Тёмный

One Weird Math Trick Estimates ANYTHING (Fermi problems) 

Kyle Hill
Подписаться 2,4 млн
Просмотров 678 тыс.
50% 1

Go to www.kiwico.com... for 50% off your first month of any crate!
There once was a scientist who was SO GOOD at estimating complicated questions from almost no information that they named this style of problem after him.
💪 JOIN [THE FACILITY] for members-only live streams, behind-the-scenes posts, and the official Discord: / kylehill
👕 NEW MERCH DROP OUT NOW! shop.kylehill.net
🎥 SUB TO THE GAMING CHANNEL: / @kylehillgaming
✅ MANDATORY LIKE, SUBSCRIBE, AND TURN ON NOTIFICATIONS
📲 FOLLOW ME ON SOCIETY-RUINING SOCIAL MEDIA:
🐦 / sci_phile
📷 / sci_phile
😎: Kyle
✂: Charles Shattuck
🤖: @Claire Max
🎹: bensound.com
🎨: Mr. Mass / mysterygiftmovie
🎵: freesound.org
🎼: Mëydan
“Changes” (meydan.bandcam...) by Meydän is licensed under CC BY 4.0 (creativecommon...)

Опубликовано:

 

29 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 2,6 тыс.   
@pirateadam3686
@pirateadam3686 3 года назад
Police officer: Sir, do you know how fast you were going? Me: *Inhales*...
@berman00
@berman00 3 года назад
I don't know for sure, but my guess is about one half a moon distance per shark attack
@erinkarp6317
@erinkarp6317 3 года назад
But officer, speed is relative!
@andrasbiro3007
@andrasbiro3007 3 года назад
I'm reasonably sure I didn't break the sound barrier.
@Z31Turbo
@Z31Turbo 3 года назад
@@berman00 So I calculated that at about 820mph! You were going pretty damn fast! Shark attacks have really increased a lot in the last 20 years, apparently.
@vincentochs637
@vincentochs637 3 года назад
This made me laugh so hard I almost peed my pants
@ReiAyanami8
@ReiAyanami8 3 года назад
"You are technically correct. The best kind of correct."
@apocalypseinheritor1523
@apocalypseinheritor1523 3 года назад
I feel like this is a Dr Who quote. Cannot confirm.
@jsimmons3249
@jsimmons3249 3 года назад
Hermes Estimation
@taronzgaming7739
@taronzgaming7739 3 года назад
@@apocalypseinheritor1523 Futurama.
@bregandaerth2529
@bregandaerth2529 3 года назад
To quote the great beurocrat #1
@inujosha
@inujosha 3 года назад
The lead burecrat dude in the main Burecrat office from Futurama?
@LegendForsaken
@LegendForsaken 3 года назад
"I've stood next to a large dump truck before" as Kyle halfway smirks at the camera.
@Princess_kitty14
@Princess_kitty14 3 года назад
Thicc aria now canon
@vikingbiker
@vikingbiker 3 года назад
That killed me.
@mattscoggins
@mattscoggins 3 года назад
That look absolutely cracked me up as well!
@andrewsparkes8829
@andrewsparkes8829 3 года назад
I'm surprised there weren't more dirty "firm" puns throughout this video...
@dorky2958
@dorky2958 3 года назад
thicc vampire mommy?
@Closer2Zero
@Closer2Zero 3 года назад
I don’t know about anyone else, but my favorite part of each episode is the section after he says he doesn’t know what or how he’s going to fill the time as the Patreon names go by. It’s a very wonderful wrapup or behind-the-scenes moment for each episode that I really appreciate and look forward to
@dubbynelson
@dubbynelson 3 года назад
7:01 "This is going to be difficult, even Fermi"
@excaliburner9413
@excaliburner9413 2 года назад
he needs to pin this
@coolpanda6471
@coolpanda6471 2 года назад
10/10 comment
@Magnymbus
@Magnymbus 3 года назад
I've been doing a version of this for so long but was never taught it or even knew what it was. Now that I know the process properly I feel more confident in my estimates and now it's even easier. Learning is great.
@dedlunch
@dedlunch 2 года назад
Same
@johanbruynsjb
@johanbruynsjb 11 месяцев назад
First time hearing or learning of Fermi calculations. Thank you. And thank you for mention South Africa 🇿🇦
@WarlandWriter
@WarlandWriter 3 года назад
Thanks for this episode. I loved it when you first demonstrated this on that livestream on a channel that shall not be named but was never able to find back what it was called. This is such a great tool, you're doing the basilisk's work with content like this.
@kathrinsides2838
@kathrinsides2838 3 года назад
I really enjoyed watching you think through the problems that you were working on. I’m a former teacher, and I really enjoy your channel. You are a great teacher, and I’m going to recommend you to a couple of my friends who have kids who are in school. I think that they would get a lot out of watching & learning from you. Thank you for what you do.
@maxwilson7001
@maxwilson7001 2 года назад
Thank you for teaching
@Techno_Tod
@Techno_Tod 3 года назад
I used to have an 89 Titanium from 6th grade through AP Calc in 12th grade (the reason I passed, and only got a C [calculator/no calculator portions]) But for college I upgraded to TI's Nspire CX CAS when the batteries eventually leaked after the 89's long tour of duty. Still what I use to date when I need something more than a phone calculator, but doesn't warrant firing up MatLab. Hopefully the Li-ion battery never leaks! Step up your product placement Kyle if you want that brand deal! (having a jest here)
@vcool122
@vcool122 3 года назад
Fun fact: I use metric system and estimated 45 cubic meter for the dump trucks. 2m high, 4m large and 6 meter long + an extra 5 cubic meter of material from the lump. this is so close from your 6ft, 12ft and 18ft dump truck.
@VoidTempests
@VoidTempests 3 года назад
When you showed the result of the shark estimate I wondered how you came to this conclusion, but then I actually got to 972 using only the given numbers and I have to say I`m kinda proud of myself. As always thanks for the video and keep going my favourite science communicator.
@Dracounguis
@Dracounguis 3 года назад
I had a professor in orbital mechanics who could guesstimate distances, figures, orbital times, etc. this way *without a calculator* and be within 10%-20% of the real answer. It was very impressive.
