Тёмный

Porsche v BMW SUV drag race! Sound test, braking & 0-100. X3 v Macan 

CarExpert
Подписаться 467 тыс.
Просмотров 62 тыс.
50% 1

You want a sporty SUV, but you're not a gazillionaire. So what do you do? Well, we wanted to find out. Paul Maric does a CarExpert dragparison (a drag race and comparison) between the 2023 Porsche Macan T and the 2023 BMW X3 xDrive30i to see which is fastest accelerating and which one stops the quickest. The results were surprising!
More BMW content: www.carexpert.com.au/bmw
More BMW X3 content: www.carexpert.com.au/bmw/x3
More Porsche content: www.carexpert.com.au/porsche
More Porsche Macan content: www.carexpert.com.au/porsche/...
Skip Ahead:
Intro: 00:00
X3 v Macan Drag Race 1 02:19
X3 v Macan Drag Race 2 03:58
X3 v Macan Drag Race 3 04:45
X3 v Macan Drag Race 4 05:58
BMW performance tests 06:41
Porsche performance tests 09:32
Verdict 13:18
We review every new car on the market, bust car myths, cover the latest car tech and answer your burning questions.
Whether you need new car advice, purchase validation or simply love learning more about new cars and technology, we are your car experts.
Subscribe to Car Expert: / @carexpertaus
You'll find us dropping new video content three times a week. If you'd like to ask a question about one of our videos, simply leave us a comment. If you'd like to give us any feedback on our content, feel free to email us, or alternatively, hit us up on social media.
Finally, we want this channel to grow with your support and feedback. If there's anything you don't like or would like to see us change, we'd love to hear from you!
Follow us on social media to see what we're up to and to ask any questions!
CarExpert:
Facebook: / carexpertaus
Twitter: / carexpertaus
Instagram: / carexpert.com.au
Paul Maric:
Facebook: / paulmaric
Twitter: / paulmaric
Instagram: / paulmaric
#bmw #porsche #dragrace

Авто/Мото

Опубликовано:

 

