Тёмный

Pannun Plot has Hallmark of Indian State Sanction, US Intel Agencies say RAW Chief Fully in Picture 

The Wire
Подписаться 5 млн
Просмотров 71 тыс.
50% 1

Alleged attempted Pannun assassination has "hallmark of Indian state sanction"; "US intelligence agencies" believe RAW Chief was "fully in the picture" but less confident about India's NSA: Gerry Shih, Bureau Chief, Washington Post
...........................................
In an interview to discuss Monday’s lengthy story in the Washington Post, which he was one of the authors of, which reveals details of the alleged attempted assassination of one of the leaders of the Khalistan movement, Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, whom India considers a terrorist, and which is alleged to be a result of a plot hatched in India, the Chief of Bureau of the Washington Post has said that it has “the hallmark of Indian state sanction”. The Post says: “U.S. intelligence agencies have assessed that the operation targeting Pannun was approved by the RAW chief at the time, Samant Goel”. However, Gerry Shih reveals that American agencies are less confident of any role played by India’s NSA, Ajit Doval, in the alleged attempted Pannun assassination. His article says: “CIA analysts have assessed that Doval probably knew of or approved RAW’s plans to kill Sikhs his government considered terrorists” but carefully adds there is no smoking gun and he adds US agencies are less confident about Ajit Doval’s role than they are about Samant Goel’s.
This raises the question what if anything did the Prime Minister know? Gerry Shih in his article says: “US and Western security officials said it’s unlikely that RAW would have launched such operations without a clear understanding that doing so would be met with approval by the prime minister.”
Gerry Shih made clear that the United States is not the only country that has expressed concern about RAW. His article reveals that Australia, Germany and Britain have had “clashes” between RAW and domestic security services and “RAW officers and agents have faced arrest, expulsion and reprimand” in these countries. In 2014-15, when Samant Goel was RAW Station Chief in London, “Britain’s domestic secret services delivered warnings to Goel” on many occasions. Gerry Shih believes they even considered expelling him but, in the end, did not do so.
Gerry Shih’s article reveals that “A US delegation that travelled to New Delhi several weeks ago for an update on the probe (into the Pannun matter) … returned with little evidence of meaningful progress”. He says the US is frustrated even dissatisfied with the rate of progress made by the Indian side in its investigation.
Gerry Shih refutes Randhir Jaiswal the official spokesman’s claim that the Washington Post story is “unwarranted and unsubstantiated imputations”. He also refutes that its “irresponsible”. He says The Post had given the Indian government sufficient and ample opportunity to respond to their story and would have carried their response had it been made available to them before publishing.
I am only giving you the main broad points made by Gerry Shih. The most important thing about this interview is that he explains the details and revelations carried by the Washington Post on the 29th of April when its story was published. This is your opportunity to find out what that major story said. He also discusses in great detail the alleged role of Samant Goel, then RAW Chief, and Ajit Doval, National Security Advisor, and what US and Western officials believe is the truth about Prime Minister Modi’s knowledge of this affair.
Join The Wire's RU-vid Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews

Опубликовано:

 

30 апр 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 654   
@mapuna5007
@mapuna5007 26 дней назад
Why should india not protect its interest? Which nation isn't doing so?
@user-rc8br5sw6j
@user-rc8br5sw6j 26 дней назад
And if that is what we are doing then let's say so and publish and be damned
@greenhoodedvigilante458
@greenhoodedvigilante458 24 дня назад
Because it's in land of another sovereign country. US is not India's land.
@asmirann3636
@asmirann3636 24 дня назад
​@@greenhoodedvigilante458 US is actually Indian land. It's natives are called Red Indians or Indians in short. Though these Indians are different from East Indians. Anyway, these kinds of things are done by many countries including US. Recently Israel killed some Iranian general in Syria. Some time back US killed another Iranian in Iraq. So these operations happen far more often.
@SakthiG-wo2gj
@SakthiG-wo2gj 23 дня назад
@@user-rc8br5sw6j Why should we need to say so ? Is every country saying so especially the west?
@SakthiG-wo2gj
@SakthiG-wo2gj 23 дня назад
​@@greenhoodedvigilante458Does US respect other countries ' sovereignty 😂
@Hypocritial
@Hypocritial 27 дней назад
NYT, Washington Post, BBC, Guardian and CNN are the last hope for The Wire
@TheLargeoldshoe
@TheLargeoldshoe 28 дней назад
if this was a RAW operation then god help india. Even bollywood can craft better script than this. It is claimed that Samant Goel is the planner of Balakot operation & is a very good friend of NSA Ajit Doval
@Naked_Sports200
@Naked_Sports200 27 дней назад
Yes so Now we can talk about pulwama openly.
@rishabhkumardwivedi
@rishabhkumardwivedi 26 дней назад
Balakot was so botched that it's better to not talk about it.
@parnamsaini4751
@parnamsaini4751 24 дня назад
Still raw...you mean?
@hj2711
@hj2711 22 дня назад
@@rishabhkumardwivedinope talk about Mumbai attack. All hail Congress.
@shreeshatokur4574
@shreeshatokur4574 28 дней назад
I cannot believe that so many persons commenting here actually support khalistani groups and people like Pannun....those very same people who brought our national flag down and disrepected our flag and our sovereignty in ways we could scarcely believe...
@pankaj5080
@pankaj5080 28 дней назад
This interview is a master piece to learn how to talk and put forward your points during a conversation and how to have a clear head
@agnescraig2912
@agnescraig2912 28 дней назад
Spot on. None of this shouting and whataboutery.
@user-co2lw5vb4q
@user-co2lw5vb4q 27 дней назад
​​@@agnescraig2912Really? This interview is full of anti india agenda and appeasement of the western masters Using western terms like 'Sikh activist' for officially designated terrorist by India
@govinchittaranjan9567
@govinchittaranjan9567 21 день назад
Karan Thappar has never disappointed me, carefully crafted queries and well presented
@PrateekBehera
@PrateekBehera 28 дней назад
Amazing work by Indian Agencies. Didn't know of so much capability. It's good for the future.
