Тёмный

Palestinians: Are you willing to share the land with the Jews? 

Corey Gil-Shuster
Подписаться 337 тыс.
Просмотров 820 тыс.
50% 1

HOW TO HELP
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
To donate to the project:
www.paypal.me/...
/ askproject
WHAT IS THE ASK PROJECT?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Do you want to know what Israelis and Palestinians really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers. All answers are from random people and all answers are included and unedited. The questions come from you, the viewers.
WHY DO I DO THIS?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
See the following videos where I explain the background and goal of the project • The Ask Project interv...

Опубликовано:

 

4 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 17 тыс.   
@apostate101
@apostate101 10 месяцев назад
As an Arab Israeli, it makes me sad seeing this! I never faced any discrimination for being an Arab, I finished my Bachelor’s degree along side fellow Jewish students, we work in the same companies, we have mixed cities and neighborhoods, and we as Arabs are not obligated to serve in the army, and yet we get the same rights as Jews! For all of those who claim Israel to be an apartheid state are full of shit! We Arab and Jews should live together and we can make this country even better!
@jimibhoy8935
@jimibhoy8935 10 месяцев назад
I found your post to be very interesting, honest and unbiased. But most importantly it is very informative. Those who claim apartied are uneducated idiots, or just downright liars.
@Falcon_Kashmir
@Falcon_Kashmir 10 месяцев назад
I think your brain is too small to see the big picture...
@CashCowz962
@CashCowz962 10 месяцев назад
Is there a difference between an Arab Israeli and and Israeli Arab?
@apostate101
@apostate101 10 месяцев назад
@@CashCowz962 nope, just a matter of how you write it, at least in my opinion, we use interchangeably
@apostate101
@apostate101 10 месяцев назад
@@jimibhoy8935 Thank you, it’s hard to watch what’s happening from the side and stay apathetic!
@CristinaPerez-ib2uu
@CristinaPerez-ib2uu 10 месяцев назад
The last woman said it: we don't question our beliefs. They think what they're told to think, and so the hatred never ends.
@hakimayari641
@hakimayari641 10 месяцев назад
Shut up marranes
@opinion3742
@opinion3742 9 месяцев назад
You would hate your oppressors too if you had any. Privilege is no excuse for ignorance.
@CristinaPerez-ib2uu
@CristinaPerez-ib2uu 9 месяцев назад
@@opinion3742 then they must hate Hamas, right? Or are they too scared to voice their opinions on those oppressors?
@davidhowell1415
@davidhowell1415 9 месяцев назад
@@opinion3742what’s your excuse for your ignorance?
@Ten_Mil_Will
@Ten_Mil_Will 9 месяцев назад
​@CristinaPerez-ib2uu I wondered two things: (1) are Palestinians so scared of hamas they dare not say anything that could be considered pro Israel while on camera? (2) Was there an edit? Were their a bunch of videos of Palestinians, that didn't make the final cut, saying "uh, YES OF COURSE, the place is big enough. Israel can have half, we just don't want less than half"? If the answers are "no" and "no", well then.... they earned what's coming next smh
@BenAllen-xb3ev
@BenAllen-xb3ev 9 месяцев назад
They won't share land but its OK for thousands of them to come and live in the UK, share our land and even have the gall to protest in our capital. Could you imagine what would happen if the English had the same mindset as these people?
@sntopietro
@sntopietro 9 месяцев назад
The British created Israel in the first place. Seems fair to me. Also, the English - invaded countries, murdered and enslaved people for centuries. So many problems start from the UK. The UK deserves every refugee they get.
@lorrainec8190
@lorrainec8190 9 месяцев назад
Palestinians really own nothing. They are world's squatters.
@JAmesBurke-sh7ju
@JAmesBurke-sh7ju 9 месяцев назад
We need to stand up for our country. not be silenced with “youre racist” no this is our land just like israel has been jewish land for 3000 years IF ANYTHING THEY TOOK IT FROM ISRAEL. Its gonna happen to us if we dont stop it
@amayad888
@amayad888 9 месяцев назад
yea the english are worse they come and colonize everything they think is unotuched by them buddy
@yessum15
@yessum15 9 месяцев назад
They are coming as peaceful guests who were invited and generally agree to abide by the rules of the host country. This is very different from ISRL which is essentially a European colony established by invaders. Apples & oranges.
@aymanbillah9827
@aymanbillah9827 8 месяцев назад
Wow now i see why the conflict is never ending
@robbie73vespa
@robbie73vespa 7 месяцев назад
🇵🇸 are brainwashed there's no hope for these foolish people 😢
@Isabella_kh
@Isabella_kh 7 месяцев назад
The Palestinian people did not have a problem with Israelis coming from abroad until they took over control of land and the government and kicked close to a million out of their homes making them refugees (the Nakba in 1948-the big catastrophe). Illegal settlements are documented by all Human rights organizations-Jews can walk into any Palestinian home and move in. How would you feel if I came to your home right and kicked you out because it’s my birth right?
@Vilgodeo
@Vilgodeo 7 месяцев назад
@@Isabella_kh Wait, when the Palestinians didn't have a problem where did the Israelis live? Also, name one settlement built on Palestinian land.
@ghadaamgad403
@ghadaamgad403 7 месяцев назад
I don't think you'll ever understand the problem as long as you call it a "conflict"
@alexborodulin8052
@alexborodulin8052 7 месяцев назад
@@Isabella_kh Just there were no Palestinians in 48 they were invented in 1960 by Arafat
@martinsolomon5500
@martinsolomon5500 10 месяцев назад
So “it’s OUR land we don’t want people from other countries” Doesn’t England, Australia, USA, France, Belgium, Sweden, Canada etc have millions of Muslims from other countries living there. Can those western countries say “It’s OUR land, all foreigners need to leave!!”
@kankerbende
@kankerbende 10 месяцев назад
Please, can you put The Netherlands on the list to ??!! Thank you !
@jakejennings5152
@jakejennings5152 10 месяцев назад
I would love to see all the Muslims leave America too; this is the reason why… when Muslims are the minority Islam is the religion of peace… when Muslims are the majority… they want to kill anyone else who isn’t a Muslim or deny their human rights altogether.
@hakimayari641
@hakimayari641 10 месяцев назад
Moi si je viens chez vous et que j enleve pas mes sales godasses et que je te dis j't'emmerde a mon avis ça va pas bien se passer. ...Moi quand je viens chez les gens j enleve mes godasse je demande un visa au consulat je m'assois je bois mon café et je dis bonjour madame et j espère que j aurais la nationalité gentiment et surtout mon cher martin je FERME MA GUEULE
@Mylostsock11
@Mylostsock11 10 месяцев назад
Exactly! It's OK for them to take over half the world tho!?
@craigwynia5280
@craigwynia5280 10 месяцев назад
Yes get out ! if you dont want to live by our laws or adopt our values .🍁
@TonyCheckano
@TonyCheckano 10 месяцев назад
I'm not Jew, but I'm living in Israel for years. And all this time I haven't faced any discrimination for nationality, language or anything else. It's good modern country. And people here are really awesome! People behave like friends if you behave the same.
@benjijarman
@benjijarman 10 месяцев назад
If you were an Arab resident of Gaza or the West Bank your experience would be vastly different.
@shredgardener9231
@shredgardener9231 10 месяцев назад
and no one is screaming jihad all the time.
@lesgaunt
@lesgaunt 10 месяцев назад
but there are 2 million arabs living in Israel that would disagree with you so you obviously have no idea what you're talking about. @@benjijarman
@benjijarman
@benjijarman 10 месяцев назад
@@lesgaunt And you are the spokesman for those 2 million Arabs are you? Good onya champ.
@rosalindpaaswell9513
@rosalindpaaswell9513 10 месяцев назад
@@benjijarman Yes, of course it would be different, because the occupation is illegal and the residents live in relative deprivation. BUT their leadership has been corrupt and deficient and has fostered the fairy tale that Israel is on "their land". The occupation must end and there will be two states. Israel will endure and go from strength to strength once its extremists are kept in their place. And there will be a Palestinian state.
@petespirals
@petespirals 9 месяцев назад
As a maori from New Zealand I want to say that I am proud that our people choose to have a peaceful life and chose to co-exist with our white cousins. its not always easy, some of them are arrogant, entitled and even racist, but I think we are loved and respected by many. Blessings to both sides and I pray you find peace and forgiveness. ❤
@divinefemininee
@divinefemininee 9 месяцев назад
Aamiin.
@pigslefats
@pigslefats 9 месяцев назад
And no Maoris are arrogant, entitled or racist. You forgot to mention that
@donzioldbuddy
@donzioldbuddy 9 месяцев назад
Ki Ora brother
@francescacook6623
@francescacook6623 9 месяцев назад
Kia ora cuz, from a white New Zealander 👍
@caspar_gomez
@caspar_gomez 9 месяцев назад
I never fail to be disappointed in the passivity of native people like you or native americans. I thought you were warriors. Maybe once were
@Oak_II
@Oak_II 8 месяцев назад
They prefer fighting worthless wars for their own ego and honor than just live together in peace...
@JH-zh7hq
@JH-zh7hq 7 месяцев назад
you must be very underdeveloped intellectually if you blame these interviewees for the conflict that was clearly brought to them by the Zionists and their Western cronies
@SL92018
@SL92018 7 месяцев назад
The Israelis don't want to give them peace, they want all their land because of their superstition that it's their on the basis of belonging to a religion, which is absurd. This is the West Bank, how on earth do you think the people in the West Bank who have been born and raised in Israeli occupation and oppression want to live with the Israelis controlling their lives? They live in conditions in many ways worse that apartheid South Africa was for black South Africans.
@yaakovstern6053
@yaakovstern6053 7 месяцев назад
or they just don't like jews and try to justify that hatred
@RoadMan-go1tg
@RoadMan-go1tg 6 месяцев назад
Ego and honor? They're literally living as 3rd class citizens at best in their own country. That's exactly like saying "the Jews only fought the Nazis because of their own ego and honor." Did you expect the Jews to just forgive the Nazis after the holocaust or did they have the right to take them to trial and execute them if found guilty like they did?
@ahlemlouihek-vi8by
@ahlemlouihek-vi8by 6 месяцев назад
That’s what a Zionist would say😂😂😂
@jozzieification
@jozzieification 9 месяцев назад
You just explained me why this war has been going on for 70 years
@birdgirl1516
@birdgirl1516 9 месяцев назад
A major brainwashing campaign has been put upon the whole society of Palestine … when I was a child I remember seeing American news showing Yasar Arafat declining the offer to make a two-state solution. I’m sadly unsympathetic to Palestinians because of their stubbornness and inability to compromise after all these years…..
@caty9995
@caty9995 9 месяцев назад
Absolutely!
@colinig4411
@colinig4411 9 месяцев назад
Most of them doesn´t want to share anything with anybody. But it's cool for them when, countries around Europe opens borders for Palestinians give them a new and safe life. So, I don't feel sorry for them.
@laurasofiafreitas
@laurasofiafreitas 9 месяцев назад
Yes. It has nothing to do with palestinians being expelled from their houses in order to create a white supremacist state using judaism as an excuse. Study what Portuga did in Angola, Mozambique, Guine-Bissau. Study what France did in Algeria, and tell me how the ocuppiers were going to live there peacefully. It's time to own our history and respect others how we wish to be respected!
@laurasofiafreitas
@laurasofiafreitas 9 месяцев назад
​@@colinig4411stop the occupation and they won't have to flee to europe. It's that simple.
@papi4253
@papi4253 2 года назад
We cannot share the land with other people of course not, but we can live in every other country of the world and they must share it with us, because we are very special.
@dogbert52
@dogbert52 2 года назад
Spot on ! Ar ab Isl amic colonization in a nutshell.
@LibertyorLiberty
@LibertyorLiberty 2 года назад
Would you share your land by force?
@papi4253
@papi4253 2 года назад
@@LibertyorLiberty That's not what was asked, and they couldn't deal with the fact that other people live on the same planet. They weren't asked to share their land, just to share the country. The COUNTRY is not their land, but the Arab has a mental problem of psychological projection. Palestine is a fantasy
@ajvorob9117
@ajvorob9117 2 года назад
Arab culture is very narcissistic. Everything has to be done to please them. But they themselves can be xenophobic bigots while condemning other countries for being bigots.
@Dinaciety
@Dinaciety 2 года назад
@@LibertyorLiberty if they won the war - yes. These people cant accept that they lost.