28 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 108   
@CarExpertAus
@CarExpertAus Год назад
We got an email from a viewer with regards to launch control in the xDrive30i. It should have launch control, but no manner of combinations that we tried got it to work. A review we have lobbing soon on the xDrive30d didn't have that issue - launch control worked fine.
@MikoTheTomCat
@MikoTheTomCat Год назад
@@scowil456 wtf? How is a Macan S more affordable? The models tested here were cheaper.
@scowil456
@scowil456 Год назад
@@MikoTheTomCat I was referring to the Macan S being more affordable than the Macan GTS, not the base Macan. Sorry, I confused things with my initial response.
@MikoTheTomCat
@MikoTheTomCat Год назад
@@scowil456 ahh okay 👍
@TheLowrider2040
@TheLowrider2040 Год назад
I had a 2021 Xdrive30i that was supposed to have LC but I could never find it qnd so I dont think Aus delivered models had it activated, some OS models seem to have it. Interestingly, models with the M Sport Differential have it which makes sense for the Xdrive30i not to have it, what would LC on a 30i actually do?
@VeeElJay
@VeeElJay Год назад
I have a 2021 non-M sport 30i in the US. It has LC (shifter has to be in S mode (not D or M)). Rest of the procedure is the same as they did in the video. But it still will only rev to just under 3k rpms so it won't affect the times at all in any way. I've tried both brake boosting and using LC and in my BMW cars, brake boosting works better than LC.
@jhui4620
@jhui4620 Год назад
Most youtube reviews always stress acceleration figures forgetting about the more important stopping ability. Thanks Paul.
@problemchild6002
@problemchild6002 Год назад
Was waiting for this drag races... ever since the Focus st manual and automatic dragparison... thanks Paul
@Cars_with_max
@Cars_with_max Год назад
Great video enjoyed this one
@currybh
@currybh Год назад
Hi Paul yes would love to see more of these but really eager to see the 2022 x7 vs 2023 x7 please paul good on ya mate!
@nd9667
@nd9667 Год назад
Loving these videos - something different. I'm never going to buy either of these vehicles but loved the review nonetheless. Excellent unbiased content.
@JammingwithKaRoger
@JammingwithKaRoger Год назад
Great video and comparison mate as always, been following your videos for years now....would it be possible for your next review, the X3 M40i vs Macan S or X3 M40i vs Audi SQ5 or GLC 43 AMG? thanks heaps and more videos
@BatDimen
@BatDimen 5 месяцев назад
No surprise that the Macan won. Also, not dissing BWM but the build quality of Porsches is really at the next level.
@BrettAlan84
@BrettAlan84 Год назад
Intresting video from your usual car reviews. I watched the review on the Porsche and i was very impressed with the review. I had to go check out the price on one. The exhaust sounds meaty as for a 4 banger. Got that AMG bark while shifting gears. Plus the transmission is lightening fast at the gear changes. Keep it up i will be watching more of these if you bring them out.
@jacekl10
@jacekl10 Год назад
awesome that you also timed normal start without lunch control etc. as in normal driving conditions for the ordinary Joe, great work!
@satishvenkat005
@satishvenkat005 Год назад
Hi Paul, waiting for your review on BMW X7 and eager to see that. Thank you
@grandandroid6283
@grandandroid6283 Год назад
Great video
@cobbahall7463
@cobbahall7463 Год назад
Surely an i30 N Line hatch vs Cerato GT, also loved the video, been awesome to see you guys make so much progress so fast 👏🏻
@ronaldov09
@ronaldov09 Год назад
'...only a car length between us' How long is your car Paul?...was about 4 car lengths mate! lol
@tellyawhatmate
@tellyawhatmate Год назад
That extra 50nm nudges the Macan to 100kmh a tiny bit quicker Paul can you do a 330i vs c300 vs A4 45tsi 🙏 🙏
@djrocc-jamaica3527
@djrocc-jamaica3527 Год назад
Great Video, placing the Macan in Sports/Sports plus will get even better pops and bangs from Exhaust.
@Rockbottomsurf
@Rockbottomsurf Год назад
Was gonna buy one but now they’re taking my superannuation off me I’m down to my last few million.
@Rockbottomsurf
@Rockbottomsurf Год назад
@@53glowe 9 smart people so far have recognised this as a piss take.
@kernal141
@kernal141 Год назад
Sending you my thoughts and prayers
@chrisschneiders6734
@chrisschneiders6734 8 месяцев назад
Whats the chances?same happened to me!!
@gbarton800
@gbarton800 6 месяцев назад
Interesting comparison and fun to watch. As for braking, I’d venture to guess the front tire size and/or perhaps the compound made the difference.
@scowil456
@scowil456 Год назад
Great test / comparison Paul. Love if you could do the same with each top of the range model, so Macan GTS and X3M?
@mateyeseratha8785
@mateyeseratha8785 Год назад
M40i stands no chance. You might need to call the X3M for that race
@jamesblond1100
@jamesblond1100 Год назад
440 vs. 360 HP ? Would not be fair...
@scowil456
@scowil456 Год назад
