Тёмный

Politics In Singapore - What Needs To Change? 

Inconvenient Questions
Подписаться 7 тыс.
Просмотров 62 тыс.
50% 1

4G leadership - can we expect a more level playing field? Is the system fair? Is it transparent? Is the government running out of ideas? Will the new prime minister have the full backing of his team? Will he become party secretary-general before the election?
Veteran journalist Bertha Henson in a no-holds barred interview with IQ Chief Editor and former NMP Viswa Sadasivan.

Опубликовано:

 

10 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 312   
@user-fy1bl4hv3g
@user-fy1bl4hv3g 18 дней назад
Thank you for inviting Bertha. All of us really wants this country and it people to succeed. Bertha unlike many observers of the political is more passionate about it. It is also good to sound out the issues that might have overlooked.
@Mrnonolol
@Mrnonolol 18 дней назад
She is right about transparency issues
@pengui6152
@pengui6152 17 дней назад
On the contrary, it is the opposition party lacking transparency and tried in many instances to hide the misconduct of its MPs.
@Mrnonolol
@Mrnonolol 17 дней назад
@@pengui6152 when lhl knew about tcj indiscretion he should have fired him on the spot. I’m sure lky would have done that
@caseyneistat2371
@caseyneistat2371 17 дней назад
​@@pengui6152u're so blind that u didn't even noticed LHL admit that he kept it a secret for YEARS !
@LonganLee
@LonganLee 17 дней назад
But who is empowered by the majority?
@gavinmoey7461
@gavinmoey7461 17 дней назад
Aiyo, Viswa, let the woman talk. Don’t keep cutting her off.
@yangwei1157
@yangwei1157 17 дней назад
Viswa seems more eager to express his views than listening to what Bertha has to say. 😂
@douglasstanley5209
@douglasstanley5209 14 дней назад
@@yangwei1157 That's what I felt too. The initial part was ok. He listened and interrupted Bertha to be more specific. Subsequently, he seems to direct the interview by expressing his opinion and seek an agreement from Bertha.
@Stephen16141st
@Stephen16141st 12 дней назад
Ah pls la you 2, go join Kenneth at his Reforming Parties with ur glasses of ribena ... and true, Viswah may hv had 1 too many, interrupting n imposing....
@keejoseph3145
@keejoseph3145 12 дней назад
This guy just loves his own voice. Bad mediator.
@jemmeteo
@jemmeteo 5 дней назад
@@douglasstanley5209 exactly!
@banyakbanyak3625
@banyakbanyak3625 День назад
Thank you Bertha, thank you for your passion of Singapore.
@irarelycomment767
@irarelycomment767 18 дней назад
contrary to a lot of the criticism here, i thought bertha brought up a lot of good points. viswa needs to improve his questioning style as an interviewer. he needs to understand this interview is not about him, it's about bertha.
@shurakishi4707
@shurakishi4707 16 дней назад
he's being a moderator and he is steering the interview by giving flash points and having bertha then expand upon and navigate further.
@karenkwok583
@karenkwok583 16 дней назад
Yes agree! I didn't like the way he kept interrupting Bertha, and she on some questions didn't finish answering them completely! I think the interviewer was kind of rude .🙄
@douglasstanley5209
@douglasstanley5209 14 дней назад
I concurred ! He should be interviewing and not driving his opinion for an agreement.
@prakhashpereira1437
@prakhashpereira1437 11 дней назад
😅​@@karenkwok583
@jeantan417
@jeantan417 8 дней назад
Viswa was pandering to the incumbents, I think Bertha nailed it on several topics. Viswa was whitewashing. He basically said we can trust that PAP will do good. Erm, against what Bertha was sharing,
@mlim7630
@mlim7630 18 дней назад
Host is interruptive. More of interviewee rather than interviewer in this session
@MathewTip
@MathewTip 18 дней назад
Yes I would concur..
@richardwong2221
@richardwong2221 18 дней назад
I also agree
@k.w.k314
@k.w.k314 17 дней назад
Yes, who is interviewing who?
@AlexYing-pq1xk
@AlexYing-pq1xk 17 дней назад
I agree! She had to tell him she was trying to explain. This isn’t a debate. The host talked too much!
@Time4Peace
@Time4Peace 18 дней назад
I find the host interrupting too much stopping the flow of answers.
@karenkwok583
@karenkwok583 16 дней назад
Absolutely agree with you!
@stingray9225
@stingray9225 14 дней назад
Papig man.
@vicpua
@vicpua 14 дней назад
The biggest challenge for Lawrence Wong is to get those colleagues who think they are smarter than him behind him.
@cutecuteoldold
@cutecuteoldold 18 дней назад
Bertha Henson besides being an excellent ex editor and journalist has an unequal brilliant mind. She is a treasure trove of wisdom
@douglasstanley5209
@douglasstanley5209 14 дней назад
Maybe she should go create an icon or a brand for SG.
@Jackpot1711
@Jackpot1711 18 дней назад
VS... I love your shows.. very informative 💯
@Hs5687
@Hs5687 18 дней назад
He’s Trying his best to remain Relevant knowing PAP is now Obedient & under Control 😊
@rogerchung260
@rogerchung260 17 дней назад
What is perplexing is she came inside the system. No experience outside non-govt linked organisations, what optical experience does she has on organizational change?? Working for SPH ...isn't a frontier organization for dynamic critical assessment of political leadership or organization weaknesses.