@crosisofborg5524
@crosisofborg5524 9 месяцев назад
I’m glad these videos are showing the real Palestinian people, not the warm and fuzzy illusion the media brings us.
@Notsam12345
@Notsam12345 9 месяцев назад
They shouldn’t be warm and fuzzy. They’re being wiped out. In their own country. They keep saying it but you don’t seem to believe them, it is their land
@leoray1234
@leoray1234 9 месяцев назад
If someone moved into your house and told you how to live your life now that you’re sharing your house, would you be ok with it? I understand their feelings
@matty4417
@matty4417 9 месяцев назад
Anybody could make a video like this. Do you think he included the people who would be willing to share?
@DiyBandits000
@DiyBandits000 9 месяцев назад
your dumb ass and dont know the history
@donc2446
@donc2446 9 месяцев назад
I would like to see a similar video with native Hawaiians.
@brokenpremise
@brokenpremise 9 месяцев назад
Wow, very revealing. Thankyou for showing this
@parkerw.2155
@parkerw.2155 10 месяцев назад
I have been consuming all forms of information trying to understand the situation. I think however after watching this I have come to some sort of a conclusion. They don’t want peace they will never accept any form of reconciliation. Unfortunately this only leaves room for war and perpetual death and sorrow.
@alefandrita
@alefandrita 10 месяцев назад
I think many of them thought that they would have to share their land in the West Bank for peace and that's all. Maybe if the question was: what if the whole territory of current Israel + Gaza + The West Bank was shared for peace? The answers would be very different. Anyways, in general, I think Arabs don't trust Israelis. Look what happened to the areas that are under Israeli control: Gaza has a blockade since 2007 and the West Bank has hundreds of thousands of Israeli settlers that came illegally, get almost all the water and have lots of privileges...as an Apartheid state. How can you negotiate with such kind of people? Nevertheless, I truly believe peace is possible for Israelis and Palestinians.
@EmperorsNewWardrobe
@EmperorsNewWardrobe 10 месяцев назад
If you could look into the future as far as needed to see a change in this perpetual situation - whether that’s 100 years or 1000 years - how do you think it might have changed?
@gianthills
@gianthills 10 месяцев назад
would you accept foreigners coming across your border and kicking you off your land?
@msforce9
@msforce9 10 месяцев назад
Proper education
@patriciareid1159
@patriciareid1159 10 месяцев назад
@@EmperorsNewWardrobe No need to go far back that era, Palestinian clearly abuse international treaty of peace. British had the right gave the empty desert area, in regard of humanity disaster they concerned to the displaced people. On the other hand, British-Europe West America, Australia widely open the door for Palestinian refugees. Palestinian clearly don't want to leave peacefully with Jews, send them back all who live in West countries America and Australia.
@Frodojack
@Frodojack 10 месяцев назад
I think if you asked them, "Let's say the Palestinians were in control of the land, but it was run by Palestinian Christians. Would that be acceptable to you?" the answer would be the same. The land must not only be under Palestinian control, but Muslim control. Once a land is under Muslim control, it must remain under Muslim control forever. This is why they not only want Israel retaken, but Spain and Greece.
@Sp3ll633
@Sp3ll633 10 месяцев назад
Exactly. The Muslims see this piece of land as Muslim conquered
@oliver5976
@oliver5976 10 месяцев назад
Ain’t gonna happen.
@iamhudsdent2759
@iamhudsdent2759 10 месяцев назад
@@oliver5976 That "it ain't gonna happen" wasn't the point. The point is it's a fanatical religious belief that prevents any peace agreement
@sbgtrading
@sbgtrading 10 месяцев назад
Their false god "Allah" has commanded them to repossess everything they've been dispossessed of. So they are not submitting to God if they permit the Jews (or any non-muslim) to own any land. All land is "Allah's", therefore all non-muslims must be destroyed. This is what we're dealing with.
@mikehawk4477
@mikehawk4477 10 месяцев назад
What a foolish question, majority of Palestinians are Muslims so why would it be under Palestinian Christian or Jewish control??
@oskytel3780
@oskytel3780 9 месяцев назад
None of them asked what "share the land" even meant. They completely reject the idea of living together in peace without details of political and social structure.
@janetisaacmorrison
@janetisaacmorrison 8 месяцев назад
Sharia law, according to the Quran, states that any non Muslim person on their holy land should incite a jihad holy war. They perceive the land that Israel sits on as Muslim holy land. Therefore you get terrorist ground like Islamic Jihad, and Hamas in the Gaza strip, plus Hezbollah in Lebanon. And Fatah and PLO in the Westbank.
@khawla7137
@khawla7137 8 месяцев назад
There were peace between the Arabs and the jews before zionism came to the stage the jews were the one who destroyed the peace between them and the Arabs in that piece of land and they could have created a wonderful state together after the brithish mandate of Palestine
@RedDawn-xv3yp
@RedDawn-xv3yp 8 месяцев назад
Israel You serve hate you gate it back 😊
@Isabella_kh
@Isabella_kh 7 месяцев назад
The Palestinian people did not have a problem with Israelis coming from abroad until they took over control of land and the government and kicked close to a million out of their homes making them refugees (the Nakba in 1948-the big catastrophe). Illegal settlements are documented by all Human rights organizations-Jews can walk into any Palestinian home and move in. How would you feel if I came to your home right and kicked you out because it’s my birth right?
@JH-zh7hq
@JH-zh7hq 7 месяцев назад
maybe they had a bad experience?
@GenikaXVI
@GenikaXVI 7 месяцев назад
now you see why Israel can't just stop
@davidl.abplanalp4478
@davidl.abplanalp4478 9 месяцев назад
When you have people that think history started in 622 AD there is no way to get them to understand any history but, their own idea of history.
@Viperfitness
@Viperfitness 9 месяцев назад
Good point.
@judithflom6366
@judithflom6366 9 месяцев назад
They retroactively co-opted the Torah and the christian bible, oppressed minority populations, and built upon their holy sites. Now they say this is Muslim history and holy sites.
@HarleyQ5678
@HarleyQ5678 9 месяцев назад
Most of them don't know Islamic conquests 😂 stuck in just 75 yrs argument
@getanala6594
@getanala6594 9 месяцев назад
not even 622 AD. It seems like most think history started in 1948
@Sam-qm5dk
@Sam-qm5dk 8 месяцев назад
You do realize that most of these people are largely native to the levant. Them calling themselves ''arab'' is more of a cultural identity in which they all share a similar language. Most of the people are probably the same that has been living there for thousands of years, with time they just adopted different religions and languages.
@veetour
@veetour 11 месяцев назад
This video shows why I have difficulties with sympathizing for the Palestinians. They can't share.
@chula686
@chula686 11 месяцев назад
​@JuLia-bz6kt, you're a bot.
@seekerout
@seekerout 10 месяцев назад
I guess no-one's told them yet that diversity will make them strong.
@dannyesse3043
@dannyesse3043 10 месяцев назад
Where are you from? Imagine the Jews coming to your land, taking it from you, dictating law and kicking you into a small region. How would you feel?
@seekerout
@seekerout 10 месяцев назад
@@dannyesse3043 That's not how it happened though. What you describe is what you say it is - imagination.
@dannyesse3043
@dannyesse3043 10 месяцев назад
@@seekerout what happened then? Are all palestinians insane ?
@xvadim
@xvadim 11 месяцев назад
More people should see this… then they will understand why peace with the Palestinians is impossible…
@tursuntongra6706
@tursuntongra6706 11 месяцев назад
See what? The question is imprecise - "Would you share land equally with the Jews for peace". It could just as well if not more reasonably interpreted as "Israel proper remains as it is, but Israelis and Palestinians share the West Bank". Obviously overwhelming majority of Palestinians would not agree to that. You simply can't go to West Bank, pose a question as "would you share the land, (aka West Bank)?" and expect a different answer.
@ochiegodfrey6428
@ochiegodfrey6428 11 месяцев назад
@@tursuntongra6706 go and sleep 😴😴
@fte6te6f
@fte6te6f 11 месяцев назад
NO SPEACIAL OPERTATIONS FROM ISRAEL HAVE BEEN ATTEMPTED ISRAEL HAS BOMBED ON MUTIPLE OCCASIONS PLACES THEY THEMSELVES DEEMED SAFE ZONES ISRAEL HAS BOMBED HOSPITALS AND SCHOOLS ISRAEL ATTACKED THE SOUTH AFTER STATING IT WILL BE SAFE FOR CIVILLIANS 8000 PLUS CIVILLIANS HAVE DIED THIS IS THE LAND OF PALISTINE. ISRAEL STOLE IT IN 1967 ISRAEL STOLE THIS LAND AND NOW WANT TO CLAIM THEY HAVE A RIGHT TO DEFEND THEIR LAND, Well doesn't Palestine? because that is their land which was invaded and stolen. WHY CUT OFF ALL THE WATER, FOOD, ELECTRICITY, AND GAS. THEY ARE PRISONERS BECAUSE IF WITHOUT THE HELP OF INTERNATIONAL HANDS IN ABOUT 30 DAYS OR SO MOST OF PALESTINE INCLUDING CIVILLIANS BECAUSE OF LACK OF WATER STOP THIS PROPAGANDA PS yes I do condem Hamas but search of RU-vid "Israel helped the creation of hamas" Also search up on youtube "Here’s Why U.S. Elites Support Israel No Matter What" f
@fte6te6f
@fte6te6f 11 месяцев назад
BROTHER THEY STOLE THE LAND AND THEN PROSACUTED THEM
@mastermind6032-wh9tl
@mastermind6032-wh9tl 11 месяцев назад
Then why the USA or Europe or ano country that support isarel share its land ?
@jeremy_5026
@jeremy_5026 7 месяцев назад
Plot twist, the land never belonged to the "Palestinians".
@gnosismonkey
@gnosismonkey Месяц назад
Well, at the founding of Israel there were several hundred thousand Arab people living there under the British protectorate. Those people existed and had lived on that land. The national identity of “Palestinian” may be a somewhat arbitrary label created by a colonial power, but the idea persists no matter what that they would like self determination on their ancestral lands. It’s a fairly common impulse that I’m sure zionists should also empathize with since Zionism is also a political attempt at self determination in their ancestral homeland. Both peoples ultimately want the same thing for themselves, but one side has the military capacity to deny it to the other.
@jeremy_5026
@jeremy_5026 Месяц назад
@gnosismonkey The vast majority of people calling themselves "palestinians" trace their ancestry back to Jordan. They are not indigenous to that region, and are nothing better than glorified squatters. The only Arabs that can truly claim that as their ancestral land are the Bedouin, and the Bedouin are Israeli Arabs. There aren't many "palestinians" that can trace their ancestry in Israel back more than 150 years. And they never owned the land, they moved there to lease and farm. They claimed ownership after the dismantling of the Ottoman empire.
@gnosismonkey
@gnosismonkey Месяц назад
@@jeremy_5026 I can’t trace my lineage in the US back even 150 years. My family comes from Europe before the early 20th century. But I still don’t have citizenship in Serbia or Norway. I was born here in the US. My grandparents were born here. To displace me for someone with an older claim to this land like the Cherokee would still be committing one injustice to correct another. I would effectively be stateless. They certainly could turn around and say that my family has only been here for 120 years. The idea that you need roots deeper than 150 years to feel connected and for your removal to be unjust is an unreasonable standard designed to satisfy a desired goal. I think it would be easy to argue this from the opposite angle, that displacing people with an immediate 150 year heritage there is more of a problematic solution as the injustice is immediate rather than one that is abstracted in millennia old history.
@jeremy_5026
@jeremy_5026 Месяц назад
@@gnosismonkey "Before the early 20th century" would be the late 1800's. That is within 150 years. You made the argument that it was their ancestral land. It is not. Technically speaking the Arabian Peninsula is their ancestral land. More than likely Syria, Jordan or Yemen. The fact of the matter is we live in a world governed by rules. Without those rules we have chaos. The UN declared that parts of the region known as Judea and Samaria would be given back to the Jews so that they may form their own state. Land was given to the Arabs as well, but the Arabs didn't like this decision. They wanted the entire territory, some still do. If the UN or some other organization decided the Cherokee people needed their own land, and your house was on that land you can bet you'd be moving. You can call it an injustice if you like, but it would still be a rule of law.