@rajeev7898
@rajeev7898 28 дней назад
If this Government can do this overseas; it can do this inland as well.
@pankaj5080
@pankaj5080 28 дней назад
haren pandya says hi
@janami-dharmam
@janami-dharmam 28 дней назад
I guess that they must have done around 1000 in the last ten years. BJP, RSS, Bajrang, Hindu gangs etc do not believe in the rule of law.
@Manish_Kumar_Singh
@Manish_Kumar_Singh 28 дней назад
good
@liberalManifesto68
@liberalManifesto68 28 дней назад
@@pankaj5080 lodha,
@budsurtees4224
@budsurtees4224 28 дней назад
And it does. And has. And keeps doing.
@dchakraborty4901
@dchakraborty4901 28 дней назад
Waiting for Thapar to interview the Chinese authorities next to prove that border problems were caused by India alone.
@subhrajitgupta5535
@subhrajitgupta5535 28 дней назад
Whataboutery rejected!!
@alendersng1466
@alendersng1466 28 дней назад
Apparently bhakts thinks questioning is crime/anti national. That's why Godi media loves to lick their master's boots instead of questioning. And bhakts love them
@dravidian667
@dravidian667 28 дней назад
Water water give me water
@npsbrar560
@npsbrar560 28 дней назад
They r discussing the report.
@mjwarror3372
@mjwarror3372 28 дней назад
Aa gaya dalal​@@subhrajitgupta5535
@PrateekBehera
@PrateekBehera 28 дней назад
LoL.. Foreign Media is trying hard for 400 paar this time 😂
@Ldtsmx84
@Ldtsmx84 27 дней назад
Not happening!! Vaccineji says Hi!!
@Naked_Sports200
@Naked_Sports200 27 дней назад
Like they Used their resources to create a university which might fail as planned in future ❤
@Ldtsmx84
@Ldtsmx84 26 дней назад
Vaxin killer is expecting 400 paar🤣🤣
@Rupeshsinghyadav.
@Rupeshsinghyadav. 23 дня назад
Behra tu bhera hi rhega 😂😂
@michealanderson2282
@michealanderson2282 24 дня назад
Host in the interview 'touches his nose'-multiple times- telltale body language sign indicating he is 'lying'. Also is their a chinese angle in this?
@theepank6620
@theepank6620 27 дней назад
Sri Lankan former President Maithripala Sirisena has formally lodged a complaint regarding Indian RAW's involvement in the Easter attacks in Sri Lanka.
@SUNNYDAY-if8yo
@SUNNYDAY-if8yo 24 дня назад
😂😂😂😂
@DonzaiNoHana
@DonzaiNoHana 18 дней назад
Lol he complained against influencing elections. Easter attacks were done by Muslims.
@rohiticku
@rohiticku 28 дней назад
I wish Mr. Thapar had probed Mr. Shih about certain ludicrous claims in the WaPO article. 1) The article refers to eleven Kashmiri and Sikh "separatists" being neutralized in Pakistan in the past two years (two days ago the article had referred to these individuals as "activists", at least the writers have updated the designation). These separatists include Zahid Akhund, who was involved in the Air India hijacking. Shahid Latif, the commander of Jaish e Mohammad. Riyaz Ahmad, a top Lashkar commander. These are not benign souls who were conducting pro-democracy activism in India, these men were responsible for killing Indian citizens, yet had continued to operate with impunity in Pakistan. 2) Even more ludicrous, the article claims that Indian intelligence is increasingly harassing groups abroad that are "perceived as disloyal to the Modi govt". Seriously? The groups that parade the assassination of Indira Gandhi through the streets of Brampton are disloyal to the Modi govt.? Groups like SJF, which wants to carve an independent state of Khalistan out of India, and whose designation as a terror group in 2019 was welcomed by then Congress Chief Minister of Punjab, are being targeted for their opposition to Modi govt.?
@internationalwatchinglion5352
@internationalwatchinglion5352 28 дней назад
Not only Modi...India has been exposed worldwide how it operates among the International Community..it's only the tip of the iceberg..The Hijacked Indian Airlines and killing innocent Indian to throw suspicions of a heinous plan at Khandar followed by the 911 attacks and Bin Laden with Al Qaeda rising was not a gradual natural phenomenon which flared to be Global Terrorism...😱
@ASeeker-9999
@ASeeker-9999 28 дней назад
Sadly, some in the left ecosystem have gone so far in their hate for Modi that they seem to cross the line that makes it harmful for the nation!
@yilts9748
@yilts9748 28 дней назад
So how exactly is a group being run by US and Canadian citizens a terr0r group? Move courts in Western countries with evidence and get them jailed. Western courts are not run like Indian courts, you can expect justice. India desginated SFJ as a terror group under UAPA, a law so draconian that it has only 5% conviction rate. Interpol has rejected India's applications trying to get them to issue a Red Corner Notice against Pannu. India's designation carries no weight.
@garrys3312
@garrys3312 27 дней назад
We will support Quebec referendum 💪
@ayanghosh7597
@ayanghosh7597 26 дней назад
Madhu Trehan had questioned Karan Thapar point blank in an interview if he has handlers in Pakistan because he aggressively lobbies the Pakistani agenda from Islamabad's point of view.
@dostondoc23
@dostondoc23 28 дней назад
Thank you. Very bold, incisive, and informative!
@ravicharan2893
@ravicharan2893 28 дней назад
India's national interest and security is India's business and if nations are requested to take action against terrorists than they should do so instead of harboring and financing them. KT and the guest were not demonstrating much confidence in their speech delivery which raises questions about their facts
@greenhoodedvigilante458
@greenhoodedvigilante458 24 дня назад
They can keep their business inside their own border. USA is a sovereign nation and it has all the right to protect itself from foreign agencies who are committing murder in US land.