If you don’t want to use the most expensive models, how about the more affordable Macan S and BMW X3 M40i. But compare using your usual more comprehensive tests - that would be great!
@sagevoxo6431
@sagevoxo6431 Год назад
You are right. 440 hp (GTS) vs 473 hp (X3M) would be best combination.
@kuopei626
@kuopei626 Год назад
@@scowil456 M40i will smoke Macan S anyday anytime when comes to the performance and speed , but Macan has great handling and comfort seat
@bohaowang1108
@bohaowang1108 Год назад
hi, Paul. can you do a car detail review on 2023 BMW X3 30i? i saw you did 40i and 30e before but not 30i yet.
@MrJBL0
@MrJBL0 Год назад
First to comment, great drag race and also when is the Subaru outback turbo coming, you’re my favourite reviewer and yet you are one of the only people who haven’t made a video about it😕
@jdfiji
@jdfiji Год назад
Nice video . Can you please do a drag race between the Elantra N vs Cerato GT ?
@drashwaryashah
@drashwaryashah Год назад
My man deserves more subs
@frank21cn1
@frank21cn1 Год назад
My pre facelift x3 30i does have launch control, just need to put to S transmission as well.
@mrkring1526
@mrkring1526 Год назад
Dude in the Porsche should have worked out by the third time how to launch the Macan. It was painful to watch.
@niko5514
@niko5514 4 месяца назад
Awesome!
@billshoe22191
@billshoe22191 Год назад
Great job on this. I prefer the GR86 more oversteer nature over the BRZ, but the pice difference is large enough that I would go BRZ and try to tune in some more oversteer
@GT500NSX
@GT500NSX Год назад
The fact the macan won with such a bad driver is impressive.
@saarensawmy2345
@saarensawmy2345 Год назад
Normally the x3 should have launch control as well if you put the gear selector in "S"
@jamesg3102
@jamesg3102 Год назад
Great job guys! I was just wondering, what's the reason for using that phone app for timing rather than the vbox you used previously?
@CarExpertAus
@CarExpertAus Год назад
We still use the VBox occasionally, but the Dragy is faster setup when jumping between cars and has no wires, so a bit easier when filming.
@CarExpertAus
@CarExpertAus Год назад
This is a link to details on the Dragy: www.carexpert.com.au/car-news/this-cheap-gps-device-lets-you-performance-test-your-car-like-a-pro
@c3vzn
@c3vzn Год назад
Saw Matt Campbell is now with you guys. Would be good to see him in some of the video content.
@monstamowing3395
@monstamowing3395 Год назад
I been watching Paul since his CarAdvice days. In addition to that, I been watching subscribers on both channels. Note: Paul went off on his own venture. At the time of this comment: CarAdvice/Drive - 298k subscribers. CarExpert - 297k subscribers. I'm here for the pre-drinks before the party when he overtakes CA/Drive. In the future, I want to see Paul having access to an airfield. Need longer drag and roll races.
@CarExpertAus
@CarExpertAus Год назад
Thanks legend! We have a fun video planned. 😁 Also - there’s an air strip planned for some future, slightly faster stuff too 😁
@monstamowing3395
@monstamowing3395 Год назад
@@CarExpertAus 298k vs 298k now...
@Grudlin74
@Grudlin74 Год назад
Please do more of these comparisons. Also display prices.
@UnCo77
@UnCo77 Год назад
Would love to see you do one of these with the Tesla Model Y RWD vs Performance so those of us like you, who switched or are thinking of switching trim levels, can get an idea of the exact differences for the difference in money.
@fungooloo12
@fungooloo12 Год назад
Hey Paul this is great, please do more. Would love to see some standard Mid size SUV's thrown in amongst the major sporty cars. This channel is fast becoming my favorite, reminiscent of carwow but the Aussie version 🙂
@bravonogero3813
@bravonogero3813 Год назад
Will you try a drag race with the GV70 2.5T please?
@ronramos1613
@ronramos1613 Год назад
what ios app did you use to measure the 0-100 times? great comparison
@CarExpertAus
@CarExpertAus Год назад
We use this one: www.carexpert.com.au/car-news/this-cheap-gps-device-lets-you-performance-test-your-car-like-a-pro
@Alex.AL_26
@Alex.AL_26 Год назад
Would love to see X3 M40i vs Macan S
@letsseeif
@letsseeif Год назад
Do it with standard (some base model) cars. It'd be a 'real world comparisons'. [I'd like to see Bathurst Cars do similar,] Thanks for your review.
@Na2gumiBlogspot
@Na2gumiBlogspot 4 месяца назад
The BMW: 6.3 is the official figure for 0-60 mph, the 0-100 kmh is 6.6 so it did just about right
@TN_AU
@TN_AU Год назад
I have the late 2020 x3 xDrive30i, the last model before the facelift. Great car, Im not a luxury brand fan, the wife is, so our first new family car, cost an arm and a leg, but I think we deserve to be spoilt from time to time. Then the wife spoil herself with a 2022 Jimny for her daily.
@Pumpedandy
@Pumpedandy Год назад
Can you wake that porsche driver up, i think hes fallen asleep at the launch
@NZsarge1
@NZsarge1 Год назад
On exhaust sound I’d give it to the Porsche but only just
@tellyawhatmate
@tellyawhatmate Год назад
That same motor in the 330i sounds awesome, same as 128ti
@mrnicktoyou
@mrnicktoyou Год назад