@gnosismonkey
@gnosismonkey Месяц назад
@@jeremy_5026 Interesting that you go to the validity of international law to justify the ongoing position of a nation repeatedly disregarding international law in how it settles, blockades, and administers Palestinian Territories. It’s a very selective fondness for the UN. And I find it deeply implausible that the UN would or could displace US citizens to give native Americans their land back. Do I think the Arab population should have accepted the first partition agreements? Of course. But we live in the modern world and the people who made those decisions are largely dead. But the crisis still lives on. If the comfort of the initial UN support for Israel on completely different borders than we are talking about today satisfies any feeling you might otherwise have for displaced people suffering, then I don’t know what to tell you.
@dudelebowski_
@dudelebowski_ 9 месяцев назад
When these people talk about "their" country, do they mean the 30 years in which their country was British or the 500 years in which it was Turkish?
@benny210169
@benny210169 9 месяцев назад
Or the hundreds of years before that when it was the land of the Jews.
@MrItchy55
@MrItchy55 9 месяцев назад
For 100s of years before satanic Islam existed, it was the Jewish homeland. 1000s of years before that fake bullshit religion islam.
@codyvandal2860
@codyvandal2860 9 месяцев назад
Constantinople was Greek for more than 1,000 years and look at it now. Will they return the "stolen" land?
@user-md2fm7ik2z
@user-md2fm7ik2z 9 месяцев назад
Quiet jew
@edwardcomiskey6556
@edwardcomiskey6556 9 месяцев назад
@@user-md2fm7ik2z when was the land exclusively palistine land, because I can’t find that information any place
@luff675
@luff675 9 месяцев назад
There are 2 million Arab Israelis living in peace as doctors, lawyers, teachers, doctors… IF they dont see you as equals maybe its because you’ve already judged them. Man this is mind blowing to watch
@ayalaostrovsky9550
@ayalaostrovsky9550 6 месяцев назад
You have to differentiate between arabs in Israel and arabs in the West Bank. They are different. Arabs in Israel are open minded because they live in democracy.
@n00b_n00b_
@n00b_n00b_ 4 месяца назад
​@@ayalaostrovsky9550is there rly a big difference or a minor?
@nomylearnspalestine
@nomylearnspalestine 3 месяца назад
​@@ayalaostrovsky9550Palestinians in "israel" are native to the land unlike jews.
@andrewstaples7544
@andrewstaples7544 3 месяца назад
25 % of then are Christians
@yoavlavi310
@yoavlavi310 Месяц назад
​@@n00b_n00b_ Depends on definition, if you meant ethnicity or culture (food music...) not so much but if you talk about political opinion and their values there are differences, I think it in general with people who live in democracies and people who live under oppressive dictator.
@philsb9388
@philsb9388 9 месяцев назад
Imagine the outrage if people said this in western countries. «We won’t share it with other people because it’s our land”
@scatalin09
@scatalin09 9 месяцев назад
Imagine if they said this about these sheets wearers.
@peterwindle4453
@peterwindle4453 9 месяцев назад
my pet hate is seeing Aussies protesting about Jews occupying "their" land... whilst they live comfortably in Australia. Imagine if our Goverment said, we're returning the land to oboriginal owners... you must get out now. Yeah, right. They would be protesting that as well...
@iliasbey3538
@iliasbey3538 9 месяцев назад
They did share it and they got expelled from it, they know their lesson, so their answer is understandable..
@austkeat
@austkeat 9 месяцев назад
It always makes me laugh to see leftists in the US openly supporting people/religions that call for the genocide of Jews and hate gay people. Then they turn around and call every conservative a homophobic antisemite. Pure insanity.
@TacticalThib
@TacticalThib 9 месяцев назад
Imagine Americans saying we don't want any ethnic group in our country and we will never have peace because this is our land. This is how the Palestine people think. All hate no matter never peace always anger and evil violence
@patricksrensen7952
@patricksrensen7952 7 месяцев назад
“They want it all”.. But are you willing to share..?”.. “No, it’s our land..” 🤦‍♂️
@meisievannancy
@meisievannancy 3 месяца назад
They are insane and crazy entitled.
@mikechiks983
@mikechiks983 11 месяцев назад
What most of them failed to realise is that it wasn't always ruled by Muslims / Arabs. The Islamic rule they're referring to came with the conquests after most of the Jews had been displaced by the Romans and a few other conquests. There's also the fact that they didn't all return from Russia and Poland. 70% of Israelis are actually from Arab lands - currently 20% Arab Muslim population and over 50% actually returned from North Africa and Middle East after they were expelled from Morocco, Egypt, Iran, Iraq, Libya, Yemen, Sudan, Bahrain, Syria... Netanyahu himself was born there. So, it's delusional to expect them to leave - leave to where?
@Colbaltshimshim
@Colbaltshimshim 11 месяцев назад
So there you have it War,War,War.
@spearmint47
@spearmint47 11 месяцев назад
Ask the simple question... How many Nobel prizes have the Jews won. Real ones. Science medicine, technology etc. How many have the Arabs won.
@anarchorepublican5954
@anarchorepublican5954 11 месяцев назад
Truth is...Muslim Arabs are the most successful colonizers of all time...they've now colonized Paris, London. Berlin, Brussels, and Detroit...
@thisistheday597
@thisistheday597 11 месяцев назад
I am learning about Islam and the Arabs that either adopted the faith through force or acceptance. And it's clear their faith is about territory, control and power. This is why the people in Gaza are not indigenous to the land and actually migrated over the centuries. The Caanites and Philistines ruled before them. This is proven. It is very common for people groups, tribes and kinsmen to move around in this region because of the climate, famine or war. It's interesting that this isn't acknowledged in "whose land is it"?
@FingswithFrankie
@FingswithFrankie 11 месяцев назад
​@@spearmint47what does that have to do with anything?
@Nik2063
@Nik2063 10 месяцев назад
Losing countless wars and still being convinced is your land 😂 this is really unique to those people.
@gianthills
@gianthills 10 месяцев назад
I see, so you believe the only reason it's Israeli land is because they took it in war. But tell me why they had a right to move in before 1948.
@amano22
@amano22 10 месяцев назад
pls read the geneva law, win a land by war does not means it is legal to bring in ur own population and chase away the original population
@snowkie
@snowkie 10 месяцев назад
@@gianthillsMove in? Try cracking a history book and stop watching Al Jazerrah. Jews have been living in Israel before Islam was a religion.
@georgeparsons5
@georgeparsons5 10 месяцев назад
@@gianthills You do realize before Israel that the People who lived in Palestine were Muslims, Jews, Christian and other religious sects they were all called Palestinian. Muslims, Jews, Christians and others stayed after the creation of Israel. They also had a say in what happens on that land. Or is it you believe the followers of Haj Amin Al-Husseini who preached that the Holy land belonged to Muslims only and all others had to leave. Now do the people in Gaza and the West bank also want the land used to create Jordan back also?
@amateur_football9751
@amateur_football9751 10 месяцев назад
Its how they feel about it, perhaps the question was asked wrong, if suitable compensation was given to them, similar to how Canada is compensating Native Canadians, something could be worked out, this conflict is not imposible to solve, people may say stuff but they can change their minds
@MEL.FreeToRoam
@MEL.FreeToRoam 10 месяцев назад
I’m not Jewish, forgetting the problem in Israel I’m looking at the mentality and thoughts from these people and only one question comes to mind. What will happen to my country after all these Palestinians are flooding in day by day and are consistently claiming that they don’t want peace? I do find it fascinating that all the neighbouring Arab countries refuse to accept Palestinian refugees. Am I missing something?
@Jasmine34952
@Jasmine34952 10 месяцев назад
You're missing reading history. They were expelled from one of these countries because of what they were doing there and the other neighboring countries know this and will not let them in at any cost because they know they would do the same thing again. Sorry, I don't mean to be vague. I've read about all this a while back, but I have to go to work so, I'm trying to hurry this comment. I think they were expelled from Egypt.
@helenohara1639
@helenohara1639 9 месяцев назад
Google black september
@peterbird8161
@peterbird8161 9 месяцев назад
Jordan
@richiemitchell6899
@richiemitchell6899 9 месяцев назад
There the Muslims no one wants.
@izzy4575
@izzy4575 9 месяцев назад
⁠@@Jasmine34952Well, Egypt at some point had control of Gaza and Jordan had control of West Bank, what happened? Why they left? Why they didn’t help their Arab brothers? Because it’s impossible, they don’t want help or peace.
@MyNameIsJ3ffrey
@MyNameIsJ3ffrey 5 месяцев назад
It is ironic why the Palestinians are unwilling to share with Jews, but expect Americans and Europeans to share their land with them.
@Elana803
@Elana803 4 месяца назад
Arabs literally colonized dozens of countries.
@user-cw9zx7lr6r
@user-cw9zx7lr6r 3 месяца назад
There is a different between stealing and immigrating but still I think they should share however they are the victims right now
@Elana803
@Elana803 3 месяца назад
@@user-cw9zx7lr6r Palestinians initiate every conflict. They're victims of their own hate and intolerance.
@rothein436
@rothein436 3 месяца назад
​@@user-cw9zx7lr6rwhen jewish immigrated there the results were the 1929 Riots
@nomylearnspalestine
@nomylearnspalestine 3 месяца назад
​@@user-cw9zx7lr6r👏🏻💖🇵🇸
@jamesberkman8531
@jamesberkman8531 2 года назад
Corey please ask Palestinians next: "If the Israelis gave you back the entire country, what would you do to all the Jews?" If they say they must go back to Europe/where they came from, tell them that most Jews won't be accepted by foreign countries (because only about 10% have dual citizenship, a million Jews went to Israel after they were expelled from Muslim countries after 1948, some were living in Palestine before 1948)
@NickyRikki
@NickyRikki 2 года назад
This is total bullshit. My father is Moroccan and we go yearly to Morocco. Jews were never expelled from Morocco they were actually loved and cherished even by the king. Moroccan Jews are welcomed always. Most just don’t want to go back for financial reasons really.
@ajvorob9117
@ajvorob9117 2 года назад
@@NickyRikki Morocco is the exception. In other Arab countries Jews were massively persecuted and killed.
@dogbert52
@dogbert52 2 года назад
@@NickyRikkimuz coseplaying online "as a je w" ?:) why are you are lying? Its really obvious
@NickyRikki
@NickyRikki 2 года назад
@@ajvorob9117 no they weren’t again you don’t know shit. The only place they fled was Iraq and that was due to the Faroud of Baghdad in 1941 where Zionists planted bombs in the communities to scare the Jews and make them feel under attack to get them to migrate. This is well documented. Yemen, Egypt , Morocco, Syria, Iraq, Lebanon etc ...... never ever kicked out any Jews they willingly left because they were promised better lives in Israel . My own grandmother from Fez can contest to this. Also they treated the mizrachi like total shit when they came. Housed 4-5 families in 1 tent. You don’t have the slightest clue...... to say they were expelled and their homes taken is a lie and only proves you know very little and just repeating what you hear VS what you study and actually learned. So if we can agree that from 1 Arab Muslim country they didn’t flee and left on their own accord then what’s stopping them from doing the same in Syria, Yemen, Tunisia etc..... those countries were not financially stable ever and of course the Arab Jews were promised better lives in the new Jewish state. To say that Arab nations expelled the Jews from their lands in retaliation to what happened to the Palestinians is also a lie. Palestinians to this day are treated like shit in neighboring Arab countries and denied many rights. The Egyptians want nothing to do with them. The Emiratis sure as hell want nothing to do with them and they are very vocal about it. The only help the Palestinians ever got from the Arab nations was in 1948. See if you actually knew the history , You would know that 6 months prior 1948 already half of the Palestinians were expelled by the Hagana, Irgun and Stern gangs. Arabs didn’t just invade once Israel was declared a state because they were Jews . The months prior to 1948 Plan Dalet ( Plan D) was in full swing . Plan Dalet was Ben Gurions plan to expel the Palestinians to create a Jewish state and become the majority. The influx of Palestinians fleeing into other Arab nations created a lot of tension and the people were putting immense pressure on their leaders to do something about it. Between all the countries that invaded to help the Palestinians there was only 40k soldiers and they had the worst coordination and no where near the level of ammunition Israel had. Israel had 100k soldiers in that war with way better equipment to do the job and training from the British who also armed them. The last help the Palestinians would want from Arab nations is to expel arabs Jews from Arab lands to populate Palestine. The only people who are gaining from this are the Zionists. Why would you send more Jews to your enemy to populate them if you are trying to fight and liberate the land . Use your brain for half a fucken second. By the way all this information is public records that the British released from their archive on what happened in Mandate Palestine before 1948 and after. It’s clear as day that Plan Dalet was the master plan to clear out the Palestinians for Jewish immigrants. It’s not secret and the war in 1948 was to save the Palestinians from this mass expulsions. Only a moron with 2 brain cells left would believe the Israeli narrative. I wouldn’t trust an Israeli opinion if my life depended on it. This only because I know very well Israeli mentality and how racist Israel really is. I would take anything an Israeli says about 1948 with a huge fucking grain of salt .
