Тёмный

NSDA Nationals 2022 - World Schools Debate Final Round 

Bodhi Silberling
Подписаться 488
Просмотров 103 тыс.
50% 1

Team West Los Angeles Violet (proposition) wins the National Tournament on a 10-3 decision over Western Ohio Blue.
The prepared motion for the final round is: “This House believes that housing is a guaranteed right.”
West Los Angeles Violet: Katie Babb from New West Charter, Sungjoo Yoon (2nd speaker) from Burbank High School, Bodhi Silberling from Sierra Canyon School, Alex Lee (3rd speaker) from Harvard-Westlake School, and Nadia Chung (1st and reply speaker) from La Cañada High School.
Western Ohio Blue: Olivia Declercq (3rd speaker) and Stephen Frank from Whitmer High School, Bhuvan Meruga (2nd and reply speaker), Kunal Ponkshe, and Nikith Vangala (1st speaker) from William Mason High School.
00:00 Introduction
00:55 Proposition acknowledgments
03:35 1st Proposition (Nadia Chung)
12:28 Opposition acknowledgments
15:07 1st Opposition (Nikith Vangala)
24:09 2nd Proposition (Sungjoo Yoon)
33:01 2nd Opposition (Bhuvan Meruga)
41:36 3rd Proposition (Alex Lee)
50:21 3rd Opposition (Olivia Declerq)
59:05 Opposition Reply (Bhuvan Meruga)
1:03:49 Proposition Reply (Nadia Chung)
(World Schools Debating Championships, WSDC, WUDC, speech and debate, congressional debate, congress, house, senate, lincoln douglas, policy, usx, ix, international extemporaneous, public forum, parliamentary, impromptu, USA Debate, national debate team, Louisville, Kentucky)

Игры

Опубликовано:

 