@skylark7921
@skylark7921 2 года назад
It’s so weird bc I use this method like all the time without realizing it’s like a thing. Like if my mom wants to know “how much have we spent on fast food this month?!!” I start figuring: a fast food dinner generally costs about $10 per person, as does the average Starbucks breakfast. Assuming we haven’t had anyone else visiting that means about $20 per meal. If our average weekly consumption of fast food in the past week was about 6 meals (including Starbucks breakfasts and fast food dinners) (she usually says this when we’ve had a month of copious fast food eating), and there are 4 weeks in a month, then we’ve had 24 fast food meals in the past month. If each meal cost $20, then we spent about $480 on fast food in a given month. Which totally tracks since I remember we once looked at a list of all of the transactions on her credit card for budgeting purposes, and we had in that month spend $400 on fast food. I’ve been doing this for ages and never realized it was like an actual method of estimating
@steffenjespersen247
@steffenjespersen247 2 года назад
I use this all the time and just like you said on most things you can get well within one order of magnitute with numbers, you can do in your head. This is also why this is such and good tool to either estimate if something is possible or imposible. If a claim says something is well outside one order of magniture of you guesstimation it is likely not correct.
@Bananaman74799
@Bananaman74799 2 года назад
17:08 mans knew what he was saying
@julianffan
@julianffan 7 месяцев назад
i tip my hat to the guy who somehow got his name put on the process of bullshitting an answer on a multiple choice exam
@AdrianWoodUK
@AdrianWoodUK 3 года назад
5:12 - "...No human's hair, laid end to end, would never reach the moon." Double negative is proof positive - all of us will, one day, have enough hair to the moon. Kyle says so. Cheers Kyle!
@skimmertakesall
@skimmertakesall Год назад
I do this all the time for fun and didn’t realize there was a name for it. I’m thinking 3 billion bricks in Baltimore, half a million pearl cous-cous in a bath tub.
@SalsaPie
@SalsaPie Год назад
I've been doing this on a smaller scale all my life and never realized there was an actual name for it.
@kingjustin1993
@kingjustin1993 3 года назад
So I’ve been doing this for the longest time and didn’t have a word for it. With the great white shark question, I figured that the Great White was endangered ( later found out i was wrong), i figured that the threshold for being endangered was 500 remaining members of a species, I figured that not all of them would be off the coast so I halved the number. My final guess was 250.
@saatwikkatiha4449
@saatwikkatiha4449 3 года назад
I use this all the time when people don't want to give time estimates - "how long will the task take?" "I don't know" "you must know the ballpark figure?" "No" "1 hour or 1 week?" "2-3 days" Good enough for me 🤷‍♂️
@1110631
@1110631 2 года назад
On the dump truck answer, alternatively, it would take just one dump truck to haul away Mt. Everest...in 6.4 billion loads.
@Lord_Brocktree
@Lord_Brocktree 2 года назад
Oh man, I'm using this with my kid's homeschooling! This is amazing!
@Druwoods
@Druwoods 3 года назад
I learned this in Navy nuke school, never knew Fermi came up with it. I use this method to answer people's random questions all the time. Yeah, if you look up some of your conversions you can calculate just about anything.
@steeljawX
@steeljawX 3 года назад
Discount Thor: "I've stood next to a really big dump truck before." Me: "Kyle, that's not a very nice thing to call Name-Brand Thor." 😆 But thanks for explaining this actual life hack. I've heard the term thrown around before and read alittle on it but I got critically confused, and no, I'm not being over dramatic or referencing Pokemon. Most online things on it just hurt my brainium so bad I lost interest in it. This is much more digestible. Thanks again.
@OzzySilent420
@OzzySilent420 3 года назад
So am I the only one who just estimated stuff like this naturally? I mean this is how I've always estimated things, and this is the first I'm ever hearing of a Fermi estimation.
@elderhickory0776
@elderhickory0776 Год назад
You could’ve made an even more accurate guess if you had increased the great white sharks actually habitat. Austriallia is a good example.
@Ryokoranger
@Ryokoranger 3 года назад
Hears Kyle joke about 2kpm air in front of him. balks at the idea that 120 CFM is blowing past him and his hair isn't moving.
@dustinhill9390
@dustinhill9390 2 года назад
I know I'm real late to this video, but it made me feel really good that i picked up on the basketball mistake. I paused the video did my own calculations for it, and unpaused just for Kyle to pick up on the same error and calculate it the way I did. 🥰 I officially love this channel. 😀
@gabeathouse9683
@gabeathouse9683 3 года назад
How to solve basic math problems using basic math. Hey, I have 4 apples, and someone gave me another apple. Can Fermi help me figure out how many apples I have? 10 apples. Close enough. Thank you Fermi, and man in video.
@elimgarak7330
@elimgarak7330 7 месяцев назад
So Fermi's big trick was the units management taught in physics 101?
@rellikpd
@rellikpd 2 года назад
I've always been good at guesstimating... always because I know "a little bit" about "almost everything".... So could guesstimate pretty darn close to any random thing I wanted to guess at..... Turns out I was using the Fermi Method in my head the whole time, but in an abstract way, instead of a pen&paper way. neato
@Fattts
@Fattts Год назад
Sharks exercise: I estimated there was around 300000 great white sharks in the oceans worldwide. I then guessed they had around a 10 percent chance of being within 50 miles of a coastline in the equatorial region, estimated that of total coastlines on earth california had probably 5 percent of equatorial coasts (which i defined in my head as between the tropics of cancer and capricorn). Came up to 200. Hair: my hair grows around an inch and a half a year, so my hair would probably be 110ish inches long if i lived to be 72 and never cut it. (Guessing roughly the multiplication since i don't wanna lose my comment so far) NBA: Probably 150000. Average NBA score is between 100 and 200, and there's around 100ish games a season. Trucks: using the volume of everest, and knowing a dump truck can haul around 2 to 7 cubic yards of rock, it would take around 2000000 loads to haul all of everest somewhere else assuming we use trucks capable of hauling the maximum of 7 yards each. This was all estimated while in the bathroom with no note paper
@luciferosborn3319
@luciferosborn3319 3 года назад
I have a question. I tried to find out the shape of our solar system and our galaxy and based on what I found on the RU-vid and the net was that the solar system and the galaxy are disc shaped rather than spherical. Why is that? As per my vague understanding of physics, I thought that the solar system and other celestial bodies would be in a arrangement similar to atoms where the bodies revolve around the center point in any plane essentially giving the galaxy a spherical appearance.