@jamesberkman8531
@jamesberkman8531 2 года назад
@@NickyRikki You are ignorant and uninformed. Read up about the Jewish Exodus from the Muslim World. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_exodus_from_the_Muslim_world
@Alkes777
@Alkes777 10 месяцев назад
An interesting follow up question would be; can the Palestinians govern themselves? So far they've not exhibited that capability.
@intsccents
@intsccents 10 месяцев назад
They have not shown they can even live as civilized humans and build a better life all they want is to take .. and this is why they will end up with nothing..
@JDAfrica
@JDAfrica 10 месяцев назад
50 years of humanitarian aid - and nothing to show for it. Hundreds of billion of dollars and all Used to build tunnels and rockets.
@Jasmine34952
@Jasmine34952 10 месяцев назад
@@intsccents It's also why neighboring countries won't let them in. Even now, as refugees. They are thought that everything is theirs and everyone must live like them, as muslims because the rest of us are all infidels.
@jay26cee
@jay26cee 10 месяцев назад
Govern? I think that is a bit of rich statement. I'd be interested to know how the people (all the people) lived 100 years ago. How was it then? Was it chaos? Did they live in relative harmony? Who ruled? But to say they can't govern themselves under the divided and oppressive natured that the Israeli government forces them to live under? Come on. I am pretty sure they would and could eventually manage. Might take a long time to sort out the issues. Would you apply your statement to South Africa? It is the exact same situation.
@giltee626
@giltee626 10 месяцев назад
@@jay26ceeIsrael left Palestine and forcibly removed all Jews from the Gaza in 2005 leaving it to the PLA who failed dismally through nepotism and corruption. In 2006 the terrorist group Hamas was elected by the Palestinians. Yes Israel controlled the border and why wouldn’t they when Palestinian terrorists were coming into Israel and attacking civilians. Hamas consequently syphoned off aid money meant for Palestine to build their tunnel system and build weapon supplies to attack Israel. No Palestine haven’t shown they’re capable of governing themselves
@paullittlehales5502
@paullittlehales5502 10 месяцев назад
This says it all and confirms Israel must continue
@usnchief1339
@usnchief1339 10 месяцев назад
100%!
@daniilkeen6178
@daniilkeen6178 10 месяцев назад
And what at the end? Will Israel prepare to kill more than 2 millions Palestinians? Became like Hitler final solution?
@that207guy7
@that207guy7 10 месяцев назад
Unfortunately, you are correct. It's sad really.
@dvb8637
@dvb8637 9 месяцев назад
Exactly!!
@periscop2023
@periscop2023 9 месяцев назад
But this two guys who want to live in peace....
@CoinMagicUnderground
@CoinMagicUnderground 6 месяцев назад
Being a conflict resolution specialist in Israel is probably like being an auto mechanic in Cuba
@spofaldx8546
@spofaldx8546 4 месяца назад
what does that mean can you explain i didnt understand it
@CoinMagicUnderground
@CoinMagicUnderground 4 месяца назад
@@spofaldx8546 My understanding is there are a lot of old cars in Cuba that need repair. Likewise in Israel there is a lot of conflict which needs to be resolved.
@spofaldx8546
@spofaldx8546 4 месяца назад
@@CoinMagicUnderground well thats true sadly
@juliogomez7744
@juliogomez7744 10 месяцев назад
Why am I not surprised by their answers...
@bluemarlin8138
@bluemarlin8138 10 месяцев назад
I wonder what they’ll say when you inform them that about 90% of Palestinian Arabs in 1947 were either immigrants or children of immigrants from Arab countries. Or that Jews were a majority in Jerusalem for several centuries prior to about 1850.
@ajvorob9117
@ajvorob9117 10 месяцев назад
Indeed. Economic migrants at that.
@caspar_gomez
@caspar_gomez 9 месяцев назад
Tell 1 youre full of sht and I have the family trees deeds and titles to prove it. 2 it's irrelevant if they legally emmigrated there they were there first and deserve to stay. End of story, period.
@ringrun9872
@ringrun9872 9 месяцев назад
they give a s... and will find another lie to back their war against the jews/ Israel. In the muslim countries they have erased the jews
@wanali4504
@wanali4504 9 месяцев назад
I wonder what you’ll say when you find out literally none of that is true
@TheMusicHeals.kjhjhhg
@TheMusicHeals.kjhjhhg 9 месяцев назад
so after 1850 they lost ownership and the UN decided they shoudl have it back.. with that train of thought the US should be given back to the native americans
@choiceblade
@choiceblade 11 месяцев назад
I can't say how important this is. You seem to be genuinely trying to engage these people, and when you press them out pops humanity. some don't have the patience. I get it.
@blackmamba___
@blackmamba___ 9 месяцев назад
Both sides are saying we choose violence. As an outsider- all I can say is "Okay then, I wish you luck on your future endeavors."
@AdegbiteSola
@AdegbiteSola 6 месяцев назад
The only way for Isreal to continue to exist is for Jews to remain strong and defend themselves from the Arabs and muslims around them.
@drfang68
@drfang68 10 месяцев назад
Spoiler alert: if we have to choose between the Muslims and the Jews, we’ll choose the Jews.
@brianurbanik7587
@brianurbanik7587 10 месяцев назад
The second question I would have asked the people that said they couldnt share the land would be thus. Should the countries around the world that have allowed you to come and live in their lands tell you now to get out?
@michaelohare6555
@michaelohare6555 10 месяцев назад
Very interesting point. Can you marine if every other country in the world refused Palestinian immigrants?
@sadeqalasady5672
@sadeqalasady5672 9 месяцев назад
People when they go to other countries to live under the law of those countries not to steal the land and make a new country and kick the people who lived there for hundreds of years out .
@numbers7n
@numbers7n 9 месяцев назад
Well, and apply that to every Arab Muslim,... Imagine sending every Arab in the Middle East back to the Arabian Peninsula,... out of the lands they conquered... These clowns are FINE with 'might making right', so long as it is Islamic might,... but when they lose, they try to cry 'foul'...
@avanzo87
@avanzo87 9 месяцев назад
​@@sadeqalasady5672thank you! It's incredible so many people can not see the difference between being an immigrant and being a colonizer! It's not that hard
@RG_1987
@RG_1987 9 месяцев назад
As a secular israeli jew I'll gladly give them Israel if we get the entire of jordan 😂 wayyyy larger area that they got in 1948, and easier access to vacation places 😅
@AlexAminoff
@AlexAminoff 9 месяцев назад
I find it odd when they say “it’s our land” when a large percentage of Palestinians (not all) descend from Arabs who emigrated from other Arab countries in the last century. Case in point Yasser Arafat who himself was born in Egypt. There’s a lot of Palestinians who were there for centuries as well but most of them as well descend from the Arab empires that colonized before the ottomans. How far back is far enough to have a claim on the land? That being said as a religion Islam has always seen military conquest as a legitimate form of land annexation. Case in point when Mohammed raised an army and conquered Mecca and Medina. Or when they first conquered Jerusalem. If that’s the case they even if it was their land first wouldn’t Israel winning every war and annexing the land be a legitimate claim to the land based on their own history? Moreover historically Arabs aren’t indigenous to the Levant or North Africa. They all come from the Arabian Peninsula. The fact that there’s Arabs in all these places comes from centuries of military expansion from Arabic Empires
@2AwesomeDogs
@2AwesomeDogs 9 месяцев назад
Another fact that they overlook is over 70% of So call palestinians, In fact have Jewish blood running through their veins.
@stevenwolfe7101
@stevenwolfe7101 9 месяцев назад
But ownership through conquest is a benefit to be conferred only upon Arabs?
@savedbygrace7145
@savedbygrace7145 9 месяцев назад
Well stated excellent
@denverlove
@denverlove 9 месяцев назад
Nah, that’s just Israeli propaganda.
@HarleyQ5678
@HarleyQ5678 9 месяцев назад
Exactly
@digitaltavern
@digitaltavern 7 месяцев назад
Because of greed and hatred, now you have no land.
@jamestoney24
@jamestoney24 7 месяцев назад
you'll never enjoy peace with that mindset
@naziaali7560
@naziaali7560 5 месяцев назад
The jews were banished from their land because of their evil ways and now they come bk to occupy it. Who gave them that right?
@khadigamahmoud4456
@khadigamahmoud4456 4 дня назад
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@insaanietihad-MSB
@insaanietihad-MSB 2 года назад
I want to ask a supplement question to this, Do the Palestinians demand their land back from the Jordanians too.....since technically that is also created out of British mandated Palestine? Why isn't Palestinians claiming Jordan as their land??
@moad7191
@moad7191 2 года назад
Follow the Grievances and you shall find your answer.
@DanielGalimidi
@DanielGalimidi 2 года назад
The West Bank used to be a part of Jordan. Jordan relinquished control of the West Bank in 1970 after a Palestinian revolt there. Thus, Palestine declared independence from both Jordan and Egypt (which was occupying the Gaza Strip) in 1988. It wouldn't make any sense for Palestinians to claim Jordan as their land, since they stopped occupying Palestine long ago. Israel still is, though.
@jasonnarayan7759
@jasonnarayan7759 2 года назад
@@DanielGalimidi no, stupid. Look at an old map. Jordan is 78% of Palestine. You’re fighting for Tel Aviv but not Amman, where you have no rights either. Hypocrisy at its finest.
@johnmockingyou7547
@johnmockingyou7547 2 года назад
@@DanielGalimidi duh 1970 Revolt? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Jordan lost the West Bank in the 1967 War 😏
@DanielGalimidi
@DanielGalimidi 2 года назад
@Shalom Shalom How is that related at all to what I said? I said nothing about Muslims.
@paulcommerford2609
@paulcommerford2609 10 месяцев назад
It’s amazing that they have this delusion of their having owned the land, there ever being a Palestinian state and that nothing about the situation could possibly be their fault.
@paulrhodesquinn
@paulrhodesquinn 10 месяцев назад
Indeed. There never has been Palestinian land.
@Jasmine34952
@Jasmine34952 10 месяцев назад
That's one of the many lies they are taught from birth.
@jordanzlotolow8254
@jordanzlotolow8254 10 месяцев назад
How did Jews colonize when the Mosque is on our temple?
@greggreed3840
@greggreed3840 10 месяцев назад
@user-hv5so6qz9z the so called “Palestinians” are actually Syrians that were booted out. They are squatting on Jewish land. There have been Jews in Israel since the time of Abraham. Yes they are the chosen people your attempted translation is a joke. A more clear translation would be “ the apple of The eye of Yahweh” which would be the most special people. If this were not so why would he say that “ I will bless those that bless Israel and curse those that curse Israel”
@Simplyveej
@Simplyveej 10 месяцев назад
It is their land.
@ubroc
@ubroc 9 месяцев назад
When a Palestinian says "occupation" they are referring to all the lands of Israel as well as Gaza and the West Bank. I don't think that most people understand the term like that.
@josipag2185
@josipag2185 9 месяцев назад
Abrahamic mosque, imagine that word and that brain salto gymnastics. He wasn't a Muslim. But..try to tell them. It is all corrupted and twisted in Islam. People don't get it. People don't get that that verse if you kill the man, as if you have killed whole mankind is literally Muhammed paraphrasing Talmud and speaking about the Jews not the Muslims.
@youtubejunkie8053
@youtubejunkie8053 9 месяцев назад
Technically that territory has been everything but Palestinian, before Israel, there was a British Mandate, but it wasn’t a Palestinian state, before the British mandate there was the Ottoman Empire, before the Ottoman Empire there was the Islamic state of Mamluks of Egypt, before that there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, but it wasn’t a Palestinian state, before that there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, before that, there was the Byzantine Empire, buy it wasn’t a Palestinian state, before that, it was Sassanids territory, before that, there was the Roman Empire, before the Roman Empire that land was a Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state, and before that it was controlled by the Seleucid Empire, before that, it was conquered by Alexander the Great, before that the Persian Empire, before that there was the Babylonian Empire, before that it was the Kingdom of Israel and Judah, and before that it was called Theocracy of the Twelve Tribes of Israel, So it kind of seems like that land has been everything, but, Palestinian territory.
