Тёмный

Psychopath Doctor Turned Stalker and Murderer? | The Story of Andrew Bagby and Zachary Turner 

Annie Elise x 10 to LIFE
Подписаться 1,4 млн
Просмотров 300 тыс.
50% 1

My exclusive Salty Chocolate Caramel Dream is almost sold out so this is your last chance to grab it! Click shopbeam.com/1... and use code 10TOLIFE to get up to 40% off at checkout.
.
We're going on TOUR!! Come see one of our episodes LIVE in a city near you! Head to annieelise.com... for dates and ticket info!
.
Shop the Merch!: www.annieelise...
Join the 10 to LIFE Community for Exclusive Content & Perks: / annieelise
.
Become a Channel Member:
/ @annieelise
.
For Business Inquiries: 10toLife@WMEAgency.com
.
Podcast: podfollow.com/...
.
Follow me on Social:
Instagram: / _annieelise
Facebook: / 10tolife
Tik Tok: / _annieelise
.
*Sources used to collect this information include various public news sites, interviews, court documents, FB groups dedicated to the case, and various news channel segments. When quoting statements made by others, they are strictly alleged until confirmed otherwise. Please remember my videos are my independent opinion and to always do your own research.
••••••••••••••••••
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this video are personal and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of any other agency, organization, employer, or company. Assumptions made in the analysis are not reflective of the position of any entity other than the creator(s). These views are subject to change, revision, and rethinking at any time and are not to be held in perpetuity. We make no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, correctness, suitability, or validity of any information on this video and will not be liable for any errors, omissions, or delays in this information or any losses injuries, or damages arising from its display or use. All information is provided on an as-is basis. It is the reader’s responsibility to verify their own facts.
Comments on this channel are the sole responsibility of their writers and as such the writers will take full responsibility, liability, and blame for any libel or litigation that results from something written in or as a direct result of something written in a comment. Please feel free to challenge or disagree in the comments section - but 10 to LIFE reserves the right to delete any comment for any reason- so please keep it polite and relevant.
Psychopath Doctor Turned Stalker and Murderer? | The Story of Andrew Bagby and Zachary Turner
andrew bagby,zachary turner,dear zachary,shirley turner,kurt kuenne,andrew bagby murder,david bagby,real crime stories,dear zachary a letter to a son about his father,dear zachary case,true crime stories,annie elise,annie elise 10 to life,kate and david bagby,dear zachary ending,true crime recaps,dear zachary trailer,shirley turner dear zachary,annie elise true crime,dear zachary documentary,true crime documentary,dear zachary doc, true crime

Опубликовано:

 

24 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,9 тыс.   
@jetskii24
@jetskii24 Месяц назад
Annie please help! My friend Kaysey Yoder has been missing out of Eaton Colorado since Jan 14. She is a mother of 4 boys and would never stay away from them on purpose, esp her oldest who is disabled due to microcephaly. She used to provide him with 24 hr care. I have submitted requests on your website. But please help us find kaysey!!
@Perthgurl_6024
@Perthgurl_6024 Месяц назад
😩@@jetskii24 .. I can't even imagine how that must feel for you (and naturally, the family). I pray peace be upon you all while you wait for your friend to be found. 💕
@AnnaElsi-y4k
@AnnaElsi-y4k Месяц назад
Like and comment so Annie can see it!
@6141794
@6141794 Месяц назад
Hope this helps.
@alejandraromero1204
@alejandraromero1204 Месяц назад
Praying for her safe return😢
@yvonneherman2189
@yvonneherman2189 Месяц назад
Hoping this will help!
@dumpiestdinosaur.3834
@dumpiestdinosaur.3834 Месяц назад
I’m from Newfoundland and people still tear up when talking about this story. The justice system 100% failed everyone involved here, especially Zachary, it’s so heartbreaking
@Crose10101
@Crose10101 Месяц назад
Me to, soon as I heard the names 😢
@laurapotpie
@laurapotpie Месяц назад
Fails a lot here - they let another murderer walk last week...
