Тёмный

Physical or Virtual? Which is better?  

David Bombal
Подписаться 2,6 млн
Просмотров 214 тыс.
50% 1

#youtubeshorts #linux #windows

Опубликовано:

 

30 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 306   
@LouiseBrooksBob
@LouiseBrooksBob Год назад
Virtualisation is great until there is a need to operate a hardware peripheral which needs an onboard chip with certain interrupts.
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
Agreed. Always something that makes life difficult :(
@lyankondolourenco8077
@lyankondolourenco8077 Год назад
Se usares sistemas operacionais voltados para virtualização, nunca terás esse problema.
@balkan77forum66
@balkan77forum66 Год назад
@@davidbombal but drivers is probably problem in MacBook
@TobiasHeyl
@TobiasHeyl Год назад
That happens less frequently these days, also your Virtualization host might just pass devices through.
@hc3d
@hc3d Год назад
USB passthrough works wonderfully. Not sure about PCI passthrough though.
@antoineleduc7611
@antoineleduc7611 Год назад
Tbh if I had the money I’d just buy a machine for each 😂 Virtualisation is not a choice but an obligation for me
@emeraldArmy4267
@emeraldArmy4267 Год назад
i feel you
@hectorjuncal2312
@hectorjuncal2312 Год назад
If i had the money i would buy a better pc and maybe a laptop, but no more than one each, why would you want more? maybe there is a real reason, or would it be only cuz u can?
@JimLahey77
@JimLahey77 Год назад
@@hectorjuncal2312Because VMs are slow and obnoxious to use
@TobiasHeyl
@TobiasHeyl Год назад
@@JimLahey77 I strongly disagree. Working in this field for almost ten years and I admit I might be slightly biased, but after building loads of infrastructures that run fine to this day with many concurrent users in all kinds of environments I'm wondering what made you come to this conclusion. Are you talking about running VMs on your Desktop machine or at a larger scale?
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
Do you agree? Or have you got examples of apps or use cases that require access to hardware directly? Based on some of the comments, remember that if you are saying that virtualization is bad, then you are implying that you would buy four computers in this example instead of one. Also note that I am not saying you should use a Mac. I am showing an example of virtualization. I do use other platforms including ESXi and what I use depends on the usecase.
@bengrogan9710
@bengrogan9710 Год назад
I have found a few devices which do seem to require bare metal access - usually CAD/CAM software in industry which requires a physical hardware key for DRM authentication, often parralel or serial port originally, that refused passthough. In many cases this can be worked around by assigning a USB controller to the VM solely and working out what motherboard ports each controller hosts
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
Great example Ben. Thanks for sharing!
@cekart
@cekart Год назад
Retro gaming comes to mind David. MS-DOS games to be specific. There were certain games that wouldn't run right if you didn't have a Sound Blaster audio card. Others would requiere an Adlib audio card. I know that nowadays, DOSBOX is able to emulate those audio chipsets, but I believe the example still stands.
@cameronribeiro9660
@cameronribeiro9660 Год назад
It does makes sense but in order to do that your going to need a laptop that is as expensive ass all of those combined. I9 128G RAM ETC. Most laptops with that hardware are around $5000?
@jackjumpin6231
@jackjumpin6231 Год назад
Makes sense until you have a hardware issue.
@deurobone
@deurobone Год назад
What I do is I have a usb drive with basically every live boot iso on it, and can choose from them whenever I need. (Ventoy) For the security people, if needed you can just grab and throw. As long as the computer supports usb 3, I haven’t noticed any problems.
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
That is another option :) I think virtualization however gives you other benefits like being able to copy easily from one OS to another.
@R3laxMyGuy
@R3laxMyGuy Год назад
Can you implement several on one USB without getting a crash? I had a idea like this but in the end I just got 5 or 6 several USBs and then they got lost when I moved...
@R3laxMyGuy
@R3laxMyGuy Год назад
And my gf threw away my password paprr becose it looked like gibberish to her so she didnt think it was important so the usb that warent lost, I couldnt use anyway lol
@stuffing09
@stuffing09 Год назад
Just wondering what do you use windows 98 for?