@gurrrn1102
@gurrrn1102 3 года назад
NBA points per season: Teams x games x team pts per game I know hardly anything about the nba but I have seen scores during my time. My guesstimate of an average team score is about 80 points. American major leagues seem to have 32 teams that never change apart from when one team moves to the other side of the country. I rounded down to 30 to make the mental calculation easier. I looked up nba records at one point out of curiosity and the most games played by one player is around 1500 - or at least only a couple of people have played more than that. I think Kareem Abdul Jabbar was one of those few and he played about 20 seasons (maybe a couple more but 20 years is pretty much an upper limit for a sporting career). 1500/20 = 75 games per season so that was my games per season estimate. 80 x 75 x 30 = 180000 so pretty damn close to the actual figure.
@purpleiguana208
@purpleiguana208 3 года назад
This was such a fun video! I am fairly certain that there are WAY more than 10,000 hairs on a human head. I once heard 110,000 as an average. You still wouldn't get to the moon, though.
@kayranis
@kayranis 3 года назад
Didn't know a calculator could run out of battery, I thought it was impossible hahaha. In my almost 25 years of life I haven't seen even one calculator run out of battery (not even scientific ones)
@Rondigity92
@Rondigity92 2 года назад
If you considered Australia as another shark habitat you would have been even closer
@TheGrimravager
@TheGrimravager 2 года назад
huh, when we discussed fermi problems in uni, calculators were strictly forbidden
@chadreese9501
@chadreese9501 Год назад
Thanks for the lesson!
@arthurb6200
@arthurb6200 Год назад
Thor teaching us about maths is awesome.
@ahiro220
@ahiro220 3 года назад
I've been doing this for years and calling it slop math, for math with estimates will have play, and I get a range
@TheModularian
@TheModularian 3 года назад
I guessed 500 sharks just with a general understanding of their declining population in the ocean!
@NirPantheraPardus
@NirPantheraPardus 2 года назад
renthead: 525,600 minutes.... 🎶
@alex_roivas333
@alex_roivas333 3 года назад
bro! you should have Fermi estimated the volume of mount Everest. I got close by pretending it was a 5 mile tall cone ^_^
@mckay91095
@mckay91095 2 года назад
Formless and emotionless void? Wow Nerdist must be really bad.
@wolfhawk1999
@wolfhawk1999 2 года назад
Okay, but how many marbles are in the jar? Guess and win the prize.
@sarahgargani5836
@sarahgargani5836 3 года назад
I got almost almost the exact answer for the hair (10.6 meters) and that is because I was off on average life a little. the fact that I get 12 inches of hair cut off every two years means I have a lot of confidence in the rate of hair growth.
@lunasills8031
@lunasills8031 3 года назад
Wow! I'm actually surprised with this ngl. For the portion where you did it on camera, I tried the hair length problem before I watched you try to solve it. And I came up with 10.16 meters! My process was as follows - I know the average lifespan to be around 80 years - I know it takes about 2 years for a buzzcut to grow to shoulder length, and id imagine that being around 10-12 inches. I played it safe and said 10 inches. I simply multiplied the inches that hair grows in a year, by the average years in a life to get 400 inches. 400 inches to meters is 10.16 meters Sadly I didn't attempt the rest because I had no clue about any numbers whatsoever for those
@typicalwatcher1557
@typicalwatcher1557 Год назад
I infered the great white shark population correctly. Cool
@deldarel
@deldarel Год назад
That's so few sharks! I thought you were an order too small because 900 is so small to maintain a species, assuming the populations don't meet.
@brodiegames4207
@brodiegames4207 3 года назад
This man is Thor if he was a scientist
@aidancloquell
@aidancloquell 3 года назад
How accurate does it sound that in a whole highschool year I see 45 000 girls obviously counting repetition?
@aidancloquell
@aidancloquell 3 года назад
I also tried to calculate the volume of the highest mountain in Mallorca
@moceri55
@moceri55 2 года назад
Is that the same method that Drake used for his famous equation named for himself?
@MrSchism
@MrSchism 3 года назад
My estimate on the sharks was more accurate because of Australia.
@rdooski
@rdooski 3 года назад
Am I the only person who has done this all their life, and thought it was something everyone already did?
@Moonbeam744
@Moonbeam744 2 года назад
I really enjoyed this video
@liambethell2584
@liambethell2584 3 года назад
From what I can ascertain your correct answer for the NBA question is off. 186000 points in an nba season/ 30 teams/82 games equates to each team averaging about 75 points per game. However the lowest scoring team in the nba last season averaged 103 points per game. So the correct answer though I cannot definitively find it is closer to you estimation than the correct answer given in the video. Being a fan of the NBA and us in Fermi I estimate the correct answer is probably closer to 260,000
@chompchompnomnom4256
@chompchompnomnom4256 2 года назад
I knew hair wasn't 5mm a week, I always heard is was about 5-10mm a month
@ligitadventurez
@ligitadventurez 3 года назад
For the sharks, my method was to guess that you could expect an average of 1 shark for every 2 or so miles of coast and assumed the coast was about 1000 miles so I guess 500-600 and I was so close
@lugardgrante2582
@lugardgrante2582 3 года назад
Маке а Nоte 📝 to Му Вгокег, John Cloar То gепегаte retuгпs oп Crурtо investment..,......,,......
@lugardgrante2582
@lugardgrante2582 3 года назад
Ш•H•A•T•S•A•P•P +•1• 9•3•6• 8• 8• 8• 6 •7• 0• 5•........,,,
@ligitadventurez
@ligitadventurez 3 года назад
@@lugardgrante2582 did you get hacked? I am confused
@lugardgrante2582
@lugardgrante2582 3 года назад
@@ligitadventurez hell no
@Nivleknosnhoj
@Nivleknosnhoj 2 года назад
If it's ok to look up the volume of mount Everest surely by that (cheating) logic you can also look up the volume a dump truck can hold?!
