I don’t know why anyone would take Pitchfork seriously. They are an old and tired publication that relies on style over substance criticism. If they don’t personally like the artist they will trash the art.
I really like the electro/krautrock vibe on the first track, I hope they keep going that way with future releases. And yeah Dylan's voice gets better and better going from his own voice to Milo Aukerman to Dez Cadena's time fronting Black Flag when he does the heavy growl