Тёмный

Paul McCartney VS. Billy Shears: Performances of Yesterday 

RipPaul1966
Подписаться 1,1 тыс.
Просмотров 66 тыс.
50% 1

I'm sorry I haven't been uploading in a while, i have had some stuff that has prevented me from being able to focus on this channel, but I am back and ready to get this channel back up and running. Hope you enjoy this video, I think it pretty much speaks for itself. Have a great day!
#Paulisdead
#Thebeatles
#PaulMcCartney

Опубликовано:

 

5 апр 2022

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,2 тыс.   
@shadowclaw878
@shadowclaw878 6 месяцев назад
it's almost as if there was over an entire decade between the performances
@mycophobia
@mycophobia 6 месяцев назад
there's just nothing you can say to deeply conspiratorially minded people, every little minor aspect of anything is proof positive for the thing they want to believe. idk why i keep looking at videos like this, like there's literally nothing you can say to the people this invested in it and it just drives me up a wall lol
@marcobaretta
@marcobaretta 4 месяца назад
@@mycophobia In the early sixties, Paul had a child with an Erika Hubers a woman in Germany. There child was called Bettina. For years Paul paid money to this woman and her child. Even though he claimed it was not his. In Germany on the woman's birth certificate it says Paul McCartney on the birth certificate to this day. It has never been removed. In 1984 in a DNA testing Paul( aka Faul) was found not to be the father. She then accused him of using someone else's DNA to hide the fact. Italian DNA specialist and experts invited Paul to have his DNA compared with that of the rest of his family. He then turned it down. Strange behaviour for a man who did no wrong. In the 1980s when he was arrested for possessing drugs in Japan. The Japanese authorities took his fingerprints. They then learnt that Paul(the real one) in the early sixties had been deported from Germany for having set a room on fire in Hamburg. They also learnt that the German authorities had Paul's(the real one) fingerprints on file. So they requested it from the Germans. The Germans send Paul's fingerprints to the Japanese authorities. The Japanese then took Paul's(Faul in this case) fingerprints and compared them. It was a MISMATCH . They then imprisoned Faul because they thought he was both an impostor and a lawbreaker. He spend days in jail after the British government was eventually able to obtain his release. There is your proof. His fingerprints did not match. Yes people change over years BUT FINGERPRINTS DO NOT. So different fingerprints mean different DNA and different DNA therefore means two DIFFERENT people. Also till this day he won't have his DNA compared with that of the rest of the McCartney family. So there is your proof. Also he was friends with Putin in the 2000s. So it is not beneath him to lie. Nothing conspiratorial about this. All well documented.
@marcobaretta
@marcobaretta 4 месяца назад
@@mycophobia In the 1970's Faul gets into to trouble in Scotland for growing marijuana. Claims that he is none the wiser. In 1980 Faul is arrested for possessing drugs in Japan. He still boasts about it today. In 1984 Faul is fined 200 Barbados dollars for possessing drugs in Barbados. In 2001 Faul is seen in multiple photos walking alongside Putin. The guy who is committing a genocide in Ukraine now. A well proven track record of criminality and controversy. Proof he is not beneath lying. Identity theft for a guy like this. No problem.
@marcobaretta
@marcobaretta 4 месяца назад
@@mycophobia In the 1970's Faul gets into to trouble in Scotland for growing marijuana. Claims that he is none the wiser. In 1980 Faul is arrested for possessing drugs in Japan. He still boasts about it today. In 1984 Faul is fined 200 Barbados dollars for possessing drugs in Barbados. In 2001 Faul is seen in multiple photos walking alongside Putin. The guy who is committing a genocide in Ukraine now. A well proven track record of criminality and controversy. Proof he is not beneath lying. Identity theft for a guy like this. No problem.
@marcobaretta
@marcobaretta 4 месяца назад
@@mycophobia In an interview with Ron Wood. Faul claims that he "became a member of the Beatles". Wow this guy does not even bother to study the life he has stolen. What really happened was that Paul(the real one) joined a band called the Quarry men after meeting John Lennon(both having gone to different and opposing schools). Later Paul introduced George Harrison to John Lennon who accepted him but reluctantly. Later they left and formed the Beatles. They went through a string of drummers until they settled on Ringo. Paul never joined the Beatles. He was A FOUNDING MEMBER. Faul on the other hand did join the Beatles in 1966. After Paul's death. And on another TV program he talks about joining the Beatles after they had already been set up. But again Paul(the real one) was a founding member and not one that joined. So real Paul = Founding member. Faul = A band that had already been formed for years. Documented FACTS. NOT conspiracy.
@Alphabettv
@Alphabettv Год назад
Hmm. Not sure I"m convinced of this. Yes, there are differences in quality. Firstly, I think this may be due to the sound quality of the films, between the 60s footage and the 70s footage. Secondly, as a musician myself, Paul maybe felt like taking a different approach in the 70s to his guitar playing rather than playing the original version note for note or strum for strum. Lots of musicians do this to avoid getting bored and stale with the material. Thirdly, it is well known that Macartney was a huge pot head, and this may have affected both the speed of which he played the song, as well as the quality of his voice, particularly if he had a huge spliff before going on stage. Finally, the camera angles are different. In the 70s footage, the camera is below so it looks like he is tilting his head very prominently, but he does similar movements in the 60s footage, where the camera angles are more even. Also he glances down at his guitar in both if you actually look carefully.
@johnrambo4245
@johnrambo4245 2 года назад
Fuckin hell Look at the difference in their teeth McCartney had straight teeth Billy had slightly bucked front teeth🤯
@Rippaul1966
@Rippaul1966 2 года назад
Exactly. They aren’t the same dude.
@thetruthfornow6045
@thetruthfornow6045 Год назад
@@Rippaul1966 yet his replacement has no proof of existence. Birth certificate, school yearbook photos, drivers license records, traceable family or people who knew Billy before he became Paul. You make up a name. Yet that person never existed. I have no fame. Yet if I disappeared and was replaced, everybody would spot the difference. Paul has hairy arms. Faul has hairy arms. Voice DNA states the same person. Both have half circle eyebrows. Paul was 5 ft 10.5 inches. You tube lists the height of celebrities about 10 years ago. It listed current Paul at 5 ft 10.5 inches. A plastic surgeon looked at the current old looking Paul and stated that he never had plastic facial surgery.
@richardb1791
@richardb1791 Год назад
Cosmetic dentistry has bern around a long time
@johnrambo4245
@johnrambo4245 Год назад
@@richardb1791 So you think McCartney went and had his nice straight teeth cosmetically made crooked?
@marcobaretta
@marcobaretta 4 месяца назад
@@Rippaul1966 In the early sixties, Paul had a child with an Erika Hubers a woman in Germany. There child was called Bettina. For years Paul paid money to this woman and her child. Even though he claimed it was not his. In Germany on the woman's birth certificate it says Paul McCartney on the birth certificate to this day. It has never been removed. In 1984 in a DNA testing Paul( aka Faul) was found not to be the father. She then accused him of using someone else's DNA to hide the fact. Italian DNA specialist and experts invited Paul to have his DNA compared with that of the rest of his family. He then turned it down. Strange behaviour for a man who did no wrong. In the 1980s when he was arrested for possessing drugs in Japan. The Japanese authorities took his fingerprints. They then learnt that Paul(the real one) in the early sixties had been deported from Germany for having set a room on fire in Hamburg. They also learnt that the German authorities had Paul's(the real one) fingerprints on file. So they requested it from the Germans. The Germans send Paul's fingerprints to the Japanese authorities. The Japanese then took Paul's(Faul in this case) fingerprints and compared them. It was a MISMATCH . They then imprisoned Faul because they thought he was both an impostor and a lawbreaker. He spend days in jail after the British government was eventually able to obtain his release. There is your proof. His fingerprints did not match. Yes people change over years BUT FINGERPRINTS DO NOT. So different fingerprints mean different DNA and different DNA therefore means two DIFFERENT people. Also till this day he won't have his DNA compared with that of the rest of the McCartney family. So there is your proof. Also he was friends with Putin in the 2000s. So it is not beneath him to lie.
@grahamherbert3612
@grahamherbert3612 2 года назад
I was 12 in 76, and I remember my Dad telling me about Shears. My Father had seen both Paul and Shears play live many times, and was a very proficient left handed player himself. He found it almost unbelievable, that more people hadn't identified the differences in playing style, proficiency, and, to him, clear vocal, and body language disparities.