@shurakishi4707
@shurakishi4707 16 дней назад
No big idea in Singapore is because increasingly, there is nothing much Singapore can actually offer. Cities and countries can catch up to Singapore - slowly, but surely. We have some manufacturing but not major enough to make waves in the world. We have no farming or agriculture. We just have people. How much do you expect people can produce or innovate if it is just people as a resource? It will be easy to replicate. We talk about innovation, wanting to change, but what is there for us to change when we are not producers of anything much? Will the world demand of our services or products? Who will when there are better and more varied alternatives elsewhere? I am not trying to be optimistic, but singapore better be on its toes and the people better be careful cos come few elections down the road and the world becomes more and more different, we may very well lose out position and placing in this world.
@kelvincheng5901
@kelvincheng5901 16 дней назад
Good observation and point...already there is a feeling that S'poreans are becoming too proud and complacent and turning into "a little island with smug people". Pride comes before a fall. Of course many countries would love to be in S'pore's position but there is a problem with high cost which is affecting not just individuals but businesses as well. On the micro level, ncreasingly I see S'poreans being priced out of the good "middle income" life that many aspire too, esp the older generation like myself. I can't speak for the younger generation but among my contemporaries and peers, many have expressed the view that it's better for us to move away as the island state is becoming more and more expensive and not conducive for retirement.
@kokwahchan8478
@kokwahchan8478 14 дней назад
Our Ministers/ex-Ministers must understand they are not elitists. A large number of them are recipients of government scholarships. Now that they made it financially, both they and their family members ought to remember their "ROOTS" and serve the country whole-heartedly without ALWAYS consider BIG payout for their effort or intelligence or talent.
@rahmandeenato2587
@rahmandeenato2587 10 дней назад
Please do more of this kind of interview. We need more constructive interview and eye opening ideas that can develop for our nation.
@kokwahchan8478
@kokwahchan8478 14 дней назад
We should categorise all parties, other than the ruling party, as non-ruling. There should be no opposition as we are all Singaporeans, fighting for the same survival, economic, political causes.
@leolee1959
@leolee1959 3 часа назад
Why put a label to describe political parties ? Just address them by their party names.
@miqaayil
@miqaayil 18 дней назад
There's a sports term .."You can only beat the team that's infront of you" , the stability that we are blessed with is also the greatest friction to change.
@LonganLee
@LonganLee 17 дней назад
Lack of IQ is
@douglasstanley5209
@douglasstanley5209 14 дней назад
haha. Now you have our Asean neighbour to watch. Malaysia, Indonesia, Thailand, Vietnam are catching up. Soon we don't even know who has eaten our lunch.
@nicrome
@nicrome 5 дней назад
When she was editor at TNP, TNP really tried pushing on investigative journalism in Singapore, despite being a tabloid with all its tabloidish-ness. In an alternate reality, if she was editor in ST, would there have been an alternate reality of a stronger, more investigative press in SG?
@keejoseph3145
@keejoseph3145 12 дней назад
Bertha is just amazing with her own colloquial and singlish thrown in. The host on the other hands seems to be trying getting Bertha to believe in his own ideal.
@philphay
@philphay 3 дня назад
Wonderful conversation and insights from these two veteran journalists.
@vincenta3aaang75
@vincenta3aaang75 17 дней назад
Hope she is not advocating that our political leaders abandon what works for us.
@caseyneistat2371
@caseyneistat2371 17 дней назад
Not all change is bad . Not all status quo is positive. Look at the hdb prices. Pap and most sporeans have forgotten HDB is public housing .
@michaeltan2222
@michaeltan2222 18 дней назад
Why is continuity bad? Is it not too premature to state that Lawrence Wong and his team have no big idea? It’s one month into their new role. Make the call a year after the next election. For now stay the course, is not a bad idea.
@malita354
@malita354 18 дней назад
Shows you are part of the problem.
@malita354
@malita354 18 дней назад
The guest is saying what she observed today, till now. So of course in the future anything is possible. What she said is based on her observations. So the Fact remains and you cannot debunk her. Singapore has no Big Ideas up to today
@malita354
@malita354 18 дней назад
Oh that's because you are not the 40%. So you totally don't understand the 40%. Blinded
@LonganLee
@LonganLee 18 дней назад
SG does not belong to anyone person's grandfather. The supreme law of the land gives voters the power to change leaders if they deem it's needed. It's human nature those benefitting a lot to not want change. It's also natural that those who disapprove several policies and seeing no signs of change possible to want to send a signal to the establishment. You need to change the SG Constitution to remove this power and then you can sleep in peace. Ban elections and you can have no change. Or migrate to China and enjoy dictatorship under one party. Don't be selfish. If the 40% wants change that's their legal rights. 40% deserves a proportional representation in parliament seats which is Not the Case Now. Next time you not happy with the 40%, don't tell them to leave SG. Tell them to Vote Them Out! Understand? Don't fool them to leave SG and leave SG with only anti-diversity-of-views people. We don't need bigots in sg
@lucretius8050
@lucretius8050 18 дней назад
That's why they change hands just a little before an election, such that it'll play into one's uneasiness when people decide on their votes.