30 июл 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 81   
@amymo6763
@amymo6763 Год назад
As a fellow debater, the framing of the motion you guys established in the first proposition speech is phenomenal. Your frontining of the definition later is simply amazing. Congrats!
@ChiefsFanInSC
@ChiefsFanInSC 11 месяцев назад
The opposition team was right in their interpretation of the motion. Words mean things and this was a sloppily worded proposition. If the housing really was a guaranteed right then why is homelessness so endemic in the USA and around the world?
@olivershaw4948
@olivershaw4948 10 месяцев назад
I completely agree, and I’m sure the opposition had a second 1st opposition script in case the first team had properly interpreted the (poorly worded) motion
@yoonsj128
@yoonsj128 6 месяцев назад
The whole point is that no reasonable tournament would set a motion asking a team to argue that homelessness does not exist. This debate was supposed to be about whether or not governments should enshrine it as a right - which has both good and bad effects. The opposition team wasn't just wrong, they were egregiously wrong.
@windows15678
@windows15678 Месяц назад
@@yoonsj128they weren’t wrong in their interpretation though, just on what you believe is a moral-standing
@iikkk271
@iikkk271 Месяц назад
because its a believes motion they are arguing about wether or not it should be a right not if it could actually be implemented. Although practical impacts exist, its more heavy on wether or not guaranteed housing is a right.
@patrickschack358
@patrickschack358 Год назад
It’s crazy that my team had the honour of debating you in semi-finals! Rocky Mountain South.
@plsdontbanmeagainyoulibtards
one of the view debates on RU-vid with actually good audio
@tiyabasilio8883
@tiyabasilio8883 2 года назад
I'm Nadia's coach. So happy to see this online.
@alexlee8353
@alexlee8353 2 года назад
You coached her to being one of the best 😍😍
@bodhisilberling8763
@bodhisilberling8763 2 года назад
Best 1/4 NA (in north america)
@nadiaachung
@nadiaachung 2 года назад
TIYA!!! I never could have been on that stage without you. Thank you for shaping me as a debater and person❣️
@tiyabasilio8883
@tiyabasilio8883 2 года назад
I was looking up the Harry Potter world school video to show in my world schools class lol and saw they put the debate online. You guys did so well. So proud of you.
@camcovpodcast
@camcovpodcast Год назад
Props to you coach
@valorant_ssfhjafaf4562
@valorant_ssfhjafaf4562 Год назад
Absolutely lover the debate ❤️. The second and third proposition speaker aced it. The points from the proposition were really well presented in a more significant manner as compared to the opposition. I think that's what allowed u guys to win with such a Lead. The 2nd opposition speaker also did really well and overall olboth sides were great. I mean from an opposition point of view, it's impossible to counter "an ideal society has to have the housing" cause that's also a truism.
@asdfkljlkjdfkg2290
@asdfkljlkjdfkg2290 7 месяцев назад
Thanks for uploading this!
@zacharyfreer7595
@zacharyfreer7595 Год назад
This is quite possibly the single worst world schools motion that I have ever seen
@sungjooy5277
@sungjooy5277 Год назад
Bro is spittin facts
@simarpawar5295
@simarpawar5295 Год назад
how come
@Imnotsurewhatthisis324
@Imnotsurewhatthisis324 Год назад
wait so are you saying they did bad?
@r.m4915
@r.m4915 Год назад
@@simarpawar5295 they ended up arguing two diffrent things, due to unclear wording. It could have been really interesting but they spent forever on definitional challenges.
@myidentityiscool
@myidentityiscool 10 месяцев назад
Ong
@zshn
@zshn 11 месяцев назад
This could have been a great debate if opposition had not misunderstood the motion. Proposition came in strong. Good job.
@Ksh0511-Lauren
@Ksh0511-Lauren 4 месяца назад
Alex starting his speech with, “no, no no. This house Believes that housing is a guaranteed right” that was so cool!…. As a debater hoping to be in the Korean WSDC team, so happy to see this;;
@ConfusedCatd
@ConfusedCatd 12 дней назад
I saw you on the other video on debates
@alexmiller4534
@alexmiller4534 Год назад
this is actually the most horrible motion I've ever seen
@iloveshopp1ng
@iloveshopp1ng Год назад
my school sent 16 ppl to nationals i think this past year! congrats !
@bodhisilberling8763
@bodhisilberling8763 Год назад
congrats!!!!!
@t.l4271
@t.l4271 2 года назад
Congratulations on winning. Is there a way where I can see more debates from your team and from you? If so where can I find that?
@bodhisilberling8763
@bodhisilberling8763 2 года назад
Unfortunately there was no recording permitted of any of the other rounds.
@naggindamaisoon
@naggindamaisoon Год назад
Alex Lee guy is good 🙌
@cirrus808
@cirrus808 2 месяца назад
third proposition speaker had me SCREAMINGGG HE COOKED SO HARD
@adwitamalik273
@adwitamalik273 Год назад
Wait so who won ?I think the Burden on team proposition was way too heavy
@aalishah5014
@aalishah5014 Год назад
Team Proposition Won on a 10-3 decision I believe. Congrats🎉
@lesegomanchidi5185
@lesegomanchidi5185 Год назад
The fact that I’m watching this makes me a nerd
@rickvaiBBB
@rickvaiBBB Год назад
I thought it should have been closer and Western Ohio Blue won. It is almost childish to think guaranteed housing could ever be available in the modernized countries, let alone the underdeveloped parts, sadly.
@r.m4915
@r.m4915 Год назад
Nah i think prop cleared this round. Your point makes sense, but that’s not what opp argued. Instead they went heavy on definitional challenges that tried to corner prop into disproving a truism. The substantive opp brought was ‘homeless people and displaced people exist on both sides of the house’, therefore opp wins. Their lack of substantive material that is mutually exclusive is also a bit iffy. To be honest, I think the reason opp lost was misunderstanding the motion. I dont blame them for that though, the wording of the motion is pretty impossible to understand. But even if you dont take that into account, its clear prop still wins due to the mutually exclusive substantive arguments brought in first, which have much greater impact than anything opp ended up bringing to this debate.