@janno04
@janno04 Год назад
Hacking
@cekart
@cekart Год назад
​@@janno04 for hacking scammers
@kalMHe
@kalMHe Год назад
You are incredible David , the little things like this makes a-lot of sense for us to understand things!!!
@deth3021
@deth3021 Год назад
Wait why win98? Hopefully it is at least 98SE.
@TheCynysterMind
@TheCynysterMind Год назад
Nice work.. just came across this. I have over 100 VM's for testing.. going all the way back to DOS4, about 2 dozen linux distros, and yes even MAC VM's (takes some effort to run MAC OS on PC version of VMware but it is doable
@TheSxW
@TheSxW Год назад
its only good when you dont need any specific program (software) to run on them that need a specific things to be present on them.
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
Agreed. There are cases for installing directly on bare metal, but in most cases VMs work well. Any specific software you are using that requires a bare metal install?
@Tstark_
@Tstark_ Год назад
This is good advice but the hard ware has to be beefy enough to support all of those vms
@BlankBrain
@BlankBrain Год назад
You don't have to run them all at the same time.
@6891s
@6891s Год назад
i can’t run a virtualizer mac without suffer immense lag.
@laughingvampire7555
@laughingvampire7555 Год назад
even with vmware fusion? tbh in macos anything other than vmware fusion is a waste of time. time is more precious than the 50 dollar license.
@orisonik
@orisonik Год назад
Forgot one thing :) Mac has issues and causes problems with virtual Linux machines... The 2nd thing is - U need a really well equipped computer to run multiple virtual WIN machines simultaneously... btw no matter how strong Your hardware is - it gets limited to VM's software settings ... e.g. password cracking capabilities on VMs seem like a demo of what the generic hardware machine can do ........ same with network ....
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
If you don't virtualize, that means that you are going to have to buy four laptops in this example. Are you saying that is better?
@JerryGarciaPOBox
@JerryGarciaPOBox Год назад
​@@davidbombal nah, just several live iso images gives you the best of both worlds
@Rheaded
@Rheaded 10 месяцев назад
dual boot @@davidbombal
@andren5879
@andren5879 Год назад
ok now press f2 or alt+f4 or start key… hahaha 😂
@andren5879
@andren5879 Год назад
or upgrade the ram, or the disk, and I haven't even started talking about performance. Virtualization for the end user is a gimmick, not a solution
@RapsyJigo
@RapsyJigo Год назад
This advice is sort of missing the point of virtualization on personal hardware as it's mostly used to run programs that need certain OS. Therefore finding alternative programs for your OS or trying to get them to run as natively as possible on your OS before trying to virtualize will make them run much better as they will use your full hardware without limitations.
@BlankBrain
@BlankBrain Год назад
I have Garmin map software that only runs on XP. I gave up trying to make it run on a newer OS.
@hc3d
@hc3d Год назад
Virtualisation feels so wrong but it works so well. Graphical fluency is of course the weakness. But in rare cases you get decent graphical acceleration. CPU performance is basically unaffected. Memory slightly. Disk performance is affected the most (apart from graphics). Network performance is not affected at all.
@javabeanz8549
@javabeanz8549 Год назад
VMs are okay if you don't need great performance for a desktop. Servers are much better target for VMs. I have run multiple virtual desktop OSes before, but they weren't as capable as bare metal.
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
I am not saying that you should do this on a Mac. I am simply showing an example of virtualization. I do this on other platforms including ESXi or the cloud.
@vyathaen
@vyathaen Год назад
This is dumb. Unless you need 10s or 100s of low-resource VMs,its always better to have a separate machine for each OS. Nothing beats bare-metal performance.Also good virtualisation software with high-speed 3D performance costs more than all of these laptops...a month!
@julesvezern6374
@julesvezern6374 Год назад
I have Linux and Hackintosh (took some time learning driver stuff) on m’y laptop and use cloud computing for Windows (30€ month). Tried vm and was awfully slow.