@alvinal1345
@alvinal1345 18 дней назад
By promoting Murali says a lot about Lawrence actually. Unless that was not his decision.
@timloo6191
@timloo6191 18 дней назад
Then whom he would promote? Talking is cheap you know
@Mrnonolol
@Mrnonolol 18 дней назад
Where she is wrong is that it’s ok to be multifaceted. Policies is not meant to be clear to people who don’t need it, it’s meant to effect change to that targeted group. And by structure it will be complex
@LM-uu8hy
@LM-uu8hy 10 дней назад
"My way of seeing it is this. He has been picked so we should give him the best support we can" Huh??? We should if he does a good job but not because he was the chosen one?
@The11061984
@The11061984 13 дней назад
She is sharp rather than clear. The core problem is a lack of core belief.
@kokwahchan8478
@kokwahchan8478 14 дней назад
I humbly suggest putting up SMCs for a re-election every 2 years to evaluate whether the incumbent MP is competent/ relevant in his/her duty?
@threelameduck3043
@threelameduck3043 9 дней назад
So the problem is Singapore too structurally good people don't know what to complain!
@STConsultancy
@STConsultancy 17 дней назад
at the end of the interview, she doesnt seem to know that LW was selected after support from his colleagues had been established
@Bryan-dr5qy
@Bryan-dr5qy 14 дней назад
I think her point was about transparency. It's one thing to say that behind closed doors he's got the support, but it's another for him to actually get elected as SG of the party and to carry the ground in the election in clear view of all his colleagues behind him.
@kawikaseet5816
@kawikaseet5816 16 дней назад
Put HDB policy back to the basic principle n target Affordable public housing for all Singaporeans n not compete with private real estate companies 99 year lease for the first buyer n transferable to immediate off brings to continue another 99 year lease Affordable rental from HDB is a second priority
@summerapple7062
@summerapple7062 5 дней назад
Leasehold property means once time is up, the lease will revert back to the landowner. What you are suggesting is a perpetual leasehold ie equivalent to a freehold property. You pay peanuts and you expect to stay in a freehold property in land scarce Singapore? There are 2 types of HDB rental right now. Rental by HDB or by owner. Rental by HDB is already very affordable. Are you suggesting government to intervene for rental by owner too?
@leolee1959
@leolee1959 2 часа назад
One of the reasons why Sg $ has such high exchange rates vis-a-vis neighbouring nations; is due to the value of Singapore's real estate. Their corporations - large and small have no faith in their currencies. They and MANY global corporations 'parked' their capital in Singapore-domiciled banks. This made Singapore the No. 2 Direct Foreign Investment destination by US $ valuation. No. 1 is USA because only she can print US $. Think about that. It isn't China or Japan or Germany. How much US $ is remitted to their respective state-domiciled banks due to their economic output ? Yet Singapore is miles ahead of No. 3, China. Why ? It is almost a certainty; many of these Letters of Credit are directly paid into the respective corporations banks accounts domiciled in a bank located inside Singapore's jurisdiction. There must be a mind-boggling sum of $$$$$$$$$$ being remitted daily to banks located in Singapore. I can safely guess most of the motivation stems from Tax Planning or Tax Evasion for a truer meaning; especially for US Corporations. I can also guess many of these corporations accept payments in Sg $$$$$$ to avoid scrutiny by US Federal Reserve or Authorities. The impact of so much Sg $ being 'internationalise" must be mind-boggling. But it has a huge benefit for a small economy; the currency attracts high demand. Or literally speaking, our monetary authority can write Sg $1 M paper or digital cheques and there would be a queue of folks lined up to buy. For a nation that has to import ALL its commodities to feed, clothe and house citizens, this translate into buying other folks materials & output; at a cheap price. This reduces the cost of tiles for an MRT project or your home renovation. This sort of gives one an idea why Prime Minister Mahathir was so cheesed-off at the price Singapore paid for Malaysian water - when converted to Sg $$$$$. He would be much less cheesed-off if 3 Malaysian sens is = 9 Singapore cents. Then he can crowed every morning what a bunch of ass-holes economists - are doing over in Singapore. In conclusion - the insinuation is - Mahathir IS the ass-hole. If the TOTAL real estate values in Singapore is pathetically under-valued, overseas folks would have MUCH LESS confidence in our $$$$; because some of those liquid cash are certainly being converted into real estate holdings to earn capital returns ( there's no capital-gains tax - if you're savvy enough ). As a HDB owner, you buy 2 or maybe 3 units in your life time; but you need to eat everyday. Just compare the price of a plate of fried Hokkien Mee in Singapore and in Johore Bahru. It probably cost 10 Malaysian Ringgit and 5 Singapore Dollars. Unit for unit comparison, it costs twice as much to eat take-out food in Johore. Dont forget, an Malaysian employee do not earn twice - in unit terms - the monthly salary of his equivalent job-holder in Singapore. This subject - HDB pricing - is something not easily understood by common folks who struggle daily under a salary only to see foreigners living in up-scale condos, driving flashy cars and dining in expensive restaurants. Citizens of Zurich (Switzerland), Honolulu (Hawaii), Monte Carlo (France) lived with the same problem - ie; Envy. "money" parks there; citizens KNOW it and the worse effect is - they DON'T get to spend any of it. You can always get a 2nd job - as a citizen there are no restrictions. Many foreign employment-pass holders wished they could but Sg laws forbid it. There is plenty of reasonably well-paid occupations on a part-time job basis. PLENTY of other cities would loved the position enjoyed by this city-state Singapore. There is no dispute over this. We just have to work our asses off - there's no choice on this subject.