@hj2711
@hj2711 22 дня назад
@@greenhoodedvigilante458lmao did you forget what happened in Middle East war?
@yassiguy
@yassiguy 28 дней назад
Well it's moot point. In international real politik, there is no such thing as ethics. Every major power is complicit in such activities. So even if the accusation is true, it's like the kettle calling the pot black !
@dip-tree
@dip-tree 28 дней назад
But it still should be a good thing to expose these activities, whenever they show their real ugly heads and state level connections.
@DaveShree
@DaveShree 28 дней назад
This is not question of ethics but crime.
@cryogenic3766
@cryogenic3766 28 дней назад
Well its not the act that is questionable , but the denial from India is ridiculous.. These days even terrorist organizations claim responsibility. This shows that the current government is cowardice to accept it , it also shows the lack of India's expertise to conduct such operations And finally it shows the pathetic nature of eliminating fringe elements than the prioritized ones like mazood azar, dawood ibrahim. And Flimsy politcal divertion tactics towards Justin Trudeau. Overall it shows the end-to-end incompetence of India be it politics, diplomacy, espionage, will to accept failures.
@dchakraborty4901
@dchakraborty4901 28 дней назад
Are you guys uneducated or thorough hypocrites to be unaware that targeted assassination is pursued by intelligence agencies everywhere. KGB used to protect Cuban President on all assassination attempts by CIA. In recent past an Iranian general and a Taliban senior leader were killed in targeted assassinations- both by CIA.
@prachetaspatel2930
@prachetaspatel2930 28 дней назад
You're correct, but it is very clear where India is in the international military and intelligence activities, usually governments work together. India did it on its own. Even US (through bribery or their own puppets, or through official channels) are able to build military outposts and work with local govts to do their thing. India did it on its own. Indicating India is a rogue nation and should be seen as a threat. - this is okay if that is the intent, but the consequences might be heavy.
@anmolkhanuja2191
@anmolkhanuja2191 26 дней назад
Government fighting against khalistan and want hindurastra 😂😂😂 such a good demooooooooocracy
@JaspalSingh-hb8em
@JaspalSingh-hb8em 28 дней назад
Congratulations Karan for your so intriguing interview to open the Truth
@rajugoborvas8964
@rajugoborvas8964 26 дней назад
Us botches never get revealed
@rajugoborvas8964
@rajugoborvas8964 26 дней назад
This guys are us cats
@rajugoborvas8964
@rajugoborvas8964 26 дней назад
Fake guys
@rajugoborvas8964
@rajugoborvas8964 26 дней назад
Kalistani was Congres creationss
@thomashunter5645
@thomashunter5645 28 дней назад
It is fun to watch Mr. Thapar is trying to put words in the guest's mouth and the guest refusing to go along with it. 😂😂😂
@authentic_101
@authentic_101 28 дней назад
That's called grilling, kiddo!
@TheNayak12
@TheNayak12 28 дней назад
American will ask for 40 billon arms deal. There is only one interest called American interest.
@neerajsinghbhar966
@neerajsinghbhar966 28 дней назад
Now some kind of defence deal will take place on much higher price,
@AjayKumar-re2zp
@AjayKumar-re2zp 28 дней назад
Are you predicting BJP win.😅
@pynkhrawmarwein3109
@pynkhrawmarwein3109 28 дней назад
​​@@AjayKumar-re2zp it's not relevant which political party comes to power , but the Americans will use this issue to full leverage. Defence deal might be one of them.
@user-ie9sp6hi6q
@user-ie9sp6hi6q 28 дней назад
Or maybe the DOD refuses to commit to the Technology transfer that MOD will acquire.
@janami-dharmam
@janami-dharmam 28 дней назад
and part of it will come back to some of the friends
@thebestevertherewas
@thebestevertherewas 27 дней назад
@@AjayKumar-re2zp BJP is coming back. They like it or not
@cheranjeevijayam8163
@cheranjeevijayam8163 27 дней назад
Criminal intent here...
@kasturiswami784
@kasturiswami784 28 дней назад
The american govt do not like modis aggressiveness,but given the indian markey bonanza dresms ,they have to keep quiet. Shows how money is everything. That the gujju knows very well!
@riverocean4380
@riverocean4380 28 дней назад
Which money? U$ = 44 when MMS was Pm. U$ = 83 . If you invest 1 billion U$ while MMS was PM, vs Modi - How much money would you lose when you repatriate the money back home?
@Hussainesque
@Hussainesque 28 дней назад
You will do yourself a world of good by coming out of those wet dreams. Sanghi delusions apart, U. S. looks down upon India as just another third world country, which it is. Now on these botched up operations. When an intelligence agency is caught several times doing its stuff on foreign soil, it indicates incompetence and limited reach.
@Hussainesque
@Hussainesque 28 дней назад
You'll do yourself a world of good by coming out of these wet dreams. Sanghi delusions apert, the U.S. looks down upon India as any other third world country, which it is, and knows pretty well how to tame it, which it does from time to time. Now about the series of botched up operations. When an intelligence is repeatedly caught doing its stuff on foreign soil, it indicates incompetence and limited reach. But you can live in your make-believe world why Fekuji is Vishwa Guru.
@avinashkamal5857
@avinashkamal5857 28 дней назад
​@@riverocean4380"Gujju knows it very well " 👹👻
@authentic_101
@authentic_101 28 дней назад
It's not about money first. It's about the China-Russia dictatorial axis primarily! TBH, at their leve, the quantities / levels of money they deal with, Money leads to Power, and Power means Survival of their Countries in the wake of China-Russia axis!
@paoisaacleo882
@paoisaacleo882 26 дней назад
I'm quite curious to know about Gerry. Is he an Indian?