@ArtamisBot
@ArtamisBot 3 года назад
So could you use this method to estimate how long until the emergence of AI super intelligence?
@tyrannosauruscock
@tyrannosauruscock 3 года назад
It takes 1 dump truck to move Mount Everest, plus a lot of time.
@lucafiore6275
@lucafiore6275 3 года назад
Thanks Kyle, now I can get every question on my math tests almost right.
@maoman4855
@maoman4855 2 года назад
"I have approximate knowledge of many things"
@zzz_zzz_ZZZ_zzz_ZZZ_ZZZ_Z_z-ZZ
@zzz_zzz_ZZZ_zzz_ZZZ_ZZZ_Z_z-ZZ 2 года назад
@@maoman4855 would this count as a shitty superpower?
@tristanmurphy7337
@tristanmurphy7337 2 года назад
@@zzz_zzz_ZZZ_zzz_ZZZ_ZZZ_Z_z-ZZ yoooo definitely should be
@zzz_zzz_ZZZ_zzz_ZZZ_ZZZ_Z_z-ZZ
@zzz_zzz_ZZZ_zzz_ZZZ_ZZZ_Z_z-ZZ 2 года назад
Actually on a second thought this can be a god-tier superpower on par with omniscience to a lesser degree though. So, in theory you can predict anything with this power. Assuming your approximation has a constant error you can always just correct it by using the constant. Stock market here I come
@richunclejoey2249
@richunclejoey2249 2 года назад
@@zzz_zzz_ZZZ_zzz_ZZZ_ZZZ_Z_z-ZZ that's why I'm watching this..find a constant deviation, program an EA and forward test it on commodities trading..lol
@Jason-ue7gi
@Jason-ue7gi 3 года назад
As a middle school science teacher, I use fermi estimates ALL THE TIME to answer crazy questions from my students that I have no way of 100% correctly answering on the fly
@ToxicTerrance
@ToxicTerrance 3 года назад
I think all my science teachers did the same. Lol Edit) Although I had a physics teacher that was too comfortable with the phrase "That's impossible" Real dream crusher. Lol
@BigDaddyWes
@BigDaddyWes 3 года назад
@@ToxicTerrance That's when you say, "It's impossible for you, but not Fermi."
@gonzalodasilva1229
@gonzalodasilva1229 3 года назад
@@BigDaddyWes great pun sir
@lunartransport5461
@lunartransport5461 3 года назад
So you lie to your students regularly... nice
@Steampuke
@Steampuke 3 года назад
@@lunartransport5461 what ?
@mattgunnell9416
@mattgunnell9416 3 года назад
I remember doing these kinds of exercises in school. My dad calls these SWAGs: Scientific Wild A$$ Guesses
@MaryAnnNytowl
@MaryAnnNytowl 3 года назад
LMAO, that is what MY dad called them, waaaaaay back when I was a little tyke, about 50 years ago! He was an engineer/radio man for decades, along with helping to design the first radar systems for the downtown KCMO airport, about 7 decades ago. He had a solid understanding of sciences and math, and often used this method, literally calling it a SWAG! Thanks for the walk down memory lane! 😊
@matthewcox7985
@matthewcox7985 3 года назад
Show your SWAG! 🤣
@mattgunnell9416
@mattgunnell9416 3 года назад
@@MaryAnnNytowl you're welcome! 😀
@Lambda_Ovine
@Lambda_Ovine 3 года назад
I doubt any dad to be that cool
@geordannik
@geordannik 3 года назад
That's actually a proper phrase! Wikipedia it lol
@mstieler8480
@mstieler8480 3 года назад
"The air's moving around at around 2 KpH in here by the way." Two Kyles per Hill? WHERE IS THIS OTHER KYLE?
@denomaly646
@denomaly646 3 года назад
I actually can't breathe lol
@TearsOfLa
@TearsOfLa 3 года назад
he's on the hill of course
@techstuff9198
@techstuff9198 2 года назад
Kilo-pascals per hectare doesn't sound right in any world... But I've seen even worse measurement systems so I'll take it
@dhayes5143
@dhayes5143 2 года назад
He'll be here in another hour
@enginerd1985
@enginerd1985 3 года назад
I love how the Drake equation is simply a Fermi estimate, jumbo sized.
@mlembrant
@mlembrant 2 года назад
i use this method to estimate how much dough will be needed for tomorrow so i can make enough pizza that customers will order that day ^^
@borttorbbq2556
@borttorbbq2556 2 года назад
@@mlembrant I do it too for all prep
@borttorbbq2556
@borttorbbq2556 2 года назад
Also yes it basically is.
@maxmccann5323
@maxmccann5323 2 года назад
Yeah same, whatever that means
@-MrFozzy-
@-MrFozzy- 2 года назад
The Drake equation is just a totally made up guess…it’s barely an equation. His guess just had great PR. Evidence?! 1 million intelligent civilisations in our universe (or galaxy) I forget……but, it could be none, it could be five…
@WitchVulgar
@WitchVulgar 3 года назад
Title: How to estimate anything Me: All non-infinity numbers round to zero
@IceMetalPunk
@IceMetalPunk 3 года назад
"When you consider the number of particles in the universe, or the age of the universe at the time of heat death, or the diameter of the universe, all numbers are basically zero."
@relzyn5545
@relzyn5545 3 года назад
infinity isn't a number smh
@Dr_Andracca
@Dr_Andracca 3 года назад
@@relzyn5545 Neither is 0 or any negative number in any real sense, but it doesn't stop humans from using their concepts to mentally grasp things though.
@IceMetalPunk
@IceMetalPunk 3 года назад
@@Dr_Andracca That's... not true. 0 and negative numbers are numbers. Infinity is literally not a number because it doesn't act like numbers.