@laughingvampire7555
@laughingvampire7555 Год назад
I prefer to run them directly on hardware, less abstraction is always better, that is why C is still the best programming language. The main problem with virtualization is that it requires beefy hardware. And if I'm going to virtualize something is not going to be on a mac. Is going to be on Linux where a virtualized macos runs faster than a macos on intel. Virtualization is great for the paranoid life with QubesOS
@chrstphrxmllr
@chrstphrxmllr Год назад
Virtualizing is never as good as bare metal. Every OS has a list of things that just don’t work well virtualized. Virtualization is good for testing and having a bit of fun but I’d way rather have my 3 laptops, one for each OS. Even on my desktop with double the ram of my laptops, if I virtualized and assigned more ram than the bare metal setup, it won’t run as well. Sure there are some benefits, but nothing beats bare metal setups in my experience when you actually want to use the OS and not just test or play around. I also prefer the dedicated hardware because I tend to use them more. Each laptop is its own little lab setup. I don’t like when the main machine has a problem now your stuck without any setup at all.
@Ghost00021
@Ghost00021 Год назад
I'm just a layman but isn't it really difficult virtualizing powerful graphics? I care about playing games, does it make sense to virtualize for this purpose?
@laughingvampire7555
@laughingvampire7555 Год назад
don't you mean is the opposite? virtualizing them is the inefficient way because they run slower, well maybe not the windows98 because even in a virtualbox it has more resources and cpu cycles than in a pentium chip. but for everyone else it sucks. I prefer to run windows 98 in an old ibm thinkpad
@JimLahey77
@JimLahey77 Год назад
Yeah well you’re not talking about input lag, choppy video and overall bad performance on VMs. Better to explain that before people install virtual box with 10 different os on it
@linuxxxunil
@linuxxxunil Год назад
Can’t just rattle off the word MacBook anymore without saying what year or whether it’s an intel or silicon MacBook
@AlexRubio
@AlexRubio Год назад
Well that's unless you want the security issues when you're running windows 98 I'll put that thing on anything CCP wouldn't want to hack my sh* cuz it's already opened 😭
@loicloic4989
@loicloic4989 Год назад
What kind of hypervisor do you use on MacBook ? Vmware workstation is not available on MacBook
@Palsanch
@Palsanch Год назад
Yes, but from the other side, if you one hardware MacBook die, all VM^s goes down. Keep an eyes open and think about safety.
@CommentGuard717
@CommentGuard717 Год назад
Yes but because of graphics cards my Intel i3 windows 7 laptop runs better than a new amd system virtualized
@V0ldemortV
@V0ldemortV Год назад
You shud do that if you got a very very very very good computer. But I don't know whi you want to have so much operating sistems.
@ATTIQ_OFFICIAL
@ATTIQ_OFFICIAL Год назад
bro i wanna know can we hack a wifi from termux?? if yes then how i also want to root my phone without a pc included in process i tried some apps but they failed my phone is tecno spark 7 kf6k
@kshaeta
@kshaeta Год назад
Can you run a Mac on a PC host? I thought the entire Apple headline was that the hardware and the software are designed together to work in unity. And can you just get a Mac license and run it on a PC?
@QuickBitMastery
@QuickBitMastery Год назад
I hope u can donate me a laptop, i was working as an online coding instructor thou i lost my job cuz i lost my laptop. I don't know wht to say
@caracolsalinas
@caracolsalinas Год назад
Which software Do you use yo virtualize?
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
In this example, I'm using VMware Fusion, but there are lots of options. Watch this video showing examples: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-7GGLi10sHDs.html
@caracolsalinas
@caracolsalinas Год назад
@@davidbombal thanks for answering!
@sprinter5901
@sprinter5901 Год назад
What if one of the VM gets affected by virus, will it spread to host and other VM?
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
That is possible. VMs are isolated, but you could connect them via a network or copy a file and get infected.
@sprinter5901
@sprinter5901 Год назад
@@davidbombal thank you for the response.