@rawanali3335
@rawanali3335 4 месяца назад
Decisions on who should win isn't based on what you actually think will work in irl. It's based off of the argumentation made by both teams and who made the better argumentation and refutation.
@shanghaistudentvoices1322
@shanghaistudentvoices1322 2 года назад
Hi! How frequently does NSDA host tournaments in WSDC format? And are they all online?
@bodhisilberling8763
@bodhisilberling8763 2 года назад
The NSDA allows two teams from every district along with some international teams at nationals. The "WSDC" circuit on Tabroom should show every world schools tournament other than nationals, but many of them will most likely be in-person next year.
@shanghaistudentvoices1322
@shanghaistudentvoices1322 2 года назад
@@bodhisilberling8763 that was crystal-clear, tysm! btw congrats to u and ur teammates you guys absolutely deserve it!!
@bodhisilberling8763
@bodhisilberling8763 2 года назад
@@shanghaistudentvoices1322 thank you so much!!
@g.agenaral6543
@g.agenaral6543 Год назад
Wait, so pro is aground it’s a human right, and Con is aground it’s a human right but people don’t have access. But pro used cons argument as evidence, or am I misinterpreting it
@LeelosAdventure
@LeelosAdventure Год назад
I’m new to this. I’ll study this vid later. Interested in learning how to handle my emotions with complete control during debates. Is there a place where we can get debate training?
@aceott8690
@aceott8690 Год назад
are you in high school?
@hjimehjime2086
@hjimehjime2086 10 месяцев назад
i am give me tips @@aceott8690
@tableofteaspoons
@tableofteaspoons 8 месяцев назад
if you're a high schooler and your school offers speech and debate join it. if you're in highschool but aren't offered the class : do some heavy research into public forum (world schools isn't widely done for tournaments, i think nsda does it but for the most part you won't do it unless you're in college, go to nationals for it, or it's your debate final) or lincoln douglas debate. you can look at the motions for all types of debate for the next month (not sure when spring topics are up). You can attend opener tournaments and regular tournaments as an independent (not from a school debate team) but i think there's a fee.
@bad99teddy
@bad99teddy Год назад
What the hell did i just find. I thought the title was ironic.
@ANGELUVR
@ANGELUVR 6 месяцев назад
First speaker i know is so nervous but its hard to understand her. Need to talk in a calm pace n take a deep breath. She sounds good but understandably nervous.
@kaustubhjain4815
@kaustubhjain4815 Год назад
Ah, yeah, lets debate on whether people have a right to have a roof over their heads 😍
@aceott8690
@aceott8690 Год назад
did you watch the video?? not a single minute of the debate was spent arguing over that
@kaustubhjain4815
@kaustubhjain4815 Год назад
@@aceott8690 it doesnt matter what they argued, this topic itself is just quite bad. And yeah, I did watch it, and they definitely did discuss the principle
@Noise_floorxx
@Noise_floorxx Год назад
So, do you get the other teams arguments before the debate or do you guess what they are going to say and kind of throw it in there after you hear their arguments? It seems like you knew exactly what their questions were and already had an answer ready. Even the most intelligent person can’t formulate a response in half a second after being asked a question.
@jovanshrestha4075
@jovanshrestha4075 Год назад
in the prep time, you think of possible arguments for the opponent team and prepare answers before hand, and for knew questions/argument if you understand the motion you can just formulate a rebuttal
@yoonsj128
@yoonsj128 6 месяцев назад
Good debaters do formulate a response in half a second
@featheroml
@featheroml 2 месяца назад
after a while you just get the same type of questions and you can answer pretty similar.
@edpiv2233
@edpiv2233 Год назад
Argh. Trying to get through this First Ladies screeching. My head.
@andreayu558
@andreayu558 7 месяцев назад
Wdym
@chloez7175
@chloez7175 Год назад
realistically, it's not possible for houses to be guaranteed.
@ttominable
@ttominable Год назад
Oh but it is, you'd be surprised. I believe you're not taking on to account the quality of the houses. but the again you are just claiming "its not possible". and i dont know what you mean by that.
@amandango9515
@amandango9515 2 года назад
u americans are something else
@bodhisilberling8763
@bodhisilberling8763 Год назад
fax
@lou3168
@lou3168 Год назад
Congratulations, Bodhi!
@bodhisilberling8763
@bodhisilberling8763 Год назад
LOUISSSSSS
@jakezeng660
@jakezeng660 2 года назад
dubs dubs dubs dubs dubs dubs
@rogerli5329
@rogerli5329 2 месяца назад
Logcon in World Schools...
@Mitchell_is_smart._You2bs_dumb
the actual debate could have been around these teams wearing masks.
@miu869
@miu869 Год назад
Is this sped up?
@bodhisilberling8763
@bodhisilberling8763 Год назад
nope
@tableofteaspoons
@tableofteaspoons 8 месяцев назад
debaters just talk fast (difference between speed talking and talking fast to make and argue points) and when we talk fast while using our hands we tend to have more sporadic movement 😸
@BenTheSkipper
@BenTheSkipper 9 месяцев назад
Who won this round? If it's team opp., I wouldn't be surprised...Nvm I just read the description. I think team opp. should've won
@andreayu558
@andreayu558 7 месяцев назад
Prop won
@cirrus808
@cirrus808 2 месяца назад
team opp wasnt even close to winning
@WIZARDGAMINGCHANNEL27
@WIZARDGAMINGCHANNEL27 Год назад
It’s fascinating how most of the speakers are Asians (biologically)
@blaiseywaiseyriot
@blaiseywaiseyriot 9 месяцев назад
what rhe hell does this mean? "asians (biologically)" the fuck
@blessGODDESSbless1977
@blessGODDESSbless1977 Год назад
.☠️.⚰️.NO MORE SCHOOLS.⚰️.☠️.
Далее
Thessaloniki WUDC 2016 - Finals | Open Final
51:11
Просмотров 390 тыс.
IQ Level: 10000
00:10
Просмотров 4 млн
Best exercises to lose weight ! 😱
00:19
Просмотров 9 млн
Final WSDC 2017
1:15:10
Просмотров 335 тыс.
NSDA Nationals 2018 - Public Forum Debate Final Round
55:56
HOW TO MASTER DEBATE, ALONE!
7:36
Просмотров 4,1 тыс.
NSDA Nationals 2023 - World Schools Debate Final Round
1:08:55
5 Вырезанных Боссов - STALKER
9:24
Просмотров 79 тыс.