@tenwhite769
@tenwhite769 18 дней назад
Bertha is quite unsure at times and it gave impression that she has nothing concrete and is trying to stir issues for sake of it.
@timloo6191
@timloo6191 18 дней назад
Like one guy across the causeway regarding his country
@Hs5687
@Hs5687 18 дней назад
This Channel sometimes “ Stirs” for Good 😌
@beezlebub9
@beezlebub9 17 дней назад
Wah so many IBs stirred up to come here because they feel so insecure.
@caseyneistat2371
@caseyneistat2371 14 дней назад
PAP didn't pfoma her.. So what does that say ? 🤔
@leslieho6378
@leslieho6378 18 дней назад
Not all are good, some even goes backwards instead of improvement. Especially the customer service, not every 😅 things can be done through digital or AI services... It seems like very rigid, and are not helpful in answering problems. After all still need customer services officer assistant to answer the call. It take up a lot of unnecessary times and it is not improving but backwards in services. Certainly things digital can't give you answers to enquiry left more doubts and frustrated. This are the set backs in this digital Age.
@superconnie5003
@superconnie5003 8 дней назад
We are No.1 who wants to change the blue print..who dares?
@tcmelvinlee4804
@tcmelvinlee4804 16 дней назад
Very interesting conversation!
@mosesng1109
@mosesng1109 16 дней назад
'If you expect the world to be fair with you because you are fair, you're fooling yourself. That's like expecting the lion not to eat you because you didn't eat him' 🤣🤣🤣
@HC-mr4mb
@HC-mr4mb 11 дней назад
Don't know what you all talking about here. All kinds of surveys reported by MSM always shows majority of Singaporean are happy and everything is affordable. It must be true, otherwise will get pofma.
@lightspeeder
@lightspeeder 17 дней назад
The part on the scripted parliament is spot on
@ziaohaha
@ziaohaha 15 дней назад
Hey, Singapore is one of a kind lah! She came into this world still-born and yet survived! Singapore's politicians must be special; think smart and careful like the pioneers and founding fathers. There is none other in the world to compare with Singapore therefore, this small successful nation has no margin for errors. Singapore is a tight rope walker balancing 1000 meters high up between efficacy and chaos, any slight imbalance will result in a huge splash of blood, flesh and bones (no more little red dot lah!) on the hard concrete pavement down below. Ha-ha-ha! Cheers🍺🍺🍺
@godfreytan1001
@godfreytan1001 19 часов назад
I agree the interviewer should let Bertha speak instead of him pushing his discussion agenda.
@Humorousguy64
@Humorousguy64 17 дней назад
She did brought out the IRSWRAN and TAN case which is abit uncleared really good and daring...their cases should not be under carpet
@pengui6152
@pengui6152 17 дней назад
The scandal involving ruling party MPs was uncovered through the party's own internal checks and was transparently revealed in parliament by the party itself. None of these revelations were initiated or discovered by the opposition. In contrast, the opposition tried to conceal scandals involving their MPs when their leader became aware of the issue. It wouldn't be surprising if more scandals involving opposition party are uncovered when the metaphorical carpet is lifted.
@pengui6152
@pengui6152 18 дней назад
I would like to ask her, being an ex-journalist for more than 20 years, to name me which country has levered and fair political ground for opposition party.
@Praetorian157A
@Praetorian157A 18 дней назад
So true. She is one of those Neo-Libs now an also-rans.
@arcencielc2065
@arcencielc2065 18 дней назад
WP would do the same lah if it forms the govt... god forbidden... after I pass on, please.
@SivalinPuthery
@SivalinPuthery 18 дней назад
According to opposition parties here, US wor. Free and fair stolen elections
@lucretius8050
@lucretius8050 18 дней назад
If you ask an AI, majority of Nordic countries, Switzerland and New Zealand have the fairest systems. And what's the point of your question?
@ShinobiWarrior007
@ShinobiWarrior007 17 дней назад
what the hell is your point? many political systems such as the UK or the West are more fair than what PAP does, are you trying to carrying balls from the PAP? Did you hang your balls in the PAP office ?
@michaelliu2258
@michaelliu2258 15 дней назад
It's really not an impartial interview. Why do i have this feeling she's really unhappy or upset because she's "ousted" from her lifelong job by a new editor.
@AhLiang08
@AhLiang08 17 дней назад
I disagree with her assessment on the last 2 PMs, and I challenge her to use her own scorecard to assess them. LKY era produced HDB, CPF, SBS, SMRT etc. The rest? GST, ERP, COE? 😮 If I sum up her best points: transparency and accountability, let's hope people vote based on their best interests. Absolutely demand for your East, West, North, South coast plan! Moving forward though, because we are first world, we need more QUALITATIVE scoring. Where's the PURPOSE and LEADERSHIP because seems like only gahmen exempt from skills upgrading and productivity drive. With AI and this new thing called computers, maybe just maybe, we should wonder why GST needs to increase to serve the same population?