@MH-ro3ww
@MH-ro3ww 24 дня назад
Asian American
@subhrajitgupta5535
@subhrajitgupta5535 28 дней назад
Truth cannot be obfuscated by Nationalism. People have rights. Violation of rights is a crime. Nothing is beyond question. Brilliant interview by Karan. People of India deserve to know!!
@user-ie9sp6hi6q
@user-ie9sp6hi6q 28 дней назад
Exactly! Very bold indeed. #Abkibaar400paar
@garrys3312
@garrys3312 28 дней назад
Sikh Genocide 1984, no justice, Kamal Nath, Jagdish still enjoy indian parliament memberships. BJP or Congress, shame on you. Also, shame on Indians for voting Rajiv Ghandi with record votes after Sikhs were k!lled in thousands.
@jaybeta55
@jaybeta55 28 дней назад
Yes people of have rights. Find what USA would do if India harbors an anti US agent. US has killed people for a far lesser crime.
@dravidian667
@dravidian667 28 дней назад
@@garrys3312why didn’t you put I’m not a bjp supporter
@garrys3312
@garrys3312 28 дней назад
@@dravidian667 what ?
@cheranjeevijayam8163
@cheranjeevijayam8163 27 дней назад
It is going to be PROUD moment for MODI Government....
@kasturiswami784
@kasturiswami784 28 дней назад
Dotforget,in the end india is a big market and so they will dance around this. Its called hypocrisy.
@rajeev7898
@rajeev7898 28 дней назад
India is a big market with very low purchasing power of its consumers.
@dchakraborty4901
@dchakraborty4901 28 дней назад
Do you guys hate your own country because you hate Modi and his government?
@dravidian667
@dravidian667 28 дней назад
They can start favouring states that are not with bjp
@rigeshyogi
@rigeshyogi 28 дней назад
More than that, the China equation.
@urrasscal8380
@urrasscal8380 27 дней назад
@@rajeev7898 yeap this is what happen what u foundation is base around llibrandu ssocialism no priority in wealth creation.
@fsckool6894
@fsckool6894 28 дней назад
Mother of democracy or rogue state?
@RonTheDon-30
@RonTheDon-30 28 дней назад
You mean the US ?
@urrasscal8380
@urrasscal8380 27 дней назад
u can be be both . .
@shielaroberts
@shielaroberts 23 дня назад
Why did not Karan ask how come this is different from USA act on Osama or on Sadam? If US law framework is so sacrosanct then what they did to others, they should be ready to accept when they harbour a terrorist.
@govinchittaranjan9567
@govinchittaranjan9567 21 день назад
US only went after terrorists who openly claimed responsibility for their actions and took pride in it
@Presidency23
@Presidency23 28 дней назад
you can try your level best to insult our PM and our country, but each time you have tried such mischief, it has misfired badly.. u know fence should not eat the crop
@eudee21
@eudee21 28 дней назад
Mr Thapar excellent interview. Almost like the HARDTALK I used to enjoy . You are doing a great job as a totally unbiased journalist .
@sureshgopalakrishnan9732
@sureshgopalakrishnan9732 28 дней назад
What a joke thapar unbiased??? 😄😄😄
@goldenpencil6398
@goldenpencil6398 28 дней назад
Unbiased? He's a Congress stooge and a Communist pawn. Every Indian knows about it. Now, on the payrolls of foreign intelligence agencies.
@siddharthadas8112
@siddharthadas8112 27 дней назад
Thapar is biased against India but unbiased against the west! 😊
@universalphilosophy8081
@universalphilosophy8081 28 дней назад
Can there be a nation at all, if it cannot protect itself from divisive forces acting against it from another country? What would America do if an Indian citizen works against America and continue to be protected by Indian govt.? That has been happening with Pakistan for years and that was perpetual trouble to India and terrorism.
@zaffazad4040
@zaffazad4040 28 дней назад
Mr. Thapar, I enjoyed your interview. Thank you for doing a great job as a journalist. Mr. Shih is a seasoned, well-trained, and articulate journalist who knows his job well. It seems that India's present government and Mr Modi's incompetence will negatively impact the best interests of the Indian people for the foreseeable future. One thing is sure: the Indian democracy as an institution is not heading in the right direction; it is becoming a sham democracy under the current Modi regime, and the US foreign policy's double standards have also exposed the weakness of policymakers and the hypocrisy that would cost the American people dearly in the coming election. Its results would be a good test for both parties in the US. What the R&AW is doing in friendly countries like the US and the UK has exposed its incompetence, arrogance and gross misunderstanding of the functioning of important capitals of the world. Authorizing at the highest level killings of foreign nationals in their home countries, executing those plans and then federal ministers, like Mr. Rajnath Singh and the Indian Prime Minister, Mr. Modi, taking credit for such criminal acts will haunt India for some time. The MEA, Mr Jaishankar, and NSA, Mr Ajit Doval, must immediately be sacked for damaging their national interest by being part of such criminal acts outside India that have hurt and would hurt further Indian interests. These officials' criminal negligence has embarrassed the people of India and has put severe questions on the integrity of Indian institutions, its democracy and the people's ability to have respect internationally. The Indian voters must remember who the best person or party is to represent them globally and make policies that serve their best interests.
@Naman_2309
@Naman_2309 28 дней назад
this coming from a pakistani?
@pynkhrawmarwein3109
@pynkhrawmarwein3109 28 дней назад
@@Naman_2309 Pakistani or not this person is right. If this story is true then it'll be very bad for Indian in the country and abroad. If the government of India can kill a foreigner in his home country then that breaks all norms of freedom that that particular country has. In turn it will be the duty of those government to retaliate and this will negatively impact India's relationship with any country.
@anuradhasubramanyan8786
@anuradhasubramanyan8786 28 дней назад
😊​@@Naman_2309
@user-og5pd1bf6s
@user-og5pd1bf6s 28 дней назад
Very true
@yagnamurthysaisaran4596
@yagnamurthysaisaran4596 28 дней назад
Would you accuse the US of criminal negligence for the highest level killing of Osama Bin Laden? The death of a terrorist isn't something anyone should be concerned about in the first place and a mere accusation of an attempt to kill a terrorist during the election time speaks of the growing insecurity in the US regarding India's growth. All the very reason to vote for Modi's BJP.
