i watch videos about the similarities/differences of The Bible and The Qur'an. I just wonder why most of the Muslim prophets descended from Isaac rather than Ishmail of whom only Muhammad descended from.
Isaac (summer) and Ishmail (winter), like Abel (summer) and Cain (winter)...are the same character but different seasons. Remember where the twins Esau (winter) and Jacob (summer) were in the womb at the same time. Jacob, the heel catcher (summer) followed Esau (winter). They are "born" at the winter solstice and summer solstice, just like Jesus and John the Baptist. The solar year can begin at either solstice.
According to the Quran and Hadiths of Holy Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), Isaac (also a prophet) prayed to God that he wants prophets from his progeny. God (Allah) accepted his this prayer but He said that Muhammad (King or Ruler of all prophets) will be from Ismail (AS).
“Verily! We have sent you with the truth, a bearer of glad tidings, and a warner. And there never was a nation but a warner had passed among them” [Fatir 35:24]. Dr Zakir Naik thinks even ancestors of Hindus & Buddhists were given Messengers & Scriptures but as years went by the people changed it as well. He said there is Prophecies of coming of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) in Bible,Torah,Gospels,Hindu & Buddhist Scriptures. Islam doesn't give importance to ethnicity like Judaism does. All of humanity needs to worship the Creator of the Universe. Today the largest Muslim country is Indonesia, second largest Muslim country is Pakistan. My ancestors were probably Buddhists or Hindus however thankfully I am Muslim because I know worship of idols is wrong and all Scriptures are corrupted except Quran.
@@diponegoro9 According to a Prophetic narration collected by Ibn Ḥibbân, the total number of prophets sent around the world, from Adam (ﷺ) to Muḥammad (ﷺ), is 124 000-of which only twenty-five are mentioned in the Quran.
Research into the first five books of the Bible strongly suggests that individual books as well as the entire compendium were the works of many contributors. By extension, individual persons may have also been representational of more than a single person, perhaps composites of a few like minded individuals. In this Ibrahim (pbuh) and Musa(pbuh) could have been more than a single person amplifying the message they are remembered for. I share my opinion only because scholarship into the origins of Islam seems to focus on acts of particular individuals while ignoring greater trends of the culture and societies in which these individuals moved. FWIW.
So what you mean is these prophets hold a bigger message than just individual people? As in something that could be applicable into analyzing people's psychology/understanding societies better?
@@MMOInformers I think what I mean to convey is that the message of any identified Prophet can be better appreciated by holding that person suspended in a particular milieu. For example, though conservative Christians seem to adhere to singularly narrow view of Jesus (pbuh), more liberal thinkers can find cause to reflect on this Prophet through the culture of Roman Judea, writings of the Essenes, Gnostic gospels and historians like Josephus. I think the same can be said of other prophets such as Moses and Abraham. IMVVHO I believe that rather than compromising their message, scholarship of this sort enhances it's impact. FWIW.
A very curious statistic: out of a total of 25 prophets in the Quran, 21 are from the Bible. Why is that?? Way were not taken from Greco-Roman religion same prophets or from India?? Is any explanation of this statistics???
I'm from the Bible belt in good ole USA. The noah story in the Bible didn't really add up to me even as a kid. I thought there was absolutely no way. Noah got two of every animal in the world on a boat. There was continents that wasn't even known about during this time. How they get them animals too? Didn't make sense to me. The Noah of the Quran makes way more sense being a localized flood. I believe I read somewhere there was a massive flood around this time. That probably did cause multiple localized flooding. However, one boat story just doesn't seem logical by any stretch of the imagination. My best guess. It depended on where you lived. It might have actually felt like the last persons on earth.
Come on, Drs. Ally, connect the dots! The difference between the Bible and Quran is more fundamental than that. In the Quran, the world is divided between good guys (the prophets and Muslims) and the bad guys. However, the Bible clearly teaches that ALL are sinners who would perish but for God's mercy and grace. In Noah's day, the whole world was so corrupt that God destroyed it in the Flood, sparing only Noah and his family because Noah himself was righteous. But the biblical narrative goes on to show that even Noah had his shortcomings. The Bible speaks truth to reality. Human beings are weak and sinful, even the seeming best of us. This is why God had to send his own Son to save a world full of sinners. Luke 18:9-14 9 To some who were confident of their own righteousness and looked down on everyone else, Jesus told this parable: 10 “Two men went up to the temple to pray, one a Pharisee and the other a tax collector. 11 The Pharisee stood by himself and prayed: ‘God, I thank you that I am not like other people-robbers, evildoers, adulterers-or even like this tax collector. 12 I fast twice a week and give a tenth of all I get.’ 13 “But the tax collector stood at a distance. He would not even look up to heaven, but beat his breast and said, ‘God, have mercy on me, a sinner.’ 14 “I tell you that this man, rather than the other, went home justified before God. For all those who exalt themselves will be humbled, and those who humble themselves will be exalted.”
