Alison visits Hanna, Emily, Spencer and Aria. Are they just dreaming or it is real? That is the question I want to have answered... Episodes when Ali visited the liars: Hanna: 01x11 Emily: 02x12 Spencer: 02x24 Aria: 03x16
I don't mean this in a creepy way but I Love the way Ali talks. In a mysterious way. Evilish way. As if she isn't scared. As if she is in control of it all. Its great
I think this was how the girls depicted her cause that's how they remember her, that would explain why allison has this like angelic aura and lights around her
Screw dreams and hallucinations, She is really there in all of them. I mean in all of them she left clues that they are real (the lipstick on the cup, Emily being moved, The pills and the window left open, and the Doll)
This show had so much lore and supernatural mysteries in the earlier seasons. Just so much edge. It was all just thrown out the window from season 4 onwards.
Its hard to tell because they all technically were on something when they saw her. Emily was knocked out, Hannah was on medication, Spencer had painkillers, and Aria had some of that tea.But at the same time theres evidence she was there.
I knew Alison was alive on the episode when she visited Spencer. Out of all the visitations that she did that seemed the most real and the door was left opened the following morning. I'm sure that was a clue
This show was literally lightning in a bottle during its early seasons! Everything about it just clicked, and the mystery aspect of the show was so much fun! In the first three seasons, I relished every single flashback or “visit” from Alison bc she was such an intriguing character and Sasha IS Alison Dilaurentis! She was so enigmatic and everything she said was mesmerizing, as if she were speaking in riddles that needed deciphering. I remember when they started to hint that Ali was actually still alive that I would love it bc I hated to think such a mysterious and engaging character was truly dead. Sadly, the show changed its storylines and the direction it wanted to take the story so many times that these early moments with Alison are still just as mysterious as they were when they aired bc they never amounted to anything. The same can be said with Alison’s character, they stripped her of almost ever ounce of charisma and confidence that made Alison so interesting to watch. There are times that I wish that she had remained purely in flashbacks, bc she lost all that power, allure, and ability to affect peoples lives in so many different emotional and psychological ways once she returned. If they weren’t going to fully commit to her being A or a villain in general, they should have allowed her to remain the “boogeyman” of Rosewood and hold onto the immortality she longed for in life and to always remain the alluring missing girl in the painting, just like she admitted to wanting in Spencer’s film noir dream.
That so true if you think about if Alison did have a twin who was A the girls would never have seen what kinda person Ali really was. It would have made her an interesting character.
5:37 Dont get to hung up on the detail and miss what's right in front you . What is in front of Spencer ... Alison ! She was trying to say that she's alive !
Look at the way Alison is saying "I'm surprise Spencer hasn't figure that out." She's looking straight at Aria. And then we have the "A" symbol in the teapot. Also, ending song of 3x16 when Mona is drinking Spencer and Toby's anniversary wine; the song playing is called "Aria with 30 variations". I believe Aria has a split-personality. Hello Black Swan? Byron also mentioned that mental illness runs in the family. And in the new Season 4 promo: Lucy says "A's ALWAYS WATCHING." (Acting like A).
omg when Aria asks Ali: Do you see A ? She replies with: everywhere I turn, so do you. And we know that Aria always looks into mirrors and gets lost in them... maybe this was a hint ? :o
Vivian, Ali's alter ego, means alive in Latin, she keeps dropping hints, "Do I look dead to you?" "It was dangerous coming here to see you" and always left behind something to prove it was real.
remember when they said the one girl had a red coat? somewhere i believe in season 2 or 3 they talked about how vivian had a red coat even though she had black hair she looked just like alison so it could be courtney (the twin) but now back with blonde hair cause aria caught her in the beauty salon at one point anyone remember that?
