Our Universe Shouldn't Exist | The Matter-Antimatter Problem 

The power of friendship? Really? 😉

tarna12 - Friendship, Effort & Victory!

Lol

😂😂

Universes form and collapse all the time with various random imbalances of matter/antimatter. Only the universes with extreme ratio imbalances are coherent for long enough for SciShow to wonder why.

Is that from exurb1a?

Mr Joe no its from hitchhickers guide to the galaxy

The Universe wasn't created. It was always there. It embraces all time, all space and all things that have existed, exist now and will exist in the future. It has no before and no outside. Nothing existed before it that could have been its cause. Nothing exists outside it that could be the source or goal of its purpose or the reference point for its meaning. It cannot conceivably have any cause or purpose. The All is its own cause, purpose and designer. "How, therefore, shall we satisfy ourselves concerning the cause of that Being whom you suppose the Author of Nature, or, according to your system of Anthropomorphism, the ideal world, into which you trace the material? Have we not the same reason to trace that ideal world into another ideal world, or new intelligent principle? But if we stop, and go no further; why go so far? why not stop at the material world? How can we satisfy ourselves without going on in infinitum? And, after all, what satisfaction is there in that infinite progression? Let us remember the story of the Indian philosopher and his elephant. It was never more applicable than to the present subject. If the material world rests upon a similar ideal world, this ideal world must rest upon some other; and so on, without end. It were better, therefore, never to look beyond the present material world. By supposing it to contain the principle of its order within itself, we really assert it to be God; and the sooner we arrive at that Divine Being, so much the better. When you go one step beyond the mundane system, you only excite an inquisitive humour which it is impossible ever to satisfy." - David Hume, Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, part 4

@@stefantherainbowphoenix Bigest pile of rubbish i ever heard.

Which angered his father who punished him severely

That a feature or side effect 😂

@@seetheanimal5867 6c676z6s6z6fy66s6j66j6dg6k6s6cyyy6yyykyk6zy6g66f666g6y6y666k66yy6y6e6c666y66666r7666k666f636d66y66666f6f666e666k6666yy

So it's not just me, sweet!

Stay tuned for the Hank Green GPS voice pack

same

To be honest, nobody is surprised that the universe isn't abiding, it is but a matter of course, if did know all, we would need scientists no more, the whole existence of scientists is because even if we know very well a lot of things, there are a bunch of other things that we still do not understand. And we research it for tech, for example researching in to this may lead us to know how to create matter from photons without the antiparticle annihilating the particle

Neither of those things are happening for anyone with an understanding of what science is. In this very video he references the fact that this is just our best understanding at this time. And no one that knows how understanding evolves is surprised by new information.

Exactly

fun, isn't it? enjoy the ride! 😁

There are few things that we understood and a bunch that we don’t know yet. I don’t understand where the problem is, should we give up and pretend that we don’t know anything ? There is also a bunch of people that are convinced that a guy created it and they stick with this nonsense forever

rocket : "why do you want to save the galaxy?" peter: "because i'm one of the idiots who lives in it!"

Lareland Cooper You mean when he was like, “So get your ‘stuff’...”

Or where your stuff keeps you...

shut up and f u, "original" yt comment "funny guy" WELL YOUR NOT FUNNY YOU ARE DEPRESSING

@@filmtape5247 HAHAHA LOL THATS SO FUNNY JOKE LOL #FUNNYGUY

*wasn't

*point at the door* 😤😤😤

Dark Matter: "Well, hello there."

It antimatters!

Mattern't

The universe: u know because existing is cool

Why not?

@@bemusedbandersnatch2069 why yes

Because it is wrong

All we know is what we do know isnt right...

More like incomplete

@Hydrochloric Acid ... we already took a wrong turn. A little ways back. Feeling a bit lost now more like.

kiraPh1234k it has to do the weak force

@@Io-vz2jq I believe anti matter and anti energy are a very smaller percent of matter. If it were any larger, it would cancel out the matter. Are you talking about dark matter?