Bible is much clearer about Noah's ark, even the Size of the boat is mentioned... Now, you can see the archeological facts about the boat surfacing in RU-vid...
Few ustadz like Zakir Naik said Bible is not word of God, due to so many error in logic and mathematic. But Quran have similar story in the bible. Bible come first than come quran. Why God copy from bible?
God didn't copy bible to Quran. God gave the same core messages since the creation of history. Quran is the collection of the Law and Path revealed to Moses and Jesus. The true Bible is re-revealed in Quran as a mercy to humankind, so that we are saved from the corruption of Paul and other people who invented falsehood and twisted God's revelation.
@@NowHereUs You going round the bush, simple question is according to your captain Zakir Naik, Bible not written by God. Next Quran written by God. Bible come first then come quran. Quran have so many similarity to Quran. So Quran copy bible. Agree th8s first. All these Moses! Jesus, Mohammad is not the argument here. True buble re-revealed in Quran also not the question here.
@@bolehsaja6951 Zakir Naik is not our captain. Quran the word of God is clear on this topic. Quran says that the God has given Injeel to Jesus and Taorah to Moses. People fabricated those. Quran corrects the human falsification.
If it be that you doubt what Allah revealed to his slave Muhammad, in it's accuracy, then here is a falsification test. Bring forth a book like unto it. May God guide you
The whole ❝Curse of Ham❞ (Genesis 9:20-27) is a fable. It never happened. It was added later by scribes to accept enslavement of Black people! I agree w/ the Qur'an, Noah didn't get drunk! ﷺ יֵשׁוּעַ משה אַבְרָהָם
@@Amen.ahmed1 ''We sent Noah to his people, and he remained among them a thousand years except fifty, thus the deluge overtook them while they were unjust.'' Its a very clear cut verse that talks about his age with no room for interpretation. This was the view of the early muslims and there is an authentic hadith thats says the gap between Adam (A) and Nuh (A) was 10 centuries.
@Hanapi Hamdan i cant be 100% but like many stories in the bible quran not factual not truth in a sense this actually happened, do you really think humankind came from adam?
In Islam you remain what you are: a slave of sin. John 8:34Jesus replied, “Truly, truly, I tell you, everyone who sins is a slave to sin. 35A slave is not a permanent member of the family, but a son belongs to it forever. 36So if the Son sets you free, you will be free indeed.…
@@olafliflaf You try being funny with something that doesn’t exist in our religion haha, our religion is so perfect you can’t even attack it, in the other hand you believe that God was a baby and Mary breast feed him and changed his diapers🤦♂️. I hope you repent cause Allah will punish those insults toward him.
He wouldn't answer about Noahs family being the progenitors of life. The scriptures clearly say that and it gives specific genealogies and families of the earth. SMH 🤦🏻♀️
Question please.... why quran ask or get idea or get to make close the bible? Bible is so strong that it dont have to be conpared, quran depends and always get reference to bible... bible itself dont get info to other book but rather quran get reference to quran?
The ‘story’ of Noah in the bible and the Quran is rehashed from old mythologies from the region centuries before both of these books were written by men. Research it
@@kraftgamer99 Noah (Earth) had three sons...aka the three ancient seasons of the year. Terah/Terra (Earth) had three sons...aka the three ancient seasons of the year. Job (Earth) had three daughters...aka the three ancient seasons of the year.
Maybe I should explain more. When god told nūh(peace be upon him) to get on the ship and the flood started, nūh (as) saw his son climbing a mountain. He told his son to get on the boat but his son said I’ll take refuge on top of the mountain. Then he drowned. Nūh (as) asked god that you keep your promises and you said that you will save my family. God then said that he wasn’t part of his family (ie spiritually) because he was a wrongdoer. The whole is in the Quran . It’s worth the read.
Only Noah can build Ark or boat in the whole world. Only Pharaoh Khufu can build highest monument for more than 3,000 yrs. Yes others too did built pyramids of smaller version. Likewise other humans too should have smaller size boat.for the family.
Lol. Totally agree. They all trying hard denying the African people to be the first on earth but now the truth are coming out. Noah himself was a black Albino.
Noah means the earth at rest. His three sons are Shem (winter), Japheth (spring), and Ham (summer). The three sons of Noah (Earth) are identical to the three sons of Terah/Terra (Earth). They are also the same as the three daughters of Job (Persecuted Earth).