@f6was9
@f6was9 2 года назад
I play bass and that’s a bunch of crap. Any bass player worth a shit will tell you that’s Paul. Unbelievable what people can talk themselves into believing. Smdh
@eddieramirez8970
@eddieramirez8970 2 года назад
#1 No disrespect to your father, but he was wrong. #2 When a person plays the guitar as often as Paul does, he learned different ways of playing the guitar, as well as any other instruments that he played. Think of it this way, when you were in Grammer school, did you write, or talk the exact same way you do now? Of course not,! Your vocabulary Improved as well as your penmanship! Some people are just so Jealous of Paul's Rich Talent, that every chance they get, they try to knock him down!
@ruelitocayamanda8162
@ruelitocayamanda8162 Год назад
And your father believes that the earth is flat.
@ruelitocayamanda8162
@ruelitocayamanda8162 Год назад
Ok let's settle this. Why would the rest of the Beatles let a look alike stand in and get the credit and royalties for Paul's songs? How in the world would a look alike and sound alike be able to create hits after hits like the real Paul? Watch the movie docu Let It Be. If that is not Paul, wouldn't George just tell the fake Paul to stuff it when he got pissed off? Why would tolerate him if he wasn't the real Paul? Remember, both George and John wanted out of the Beatles. No sense in joining a conspiracy to prolong the agony.
@garyenwards1608
@garyenwards1608 Год назад
Your father was correct. These people are sleeping. Many of us see past the illusions ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-K-3ebH6SP8g.html
@shivasirons6159
@shivasirons6159 Год назад
Notice how he wrote 9 #1 hits after the beatles.
@louk6196
@louk6196 3 месяца назад
Sold his soul.
@DexLikesMinecraft
@DexLikesMinecraft 2 месяца назад
@@louk6196 To have silly dreans
@agentj7852
@agentj7852 Месяц назад
@@louk6196 Ah yes, he had Satan's cell # and easily made that deal.
@lauramartin-bk9nr
@lauramartin-bk9nr 2 года назад
I don´t know if in fact there are 2 persons or 1, but to me the 1st Yesterday in the above video sounds corny. The 2nd Yesterday (the original, the earlier Yesterday) is magical.
@jadaaakk
@jadaaakk 2 года назад
Paul has a magical vibe when he sings yesterday, feels like he’s putting his whole heart when singing it…
@guitarvorous
@guitarvorous 2 года назад
Not as much as Billie
@cliffheywood3671
@cliffheywood3671 2 года назад
@@guitarvorous faul
@garryleeks4848
@garryleeks4848 2 года назад
He did , only the real Paul McCartney could that, and let it be , hey Jude and so on , the only fauls are the ones that don’t believe in it 👍
@garryleeks4848
@garryleeks4848 2 года назад
@@guitarvorous you mean Paul
@jackdshellback3819
@jackdshellback3819 Год назад
@@guitarvorous Billie Holiday Yeah, she was great wasn't she?
@pointormond
@pointormond 2 года назад
1976 compared to 1965.. Show me an artist who doesnt slightly vary up one of their old classics after that length of time. Hes just laying back into a live groove and giving it a different treatmet - it doesnt mean its a differnt person ffs.
@CIS_22
@CIS_22 2 года назад
If we go by this logic then Elvis was replaced in 1970 and the real Elvis is still alive or Michael Jackson was also replaced in the 1990s and the real mj is still alive.
@pointormond
@pointormond 2 года назад
@@CIS_22 If we go by that logic Id say you have missed my point completely.
@Paul-gn6bt
@Paul-gn6bt Год назад
The earlier version sounds like it is played at a slightly faster tempo and has a backing tape. The later version is slightly slower and has a live backing. Can't really see how this is supposed to be a different person or phoney imitator playing it the second time. Same chords, same key. A great little song that became a classic played ten years after he wrote it. Probably lucky he doesn't sue you for defamation!
@billyhenry27
@billyhenry27 Год назад
This is NOT the original Macca
@pointormond
@pointormond Год назад
@@billyhenry27 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-jeSmFp9foPM.html
@barbaraferron7994
@barbaraferron7994 10 месяцев назад
If there's a faux Paul you've got to admire his talent to fill in for Paul so well, and at the sacrifice of his own personal life. Maybe there were fans who would have been traumatized by hearing that Paul died. If you compare older photos etc to later ones, I see more changes in John than Paul. Maybe the "Paul is dead" rumor was a cover up for faux John.
@bustercherry8734
@bustercherry8734 7 месяцев назад
They were all replaced at some point. Original "paul" is john halliday. Original john is colin unwin. Pretty sure marc staycer is the lennon that got shot.
@Helsinki40268
@Helsinki40268 7 месяцев назад
If Paul was replaced I think faul outdid Paul in every regard. Pretty much all major major hits from the Beatles came after 66
@bustercherry8734
@bustercherry8734 7 месяцев назад
@@Helsinki40268 Except the beatles didn't even write their own music from what i've heard. Theodor adorno did. The beatles were a tavistock institute creation.
@JJJJJVVVVVLLLLL
@JJJJJVVVVVLLLLL 3 месяца назад
endless dreaming
@carmelanoname3526
@carmelanoname3526 17 дней назад
I have heard that Ringo was replaced by Wrongo
@leonardblush2557
@leonardblush2557 2 года назад
If this is '76, Billy would be pushing 40. Whoever's voice it is, given all of the ciggies, drugs, booze, etc, it would naturally be shredded all to heck. Throw in 2.5 hour break free concerts, and it's something that he had what he had. I would disagree slightly about Paul vs Billy in the sense that the '67-69 singing may have been the best vocal period for the character publicly known as Paul. ('62-66 vocals were outstanding, too, if course.)
@Rippaul1966
@Rippaul1966 2 года назад
I would say that his vocals were superb for both periods, however I think the real Paul had a slightly better voice. Agree to disagree on that.
@mamadordetravecos9254
@mamadordetravecos9254 2 года назад
Compare The Long and Winding Road in 1969 and 1976 at Rockshow, Paul sounds very different, do you mean he was switched in those years?
@markzappasodi
@markzappasodi 2 года назад
It's from 1975. Australia. That's the outfit he wore on that tour.
@paolomontemurro2569
@paolomontemurro2569 Год назад
Leonard Blush I agree with you ; they are two non-comparable performances .
@richardb1791
@richardb1791 Год назад
Sorry, same guy.
@Elvisultimatefanchannel
@Elvisultimatefanchannel 7 месяцев назад
Whenever I'm down(see what I did there?)and need a laugh I watch one of these videos or an ''Elvis faked his death'' one. They never fail to make me burst out laughing. Thanks for cheering me up 👍
@marcobaretta
@marcobaretta 4 месяца назад
In the early sixties, Paul had a child with an Erika Hubers a woman in Germany. There child was called Bettina. For years Paul paid money to this woman and her child. Even though he claimed it was not his. In Germany on the woman's birth certificate it says Paul McCartney on the birth certificate to this day. It has never been removed. In 1984 in a DNA testing Paul( aka Faul) was found not to be the father. She then accused him of using someone else's DNA to hide the fact. Italian DNA specialist and experts invited Paul to have his DNA compared with that of the rest of his family. He then turned it down. Strange behaviour for a man who did no wrong. In the 1980s when he was arrested for possessing drugs in Japan. The Japanese authorities took his fingerprints. They then learnt that Paul(the real one) in the early sixties had been deported from Germany for having set a room on fire in Hamburg. They also learnt that the German authorities had Paul's(the real one) fingerprints on file. So they requested it from the Germans. The Germans send Paul's fingerprints to the Japanese authorities. The Japanese then took Paul's(Faul in this case) fingerprints and compared them. It was a MISMATCH . They then imprisoned Faul because they thought he was both an impostor and a lawbreaker. He spend days in jail after the British government was eventually able to obtain his release. There is your proof. His fingerprints did not match. Yes people change over years BUT FINGERPRINTS DO NOT. So different fingerprints mean different DNA and different DNA therefore means two DIFFERENT people. Also till this day he won't have his DNA compared with that of the rest of the McCartney family. So there is your proof. Also he was friends with Putin in the 2000s. So it is not beneath him to lie. I do not know why you find this funny.
@thomasfonager6986
@thomasfonager6986 2 года назад
And the fact that Billy Shears was Ringos alter ego on Sgt. Pepper is just ignored?
@user-fu2mi1nd5l
@user-fu2mi1nd5l Месяц назад
it was a red herring....
@MaccaBulsi
@MaccaBulsi Месяц назад
Lass dich einliefern, eingepackt in eine Zwangsjacke.