@asdfasdfasdf1218
@asdfasdfasdf1218 3 года назад
@@IceMetalPunk *Wrong* , infinity is a number. To be more precise, infinity is an extended real number. It is not a real number, though. Just like i is a complex number, but not a real number. And j and k are quaternions, but not complex numbers. Another related concept is infinitesimals, numbers > 0 but less than 1/n for any natural number n, and their reciprocal, infinite numbers (not to be confused with infinity) greater than n for any natural number n, which exist as hyperreal numbers, though neither infinitesimals nor infinite numbers are real numbers. One way to understand how infinity fits in with the real numbers to make the extended real numbers is through stereographic projection. Each point on the line can correspond to a point on the circle, and infinity would be the point connecting the two ends. Thus infinity naturally completes the circle from negative large numbers to positive large numbers. This is even more important on the complex plane, where it instead sits as the north pole of a sphere. Points of infinity are a central study in complex analysis, where they're called "poles" and determine the value of path integrals based on the topological properties of the path around the poles, such as their winding number. This shows that not only does infinity fit in well with the rest of the complex numbers, but it is a central concept.
@Siansonea
@Siansonea 3 года назад
"Is that a firm estimate?" "No, it's a Fermi estimate." "Isn't that what I just asked?"
@dinamosflams
@dinamosflams 3 года назад
"almost"
@madkirk7431
@madkirk7431 3 года назад
@@dinamosflams *well yes but actually no*
@boio_
@boio_ 3 года назад
@@dinamosflams lmfao
@anchovybushwack472
@anchovybushwack472 3 года назад
Three replies in and I already love this thread
@Random_Nobody_Official
@Random_Nobody_Official 3 года назад
@@anchovybushwack472 make that four.
@THE_KIRYU
@THE_KIRYU 3 года назад
"what's 9+10?" Enrico Fermi: "21"
@werebison
@werebison 3 года назад
Three statisticians go hunting. The first one takes a shot, missing 1m to the left. The second misses his shot 1m to the right. They all high five and go home.
@ImieNazwiskoOK
@ImieNazwiskoOK 3 года назад
*29
@Joseph125
@Joseph125 3 года назад
Eh, it's the right order of magnitude. Close enough. Once you've seen lecturers estimate pi as 1 and 10 in the same lecture, anything is reasonable.
@Nightriser271828
@Nightriser271828 3 года назад
@@Joseph125 engineers, amirite?
@The_Viktor_Reznov
@The_Viktor_Reznov 3 года назад
@@Joseph125 π = √g = e = 3
@niamhythedegen
@niamhythedegen 3 года назад
"A few years ago when I was trapped in a formless, emotionless void-". Ah, so working on Because Science
@stelmaria-mx
@stelmaria-mx 3 года назад
Yes, that's the point
@AxxLAfriku
@AxxLAfriku 3 года назад
AAAAAAHHHHH!!!! PAAAAAIIIINNNN!!!!!! I broke my hand yesterday because of the hate comments I get all the time. I was so angry that I punched a hole in my computer. Please don't hate me, dear mera
@niamhythedegen
@niamhythedegen 3 года назад
I have ascended, I've received the fabled AxxL reply
@AxxLAfriku
@AxxLAfriku 3 года назад
@@niamhythedegen *AxxL
@niamhythedegen
@niamhythedegen 3 года назад
@@AxxLAfriku ah yes of course, how foolish of me
@goldenoreo9171
@goldenoreo9171 3 года назад
That "Texas Instruments, sponsor us" at the end made me laugh my ass off. I'm sitting at work, on break, at a Texas Instruments facility in TX at this very moment
@Xadov
@Xadov 3 года назад
Please sponsor him
@Skelterbane69
@Skelterbane69 2 года назад
So.... Is that a yes?
@maoman4855
@maoman4855 2 года назад
And I immediately hopped up to grab my TI-89 Titanium! ...then hopped up again to search for my TI-82 which was buried in my under-bed drawer ...then hopped up again to put batteries in both of them because I haven't touched either in almost a decade. But I knew where they were!
@DialecticRed
@DialecticRed 10 месяцев назад
​@@XadovThey're likely just an employee, who does not have the power to do that.
@nightthought2497
@nightthought2497 3 года назад
The best part of a Fermi estimation is that once you've done it, you have an incentive to check your work, providing yourself with even more points of confidence.
@GarethTheGreat325
@GarethTheGreat325 3 года назад
"How many great white sharks are swimming off the coast of california?" All of them, you don't swim on a coast
@CSpottsGaming
@CSpottsGaming 3 года назад
Badum tss
@jeramil1271
@jeramil1271 3 года назад
"All the live ones." Great white sharks need to swim to breathe.
@manuelc3671
@manuelc3671 3 года назад
Found the A.I.
@ratdog9
@ratdog9 3 года назад
checkmate rico fermi
@kamalmanzukie
@kamalmanzukie 2 года назад
off a coast genius
@YouTubeCommenter8
@YouTubeCommenter8 3 года назад
What’s even more fun is using the right answer to triangulate, cross reference, and analyze my guesstimation biases
@Impassive_Bru
@Impassive_Bru 3 года назад
YESSS I was raised badly and adopted this thinking style
@Impassive_Bru
@Impassive_Bru 3 года назад
Rather, not normal.
@KickstandOptional
@KickstandOptional 3 года назад
This is the kind of nerd representation that we need. Good on ya, Hunter.
@YouTubeCommenter8
@YouTubeCommenter8 3 года назад
@@KickstandOptional thanks Papa! It’s always been interesting to me to find what trains of thought might have impacted my final conclusions. That way if I ever move past the “guesstimation” phase I know where I probably need more research
@KickstandOptional
@KickstandOptional 3 года назад
@@RU-vidCommenter8 Using the accuracy of your guesstimates to guesstimate the biases that influenced them. This guy sciences.
@bWOOOPdeWooop
@bWOOOPdeWooop 3 года назад
Kyle, you were actually even closer on the NBA question if you're counting the points scored in a normal season. The last two seasons were shortened due to covid so the totals were lower but 2018-2019 there were about 275,000 points scored. I know the point is just getting close by fermistimating but gotta give you the credit you deserve you total sports guy. Love the channel, keep it up
@GrayBlood1331
@GrayBlood1331 3 года назад
My guess was 230,400. It feels so good to be vindicated.