@sal-the-man
@sal-the-man 9 месяцев назад
@@youtubejunkie8053 stop with this stupid lies
@dawnstaszak1567
@dawnstaszak1567 9 месяцев назад
Great breakdown. If you go off the bible didnt abraham come thru from Ur up to Haran & even down to Egypt. He had an illegitimate child Ishmael who he loved but Isaac was from his actual wife & so on. Ishmael tribes split & bible says they fight. The land before Abraham? Kingdoms & tribes, Abraham fought won back his family & paid for land. Didnt accept money or bribes from the kings of that time, etc. So, so long ago... God owns the land & humans occupy it for a short while. Ashame peace cant be created in their hearts. I dont understand this conflict but I believe the bible & that natural law is written on everyones heart. Some come to repentance & faith in Jesus & find forgiveness, the rest send themselves to hell & full of greed & hate. Love thy neighbor...
@sammencia7945
@sammencia7945 9 месяцев назад
​@@dawnstaszak1567 "West Bank" is Samaria and Judea. Jewish area since David and Solomon.
@sherinvarghese8095
@sherinvarghese8095 8 месяцев назад
Like if the last women said, if you consider taking genetic tests related to land, all these palestinians will be related to Jordan, Egypt, Syria and Saudi 😂
@surfingbilly9654
@surfingbilly9654 5 месяцев назад
yeah and all of the others genetic tests would be in europe, which one is closer?
@zerohere0
@zerohere0 2 месяца назад
they all will be palestinian. jordan was never crowded saudi totally different than palestinian. palestine was always crowded with people from more than 4k years ago and fact alot of palestinian muslims/Christians was a jew before converted to one of these religion and many are cananties and many more so stop clowning please
@Randommm-o3b
@Randommm-o3b 9 месяцев назад
You forgot the most important question... “If a jew agrees to convert to Islam…, can he live there?” You will get the astonishing “YES” 😂😂😂 It's all about the religion… it has always been in the history 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️
@sn1perman
@sn1perman 9 месяцев назад
Well thats a shit option..
@Randommm-o3b
@Randommm-o3b 9 месяцев назад
@@sn1perman but you can see their change of heart in one sec 😂😂Real reason for the war will come out... Believers vs non-believers... It's not about land... It's all about THE religion 🤷‍♀️
@sn1perman
@sn1perman 9 месяцев назад
@@Randommm-o3b its all fubar
@ServantOfYHWH
@ServantOfYHWH 9 месяцев назад
THIS COMMENT!!! 🔥 👆🏻 😆
@tjp1451
@tjp1451 9 месяцев назад
Religion is the greatest scourge of humanity.
@navy_flyer2331
@navy_flyer2331 9 месяцев назад
I love the narrative "it's out country" when the name "palestinian" was LITERALLY a name meant as an insult to the jews who inhabited it BEFORE the arabs (give by the Roman empire). It is a biblical reference to the philistines who were invaders and occupiers who stole the land from the JEWS. Their own SELF-IDENTIFIED name is a historical reference to the Jewish predecessors to the land. Not to mention, their holy mosque is built ON TOP of the Jewish temple... tell me which one came first?
@margotleenders4133
@margotleenders4133 9 месяцев назад
Oh my goodness! At last! Someone who knows history! 👍
@AliyaDabkes2465
@AliyaDabkes2465 9 месяцев назад
@donovanteale6502
@donovanteale6502 9 месяцев назад
thats a whole new silly conspiracy. shame on you
@donovanteale6502
@donovanteale6502 9 месяцев назад
@@margotleenders4133 thats not history its just moronic conspiracy
@2AwesomeDogs
@2AwesomeDogs 9 месяцев назад
At least some people are educated on history. You're a hundred percent right the romans are the ones that named siri-palestinia. Also, if d n a testing was done over seventy percent of all, palestinians are Jewish. FACT
@agochoa
@agochoa 10 месяцев назад
This is only one of MANY videos proving that this is about complete removal and not coexisting on Palestines part.
@mobiblaize
@mobiblaize 7 месяцев назад
This video is very important for posterity. Thanks for uploading Palestinians are not and never have been interested in a 2-state solution
@AG-mo9zs
@AG-mo9zs 10 месяцев назад
This is the major problem with the Palestinians. They are NEVER willing to compromise; it's ALL or nothing for them, which is sad!
@xxuncexx
@xxuncexx 9 месяцев назад
Apparently they chose nothing.
@HillyPlays
@HillyPlays 9 месяцев назад
@@xxuncexx They chose 500 km of terror tunnels instead of peace. So yes, they chose nothing. :(
@AEdy93
@AEdy93 9 месяцев назад
The same goes for Israelis. Its surprising everyone in the comments thinks Israelis are angels. The answers from their sides is even worse. Atleast the Palestinian answers are "because they stole it, they killed us". Go and see the Israeli answers and come back to the comment please.
@baeh3657
@baeh3657 9 месяцев назад
@@AEdy93izrael agreed on every single peace/boarder plan - even white papers which was most “ pro palestine “ one . izrael gave back land they win over them in war . they are not the SAME .
@kaosaechao56
@kaosaechao56 9 месяцев назад
@@AEdy93doesn’t Israel have Palestinians in office? Can you imagine the opposite happening?
@margaretbehler4935
@margaretbehler4935 9 месяцев назад
So much for a people of peace.
@PROVOCATEURSK
@PROVOCATEURSK 9 месяцев назад
They literally want to kill people for "sins".
@bighornriverpaul
@bighornriverpaul 9 месяцев назад
They never were.
@digitaldoom3593
@digitaldoom3593 9 месяцев назад
That's because they are Canaanites. Descendants of Cain. And we all know what he thought of abel
@LJ181-qe6uj
@LJ181-qe6uj 9 месяцев назад
They don’t want peace. They want the Jews to leave or die. The funny part, they don’t get that choice. The Israeli’s have a strong military and are backed by the #1 military and economy in the world. The Palestinians will either find peace or die. Nothing else. They are so blinded by anger and hatred that they think there’s another option. RIP Palestine.
@john2300
@john2300 9 месяцев назад
All humans are evil
@brubrushanghai
@brubrushanghai 10 месяцев назад
This is very useful reporting man! Understand better what's in their head now. Peace is going to be a challenge...
@iamhudsdent2759
@iamhudsdent2759 10 месяцев назад
You're just figuring that out. I don't know about you, Brother, but I am 68 years old, and it's never been any different.
@blackmamba___
@blackmamba___ 9 месяцев назад
Sounds like they are both saying peace is not an option. So maybe us outsiders need to respect that fact.
@anandamirtharaj4400
@anandamirtharaj4400 7 месяцев назад
Here is the reason why "Two State Solution" will not work and not the solution!
@philippang07
@philippang07 10 месяцев назад
An exceptionally important video. Thank you.
@alexisportilla8045
@alexisportilla8045 9 месяцев назад
You are doing great work trying to have these conversations
@vostok2360
@vostok2360 9 месяцев назад
It would also help if video was not edited to show one side of the story only.
@nathanielwilliams6042
@nathanielwilliams6042 9 месяцев назад
​@@vostok2360 He did the same exact one sided approach against jews so I guess he's just being fair
@vostok2360
@vostok2360 9 месяцев назад
@@nathanielwilliams6042 but it’s not fair, it’s controversial. Unless someone is subscribed to this channel the chances are that majority of people will form opinion based on the content of one single sided carefully edited video. The only fair way to do it is approach people on street and ask them questions. No editing, no crafting to get the most controversial image possible with radical positions only. Applies to both sides, Jews and Palestinians.
@JeanBod1111
@JeanBod1111 8 месяцев назад
The only video you need to watch on this channel. sums everything up.
@Isabella_kh
@Isabella_kh 7 месяцев назад
The Palestinian people did not have a problem with Israelis coming from abroad until they took over control of land and the government and kicked close to a million out of their homes making them refugees (the Nakba in 1948-the big catastrophe). Illegal settlements are documented by all Human rights organizations-Jews can walk into any Palestinian home and move in. How would you feel if I came to your home right and kicked you out because it’s my birth right? Also, the video maker obviously didn’t post the people who said yes we can live together if given equal rights.
@JeanBod1111
@JeanBod1111 7 месяцев назад
im sorry dear but you have no clue. jews started buying land from arabs since the the 19th century no jew took any arab land by force only until 1948. when all the arab nation denied the un agreement of giving the jews a state and with 7 armies tried to annahilate every jew in the land. they lost and many people left and expeled due to the war and the jews won some land in the fight. and by the way the term palestinian people was coined only by yassar arafat in 1964! there was no palestinian nation only arabs. palestine is a european colonial name. the true arab name of the region is bilad al shams. expand your mind outside your echo chamber. @@Isabella_kh
@SL92018
@SL92018 7 месяцев назад
This is the West Bank, how on earth do you think the people in the West Bank who have been born and raised in Israeli occupation and oppression want to live with the Israelis controlling their lives? They live in conditions in many ways worse that apartheid South Africa was for black South Africans.
@richardgreen7811
@richardgreen7811 9 месяцев назад
Ya know what I like about this woman ??? She's being truthful. It's a truth I've recognized since being a child. Hatred is not a race ... hatred is not a religion ... hatred is not innate. Hatred is learned and passed down from generation-to-generation. She is correct. The Arabs and the Jews will never leave in peace so long as there is an Arab alive to instill hatred in their children, which will never cease. In front of a camera you might hear a public version, but behind closed doors and in schools, hatred is predominant.
@suzannemartin6817
@suzannemartin6817 9 месяцев назад
And it’s perpetuated by the UN supporting Hamas schools and their curriculum that glorifies terrorists and hate Jews
@androsc1418
@androsc1418 9 месяцев назад
So Hamas is a manifestation of Palestinians ?
@stevenwolfe7101
@stevenwolfe7101 9 месяцев назад
Yep.
@noski33
@noski33 9 месяцев назад
Yes. It is so sad how hatred was instilled in their psyche from birth, and then passed on down to next generations. It's very sad.
@vikingdrengenspiders7875
@vikingdrengenspiders7875 9 месяцев назад
Where do the hatred come from Islam
@Max-ht9hf
@Max-ht9hf 10 месяцев назад
It’s never been about land it’s about hate!
@doddsalfa
@doddsalfa 10 месяцев назад
Not true American settlers have been stealing land for decades
@reallyhappenings5597
@reallyhappenings5597 9 месяцев назад
It's about the land, firstly, always.
@charleshixon1458
@charleshixon1458 9 месяцев назад
Watching people choose their own extinction is fascinating.
@hairyarms1902
@hairyarms1902 9 месяцев назад
"Give me liberty or give me death" is only cool when it's white people?
@JH-zh7hq
@JH-zh7hq 7 месяцев назад
no it wasn't chosen it was actually brought to them by force, you intellectual toddler. Or did you think that this segment was a serious proposal for peace and equality. Smh.
@coehenrique
@coehenrique 9 месяцев назад
This is the real people that media doesn’t show.
@UsmanKhan-coolmf
@UsmanKhan-coolmf 6 месяцев назад
Their view point comes back to they can't live with jews because jews don't treat them equally and take their land. They didn't understand the question to mean that "imagine true equality". Therefore they say they aren't willing to share.
@Femmeaesthetic
@Femmeaesthetic 5 месяцев назад
they only want to show the suffering instead of the culture
@UsmanKhan-coolmf
@UsmanKhan-coolmf 5 месяцев назад
@@Femmeaesthetic they only want to show what people want to see and unfortunately that's what we want in this stage of our evolution
@darwinmetropolis8768
@darwinmetropolis8768 3 месяца назад
this is media, you are funny
@jackfeifer2501
@jackfeifer2501 9 месяцев назад
I liked when you asked them in the last video. What they say about Jewish relics from thousands of years ago proving that Jews were actually there before the Palestinians, and they all denied it. They made up a narrative that it is their land, and it is so powerful a narrative that they will die for it.
@1871-b9m
@1871-b9m 9 месяцев назад
This argument is so weak it weakens your point. Land doesnt belong to you, just because thousands of years ago it was yours. A lot of eastern europe and even the Krim was settled by germanics long before the slavic people came there. So would it be our divine right to claim it back?