Moses killed a man in both the Quran and Bible. David killed Goliath on both the Quran and Bible. I don’t see how Noah’s drunkenness is worse than this. The prophets were righteous but were also human beings. For all have sinned and come short of the glory of God.
@@jayblockchain100 bro, prophets are innocent, they cant do wrong to the level of drinking. Adam made a mistake and he was forgiven later, noah insisted on to save his son but warned by God and he retreated.
I actually wonder wether Islamic woman don't read the shariah.... how can a woman read the shariah and think Islam is from God? Whoever talked to Muhammad in the cave and inspired him to write the Quran could never be the same God as the God of Moses, Abraham or Jesus which gets super obvious when reading what God commanded Moses and compare that to the Quran.
Grievous Mistake Dr. Shabir Ally, No Prophet of God ever chose wine that’s against their Natural Disposition / Inclination (Fitrah), proof of this is The Prophetic Tradition where He was presented with Wine and Milk in Night Journey to Paradise, and He rightly chose Milk over Wine and thus, Angel replied this is how You showed your True Fitrah (Natural Disposition / Default state) that Allah has created upon all Human beings. Qur’anic Ref: (فطرة الله التي فطر الناس عليها لا تبديل لخلق الله) Hadith Ref: أن النبي صلى الله عليه وآله اتي ليلة أسري به بايليا بقدحين من خمر ولبن فنظر إليهما فأخذ اللبن” “ فقال له جبرئيل عليه السلام: الحمد لله الذي هداك للفطرة، لو أخذت الخمر غوت أمتك Therefore it’s clear that All Prophets and Messengers of Allah were upon pure state (Fitrah) of Islam (In full submission to Almighty’s Law)
🤺☦🇷🇺Yes, they have - the law of Moses or the Quran didn't exist back then. Also, that's a first...I didn't know Muslims conform their holy book to the popular theories in science, and change the meaning of their teaching of the history of mankind accordingly...🤔No, actually science claims that human genetics are derived from only ONE man and one woman, while we say that, no, it is derived from THREE brothers - Noah's sons, and that explains the "genetic diversity", that he claims the Bible contradicts. Very disappointed of you, Muslim brothers...😪
@lionboy4427 hold your horses.. I don't know what gubrish you are talking about Put forward your argument step by step.. do not bloat all out at once ... give it a break.. and tell what your none sense has anything to so with what I wrote above.. cheers
@@abdullahalrai I don't write nonsense, you and Shabir did. Every human is falible, including Noah, and he got drunk mistakenly, so what? It was at the beginning of the world before there was anything written, no Torah, no Quran, only oral Tradition. So both you and Shabir are wrong, and I criticized Shabir for capitulating to modern popular theories in science, putting them before the Quran and the Bible, which is heresy. He copied the Protestant theory of a local flood, which is ridiculous and blasphemous, so why don't you address this instead, it is much more important than your complaint about Noah being drunk?
@@abdullahalrai *gibberish. No, you do. It ain't my fault that you can't read between the lines. Why do you Muslims say that the Quran says there were more people in the ark, other than Noah's family?! Why do you say that the Quran supports a "local flood" theory when it doesn't! Has it ever accure to you that if that was the case, Allah would have told Noah to just migrate to dry land instead of building an ark??🤦♂️Why do you Muslims keep saying that aliens might exist, when it is clear that Allah clearly shows that he only gave life to us on this planet, and WE are the center of the universe, and all that's out there was created for us! There is nothing out there, only empty stars, so why don't you Muslims just say it, instead of talking like secular Americans and their alien fantasies?
Since the Prophet Noah is the subject of this video , there is a issue though it is not related to Noah ark or flood , Quran says the wife of Noah & Lot were thrown in Hell by Allah # but Quran also says the good men are for good women & dirty men are for dirty women # Why Allah knowing that Noah's wife was dirty decided to marry with Noah ????? if the answer is at the time of marriage she might be good & later became dirty then why Allah knowing that she had become dirty did not order Noah to divorce her ?????#
Christians speak from their Christian belief of What GOD'S Holy Word Says. Noah's son was punished for not covering his father's nakedness . And we know that Noah was a Just Man. I would think Noah had celebrated after coming out of the ark after All those Days...All is well....
