"...On My Bow" - MLP Grimdark Song 

What are you up to with the end statements of the video's so far Lost? I suspect that you're up to something....Something that we've been waiting for.... *TOTLN* 2:52

Ok. But like. Inky. Sweetie. It’s not “cheating” when she leaves you cause you were abusive. It’s just leaving you cause you were abusive.

Moral of the story, have no affairs with a pony who specialises in haunting music. :p

Soooo... Somebody found 'A Puppet To Her Fame'.

Fun Fact! In the book Hunchback of Notre Dame, Fleur de Lis is the woman who seduced the female lead's (Esmeralda's) love interest, so it's no surprise that the mare that Vinyl cheated on Octavia with in none other than the mlp version of Fleur de Lis.

Here’s a funny thought Imagine if she’s singing this out loud and vinyl is in the Audience

*"...sounds familiar"* Yes, kinda, and im waiting for it

Not gonna lie, this is probably my favorite MLP Grimdark song so far, maybe it's because I'm a sucker for the violin or maybe it's because this actually felt like a real song, or maybe it's The Melancholy singing, regardless it's still great, great job Lost.

I have never heard such an artistic portrayal of the emotions behind an affair previous to listening to this song.

tell ink dye to get lost she had her chance and blew it

Hmm, I feel like this song is a metaphor for something, but I can't put my finger on it. Eh, I'll never understand those crazy, symbolic music types.

The lyrics, the creativity, the sounds from the orchestra to the singer! It's amazing!

This was bloody good

The lost narrator finishes her tale this nightmare night only a matter of time until the end of what's been in the making all this time...

Octavia must have been singing this song in her head as she took part in one of her performances.

Holy Hellhounds! Yes! This was so dark and awesome! So pretty. And Ink Dye ... I need more!

Hey, Lost, you videos have been acting up at the very end lately. I think there might be a problem with your computer. You may want to get that checked out.

So this was great, and left that sweet feeling all good chilling songs/stories do, and from you no less Lost, you’ve both ruined and revived my childhood multiple times, keep doing what you do best And if you see this, congrats this song is great Please notice me Edit: thank you! I’ve been a massive fan for years, your stories are able to make me feel joy, disgust and fear, all while making me want more. I love all of your videos!

Absolutely beautiful Lost i love it.

The music that was used in beautiful song is called Now or Never by Myuu

Omg Ink Dye no!! Not my Cursy and Mag!

What pony was Vinyl with? Is it that one pony with a similar build as Princess Cadence with white fur and pink hair? Fleur De Lis is the pony she's with. (Check the tail at 0:46 or 0:47 and then look up her cannon character.)

1: Mag has a lovely singing voice. 2: Why all the horror stories surrounding Vinyl and Octavia? 3: Carmen is always a win.

1:22 *gasps* y-you killed Vinyl?!

This song and the vocals are so beautiful. The song in itself is so gorgeously done. I love it!

Yass the queen has uploaded

Mag singing always makes me smile

Oh Celestia! She killed Vinyl!(screeching)

This is amazing you guys are great at making grimdark videos they always give me the shivers.keep up the good work, and I know it's a little early but happy Nightmare Night.

Wow!😳 Amazing Song Lost!👍

First! Love you Lost! This is amazing. Mag did an amazing job at singing this too!

Omg!! Your voice fits so well with the song. It's elegant, dark, beautiful, and sad all at the same time!!

Why don't these songs have the lyrics in the description?!

The most fire intro I've ever seen.

This is absolutely wonderful Lost i love it.

Is it just me, or is her profile pic changing... Edit: IT IS, IT IS! The picture is changing! C'mon, I can't be the only person who's noticed this!

Still baffled how she managed to kill someone with a bow

This is a nice song and time to listen to it about 20 more times

a very catchy song, tell mag that she did a great job, can't wait for the rest of this month's videos

i love myuuji!!!!! and the instrumental is one of my favorites!! thank you so much to adding more awesomeness to Octavia x vynel!!

Oh my Goddesses MagPiePony your voice is so beautiful. Awesome song I truly enjoy it. Have a wonderful Day.

*Screeches to a stop* Octavia: " . . . Did I sing that out loud?"

This is an beautiful song here, I hope you sing more during this wicked season.

Marvelous Lost!

Damn. .just damn!! Oddly enough, this doesn't seem like it's OOC for Octavia to do.

Beautiful, dark, and powerful. Well done.

There should be an official creepypasta to go with this song.