@plopping-wetlyacademyofmot9639
@plopping-wetlyacademyofmot9639 9 месяцев назад
​@user-zr8cc2pv5x this argument is not weak its historical fact 🤦‍♂️ Jews were in Israel thousands of years before the Philistines. During wars, many jews fled or were expelled from the land. Then some tribes of philistines come and start squatting there and when the Jews *return home* to their native land, they are now "occupying" or "oppressing" the squatters? Weeeeird logic. But you believe what you want to believe. Not like there's 30 other Arab/Muslim countries nearby, better make sure the Jews don't get one. (Your antisemitism is showing)
@jackfeifer2501
@jackfeifer2501 9 месяцев назад
@@1871-b9m the point is,not one of those people questioned were old enough to own land in 1948, they claim that the Jews were not there, and it is their land,as opposed to anyone else’s land who currently occupies it!what they are willing to die for is their narrative that the Jews have no claim to the land…that it belongs only to them, the Jews claim they have as much a right to the land as the Palestinians, sharing this land is ultimately the question being asked…. Now do you understand my point?
@balthasar3
@balthasar3 9 месяцев назад
@@jackfeifer2501 Israel is still taking land present day.
@Tranquil_Hobby
@Tranquil_Hobby 9 месяцев назад
@@1871-b9mJews are from Judea, if Palestinians argue their ownership of the land doesn’t diminish with the passage of time, that is doubly true for the Jews who were exiled from their land and kept their religion and people consistent over the centuries.
@EmilyJolie-e8t
@EmilyJolie-e8t 9 месяцев назад
This is a great documentary! It shows the reality! No they don’t want to share their land, yet they want to come to our countries and use our resources and are ok with us sharing our lands!
@JonRowlison
@JonRowlison 9 месяцев назад
We really need to stop calling it "their" land. The Jews lived here for 4,000 years. The Arabs who do most of the complaining are Arab Muslims who moved there in the past few hundred years. The initial inhabitants (Canaanites, Jews, and Christians) have been there continuously for this entire time. There was never a country called "Palestine" except when the Romans renamed the Jewish nation from Judea to Palestine (at which time it referred SPECIFICALLY to the native Jews.) It's all a big mess because Arab Muslims now calling themselves "Palestinian" are trying to re-write history in woke 2023.
@alanmacdonald1457
@alanmacdonald1457 9 месяцев назад
all of that means nothing, the palestinians were there for 1k years and the occupation has been dont completely illegally so no, its funny you say the palestinians are trying to rewrite history when the israeli people are literally doing that what world do you live in where the losers write history? so deluded you must be from the US @@JonRowlison
@EmilyJolie-e8t
@EmilyJolie-e8t 9 месяцев назад
@@JonRowlison I am talking about them sharing their land, where they are living now, with newcomers, Jews that would move there and buy a house. They are not willing to do that, yet they our ok to move to our countries and get welfare and live happily ever after.
@Red-Check-Mark
@Red-Check-Mark 9 месяцев назад
​@@JonRowlisonNobody cares about Jews from 4,000 years ago. That Isreal is gone. Doesn't exist anymore.
@ameerahtareeq9771
@ameerahtareeq9771 9 месяцев назад
⁠@@JonRowlisonyou’re literally so dense it’s insane. You do realize people can convert to Islam right? It’s not a race. My father is a Christian Palestinian his father was a Christian Palestinian and I’m a Muslim Palestinian. According to you only the Christian and Jewish Palestinians are “caannites” and indigenous so does that mean just because I converted I’m stripped of my identity and heritage? I’ll let you think about that for a bit. My family claims to be descendants of the first Christians to exist and speak Arabic AND Aramaic (the language Jesus spoke) so r they not native to the land? Languages change religions change that doesn’t mean the people changed. Jesus didn’t even speak Hebrew are you saying he wasn’t indigenous to the land?
@Inwoodarts
@Inwoodarts 10 месяцев назад
You are very Courageous to ask tremendously hard questions on both sides. May you be blessed with good health, joy + prosperity.✌️Thank You!
@dianneking3616
@dianneking3616 10 месяцев назад
He is an ignorant American who asks the most unrealistic questions. His country America supports Israel. It is quite obvious he supports Israel.
@medicgaming101
@medicgaming101 7 месяцев назад
“we won’t share it, it’s our land” why is it ok for tens of millions of them to go to europe from arabia then
@Sentinel48
@Sentinel48 7 месяцев назад
That’s called immigration and not colonization
@devileyes4u
@devileyes4u 5 месяцев назад
@@Sentinel48 so it called immigration not Zionism if so
@dutchskyrimgamer.youtube2748
@dutchskyrimgamer.youtube2748 4 месяца назад
​@@Sentinel48 Mizrachi Jews: am I a joke to you?
@xx-kj1om
@xx-kj1om 3 месяца назад
@@Sentinel48Like they said it’s not your land, it’s ours.
@tamaralexander9379
@tamaralexander9379 2 года назад
They want no Jewish state. Thats the issue of this conflict.
@randomeardrum
@randomeardrum 2 года назад
The issue is that jews are taking over their land and their homes.
@JonathanMartin884
@JonathanMartin884 2 года назад
Just like Israelis don't want a Palestinian state. At some point the group with more power is going to need to relent.
@rachelsamuel3328
@rachelsamuel3328 2 года назад
@@JonathanMartin884 The Jews offered the Palestinians a state many times. The Peel Commision in 1937, offered the Arabs 80% of the land, they turned it down because the Jews were offered the other 20%.
@hamerstein7117
@hamerstein7117 2 года назад
big deal. integrate like there is no war and war like there is no integration. we dont need to wait for their permission 😎
@rxtr664
@rxtr664 2 года назад
@@rachelsamuel3328 Oh, I guess when a thief steals something, he's allowed to have it as long as they return a small percentage of whatever he stole?!!
@Bluezer85
@Bluezer85 10 месяцев назад
This gives me the shivers. After Oct 7 we listen to what they say. There won't be peace, and their conditions will be worsened. We're done
@Lanadelreyandindilaontop
@Lanadelreyandindilaontop 10 месяцев назад
yeah keep babbling spreading wild propgandas is wild
@jimibhoy8935
@jimibhoy8935 10 месяцев назад
No, this video isn't propaganda, it's Palestinians expressing their beliefs when asked a straighforward question. That's why they are in the mess. Dancing in the streets on 7/10. The world saw what they are. Live, and filmed by themselves. Not propaganda. Reap what you sow
@WhatsOnYourMind.
@WhatsOnYourMind. 10 месяцев назад
@@jimibhoy8935 Are you serious? You listened to the video and still haven't figured out that Israeli settlers were taking over their land and breaking every rule imaginable as agreed. Wow...
@intsccents
@intsccents 10 месяцев назад
I think most educated westerns and even some arab countries can see these people are not going to be able to live in a civilized world ! better to deal with it now and let the chips fall where they will...no one here will mourn the loss of such people...
@gallowglass3764
@gallowglass3764 10 месяцев назад
​@@WhatsOnYourMind. Well, Palestine is getting war, then. Israel is ending the debate, one mile at a time.
@setaside77
@setaside77 9 месяцев назад
The problem is that, in all Islamic dominated lands it is either illegal to practice anything other than Islam with strict penalties ( up to death, though not necessarily)or at very least you will be socially, and economically outcast by your family and community.
@skyloh258
@skyloh258 9 месяцев назад
GCC countries are confused
@goodkaja8330
@goodkaja8330 9 месяцев назад
Agree and add that their flawed governments reflect the lack of division between religion and state which leads to prohibitions on non-Islamic persons holding leadership positions in their government bureaucracies and military.
@wothin
@wothin 9 месяцев назад
What you describe only applies to apostates aka you must have been muslim in the first place or had to have a Muslim family
@Merakis100
@Merakis100 9 месяцев назад
Yep, we can and we should.
@bluey6440
@bluey6440 9 месяцев назад
Islam is not a religion, it’s a political ideology. Heavily involved in politics. This “political religion” claims to represent God, but has committed shameful violence and atrocities even toward their own people. Immigration is high amongst people of the Islamic religion, because of its failing toward its own people. These people often bring along this radical ideology to many other non Islamic countries. Often causing much problems. Islam as a whole is guilty for the birth of Islamic militia’s in many countries. This political ideology was founded on war and spread as a result of blood shed…the true intentions of this is greed and power. The honest hearted Muslims who see the truth and end up leaving are either persecuted or even threatened with death. Sad.
@C.I366
@C.I366 7 месяцев назад
Well done Corey,you have given me so much insight.
@Ninjajitsu562
@Ninjajitsu562 11 месяцев назад
I love how honest this youtuber is who made this I respect him so much I seen his other videos truly balanced
@nivasylstrongman4352
@nivasylstrongman4352 11 месяцев назад
Corey Gill-Shuster is naive and stupid. when did a jew become a race? Jewish is a religion. samy davis junior, donald Trup dauther, Evanka were both Christian then converted to Judaism.
@rigelrigel2432
@rigelrigel2432 Год назад
Wow! Thank you for making it easier to read the subtitles and having an interpreter made it a much more enjoyable experience. Thank you!
@tommalone58
@tommalone58 10 месяцев назад
same attitude prevails that led to the trouble back 1948
@viking670
@viking670 2 года назад
What the Palestinians don't seem to realize is that Israel was inhabited by Jews long before the Muslims showed up, can any see my comment?
@shainazion4073
@shainazion4073 2 года назад
Yes, I agree.
@merrychreysler8717
@merrychreysler8717 2 года назад
u know palestinians are christians too ? 💀
@shainazion4073
@shainazion4073 2 года назад
@@merrychreysler8717 there are only 2% of the "Palestinians" are Christians.
@Guildofarcanelore
@Guildofarcanelore 9 месяцев назад
As someone who spent 19 months living in a tent in the Registan desert, I gotta say, as open air prisons go, I expected a lot worse.
@jedivideo6203
@jedivideo6203 8 месяцев назад
This is not filmed in Gaza
@Guildofarcanelore
@Guildofarcanelore 8 месяцев назад
@@jedivideo6203 where is it filmed then?
@jedivideo6203
@jedivideo6203 8 месяцев назад
@@Guildofarcanelore Somewhere in the West Bank. There are two main areas where the Palestinians live, the West Bank and Gaza. Gaza is the area that is described as an open air prison because it is walled off and Israel controls anything or anyone that goes in or out.
@Guildofarcanelore
@Guildofarcanelore 8 месяцев назад
@@jedivideo6203 doesn’t Gaza share a border with Egypt? How does Israel control that border?
@meinte874
@meinte874 7 месяцев назад
@@Guildofarcanelore egypt cooperates with israel since their peace treaty
@bigdmcgee101mikwilla7
@bigdmcgee101mikwilla7 9 месяцев назад
When you’re repeatedly told, surrounded by people saying ‘this is our land, they stole it,’ it’s natural to believe it unless you conduct your own research. I’ve witnessed a similar phenomenon with the ‘stolen generation’ in Australia. Having only one side of history can lead to a skewed perspective.
@JohnDoe-dk4dr
@JohnDoe-dk4dr 9 месяцев назад
When Palestinians say it is their land it’s because they’ve lived there forever. When Israeli’s say it’s their land, they mean God said it was their land, so they immigrated there. Of course most Israeli’s don’t even believe in God. One day people will live in equality in Palestine, and most of the colonisers will leave then as they did in South Africa, Rhodesia, Algeria, and so many other places
@TheWarriorLV
@TheWarriorLV 9 месяцев назад
True. My Palestinian friend is this way. Makes sense. Not saying it’s right or valid, but makes sense. I sent her historical articles about the truth of the land and she didn’t care.
@TheEarningsGuy
@TheEarningsGuy 9 месяцев назад
@@TheWarriorLVpost the link here
@airognolsalocin3256
@airognolsalocin3256 9 месяцев назад
Sounds like black people in America
@battlepassgaming
@battlepassgaming 9 месяцев назад
@@TheWarriorLV she didnt care because religiously speaking in islam they lost there priveleges and even some jews will argue that they dont belong
@sayuas4293
@sayuas4293 2 года назад
Every naive liberal needs to watch this
@JonathanMartin884
@JonathanMartin884 2 года назад
Why? So we can see what apartheid does to people in other counties? We see what apartheid does to African American culture in the US. Why do we need another example?
@sayuas4293
@sayuas4293 2 года назад
@@JonathanMartin884 Because liberals keep saying just make peace with them and they will accept it and the violence will stop.
@mister4593
@mister4593 2 года назад
Every kolonial imperialist too!!