@ismailaslam7922
@ismailaslam7922 3 месяца назад
Bro how could you open that much machines in a one go? For me if i opened 2 machines then it's done for it 😂
@AliYar-Khan
@AliYar-Khan Год назад
Than Proxmox makes much more sense as it is more powerful than virtual box and vmware
@enykphotography
@enykphotography Год назад
I have a MacBook and I’m thinking of getting a windows laptop. Please how do I get all the VM on them
@flowerlinda1674
@flowerlinda1674 Год назад
David Dombal I have fine out way to get you for you to hack Aviator predictor for me..
@lauej
@lauej Год назад
You fail to explain why one would ever need to run all four operating systems ?
@user12122
@user12122 Год назад
You really should not show that only MAC can do that. Unsubscribed.
@eshendias6833
@eshendias6833 Год назад
sounds like you're trying to prove how powerful a macbook pro is. why tho?
@anaphaxeton
@anaphaxeton Год назад
Hehe don't underestimate the power of PS/2
@shuvstan
@shuvstan Год назад
So Mac is the best among all of them ??
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
Really depends on what you want to do. I think most people have a preference like Windows for games, Mac for graphics or blender or apps like that, Linux for a large number of tasks etc. All have strengths and weaknesses.
@n124ajdx
@n124ajdx Год назад
if are willing to learn just go for Linux, if you want the "just works system" go for Windows, in any case don't ever use Mac, it's just an overpriced scam like most things that Apple made
@JerryGarciaPOBox
@JerryGarciaPOBox Год назад
​​​@@n124ajdx 👍🏼 agree but don't really buy into "have to learn" comment on linux that I hear often. I jumped in with no explanation and just installed Debian on a new laptop having never used *nix before. I'm not very tech savvy but it was almost seamless from the start. Plus learning to use bash, awk, sed efficiently was really rewarding as opposed to a drag. Plus you can get away without learning most of that anyway. Just my. 02. That was almost 15yrs ago and I've not used a windoz or mac even once since. And yes, Apple makes overpriced fluff
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
I disagree with this. In my experience I've found that an Apple Mac is a good middle ground between Linux and Windows. I would love to use Linux for everything, but a lot of apps that I need including video editing don't run on Linux. I've also found that the M1/M2 changes the game with regards to Apple laptops - much better battery life, much cooler, much quieter etc compared to Intel. I use Windows, Linux, macOS, Cisco IOS, iOS, Android, ESXi and many other operating systems. All have good and bad, but each to their own :)
@mrpenk9720
@mrpenk9720 11 месяцев назад
windows natively on a thinkpad aith virtual linux ? so i dint have to flash the bios, or the other way around ?
@Mrahmed02495
@Mrahmed02495 Год назад
If you want a better performance I thing physical is a good choice, and if you looking for a lower cost I think virtualization is good
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
This is a great comment :)
@Mrahmed02495
@Mrahmed02495 Год назад
@@davidbombal Thanks David I appreciate your reply, and I learned from you.
@WUGH
@WUGH Год назад
How? And is it paid?
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
On Windows, you could use VirtualBox or VMware Workstation Player which are both free. On a Mac, you could use VMware Fusion for free as well.
@WUGH
@WUGH Год назад
@@davidbombal Thank you so much, I'm looking to learn some new stuff on Kali Linux
@ngawnmedia2747
@ngawnmedia2747 Год назад
What I do, even I don't laptop
@chaseisgame8768
@chaseisgame8768 Год назад
As long as you have enough disk space and their is a practical need to run all of those OS’s
@koyandesignenterprise3555
@koyandesignenterprise3555 Год назад
tripple boots....mine ubuntu,linux and windows 10
@evoli2708
@evoli2708 Год назад
i use tons of old physical pcs . still prefer native
@aviborse1
@aviborse1 Год назад
Wow!! WHats the config of the host machine wrt ram and cpu
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
This is an older Intel Mac with 32GB RAM, Intel i9 2.9 Ghz
@aviborse1
@aviborse1 Год назад
@@davidbombal Thank you so much David, Love your content. Much to learn.
@alisahin3166
@alisahin3166 Год назад
@@davidbombal What do you think of the newer ARM based MacBooks? Are they worth it or even better than the intel ones for virtualization?