@vladimirsamardzic963
@vladimirsamardzic963 Месяц назад
​@ya thats what they do 😢laurapotpie
@bewilderedwomenstravels6776
@bewilderedwomenstravels6776 10 дней назад
Canada's criminal protection system fails all victims
@shanaknibbs3790
@shanaknibbs3790 Месяц назад
By far, one of the most heartbreaking cases I’ve heard. To have a miracle baby, then have him ripped away from you, only to send you an angel from beyond the grave and then have him ripped away too, all by the same person. I would set the world on fire!
@shannon897
@shannon897 Месяц назад
I knowwwww 😢😢 I think of this case often as it’s one of the most heartbreaking for me too. What are the chances so many tragedies affect a good, hardworking, loving family? It’s horrific. I’m so grateful Zachary’s grandparents didn’t go through with their plans and became motivated to advocate for change. Beautiful ppl 🤍
@shanaknibbs3790
@shanaknibbs3790 6 дней назад
@@shannon897 Bad things happening to good people always hurts the most! 😥
@Miss_Meee
@Miss_Meee Месяц назад
Dear Zachary broke my WHOLE heart. I dont think ive ever heard a more tragic and haunting case
@JackieBlue65
@JackieBlue65 21 день назад
Mine too 💔💔
@leslieannaconnally4830
@leslieannaconnally4830 Месяц назад
What makes this case so disheartening is Andrew’s parents longed for him and then to lose both their son and beautiful grandson to one horrific human is inconceivable. I had never heard about this case and I now will never forget get. I truly hope Andrew’s parents know how utterly amazing we as society think they are.
@marynehra502
@marynehra502 Месяц назад
Their heartbreak must be immense
@Xsintrik7777
@Xsintrik7777 Месяц назад
Their story... I can't shake how sad it makes me. But I wanted to totally agree with your last sentence. I'm kinda speechless, I can't find the correct words to describe how unbelievable I think the parents are. They are kind warriors. They are gentle Giants. Their grace and authenticity has made a huge impact on me.
@alexduff6264
@alexduff6264 Месяц назад
I totally agree.... devastating 😔
@susanmunn8249
@susanmunn8249 Месяц назад
The documentary Dear Zachary is absolutely amazing about this case. It's heart breaking but definitely worth the watch
@ellenthom34
@ellenthom34 Месяц назад
People unstable erratic over the top manipulative people are dangerous. Never meet them alone! If you have to retrieve items or feel you need a final talk surround yourself with friends in a neutral location. Life truly boils down to risk management. Cooley and objectively.reflectvon actions not words. Listen to your family and friends. Their control. Their stalking. Their refusal to take responsibility for lies😀and actions. You just never know when that once charming person will go off the rails. Pls protect yourself.
@samanthatippett4431
@samanthatippett4431 Месяц назад
Oh my god. This happened local to me (NL). My mom babysat Zachary several times, I remember when mom walked into my room to tell me what happened. We were both devastated. Zachary's grandparents (Andrew's parents) are such lovely people, and they fought so hard for custody. The system failed them. Thank you for telling their story.
@mevv
@mevv Месяц назад
We need to start holding judges accountable.
@lauragosnell2481
@lauragosnell2481 Месяц назад
Yes, we do!
@wendywonnell9020
@wendywonnell9020 Месяц назад
Not the judge. It's the responsibility of the prosecutor to bring the history of the defendant to the judge's attention at the bail hearing. It's a serious failure on the part of the prosecutor who should be held accountable before the state bar.
@jenniferdavis1873
@jenniferdavis1873 Месяц назад
Just as much as the cps works, when they give advice, then go and let them out with no supervision.
@dontworryaboutit4255
@dontworryaboutit4255 Месяц назад
Like the one who gave Gypsy Blanchard 10 years. 🤮
@bethpaluzzi1380
@bethpaluzzi1380 Месяц назад
Yes, absolutely
@jarikawinfield
@jarikawinfield Месяц назад
that judge should go to jail, she's a huge reason baby Zachary isn't here anymore. his poor grandparents, they didn't deserve all this pain. such good people and they were robbed of both of their precious boys.
@NikkiTinAZ
@NikkiTinAZ Месяц назад
Judges are NOT allowed to give legal advice to parties. And definitely CANNOT walk them through their paperwork!!