@@ellenn7 yes ikr alison seemed to genuinely like aria and didn't target or bully her that much, she also said in her diary that she thought aria was pretty, which is rare for alison since she doesn't compliment people
I hope, by any chance, somebody can answer my question... In the last scene where Ali and Aria are talking... Ali said she knew who A is but since it happened on the third season that couldn't be possible. How is she surprised "Spencer hasn't figured that out" if not even Ali knew who A was in that moment. They were all surprised when it was revealed!
When Alison tells emily she won't tell her who A is, because "two can only keep a secret if one of them is dead" gives away that alison is indeed Alive. She didn't want Emily to die if she told her because "Emily was always her favourite". If alison was dead, she would have told her because then she would have been the one that dies in that phrase. :D
She really try to give small hint to every one of them and noone figer out she was the smartest one from all of them she need to think ahed for those girls
Maybe she wanted then to know she s alive but what I don't get is how she 's always certain who A is but in season 5 she had no clue ,doesn 't make any sense
Lara Maria Busuttil It does, she simply thought it was someone and then discovered it wasnt them after all. I think she thought Ezra was A but then found out he is "just" writing a book. And she obviously didnt want them to know she is alive and even if she did it doesnt explain why she visited Hanna and Emily and didnt visit Aria and Spencer, she just wanted to take something from their houses. I think she doesnt trust Aria and Spencer. Idk why though
You re right didn't she trusted spencer for sure as seen in the shovel scene !Emily and Hannah were always her puppets ,but I don't know why she didn't trust aria she always seemed kind of neutral
Lara Maria Busuttil It is really messed up. She caused Hannas eating dissorder and she made Emily feel like shit yet she seems to care about them the most. Like WTF?
She really care about emily the most i think that the reason why she came visiting emily the most and save her i don't think she not really visit the only but emily
Such an amazing actress. While the others were like 22 playing the roles of 16 which they've been obviously. Sasha was only 12 pretending to be 22 playing the role of 16. To act so mature like an adult to the point no one suspected she was a child. Then to play the role of a 16 year old when she hasn't even been that age yet is truly impressive.
They all saw allison and everyone of them thought they were dreaming or hallucinating. Not one of them ever realized she was right there. Alison is really good at not being seen or getting in and out before anyone realized she was actually there
My Pll theory: Ok, this may sound crazy but it kinda makes sense. Alison is really dead. The person the liars see is her ghost. Yes, Alison's ghost. I know it sounds cray but here are my reasons: (1) She appeared in everyone's hallucination (or was it?) How is it that she comes to Spencer's and Aria's house, Hanna's hospital and that barn for Emily without anyone seeing her? It was real since Alison (her ghost) tells them and she leaves hints behind. Aria's doll gone, Spencer's door open. (2) She appears/disappears. When Hannah goes to find Toby , she sees red coat (Alison's ghost) running inside the building, Emily runs inside too but finds Toby's work colleague and people working inside there. None of them saw Alison come inside. How's that possible? Also, in the latest episode, Alison just disappears inside the elevator. Even Spencer goes like, 'Where did she disappear, how is that possible?" (3) In the Halloween episode, when the liars see Alison, she suddenly disappears (again) when Ezra appears. And he goes like, "You guys look like you've seen a ghost". Not that Ezra knows she's a ghost but kind of like a hint and giving the audience and indirect idea. (4) In the other Halloween episode, a small child comes to Hannah's house. Who resembled Alison and she suddenly disappears too when Hannah's mom goes back up. Some kind of relation between her and Alison?
Good point, or it could be another reason or clue why Alison is alive. Why didn't she tell Emily who A was if she was dead anyway. But if she actually was alive she couln't tell Emily the secret because two can only keep a secret if one of them is dead. Do you know what I mean? :)
Is it just me or does anyone else see letters in the lipstick Mark on the cup at the end of Hanna's clip?!? It looks like a name like Brian or something?? Or am I just on crazy overload with all these A theories?? O.o
It has to be someone that has been in the show the whole time, because when Aria askes Alison if she sees A. Alison says : Everywhere i turn, so do you. You all do.