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
Ali - See this video of me virtualizing ARM and emulating X86/X64 VMs on a M2 Macbook air: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-7GGLi10sHDs.html - however, I think if you want to virtualize x86/x64, then M1/M2 is probably not the way to go in my experience.
@chowderwhillis9448
@chowderwhillis9448 Год назад
@@davidbombal you think I’m crazy to still use my old 2011 retina model MacBook Pro with only 8gb ram and I have no idea what chipset but it still runs, I’ve also got the iMac desktop i7 with 64 go RAM lol but I still love my old MacBook Pro
@aminvand
@aminvand Год назад
Virtualizing without hardware passthrough is a joke
@bobgreene2892
@bobgreene2892 Год назад
What virtualizer do you use to create your VM's?
@hc3d
@hc3d Год назад
Parallels is great, maybe the best one on mac. Ubuntu ran butter smooth on my old macbook pro.
@paulrebellion9548
@paulrebellion9548 Год назад
Hate to be that guy but... No fun in having only one computer
@maanooj
@maanooj Год назад
Hi...Which one is more efficient to run multiple os according to you......vmware or aws....i have read somewhere vmware ruin ram& memory in longterm so i am using aws to run Ubuntu...... please share your view
@punkerts7711
@punkerts7711 Год назад
How many computers do you have? Only five in one!
@davidl8523
@davidl8523 Год назад
Biggest flaw in your plan: you're using a mac :)
@hauke2996
@hauke2996 Год назад
For what you need win98 etc? I mean the old systems.
@daneberryman
@daneberryman Год назад
While true having the real machine, gets you more ladies
@anomalytm05
@anomalytm05 Месяц назад
I'd buy physical if I had the money.
@SumitSharma-bb6cb
@SumitSharma-bb6cb Год назад
Can all these VMs can be hosted on an 12th gen i3 laptop??
@Birumarekt
@Birumarekt Год назад
But virt on mac is still meh I would rather go for esxi
@WiFi2021
@WiFi2021 Год назад
All your eggs in one basket, 🧺 so when the basket breaks, all your eggs are gone 🤦🤦🤦🤦 scrap apple, useless anyway.... And work PC's are cheap enough.
@unknownworld8238
@unknownworld8238 Год назад
Then explain how should I use the software that wont work on virtual machine!
@js0988
@js0988 Год назад
There is absolutely NOTHING nice about Mac OS! Unless you enjoy nightmares!
@WelcomeToTheRezvolution
@WelcomeToTheRezvolution Год назад
I thought the fuy was flexing what he had for a moment 😅
@mworld
@mworld Год назад
Sure, but you need lots of ram to do anything useful.
@issamboutallaa8722
@issamboutallaa8722 Год назад
hey, can i ask about the laptop models you were using for win11 and linux..... and about the mac too which version ?
@arvindian
@arvindian Год назад
what are the downsides?
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
You need a PC that can support virtualization :)
@alisahin3166
@alisahin3166 Год назад
@@davidbombal Which PC can’t support that?
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
Some devices don't support vTX / AMDv. You definitely want one that supports that.
@cYrusplays6
@cYrusplays6 Год назад
Legends using triple, Quadro boot
@kostya8764
@kostya8764 Год назад
Smh how would I run games from each OS?
@jhromeror
@jhromeror Год назад
And that is why virtualization has been around for decades now! :-)
@firaswazeer3488
@firaswazeer3488 Год назад
Can you please make a video explaining how to do so?
@_ishowfuture_
@_ishowfuture_ Год назад
Search "how to make your own hacking lab" of networkchuck
@chowderwhillis9448
@chowderwhillis9448 Год назад
Agreed hope he does
@OneBikeForAll
@OneBikeForAll Год назад
Damn right David! Not long ago I wouldn’t budge. But damn … you are right!
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
Happy to hear that! It's just another option in our toolbox. Sometimes bare metal is best, other times virtualization :) Use the best tool for the job.
@OneBikeForAll
@OneBikeForAll Год назад
@@davidbombal Yup, also when you are young brat with all the time to spare on separate bare metal machines but no money and later in your life maybe having deep pockets but no time :) Catch 22 for most, ain’t it just brutally beautiful life :) Cheers !