@notme907
@notme907 3 года назад
but wasn't his calculation way off? why would he multiple 32(Teams) x 100(total games) x 100(points)? This would mean that every Team plays 100 games per season, but Kyle meant to calculate that there are 100 games in total thru all teams per season, didn't he?
@bWOOOPdeWooop
@bWOOOPdeWooop 3 года назад
@@notme907 no I think it worked out because he was assuming 100 games per season per team
@notme907
@notme907 3 года назад
@@bWOOOPdeWooop ah yeah would make more sense that way.
@bWOOOPdeWooop
@bWOOOPdeWooop 3 года назад
@@notme907 yeah initially I thought he meant 100 games total when he was thinking out loud
@Ariuss3
@Ariuss3 3 года назад
"No this isn't cheating, this is using what we have available." So are you saying that I can just google answers instead of using this method?
@ShizaanSil
@ShizaanSil 3 года назад
Not gonna lie, if he estimated the volume of Everest that would be way cooler
@azuregriffin1116
@azuregriffin1116 3 года назад
@@ShizaanSil I was thinking he'd model Everest as a cone and do that math lol
@mclason
@mclason 3 года назад
@@ShizaanSil Did pretty well on my own fermi estimate for this, all in all. Don't recall how high it was. Figured maybe 10 mi, but then recalled I think that's actually Olympus Mons (mars), so dropped it to 2 mi, which seemed more accurate. A mountain is basically just a big triangle if you look at it from the side, but it's not equilateral, so let's figure it's maybe 2x as wide as it is tall. So that's a triangle with a 4mi base with a 2 mi height. Then we consider the 3D rotation, so we make it a cone (circle that moves up to a point) instead of a triangle. I'm thinking recalling that the prefix for volume of cone or sphere is 4/3 (unsure which one), and it's volume, so radius cubed (radius being half the base), and it's a circle, so definitely need a pi in there, then we also need the height, so formula is probably 4/3*pi*r^3*h. This gives us about 67 cubic miles. Converting to feet, we multiply by (5280 ft)^3 = 9.86x10^12 cubic feet. 2.1x10^12 is the actual value. This makes sense as volume constant is actually 1/3 for cones not 4/3 (that's for spheres). That gives us the much closer (within 18%) 2.465x10^12 cubic feet. Showing that it does pay to look up the correct formulas when doing fermi estimates :).
@1999Fabion
@1999Fabion 3 года назад
@@mclason we wouldn't be here if we didn't know what a cone is and what a radius is
@mclason
@mclason 3 года назад
@@1999Fabion probably but doesnt hurt to clarify. Also radius in thst case waas half the base of the triangle, so slightly less obvious.
@squish3r
@squish3r 3 года назад
Fermi guesses are PERFECT for making sure your "precise" calculations make sense. The funniest example I found of it is "How many piano tuners work in Chicago?" The author looked up the population of Chicago, and then guestimated their way to within 5% of the right answer. It was pretty impressive, NGL. Great work, as always!
@tomcads1604
@tomcads1604 2 года назад
The piano tuners one is supposed to be an original one by Fermi myself he used to test students with. I only think it was for New York rather than Chicago
@saltycreole2673
@saltycreole2673 3 года назад
I can guesstimate within a few cents all of my grocery bills with admirable regularity. Does that count?
@flygawnebardoflight
@flygawnebardoflight 3 года назад
Yes
@natanoj16
@natanoj16 3 года назад
Yeps. It does
@gemma7438
@gemma7438 3 года назад
I think it does
@fancyf33t295
@fancyf33t295 3 года назад
Oh yeah. Definitely comes in hand with budgeting.
@shutupstupid5630
@shutupstupid5630 3 года назад
Yes, yes it does
@TheCharmanderMaster
@TheCharmanderMaster 3 года назад
I really think this should be taught in more courses than just physics. I was a physics major for 5 minutes before switching to engineering and my physics classes were the only ones to teach Fermi estimations. The thing is, this technique doesn't require any specific vault of knowledge, it just requires that you be taught how to think. Any student could learn this, regardless of major. It also would be super helpful for those annoying job interviews where someone asks you "How many pianos are in New York"?
@DarkwarriorJ
@DarkwarriorJ 3 года назад
I think it should be taught in algebra class. This sort of estimate strongly makes algebra useful and fun; and really is just an application of algebra - relations. Now that I say this, it actually almost seems criminal that it isn't usually taught in ~grade 6 algebra.
@bulldozer8950
@bulldozer8950 3 года назад
They actually are taught a bit in high school maths. That’s the exact format many of my teachers have used to convert between units in math class, such as minutes to hours to days, but they never name the Method or acknowledge that it could be used in such a way to estimate
@DarkwarriorJ
@DarkwarriorJ 3 года назад
@@bulldozer8950 Yeah - unit conversion and dimensional analysis are taught; the big leap that isn't taught is the idea that we can really abuse this to estimate things using very rough numbers, get within an order of magnitude, and feel what the order of magnitude means. It's crazy - like, we basically learn all the mathematical skills needed for this by high school; the final leap is realizing how we could use this! I think part of this is that math questions might actually focus too much on highly specific numbers that one may not have on a regular basis. Grading by exactly correct numbers; whereas trying to judge how a student handles a Fermi estimate is more like reading a small essay, I'd figure.
@Merennulli
@Merennulli 3 года назад
The answer to any job interview that asks "How many pianos are in New York" or similar questions is usually "goodbye". There is a fantasy that those kinds of questions demonstrate problem solving skills, but they really don't. You're correct that Fermi estimation would be the way to address those questions, but Fermi estimation is just one tool that you've either learned or not learned, and it's not a useful tool for most career fields where these kinds of questions get asked. I know your instinct is to think that they must be asking them for jobs where it makes sense to ask them, but they really aren't. And there have been studies done on the efficacy of the questions...and who asks them. The answers to those questions are not indicative of employee performance, meaning it's utterly useless to be asked them. However, being asked them does correlate strongly with bad employers.
@choty7066
@choty7066 3 года назад
My guess is 80.000
@ronrainey1639
@ronrainey1639 3 года назад
What’s fun about this is once you have tour guesstimation next to the actual number, you can reverse engineer your estimations to find where you were off and posit why you where over/under on a number. Like the dump trucks- the truck might be 2 Kyles tall but the bed starts 1 Kyle up which makes it only 1 Kyle deep overall. Run that calculation and you’d be closer to the actual number. Fun!