It's world wide in the Quran why would not have to being 2 of every animal if it's just local there's no reason! It makes more sense to say it's world wide if you can't believe that then be a agnostic
It’s possible that it’s world wide but he very well could have brought 2 of every animal of his livestock. The Quran does not say that he brought 2 of every living animal on earth
We did not have boats and social media and all these other things that we do todayso it's pretty possible that we did not know that they were still other people far away that was still alive after the flood
2:45 The family of Noah wasn't just saved because they were family. A true believer will put their belief into action, in this case, obedience to God's command to get on the ark. Because Noah's family obeyed, they are counted as believers. 3:10 The flood lasts for about a year according to the Bible. 3:45 Why is it so shocking to a Muslim that prophets make mistakes? The Quran records mistakes made by the prophets: Adam 2:121-122, Moses 28:15-15, David 38:23-24, and Muhammed 66:1, 8:67-69, and 80:1-2 4:40 The statement is made about "previous legislations" implying that God's laws have been changed. God is not a man that He should change. God never makes mistakes and to change His legislations would imply that He previously made a mistake. 9:00 There is nothing difficult to accept scientifically about the idea that all of humanity descends from a single pair. Mitochondrial DNA analysis gives evidence that we all go back to a single pair within the last few thousand years. This idea comes from athiest scientists, not scientists who believe in one true God. 9:50 The Quran does not say it was a local flood! 10:15 Once again, statements about science in regards to animals are coming from secular/athiestic scientists and not believing scientists who have done studies on if the ark. These scientists used the dimensions given in the Bible, was big enough for all kinds of animals, and found that it was (even big enough to also hold all their food for a year). 11:00 An archeologist isn't going to find evidence of a global flood. Ask believing geologists (of which I am one) and paleontologists and they will tell you there is tremendous evidence for a global flood. Anthropologists have also identified flood legends in almost every culture globally. Please remember that the Quran says to believe in the Scriptures that were sent down before 4:136 and that the Torah and Injeel are true 3:3-4. God also tells Muhammed to ask questions of those who read these Scriptures 10:94. Why? Because God didn't need to repeat Himself in the Quran, the previous Scriptures help complete the story!
Sura 69:11 it says the flood overflowed all limits. Also, a man tried to save himself by going to the top of a high mountain but still drowned. Overflowing all limits and covering high mountains would necessitate a global flood, otherwise, there would be a limit to the flood. This agrees with the Biblical account found in The book of Genesis in the Torah Which says that all the mountains were covered. Also, I am a geologist, I can assure you there is tremendous evidence for a global flood from science.
I am just a learner, same as you. You should read the Quran, the Injeel, and Torah for yourself. That is the only way to know what Allah wants us to know. Let’s keep talking too! Let me know what you think of some of my RU-vid videos, I would love to get your feedback! May God bless you!
So in the Muslim faith, God will not bless a family as reward for the obedience and faith of the father? Yea - biblically, he has rewarded children due to the faith of the fathers. Look at Lot.
2:45 The family of Noah wasn't just saved because they were family. A true believer will put their belief into action, in this case, obedience to God's command to get on the ark. Because Noah's family obeyed, they are counted as believers. 3:10 The flood lasts for about a year according to the Bible. 3:45 Why is it so shocking to a Muslim that prophets make mistakes? The Quran records mistakes made by the prophets: Adam 2:121-122, Moses 28:15-15, David 38:23-24, and Muhammed 66:1, 8:67-69, and 80:1-2 4:40 The statement is made about "previous legislations" implying that God's laws have been changed. God is not a man that He should change. God never makes mistakes and to change His legislations would imply that He previously made a mistake.
9:00 There is nothing difficult to accept scientifically about the idea that all of humanity descends from a single pair. Mitochondrial DNA analysis gives evidence that we all go back to a single pair within the last few thousand years. This idea comes from athiest scientists, not scientists who believe in one true God. 9:50 The Quran does not say it was a local flood! 10:15 Once again, statements about science in regards to animals are coming from secular/athiestic scientists and not believing scientists who have done studies on if the ark. These scientists used the dimensions given in the Bible, was big enough for all kinds of animals, and found that it was (even big enough to also hold all their food for a year). 11:00 An archeologist isn't going to find evidence of a global flood. Ask believing geologists (of which I am one) and paleontologists and they will tell you there is tremendous evidence for a global flood. Anthropologists have also identified flood legends in almost every culture globally.
Also, the Quran says to believe in the Scriptures that were sent down before 4:136 and that the Torah and Injeel are true 3:3-4. God also tells Muhammed to ask questions of those who read these Scriptures 10:94. Why? Because God didn't need to repeat Himself in the Quran, the previous Scriptures help complete the story!
