Тёмный

Protect Your Economy: A Reply to Atif Mian 

Taimur_Laal
Подписаться 220 тыс.
Просмотров 5 тыс.
50% 1

Recently the FBR has recommended 25% GST on imported luxury items. Economics such as Atif Mian oppose barriers on trade as a general principle. In this video essay I will look at the historical evidence of protectionism from the work of South Korean economist Ha-Joon Chang and argue that Pakistan needs such barriers on imported luxury items to save forex.

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

9 мар 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 41   
@Knockingvoice65
@Knockingvoice65 Год назад
Sir, Also include the history of Ireland, the country adapted total free market economy and removed all tariff barriers. Now it is going to be one of the richest countries
@stu1246
@stu1246 Год назад
It is not the ultimate solution but a step in a right direction.
@faizahmed6068
@faizahmed6068 Год назад
Excellent lecture Dr. Sahab. But maaf kijiyega, I think you should embrace your silver hair now. Their shine in the light reflected your wisdom.:)
@dinny4001
@dinny4001 Год назад
Half way through the video just thought about the present day. EV adoption is picking up in USA and Europe. US government introduced inflation reduction act which subsidized all EV related industries while keeping Trump era tariffs on china . They also stopped ASMl the manufacturer of semi conductor fabricators to stop selling to China.
@Taimur_Laal
@Taimur_Laal Год назад
Excellent points. Thanks for that.
@teknikaisb2699
@teknikaisb2699 Год назад
@TaimurRahman Could you please present the structure of farmland holding policy presently implemented and practiced in China along with its pros and cons.
@amirniazi5184
@amirniazi5184 Год назад
Very well explained. Thanks
@ghulamalikatto1577
@ghulamalikatto1577 9 месяцев назад
Very well explained… thank you for this 👍🏼
@sumiyahussain7252
@sumiyahussain7252 11 месяцев назад
AoA Sir, Sir your lectures are so informative and mind blowing to understand the actual realities of international political economy. Could you please upload video about taxation system of Pakistan and how an ideal taxation regime can work well for the benefit of masses and how real estate has affected Pakistan's economy. Thank you sir
@ayvesshekh1313
@ayvesshekh1313 Год назад
Sir can you please do a content on clarification of authoritarianism in Communism, because it's the most controversial and criticized nature of this system and I haven't seen any serious defense for it.
@tahircheema7817
@tahircheema7817 Год назад
Muftah or atif both are in favour of free market.lkn wo import tax(import barriers)k against nai h.pakistan me 300% tk b tax mojud h kuch chezo pe.import ban lgany k bad ki surat hal b bta dain sir. Na dwai ho gi na koi machine,na koi lab,na koi computer,na oil,na gas na koi karhana, na koi rozgar economy ik dam beth jaye gi. Import barriers mazeed strict kiye ja sakty h or hony b chahye lkn full stop is impossible. Ban is not solution
@AsfandSaleem
@AsfandSaleem Год назад
Can you link the original article? I couldn't find it over the web
@alikhanak123
@alikhanak123 Год назад
Mara aik bohat important Sawal hay, " apne bal kyo kalay kar liya hain 😂😂😂".. Taimoor Sahab i love your lectures.
@hamzaimran7086
@hamzaimran7086 Год назад
So the crux of the matter is that our dean at NUST Dr Ashfaq Hassan Khan is right about imposing restrictions on imports is necessary and beneficial for our economy.
@NadirKhan-zi6ng
@NadirKhan-zi6ng Год назад
Sir let assume if we try to adapt protectionism in our country, but we have no choice for it because as as PM Shabaz shreef said there is no other way except accepting IMF demand , so please guide us how can we overcome current crisis without help of IMF ?
@babarazam900
@babarazam900 Год назад
👌
@duttadebadrito8846
@duttadebadrito8846 Год назад
Respected Sir , I'm from West Bengal, India. Does India take the right decision to not join RCEP ? & Is selective FTA beneficial for us?
@Habib2004
@Habib2004 Год назад
Lol. No, we will ask questions about hair only. Have already learned a lot on the topic :). So, the reason 🥺 for dying hair, please?
@servantof1god
@servantof1god Год назад
Slaam! Thanks
@waseemshahzad5991
@waseemshahzad5991 Год назад
Very nice 👍👍
@NinjaThinker
@NinjaThinker Год назад
Luxury items band kar dain plz gareeb molk k ameer log
@shahzad4646
@shahzad4646 Год назад
Dha property dealers per tax kib lage ga
@journeyofcss399
@journeyofcss399 Год назад
Sir kindly tell ways to deal with aftermath of trade barriers as Pakistan is highly import dependent country
@alikhanak123
@alikhanak123 Год назад
I understand if we increase terrific barriers it definitely will save dollers plus it will help industrialization of products we import. But what do you say about immidiate short term impact of this. Thoes who have this business of imports or rely heavily on imported raw material will be effected and may result in joblessnesss in short run until we have Industries coming up producing thoes raw material
@hamzaimran7086
@hamzaimran7086 Год назад
Wesay balon walay sawal ka jawab banta hai
@mirmuslim92
@mirmuslim92 Год назад
Salam sir humen luxury items k ilawa kin cheezon per tariffs berhane chaiyen? Aur sir Pakistan aur kin industries ko develop kersakta hai ager tariffs berhadiye jaen? Sir discos k losses ko cover kerne ka koi solution btaden? Aur pia and Pakistan steel mill and railway k liye b koi solution btaden? Aur sir ap kehte Hain k state ka hissa GDP mein zyada hona chaiye to kindly ye btaden k aur kin sectors me mazeed state ko involve hona chaiye? Sir china ka state wo konse 8 public sectors Hain jinko control kerta hai to inflation b control hojati hai? I'm your regular visitor thanks for making all this for us Allah bless you
@hamzakazmi2204
@hamzakazmi2204 Год назад
Sir ap aik din me jawan ho gae
@abdullahdogar699
@abdullahdogar699 Год назад
nyc transformation of hairs 😇
@babarazam900
@babarazam900 Год назад
Hair❤️
@zainabbass9937
@zainabbass9937 Год назад
Why would anyone trust your approach vs atif mian who is a respected economist? You are a youtuber
@Taimur_Laal
@Taimur_Laal Год назад
Actually, I'm professor of Political Economy at LUMS. But doesn't matter what my qualifications are. You should follow the logic and evidence presented.
@ctscan3088
@ctscan3088 Год назад
Slavery was not the reason for the civil war, it was purely economic. Slavery was abolished by Abe outsides the union to attract the slaves. Abraham is given undue credit, He was a politician and just as Machiavellian as any other siasi dog.
@Taimur_Laal
@Taimur_Laal Год назад
I disagree. Look at it the other way around. Read what the South was writing. They were clear that they had to fight to save plantation slavery. That was their main motive.
@MM-qs7qd
@MM-qs7qd Год назад
You're propagating the lost cause narrative espoused by the defeated landowners and slave owners of the south. The same people were able to implement jim crow laws of racial segregation after lincoln. The confederates themselves were very clear in identifying their reason for rebellion due to slavery.
@ctscan3088
@ctscan3088 Год назад
@@Taimur_Laal Yes that's true Rehman bhai, but it's never black or white. I suspect both opinions existed, along with extremely illogical ones.
@ctscan3088
@ctscan3088 Год назад
What did you do to your hair man, your wisdom is gone
Далее
Economist explains why India can never grow like China
23:47
Atif Mian | What to do about Pakistan’s Economy?
1:40:53
What is Taghut?
20:20
Просмотров 33 тыс.
У Котика Отняли Игрушку 🥺
0:15