These are all the time stamps of Ali just saying she’s alive to all the liars in one way or another which is soo good: Hanna: 0:15 Emily: 3:45 Spencer: 5:36 Aria: 7:50 - 9:07
Sorry I can't understand your language but if you read the description you'll see which season and episode Alison visited the girls :) Desculpe, não posso compreender a sua linguagem, mas se você ler a descrição você vai ver que temporada e episódio Alison visitou as meninas :)
Whatever happened to this 'bigger role' storyline? Weren't they sort of hinting that each girl did *something* that night that had something to do with Ali's disappearance? They only did that for Spencer but forgot the rest
When ali says 'two can only keep a secret when one of them is dead', doesn't that mean that she can't tell Emily who A is because others will find out because she's not dead, which means they can't keep the secret
it's so confusing....i mean in the last episode we saw two red coats the one was cece but the other helped emily and then helped spencer find the a's ''house''...
my personal theory: Ali confessed to CeCe the truth about her (CeCe's) kicking out of college and CeCe buries her or maybe Ali was lying to CeCe all the time about the same thing but she found out the truth and buried her. SPOILER: The girl Spencer saw in Ali's room in PILOT is CeCe. (sorry, my english is not really good) PP I don't say Ali is dead.
Ally is alive and I have known that forever. Even though they are not going by the books the books do mention Ally all the time in the books. I have known Ally has been alive. I can't wait for the special on Tuesday!
Olivia M maybe they weren't whenever ali visited the girls, they were always like drugged or daydreaming. Ali only visits them when she knows that there drugged so the girls can think that they were hallucinating
What does Allison mean when she said to Aria "you know why I picked you right?" I think that Aria is part of the A team. She is the only in the opening theme that put her finger on her lips and says "shhh." Also in one of the scene endings, they show a doll house with all the dolls, Allison is seasted on top and there are four dolls on another level, 3 of them are wearing normal cloths and Aria's doll is wearing jeans and a black hoodie!
I just don't get it!!! In this visit Ali tells Emily she knows who A is, but when she re-visits her in season 4 she says she doesn't know who's after her?!? Maybe she was talking about Mona the first time, but doesn't know who the real A is? Or maybe one of the visits are her twin? But I thought it has been said there won't be a twin for Alison on the show? CONFUSED!
I think Ali has a split personality. I mean I couldn't think of any other explanation. Well...actually I could. She is playing along with A to keep herself and her friends safe. Didn't Mrs. D have an affair with Toby's dad, Spencer 's dad, and Aria's dad? Maybe she's the mother of Jason, Bethany, and Cece.
MsBombastix well Mona was a and Ali knew that but she then realizes that it wasn’t just Mona because Mona was in radley and the night of the fire how Sara Harvey and Charlotte were both there Ali saw Sara and thought she was a Bc not only were the girls seeing red coat Ali was to. Even tho she was also red coat. So after she realized all that she knew somebody else was after her but she didn’t know who. She knew Cece aka a but it never crossed her mind Cece was a.
notice Ali's boots? Look at the boots of the person that dragged her out. It was Ali. She dragged her out of the barn. It wasn't a dream, it was her really Ali.
Remember In The Episode when ali was telling the story about the twins . Well Ok when they was fighting over the doll . Mabey Ali was the one who got killed . Or whatever , When she came back to see Aria , She got the doll back and said " Im taking back whats mine" Thats How U Know Ali IS NOT DEAD ....
Actually they are maternal cousins I'm so confused right now each season I got more and more confused first Ali was alive then A turns out to be Cece Drake who happens to be Ali's older sibling who was a transgender named Charles/Charlotte by birth then her mother Jessica has a twin sister who was Charlotte's biological mother and not only have one child she had two and later on it's revealed that Spencer is the second child of Jessica's twin sister Mary making her and Charlotte biological siblings sorry for spoiling but it's so confusing.