@solvenet
@solvenet 18 дней назад
13:45 im trying to answer lah babe 😂
@ownthegame3
@ownthegame3 17 дней назад
took me a few starts and stops to watch the interview it reiterates and emphasises why i dun follow politics too closely and get emotional there are more constructive ways to spend time and help SG to succeed in other ways
@ehchua6391
@ehchua6391 16 дней назад
In the 60s we had iconic Quests, The Stray Dogs etc. Have less govt control & interferance.
@douglasstanley5209
@douglasstanley5209 14 дней назад
We also have talent times in the 70s but now what have many talents but no time.
@user-iv8ch6jb3q
@user-iv8ch6jb3q 17 дней назад
The most important policy for now is to come out a marriage policy for Bertha so that her to keep her mouth stuck. Wasted few mins listening to her 80s - 90s view.
@franciscody9622
@franciscody9622 4 дня назад
Without openness and transparency in government cannot really say what is good.
@kokwahchan8478
@kokwahchan8478 14 дней назад
Fundamental issue with this present Govt is accountability. Scrape the notion of collective leadership. Let individual Ministry => Minister, SMS, MS, PPS, PS be entirely responsible for their actions.
@LingtbJ
@LingtbJ 18 дней назад
To be on the pessimistic side, probably LKY/1G leaders are the only visionaries 🤷🏻‍♂️ Singapore will have
@malita354
@malita354 18 дней назад
Good joke of the day
@SivalinPuthery
@SivalinPuthery 18 дней назад
Vote for Trump! Migrate to the US via Mexico!
@Yang_man608
@Yang_man608 17 дней назад
And they are still milking the goodwill of LKY's team, spending unnecessary money with all the Founders memorial thing, when LKY explicitly mentioned no statue whatsoever
@kelvincheng5901
@kelvincheng5901 16 дней назад
Actually it's ok to milk the goodwill of past leaders who have been instrumental in bringing Spore to what it is today...all countries do that. But it's a different thing altogether to spend extravagantly on building monuments, while at the same time harping on financial prudence. Somehow it just doesn't click.
@malita354
@malita354 15 дней назад
@@Yang_man608 do tax payers care? See my point?
@CharlesTay
@CharlesTay 18 дней назад
Good interview
@kawikaseet5816
@kawikaseet5816 5 дней назад
Thank you for your update My information are at least outdated or incorrect in some parts Surely you will agree some parts of HDB policies of late are getting out of the original intent of public housing for all Singaporeans BTO needs to be tweeted to operate more fairly and efficiently
@tanemily9604
@tanemily9604 14 дней назад
Frankly speaking, who is the interviewer and who is being interviewed? Vis, you are frequently interrupting Berta and putting your opinion into the topics being discussed. This is not a forum but an interview for Gods sake !😮 15:13
@williamkwah1
@williamkwah1 12 дней назад
Viswa well done, you are better than BBC host.
@Stephen16141st
@Stephen16141st 12 дней назад
Nonsense
@kokwahchan8478
@kokwahchan8478 14 дней назад
May I suggest that those non-Ministerial caliber MPs will have to perform full-time as an MP? And revamp the existing RC Manager system to better serve the constituents ==> CEO People’s Association ?
@Jackpot1711
@Jackpot1711 18 дней назад
Hi VS ... do you think it's possible to interview LHL or GCT...
@sglearning5996
@sglearning5996 15 дней назад
Know how to talk only blame but cannot do do be fool by this interview motive
@kokwahchan8478
@kokwahchan8478 14 дней назад
Dr Tan See Leng took a large pay cuts to join politics. He must have loved the country and the people for this decision. Not just about the Govt trusting him. Please credit Dr Tan with that bold decision of his!
@douglasstanley5209
@douglasstanley5209 14 дней назад
Ya. We need private sector leaders to join and contribute to the SG Gov and not private sector asking what the SG Gov can do for them.
@deangoh3997
@deangoh3997 18 дней назад
very incoherent responses from Bertha... even Viswa looks perplexed at times
@caseyneistat2371
@caseyneistat2371 17 дней назад
I think both u and him are confused easily
@AlexYing-pq1xk
@AlexYing-pq1xk 17 дней назад
Bertha is very clear. This isn’t a debate so why was VS talking so much Bertha had to tell him she was trying to explain.
@Hs5687
@Hs5687 17 дней назад
Actually they Complement each other Well 😊
@beezlebub9
@beezlebub9 17 дней назад
What exactly was incoherent?
@douglasstanley5209
@douglasstanley5209 14 дней назад
@@AlexYing-pq1xk .... "Because, I'm trying to answer, babe."
@patrickjeow
@patrickjeow 17 дней назад
You think is so easy to manage a country. I won’t want any of the present opposition politicians to run country. Talk is cheap. If she think that she is so right, why don’t she stand for the coming election? For me the government should quietly work and make sure the country is doing well. After all the results will show.
@k.w.k314
@k.w.k314 17 дней назад
Duh...