@moosemangarfield9650
@moosemangarfield9650 8 месяцев назад
You would be shocked to learn how quickly a singer without vocal training can ruin his voice. Liam Gallagher’s voice was almost beyond repair in 2006 despite being completely fine in 1999.
@agentj7852
@agentj7852 Месяц назад
I'm afraid that your facts won't fly here.
@jimo3173
@jimo3173 5 дней назад
Did Liam Gallagher's jawline get longer, his eye color change, and his hairline change? If you can't see the obvious differences, it's because you don't want to see it and don't want to know the truth. Stay deceived, my friend.
@dirgesinthedark5637
@dirgesinthedark5637 2 года назад
It flows out of Paul with feeling of a composer. Billy is pure distain
@OCTOBERBABY7901
@OCTOBERBABY7901 Год назад
Because its not Billy's song. That's why he has distain for singing JPM's songs. he rather sing his own from late 66-present day.
@TimWrightt
@TimWrightt Год назад
disdain*. And it's not disdain, he just has no connection the words. Paul is feeling them as he sings them, which is why his tone is far superior.
@dancegod1691
@dancegod1691 Год назад
Lol he’s just singing different because he’s sitting down and looking up at the mic.
@jonasrmb01
@jonasrmb01 Год назад
@@TimWrightt no, his tone is far superior because he probably has a higher (and much more beautiful) voice
@kauromisweas3375
@kauromisweas3375 10 месяцев назад
Exactly, finally someone says it like it is. For me is just good vs evil.
@cannedratmeat5258
@cannedratmeat5258 2 года назад
Not only did Paul sing Beatles songs from the early 60s differently, but he also was experimenting with different sounds, especially in the 70s and 80s. It’s not hard to believe that he’d sing the same song he’s sung millions of times a little different each time. Every singer does this. It’s not uncommon. Paul sing song different = Must be dead Come on guys :/
@garryleeks4848
@garryleeks4848 2 года назад
He’s still alive
@garryleeks4848
@garryleeks4848 2 года назад
@ARKASH he didn’t have 6 toes 😂
@garryleeks4848
@garryleeks4848 2 года назад
@ARKASH it started as a joke by some college kids , probably on to much ganga and it got out of hand
@beatlebrian4404
@beatlebrian4404 Год назад
@ARKASH nobody called McCartney Billy!
@beatlebrian4404
@beatlebrian4404 Год назад
@ARKASH well you tell me who called McCartney Billy and than I will answer you
@TimWrightt
@TimWrightt Год назад
the difference: paul sings like the words actually mean something to him
@agoodpitch9
@agoodpitch9 9 дней назад
soon after it was written, not after 1,000 performances
@milosit
@milosit 2 года назад
There's a rumor that this video died on April 6, 2022 and what you're watching now is an imposter.
@Rippaul1966
@Rippaul1966 2 года назад
Oooohhhh nooooo
@user-oj4pd9pv5u
@user-oj4pd9pv5u 2 года назад
Absolutely the same man. And i say this like a professional musician and vocalist. In 76 Paul just changed a bit a vocal style of this song. There is only one and alive genuine Paul McCartney
@mamadordetravecos9254
@mamadordetravecos9254 2 года назад
exactly, he in 1976 sings The Long and Winding Road in Rockshow. Compare with 1969 that until then, they will think it's someone else
@elizabethfonseca922
@elizabethfonseca922 2 года назад
According to the video, there's a 10 year gap between the two presentations. This is more than enough for a person's voice and manners to change, although I didn't notice anything relevant. This whole Paul is Dead hysteria is ridiculous. There's been one and only Paul McCartney, admit it.
@MisterTMH
@MisterTMH 2 года назад
Denial is a river in Egypt!.Billy is a clearly a differnet person but there is no one so blind as those who refuse to see. Wake up. It is easy to fool someone but very hard to convince anyone that they have been fooled. We don't get fooled again !
@beatlebrian4404
@beatlebrian4404 2 года назад
@@elizabethfonseca922 how can he admit it? If he does than that's the end of this stupid channel!
@beatlebrian4404
@beatlebrian4404 2 года назад
@@MisterTMH I will wake up, if you can explain this video. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-GfkRHM30aOo.html
@erikdirks
@erikdirks 16 дней назад
Thank you so much for this! If they can replace a rock star and deceive the public, they can do the same to a President, a Prime Minister, Congressman, Senator, etc.
4 месяца назад
Tina Foster's book sealed James Paul McCartney's casket for me. Yes Billy did an outstanding job, but they are two different people.
@louk6196
@louk6196 3 месяца назад
I called BS on this until 24 hours ago. Then I started to actually watch the videos. After 1966 Paul sings in a lower key, has different pronunciations and different mannerisms. He is more nasal. He sometimes forgets that he is left-handed. Even his personality changed. That is obvious to us when comparing interviews but Jane Asher herself said he had changed.
@user-rd4zq4pf2y
@user-rd4zq4pf2y 19 дней назад
You are in touch with reality, unlike the PID deniers. All it takes is an open mind and confronting the truth. Plenty of proof with all these videos and podcasts on the internet.
@carmelanoname3526
@carmelanoname3526 17 дней назад
a pity she did not really notice his boyfriend had changed, but only assumed. OMG!
@sheilariley1261
@sheilariley1261 Год назад
Paul had a round baby face. Adorable. Faul has a elongated face. So effening obvious.
@jamesscanlan6240
@jamesscanlan6240 Год назад
Obvious; like your room temperature IQ.
@bazil9323
@bazil9323 10 месяцев назад
Its called aging lmao
@Henrik2020
@Henrik2020 10 месяцев назад
@@bazil9323 In their view, Paul, unlike John, George and Ringo, is not allowed to age, improve as a musician, or do versions of his songs remotely different to pre 1966. Blimey, look at John in the early years compared to the later years. He changed so much, but as with this theory, you would have to be stark raving mad to say that he had been replaced by an imposter. These guys need therapy.
@dr.scanlan6112
@dr.scanlan6112 8 месяцев назад
@@bazil9323Aren't these idiots amazing!?
@paolaalmazan6441
@paolaalmazan6441 6 месяцев назад
It's called a fringe 😂
@marcocarbajal9299
@marcocarbajal9299 10 месяцев назад
The real Paul McCartney was a genius..
@Henrik2020
@Henrik2020 10 месяцев назад
Yes he is.
@zoeazsss5035
@zoeazsss5035 Год назад
Let me introduce to you the one and only Billy Shears, Nothing is Real, Strawberry Fields Forever. RIP Paul. I can see and hear the difference.
@thetruthfornow6045
@thetruthfornow6045 Год назад
That is the voice change over the years due to smoking and life in general. Both Paul's have hairy arms. That means they are one person. Listen to Jagger sing Satisfaction in 65 and again in 73. Big difference. Voice DNA said only one Paul. Stop being stupid.
@LaMYsteriosa87
@LaMYsteriosa87 Год назад
Wonderful.
@MacenW
@MacenW Год назад
2 dummies
@rjetsamonte5971
@rjetsamonte5971 11 месяцев назад
Paul is dead is ridiculous
@zoeazsss5035
@zoeazsss5035 11 месяцев назад
@@rjetsamonte5971 Thats your opinion, do some research.
@michaelparker5510
@michaelparker5510 7 месяцев назад
Paul is alive and well. What ever is the matter with people
@chuckblank9063
@chuckblank9063 Год назад
Paul was touring - probably "Wings Over America," playing an Ovation guitar which they took on Wings tours. He looks exhausted from rocking the stadiums. Recording Paul's voice changed from Beatles days being less mid-rangish to the fuller sound during Wings. These are both Mary's son James Paul.
@virginiadearguello979
@virginiadearguello979 2 года назад
You are right!!Paul and fault are different
@lucadeflorio502
@lucadeflorio502 Год назад
The real Paul has a slight deeper voice than billy shear
@LaMYsteriosa87
@LaMYsteriosa87 Год назад
Fuller too.
@time4change878
@time4change878 7 месяцев назад
Faul is very talented. But he keeps going in and out of character
@_steamfunk_2271
@_steamfunk_2271 10 месяцев назад
Paul played Yesteday without looking at his guitar Billy keeps looking at his
@lorichet
@lorichet 7 месяцев назад
I imagine it's difficult for a right-handed person to play left handed.
@Caine462
@Caine462 24 дня назад
@@lorichetPaul McCartney was right handed all this time? Why’d he just play left handed?