In other words its true the more we learn the less we know

@@Io-vz2jq That isn't what you learned so I don't think it was the scientists fault you just should've paid more attention, you learned about Dark Matter since that is the force we believe makes up 85% of the Universe due to its gravitational force on objects. Anti-matter and Dark Matter are completely different they just happen to share a similar name.

Popping into existence??? So you and the professor believe nothing can make something??? So you guys believe in magic??? Cool!!!

@@freeyourmind7538 huh

@@snal8073 eh?

And(perhaps) a third antimatter might join in as well.

Woa...... but mama. . . so.. then where does the baby come from? THE EXPLOSION?!

@SigmaTauri2 lolz, for realz?! well I'll be a son of a gun.

That's hot.

When a matter particle and an antimatter particle love each other very much, they turn into a gamma ray

X2

Everybody here was a consequence of some bad decisions

@JustinTheDragonKing On the contrary...

Me too

Nekrumorfiini1 your corpse will still be there until it’s decayed, but tiny particles of yourself will still exist in bacteria

You pass the butter.

Mind over matter- if you dont mind, it doesn't matter.

"Mind over. Nothing matters." --Wayne Fossick, Ph.D.

No one is ment to exist. We all die. Nothing matters.

@@garylee8132 “Nobody exists on purpose. Nobody belongs anywhere. Everybody's gonna die. Come watch TV” ― Morty yes?

Anti-they anti-are anti-watching anti-a anti-video anti-about anti-how anti-the anti-universe anti-doesn't anti-have anti-ennough anti-matter.

Well in that universe the antimatter would be the norm so they would just label it as matter

@Lobsta12874 That's just me every time I get home from vacation.

@Lobsta12874, you must be thinking of my doppelganger. I try to avoid him.

@@TheTacRat it's actually called rettam there

You kinda need a big brian to understand this

Good thing you can watch it as many times as you want. 😁😋

@@God_Yeeter I would disagree. The Scishow crew has a very Feynmany way of explaining things.

@Chr1stown but it all makes sense

Because if we succeed the glory will be endless and the profit unmeasurable.

You are all figments of my imagination.

@@tomf3150 "I am insane...and you are my insanity!"

and I say, "Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn"

We are in a Matrix.... ╮(. ❛ ᴗ ❛.)╭

You’re in a coma Kundu. Wake up.

Yes, abundantly pleasant

Now that's a process I'm down to experience. My atoms being straight violated particle by particle at the subatomic level. Oh yes, just pure extacy.

Without this annihilation we wouldn't exist, so...woopee.

Fantastic movie.

@Retrogamer 420 Probably lika an onomatopoeia

There shouldn't be a distinction between the two, are you thinking of a white hole...

@@brunoagostini1355 there is a Distinction because an Antimatter blackhole would have an Opposite charge of a Black hole... They come from a sourse of matter, A dying star which means its Mass and since Gravity exists in this Matter Form Antimatter should exist in the opposite Force... the same with White Holes... so it's a legit question

I'm not sure how the black hole thing would work as it is literally not matter but just a hole in spacetime

He specifically said gaps of anti matter can't be possible otherwise we would consistently see the production of gamma rays st the boundary between theee two spaces at the edge of the universe.

@@ericthegreat7805 …that’s why he said his theoretical antimatter galaxies would be surrounded by “vast intergalactic voids” so as not to come in contact with any matter!

First he has to figure out what the order is supposed to be.

Christel Headington: It's our lord and savior, Muscle Hank. The order is whatever he SAYS it is!

That meme was really obnoxious when it was as most alive, but now, i admit, it has some charm.

A Jolly Nurgle Prick: Muscle Hank transcends meme life and meme death. He is, was, and ever shall be.

Damn. What ever happened to Muscle Hank's RU-vid account? He was always scouting the comments section

That's the code for infinite life. You win!

