Тёмный

Porsche 911 spin analysed - Track Mistakes #2 

L2SFBC - Robert Pepper - auto journo
Подписаться 48 тыс.
Просмотров 11 тыс.
50% 1

#porsche911 #spin #sandown #oversteer
In this Track Mistakes video we're looking at a new track day driver spinning his Porsche 911 at Sandown Raceway...how did that happen, what are the car dynamics involved, and what could have been done differently?
Post questions as comments!
Follow me on Facebook:
/ robertpepperjourno
Support me on Patreon:
/ l2sfbc
Buy my books:
l2sfbc.com/where-to-buy/

Авто/Мото

Опубликовано:

 

24 сен 2021

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 69   
@wilsonjj
@wilsonjj Год назад
Thank you for the short and clear expiation with both video and charts on weight transfer 😊
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC Год назад
You are so welcome! Please share :-)
@xiaoyu88
@xiaoyu88 9 месяцев назад
Very informative. I went into this video kind of knowing what happened but you helped me understand it way better. Thank you.
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC 9 месяцев назад
Glad it helped! Please share :-)
@jasondang1920
@jasondang1920 2 года назад
Your doing a great job of explaining the weight transfer.
@hallamring2036
@hallamring2036 2 года назад
Excellent video...thanks!
@WorldOfSinMusic
@WorldOfSinMusic Год назад
Thanks for the video. This explains a lot 😊😅 cheers
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC Год назад
Glad it was helpful!
@DarthVader-eg9jm
@DarthVader-eg9jm 2 года назад
genius. thanks!
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC 2 года назад
Thanks, please share!
@DanEBoyd
@DanEBoyd 6 месяцев назад
It's all fun and games until someone loses a headlight!
@aniladitya
@aniladitya Год назад
Great explanation. I learnt many of these things the hard way:)
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC Год назад
Great to hear! Please share :-)
@aniladitya
@aniladitya Год назад
​@@L2SFBC I spun off multiple times during my initial track days as I didn't understand the releasing the clutch to rear tire lock out phenomenon well
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC Год назад
Watch for a video soon on heel and toe shifting which will help 👍
@langsor
@langsor Год назад
Great presentation and explanation. I've been going through this series of steering/braking videos and trying to figure out where to practice this in my area. Hard pressed to find an open area. Also, just picked up an NB1 Miata and you've mentioned a couple times how 50/50 weight distribution isn't ideal. I haven't been able to find that video on your channel--can you point me to it? Thank you for all the work you've put into this to help new learners like me.
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC Год назад
Thanks Kevin. I've not made the video yet, will do in the future. Takes a bit of time to do the calcs and make the diagrams.
@TomasRamoska
@TomasRamoska 9 месяцев назад
I'm more interested in what's happened with headlight 😅
@ramezaziz2336
@ramezaziz2336 3 месяца назад
If ever there was a need for a perfect example of over explaining the easy part and skipping over the important tricky bits, this is the clip you’re looking for.
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC 3 месяца назад
Which were the important tricky bits?
@a.c.e.7568
@a.c.e.7568 4 месяца назад
Excellent video. I knew about traction circle from my motorcycling days and more recently about weight transfer after taking the Porsche Track Experience (the 2-day Performance Course) yearly since 2021 in Canada. But weight transfer was very noticeable last summer when I was behind the instructor in a lead-follow group. The pace was a bit slow for me and I purposely slowed down a bit after turn 3 so that I can pick up the pace into turn 4 at Mosport. Turn 4 is a left hand and a steeper downhill towards turn 5A. Coming up on the instructor I braked a tad while in the turn and it being downhill, it lightened up the rear and you could feel the rear coming out slightly but controlled. The 992 had a PDK, so I am unaware how that might change balance as compared to the two 911s I have that are manuals.
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC 4 месяца назад
Thanks! Modern cars also have DTC or Drag Torque Control which adds torque to the drive wheels (rear in this case) to avoid this problem. I would expect newer 911s to have it which is yet another way electronics can reduce the need for driving skills, and mask errors.
@a.c.e.7568
@a.c.e.7568 4 месяца назад
@@L2SFBC Yes they do and we were all told not to switch it off. I am used to winter driving where my wheels are pointed in another direction in my car or motorcycle riding dirt-track style. Personally, I have no use for nanny controls such as stability control, ABS, etc for people that have no judgement and fail to take the time to improve their skills, this coming from a past flight instructor. They are passengers, not drivers. Sorry that Porsche in Australia does not have any courses in Brisbane in January or February when I am here on the Gold Coast. Lucky you, I'd love to go to Bathurst...what a track.
@a.c.e.7568
@a.c.e.7568 4 месяца назад
@@L2SFBC Also, my two 911s are a 1995 911 Carrera (993 series) and a 2015 911 Carrera 4 GTS (991.1 series), both coupes and with a 6 and 7 speed manual.
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC 4 месяца назад