@skiewalker1033
@skiewalker1033 Месяц назад
So sad and sick the judge allows her to have Zachary after she murdered Zachary’s dad!. Canada and America both have corrupt governments. Criminal justice system is justice for the criminals not the victims. That’s why irs called the criminal justice system. A fact!. So sad and so preventable.
@itsruckaswife7036
@itsruckaswife7036 Месяц назад
⁠@@NikkiTinAZright ? I thought that sounded insane.. so what Sara Boone is expecting actually happens ??
@cynthia-n9w
@cynthia-n9w 12 дней назад
Y'all have obviously not spent time in Newfoundland.
@bewilderedwomenstravels6776
@bewilderedwomenstravels6776 10 дней назад
There are no good judges in Canada. They are all about protecting the criminal
@Crimeandpunishment65
@Crimeandpunishment65 Месяц назад
She was so evil. She didn’t want to face the consequences and she didn’t want to see David’s parents have the baby. 😭😭😭😭😭
@bethpaluzzi1380
@bethpaluzzi1380 Месяц назад
I agree completely
@Tron4JC
@Tron4JC Месяц назад
And she wanted to frame her most recent ex for what she did to herself and Zachary. A true monster.
@michhaynes7272
@michhaynes7272 Месяц назад
This poor couple, I can't believe how much they have been put through at the hands of Sheryl and this judge! These amazing people deserve so much better. My heart goes out to them.
@maxmccinnamon
@maxmccinnamon Месяц назад
Dear Zachary is one of the best documentaries I’ve ever seen, I cry every time I watch it. Absolutely devastating
@Snoodles294
@Snoodles294 Месяц назад
Same
@scudmisslez
@scudmisslez Месяц назад
Im blown away by this story. These judges need to be held accountable.
@AliciaLynn2
@AliciaLynn2 Месяц назад
How was the judge not removed from the bench????? Not only for her ignorance in not looking into Shirley’s past violent behavior but also for giving her legal advice and basically step by step instructions on how to appeal which I thought judges weren’t allowed to do, definitely not the judge presiding over your case!!!!
@balonitoni999
@balonitoni999 Месяц назад
Because she’s in Canada, land of the clowns. Where we do everything backwards and where everything is rotten and doesn’t make sense.
@kweenz109
@kweenz109 Месяц назад
Definitely not right. Shes showing her bias. Hope she has nightmares every night for her VERY poor judgement.
@balonitoni999
@balonitoni999 Месяц назад
@@kweenz109 she doesn’t because she’s obviously too brain dead to have that level of self reflection
@irrpaqeyes
@irrpaqeyes Месяц назад
Right? Curious to how many cases she did this to before this one
@Bats4lawyer
@Bats4lawyer Месяц назад
That judge is a murderer. He is the reason a little boy is dead and honestly I’m sure this ain’t the first time this has happened under his watch. Disgusting.
@choicekat
@choicekat Месяц назад
Andrews parents played the long game. It takes so much patience and solidarity. Those parents are heroic. I haven’t seen the end but those two were/are heroes
@erinlchapman61925
@erinlchapman61925 Месяц назад
Dear Zachary was the first documentary I ever watched on purpose. It's such an amazing tribute everyone go watch it!!
@sonjaotwell5439
@sonjaotwell5439 Месяц назад
I can’t recommend it enough. I’ve rewatched it with probably half a dozen friends and family because I needed to share it!
@wendywoobles
@wendywoobles Месяц назад
My favorite documentary ❤ heart wrenching but also his parents are so amazing ❤
@sabrinahofmeister
@sabrinahofmeister Месяц назад
Get the tissues ready, though! 😫
@fahsky
@fahsky Месяц назад
It's too gut wrenching for me to recommend it to others, but it is so wellmade.
@indianikit741
@indianikit741 Месяц назад
Next doc you should watch is Marwencol. Mindblowing.
@tonjiakyle3236
@tonjiakyle3236 Месяц назад
The judge should have been disbarred and held accountable for involuntary manslaughter for Zachary. She let this psycho loose. RIP Andrew and Zachary 🙏🙏🙏
@ashleyparker1481
@ashleyparker1481 Месяц назад
Yes!!