Remnant Rendezvous We believe in the original scriptures revealed by God (Allah swt) to Moses (Musa A.S) and Jesus (Isa A.S) peace be upon them in their original form. Not the fabricated and altered versions of today. The Qur’an was needed to be revealed as a guidance for all of humankind after the previous scriptures were tampered with. The Qur’an was revealed in an oral tradition with many memorizing it cover to cover, so it couldn’t be tampered with. The Qur’an we have today is the same Qur’an revealed to Muhammad (S.A.W) more than 1,400 years ago in its original form. All of Allah’s words and laws, his guidance for humankind as revealed in the final scripture has been preserved and will be preserved until the end of time.
@@RemnantRendezvous Allah and the Koran has nothing to do with the Bible the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob is the only true God, God spoke and the jews use to hear him Allah has never spoken, only thing you hear about Allah is that he is merciful
Basil Hendricks the Quran teaches that one should read the Bible. Also, Allah is found in the Bible, it just means God in Arabic. The sister language of Aramaic, in which portions of the Bible were written have the word Elah, and the Hebrew is El. All the same
@@RemnantRendezvous I am or Hywy or the God of Jacob Isaac and Abraham who spoke with the jews, he who knows Jesus knows the father, Christianity is to be understood by faith, God sending his only begotten son who came from above and only he who comes from above can talk about above Allah is not known only on paper he never showed himself
The starting point for the prophets has to the Torah, not the Quran, Mohammed must be judged by the Torah, not the Quran. If Mohammed does not meet the requirements for a prophet according to the Torah, then, he is not a prophet.
@@mohamadkhateeb402 and that is the point - you see all the prophets who came before Mohammed as Muslims - as worshipers of Allah - a deity was totally unknown to the true prophets found in the Bible. The starting point must be the Torah and not the Quran and if you start with the Torah and the Prophets then Islam is finished and proven false.
@@stephenatkins13 And yes I trust the Torah. It’s not the literal word of God but rather it’s the word of Musa (peace upon him) so I can’t hold it to the same standard as the Quran.
I find this very interesting. Here's what is more interesting. The flood may have happened just over 5,000 years ago. Our earth is young. And our God (Allah) created us. We definitely did NOT evolve over millions of years. Although I am Christian I am also very interested in the Quran account of this incredible true story. For example...when Noah tried to persuade people to live righteously and to repent.
here Muslim means who worship 'One God' .... they didn't follow the Quran that time but they have their own revelation.... this is deep, you need to dig more deep to understand it.... Noah (pbuh) was not neither jew (from Moses) or christian (from Jesus) but he worship 'One God' that's why muslim say all people who lived in past if they worship One God and follow the their prophets then they are called ''muslim'' in arabic.... If you don't want to use the arabic word 'muslim' then you can say in your own language... Like in English, you can say Noah (pbuh) was a ''Monotheistic'' means who Worship One God....
@@basilhendricks788 the one God is the ''God of Abraham....'' the One Universal God.... Yahweh is not the name of God, Jews say Yahweh to refers God because they forget the real name of God... the reason is, Jews are prohibition to use of the name of God in their tongue ... Muslim say ''Allah'' in arabic means ''The One God'' which refers the God of Abraham/Ibrahim ..... Even Arab Christian also use ''Allah'' to refers ''God the Father'' ... Jesus (pbuh) used ''AlaHa'' to refers God in Aramaic (Jesus Spoke Aramaic, a semitic language)
All prophets have sinned except Jesus. It is written “Thou shall not Kill” . Moses has killed before & God forgave him. David has killed his enemies & was not fit to build the temple he wanted to build for God. I read that Prophet Muhammad has killed Ubayy ibn Khalaf. So it should not be surprising that Noah has committed a sin by getting drunk & got naked💯
@@retrogamingfrenzy2373 I am not disputing💯 I am saying they have sinned by killing a human being(innocent or not). Eg. Because King David has killed people in battle(Guilty people) he was not qualified to build God a temple. His son was chosen because he had never killed any human being💯💯 I am saying this because Dr Shabir mentioned the Muslim presupposition that prophets committed no sin.
@@Khumzalet it's not a sin no prophet has done sin whether you like it or not. Maybe they have done mistakes for what they repent but Allah (god) knows better.
"The different between genius and stupidity is genius have limit" Albert Einstein First of all nation of Israel have covenant not religion. Second there is no separation between tahnak and NT. Savior called christ and his deciplie didn't called themselves Christian. That is one of many satanic deception. Third how can a religion that did not exist when tahnak already was written dictate mass claims. And include all prophets in islam? This is not to insult or hate this is a warrning. Allah is imposter the devil pretend to be the holy one God the creater of heaven and the earth. If you don't believe you will.
When the BIBLE started to be corrupted? And also wan Noah a muslim ? What can you say about the animals wich enter into the Ark acoording to Quran? Was there haram and halal animals ? And if soo how did you find out according to quoran ?