There are occasional trackdays at Bathurst, maybe twice a year. If you can time your next visit? I tend to agree with your point re aids, the problem is they mask errors which is all well and good until you get in a non-electronic car, try to go as fast as you did before using the same techniques, and find yourself backwards into a wall. I think there is a good argument for teaching with no aids for that reason.
@a.c.e.7568
@a.c.e.7568 4 месяца назад
@@L2SFBC Unfortunately, I only get by with a Queensland Go-Card when I spend time on the Gold Coast. Its usually a run from Brisbane International to Nerang and a bus to my unit. I could rent a car, but driving on the other side of the road is a bit challenging although I did get from London-Heathrow to the Dover on my motorcycle to take the Euro-Tunnel. Same as when I had to switch from the left seat to the right seat in an aircraft when I became an instructor. Took about 8 hours to be just as 100% proficient. Anyway, the mountain road part of Bathurst is my kind of road. Working on a tablet is no fun, but will watch your understeer and oversteer videos as well on a real PC. Looking forward to my July track days in Canada which is where I live.
@mohammadanwar6857
@mohammadanwar6857 4 месяца назад
TLDR: Don't engine brake while turning, Accelerate slightly through the turn to maintain weight distribution.
@studiolezard
@studiolezard Год назад
Would the new "auto-blip" feature help in this case? Great explanation. Thanks.
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC Год назад
Not really, as the problem seemed to come after the downchange - braking on the rear wheels. It would have helped for sure in the other spin shown when downshifting into second.
@25jai123
@25jai123 8 месяцев назад
Thank you for the great analysis. So in the first scenario, it would have been fine for the driver to trail brake into the corner but they should have completed all their downshifts in a straight line right?
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC 8 месяцев назад
Yes. Downshifting in this case brakes only the rear wheels trailbraking brakes more the front
@ThePhantom41
@ThePhantom41 2 года назад
What do you think about setting the car up on axle stands so that you can practice full lock steering technique (without all the actual steering load)? Just to get a handle on the range of movement, check seating position etc.
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC 2 года назад
Interesting idea, not thought about that. I like it. However you could also just find a carpark and drive slowly around it. That is how I teach the techniques. The thing to learn is what to do with hands. Load doesn't really make a difference to the learning. But relying on a self centring effect is a bad idea.
@niceguy100000
@niceguy100000 Год назад
If possible, learn drifting. Who can drift can drive. Easier said than done though, not everyone has access to high power and rear wheel drive.
@Align700nitro
@Align700nitro 11 месяцев назад
@@niceguy100000 you don't need high power or RWD. Lift off oversteer works on anything run on wheels. It's all about weight transfer. If a 100hp fwd corolla can go side ways, there is no execuse.
@thefreedomguyuk
@thefreedomguyuk 7 месяцев назад
lifting the foot off the accelerator in a curve will ALWAYS make a 911 spin
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC 7 месяцев назад
I would go with sometimes...
@Align700nitro
@Align700nitro 11 месяцев назад
looks like a typical lift off oversteer to me. Be aware even you foot is not on the brake, Engine itself generates tons of drag at no throttle acts the same as depressed brake pedal.
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC 11 месяцев назад
That's essentially what my conclusion was!
@bvward
@bvward 2 года назад
Robert, learn on snow at low speed? I almost wrecked a 911 in a changing radius turn back in the '80's ;) I was an apprentice on a "road test"... Left for Uni shortly after...
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC 2 года назад
I reckon snow is great to learn on..but because you start off on low traction and it doesn't take much to slide, then it's not quite representative of a higher traction surface where your speeds and cornering force are higher, and the transition from grip-to-slide is more abrupt. Same for gravel driving, very useful but not quite the same as the fairly sudden transition on bitumen. How did you recover the 911?
@bvward
@bvward 2 года назад
@@L2SFBC Hard braking and extreme counter steer, and never telling the owner ;)
@bradleywinters5825
@bradleywinters5825 Год назад
Nice video! It brings up an interesting question for EVs. I have a Tesla EV and wondering about leaving regen on when on a track. It is essentially like engine breaking and activates as soon as you let off the accelerator pedal. And in a Tesla it is pretty strong to allow for one-pedal driving. I guess you could maintain some accelerator pedal and do left-foot braking, but that seems touchy as far as how much accelerator to give. In my car I can also turn off regen in "track mode" but all the videos I have seen leave it on because you burn up so much energy at the track. Let me know your thoughts and whether you have discussed this with any EV folks at the track.
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC Год назад
Interesting question I shall write a reply as a blog post on my website
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC Год назад
Now answered on my site!