@michelleguzman77
@michelleguzman77 Месяц назад
Omg!! The anger...the rage...the heartbreak... all the the emotions I feel from one. What an evil monster!! That judge is just as evil & gross.
@brandonjusblong
@brandonjusblong Месяц назад
I hope the judge and psychiatrist has trouble sleeping at night and living with theirselves during the day it’s sad I hadn’t broke down like that in awhile it’s so heartbreaking that someone can be so evil to a baby
Месяц назад
Is that Judge, another Narcissist?
@7Mushrooms7
@7Mushrooms7 13 дней назад
​@brandonjusblong they probably saw themselves in her because they're probably also psychopaths. Unless they were so gullable they were manipulated by her. Either way I don't think they have remorse. They gave zero Fs the whole time knowing full well what she had done.
@karlag8312
@karlag8312 Месяц назад
I keep saying it, some of these so called “judges” should be held accountable. When is this s**t going to STOP. That stupid judge should be in jail if not removed from the bench. How many more lives if she going to destroy? And the psychiatrist only getting a $10K fine, give me a break, they should have revoked his license. It’s sickening, disgusting, appalling and a miscarriage of justice. I feel so bad for Kate and David. Andrew and Zachary may they rest in peace.
@Humanlexpression
@Humanlexpression Месяц назад
what pisses me off the most about this case is the fact that zachary wasn’t given immediately to his grandparents. shirley is a MURDERER. how could anyone in their right mind, allow a murderer to take care of a baby. the screwed up justice system is the reason why Zachary isn’t here today. rest in peace andrew and Zachary. i’m sorry you were failed.
@rhondadavis1483
@rhondadavis1483 Месяц назад
In the US WE DO HAVE THE POWER to change our Justice system!!! We can VOTE these judges in or OUT! It’s the same with our legislators(that make the laws), our DAs (they can choose to prosecute or recommend sentences)and our Judges (that can free or give sentences to the max!!!) We have to take our power back by doing a little research on all these positions and vote appropriately!! These ppl serve as OUR representatives! Please ppl be smart and make our Justice system fair!
@KathrynH81
@KathrynH81 Месяц назад
In Canada we do not vote for judges. We also do not have DA's that are voted in. We have Crown Attorneys that are appointed.
@whynot12321
@whynot12321 Месяц назад
@@rhondadavis1483 We don't have that power here in Canada, unfortunately.
@rhondadavis1483
@rhondadavis1483 Месяц назад
@@KathrynH81 oh ok👍 We see such injustices in the US so we do have choices to make changes in our justice system. I’m curious… how can ppl like this horrible Judge be removed? Do the ppl have a voice in changes? Also can you not vote in legislators to make changes to laws?
@rhondadavis1483
@rhondadavis1483 Месяц назад
@@whynot12321 I’m so sorry, I honestly didn’t know that! I did edit my comment to make it towards Americans. Is there nothing you can do if there is a horrible Judge like this??
@kierawelch2106
@kierawelch2106 Месяц назад
Thank you Kate and David for making the ultimate sacrifice to save so many other children. That judge should be thrown in prison for murder. Disgusting. Disgraceful. Atrocious.
@bakermob29
@bakermob29 Месяц назад
I hope that judge was removed. Those poor parents. What a sad story.
@corablah9809
@corablah9809 Месяц назад
Doubt it. Canada loves evil, awful judges
@Bats4lawyer
@Bats4lawyer Месяц назад
Apparently he wasn’t. Which is insane because he is a murderer.
@ACSuperstar
@ACSuperstar Месяц назад
​@@Bats4lawyerOr at least an accomplice.
@7Mushrooms7
@7Mushrooms7 13 дней назад
​@@Bats4lawyershe.
@7Mushrooms7
@7Mushrooms7 13 дней назад
Everyone ever judged by her should appeal based on how she aided and abeded a murderer. Only then the courts would want to shove her away for causing so much trouble and costing so much to the court.
@Dgervelis1
@Dgervelis1 Месяц назад
Absolutely frustrating. The judge should be removed from the bench. God bless the grandparents of Andrew and baby Zachary. Prayers and love and blessings!!!!!
