On scientists and their demons | Jimena Canales [Full Interview]

Подписаться 287 тыс.

Просмотров 3,9 тыс.

50% 1

Science historian Jimena Canales talks about discovery vs invention, the importance of creativity and the role of the imaginary in science.
Should scientists engage more in the history of science?
Watch Jimena Canales debate the trouble with time in physics with Avshalom Elitzur and Michio Kaku at iai.tv/video/the-trouble-with...
Join award-winning science historian Jimena Canales in this studio interview as she discusses the process of discovery and the nature of the unknown in science.
#historyofscience #philosophyofscience
Jimena Canales is a pioneering historian of science and an expert in 19th and 20th century history of the physical sciences. She is currently Vice-President of the Board of the American Council of Learned Societies (ACLS).
The Institute of Art and Ideas features videos and articles from cutting edge thinkers discussing the ideas that are shaping the world, from metaphysics to string theory, technology to democracy, aesthetics to genetics. Subscribe today! iai.tv/subscribe?Y...
For debates and talks: iai.tv
For articles: iai.tv/articles
For courses: iai.tv/iai-academy/courses

Опубликовано:

10 июн 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 36

@annakarl9989 Месяц назад

Thank you 💖💐 🕊️

@Thomas-gk42 Месяц назад

interesting, thank you

@FabianGautero4D Месяц назад

Lo que nos motiva a inventar ciertos artilugios tecnológicos, según me parece, va en línea de potenciar nuestros sentidos en términos de ciencia básica; a la vez, de ponernos en posición de dominio. El poder, desde un punto de vista político, está en cada hipótesis, siendo la posible interpretación semántica más adecuada al prefijo a la palabra hipótesis en general.

@exerjiexerji289 Месяц назад

Beautiful articulation and her voice is endearingly persuasive too. Great interview.

@stevenverrall4527 Месяц назад

Scientific historians should study how the establishment crushes both rational true innovators and irrational dissenters. The most profound discoveries have always faced tremendous pushback from the establishment.

@Thomas-gk42 Месяц назад

just think of Sabine H.

@grrrbrrr9053 10 дней назад

would

@stevenverrall4527 Месяц назад

Those who think eureka moments don't exist cannot ever have made a discovery.

@pubguc6771 Месяц назад

0:11 0:13

@reginaerekson9139 Месяц назад

10:57 guess you better figure out who marked the daemons/demons/diamonds? Some of this isn’t my imagination it was just stories I heard and I’m just trying to figure out what’s true - because some of you are bored psychopaths literally… I’m guessing it was a church, I don’t enjoy going so your guess is as good as mine!

@vanikaghajanyan7760 Месяц назад

"God does not change the rules He has chosen once." (Socrates).

@SebastianKrabs Месяц назад

All modern scientists are superstitious children in adult bodies who see monsters under the bed. Makes sense. 😅

@homewall744 Месяц назад

Or you don't understand basic language. Do you know what computer bugs and viruses are? Are they actually bugs and viruses per the vernacular?

@SebastianKrabs Месяц назад

@@homewall744 I actually graduated community college at 18 with an associate's degree in computers. It's called malicious code not a virus... Adults and scientists use precise language children use words like demon. 🤯

@petervandenengel1208 Месяц назад

That is the reason why the populus calls scientists and philosophers Geeks. Irrational people talking about everything being trivial. Obviously derived from Greek. There must have been early contacts in England. Perhaps because they had fled Greek democracy killing Socrates for his absurd ideas.

@SeedsofEcofrog Месяц назад

Remember No jab No job. We must never forget WHO coerced and emotionally blackmailed the children to risk as shields, to temporarily and marginally "protect" adults. Thou shall not use pregnant women as Granny shields. Risking the young to "save" the old is rotten to the core.

@jewulo Месяц назад

It was a valid and rational position to hold to stop the spread of an unknown virus and health pandemic. Scientist are not without flaws. They are human and subject to the same foibles that we all are.

@SeedsofEcofrog Месяц назад

@@jewulo what about the schools still requiring it to attend?

@stevenverrall4527 Месяц назад

@@jewuloHowever, those who were ultimately correct were demonized and had their careers destroyed. To be both correct and unpopular is a very dangerous mix...

@stevenverrall4527 Месяц назад

@@jewuloSince when has over-reacting in the extreme been considered rational?

@VictorKibalchich Месяц назад

how's the tin foil hat? Comfy?

@jewulo Месяц назад

Anytime somebody uses ontology too often in a sentence I get worried. They are trying to place themselves in a higher knowledge category wherein science and scientist are folks in one of the many categories that make up the world. According to these type of folks there are many categories. Religious, Philosophical, Scientific, etc. All these are just various categories that have equal validity. I always worry that it might be nothing more than a special kind of salad they are making here. A word salad to be precise.

@CONNELL19511216 Месяц назад

Well it beats having to invent other words

@dnescodino Месяц назад

I am also worried that we are just watching some reworking of labels here. However, I find myself dreading the mechanicsist, pragmatic attitude, and discourse of scientists. People like her are not as harmful as those whom she is placing in those categories...

@courtcomposer Месяц назад

7:53. Daemon in Greek means spirit not an evil entity. Thse are not "imaginary concepts". They DO work!! Science has been the only thing that explains the national world. Not religion. The intellectual level of this discussion is pathethic.

@Robinson8491 Месяц назад

Is Maxwell's demon real?

@courtcomposer Месяц назад

@@Robinson8491 yes. I had tea and biscuits with it yesterday.

@stevenverrall4527 Месяц назад

Religion is necessary to explain what science cannot. It is irrational to think that science can explain all phenomena. Religion actually explains far more of human nature than science ever has.

@courtcomposer Месяц назад

@@stevenverrall4527 the myths of religion explain nothing.

@courtcomposer Месяц назад

@@stevenverrall4527 like revived corpses, talking snakes and virgin births?