@eisnotanumber3557
@eisnotanumber3557 2 года назад
People change a lot in ten years, and also Ringo said in the song "I'm The Greatest" that he is Billy Shears. Also, that part going into "With a little Help From My Friends" the band say "Billy Shears" and then after that Ringo starts singing.
@josephthunderhorse8793
@josephthunderhorse8793 Год назад
Most of the obvious inserts to the songs were intentionally placed to bolster the conspiracy theory....did John Lennon strike you as shy?....if he wanted to tell you that "Paul was dead"...he wouldn't do it with hints in backward playing lyrics...he would say "me best bloke is dead" ...it was probably Paul and Brian's idea
@Nitrotoast1
@Nitrotoast1 Год назад
@@josephthunderhorse8793 yeah exactly, John got murdered because he spoke up against the war as well as injustice in our world. Why do people think he’d stay silent on a massive cover up conspiracy against an imposter he allegedly hated?
@LaMYsteriosa87
@LaMYsteriosa87 Год назад
Not the shape or the size of the skull. Not ears, their size or the way they are angled. Nor height after 24. Or 1,5 larger shoe size. Give me a break.
@Henrik2020
@Henrik2020 10 месяцев назад
Yes, indeed. It was Ringo's chosen name for the fictional band Sgt Pepper. Shears is a fictional character connected to Ringo, and has nothing to do with Paul.
@sylviaelizabethclarecholic2073
@sylviaelizabethclarecholic2073 2 года назад
Well, well...BEAUTIFUL melody, voice, and person! ❤️ Speechless again....but pleasantly so. 🌹
@sylviaelizabethclarecholic2073
@sylviaelizabethclarecholic2073 2 года назад
@THE REAL PAUL McCARTNEY REALLY DIED I know, but what is life as a fading "pornographic peasant'. Without a few delusions! Pray thee....allow us a few comforts in our final years....♥️🎶😄🥴🙏🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
@retrobaseballjunkwax5302
@retrobaseballjunkwax5302 2 года назад
To be fair William is right handed...
@Rippaul1966
@Rippaul1966 2 года назад
My point exactly
@beatlebrian4404
@beatlebrian4404 2 года назад
@@Rippaul1966 McCartney used his right hand as well, just because you lefthanded, means you never use your right!
@Rippaul1966
@Rippaul1966 2 года назад
@@beatlebrian4404 the point that I am trying to make is that Billy was clearly having trouble playing left handed, which only happens when someone is naturally right handed, which is exactly what Billy Shears is. However Paul McCartney is left handed, so he, as seen in the second video, is playing left handed with far less difficulty.
@beatlebrian4404
@beatlebrian4404 2 года назад
@@Rippaul1966 where's the evidence, that your Billy is right handed?
@Rippaul1966
@Rippaul1966 2 года назад
@@beatlebrian4404 in this video. He’s clearly having trouble playing
@europoets
@europoets Год назад
The transition between Paul s voice on Red Album and Billy on Blue Album is Very noticable...z different peoole. Most people just didnt pay attention to it back then since his death was not announced...
@europoets
@europoets Год назад
Try playing Eleanor Rigby and Penny Lane back to back and you notice it immediately
@thetruthfornow6045
@thetruthfornow6045 Год назад
@@europoets I did and it is the same person. Vocal DNA proved that point back in the late sixties. So it was put to rest.
@garyenwards1608
@garyenwards1608 Год назад
@@thetruthfornow6045 explain this Brainiac ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-K-3ebH6SP8g.html
@thetruthfornow6045
@thetruthfornow6045 Год назад
@@cruksi7001 It was in the newspapers and on tv back then. My mom saw it. I notice no one disputes it. If they did they could do it again now. There are plenty of musical sources available pre 1967 and after.
@gaylealleluia8392
@gaylealleluia8392 Год назад
@@thetruthfornow6045 There is new, better voice forensic techniques today and there is true Beatle Paul, and, as John referred to Billy as “False Paul,” Faul, they are two different people
@agitatedmongoose
@agitatedmongoose 2 года назад
paul's voice got better in the 60s. By 69 it is was at his very best. So if this is a man named Billy Shears (which it isn't) he is by far the better singer
@botvertex3830
@botvertex3830 2 года назад
and writer I mean to think some random dude made all of the wings catalog + solo paul would just be insane and if so I prefer billy😂
@agitatedmongoose
@agitatedmongoose 2 года назад
@@botvertex3830 exactly. I am not on board with the Billy thing at all as I imagine you are not either.
@botvertex3830
@botvertex3830 2 года назад
@@agitatedmongoose oh yeah it's 100% not true funny how some people think it is
@2v_5r84
@2v_5r84 2 года назад
@@botvertex3830 Plus Beatles 1967-1970 output
@garryleeks4848
@garryleeks4848 2 года назад
@@botvertex3830 Paul 👍
@joelhenderson5404
@joelhenderson5404 Год назад
Billy has a artificial right eye to and has to look down to see if he is in the right place on the neck. RIP Paul.
@Ashyri
@Ashyri 2 года назад
God I can’t tell if this comment section is just a bunch of trolls or being dead honest…
@yolowell9564
@yolowell9564 2 года назад
Same
@sharky09000
@sharky09000 Год назад
I can only imagine Paul wanted to keep his soul, RIP Paul & many more no doubt.
@AnyoneCanSee
@AnyoneCanSee 7 месяцев назад
You are delusional.
@2v_5r84
@2v_5r84 2 года назад
Bob Dylan was also clearly replaced by a lookalike. Just compare the studio version of ‘Don’t Think Twice, It’s Alright’ to the version from the 1979 Live at Budokan album. It’s completely different. The only conclusion that we can draw from this is that he was replaced by a fake.
@garyenwards1608
@garyenwards1608 Год назад
ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-K-3ebH6SP8g.html
@z512345
@z512345 Год назад
So wasn't Elvis. OOPS Elvis is dead.
@UseByDate-Expired
@UseByDate-Expired Год назад
@@z512345 Elvis died ? OMG
@carlomayr4494
@carlomayr4494 2 года назад
Se fosse vera la morte di Paul Mc Cartney nel 66, devo dire che chi ha scritto tutti i pezzi dopo Hey Jude ecc ecc è un vero genio. W Paul mc cartney. Saluti da Milano 🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹
@bonessakellis195
@bonessakellis195 2 года назад
You're all insane thing's change in 10 years can you not see it's the same person please long live Paul McCartney!
@jenniferm6042
@jenniferm6042 2 года назад
At least 5 different people play that 1 character on the world stage
@Rippaul1966
@Rippaul1966 2 года назад
Things do change a little , but not that much! Nobody is that different after 10 years! This is clearly not paul.
@Rippaul1966
@Rippaul1966 2 года назад
@@jenniferm6042 I disagree. From what I have seen it seems like one person. That being said, it is certainly a possibility that it is more than one person, that would make some sense. However I have found very little evidence to say that with certainty, I believe it is far more likely that there is just one, that person being the one and only Billy Shears.
@bonessakellis195
@bonessakellis195 2 года назад
@@Rippaul1966 I'm 56 my ears nose and neck look different from when I was 46. Look at yourself 10 years ago. There's no way in hell if Paul McCartney had died in 1966 without the world knowing about it let alone someone with the same talent looks identical plays left handed do you know how hard it is to do that. The Beatles yes left some clues behind sure shits and giggles that's all it was. It's all for fun people also listen to Mike Williams channel what a joke !!!
@Rippaul1966
@Rippaul1966 2 года назад
@@bonessakellis195 Mike Williams has some really weird theories, I think he takes this whole thing way too far. I respect what he is doing with his channel but I disagree with him on a lot of points. But anyways, agree to disagree on this. Have a great day though. Peace out ✌️
@RickiKeith
@RickiKeith 7 месяцев назад
Coming from a professional singer and vocal coach, I can hear the VERY distinct differences in the two performances notably tone and the different approaches to each note. The first performer "dips" into some of the notes whereas the second performer never does. The first performer has a clearly different vocal cabinet that has a more rigid quality and his pulling his head back like he does also "squeezes" the sound to lend a similar tonal quality as the second performer, but it fails. Every well know singers voice has a signature sound like a fingerprint that to the untrained ear may not blatantly detectable, but to another singer and vocal coach, the differences are very obvious. The 8 years or so between the performances would not present this much change in tone, timbre and style. I say it is two different singers.
@robertzafaras4462
@robertzafaras4462 Месяц назад
ricki, totally agree
@noemifrometa9310
@noemifrometa9310 Месяц назад
Esa es una de sus canciones que son tantas !!!!! Mi favorita ❤
@rupertbear6883
@rupertbear6883 Год назад
brilliant work..