@emo_penguin420
@emo_penguin420 Месяц назад
David and Kate are the literal definition of classy. Wow, all my respect! I can't even imagine how that went: >hey, what are you up to today? >oh, you know, hanging out and tolerating our son's unaliver and her ridiculous whims... Wow, talk about some mental strength and resilience 💕
@ivy821
@ivy821 Месяц назад
poor baby Zachary :( he was so cute and lovable.. prayers for his grandparents
@catsanchez5749
@catsanchez5749 Месяц назад
That judge should be FIRED.
@Sixthedragon0720
@Sixthedragon0720 Месяц назад
At the very least 😡
@catsanchez5749
@catsanchez5749 Месяц назад
@@Sixthedragon0720 Definitely agree, the pyschiatrist also.
@mariafdiaspadilha1445
@mariafdiaspadilha1445 Месяц назад
The judge is just as guilty, there is no excuse for what she did
@catsanchez5749
@catsanchez5749 Месяц назад
@@mariafdiaspadilha1445 Definitely agree.
@nathanmanning5219
@nathanmanning5219 Месяц назад
Sadly, she continued her career for years and retired two years ago
@StarlightSelenite
@StarlightSelenite Месяц назад
Corruption from the justice system and law enforcement, in general, pisses me off to no end. So, yes, this case was so frustrating and sad. But the light at the end of the tunnel was Zachary’s law, and Kate and David. The strength that couple has is incredible.
@blacknbougie8021
@blacknbougie8021 Месяц назад
I'll never forget this story. The anger & sadness i felt was indescribable. Zach & his dad deserved so much better, so did the grandparents 💔
@marissaraedickman9103
@marissaraedickman9103 Месяц назад
I don’t often cry watching these videos, but damn. Zachary’s story really destroyed me. Rest In Paradise, angel.
@reynaolvera7526
@reynaolvera7526 Месяц назад
This documentary will absolutely crush your soul. The devastation is so extreme you’ll never be the same.
@I_DontRemember
@I_DontRemember Месяц назад
Well said. I watched it 10 years ago and not a day goes by I don’t think about it. The parents are who I modeled the parent I want to be off.
@reynaolvera7526
@reynaolvera7526 Месяц назад
@@I_DontRemember absolutely. How their son said it would be a waste of parents to be a lousy person. He knew his parents were the best.
@mwalkerl
@mwalkerl Месяц назад
This woman is a great reminder that being a doctor doesn't mean you're smart. Same goes for lawyers, CEOs, etc.
@lesterine77
@lesterine77 Месяц назад
No. You actually have to be intelligent to make it through medical school and law school. She is just evil. And lacks common sense. But no one should ever make a claim that any moron could become a dr or a lawyer bc that is 100% false.
@lesterine77
@lesterine77 Месяц назад
Umm. No. I'm sorry. But to claim that you don't have to be intelligent to become a dr or a lawyer is utter nonsense.
@demarcusholmes2866
@demarcusholmes2866 Месяц назад
That's not what he said he said just because you are those things doesn't mean you are smart or have common sense ​@@lesterine77
@calihipechik7657
@calihipechik7657 Месяц назад
​@@lesterine77That's not what the comment said. Besides, having spent a lot of time around highly educated people, I definitely see the difference between book smarts and common sense, empathy and moral compass.
@PESWINOMVX
@PESWINOMVX Месяц назад
I dont know how she made it because she lacked intelligence in every other aspect of her life
@LaurenMcAlister-j4s
@LaurenMcAlister-j4s Месяц назад
This is so so so sad! Wow. Those poor parents/ grandparents and sweet little baby Zachary. How heartbreaking. He looked just like his daddy too. 😭
@OhCeCelia
@OhCeCelia Месяц назад
That was an intense case!!💔 When you said Andrew's parents planned to take their own lives, my heart SANK! I'm so happy they didn't follow through. Now the law is passed and scholarships are in place. Amazing parents, grandparents, and overall outstanding people!! 🩷🩷
@Mitchy407
@Mitchy407 25 дней назад
I have watched Dear Zachery so many times. I’m not a crier not but I always weep by the end. Same here, to have such amazing GOOD people have there lives utterly and completely destroyed by one pure evil woman is beyond words. Thank you for sharing The Bagby’s story 🙏🏻
@Snoodles294
@Snoodles294 Месяц назад
Thanks for covering this case. I am from Newfoundland. My cousin was the lawyer for Andrew's parents. She got called to the bar after this case. She is a judge here now. What a sad, tragic, and preventable case
@kaydublin5164
@kaydublin5164 Месяц назад
Awful
@thechloechronicles9688
@thechloechronicles9688 Месяц назад
Did they get rid of that judge?