@user-bo8nb2mi
@user-bo8nb2mi 2 года назад
Since 20% of the Israel population is Arab, then 20% of the Palestine population should be Jewish... If Palestine refuses to have Jewish people in their future country, then it's just they that are guilty of apartheid
@user-bo8nb2mi
@user-bo8nb2mi 2 года назад
The Mount of Olives cemetery, which is the oldest Jewish cemetery in the world. The 150,000 graves in the 3,000-year-old burial site include "three of Jewry's greatest prophets, foremost Torah scholars, heads of Hassidic dynasties, and many of Jewry's national leaders over the ages, not to mention the ancient Jewish Quarter in Jerusalem where the holiest site for world Jewry stands the Temple Mount built by Kings David and son King Solomon!
@Nooticus
@Nooticus 2 года назад
This video is such a huge punch in the stomach to those like me who think peace can come one day. B'H bring some sense of understanding to these people who I'm sure have kind caring hearts.
@tripzville7569
@tripzville7569 2 года назад
Hello distant friend, I hear you. Do not despair "the earth is but one country and mankind its citizens '. Unity in Diversity.
@Nooticus
@Nooticus 2 года назад
@@tripzville7569
@ajvorob9117
@ajvorob9117 2 года назад
Nah they're too far gone.
@Nooticus
@Nooticus 2 года назад
@@ajvorob9117 At the moment, yes, they clearly are. But what about their great-great grandchildren?
@dogbert52
@dogbert52 2 года назад
@@Nooticus what education do you think they will give their kids?
@avatarnaya
@avatarnaya 7 месяцев назад
At 9:42 in the video, the woman says if you convert you can live here. Imagine if nonmuslims were to say that to muslims in countries they have invaded.
@gianniskamakas3578
@gianniskamakas3578 5 месяцев назад
Underrated comment
@bronya8108
@bronya8108 4 месяца назад
she was saying that people that convert to Judaism can then come to live in Israel even though their ancestors are not from there and that it's unfair.
@sodakk17
@sodakk17 9 месяцев назад
As they said, for them "it's all or nothing", so it's difficult to sympathize with their cause.
@arthurb8924
@arthurb8924 11 месяцев назад
However, the Qur'an specifies that the Land of Israel is the homeland of the Jewish people, that God Himself gave that Land to them as heritage and ordered them to live therein. Quran Verse 17:104 'And We said thereafter unto the Children of Israel, “Dwell in the land. And when the promise of the Hereafter comes to pass, We shall bring you as a mixed assembly.”
@Elena...elena...1986
@Elena...elena...1986 11 месяцев назад
Thats true. Same in the Bible.
@vero9348
@vero9348 11 месяцев назад
And people still believe Quran and Bible are historical books lol 😂😂🤡
@yaraAAAA994
@yaraAAAA994 11 месяцев назад
later they were punished and casted out of it so of you ganna quote take the the whole story or leave it
@ColoniaMurder20
@ColoniaMurder20 11 месяцев назад
@@vero9348 have you read about Solomon story on Holy Bible? especially about journey of King Solomon in "Land of Ophir" im telling you that story is true.. people in "Land of Ophir" as known as Philippines have connection to ancient Israel.. origin gold to build Solomon's Gold Temple came from the Philippines.. and people in the Philippines have loan words from Hebrew and one of their ancient writing system similar to Hebrew.. and I have relatives in Mindanao Region are look like have ancestry from Jewish with their white skin.. native filipinos have brown skin. if you dont know people in Maritime Southeast Asia as known as Austronesian people were ancient seafaring people who dominated entire Pacific Region, Maritime Southeast Asia, Central Vietnam, Taiwan, Southern China and Madagascar.
@screwsloose8631
@screwsloose8631 11 месяцев назад
The Qur'an says it's for the righteous. The promise made was not without conditions.
@homosapien.a6364
@homosapien.a6364 2 года назад
They don’t understand the fact that they aren’t in a position of power, The best for them and for their children future is to move on. This mentality ain’t gonna get them anywhere
@zetto814
@zetto814 2 года назад
When you are powerless you resist, one day it might pay, not sure but it might... It can also be long, in some cases 2000 years
@GlobetrotterBR
@GlobetrotterBR 2 года назад
@@zetto814 Blah blah blah...
@zetto814
@zetto814 2 года назад
@@GlobetrotterBR your comment is much better then a bla. Bla
@GlobetrotterBR
@GlobetrotterBR 2 года назад
@@zetto814 It's the only type of comment Falasteen mongos and friends understand.
@hanna319
@hanna319 2 года назад
@@zetto814 yeah but then the whole world will condemn them for stealing another people land, same thing that happened to those who waited 2000 years.
@brucec5578
@brucec5578 7 месяцев назад
Thanks for exposing this!
@fionaforward3358
@fionaforward3358 10 месяцев назад
Really,what can you do with these people.They do not deserve our sympathy.Such racist,hating people.
@opinion3742
@opinion3742 9 месяцев назад
Hilarious. Because Israel is definitely not prejudiced towards the people they are oppressing and murdering!
@mik3ymomo
@mik3ymomo 10 месяцев назад
Everyone on the world needs to watch this.
@markfrazer7706
@markfrazer7706 9 месяцев назад
At least our ignorant youth in college need to watch it and anything that is not the indoctrination they are currently paying 10 of thousands for. Oh shit, i forgot, i paid for my sons indoctrination.
@ringrun9872
@ringrun9872 9 месяцев назад
the western world should tread the muslims like they tread other people.... that would bring them back 2 reality.
@kleopatra6234
@kleopatra6234 9 месяцев назад
Especially JoebamaBiden, and Blinken.
@donnapartow
@donnapartow 10 месяцев назад
Truly tragic. There can be no future when someone is still talking about 1948 like it was yesterday when it's been nearly 100 years. Heartbreaking that this self-destructive mindset is so pervasive.
@martinbisschoff988
@martinbisschoff988 9 месяцев назад
The mind sciences fraternity states that it takes on average 62 days. To abandon or start a "bad" habit. Just 62 days. Think it through.
@nazgul7914
@nazgul7914 9 месяцев назад
then why are the israelis talking about shit that happened 3000 years ago? scratch my head.
@lingo2025
@lingo2025 9 месяцев назад
@@nazgul7914you think it through. Just because some Israeli’s do the same with history, doesn’t mean that it’s a useful tool for peace. The original comment here did not say that it was OK for Israeli to say that, but not OK for Palestinians. You just assumed that for one party to be wrong, the other one has to be right. That’s another reason why there’s no peace. Too many people think the way you do.
@nazgul7914
@nazgul7914 9 месяцев назад
@@lingo2025 oh so it's okay for them to do it but not other people? I get your double standards.
@DBFIU
@DBFIU 9 месяцев назад
​@@nazgul7914 you didnt read what the guy wrote bub
@xTunafishx
@xTunafishx 9 месяцев назад
I sure feel the love and peace from these people.
@meinte874
@meinte874 7 месяцев назад
watch the israeli interviews then and these people will seem like saints
@SL92018
@SL92018 7 месяцев назад
This is the West Bank, how on earth do you think the people in the West Bank who have been born and raised in Israeli occupation and oppression want to live with the Israelis controlling their lives? They live in conditions in many ways worse that apartheid South Africa was for black South Africans.
@User.665
@User.665 9 месяцев назад
The whole "its our land" excuse doesnt fly with me. Plenty of countires in the west are expected to "share" their land via immigration so they can work through their hatred to do the same.
@SweBeach2023
@SweBeach2023 9 месяцев назад
True, but we are not expected to share our land because an invading army forced us to do so.
@User.665
@User.665 9 месяцев назад
@@SweBeach2023 it's disputed if it really belongs to you. If anything it points to the Israeli people since they have a claim to it back when it was known as judea and was stolen from them. If you're talking about the west then yes, we are being invaded since illegal and undocumented immigrations en masse is an invasion.
@placidochan9702
@placidochan9702 9 месяцев назад
@@SweBeach2023 That's how land started to belong to people, to begin with.
@johnsheehy4192
@johnsheehy4192 9 месяцев назад
You've got to be kidding. Israel was made mostly Jewish by a NAZI-like expulsion of most of the non-Jews, by recent immigrants. This isn't simple immigration.
@Dailyclips_podcast
@Dailyclips_podcast 8 месяцев назад
Yeah but they dont want to create their own country on your territory
@Wulfzz
@Wulfzz 9 месяцев назад
How can you say "it's our land, they cant be here" and that the problem is "they want it all" at the same time?
@SkrifftheDragon
@SkrifftheDragon 9 месяцев назад
Because you don't give your land to an invading force.
@itz_viriya_.p._yuk-1345
@itz_viriya_.p._yuk-1345 9 месяцев назад
​@@SkrifftheDragon So what is the way out of this endless conflict, for them the only way out of this is war, the only way out is to destroy Jews state but to achieve this they have to win the war but in reality that'll not happen, they can't win the war, they tried before and they lost. The Jews is going nowhere, so if peace is not the way out, which way is the way out of this.
@FolkoMagipaw
@FolkoMagipaw 9 месяцев назад
​@@SkrifftheDragonExactly. And the Palestinians are invaders. They are the remnants of Muslim conquerers and colonisers.
@omarromo5293
@omarromo5293 9 месяцев назад
​@SkrifftheDragon whose land? Yasir Arafat, the head of the PLO for years was an Egyptian. Why was he considered a Palestinian more than a Jewish family that immigrated from Syria, for example?
@blahblahboii
@blahblahboii 8 месяцев назад
@@SkrifftheDragon "don't give your land to an invading force" Time to push all the arabs back to the arabian peninsula then? since they invaded from there and all
@timurcan2210
@timurcan2210 2 года назад
FROM TURKEY, the palestinians there are more 20 arab countries. If you are NOT happy there, just go and live with your people in those countries, THAT IS THE SOLUTION.
@zetto814
@zetto814 2 года назад
They are not happy and they are not gonna go anywhere as the 20+ countries are not their home and they will fight and resist their oppressor. . If you are not happy you can, go to Azerbaijan or Turkmenistan where you original come from.
@timurcan2210
@timurcan2210 2 года назад
@@zetto814 I am very happy in Turkey you arab.
@zetto814
@zetto814 2 года назад
@@timurcan2210 I'm also happy wherw I am.
@dogbert52
@dogbert52 2 года назад
@@timurcan2210 b bu but if they go back to their homelands.... who will they take social security benefits from? And free healthcare? 24 7 electricity?
@zetto814
@zetto814 2 года назад
@@dogbert52 no body is forcing Ixrael to supply electricity, healthcare... Ixrael is just being so nice and generous but those Palextinians are so ungrateful.
@riffrite333
@riffrite333 9 месяцев назад
Your Land? I think the dinosaurs may have something to say about that.
@BatyaGilbert-l2g
@BatyaGilbert-l2g 11 месяцев назад
The people who reject Israel, must learn The history
@fact6360
@fact6360 9 месяцев назад
This video really helps put the current situation in perspective
@hamishlittleton8783
@hamishlittleton8783 7 месяцев назад
Yup, exactly; it’s Palestinian land and the zionists are stealing it through the use of terror - simple.
@SL92018
@SL92018 7 месяцев назад
Another one would be to show the attitudes of the so called "settlers" and the military and paramilitaries stationed there who opress the Palestinians.....
@fact6360
@fact6360 7 месяцев назад
@@SL92018 thats not in Gaza tho - thats the west bank
@SL92018
@SL92018 7 месяцев назад
@@fact6360 I know it is. You can see the names of the cities in the video. I think what you were trying to say is Israel can only commit oppression against the Palestinians in Gaza and the ones in the West Bank are living an absolutely fantastic life. All the people of Palestine, West Bank and Gaza have had hellish lives filled with daily misery for decades because of Israel. You missed my point.
@fact6360
@fact6360 7 месяцев назад
@@SL92018 no you misinterpreted my comment
@tees4382
@tees4382 8 месяцев назад
The responses always come back to ‘it’s our land’. Hard to have peace when the ordinary citizen shuts down hypothetical peace offerings.
@tia23t
@tia23t 11 месяцев назад
Perfect, now you know, why there is no chance for peace.
@louskywalker9656
@louskywalker9656 9 месяцев назад
If only the rest of the world shared their feelings about sharing the land when they go into other countries.
@josipag2185
@josipag2185 9 месяцев назад
This. Imagine Betlehem had 85% Christians in 1948 that they reduced to 16% and had the nerve to speak about anything! They owned only 3.5% of British Madate Palestine. The Jews, 80% of Israel was non Arab land. Just look what those muslims did to Christians in Lebanon. There is no peace with them.