@chrisbooth3417
@chrisbooth3417 8 месяцев назад
Looks like the same person to me. In the first video as pointed out by others he was finishing a long tour. Still sounds good to me. Same voice to my ears.
@carmelanoname3526
@carmelanoname3526 17 дней назад
because it is the same person
@dylanakent
@dylanakent Год назад
10 years is a lifetime in the performance levels of a musician, particularly a singer. The voice is not like a physical musical instrument you can put away in a box for years and pick up later and have it sound nearly the same. The voice is subject to change not only year over year but day to day and even hour to hour because it's part of a human body. Some singers get stronger with age and most do not. It takes intense conditioning and practice and sheer LUCK to maintain your voice over the years. No amount of money can guarantee that! As far as looking at the guitar, there are a MILLION factors why someone would look in various places at a live performance, particularly the star of the show who is The Boss at the time. I'm calling this Billy Shears controversy for what it is - ignorance about musicianship, performance and the music industry. That's Paul McCartney.
@cutekanjii
@cutekanjii Год назад
Ignorance about seeing a different person with different features they look very alike but it's obvious they are 2 different people. Like 2 twins always have slight differences. Maybe if u are not a very observant person u might not be able to tell them apart but an observant person can.
@ignaciocardenas7640
@ignaciocardenas7640 Год назад
@@cutekanjii...
@jivet3919
@jivet3919 Год назад
These people are insane. It’s wild.
@LaMYsteriosa87
@LaMYsteriosa87 Год назад
@@jivet3919 Awake to the reality in front of them. Big difference. Contrary to many others.
@Henrik2020
@Henrik2020 10 месяцев назад
@@cutekanjii Playing the usual "you're not smart enough" card and saying "it's obvious" is not a good look when you are 100% wrong. Plenty of evidence of this to open your closed mind. That is, if you are observant enough when you are presented with it. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-bCf4RkowTks.html
@cboisandlin9601
@cboisandlin9601 9 месяцев назад
Rest in peace Paul 😞
@Truthseeker-kc8rd
@Truthseeker-kc8rd 10 месяцев назад
I never listened to this song , i just got to know about this conspiracy.I dont know why but the old clip legit teared me up. It moved me
@nadiachristiansen7599
@nadiachristiansen7599 9 месяцев назад
That's propably because the guy singing it died in 1966 and was replaced with William Campbell who looks nothing like Paul McCartney (1942-1966) and sings nothing like him.
@carmelanoname3526
@carmelanoname3526 17 дней назад
@@nadiachristiansen7599 you cannot be serious - this is the most ridiculous comment I have read. He looks exactly the same and sings exactly the same.
@jeffp6072
@jeffp6072 2 года назад
Obviously The whole Paul is dead stuff is just silliness but still fun to talk about.
@miriam2956
@miriam2956 2 года назад
My brain hurts from some of these peoples "logic" I can't. This rumor is so stupid lol. Their "Evidence" adnsfonadofoad.
@SharkEatFish
@SharkEatFish 2 года назад
1. The voice: It's two different performances, do you really expect them to sound identical? No. Tbh, they sound practically the same. 2. The way he plays guitar: He probably just picked up a different way of playing, how hard is that to believe? Especially after 10 years. 3. Looking down to play guitar: He probably just wasn't having as good a day as the original performance. Think of it this way, in the 10 years after the performance of Yesterday, he had written a lot of stuff and Yesterday wasn't fresh on his mind because he hadn't written it so recently. There are others which are easily explained like the head tilting, but again, people change in 10 years, and pick up new techniques for stuff.
@hole5shrimp
@hole5shrimp 2 года назад
no thats too plausible. pretty sure the entire british government, rest of the beatles/wives/kids, producers/technicians/roadies are ALL in on this... this is the switchup of the century....
@michelewalburger9729
@michelewalburger9729 2 года назад
Agreed. Who on earth is identical every day? Stupid conspiracy theories So sad and disrespectful to dear Paul who we are blessed to still have
@jaimelesenfantsepstein737
@jaimelesenfantsepstein737 2 года назад
@@michelewalburger9729 RITE? PPL B THINKIN WAY 2 MUCH. THAT NOT WUT THA GOVERMENT WANT US 2 DO. WE AINT SUPPOSED 2 B THINKIN LIEK DAT. THAT NOT OUR JOB 2 THINK. OUR JOB IS 2 WORK 4 A BETTR WORLD WHER CHIDRIN CAN B WHOEVER THEY WANT 2 B AND HAV ACCESS 2 HOARMONE PILLS, WHERE WOMEN CAM ABORT THEY BABIES WHENEVER THEY NEED 2 (AT LEAST WE NEED 6 MONTH POST BORTH ABORTION IF WE NOT GUNNA B SEXIST LIEK DAT), WHERE SATANISTS CAN OPENLY PRACTICE THEY RITUALS N PUBLIC WITHOUT NO RESTAURAINTS N CAN OPENLY SACRIFICE N DO WUT NEED 2 B DON, A WORLD WHERE AGE B ONLY A ### N ADULTS N CHIDRIN CAN HAV FUN WIT EACH OTHA IF THEY WANT 2, A WORKD WHERE WE CAN B FREE TO XPRESS LUV 2 OUR ANIMALS BCUZ WE LOVE THEMS RITE?? I MEAN COME ON BRUH, IT B 2022 ALREDY, THA WORLD IS CHANGE. CHANGE GON CUM N WE KNEW THAT. PERIODT. WE NEEDA WORLD WHERE WE CAN ALL HAVE UNIVERSAL IN COME, FREE HELLTHCARE, FREE COLLAGE, N B TAKEN CARE OF 4 THA HARD WERK WE DO SERVING OUR MASTERS. #HAILSATAN. WE R A IMPORTANT ### IN THIS SYSTEM N WE NEED 2 FASILITATE THA CHANGE WE NEED 2 MAKE. A WORLD WHER PPL WORK HARD EVERY DAY N THEN WHERE WHEN DEY GIT SICKKK, THEN CAN B YOUTHENIZED, N THA ORGANS CAN B GIVEN 2 YUNG POC WHO NEED DEM 2 WORK 4 A BETTR WORLD. PERIODT. DEEZ WEIRDOS ALWAYS B TALKING N THINKIN. AGAIN, THAT NOT WUT WE R SUPPOSED 2 DO. THAT NOT OUR JOB 2 THINK. WE DONT GET PAYED 2 DO THAT. U FEEL ME? COME ON FAM. DNT WORREY BROTHAS, WE DON B ALRITE. THEEZ WEIRDOS AINT GON B AROUND 4 MUCH LONGER BCUZ WE GOT SOME NICE SUMMER CAMP PROGRAMS IN OUR NEW WORLD 🌍 🏕 💀 SATAN BLESS YALL 🙏🏿🌈🔪👶🏻🩸🩸🩸🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍⚧️⚧💯💗🌀💗🌀🗣🗣🗣✊🏿✊🏿✊🏿✊🏿✊🏿✊🏿✊🏿🖤🖤🖤
@markv.5962
@markv.5962 2 года назад
@@michelewalburger9729 yes indeed. these people who believe this are uninformed and clueless
@TimWrightt
@TimWrightt Год назад
>probably >probably So, you have no actual reason to dismiss the idea then? So be quiet, please.
@cullerton27
@cullerton27 Год назад
George said Paul died 1966 on his death bed
@cullerton27
@cullerton27 Год назад
When the fake Paul dies Will he be his gravestone name be Paul or Billy ? Will his children be named MaCartney officially
@carmelanoname3526
@carmelanoname3526 17 дней назад
to you?
@stephenspringer2203
@stephenspringer2203 4 месяца назад
You are right the voice is different. Eleven years will change it. Cigarettes as well as he admitted to those changing. Watch other performances of him as a Beatle and you will notice the same then as now in 2023. Sir Paul is very much alive.
@boojiboy584
@boojiboy584 2 года назад
Miss him, Miss him, Miss him. . .
@elizabethfonseca922
@elizabethfonseca922 2 года назад
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 John Lennon laughing from the grave.
@boojiboy584
@boojiboy584 2 года назад
@@elizabethfonseca922 ❤️👍🏻
@kako1023
@kako1023 9 месяцев назад
JPM's ending on each line is so smooth. Billy's version here is ok
@navydad8916
@navydad8916 9 месяцев назад
And you dear are in need of mental health help !
