Charlotte is one of my favorite NPCs in RDR2, even if her role is rather small. It's nice to visit her one last time with John and see that's she is doing well.
Why kill him? We know for a fact he never does anything. And he clearly doesn’t have the intention to harm her, or even you after you “disrespect” him. He just asks you to leave. This is a person with good intentions, but was likely raised poorly, and doesn’t understand he’s being so creepy. This is like the opposite of messing with the feminist lady.
He’s creepy but he is FAR from the worst NPC. Like not even close. I would say it’s between the guy and his wife who _literally_ grapes Arthur and the horrible cultist person in the mask who beckons you over then stabs you, but I haven’t seen every NPC in the game so idek if it is
I never met her as Arthur, i did two missions as John then i waited days for reappear but never did. May be this guy killed her. I went to this place to see if i encounter him but hes not there too.
Oh yeah, this dude. Yup I would replay this part over and over again to see how I could keep from losing honor. When I saw that wasn’t possible, I would play it over and over to come up with creative ways to off the guy.
@@someperson8649 oh wow, I’ll have to try that. Still, I don’t mind losing a few honor points to get the satisfaction of blowing him to smithereens with a volatile dynamite arrow.
I never understood the placement of this guy. He’s MILES away from the girls cabin, in terms of the game’s logic, like literally states away. Nowhere near Charlotte.
First playthrough i didn't really listen to him and let him live. I ran into in chapter 2 of my most recent playthrough and was met with immediate hostility and none of the speech. He was then hogtied and thrown into the fire
That guy did nothing wrong. He only described a woman he liked (Charlotte) and that when she politely rejected him, he understood it and didn't impose. Despite still harboring feelings about her, he had apparently respected her rejection. What a creep, right!!?
@@AI-3279 That's not stalking. He approached her and talked to her and she turned him down. He respected her wish and was about to leave. But before he left, he took one last look at her from a distance. Then he moved to another state. "Stalking" means to repeatedly spy or follow someone. This is as much stalking as one insult is harassment.
he literally has his tent covered with pics of drugged or dead naked women but he did nothing wrong?? Jesus y’all are clueless just as bad as the cops who arrested Jeff dahmer and didn’t believe he was eating people🤦🏾♂️😂
I don’t have a problem with it. Sure, creepy. But he never ends up doing anything, or attempting anything, and honestly… homie doesn’t seem to understand he’s being creepy, so I genuinely don’t think he’s being malicious. Not like most average Americans were taught manners, and not to stalk people in 1907.
Oh boy. You said a lot of things that were disturbing. I think you might want to consider if your current living situation is appropriate. I'm not joking, I'm not trying to make fun of you, but sometimes people are being abused, and they don't even know it. It's not ok for someone to violate your personal space. It doesn't matter if it's your uncle, your aunt, your father, a teacher, or whoever. And it doesn't matter if it seems mundane. They don't have to be physically touching you to be abusing you. It's not normal. It's not ok. And if this is happening to you, I really do hope that you find someone you trust that, so that you can talk to them about it. Again, not trying to make fun of you, but what you said is NOT normal.
I don't remember seeing any KKK guys that weren't hostiles, so it's not really a question for them. The eugenics guy though, yeah f that guy. Interestingly, literally no one cares if you off him, though you can get in trouble with the police if you hit the wall too much while destroying him due to vandalism.
I never played RDR and I don't get it. He told a stroy about a girl he find attractive. I suppose this girl is not like girl-girl, coz she is widow. He told the story in a kinda creepy way ngl, but he dosen't do anything to her, stay in his camp and everything seems to be ok. Is this camp near her house? Did he lie about leaving without touching her? Maybe he would assault her later in the game? Without context it looks like you just shoot someone for being weird, and it makes you much-much-much weirder 🤣
I don't know but it sound like he might have hurt her? He watched her cry from the bushes. What did he do to make her cry. I can understand why you don't like him...
What about the two murphys that killed the city folk with trinkets???? Or skinners??? U let them live..but kill an innocent man with a crush???? Says alot bro
He is a creep. He was already rejected by the women he stalked since she told the man to leave meaning the woman was uncomfortable with his presence. Meaning the man is creeping her out. But if you decide to help the stalked woman as arthur does she tell you to leave? No. its because she is comfortarble with arthur since arthur isnt even acting creepy. The man doesnt even have a crush its more of a pervertion. get it right
@@Alex-dr2lp @drystanauthors No, if this man is telling the truth he is not a stalker at all. He saw a woman he liked, he understood that he was politely rejected and even though he still clearly likes her, he's respected her by keeping his distance ever since. He didn't even put his tent in the same state as her house. You don't qualify as a stalker or a creep simply because a woman you approach doesn't like you. If you kill this guy based on what he says here, you failed a moral test and the game justifiably takes your honor.