@Stephen16141st
@Stephen16141st 12 дней назад
She'll fit right in at Reform Party
@Danderman888
@Danderman888 17 дней назад
Trying to come across as objective based on her confirmation biases. Silly woman!
@hatchegg80
@hatchegg80 15 дней назад
indeed, private sector with a path to the top won't want to come in, that's why we have 4th tier people like alvin tan being made ministers of state
@happydaysalways365
@happydaysalways365 2 дня назад
@23:30 min; accepting retirees to join as leaders of our country should just be a a joke, I don't think she meant it to be real!!
@kelyong77ss2013
@kelyong77ss2013 17 дней назад
Stay in power is not very good Government must be changed and replaced. 👍👍👍👊👊👊
@ngsoonheng9483
@ngsoonheng9483 17 дней назад
Replaced you lah...
@kelyong77ss2013
@kelyong77ss2013 14 дней назад
@@ngsoonheng9483 Same to u. Thk u.🤣🤣🤣
@douglasstanley5209
@douglasstanley5209 14 дней назад
LKY also said that. If PAP is replaced one day, they must continue to keep watch because if the elected opposition became the ruling party and they cannot do better, Singapore will know within 1 term. PAP must be ready to take back the government. So he started the 2-keys system to unlock SG reserve because within 1 term, an incapable ruling government can finish everything we have saved for years.
@Stephen16141st
@Stephen16141st 12 дней назад
Berth, don't try to talk like you know what to do... cause you don't..... Viswah, same goes to you....
@ving8355
@ving8355 17 дней назад
What she said is generally correct.
@wanderfooltang3520
@wanderfooltang3520 18 дней назад
very interesting view. Mr Goh is good
@Mrnonolol
@Mrnonolol 18 дней назад
The state model of company creation must be an enabler and not a market destroyer. The last thing u want is another dbs. A glc linked company that dominates. You want a total enterprise that is privately held. It’s diff
@pgobserver254
@pgobserver254 7 дней назад
In Singapore's leadership succession process, the **People's Action Party (PAP)**, which is the ruling party, does not hold a direct vote among Cabinet members to decide the next Prime Minister. Instead, the selection is made through a consultative process. Here are the key points: 1. **Consultation Process**: - Former minister and ex-PAP chairman **Khaw Boon Wan** facilitated consultations with relevant stakeholders. - These stakeholders included current Cabinet ministers, **Speaker Tan Chuan-Jin**, and **NTUC secretary-general Ng Chee Meng**. - The views of the Prime Minister and the two Senior Ministers were not sought during this process¹. 2. **Decision Outcome**: - **Finance Minister Lawrence Wong** was chosen as the leader of the fourth-generation (4G) team by **15 out of 19 stakeholders** who participated in the consultation. - The overwhelming majority supported Wong's leadership¹. So what is the interviewee trying to say? Wait till November for the CEC meeting to decide? Looks funny ley. 3. **Next Steps**: - Prime Minister **Lee Hsien Loong** and Wong will discuss the best strategy for the next General Election. - Regardless of the approach, the plan is for Lawrence Wong to be the next Prime Minister if the PAP wins the next election¹. In summary, while there isn't a formal vote, the decision-making process involves consultation and consensus-building within the PAP¹. Source: Conversation with Copilot, 23/06/2024 (1) Decision on when to hand over leadership will be taken later: PM Lee. www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/lawrence-wong-lee-hsien-loong-ge-2025-pap-succession-4g-leader-2629291. (2) Singapore’s PM Lee will hand over power to Lawrence Wong ‘before next .... www.scmp.com/week-asia/politics/article/3240380/singapores-lawrence-wong-ready-top-job-and-win-trust-singaporeans-election-looms. (3) Singapore: Politics of Succession - Asia Media Centre. www.asiamediacentre.org.nz/news/singapore-how-to-chose-a-leader/. (4) Enter Stage Right: The Choreography of Prime Ministerial Succession in .... www.internationalaffairs.org.au/australianoutlook/enter-stage-right-the-choreography-of-prime-ministerial-succession-in-singapore/. (5) Singapore’s Succession Headache - The Diplomat. thediplomat.com/2022/03/singapores-succession-headache/. 31:48
@darrenkhoo1516
@darrenkhoo1516 12 дней назад
SG politic got rooms for improvement lah, not change. If change, our secured life will be challenged (proven from pandemic). SG done very very very well already. We are not navie that we are living in Utopia.
@leanne2330
@leanne2330 18 дней назад
Why the need to ask MP to fill achievements form /template prior voting? If one disinterested to followup, engage, contribute and know in these past 5 years, it won't matter to himher now or the next 5 years. To suddenly want to be a quick CEO to cherrypick your team? U won't cut the bill.
@denhen6016
@denhen6016 15 дней назад
And Bertha Henson commented one female MP's outlook, when the new female MP was swore in during 2020 ceremony in her Facebook......posted, "can someone gets her eyebrow pencil!"......Here trying to give political views....
@ilovefish7991
@ilovefish7991 18 дней назад
We can't appease everyone. So long as pap does a reasonably good job in ensuring the population is taken cared of and we have a right mix of immigrants. Also the economy continues to thrive amidst the geopolitical shift and the pap leaders continue to have a forward thinking mentality.