@vince943
@vince943 Год назад
*Please do a video on the outcome/and or opinions of the recent lay-off news circulating from the Big Tech giants if you would be kind, as I feel it would keep novices intrigued in still pursuing these types of careers. Thank you 😊.*
@paulscott3802
@paulscott3802 Год назад
Folks need to know they'll need a CPU that can support virtual servers.. 💡
@Abdirahmaann
@Abdirahmaann Год назад
David I prefer physical Always
@mar-tin702
@mar-tin702 Год назад
You just need so sell a kidney to buy it and you all set
@hauke2996
@hauke2996 Год назад
But why you have so much laptops than ? ;-)
@digitalemotionfilms
@digitalemotionfilms Год назад
Why not a Mac virtual machine 😂
@MichaelMantion
@MichaelMantion Год назад
the best part is if the computer is stolen or dies, you lose everything. Also if you want to use screens at once you can't. For the price of that mac you can have multiple computers running linux with redundant virtual machines.
@gabrielescaramuzzo
@gabrielescaramuzzo Год назад
the point is not the max, it's the vms. It doesn't matter whether they run on his macbook, a gaming pc or a 200$ windows laptop.
@earflow4300
@earflow4300 Год назад
The RAM!! 98 memory is small but still.. the RAM!
@davidbombal
@davidbombal Год назад
lol... So little is needed for Windows 98 :)
@LordRuth3rford
@LordRuth3rford Год назад
Virtual Machines for the win!
@wockehs
@wockehs Год назад
What virtualisation software are you using on your Macbook?
@joanjett69697
@joanjett69697 Год назад
They’re not running on the new M1 chips
@andrei.tazetdinov
@andrei.tazetdinov Год назад
M1-2 is so sucks for virtualisation 😢
@LuvxJacqu4li8e
@LuvxJacqu4li8e Год назад
Lol you're a network guy or a vm guy
@Davinci637
@Davinci637 8 месяцев назад
Este Video Está Realmente Increíble.
@SAGEFPATHS9
@SAGEFPATHS9 Год назад
I don't understand. Wouldn't this stress the 1 computer to the max?
@SAGEFPATHS9
@SAGEFPATHS9 Год назад
How does Virtualizing able to use your other hardware for the main pc?
@mosabsh511
@mosabsh511 Год назад
the question is, what is the point ?
@ThatGuy68580
@ThatGuy68580 Год назад
So the mac is that powerful?
@AntiMason
@AntiMason 10 месяцев назад
You must have a shit ton of RAM
@theproperfix
@theproperfix Год назад
Why do we need to run outdated OS, are you testing applications on them ?
@cekart
@cekart Год назад
It's to hack the scammers
@justincase9471
@justincase9471 Год назад
Yeah that will work great on Apple's ARM processors.
@tunnandaaung2
@tunnandaaung2 Год назад
NaH I rather use native
@jameskurk5668
@jameskurk5668 Год назад
Unless it is a Mac. I mean wtf?
@fluffybunny510
@fluffybunny510 Год назад
But MAC ssd is limited
@TraderSnoopy
@TraderSnoopy Год назад
Terabyte RAM required 😂
@jsjzjzebxjxjjzz
@jsjzjzebxjxjjzz Год назад
pls make vedio on advance pentest or red team
Далее
TailsOS Guide For The Ultra Paranoid
35:32
Просмотров 436 тыс.
WSL 2: Getting started
20:34
Просмотров 713 тыс.
NEVER install these programs on your PC... EVER!!!
19:26
Flipper Zero vs "Proper" Hacking Tools
40:02
Просмотров 276 тыс.
When you Accidentally Compromise every CPU on Earth
15:59
Are Linux Smartphones about to KILL Android?
11:19
The Linux Experience
31:00
Просмотров 1,1 млн
Why VPNs are a WASTE of Your Money (usually…)
14:40
I've never seen ANYTHING like this before... Temple OS
17:57
Mac vs Windows - Who Wins in 2024?
17:11
Просмотров 8 млн