Part 1 - The Roots of "Kalām Theology" and Why the Jahmites and Their Offshoots Accuse Ahl al-Sunnah of Being Mujassimah/Mushabbihah (Video, 37 minutes) Follow us on Twitter TT...
Masha'Allaah excellent video. These issues needed to be addressed because these so called "hanafis" are getting too confident causing doubt on the salafis and their aqeedah.
Qadri deny Allah's siffat due to saying why doesn't Allah stop evil. Allah is Al Hakim as we see in story of Kidr things appear evil, Allah's Siffat help us understand others. The Mutzailah say each Attribute is a separate being like the idols in Quran 53.19. Asharis combine these 2 deviations, deny Allah's Siffat Qabr for their own pre conceived notions and see them as parts. They rely on substance theory as their foundation and call it rationality, after that they filter the holy texts through this ''rational framework'', which in reality is Arestotelian/Greek philosphy. --- Oh so Juwaini and Fakrudin went back to Jahmis. I heard Ghazali combined ashari and sufism and alot of them repented!
Now compare the intelligence, the eloquence in speech and the way the proofs are presented and explained by our sheikh Abu iyaad, to the foolish so called "dawah" of Ali (needs) Dawah and Muhammad Hijab. Wa Allahu al-Mustaan.
In all fairness didn't Imam Ghazali publish a book called "Incoherence of the Philosophers" which attacked philosophy on 20 counts of heresy" ? I did not know that the Ashari's had Mu'tazilah roots, but that might have been a case of being a victim of those times, when Mu'tazilah beliefs were state sponsored by the Caliphs of that era? There are times when the Ummah improves as it becomes smarter and less exposed to philosophers, and then there are times when people start calling themselves Salafi but they do not resemble that previous generation either. I think this back and forth in our ummah will continue to happen until the day of judgement because we are even worse off without a caliph. Only imam Mahdi will set things straight again for the last time.
The sunnah of Allah is such that he grants the Muslims a righteous, powerful and just ruler after they themselves become righteous. Only Allah can rectify the ummah, and the means is that the Ummah collectively return to righteousness in creed and action. Khilafah is a result of the solution, not the solution itself
It is a **SUNNI** principle in Islam that ayat are taken on apparent meaning until there is another ayat or hadith to take it otherwise. View Quran 6 :82 Tafsir Bukhari ( Athari Aqida) & Quran 3 :7! Athari Aqida prevents baseless tatil & tawil, not just on Allah's Siffat due to pagan foreign idolator influence awuthubillah, but the idea to do this in general to any ayat & open foreign bida over sunna (see Q 5 :48) --- • Shaykh al-Islām Abū Ismā’īl al-Harawī (396-481H) said: ❝Passing the report [pertaining to the attribute] upon its apparentness. And this is that the general signposts of Tawḥīd that have come in the reports are left upon their apparentness. [Thereafter] excessive investigation into them should not be undertaken, and nor should any burden be taken to make ta’wīl of them, and nor should their apparent meanings be exceeded [into] tamthīl (likeness). And nor should comprehension [of their realites] or any presumption be asserted regarding them.❞ الدَّرَجَةُ الثّانِيَةُ: إجْراءُ الخَبَرِ عَلى ظاهِرِهِ. وهُوَ أنْ تَبْقى أعْلامُ تَوْحِيدِ العامَّةِ الخَبَرِيَّةِ عَلى ظَواهِرِها. ولا يَتَحَمَّلُ البَحْثُ عَنْها تَعَسُّفًا. ولا يَتَكَلَّفُ لَها تَأْوِيلًا. ولا يَتَجاوَزُ ظَواهِرَها تَمْثِيلًا. ولا يَدَّعِي عَلَيْها إدْراكًا أوْ تَوَهُّمًا. 📚 (Manāzil al-Sā’irīn p. 40)
What a foolish comment. You either slander him purposefully, or you are simply an individual whose babbling mouth precedes his rational mind. Try not to make a habit of it
When you believe that Allah is above the throne, you are indicating that he has, naudubillah, a place. So I don't know why you pseudo-salafi/wahhabi people believe this.
Yeah, anything that exists in reality and not just an imaginary being, exists in a place, the only ones who are against this are those who believe in the fallacious Greek theories of bodies and substances, you whole belief system is based on the rhetoric of the pagan greeks. Also the Quran clearly says that Allah is above his throne, deny this and you'll be a 5 grade kaffir.
@@hasakicioguz9312 What do you mean by limited? And yes, Allah is above his creation, this proven by revelation and by the fitra, anyone who denies this is a disbeliever, this known by necessity in the religion.
@@tayloryoung4974 Why not assign the meaning to Allah instead of taking the literal meaning? Why not just accept that we cannot fully understand some verses and some ahadeeth?