@playandwatch3129
@playandwatch3129 27 дней назад
R&AW shoud focus on the training of their agents.....getting caught such red handed is so embarrassing 😂😂
@matthewjoseph7671
@matthewjoseph7671 26 дней назад
True and Thats Why Our Doval Ji is in talks with MOSSAD
@kuldeepkaur-uw8tn
@kuldeepkaur-uw8tn 6 дней назад
If I want sovereignty it is my right but if other want it is a crime . it is the real face of Indian democracy
@tilaksarkar5654
@tilaksarkar5654 27 дней назад
All external security agencies work like this. Whats the big issue ? Americans and the British and the French do this all over the world and terminate 'designated terrorists'. Why the double standard ?
@myounus11
@myounus11 26 дней назад
India is not Britain or Frenace yet.
@ranger5705
@ranger5705 24 дня назад
They take the responsibility for their actions unlike Indian government who is hiding it's cowardness by denying it's involvement.
@asmirann3636
@asmirann3636 24 дня назад
​@@ranger5705Nobody takes responsibility for such kinds of operations. Stop watching Hollywood propaganda.
@butan9019
@butan9019 23 дня назад
Bhai Woh loog ase pakde Jake desh ki embarrassment nhi kerwata
@hj2711
@hj2711 22 дня назад
@@ranger5705lmao stop kidding yourself. Give me examples?
@kshitijghildiyal1537
@kshitijghildiyal1537 26 дней назад
Bhai ye Goel saab ko koi award do! Baaki bakchodi inki chalti rahegi.... lekin ye Goel sir toh desh ke sakht bhakt hain!
@Tirah5
@Tirah5 28 дней назад
Modi govt thought its important either way after this new found wealth by India. US is discipling India, telling them that India is only essential because China exists and not otherwise.
@ASeeker-9999
@ASeeker-9999 28 дней назад
That is geopolitics! China was only important because it was neighbours with Russia!!
@suvrajyotigupta2368
@suvrajyotigupta2368 28 дней назад
US is important to us , because of China !
@Godfavourite01
@Godfavourite01 28 дней назад
​@@ASeeker-9999US supported Pakistan not us in the past..hope u remember 😂
@ASeeker-9999
@ASeeker-9999 28 дней назад
@@Godfavourite01 True! Because they needed Pakistan to get access to Afghanistan. Russia was trying to get access to Afghanistan and US was keen to stop Russia. Geopolitics is like a chess game. No permanent friends n enemy. Currently they are using India to stop China from growing. In future if India grows big then they will again use Pakistan to stop India from growing. They only care about their own interests!
@SumiOccult
@SumiOccult 28 дней назад
If that is the case that means USA can not take on PRC alone. Great acknowledgement.
@harshittiwari7424
@harshittiwari7424 20 дней назад
The timing of the article is very interesting.... definitely they want to influence indian election.
@mohanshunmugam7399
@mohanshunmugam7399 28 дней назад
Too many assumptions. Even they cannot be sure of what answers to give to your questions
@gnyanray101
@gnyanray101 28 дней назад
Fekuj may now travel to Washington in his 20000 cr Airforce one plane after june 4 to do the defence deal and will hug us president
@parnamsaini4751
@parnamsaini4751 28 дней назад
😂😂😂😂
@dipoboyrogu9366
@dipoboyrogu9366 27 дней назад
gyan de do baba... what should India do
@bornfourthmay
@bornfourthmay 27 дней назад
Yes he will and even in 2029 😊
@SUNNYDAY-if8yo
@SUNNYDAY-if8yo 24 дня назад
Save some tears
@Rupeshsinghyadav.
@Rupeshsinghyadav. 23 дня назад
Pappu
@goldenpencil6398
@goldenpencil6398 28 дней назад
Who funds The Wire?
@JaySharma45353
@JaySharma45353 28 дней назад
I do, what happened?
@paritoshjain62
@paritoshjain62 28 дней назад
The right sort of people.
@kaaboom6996
@kaaboom6996 27 дней назад
Gays😂
@rajugoborvas8964
@rajugoborvas8964 26 дней назад
Both have one American oar
@johnalexander4982
@johnalexander4982 28 дней назад
Interesting.
@ahmedmalek4758
@ahmedmalek4758 26 дней назад
Excellent discussion. Thanks to both Gentlemen
@nagaiahgovindarajalu8110
@nagaiahgovindarajalu8110 28 дней назад
Brave Briliant thank you
@SumiOccult
@SumiOccult 28 дней назад
These Idiots first claimed that he was a rogue R&AW officer. Now they are claiming he was not a rogue officer. And these are the sources Karan is relying on.
@rigeshyogi
@rigeshyogi 28 дней назад
The US government has not refuted the points in the article.
@randhawaz1
@randhawaz1 27 дней назад
It was Indian govt who said bullshit about a rogue officer.
@SumiOccult
@SumiOccult 27 дней назад
@@randhawaz1 Indian Govt kept mum, Sweety. Just check what Jerry is saying. Indian govt did not respond to USA govt then the article was published.
@SumiOccult
@SumiOccult 27 дней назад
@@rigeshyogi USA govt has nothing to do with this article. Unless of course the publication is controlled or influenced by the US govt. So much for the freedom of speech!!
@urrasscal8380
@urrasscal8380 27 дней назад
@@SumiOccult because this present govt. want this news to spread so that people in iindia views them ( present govt) that they r neutralizing countries eenemy in foreign land ...
@karan.kunwar543
@karan.kunwar543 27 дней назад
The wire is a west partner for sure dont understand who are those fools following wire 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@navinkumarsingh3934
@navinkumarsingh3934 28 дней назад
The Americans should be the last one to comment on assination. From the South American and the middle east.Europe is another. Put away the pompous attitude and accept and be silent on the issue.A newspaper writer is making a foolish rant on the issue.National security in India at present,The state of India is under threat.