@DialecticRed
@DialecticRed 10 месяцев назад
ooh, and I'd imagine if you practiced this enough you'd improve your guestimation abilities as well from knowing how close or far you've been in the past
@40watt53
@40watt53 9 месяцев назад
@@DialecticRedgod i love how yall talk about this like its a superpower or something 😭
@mud4309
@mud4309 2 года назад
Dude this is so freaky and cool. When Kyle was doing the guesstimations for sharks I did my own even shoddier, even more imprecise measurements going “Yeah that sounds about right”. I guesstimated knowing the distance from my home in Vegas to the coast of California which is 300 or so miles (and I only know due to visiting family on the coast) then went “I think the coast is about two of that distance”, doubled it since I think I recall miles to km being vaguely “double the miles = km” (only just now remembering thats just for metric WEIGHT and I have no clue if that actually applies to distance) then asked from my experience at beaches and very vague knowledge of shark inspired beach hysterics if one shark per kilometer sounded right, then if two sharks per km sounded right - and it did So I ran the Fermi estimate numbers, 1 shark per 2km divided over 600km of coast = about 300 sharks off the coast right now. I sat there waiting to see how insanely off I was because no way my estimate is within a mile of this super smart science man with tons of statistics and figures (vs me, a highschool dropout who, yeah, LOVES hearing about the results of science but struggles to even sorta comprehend the processes and math involved in getting those results 95% of the time) yet LO AND BEHOLD. I WAS MORE SPOT ON THAN HIM This is the only situation in math I have ever heard of where less precise data and figures have been a boon, and I can only assume its due to the fact that he had a lot of precise and neutral numbers, with big and heavier numbers, resulting in a net skew towards larger estimations. Meanwhile my dumbass (probably, I havent checked) way underestimated the distance of the coast and (again, probably) way over estimated the amount of great white sharks that exist on the coast and so those both balanced out to a way more neutral number. I know no one cares or will read this but I just needed to write it down somewhere because this was such a wild and mind blowing experience for me. Never before have I truly experienced and utilized the sheer power and magic that is MATH to this insane degree, all thanks to Kyle. Thank you Kyle this is amazing stuff
@stevenholt824
@stevenholt824 2 года назад
I read it ! Theres every chance you were way off somewhere but it averaged out , more importantly you did it by yourself. I'm into astrophotography and my wife says just Google the pics theyre way better , but that's not the point , it's doing it for yourself. I mean why go camping when you own a house, why watch sport when it's far more fun to do it yourself. Why watch a reality soap when you have your own life to live.
@Niugnep
@Niugnep 3 года назад
"within a value of 3" " you gotta be impressed by that... unless you're a seal." I may be wrong, but if I was a seal and I knew there are less than imagined i'd be pretty happy.
@shawnnoyes2776
@shawnnoyes2776 3 года назад
and then sad that Gerald was eaten last year anyway :-(
@mclason
@mclason 3 года назад
That's still a lot more than you want as a seal.
@predoarantes4641
@predoarantes4641 3 года назад
That's how me and my dad solve discussions when we drink
@GraemeGunn
@GraemeGunn 3 года назад
What a terrible joke.
@MarkusAldawn
@MarkusAldawn 3 года назад
@@GraemeGunn I don't think it's meant to be- it's not that unreasonable to grab a napkin and a pen and start writing down numbers
@davidechols2016
@davidechols2016 3 года назад
My dad and I
@gingercore69
@gingercore69 3 года назад
And the history of guiness world records actually started in a similar way
@Spolt_main
@Spolt_main 3 года назад
@@davidechols2016 shut up dad
@aur3ldu05
@aur3ldu05 3 года назад
"My TI is out of battery". This is the story of my engineering life
@Virsconte
@Virsconte 3 года назад
Taking a heat transfer final when your calculator is dead. Not fun.
@aur3ldu05
@aur3ldu05 3 года назад
@@Virsconte I know that feel... Doing as much as you can by hand and using what's left of the battery to finish it, hopping it doesn't die on you
@thecrimsonfire4921
@thecrimsonfire4921 3 года назад
I feel like this should be properly taught in school. Over in Australia I’ve never once heard of this. Just feels like it’s a great way to get people to think about a problem instead of knowing the answer to a problem
@bishoptrees
@bishoptrees 2 года назад
Also, last time I checked, we have great whites down here too... But we don't exist, right flat earthers?
@alexandergremory9468
@alexandergremory9468 2 года назад
@@bishoptrees Aren't all whites great? Okay, I'm going to go sit in the corner.
@DialecticRed
@DialecticRed 10 месяцев назад
​@@alexandergremory9468White supremacists be like
@Mernom
@Mernom 7 месяцев назад
​​@@bishoptreesif you divide by 4 instead of 3, the answer he came up with would be even more accurate...
@HeWhoComments
@HeWhoComments 3 года назад
My mind has been corrupted. Every time I hear “dump truck” I can’t help but to think about rear ends lol
@daniel-zh9nj6yn6y
@daniel-zh9nj6yn6y 3 года назад
Pixar mothers :)
@harrygenderson6847
@harrygenderson6847 3 года назад
I'd rear-end that dump truck ;)
@BigDaddyWes
@BigDaddyWes 3 года назад
"But this is going to be difficult....... even Fermi."
@didntask6019
@didntask6019 3 года назад
hehe nice one
@wojciechszmyt3360
@wojciechszmyt3360 3 года назад
At a physics competition in high school that I took part in, there was a special section of problems to solve: estimation challenge. They didn't give any parameter values, we had to estimate them best we could. That was certainly out of my comfort zone, because all the problems would always have precise "here is X and Y, figure out what's Z". It was an interesting experience for sure! Good times :) Not to flex, but I managed to be a laureate on this thing, which gave me an easy entrance to a good university, and I work as a scientist now, and estimation is a very important part of my job!
@sayanjitb
@sayanjitb 3 года назад
Nice to read your experience!