@jameschu512
@jameschu512 16 дней назад
We need diversity of view.
@kslbl2776
@kslbl2776 16 дней назад
Short sighted
@Shimra8888
@Shimra8888 10 дней назад
She should be more grateful to what the PAP has done for Singapore. The ingratitude is sickening. Singapore could be a Third World shithole without Lee Kwan Yu. Prosperity is not inevitable, it can be lost easily … ask any Argentinian!
@Will.i.am55555
@Will.i.am55555 16 дней назад
😂😂😂😂😂 Come across to me as a grumpy ex😅blah.blah.blah.blah……😅😅😅😅😅 Go join WP and stand as a opposition MP babe-auntie🎉🎉🎉
@tanlaihock1598
@tanlaihock1598 18 дней назад
Don't ask stupid question. We always talk about giving chance. Yes, before you are thinking of giving chance one has to consider whether Singapore can afford to give chance to people who have doubtful character
@richardlu4195
@richardlu4195 17 дней назад
Sorry bro. What is your point ? Doubtful characters are found even in LKY's government and generally in all governments. We just have to be vigilant. Then what chance are you talking about ? We only know if the character is doubtful when he is caught isn't it ?
@shurakishi4707
@shurakishi4707 16 дней назад
Iswaran is now doubtful
@teresang9740
@teresang9740 18 дней назад
She talks as if she is a seasoned politician. If a person harbours deep negativity in her life against an agency nothing comes out good in their mouth. Best to keep away from this woman.
@Hs5687
@Hs5687 18 дней назад
What You expect when current 4G helmed by Boy Scout Team 😂
@leslieho6378
@leslieho6378 18 дней назад
Nothing wrong with her; she got the gut to speak truthfully and that gained my respect for her and don't forget it's her own opinions. People must be allowed to speak freely, so that it can help to bring change for the better. Not be a YES MAN all the time. Just get Real!!!
@Hs5687
@Hs5687 18 дней назад
@@leslieho6378 too little too late to now grow a Spine … She pbly realising Significance that Not even 1 LKY Trusted General Bothered to intervene to Rescue LKY’s Reckless Kids in Lee Family Saga … ie. Ownself Destroy Ownself
@Hs5687
@Hs5687 18 дней назад
too little too late to now grow a Spine … She pbly realising Significance that Not even 1 LKY Trusted General Bothered to intervene to Rescue LKY’s Reckless Kids in Lee Family Saga … ie. Ownself Destroy Ownself
@douglasstanley5209
@douglasstanley5209 14 дней назад
@@leslieho6378 Opposition also speak out. It is different if she joins a party and speak out. Then you can't say nothing wrong with her anymore since it is her own opinions.
@ericneo3780
@ericneo3780 17 дней назад
Why Bertha calls him Babe at 13 minute mark?
@Chisel55
@Chisel55 15 дней назад
Y the drumming sound in the background? Disturbing
@user-mc9ro4ll7j
@user-mc9ro4ll7j 17 дней назад
Iswaran Case will make PaP lose GRC awest Coast
@karenkwok583
@karenkwok583 16 дней назад
Yes ! Also Tan Chuan Jin's extramarital affairs ! It's quite shocking that LHL knew about his affairs for quite some time and yet he didn't disclose it at that point of time . What Bertha said was true... there's no transparency !
@user-mc9ro4ll7j
@user-mc9ro4ll7j 15 дней назад
@@karenkwok583 Also Tengah residents are not happy. Maybe they will redraw tengah under Amk GRC
@MarcS777
@MarcS777 7 дней назад
I concur w several of the comments here: it was nice to hear the views of Bertha, but the interviewer Viswa certainly need to exercise restraint. At some point, I was wondering is he going to let Bertha talk, or he is more interested in giving himself the platform to say his own thing? 😅
@paulchen1537
@paulchen1537 16 дней назад
Why does the private sector need to wait for government leadership? How much incentive do MNCs receive for coming to Singapore? It’s clear that the private sector must collaborate with government strategies. Does the failure of private leader to propose different or contrasting strategies, a reflection on the local education system? Do politics and education have a close relationship?
@kennySg101
@kennySg101 17 дней назад
PM has a very short runway. It will be a very busy months ahead. The guest had rightly pointed out, he needs to get his party colleagues to support him. Best is to speak to Mr Goh CT.
@douglasstanley5209
@douglasstanley5209 14 дней назад
Goh has a hard seat because LKY set the high standard. Similiarly LW will also have a hard seat because LHL has pushed SG into ultra growth. So ya, go listen to what he will say.
@kennySg101
@kennySg101 14 дней назад
@@douglasstanley5209 Goh had won over the support of people after LKY with a series of social measures like medical fund. Frankly, most straight fw is to tackle GST, COE and housing...
@reginalim7409
@reginalim7409 4 дня назад
Private enterprise need to come out more innovation like USA does. USA has open- door to foreign talents so be acceptance of it.
@abdulkarimyusoff2530
@abdulkarimyusoff2530 17 дней назад
You are very much in the mould of LKY "Cake making moulds"...strict and holding yourself.....people have feelings despite being a politician....