@@ChapSinclair you mean used time wisely..... What a great game

Its up-up-down-down. Konami code.

Your 30 lives are up.

It's up up down down left right left right B A start

Damn i thought i was weird because i clicked so fast. *behold, i am not alone*

It shouldn’t, the universe is a simulation that is being run by a much more intelligent life form. It explains why everything, everywhere is run by the exact same physics engine, almost like a game, no matter where, the universe runs on numbers

Agree

@@CasusCantare You know that it doen't really explain ANYTHING? In fact, all it does is pushing the history of the universe to a much more distant past. More than that, there's no reason for the universe to have different laws of physics at different locations. In fact, spaces with different laws of physics can be considered their own independent universes, because those parts won't be able to interact with each other in any way (or almost any way). So, no, it does not support simulation hypothesis at all. It is, if I am not mistaken, a "Causal Fallacy". You commited it when you thought: "Computer games have identical physics everywhere. Our universe has identical physics everywhere. Therefore our universe is a, most likely, computer simulation".

@@CasusCantare what if it tuns out that the answer to the fermi paradox is that our simulation just so happens to be the one that is meant to answer the question "what happens to a civilization that evolves in complete isolation" :'(

Obviously the answer to the Grand Unified Theory lies in the dank depths of tomato sauce. That's why no one's ever found it!

That's a spicy tomato.

No speghetti?!!!! The nerve of our universe I vote we restart the universe this time add oregano and speghetti.

Flying Spaghetti Monster confirmed!?!!

So we eating universes in our spaghett

I'm glad I'm not the only one! Lol

*ba dum tss*

It holds quarks together

People are so picky in the comments. Maybe one of us should apply for Hank’s job? Nah, none of us are as quirky as the Hank/Muscle Hank pair, and if we annihilated THAT pair, it would be the end of SciShow as.we know it. AARGHH!

@@kj2354 But also protons and neutrons.

Luis Aldamiz what are protons and neutrons comprised of?

@@kj2354 protons and neutrons are comprised of quarks which holds together by gluons which is the mediatory of strong interaction. So neither we wrong.

it has the exact opposite effect on me

Anti hank made the anti video.

I would like to see that collab

@@arska2928 I'd not like to be anywhere near when they shook hands.

We'd realise too late because they'd be calling antimatter matter.

@@GoPieman Not if it was announced a week beforehand.

mood.

I mean, just don't watch this kinda stuff, if you can't handle it... 🤦‍♂️ Also, this isn't even the "bad" parts... 🤣

Eventually the universe and all things will cease to exist.

Y’ALL ARE NOT HELPING

The universe is what it is. When our understanding/theory disagrees, it simply our understanding/theory that's flawed. That's how our understanding grows.

Gamer Science exactly

"Our understanding" is different than "our theory".

That's what I was thinking, the title is wrong but probably because it attracts more average viewers.

@@winddoggo9406 basically title should be, "This video shouldn't exist, unless our theory of clickbait is correct".

@@TheGunmanChannel lol

THE TIME HAS COME

A career highlight

its not strange

Is there a “Power Bottom” quark?

I guess we lost you somewhere in the science.

Stranger than an Ω-

I just happened across this video and your comment which is similar to the one I just added. The idea that matter and antimatter went their separate ways in the early universe would not make it impossible for antimatter to be manufactured in limited and short term instances. The same would be true for the antimatter realm. I picked the time dimension as the differentiation factor. One nice thing about that is that when annihilation occurs, the energy could be just the release of both particles potential time energy being released as they both return to zero time. That is, turned to energetic photons which reside outside of the time dimension since they move at c.

Universe: Was Created Scientists: surprised pikachu face

@ yeah... sure

I thought the pikachu meme was dead

@@radias2589 /surprised pikachu face

Shazam Music gotta catch em all!!!

Alternatively you could call everything else fake news and try to be the loudest person in the room.