@cornofthechildren
@cornofthechildren 3 года назад
I use this process everyday just for fun, I didn't even realize it had a name.
@heroiuraresjustinian4681
@heroiuraresjustinian4681 3 года назад
Lol same
@trybunt
@trybunt 3 года назад
Yeah, I've actually calculated the number of seconds in a year before... And how many meters per second I drive, how long it would take to walk around the world, how many generations there has been since life began.... so it was funny to see the weird stuff I subconsciously do in my head being explained as something useful
@narx4cancer
@narx4cancer 3 года назад
same
@bulldozer8950
@bulldozer8950 3 года назад
@@trybunt remember. It’s wasting time, unless you write it down. Then it becomes science.
@3nertia
@3nertia 3 года назад
Me as well
@jocloud31
@jocloud31 3 года назад
I sincerely appreciate the segment showing how you did these in real time AND that you got one wrong and went back and fixed it. So often we only see the polished, finished product on RU-vid tutorials and it can be intimidating when you try to replicate it yourself. Thank you SO MUCH for showing that process!
@housecaldwell
@housecaldwell 2 года назад
@@AspynDotZip Same here - but ironically the first estimate was closer to the truth.
@hyliasknight
@hyliasknight 2 года назад
the only issue is that the reworked equation was assuming every team in the NBA plays all 100 estimated games that happen in a single season... when only two teams can play in any one game.
@thepewplace1370
@thepewplace1370 2 года назад
Yeah this was a blast. Even estimating the size of Mt. Everest by figuring its probably 3 times as wide as it is tall, knowing it's about 30,000 feet tall, and ball parking a dump truck, I wound up about a factor of ten off (99B trucks), factor of 3 for the hair, and factor of 2 for the basketball scores. In the realms those answers wind up being, it's close enough for government work (the difference between 7 billion dump trucks and 100 billion dump trucks seems irrelevant). It's also pretty interesting to see that Kyle tends to underestimate, whereas I tend to overestimate. Useful to know when considering your estimated answers. I've done estimations similarly to this before, but didn't know it was a thing that could yield actually useful answers in so many places. This will be fun to try.
@spacenerd9499
@spacenerd9499 2 года назад
Learning and solving problems can get pretty messy
@niagaradrones
@niagaradrones 3 года назад
As a Guitarist in front of Whole Foods in Birkenstocks... I feel personally attacked...
@dubyalast3734
@dubyalast3734 3 года назад
I’d be interested to see a detailed breakdown of Fermi’s actual estimate from the blast
@jonathanshaw6784
@jonathanshaw6784 3 года назад
At a guess: they would know pretty much their exact distance from the blast (they were the ones designing the experiment and the safety parameters). Inverse square law for distribution of the energy, compare movement to known quantity of TNT explosion, with sanity check from previous estimates. Edit: they would already know the maths for how suspended things move since they used rocket trails to track the shockwave on camera.
@Arcangel0723
@Arcangel0723 3 года назад
I think numberphile did a video on this before
@espinozamarko6118
@espinozamarko6118 3 года назад
"i've stood next to a large dumptruck before" **remembers the vampire's mommy video**
@Tofu1998
@Tofu1998 Год назад
My freshman Physics teacher told me that you can even estimate how physical equations look like. Start from gathering as much as seemingly relevant input parameters and try to arrange them in an equation in a manner where the units cancel out until they matches the unit of the output.
@GeekPsychologist
@GeekPsychologist 3 года назад
So apparently I've been using Fermi estimates all my life without knowing they had a name. Neat, I think.
@Parodox306
@Parodox306 3 года назад
It is neat that you think
@queenannsrevenge100
@queenannsrevenge100 3 года назад
@@Parodox306 - I wonder if the method was used before Fermi, whether he actually created the process or just popularized it. I’d like to believe someone like Archimedes or one of the Arab mathematicians came up with it, but sometimes the simplest solutions really do take a long time before someone envisions them.
@Parodox306
@Parodox306 3 года назад
@@queenannsrevenge100 I feel like the technique is something many people were aware of well before Fermi (look through the comments and notice how many people used it before knowing it had a name; hell, I've personally used it plenty of times before know who Fermi was), but he codified it in a way that made it more accessible. It's likely that many of the greats throughout history had similar strategies but used different language to describe the process, or just took it for granted, thinking it's what people naturally do.
@christianstarr9188
@christianstarr9188 3 года назад
@@Parodox306 I would put my money on your last guess. When I was in middle school our science teacher covered dimensional analysis for simple unit conversions, because it's a simple format, and I had the same "aha" moment the comment section is having now.
@JimRFF
@JimRFF 3 года назад
Video title "How to Guesstimate Like a Genius" Uploaded: 1 minute ago Me: I'm already 4 parallel universes ahead of you
@LuxGamer16
@LuxGamer16 3 года назад
Video title changed. I see this alot actually. Confuses me on why tho
@bizichyld
@bizichyld 2 года назад
I am a pharmacist and use dimensional analysis all the time while working, but it applies in so many areas of life. It’s probably the single most useful mathematical tool I’ve ever learned.
@GabrielHodge
@GabrielHodge 11 месяцев назад
My man
Далее
This Thought Experiment Changed THE MATRIX
15:06
Просмотров 386 тыс.
Quantum Levitation - Why Superconductors Float
16:40
Просмотров 335 тыс.
Suing YouTube’s Science Scammers
19:45
Просмотров 1,2 млн
The Oldest Unsolved Problem in Math
31:33
Просмотров 10 млн
Will a Space Gun Always Hit Something? (w/ THE EXPANSE)
26:13
We Solved Nuclear Waste Decades Ago
18:14
Просмотров 4,3 млн
Can ANTI-TELEPHONES Call the Past?
13:46
Просмотров 378 тыс.
The Infinite Money Paradox
10:32
Просмотров 3,1 млн
Cursed Units 2: Curseder Units
20:18
Просмотров 437 тыс.
This Lab Makes LAVA Without a Volcano
27:37
Просмотров 537 тыс.
What are IMPOSSIBLE COLORS?
14:15
Просмотров 1,5 млн
Dead Internet Theory: A.I. Killed the Internet
16:14
Просмотров 1,2 млн