@Concertgoer-mj5ek
@Concertgoer-mj5ek 2 года назад
It looked like in the first one that he wanted to speed through it, having just gone on tour and doing Beatles he probably wanted to just burn through the Beatles and do his regular stuff
@coZyLos
@coZyLos 2 года назад
I can’t believe this channel’s dedicated to Paul’s rumored “death”. Although I don’t believe this rumor, i still find these videos very interesting, kudos to all the dedication this channel gives for something that isn’t even true.
@Rippaul1966
@Rippaul1966 2 года назад
Lol well I’ll take that as a compliment, agree to disagree on whether or not it’s true tho. Still glad u like the content!
@coZyLos
@coZyLos 2 года назад
@@Rippaul1966 yeah and it’s also very worth watching considering how much effort you put making these videos.. you’re doing alright as long as you’re doing something you believe in, hats off to you, sir!
@Rippaul1966
@Rippaul1966 2 года назад
@@coZyLos thanks 🙏
@marioceva7163
@marioceva7163 Год назад
@@Rippaul1966 some people as me do not need proof for what is obvious. Are clearly two different persons.
@harpar1028
@harpar1028 Год назад
@@marioceva7163 me neva C him......BUT me no it is different person....FIJIAN DUDE....smart alec
@pacomarcone4271
@pacomarcone4271 2 года назад
Some people have nothing to do…
@orlandosoto6080
@orlandosoto6080 2 года назад
Tell me about it 🤪
@canopyfields
@canopyfields 10 месяцев назад
Billy didn't go to Paul's father's funeral. And has no communication with Paul's sister.
@chrisnolan5607
@chrisnolan5607 2 года назад
Totally Billy Shears aka Vivian Stanshall of the Bonzo Dog Doo Dah Band. The Real Paul here is sooooo much better than the Imposter Billy.
@olgadefeo598
@olgadefeo598 2 месяца назад
These conspiracy theories are hilarious! 😂 Moreover, this Billy Shears is really talented, since Paul's best music came from 1967 onwards (Sgt Pepper, the White Album, Abbey Road, Let It Be).
@durandaldevil
@durandaldevil Год назад
Like nobody’s voice has ever changed in 20 years? 😂😂😂
@marcobaretta
@marcobaretta 4 месяца назад
As well as their face, HIEGHT AND DNA. That is a lot of change for 20 years.
@durandaldevil
@durandaldevil 4 месяца назад
@@marcobaretta do you have the proof?
@marcobaretta
@marcobaretta 4 месяца назад
@@durandaldevil In the early sixties, Paul had a child with an Erika Hubers a woman in Germany. There child was called Bettina. For years Paul paid money to this woman and her child. Even though he claimed it was not his. In Germany on the woman's birth certificate it says Paul McCartney on the birth certificate to this day. It has never been removed. In 1984 in a DNA testing Paul( aka Faul) was found not to be the father. She then accused him of using someone else's DNA to hide the fact. Italian DNA specialist and experts invited Paul to have his DNA compared with that of the rest of his family. He then turned it down. Strange behaviour for a man who did no wrong. In the 1980s when he was arrested for possessing drugs in Japan. The Japanese authorities took his fingerprints. They then learnt that Paul(the real one) in the early sixties had been deported from Germany for having set a room on fire in Hamburg. They also learnt that the German authorities had Paul's(the real one) fingerprints on file. So they requested it from the Germans. The Germans send Paul's fingerprints to the Japanese authorities. The Japanese then took Paul's(Faul in this case) fingerprints and compared them. It was a MISMATCH . They then imprisoned Faul because they thought he was both an impostor and a lawbreaker. He spend days in jail after the British government was eventually able to obtain his release. There is your proof. His fingerprints did not match. Yes people change over years BUT FINGERPRINTS DO NOT. So different fingerprints mean different DNA and different DNA therefore means two DIFFERENT people. Also till this day he won't have his DNA compared with that of the rest of the McCartney family. So there is your proof. Also he was friends with Putin in the 2000s. So it is not beneath him to lie. There is your proof
@durandaldevil
@durandaldevil 4 месяца назад
@@marcobaretta he probably really wasn’t the German girls father. Who knows what the hell the Japanese did to records of his digits digitally. Paul has a very unique look. And charm. Kind of hard to duplicate within the same little city don’t you think? And again, John and Yoko, who were his adversaries, would’ve said something in the 70s
@marcobaretta
@marcobaretta 4 месяца назад
@@durandaldevil "he probably really wasn’t the German girls father." Why pay money to a child who is not yours for years then? Also when Italian DNA specialists asked to compare his DNA with that of his brother Mike, he(Faul) chose not to. Strange way to behave if it is not your child. "Who knows what the hell the Japanese did to records of his digits digitally." Sorry you can't fake fingerprints. No way. Nor would the Japanese have had any reason to do so. They mismatched because they are not the same person. Remember the other sample they obtained was from the German authorities. So if they manipulated the fingerprints (which you can't) then they could have called the German authorities into question. Not something they would want to do or had any reason to do at the time. The reason the fingerprints mismatched was because they are two different people. Different fingerprints, different DNA, therefore different people. "And again, John and Yoko, who were his adversaries, would’ve said something in the 70s" At John's funeral Yoko accused Faul of having opposed John. Which of course Faul denies. Also maybe John was about to talk and tell the whole truth. This may explain why he really died in 1980. As well as for saying he was bigger than Jesus( which was not entirely untrue). Paul(Faul) even has difficulty remembering his own life. In an interview in 1987 he claimed that he wanted to become a teacher and that was what he was qualified to do. That singing had been the last thing on his mind. TOTALLY WRONG. In an interview in America in 1964 when asked about if he had any other career choices in his life. Paul(the real one) says no. Singer/songwriter and being a Beatle is all he ever wanted to do. His teacher and prominent educator Allan Durband from Liverpool testified that all Paul ever wanted to do was play his guitar and do music. He had no intention of persuading him otherwise. Paul's love for music was so great he was failing all his subjects baring English. This was in an interview in 1965. Again Faul has difficulty remembering his own life. Decades after the song Let it be come out he was asked what inspired him to write it. He says in a dream he had in 1969 his mother come to him. It was a stressful time in his life and he asked her for advice. Let it be was the advice she gave to him. He (Faul) felt that this was a sign from his mother who had died 10 years prior in 1959. Again TOTALLY WRONG. His mother(Mary) died in 1956, 13 YEARS BEFORE THE SONG WAS WRITTEN. The man can not even remember when his mother died. Paul's mother died on 31 October 1956 at the age of 47. Which child would not remember such an important event in there life. Strangely he remembers when Jim his father died on 18 March 1976 and was buried at Landican cemetery on the 22 March 1976. Three days later he is filmed in Copenhagen having a party with his friends on the 25 March 1976. Yes he had a concert on the 23rd March 1976 in Berlin. But he would have been able to make it if he had wanted to. Problem with that was that Jim had remarried in 1964 to Angie. Angie the stepmother asked Paul not to be at the funeral. Strange thing to ask your stepson. Especially if he is the man's biological son. But he is not. He is Faul. The real Paul had died in 1966. There is your proof.
@micolsen9824
@micolsen9824 Год назад
10 years of smoking cigs and weed, is your answer. 🚬
@aaronhughes2550
@aaronhughes2550 Месяц назад
Bingo
@VallaMusic
@VallaMusic 5 месяцев назад
yes indeed, Billy - you are not half the man you used to be
@agoodpitch9
@agoodpitch9 9 дней назад
Whatever the truth about this, that Paul in '66 was one heck of a singer .
@DungeonTV100
@DungeonTV100 11 месяцев назад
Hes miming in the original though.. where on earth do you think the string quartet is coming from? Tape!
@evanmeiskin6498
@evanmeiskin6498 Год назад
there was a voice test with advanced equipment. It looks at voice signatures. This is like fingerprints. Flats sharp etc. They found it was exactly the same guy.
@truthseeker9692
@truthseeker9692 Год назад
post it here
@AuntKimmySez
@AuntKimmySez 11 месяцев назад
I think the Beatles were counting on the gullibility of half their fan base when they put all those alleged "clues" in their songs & whatnot.