@dstudio1
@dstudio1 18 дней назад
What is the PAP's favourite rock band? Status Quo.
@SivalinPuthery
@SivalinPuthery 18 дней назад
Who is your fav politician? Trump
@beezlebub9
@beezlebub9 16 дней назад
24:14 This was so poignant and so many of us in Gen X feel that the roots are not that strong anymore. 31:37 exactly
@tangt4860
@tangt4860 17 дней назад
Really! She used to be the mouthpiece of PAP at Straits Times. Out PLPed by others?
@tanlaihock1598
@tanlaihock1598 18 дней назад
It's not Singapore politics that needs to change. BH needs to change herself. As an old auntie, her time is over. Why does she keep meddling with Singapore politics? At her age, she could have retired and enjoyed her last lap of life. Don't be a hater. If she thinks she can contribute, I suggest she should join politics to become a politician. No need to show your frustrations.
@keejoseph3145
@keejoseph3145 12 дней назад
Ah Lai you will be an old uncle one day or maybe you are already an old uncle calling someone old aunty. Humble otherwise karma will bite you.
@tayps1814
@tayps1814 День назад
An obsolete mindset that one should enter the political arena to air or promote his or her political views. Every Singaporean's views (positive or negative) count so long as these are given in good faith and for the betterment of Singapore.
@caseyneistat2371
@caseyneistat2371 17 дней назад
Ridiculous that TAN SEE LENG a literal parrot of PAP policies is considered "FRESH" 😂
@ha421334
@ha421334 15 дней назад
True we don't see Ministers these days
@danielquantum143
@danielquantum143 17 дней назад
She is being honest yet careful. There appears to be cross-talk and conflict but it's complex, I think I get what she's trying to say. She will not be enough to solve our issues. I think the key word She seems to be pressing is TRUST, yet no answers, sure let's be understanding. I do agree with er that LW should be SG i.e. the head honcho.
@chlim8336
@chlim8336 14 дней назад
Experienced human talk. Only people like us who leaves from 50s may understand
@jessiejames7492
@jessiejames7492 17 дней назад
Shes good! Very tactful in the way she answers
@spencergan4353
@spencergan4353 13 дней назад
I find this confusing, on one hand you find the policies of processing is confusing (which I do agree) on the hand you cannot see the big idea from the new team. Not all policies introduced are going to work on the ground even with the best intentions but it still needs to be tested and you never know if this is going to be the next big idea. The next big idea comes from little ones formulating with changes in between. I do agree with Bertha about the selection of the presidential candidate. There are just too many “qualifications” before a candidate can qualify. I think the way Iswaran and specially TCJ cases were could be better handled and I think LHL realized this. Honestly, how many in the private sector is willing to forgo that fat paying jobs and open themselves to public scrutiny. How many of these Tan See Lengs are prepared to just dive into this. So that leaves you with only the talent in the public sector. Remember how the Keppel executive was thrown out of PAP after word got around he was not the most favourite guy to work with in SAF, in the intro of the new faces? Anyway this is a new political era in which public scrutiny with all the social media attention is more intense. The 4G generation and particularly PM LW (my school mate in HBS) need to galvanize his team and show us how he’s going lead us. I too dunno him but give him and his team a chance to demonstrate their worth and judge after that….continuity is not a bad thing given you’re so new.
@skgan4739
@skgan4739 11 дней назад
Sister Bertha is a professional doubter who likes to have a Govt with perfection but does not realize that she herself is not perfect, a typical armchair critic who has no hands-on experiencing in helping people to cope with life challenges. I am very grateful to the govt for creating n maintaining & sustaining a society with safety, good education, healthcare system , high standards of living, clean environment, eceteras. Of course there is always room for continuous generational improvement as society n govt are never perfect. Well, Bertha is a very quarrelsome auntie with a judgmental perfect mind of know it all. ...my apology of no support for her loud talk of a critic who expects perfection..
@simroysten7963
@simroysten7963 17 дней назад
A talk on how to spend political capital and think it is worth it.
@dstnrunner
@dstnrunner 16 дней назад
LKY set the precedence of leveling the playing field by imprisoning, bankrupting and destroying his detractors. The country has moved away from this but transparency, accountability and power sharing may still be a ways off
@malita354
@malita354 18 дней назад
A.I is a big idea and of course does not come from xing jia po. Sg is just waiting to adopt a safe and proven tech.
@heidi-hu1tv
@heidi-hu1tv 8 дней назад
The interviewer is evidently bias here. He ends the interview by psychologically steering the viewers to his direction, i.e., to his stance that the viewers should also trust his summative conclusion to support a candidate they do not know at all as opposed to the position that Bertha stated, namely we know more that the current PM is more of the same as he was an administrative service officer who reported to his former boss.
@terence1635
@terence1635 5 дней назад
Is this meant to be one where the interviewer ask questions, or is this a dialogue? Seems like the facilitator can't wait to show that he knows things. If this is rhe former, let the guest speak please.
Далее
🎙️ПЕСНИ ВЖИВУЮ от КВАШЕНОЙ💖
3:23:13
How the hell is this done#joker #shorts
00:14
Просмотров 2,4 млн
Why Does Singapore Need a Kindness Movement?
24:02
Просмотров 3,5 тыс.