@dravidian667
@dravidian667 28 дней назад
They are superpower we are third world
@Pep_singh
@Pep_singh 28 дней назад
​@@dravidian667 Might be third world economically, but from the military perspective it is not, given that India possesses WMD, huge military, nuclear triads, ICBMs.
@dravidian667
@dravidian667 28 дней назад
@@Pep_singh in what way? We don’t even have chief of defence. We do not manufacture fighter jets, we still import rafale kind of aircrafts. Most of our equipment are old gen. We have never had massive war and won during modern times. So what makes you claim such things?
@mahendraagarwal219
@mahendraagarwal219 28 дней назад
So what was 1971 and 1999 Kargil War​@@dravidian667
@budsurtees4224
@budsurtees4224 28 дней назад
@@Pep_singh Seriously? India is the world's second biggest arms IMPORTER. It manufactures or makes very little of its own armaments. How is a nation dependent on other nations for its own security to be considered a "first world" country from a "mlitary perspective"? Get your head out of your ass.
@bishnoiamit29
@bishnoiamit29 28 дней назад
Thanks
@Rajasthani710
@Rajasthani710 28 дней назад
mere ko bhi paise de do uncle main garib ghar se huun
@socialdistance4508
@socialdistance4508 28 дней назад
@@Rajasthani710 ok Bhai ye le loo... 💲💯
@baldevmankoo1049
@baldevmankoo1049 28 дней назад
Karan excellent work.
@Vicdhinsa1495
@Vicdhinsa1495 27 дней назад
Shoddy job😂 they got caught with their pants down.😂😂
@urrasscal8380
@urrasscal8380 27 дней назад
now people in iindia will know about this and bjp will get more vote. this sstupid people think that this kind of news make bjp look weak no it is otherwise.
@ShaneCallum
@ShaneCallum 6 дней назад
Job well done Government of India
@diganta171088
@diganta171088 26 дней назад
Isn't a tough interviewer supposed to ask uncomfortable questions to the guest? Couldn't he ask why Khalistanis are designated terrorists? Or why USA accepts these as citizens in the first place? Or why is USA lauded for breaching other county's sovereignty to kill terrorists? Technically USA invaded Pakistan with conventional millitary and killed Osama Bin Laden. I would have been very interested to know these facts. Also, I sense a tone of disappointment when Karan questions why USA hasn't come down heavily on India, I'm interested to know what other viewers think of this?
@sumitraamarnath2435
@sumitraamarnath2435 28 дней назад
Interesting
@gnyanray101
@gnyanray101 28 дней назад
Expose tadipaar and his son and their misdeeds in ipl .
@gnyanray101
@gnyanray101 28 дней назад
Now indian government will do a defence deal at much higher price in the benifit of USA government and a huge loss to indian economy.
@AjayKumar-re2zp
@AjayKumar-re2zp 28 дней назад
Are you 100 % sure that BJP government is returning to power,
@Subh8081
@Subh8081 28 дней назад
@@AjayKumar-re2zp No, but BJP represented GOI. And the US now have a leverage on the GOI.
@reecosmicatomsb8576
@reecosmicatomsb8576 28 дней назад
This Indian govt is not congress, communists, lunatic leftists govt.😂😂😂
@reecosmicatomsb8576
@reecosmicatomsb8576 28 дней назад
​@@AjayKumar-re2zp500%🚩🚩🚩
@JumgeSora
@JumgeSora 28 дней назад
Well well well
@butan9019
@butan9019 23 дня назад
Great interview 👏👏
@kr.manishpratapsinghchauha1837
@kr.manishpratapsinghchauha1837 27 дней назад
The first and the last rule of this business is don't get caught and if, then It's the biggest blunder.
@sangitaagrawal6008
@sangitaagrawal6008 28 дней назад
Mr. Thapar trying to force Mr. Doval’s involvement.
@trulylogicalmind3645
@trulylogicalmind3645 28 дней назад
trying?, nothing happens without doval ok
@urrasscal8380
@urrasscal8380 27 дней назад
@@trulylogicalmind3645 ur making doval more popular do u think iindian people don't like neutralizing iindia's eenemy outside. u guys r real llibrandus.
@trulylogicalmind3645
@trulylogicalmind3645 27 дней назад
@@urrasscal8380 ppopular? ddoval sstanding for eelections?
@urrasscal8380
@urrasscal8380 27 дней назад
@@trulylogicalmind3645 but wire making him more popular which directly helps present govt.
@adamsinghlealadhar6234
@adamsinghlealadhar6234 28 дней назад
I doubt he was a rouge officer
@abedmansur3100
@abedmansur3100 28 дней назад
Lessons need to be learned. Nothing seems like rosy scenario.
@Arihant997
@Arihant997 28 дней назад
Usually Karan looks tired in a late night T shirt ..today since w post came on board to talk.. he decided to get suited booted !!❤
@SumiOccult
@SumiOccult 28 дней назад
Wilayati sahib betha hein samne. Itna toh karana hi padega.
@indroc5500
@indroc5500 28 дней назад
Everything is suggested.