@jonasrmb01
@jonasrmb01 9 месяцев назад
almost all singers are a little bit flat except maybe for elite opera singers that doesn't prove anything the only singer that a master imitator couldn't imitate that comes to my mind might be freddie mercury because of his unusually slow (and irregular) vibrato but mccartney is absolutely possible to immitate you probably watched that wacky video by wings of pegasus which doesn't even remotely prove that it's the same voice if you can't hear that billy does not have the same range and richness of tone in his upper registers as paul did then you're absolutely deaf
@zoeazsss5035
@zoeazsss5035 Год назад
And Linda was really Princess Diana. :)
@1bassman9
@1bassman9 3 месяца назад
I'm not convinced either way but I will say the early performances of Paul McCartney were played with incredible confidence and he never looked down in his guitar and I don't find that same confidence in later performances
@howthebeatlessaveusfromboredom
Paul glances at his hands while he plays Yesterday minimally--maybe 2-3 times tops. Billy must constantly glance at his hands while he plays. I've been playing guitar since the 70s and decided to learn Yesterday a couple of months ago to see if I needed to look at my hands while I play it. I do not and I'm curious to know if other veteran guitarists need to constantly glance at their fingering while they play the song. Thanks for making this video. I never got around to it while I was researching this topic. I wish people would take some time to do their own research and/or read Memoirs of Billy Shears before coming to a conclusion about this issue.
@DiegoRodriguez-dw7pv
@DiegoRodriguez-dw7pv 2 года назад
Didn't know Ringo played Yesterday
@amain325
@amain325 4 месяца назад
It wasn't Ringo, it was Fingo 😂
@luishumbertovega3900
@luishumbertovega3900 2 года назад
Mike McGear agreed to have a brother replacement, like a part of an engine at the mechanic's shop. "My brother died ? No problem, got a substitute ? Great, send him in !" Pppppppppleeeeease !!!
@MegaGenten
@MegaGenten Год назад
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@carloscaparroslledo1130
@carloscaparroslledo1130 4 месяца назад
You guys are sick 😂
@2v_5r84
@2v_5r84 2 года назад
Jimmy Page was also replaced by a lookalike. On Stairway to Heaven, the real Jimmy Page played the guitar solo on a telecaster. We can tell he was replaced because when Led Zeppelin went on tour, the fake Jimmy played a double neck Gibson guitar and played longer, improvised versions of the solo that were completely different than the original. Rest In Peace to the real Jimmy Page.
@2v_5r84
@2v_5r84 2 года назад
@THE REAL PAUL McCARTNEY REALLY DIED Then this can’t be proof of Paul being replaced. The video is preposterous and I was being sarcastic
@2v_5r84
@2v_5r84 2 года назад
@prince jones It was just sarcasm. I was making fun of the ridiculous claim that paul McCartney was magically replaced by a lookalike who sounds exactly like him
@asloii_1749
@asloii_1749 Год назад
True, John Lennon also died bc look at how different he looks in 1968 compared with the early 60s
@jackdshellback3819
@jackdshellback3819 Год назад
@@2v_5r84 Sarcasm is lost on a lot of Americans. I notice they ran away in embarrassment.
@handle-schmandle
@handle-schmandle Год назад
I understood it was sarcasm, and appreciated it enough to hit the like button. And yes I am from the U.S.😊
@mileswalcott7241
@mileswalcott7241 2 года назад
I am sure that a singer can sing the same song in two consecutive performances and each time sing the song different it has to do with the mood and vibes from the audience
@michelewalburger9729
@michelewalburger9729 2 года назад
Exactly 💯
@RSVPini
@RSVPini Год назад
@@michelewalburger9729 Just go see Bob Dylan. If you see him 16 times, you'll think there are 16 Dylans. This "McCartney is dead" joke is getting old. It's too bad that such a McCartney fan can't appreciate McCartney based on the fact that he thinks he's dead. Weird.
@TimWrightt
@TimWrightt Год назад
@@RSVPini Bob Dylan literally admits to selling his soul to the devil and he is just living out his end of the bargain. What a horrible example, thanks for proving us correct and Paul is dead.
@RSVPini
@RSVPini Год назад
@@TimWrightt Oh boy. A Dylan conspiracy theorist. What else do you believe? Elvis is alive? Beethoven is in your oven?
@bleeb2024
@bleeb2024 Год назад
@@TimWrightt THERE IS NO GOD AND THERE IS NO DEVIL :)
@ironwood9
@ironwood9 Год назад
Paul was very talented...very good at playing the acoustic...yeah, he hardly looked at the guitar.... I love stuff like this I just saw a video of Billy "playing Bass," a Rickenbacker, on "Silly love songs"...the bass line is AWESOME... what I hear in my headphones is this excellent bass playing, which seems to be played with a pick ..but Billy has no pick, and he doing this thing where he seems to be lightly strumming with his thumb, and I'm like: "What's going on, here"???
@edwardhill7297
@edwardhill7297 10 месяцев назад
Many bass players don't use picks
@ironwood9
@ironwood9 10 месяцев назад
@@edwardhill7297 Right. I never did.... always played by pulling the strings with alternating index\middle finger.... Plus without a pick, I'm free to slap and pluck, something pick- holders can't do....but you get a unique sound playing with a pick...in my experience, it's guitar players who play bass with a pick.... But Paul seems to do this swipe thing with his thumb, just striking the string on the downstroke...
@edwardhill7297
@edwardhill7297 10 месяцев назад
@@ironwood9 I'm not a bass player but I've played guitar songs like that, just improving and jamming on an acoustic. It's a bit odd but it's fun
@Pmfried
@Pmfried 3 месяца назад
So, your biggest argument is that he looks down at his guitar in one performance, 10 years after another performance where he doesn't??? 🤣 & You really think his voice deteriorated between 1966 and 1976??? Come on!!! You can't say that "My Love" was anything but a vocal, lyrical masterpiece!!! Or even "Let 'Em In" or "Band On the Run" or many other of his songs from that era. Plus, in the old clip, he is singing it much like the original recording because it has just come out. In the 70's, he has "refined" the song to sing it in a more "sing-along"-friendly manner, since HE was the focus of the whole show (as opposed to the Beatles as a group). But I will give you the DEFINITIVE PROOF that it is the SAME PERSON.... Look closely at his EYES at ANY TIME of his life and compare it to ANY OTHER time of his life (they remain the same)! Paul's right eye is slightly "off angle" from his left eye! There is NO WAY this can be duplicated, neither naturally nor artificially, ESPECIALLY in 1966!!!
@mitch1847
@mitch1847 2 года назад
Yes, it's the same guy. Anyone with 2 working brain cells and a modicum of intelligence knows a grown man can change the color of his eyes, grow 2 inches in height, change playing style, have a different shaped head, and a different voice, all within a year. And anyone can make their left eye socket move up 1/2 inch. I've done that. It's easy. Not to mention the hair on his head. Some guys even have hairy gorilla arms, then a year later they're smoother with less hair. And some get forget when they joined the most successful band in the entire history of forever. Damn, just yesterday, 3 people called me Billy for no reason at all.
@Kelvinack
@Kelvinack 2 года назад
Color of eyes always depends on lighting and camera quality, a friend of mine whom I've known for 5 years once said to me she never noticed I had green eyes and always thought they were brown, height of a person depends on shoewear and for that matter Paul did seem to be a bit taller than the others even in early interviews with the "real" Paul, change playing style? You gotta be kidding me, he's a musician, trying out different things on an instrument, getting to know it better, Paul has the same voice in boths clips, but even if he didn't in the first he was 32 and in the second 23, your body and your voice changes in 9 years, also he's a singer who can try out new things on his songs, Michael Jackson also doesn't sing They Don't Care About Us the same way he sings Man In The Mirror, that thing with the eye socket is just ridiculous, Paul always had his Gorilla arms, look at the 1968 White Album picture collection, and do you know how people change their hair on their head? It's called a haircut, ever heard of it?
@codetech5598
@codetech5598 2 года назад
@@Kelvinack The differences cannot be explained by things like lights and hairstyles. There were multiple actors playing the role of "Paul" *right from the beginning.*
@rawnature5356
@rawnature5356 Год назад
WAKE UP,PAUL IS DEAD.
@garyenwards1608
@garyenwards1608 Год назад
ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-K-3ebH6SP8g.html
@georgeharrison243
@georgeharrison243 4 месяца назад
Paul didn't die..he just matured. As you get older your voice gets deeper. Someone said the teeth are different..maybe he had dental work done!! People will only see what they want to see. John changed more than paul..does that mean there was a fake John?? Just enjoy the music, the humour....The Beatles..it doesn't REALLY matter anyway....Let it be!!😉😁🎶🎼💗💖❤
@cisster76
@cisster76 8 месяцев назад
The real Paul is still alive. He has a band but I can’t recall the name of it but one can research him at his house
@asichka2
@asichka2 2 года назад
All i can say it is HAHAHAHAHAHAH,this imposter can't do anything,as i see in his eyes i could read''yesterday,you love him,but now you must love me!Me-me-me-me and you are fools and i can play with you like dolls!!!''