@@RadexyTV *cough* trump *cough*

Well in maths and sciences, you can have models that aren't totally accurate, but are accurate enough for certain circumstances. For instance: Newtonian Physics is great at explainging mechanics when you aren't dealing with relative frames of references. You could use a more accurate model that is much more complex, but that's just impractical.

Science is about getting less and less wrong. And that's ok.

Exactly maybe our understanding of the universe is wrong.

Its vsauce

maybe thats why we havent got to the unified theory yet, it is actually a type of barbecue sauce, maybe even some other tipe of sauce, and not a soup

@@ceiling_cat Underrated comment! XD

So is the universe more like lobster bisque or Italian wedding? This could change everything...

It's np, we should just hide in a box.

Beth yeah

Terriera💕

notagoon695

why is there boss music

daaaamn

Wait, how would it cause the big bang?

@@alexanderb7721 stuff exploding into existence would be my hypothesis.

@@alexanderb7721 cause it threw off the balance of matter/anti so all the matter we observe wasn't annihilated.

Nadav Gur Arieh - Darn Resources Extractors!

I'll never not upvote a bill Wurtz quote

Beelz for fuckin reals. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

I liked that little dig at the flerfs!

Give me one scientific fact that *doesn't* piss them off.

@@mikitz ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-_Qfy1wiTy6U.html Oh wait doesn-

@@mikitz The rrridiculous amount of energy we get from splitting atomic nuclei, perhaps?

Yep, all their members, of which they have many all around the globe, last seeing exploding.

George The OG Washington we have to cause we do. we shouldnt exist according to our work

Strothy2 it’s not as strange as this though so not as interesting

@@brogant6793 You're not speaking for everyone.

Alexis Rodriguez just justifying this one coming first :)

My ex was a strange matter

“Why errbody gotta stay in they comfort zone and avoid challenges?” - Benjamin Franklin

WestRaptor Pro Me too.

spoiler alert: you won't...

I'm afraid we may not live that long, most people living today think that being featured on the Kardashians is a life time achievement, only a handful tries to answer these questions.

42

@Lil Poco bold of you to assume we’ll die from old age

May the sauce be with you.

There are theories in science that we live in a simulation, one big complex computer program. Or the cosmic consciousness theory where the universe is emergent from mind.

Dean Hunt and may the cheese reign freely

If you take some acid you’ll see the Flying Spaghetti Monster lmao

Silly you we like acid not that weedy crap.

Fact is stranger than fiction.

Are you from iit or local engineering collage

@@mahakshshetty No, I'm a graduate student at University of Colorado Boulder

How else would we come up with these ideas?

Dude

Lots to do and discover but not that many jobs unfortunately

Agreed! Do plasma cosmology next!

Almost as if constant falsification of hypotheses is the scientific method but you thought that was a gotcha, didn't you? I bet you're a creationist.

"Its just a prank bro" -logan paul-

From the anti-Harward University?

Define a "non-physical" phenomenon.

@@w3irdo13 everything usually relegated to "spirit", "mysticism", and "quackery" by the scientific community.

@@400nm2 Well, in that case, how can that be studied reliably?

@@w3irdo13 thing's can only be measured "reliably", not fully studied. I believe that was the point. Creativity, not sticking to safe pre-existing assumptions.

@@400nm2 Science doesn't stick to assumptions, it sticks to evidence.

I'd think a more likely explanation would be that _some_ of the matter and antimatter in our universe was lost somehow, causing that 1 in a billion difference.

Yes

Lol @ rounding error.

@@yeetman6655 Mr stark...

Probably correct

Lol

Well 1944 happened

Inflation. Else it does not seem to work. Search for Alan Guth...

@@LuisAldamiz Maybe , no inflation and no singularity, but something else

@@razvanm2217 - Penrose's model? I find it attractive too but maybe something else altogether. In any case inflation is the mainline model and a reasonable, even if ultimately uncertain, answer to the original question.

Life in the mirror universe has a greater tendency to grow goatees