@Align700nitro
@Align700nitro 11 месяцев назад
believe it or not, the "one pedal" driving caused a lot of accidental acceleration because people thought they were on the brake pedal, but it's actually the gas.
@brucelee3835
@brucelee3835 Год назад
one of the fry egg highlight fell off thely are egly.
@jefferyshort6181
@jefferyshort6181 Год назад
How long has Porsche been making "mid engine " cars VS rear engine cars? Porsche knows better.
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC Год назад
An interesting question - if the 911 didn't exist, would Porsche choose a rear-engined layout again? I'd suggest not. They've spent decades making it work, and recent years ensuring the Cayman/Boxster never get quite too close to the 911.
@daniel1838
@daniel1838 3 месяца назад
On a mountain road thats mostly downhill, is it bwtter to be on a lower gear (no shifting involved) at higher rpms or higher gear at lower rpms? I feel like i have more control in the lower gear as the car doesn't speed up through the corners
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC 3 месяца назад
Lower gear as that way your brakes don't overheat by the bottom of the hill. However...given this is a video about a 911, then if that's the car in question it doesn't really matter as Porsche fit track-standard brakes to 911s (mostly) so overheating is unlikely to be a problem. Still would go lower gears.
@oliverradcliffe7974
@oliverradcliffe7974 6 месяцев назад
So when you rev match on a down shift, does that not engine brake then?
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC 6 месяцев назад
It does engine brake yes, but it's less abrupt.
@JuanAdam12
@JuanAdam12 6 месяцев назад
Will be transitioning from a 987 Cayman to a 992 in a few months. I don’t know anything about driving a rear engined car like the 911, but at least I know I don’t know anything. Are there a few rules of thumb for driving (modern) 911’s on fast, curvy roads to at least keep you out of trouble?
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC 6 месяцев назад
Yes have a look at my Lotus vs 86 video, the Lotus is mid-engined but same dynamics apply. In short your risk of oversteer is more likely to be under braking, it'll be very stable until suddenly it isn't. It'll be very hard to break traction under power - I've got a video of me drifting an old 911 on a skidpan and the only way I could get it out (and mid-engined cars) was a clutch kick. For driving the usual; smooth, controlled braking and accelerating, and if you do get a skid...well look at my Oversteer and Understeer videos for details.
@JuanAdam12
@JuanAdam12 6 месяцев назад
@@L2SFBC thank you! Will watch that video.
@niceguy100000
@niceguy100000 Год назад
Hello. I can't figure out the difference between the three laps. Driver seems to leave a very long gap between braking and turn-in in all three laps. Should have spun three times 🙂
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC Год назад
The gap between spinning and not spinning can be very small...
@redzone5655
@redzone5655 9 месяцев назад
What about PDK? Engine break applies to manuals?
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC 9 месяцев назад
Both if you downshift a manual you'll get engine braking too, but modern cars have drag shift control which helps prevent lockup a little.
@danielsoto_toronto
@danielsoto_toronto 7 месяцев назад
Simple, no throttle, no grip in the rear
@thefreedomguyuk
@thefreedomguyuk 7 месяцев назад
Always true of 911, and then the engine will try to reach its correct position, at the front of the car 😅
@chrisboston411
@chrisboston411 Месяц назад
Let me simplify 10 min of video by saying simply, you need to be on the gas at the apex of a turn in a 911. Otherwise you don't have weight on the back tires, meaning you won't have grip in the back. Watch the video again and see the first two times the driver got on the gas by the apex. The third time no gas, and spin. Done this myself a few times and it can be confusing when it happens since if you're not actively thinking about adding gas at the apex, one can easily forget and a spin will commence. While the driver tried to correct with the wheel, it doesn't help unless he also gets back on the gas at the same time.
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC Месяц назад
That's wrong. Consider this; on the way to the apex, or even just before, are you not turning and slowing down? Also consider the effect of engine braking vs friction brakes. This "power through the corner" business has its roots in reality, but has been over-simplified and over-repeated.
@gt4rca
@gt4rca 2 года назад
The Porsche cayman GT4 has absolutely no engine braking.
@L2SFBC
@L2SFBC 2 года назад
Why not?
@gt4rca
@gt4rca 2 года назад
@@L2SFBC I dunno, I have the 718 GT4 and when you take your foot off the acelelator there's no engine brake at all? I haven't driven another one so assumed they all do this.
@thefreedomguyuk
@thefreedomguyuk 7 месяцев назад
Which type transmission do you have ?
@gt4rca
@gt4rca 7 месяцев назад
@@thefreedomguyuk manual.
Далее
Oversteer recovery - how to save your car!
24:25
Просмотров 55 тыс.
Understeer recovery - how do you do it?
12:45
Просмотров 13 тыс.
Track Day Guide: MUST WATCH BEFORE DRIVING
16:09
Просмотров 461 тыс.
Your 'grip budget' - how do you drive it?
18:25
Просмотров 7 тыс.
Trail Braking: 5 Mistakes DESTROYING Your Laptime
6:50
5 Steps to FINALLY Master TRAIL BRAKING in Racing
7:31