@trebleclef46
@trebleclef46 2 года назад
I have been a singer/ guitarist for 50 years..pro for 30. My voice has changed considerably since I was 20. I could sing higher then..but have better tone & control now. Amateurs judging how voice, tone and timing changes...and concluding it must be a different person, have not a clue what they are talking about.
@elizabethfonseca922
@elizabethfonseca922 2 года назад
These people are pathetic, this whole nonsense should have been over right after it started. There's been only one Paul McCartney.
@guitarvorous
@guitarvorous 2 года назад
You need to read more
@cliffheywood3671
@cliffheywood3671 2 года назад
@@elizabethfonseca922 no one plus bill shepherd
@mileswalcott7241
@mileswalcott7241 2 года назад
Everytime you conspiracy theories talk about Billy fall and James Paul McCartney you always use the song yesterday as your benchmark one of the most difficult songs to sing I've never heard you all try other songs like Elonara Rigby, night before ,And I love her or Michelle.
@guitarvorous
@guitarvorous 2 года назад
@@mileswalcott7241 there is no Paul. It was always Billie
@GodsMan500
@GodsMan500 Год назад
His head goes back in the first version because the mic is set very high. In the second version the mic is low. The looking at the fretboard is interesting, but it could be that he was better practiced in the second clip. I think most of the evidence supports that his death is a hoax, it is fun and harmless to speculate and wonder about it. The Beatles obviously had fun with it with all the “clues” they provided. I’m sure it also beefed up the sales numbers.
@Kieop
@Kieop 7 месяцев назад
There is nothing fun or harmless about PID. The original hoax may have been fun and harmless, but what it has evolved into is EVIL. Either Paul is dead and the entire music industry, government etc is complicit in perpetuating this massive fraud for some nefarious purpose, or he is alive and there is an equally evil conspiracy out there trying to convince people that he isn't for some equally nefarious purpose. This is not just a collective of individuals looking for clues. Someone is doctoring photos, reversing photos, making documentaries, writing new editions of The Memoirs. It's a massive effort. Why?
@luishumbertovega3900
@luishumbertovega3900 2 года назад
Mickey Braddock, of Circus Boy fame, was replaced by Micky Dolenz (see The Monkees).
@colkurtz8065
@colkurtz8065 2 года назад
This is when he was at the height of his powers.
@cliffheywood3671
@cliffheywood3671 2 года назад
who faul
@colkurtz8065
@colkurtz8065 2 года назад
@@cliffheywood3671 wha?
@harpar1028
@harpar1028 Год назад
@@cliffheywood3671 FAUL GUY
@PompeyMatt17
@PompeyMatt17 2 года назад
Given Billy Shears is a figment of people's imagination, tough call
@TimWrightt
@TimWrightt Год назад
"it is cuz i say so" - typical brainwashed slave
@rhrh2025
@rhrh2025 5 месяцев назад
Some of the vocal differences could be because of the mixing, but I'm hearing other differences and seeing them as well. During an interview in Australia, George referred to Paul as "Faul" and it's easy to understand. I've as always found that interview to be interesting!
@theodorpalmquist2036
@theodorpalmquist2036 Год назад
Wasn't it Ringo they called Bill Shears for the Sargent Pepper album? Cause in the beginning of the song "With A Little Help From My Friends" they sing Biiiiiiill Sheaaaars. I don't know.
@bojanstojanovic5465
@bojanstojanovic5465 10 месяцев назад
Billy Pepper and the Pepperpots.
@loraineashton4899
@loraineashton4899 11 месяцев назад
Paul is softer billy is harsh two very different types of people.
@marcobaretta
@marcobaretta 4 месяца назад
Real Paul is a nice guy. Billy is a criminal who has been fined and spent time in jail for drug possession and hangs about with international dictators like Putin. Very different people indeed.
@namronanilab9757
@namronanilab9757 Год назад
How I long for yesterday and Paul
@davidjames6551
@davidjames6551 10 месяцев назад
Never mind the difference in style just look at the difference in their ears, one has earlobes that are attached and the other one doesn't
@hermmentyller4397
@hermmentyller4397 Год назад
If Paul really died in 66 I have to say this Billy Shears is waaay better then him. Look at what they did from 67 on, and more specifically to what "Billy Shears" did. Come on! Billy is my favourite beatle hahaha.
@Rippaul1966
@Rippaul1966 Год назад
I agree, Billy was far more talented than Paul.
@philliptate148
@philliptate148 Год назад
Thing is there is 10 years or more difference in these videos. You can't expect the 65 live version to sound like the mid 70s versions. Paul is Paul not billy shears
@marcobaretta
@marcobaretta 4 месяца назад
Faul hangs around with Putin in the kremlin. You think he would not lie about identity theft. Come on man. As Joe Biden would say.
@2v_5r84
@2v_5r84 2 года назад
Billy Shears played Blackbird differently in 1968 compared to live performances in the 70s. He changed the key from G to F and sang it in a slightly different arrangement. This is indisputable proof that Billy Shears died and was replaced by a lookalike. In conclusion, Paul McCartney has been replaced at least two times.
@miriam2956
@miriam2956 2 года назад
so no one is aloud to play songs differently any more. If you DARE try you are automatically fake and a double.... where is the logic behind this nonsense?
@noemifrometa9310
@noemifrometa9310 2 месяца назад
Esta cancion me ha hecho llorar. ❤
@nobidocoolbeautynobu9278
@nobidocoolbeautynobu9278 2 года назад
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
@BugRib
@BugRib 2 года назад
Faul actually died in 1977 and was replaced by a Faul lookalike with extremely similar musical talents named "Ffaul". The current "Paul" is named "Fffffffaul". I guess it must be some kind of curse or something.
@Rippaul1966
@Rippaul1966 2 года назад
Lol idk if you’re joking or being serious but that’s halarious. I’m pretty sure it was just one faul tho
@jackdshellback3819
@jackdshellback3819 2 года назад
@@Rippaul1966 You make yourself look faulish with this ridiculous conspiracy nonsense.
@LaMYsteriosa87
@LaMYsteriosa87 Год назад
@@jackdshellback3819 Don't you know? 'Conspiracy' translates into 'truth'. Conspiracy theory is a phrase the C / A coined to prevent the truth/s (note: the lies/ the shady/criminal business of the establishment) from coming to light and being accepted by global consciousness. Every well-researched theory/statement proves to be the truth in the end. All truths passes through three stages. First, they are mocked and ridiculed, secondly they are violently opposed, and ultimately, they are accepted as being self-evident. It's just a matter of time.
@marcobaretta
@marcobaretta 4 месяца назад
@@jackdshellback3819 In the 1970's Faul gets into to trouble in Scotland for growing marijuana. Claims that he is none the wiser. In 1980 Faul is arrested for possessing drugs in Japan. He still boasts about it today. In 1984 Faul is fined 200 Barbados dollars for possessing drugs in Barbados. In 2001 Faul is seen in multiple photos walking alongside Putin. The guy who is committing a genocide in Ukraine now. A well proven track record of criminality and controversy. Proof he is not beneath lying. Identity theft for a guy like this. No problem.
@BugRib
@BugRib 2 месяца назад
@@Rippaul1966 - Haha, just being silly. 🤪
@VideoSaySo
@VideoSaySo Год назад
Paul sings from his diaphragm. Billy sings from his throat. Singers don't switch up like that with the same song.
@godjesus2107
@godjesus2107 20 дней назад
He spent time in Scotland a lot. That would explain his change in vocal tone.
@johnpaulacoustic
@johnpaulacoustic 3 дня назад
I couldn’t help but notice that Billy is sitting down whereas Paul is standing
Далее
Nobody Can Do it🚗❓
00:15
Просмотров 4,5 млн
НАМ ВРАЛИ О ПИРАТАХ
52:52
Просмотров 2,1 млн
Boots on point 👢
00:24
Просмотров 675 тыс.
Paul McCartney Carpool Karaoke
23:43
Просмотров 72 млн
Ringo Starr - Don't Pass Me By (Live)
4:22
Просмотров 700 тыс.
The Beatles - Rain
3:09
Просмотров 18 млн
The Bizarre Fan Theory Claiming Paul McCartney Is Dead
11:44
The Frost Interview - Paul McCartney: 'Still prancing'
47:18
The Beatles - Hey Jude
8:10
Просмотров 392 млн