Awesome and thorough comparison but I couldn't care less about these cars. Maybe the 6 cylinder versions.
@jerrymyahzcat
@jerrymyahzcat Год назад
Please can you do the 80-120 test in realistic conditions ie from cruising at 80. While accelerating through 80 floored is not realistic as it’s supposed to represent a passing manoeuvre.
@tamtruong2356
@tamtruong2356 Год назад
Why didn’t you try Sport+ on the X3 ?
@Ckktopa
@Ckktopa Год назад
awesome
@sheznez
@sheznez 2 месяца назад
so good
@billshoe22191
@billshoe22191 Год назад
More of these please. Toyota GR86 vs Miata/MX-5 next
@S9RUT
@S9RUT Год назад
Surely a Jimny Manual vs Auto comparison!!
@shivomtiwari7933
@shivomtiwari7933 Год назад
Getting into carwow territory
@chileshemubanga3594
@chileshemubanga3594 Год назад
Sound Wise I'll Go With The BMW,Car Wise The Porsche!.Both Look Good But I Love The Porsche More.
@jacekl10
@jacekl10 Год назад
definitely more of those normal drag races!!!!
@leonwakefield7285
@leonwakefield7285 Год назад
More,more pleasssse
@Yeanmann
@Yeanmann Год назад
plz do a countryman jcw vs macan
@CathodeRayNipplez
@CathodeRayNipplez Год назад
Please tell me where anywhere in 'Stralia this is relevant to anyone's daily 9 to 5? 0 to 20 hunting for a park at Westfield for the latest handbag sale?
@jameshinchy7758
@jameshinchy7758 Год назад
it's just a bit of fun...
@CathodeRayNipplez
@CathodeRayNipplez Год назад
@@jameshinchy7758 🙄
@mvnorsel6354
@mvnorsel6354 Год назад
A great day at the office and no mention of interest rates.
@CarExpertAus
@CarExpertAus Год назад
You need something to get you to the Westfield quickly.
@CathodeRayNipplez
@CathodeRayNipplez Год назад
@@CarExpertAus Touche! Good point
@TechHead03
@TechHead03 Год назад
After watching a ridiculous amount of carwow drag races it seems you gotta pre-empt the "go" in the countdown but some fraction of a second to actually launch on time and not get "caught napping" as they call it, waiting for launch control foibles.
@buncha5651
@buncha5651 Год назад
Who won the reverse test?
@JohnDoe-zt3np
@JohnDoe-zt3np Год назад
Macan looks much better
@aquaboy1650
@aquaboy1650 Год назад
CX-5 turbo vs everybody please!
@ash-hi3dm
@ash-hi3dm Год назад
You didn't mention the price Paul
@Dorko85
@Dorko85 Год назад
What’s the app you are using?
@CarExpertAus
@CarExpertAus Год назад
This one: www.carexpert.com.au/car-news/this-cheap-gps-device-lets-you-performance-test-your-car-like-a-pro
@Garri1807
@Garri1807 Год назад
It does have Launch control, you just didnt have the gearbox in S mode.
@renehickmann3003
@renehickmann3003 Год назад
i was a bmw driver but porsche is a head of bmw in quality is . the baddest thing by bmw is when you lease a car(as a company) from the bmw bank and you want to "buy" the car after the leasing they dont use the residual value of the car. they say if you want the car u need to pay the "used car" price . that is just fraud. (like 15-20k diffrence) Many bmw drivers switch to Porsche because of this. I knew at least 4 with the same problem.
@TheCaesarChris
@TheCaesarChris Год назад
Is this carwow??
@goran2009
@goran2009 Год назад
Porsche for me, X3 for my wife!
@mvnorsel6354
@mvnorsel6354 Год назад
We are all here to see the reverse speed winner.
@bobubastardbbqandmetal9908
@bobubastardbbqandmetal9908 11 месяцев назад
Close? Not even..Macan all the way
@slogeswaran1
@slogeswaran1 Год назад
X3 look big in size compare to porsche
@sagevoxo6431
@sagevoxo6431 Год назад
EA888 over B48 all day 🔥
@d.k.1394
@d.k.1394 Год назад
Hiiiiiii
@pascalscheir4578
@pascalscheir4578 8 месяцев назад
The guy in the porsche can't drive !!!
@georgeackerman1752
@georgeackerman1752 Год назад
As much fun as drag races are, please don't become another carwow. Love your reviews of normal cars for normal people. Thanks
@Youcallthesebagels_
@Youcallthesebagels_ Год назад
Yeah sure bud, let them just make less money and not follow the RU-vid trends and fall flat on their faces. These videos put food on their families tables. It’s not all about you! Keep the drag races coming!
@georgeackerman1752
@georgeackerman1752 Год назад
@@Youcallthesebagels_ no worries, just my opinion
@Charis_Cheng
@Charis_Cheng Год назад
This is an unfair race because the BMW has all the gopros on it increasing drag and weight significantly whereas the porsche has none.😠
@Gezzaman14
@Gezzaman14 Год назад
Pretty sure the GoPro weight and "drag' is absolutely insignificant
@SunnyNagi
@SunnyNagi Год назад
good joke 😬😬😬
@GT500NSX
@GT500NSX Год назад
It's unfair because the X3 sucks and the macan is awesome.
@MikoTheTomCat
@MikoTheTomCat Год назад
Hahaha you’re kidding right? The Macan is the heavier car and still smoked it.
Далее
Can a BMW & Porsche off-road?! 😳
14:03
Просмотров 1,2 млн
Porsche Macan vs. BMW X3 -- Which Should You Buy??
6:12
PORSCHE MACAN T
3:59
Просмотров 8 тыс.
Porsche 911 GT3 RS v GT4 RS v GT3 v GT4: DRAG RACE
18:10
Porsche Macan S vs. BMW X3 sDrive 30i
19:59
Просмотров 2,3 тыс.
Оживляем Tiguan втайне от Ильдара!
1:12:26
МОЯ НОВАЯ МАШИНА🤩😍 MERCEDES?😱
0:59
Когда купил машину 300+ л/с 🤔😂
0:59