Тёмный

Northeaster Dory Capsize Test on Maine Island Trail (UPDATED) 

WC Mcbuske
Подписаться 269
Просмотров 35 тыс.
50% 1

Due to various factors we were unable to overnight on the Maine Island Trail (MITA) this year. However, we were able to do some practice capsizing. Some thoughts:
we capsized on a calm day with no gear in the boat
I think (hope) that our dry bags, if well tied down would actually add buoyancy. They float and are large.
with standard under-seat flotation as called for in the NE Dory plans, we had the topmost plank above the water after righting.
even with this freeboard, it was very tippy and strong chop would make bailing much more challenging
I used a 10 quart paint bucket to bail and it took under 3 minutes of bailing to get the water down to safe levels
based on other swamping tests not included in the video, those small bailers (clorox bottle and small scooper) were nowhere near as effective as the bucket
the importance of tying everything down was clear. Even with a virtually empty boat, stuff (paddles, sponges, bailers) went everywhere immediately. Not tying down my bucket resulted in a lot of cursing (edited out in post-production) even in a calm test run.
Finally: could the sail be used as a kind of sea anchor if made fast to the bow!? The way it was floating next to the boat in this video made me think it could be used to keep everyone head to wind if the seas got up. This could make bailing easier and might prevent re-capsizing. Just a thought.
UPDATE: Based on some comments on boating fora, and in a demonstration of my commitment to the science of small boat safety, I've edited the video to include the awkward sequence of my re-boarding. Though undignified, getting in the boat in deep water was not difficult. However, because significant quantities of water unavoidably came in with me, I conclude that attempts to "pre-bail" while floating next to a capsized NE Dory are not productive. Similarly, attempts to "slosh" water out of the boat prior to re-boarding were equally ineffective. What little water was removed came right back in when I came over the rails. I now believe that reboarding as quickly as possible and limiting time in the water is the best and safest plan.

Опубликовано:

 

14 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 26   
@DanielSpiegel
@DanielSpiegel 7 лет назад
I'm so glad to see that my wife and I aren't the only "crazy" ones cruising about in small sailboats. We got married around the same time as you guys it seems and every summer have been taking a trip down a section of our local waterway, the Columbia River.
@ryankarraker4200
@ryankarraker4200 2 года назад
Roll on mighty Columbia. I live on the river too.
@papajeff5486
@papajeff5486 2 года назад
Thanks for doing this. I have capsized my boat, by accident, throwing my crew over my head, into the sail. My aluminum mast did scrape the bottom and seas were not so much fun. Swam the mast to point into the wind. With pulling a big rope around the base of the mast and standing on the centerboard she caught the wind in the main and righted. Wind, waves and shallow bottom complicated the recovery. Hope you never have to worry about this. Good sailing. Thanks again. SE Texas
@NotAnAngryLesbian
@NotAnAngryLesbian 8 лет назад
I have been knocked down in conditions. When the boat went over I took a very hard hit to my leg. I feel lucky I did not break it. Others are very correct about swells refilling the boat. Another issue is how long it would take to remove the rig while being knocked about. I set up my main and mizzen so a single short line could be pulled and the mast would come free. Yes, it worked when I was knocked down under conditions. It was likely the reason when the boat turned turtle that the masts didn't break while being dragged over the shallows by the tide. I was able to free up both rigs and roll them up for stowing in about two minutes. Not bad considering there were breaking waves. Both rigs were full of sand when I got things straightened out. Have fun. Create adventures. Never look back my friend. I wish you the best.
@geraldtrumpp2340
@geraldtrumpp2340 2 года назад
Tried yesterday with the sloop rigged NE. It's even worse, as I cannot take away the sail, so I have to righten the boat with sails. By turning it upside, it is pressed under water and is even more full as the lug in the clip. No chance to climb in for bailing. I have an electric pump with 70 liter per minute. It needed 13 minutes to empty the boat. Result: much more buoyancy and a second pump needed.
@stevewhite791
@stevewhite791 Год назад
Excellent thing to practice.
@TheMaineSurveyor
@TheMaineSurveyor 8 лет назад
Thanks for making and sharing this video. It's a beautiful boat; I just don't like how low it sits in the water. Have you tested it's ability to negotiate the wake of passing power boats?
@brianskinner5711
@brianskinner5711 8 лет назад
I live on Willapa Bay and it would be tough to find a day when out sailing that there would be be no wind and chop. So-- thanks for for the demo but it doesn't ( to my mind) do much for real life emergency preparation. Nice boat though, and lovely waters to sail on. Thanks for sharing.
@lolathedog3108
@lolathedog3108 Год назад
How does one sail without a rudder? Or was it temporarily removed for the video? Would it fall out in a knockdown?
@warjacare
@warjacare 3 года назад
Capsize is a dangerous situation, without bouyancy.
@paraglide01
@paraglide01 7 лет назад
So in choppy conditions you'll be dead in a NE Dory when it capsizes. You'll never get it bailed out.
@robinwarga9
@robinwarga9 3 года назад
Well done
@chrismackay8314
@chrismackay8314 5 лет назад
Have you found a solution so the boat will float higher after a capsize? This boat seems to float nicely half way in the water with no risk of turtling.. but it looked like you were practically "awash" after you righted.
@mickcarson8504
@mickcarson8504 4 года назад
You can always attach two float sausages at each end, making it harder to capsize
@boatman222345
@boatman222345 9 месяцев назад
Try that in rough windy conditions…
@mickcarson8504
@mickcarson8504 4 года назад
That's the benefit of wodden boats, they never sink.
@ajm2872
@ajm2872 2 года назад
Peeps gonna get Jaws'd
@JBattler
@JBattler 5 лет назад
Absolute calm in water you could stand up in..not very realistic. Might be better to have a stay stabilized mast with quick release or pivoting mast. When the wind is blowing your mast will likely be wrecked by the time you get it all unhooked.
@onefodderunit
@onefodderunit 7 лет назад
+1 for scoring the supermodel, but you should've used her more.
Далее
Boatymoon
13:59
Просмотров 57 тыс.
Trailside S02E05 Sea Kayaking the Maine Island Trail
39:45
Perfect winds for my Northeaster Dory
4:32
Frank Builds a CLC Northeaster Dory
5:54
Просмотров 12 тыс.
Preserving the legacy of Pacific City's dory boats
9:26
The Boatymoon Revisited
9:30
Просмотров 14 тыс.