@publicvoice2360
@publicvoice2360 28 дней назад
Who loves Karan’s Interview❤🙋🏻‍♂️🙋🏻‍♀️
@AjayKumar-re2zp
@AjayKumar-re2zp 28 дней назад
.no one,
@Rajasthani710
@Rajasthani710 28 дней назад
only anti-modi people. ha ha
@publicvoice2360
@publicvoice2360 27 дней назад
@@Rajasthani710 Shukr hai Anti-India nahi bola😝🙏
@publicvoice2360
@publicvoice2360 27 дней назад
@@AjayKumar-re2zp I hope aap poora interview dekh kar hi comment daal rahen hain
@dayanarayana7100
@dayanarayana7100 28 дней назад
thanks guys .. i was in doubt to vote modi now i can vote him confidently
@sureshgopalakrishnan9732
@sureshgopalakrishnan9732 28 дней назад
👌👌👌
@sam007sam
@sam007sam 28 дней назад
Yes Go Modi 👍👍
@tomatoketchup1582
@tomatoketchup1582 28 дней назад
Your ₹2 credited. IT cell daily wage labour. 😂
@sam007sam
@sam007sam 28 дней назад
@@tomatoketchup1582 we doing all for you so this RS 2 donation will help you purchase ketchup
@jaihind3595
@jaihind3595 27 дней назад
​@@tomatoketchup1582hi traitor!!!😂😂😂
@vijayantsingh7553
@vijayantsingh7553 28 дней назад
So everyone here is very proud of KARAN...for interviewing fearlessly.... but all of u will be ok if plans of breaking India apart is conceived outside of your country and constantly targeting our people in Punjab... killings ,threats to our embassies....and all of it... Also how shallow is this person who has picked up on our election rhetoric...on a guardian article... and of Pakistani killings...wowowowow and people here are appreciating this shit... what if we were talking and planning a breakup of a western country... They can't even tolerate the protests in their colleges in their own country .... and Mr Karan Thappar... is woking soooo hard to falsely expose India as an hooligan country of some sort or may just this sitting govt... if this govt takes care of Indian's interest and India's safety...and above all the people of India... I'm still not able to get this....what is wrong in doing this.... So Israel can go about killing left right and center... and here they want to question India for something we don't even accept ..wowowo Mr Karan... excellent job... Keep it up... well done...Also this journalist's bio says it all ...Gerry Shih is the India Bureau Chief for the Washington Post, covering India and neighboring countries. He previously served as China correspondent until 2020, when his Chinese journalist visa was revoked. Before joining the Post in 2018, he reported for the Associated Press from Beijing. He has also covered Silicon Valley’s social media companies for Reuters and northern California for The New York Times.
@atanusen1736
@atanusen1736 25 дней назад
While Gerry Shih says that there's no smoking gun for the command chain trail connecting the NSA, it is an open secret that such preposterous adventurism is completely possible to be committed by this gentleman who romanticises himself as a modern-day Chanakya and perhaps wants his name to be written in modern day history books for having executed such comic book style stunts.
@bhavikvaghela1311
@bhavikvaghela1311 19 дней назад
I don't see any embarrassment, that guy is threatening india for a long time. So Mr Modi is doing right if he has any involvement
@kshitijghildiyal1537
@kshitijghildiyal1537 26 дней назад
The bow tie is too much! :)
@harsingh9717
@harsingh9717 28 дней назад
Khalistan Zindabad!!! Sikhs want their sovereignty back!
@sureshgopalakrishnan9732
@sureshgopalakrishnan9732 28 дней назад
Justin trueado is waiting for you. His house is for you. The real sikhs are with us. The nakli sikhs can go to canada
@mjwarror3372
@mjwarror3372 28 дней назад
Pols aa gayi
@sambhavnath6668
@sambhavnath6668 28 дней назад
Thank god finally a face to face interview
@user-ie9sp6hi6q
@user-ie9sp6hi6q 28 дней назад
Please share max this interview. If you want Modi to come back to power. ❤❤❤❤❤ Gerry Shih #Abkibaar400paar
@arshpreetsinghdeol385
@arshpreetsinghdeol385 28 дней назад
2 rupees credited to your account
@dravidian667
@dravidian667 28 дней назад
He will join prajwal reddy in Germany after election
@sureshgopalakrishnan9732
@sureshgopalakrishnan9732 28 дней назад
👌👌👌👌
@wonderworld7721
@wonderworld7721 28 дней назад
@@arshpreetsinghdeol385 : fake news !
@ranjitme9957
@ranjitme9957 28 дней назад
This is a new Hindu India.
@subbaraotanguturu9271
@subbaraotanguturu9271 23 дня назад
If so why they killed Saddam Hossain, Guaddafi and Hussain were killed and countries were destroyed?
@amarjitsaini5425
@amarjitsaini5425 27 дней назад
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh 🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾
@jatindersaini4277
@jatindersaini4277 28 дней назад
Brave journalism. Your guest is unflinching and forthright.
@paoisaacleo882
@paoisaacleo882 26 дней назад
Is Gerry Shih from India?
@vijayantsingh7553
@vijayantsingh7553 28 дней назад
I also wonder what will happen after June elections... will this all stop and what about their jobs and funding... wowowow....I hope they are saving their salary from now on...
@aurangzebansari3007
@aurangzebansari3007 28 дней назад
इस वीडियो का साउंड कम क्यों है?
@imomerenlongkumer6797
@imomerenlongkumer6797 28 дней назад
Raw needs training from mossad.
@Arihant997
@Arihant997 28 дней назад
If you are a patriotic Indian you should ask Mossad to get trained by RAW.. Considering..how these people have beaten all opposition black and blue 💙..
@philipjohnify
@philipjohnify 28 дней назад
Very incisive and revealing.
@amania9254
@amania9254 28 дней назад
Modaniji the Liar, the hypocrite and the dictator.
@karan.kunwar543
@karan.kunwar543 27 дней назад
Intact it's a great job by India❤️❤️❤️❤️Modi ❤❤❤❤
@ronniedeee
@ronniedeee 26 дней назад
This guy is such an embarrassment. Of course there's family legecay to live up to.
@subhrajitgupta5535
@subhrajitgupta5535 28 дней назад
People of India deserve to know the real face of dictator Modi. Kudos to Karan!! Great Journalism!! This is what democracy should be!!
@hemb7163
@hemb7163 28 дней назад
I suppose you have not realized you have called this an example of democracy while calling our leader a dictator. Get better soon
@universalphilosophy8081
@universalphilosophy8081 28 дней назад
People need to know why America and Canada are protecting Khalistan separatists.
