@@lartonkiI like the voices MC, but it would have been nice if there were more voices. (I know that would have been really repetitive and expensive though, having to record the same lines with like six different people)
The voice itself isn't the problem, the problem is the dialogue being dumbed down to yes, sarcastic yes, no but yes, and more info (yes), which is largely a consequence of every PC line being voice.
I wouldn't want to fully go back to Fallout 3 with the protagonist being silent, I love that they speak their lines in 4. I'd like 3 and 4 combined. Still have the main character speak, but also have the full text box so I can see what the protagonist is actually going to say.