@sal-the-man
@sal-the-man 9 месяцев назад
@@josipag2185why do you love to lie? This is such an absurd lie that I can’t even react. 💀
@josipag2185
@josipag2185 9 месяцев назад
@@sal-the-man I don't lie. Everything is correct. You might don't like it, but Israel bought from the Sursocks, lebanese Greek Orthodox family- Haifa bay and Jezreel valley, because most of the Palestine was Lebanon and Jordan was Syria and Jeruzalem was sanjak under the Ottomans. So, either way Muslim Arabs (and than UN gave to Israel was desert and Beersheba, a Beduin, not Arabic city) and Beduins weren't friends but enemies rather then fellow muslims, and Ottomans offered the protecion for the Arabs from Beduin raidings, until the Empire went down, so then the Arabs started to move to the cities. Now, Jerusalem late half of the 19 century had 60% of Muslims, and other 40% were Jews and Christians. Now, other land that the Jews bought was Hula valley -swamp and malaria -were again, Arabs didn't live. So, when I say 80% of Israel was never inhabited by Arabs, I say this because it is the truth. Now, whole ownership of the lands under the British invention of Palestine- you see it was under Beirut, and Beirut and Lebanon wasn't Arab Muslim majority- was 16% of the lands owned by rich families of Damascus, Beirut, Bagdad, etc, and less then 4% by "Palestinians" while the Jews got 8-9%. The biggest part, 70% - so the rest, the Brits holded for themselves. Now, this data you can find as in my previous comment in every census, as I for sure am not the one who is lying here. You are! But sure, you don't as you can't "debunk" anythung, because I am not lying. You are just afraid that people would actually read the truth and data I am showing, and got the things as they are, and it wasn't never majority Arab Muslim region. This is the fact. And now with Israel there, it won't ever be. And I am pro Israel because nobody cared for the Christians and the Jews that are really genocided from every other muslim country. O, dear and one more thing. More then 600,000 Jews get to Israel from - not Europe but neighbouring countries, that kicked them and genocided them like Iraq, Yemen, Egypt,.. but they are productive, working people that 1.don't start wars, 2.don't cry that they are refugees, 3. don't even dispute over the their lands back, becuse guess what, they left. So they are realistic.
@sal-the-man
@sal-the-man 9 месяцев назад
@@josipag2185 listen bro, I know the truth. And it’s that Palestinians were the indigenous people of the land and comprised of different faiths while the Israelis are just European colonizers. Don’t believe me? Then why did the founders of Israel decide to go to different countries instead of Palestine. If it was indeed that they were “returning” to their land, then that would have been the first thought. Also how come many Jews are against Israel as well. Also Jews being genocided from Arab countries doesn’t have to do with colonizers taking Palestinian land. Those were post colonial movements that had nothing to do with religion. Also This ain’t a religious war it’s a geopolitical. The Palestinians were the people who their land was taken from. And Palestinians of all faiths are trying to fight back against it.
@sal-the-man
@sal-the-man 9 месяцев назад
@@josipag2185 and yo wrote all of this to just lie. I can’t pick every detail but this is such a bad excuse for colonization. And ridiculing the Palestinian people. You have no shame.
@seanduncan9722
@seanduncan9722 9 месяцев назад
The next question to really make these people who won't share the land think is to ask: "Why is it your land?"
@BRockIITWi
@BRockIITWi 9 месяцев назад
​@KevinTambling Considering they were squatting on the land and didn't pay for it, and were not historically the original people from the land, you have little to no argument. How do you feel about America stopping illegal immigrants from coming? Are you consistent?
@TheEarningsGuy
@TheEarningsGuy 9 месяцев назад
Because Israel was founded in 1948 and the vast majority of the population was Arabic Palestinians. Your country literally didn’t exist until 1948 you idiots.
@TheEarningsGuy
@TheEarningsGuy 9 месяцев назад
And we had a Palestinian state and the few Jews there lived in peace until you stole our land and murdered everyone.
@bluebellcrushedvelvet
@bluebellcrushedvelvet 9 месяцев назад
​@@TheEarningsGuytry again. But try even HARDER this time. Before you even OPEN YOUR FKING MOUTH just go and look at the facts!! The history!! Not ONCE!! Nor EVER was there EVER a palastenian state Kingdom or territory!! None!! There were Arab population sure but you guys NEVER had a real claim to the land!! You belong to Syria, Jordan or Egypt really!! Muslims who've migrated from those lands into other religions of judea and kingdom of Israel!! Look at the 12 tribes if judea! The native Jewish people ALWAYS lived in this area, and there are enormous archaeological and historical facts supporting this!!! In scrolls from Egypt to Mesopotamia! Judea and Israel always existed!! Nobody forces you to stay in the land!! Go to jordan where there are like minded hateful antisemites!! You'll be happy there!!
@bluebellcrushedvelvet
@bluebellcrushedvelvet 9 месяцев назад
​​@@TheEarningsGuy oh and one more thing, palastine was never a thing!! Never a thing even until the Roman's massacred and pushed Jewish people out or Israel, and to add insult to injury (literally) they decided to call the land philistine!! Which came from the name of "Plishtim" פלישתים, enemy of the Jewish, which another fan fact, were NEVER arabs!!! They were *GREEK* you ret@r.ded imbacil! So Roman's called the area philistine... the ottoman empire, borrowed it, then the British mandate also borrowed it and only NOW you wonna claim that people belonged here?? Nope boi, it doesn't work this way!! You NEVER HAD A REAL CLAIM FOR THE LAND!!! you may share it - PEACEFULLY, AND BY FORCE IF YOU DON'T ACCEPT THE TERMS - but you never have any real claim to the land!! Gull stop kapish!!! Nada! ZILTCH!
@thameralobaidi1135
@thameralobaidi1135 9 месяцев назад
It’s Jewish land, not Palestinian. God bless Israel.
@mrobserver474
@mrobserver474 2 года назад
"It's our land we invaded it in the 7th century if we hadn't stolen it, someone else would" ABDUL 7th century Islamic invading marauder
@tamaralexander9379
@tamaralexander9379 2 года назад
Good one.
@tamaralexander9379
@tamaralexander9379 2 года назад
@Abdulaziz Mohammed Jacob was the father of the 12 Jewish tribes the father of the Jewish people. His name was also Israel and thats where the name Israel originated from. Even if u stole him and made him a muslim just like u steal everything else. There were never Palestinian people there was never an arab country called Palestine.
@farissharara5169
@farissharara5169 2 года назад
@@tamaralexander9379 palestine was present alongside ancient egypt before moses pbuh was born and before arabs even got out of arabia
@tamaralexander9379
@tamaralexander9379 2 года назад
@@farissharara5169 There was no Palestine . Cannan wasn't Palestine. It was Cannan. Allways stealing other people prophets and lands.
@BenDov
@BenDov 2 года назад
Let me sum up the point as an Israeli, I would be very happy for cooperation between Israelis and Palestinians, I have no problem meeting such a person if he does not want to kill me and my people. I respect every person - you need to understand that Israelis are afraid from the Palestinians because they are really anxious about their security, and the security to the people they love. An absolute majority in Israel would have agreed to such a peace agreement if he had believed that the Palestinians were indeed coming with real intent to peace.
@drunkbee880
@drunkbee880 2 года назад
When you raise a flag which says “ the land between Euphrates and Neil rivers is Jewish land , “ talking about peace is like Louis and Clark shaking he Indian hands as they mapped the land . Middle East is an ancient region and they have seen and heard it all. They are not some naked Indians on horses to get fooled with a thanksgiving dinner.
@toasted_donut2308
@toasted_donut2308 2 года назад
The majority of Israeli's are willing to return the houses and natural resources to their original owners, grant Palestine complete autonomy, return the settlements all over the West bank, leave Al-Aqsa and the the dome of rock, abolish Jew only roads and checkpoints, stop disproportionate policing and discriminatory laws of Palestinians while convicting abusive IDF police and soldiers? And then after all that give them half the land including East Jerusalem or at least equal sovereignty? An absolute majority would agree to that?
@The30115
@The30115 2 года назад
The majority of Israelis are there as a result of ethnically cleansing Palestinians. Why do you expect Palestinians would agree to this question?
@dogbert52
@dogbert52 2 года назад
@@drunkbee880 the flag actually means between the amazon river and missisipi. Adolf or achmet?
@drunkbee880
@drunkbee880 2 года назад
@@dogbert52 // Bro, the concept of “ who me?” Was good in the 15th century where it would take 9 months to send a letter. We are living in a digital age where everything is recorded and you can send the library of Congress across the planet in 5 seconds. Today if you say “ who me?” People will put 500 pages of proof in front of you and say “ yeah you.”
@patriotsforisrael3610
@patriotsforisrael3610 2 года назад
Arabs are from Arabia. Jews are from Judea. Remind me again *who* the occupier is? 🤔
@alireact1827
@alireact1827 2 года назад
No thats wrong. The original Jews were arabs. They used to live medina in Saudi Arabia, the used to live Syria, Lebanon and palastine. They were all original arabs but follow Jews scriptures. The in 1918 were seen zinost people claiming to be Jews. Where were browns and Blacks a few who were lighter. But this people now saying we are Jews and don't have any knowledge of Torah is sad
@shanihodia5573
@shanihodia5573 2 года назад
@@alireact1827 not true the orignal jew are from jacob like us jews yoy islamnazim from ishmaHELL
@shanihodia5573
@shanihodia5573 2 года назад
@@alireact1827 NOT JEWS WERE WHITE SKIN AND LIGHT BROWN
@shanihodia5573
@shanihodia5573 2 года назад
@@alireact1827 WE KNOW THE TANACH BETTER THAN YOU ISLAMNAZI WE JEW KNOW allah is satan smal
@shanihodia5573
@shanihodia5573 2 года назад
@@alireact1827 lol they share the land of us jews with us "willing "that is an a JOKE qoution really we jews have this land 3500 yesrs israel judah kingdom before even islamnazim being exsit
@040jonas5
@040jonas5 8 месяцев назад
This video shows why there is no peace
@pilgrimwings1295
@pilgrimwings1295 9 месяцев назад
A lot of these people's responses about it being their land raises the question as to why they don't, or didn't, develop and care for it like the Israelis did. Too bad that they cannot see befriending Israel would actually improve their living standards.
@brittongodman7769
@brittongodman7769 9 месяцев назад
Far too concerned with taking the hundreds of billions they have received over the decades and using most of it to wage an insane war and kill innocent people. Just think of all the great things these Heathens could have done in Gaza since 2007. It boggles my mind how ignorant, arrogant, and consumed with hate they are. Nothing good will ever come from the ''Religion of Peace'' until there is a terrible and great Reformation of Islam. By that, I mean it will be a violent upheaval.
@getanala6594
@getanala6594 9 месяцев назад
imo that's not a legitimate argument. One person may value more development, another may value more natural and rural landscape. One isn't better than the other, and each people should be allowed to choose whichever they prefer. Clearly, they valued the natural beauty and state of the land over covering it with factories and malls. The point isn't "whoever develops this land the most gets it" because that sets an incredibly horrifying and dangerous precedent. The Palestinians should be able to have their land, and the Israelis should be able to have their land, neither side should be attacking the other and both sides should live in peace with each other and accept that the other side also has a right to their part.
@notyourtypicalcomment2399
@notyourtypicalcomment2399 2 года назад
They prefer war vs sharing? amazing, u can’t even enjoy the land when there’s war
@ajvorob9117
@ajvorob9117 2 года назад
Many of them are descended from Arab economic migrants so a lot of them aren't even indigenous to the land to begin with.
@naceraher9632
@naceraher9632 Год назад
who kills kills who? be fair
Далее
Noam Chomsky - Why Does the U.S. Support Israel?
7:41
Women’s Free Kicks + Men’s 😳🚀
00:20
Просмотров 3 млн
КОТЯТА НАУЧИЛИСЬ ГОВОРИТЬ#cat
00:13
这位大哥以后恐怕都不敢再插队了吧…
00:16
Jewish Settlers: Why do you steal Palestinian land?
13:32
Douglas Murray: A Time of War
1:05:45
Просмотров 463 тыс.
Whose Land Is It? Jewish Claims Explained
14:01
Просмотров 505 тыс.
The One Video Israel REALLY Doesn't Want You To See
16:02
Women’s Free Kicks + Men’s 😳🚀
00:20
Просмотров 3 млн