@uattestthree6499
@uattestthree6499 28 дней назад
Which side a re you on ? You don't seem concerned at all that the person in question was designated T in India
@subhrajitgupta5535
@subhrajitgupta5535 28 дней назад
@@universalphilosophy8081 They are American citizens. They should be protected by american law. Funny brainwashed propagandist you. Lol
@subhrajitgupta5535
@subhrajitgupta5535 28 дней назад
@@uattestthree6499 Labelling someone as T arbitrarily, doesnt make one. There has to be evidence of T. Separatists are not T
@imtcdlfaridabad0138
@imtcdlfaridabad0138 27 дней назад
what a rubbish futile exercise leading to no where.. BUT KARAN JI IS EXCITED LIKE*************
@gnyanray101
@gnyanray101 28 дней назад
Now indian government should be little less showy and modi has to do less frequent travels to world capitals and do hugging with world leaders.and also India should not distribute hard earned money among neighborhood countries without taking any security from them.
@Tirah5
@Tirah5 28 дней назад
India is distributing money? where?
@xr55
@xr55 28 дней назад
He's talking about foreign aid which India as well receives.​@@Tirah5
@dipoboyrogu9366
@dipoboyrogu9366 27 дней назад
@@Tirah5 study the previous budget...
@sanjeevbjain
@sanjeevbjain 27 дней назад
Lets talk about how China deals with dissent and how the world deals with China
@suzie901
@suzie901 28 дней назад
Thank you prime minister. Feel proud of you. 🇮🇳
@liberalManifesto68
@liberalManifesto68 28 дней назад
ask women in Manipur and Hasan about it... Same thing will happen in rest of the India and you will feel much more pride.
@wonderworld7721
@wonderworld7721 28 дней назад
@@liberalManifesto68 : lol.. what happen joker !??..
@rigeshyogi
@rigeshyogi 28 дней назад
Feel proud of an incompetent agency that tries to kill a US citizen in the US, hiring a US undercover operative?
@venus8738
@venus8738 24 дня назад
RAW probably watching too much India and Pakistani movie
@naf_k5126
@naf_k5126 28 дней назад
जलेबी बना रहे हैं।
@shekarnt
@shekarnt 28 дней назад
And you got chinese to yell this?
@baldevmankoo1049
@baldevmankoo1049 28 дней назад
Karan ji ki iss vich koi doubt hai ki modi ka hath iss conspiracy vich hai.kio ki aab toh modi, rajnath and jaishankar openly bol rahe hai ki ham dusre deshon me ghus kar mare ge Aab to usa ne tkink karna hai ke usne India par ki action kana hai.
@wonderworld7721
@wonderworld7721 28 дней назад
Kya action hona chahiye "India par", in Ur opinion ??...
@baldevmankoo1049
@baldevmankoo1049 28 дней назад
@@wonderworld7721 India ko eak terrorists country declare kana chahiye aur human rights ka ghan karne vala country declare kana chahiye.Aur sabhi sanction ju uno ke chattar me laws Han.Aur Vikram yadav,samant goel and Ajit doval nu khud interogat karna chahiye.Ta ki India in future essi himant na ka sake ji.
@wonderworld7721
@wonderworld7721 28 дней назад
@@baldevmankoo1049 : r uske baad India koi response nehi degai in Ur opinion ???...
@harpritbains9428
@harpritbains9428 28 дней назад
America welcomed modi giving him the benefit of doubt, but modi turned out as a bigger besharam than anyone thought. He has no shame or guilt about killing innocent people.
@RaviSingh-iv2nw
@RaviSingh-iv2nw 28 дней назад
When was the last time Karan Thappad said anything positive about india, or anything which would defend the honour of our country? How else do you define a traitor? How else do you define a bast***d?
@dravidian667
@dravidian667 28 дней назад
Did prajwal teddy defend the honor of the country when he fled to Germany?
@artemis-fo4xf
@artemis-fo4xf 28 дней назад
​@@dravidian667why isn't Germany giving him back?
@dravidian667
@dravidian667 28 дней назад
@@artemis-fo4xf why Nirav Modi not getting sent back to india? Because corrupt Modi government always washes all with washing powder and does not attempt to extradite
@chakravarthybharadwaj8595
@chakravarthybharadwaj8595 26 дней назад
plse do spl intervies on kashmiri pandit life karn sar
@NarendraKumar-jj4fu
@NarendraKumar-jj4fu 27 дней назад
Highlight How much bull shit is being puked. BY the way, where did you guys get schooled?
@haridasshenoy8334
@haridasshenoy8334 27 дней назад
Devil quotes scriptures.
@chandkhongsai2196
@chandkhongsai2196 22 дня назад
Hepa .... Nache te kagenthei Val ta ve.... Narendra Modi hi apan mun a kon in kheh sah jing o... Hepa ka Tao na a he ..........
@navinansal7879
@navinansal7879 28 дней назад
I’m glad India can take action, but silly to be caught, they were sloppy
@jagchahal1393
@jagchahal1393 28 дней назад
India top leadership dont alway have control over many levels of india gvt agencies.
@basusri1120
@basusri1120 28 дней назад
The fact that Nikhil Gupta a suspect in this alleged plot to assassinate Pannun in the US, is being held in the Czech Republic is similar to what the Americans did to terror suspects during the George W Bush Presidency. This is undoubtedly the ability to the use of so called enhanced interrogation techniques on Gupta, which would be illegal on American soil. The Czechs would have no qualms in carrying out this unpleasant task on behalf of the Americans in return for monetary benefits.
Далее
Baxtli bo’l do’stim❤️
00:47
Просмотров 1,5 млн
Giving 1000 Phones Away
00:18
Просмотров 19 млн
What Is an AI Anyway? | Mustafa Suleyman | TED
22:02
Просмотров 982 тыс.
PBS NewsHour full episode, May 29, 2024
56:46
Просмотров 15 тыс.