All I can say Ink Dye is that she is a bird and birds obviously sing. Read " Birds 101 " I'm sure it'll be in there.

got this stuck in my head! I cannot stop watching it!

Hehe.... I like this song because of the way the song is sing. Plus the ending of the video. “Since when does my little bird sing?” -small laugh- Great Lost. Keep up the great work.

Apparently she's singing this song in her head...

AMAZING I LUV IT SO MUCH AAAAHHH

This grimdark was from "A Puppet to her Fame"

Oh my! I love this! MUST DOWNLOAD!

*gasps in music studies* You use the dies irae!!

Love the text and voice ! :D

This sounds so much like Estelle from “Princess Trixy Sparkle” and it’s really throwing me of

Ink, give Lost back her channel, please.

That was the most beautiful song I've ever heard

Oooh, I like this, good job!

I find this song a year later and love it- glad i found it because i absolutely love it acckk

this song has such Phantom of the Opera for me for some reason

Is it bad that I sang along with this song because of how AWESOME and well done the music and the singing was?

I just got done listening to A Puppet to Her Fame, this is great!

Wow, this is a very awesome grimdark idea and I love Magpie's voice! ❤

every time i listen to these, I'm like, what would AppleJack or the mane 6 sing in turn for their gruesome crimes. I know there's fics that probably correspond with the songs, but it just makes me wonder. Also I wanna voice act at some point but I don't wanna challenge Lost's AJ impression lol

This was chilling. I loved it!

You can do nothing, Ink Dye. They're together, against you, against the world.

TOO CATCHY!!!! I LOVE THIS AND THE STORY BEHIND!!!

That inky back hair those soulless eyes lost has something planned

Beautiful.

This is the equivalent to burn but very gory and with Eliza killing Alexander instead of burning all of his letters

Hey Scribbler you did an awesome job on the songs and by the way Octavia and final are my favorite My Little Pony characters

Six dislikes . . . Octavia killed six ponies

I love watching and listen to your channel i found it while i was waiting for part 6 of twilights experiments to come out :D honestly i like listening to them just before bed messed up i know but i like it :D

Anyone knows where i can read or listen to the story this song was about??

This was very well made and everything sounds astounding together and piece by piece

OMG AMAZING!!! I LOVE IT!!!

This is hauntingly beautiful

ENCORE ENCORE WOOO AMAZING I found this channel from blank slate

Happy Halloween, Losty

so did anyone actually take their time to put the lyrics in text form?

Noice this is an amazing song great song I love how dark yet soothing the song sounds

I’ve never read the story for this. I actually only heard of this story from this channel

So, I might sound like an idiot, but who did she cheat with???

It's been so long since I seen another good Octavia song.

I love the song blood on my bow

I’m a Cellist and there is so many things wrong with this... !not the song! But the logic. Ok so, Octavias cutie mark is a violin cleft, and where did the fine tuners go? And why is there only two top tuners? The black part where the strings come down is supposed to go down kind of by the bridge, but not all the way. Octavias bow should also be down some more. Hash bro apparently doesn’t know how to draw a Cello. Please don’t hate on me for this. It’s amazing are and the song is great!

Was this from the original creepy pasta where Octavia was a puppet? Btw, well done!!! :D

Wow... just wow, This is so awesome

Can't I change my like button to love button before hitting it cuz this was pretty amazing.

Bravo, bravo,👏, finally she has performed, bravo, bravo, 👏,👏,👏.

...whoa. This song is so haunting! I love it! =D

All these grimdark things are getting more interesting with every video, am I right everypony?

Can I make a animatic of this song?

I've been coming up with an epic fan fiction on my notebook which is a crossover between Smash Ultimate and MLP. (I know, but I love smash so wtfn?) Anyway, I've been coming up with a scene where Nightmare Moon and Dracula join forces, followed by Majora and King Boo and even Jeanne from Bayonetta. And then in the old case of the two sisters rebuilt by Dracula and Nightmare Moon, they also have sonic and shadow turn into werehogs and so the fight is on. Luigi, Flutterbat, Simon, Richter, and Alucard, Sonic Werehog, Bayonetta, Luna, Vinyl Scratch as a vampire, Octavia and Young Link/Fierce Deity Link vs Dracula, Nightmare Moon, King Boo, Jeanne, and Shadow Werehog. What do you think Lost?

When I first heard the song I felt kind of weird afterwards and I still do now listening to it in 2020

Is this a real grimdark or is it just the song?

WOW!!!! THIS IS AWESOME!!!!!

Awesome such a lovely song.