@Snoodles294
@Snoodles294 Месяц назад
@@thechloechronicles9688 Justice Gale Welsh: Appointed to the Trial Division of the Supreme Court of Newfoundland in March of 1999; Appointed to the Court of Appeal March 2001; Elected supernumerary status March 31, 2021; Retired October 22, 2022.
@tngirlintx1195
@tngirlintx1195 Месяц назад
Short and Simple…She did this to continue causing pain to the Parents/Grandparents….this woman was INSANE!!!
@sherylyates7551
@sherylyates7551 Месяц назад
I soooo remember this case. This was a TRUE Heartbreaking story…. Should have NEVER EVER happened. She was a true MONSTER and that Judge is NO better …
@sharongrigg5336
@sharongrigg5336 Месяц назад
I watched the documentary dear Zachary year's ago & to this day can still remember Andrew's incredible family & his wonderful friends. It really showed what a great person Andrew was but i ugly cried for hours & it's never left me so you've been warned.
@ccthefox517
@ccthefox517 Месяц назад
If anyone has not watched the Netflix documentary about this, Dear Zachary, please do. It’s the absolute best documentary I’ve ever seen, but beware it’s extremely upsetting and heartbreaking (my apologies if Annie mentioned this, I’m about to start the video now. Sending lots of love to you, Annie! You’re the best 🫶🏼
@sarascrewed
@sarascrewed Месяц назад
I've never seen it I don't know anything about this case or anything yet...... Which is weird because I always have at least some idea about things especially if there are documentaries out there so I will definitely be watching it thank you.
@katief8449
@katief8449 Месяц назад
Yes watch the documentary first then watch this episode
@VibinJivin
@VibinJivin Месяц назад
watching tonight!!!!!!!
@alisonbanner9471
@alisonbanner9471 Месяц назад
I’m scared to watch it bc I’m bawling over this video 😭 but I want to!!!
@TheSHTFFarm
@TheSHTFFarm Месяц назад
Such a sad, sad documentary. Heartbreaking. His friend is a good man.
@brynnbowers8405
@brynnbowers8405 Месяц назад
Video starts at 4:17
@candacedixon6443
@candacedixon6443 Месяц назад
Ty 😊
@scorpianna420
@scorpianna420 Месяц назад
Thank you!
@megancolburn4131
@megancolburn4131 Месяц назад
THANK U
@ItsMe_Chelle
@ItsMe_Chelle Месяц назад
TY!
@whitediamonds5327
@whitediamonds5327 22 дня назад
Thank you.😂
@audreygallo8358
@audreygallo8358 Месяц назад
Two lives senselessly ended for no reason. Everyone who failed them needs to be held accountable
@jodismith7781
@jodismith7781 Месяц назад
Did anything happen with the judge? Was she held accountable? Was she removed from the bench? That judge should have paid dearly for the damage she caused to so many through her completely negligent, corrupt, and incompetent actions! It’s enraging she ENCOURAGED and ALLOWED this to happen.
@michelebell1997
@michelebell1997 Месяц назад
My mind cannot comprehend all the evils in this world, I mean I feel guilty when I raise my voice to people so how could another human do these things? 😢 I hope everyone is having an amazing day and much love from Colorado! 💜
@ladonnaramirez4467
@ladonnaramirez4467 Месяц назад
Much love from AZ! I think it's because we are empaths. I could never hurt someone. It would be the same as hurting myself. ❤
@tv-21
@tv-21 Месяц назад
She was so beautiful too like she can get anybody she wants
@JenniferHarr-b9b
@JenniferHarr-b9b 29 дней назад
I have no idea how Andrew’s family maintained such composure through all of this. Heartbreaking 💔 I don’t think Shirley ever wanted that child she wanted a pawn, some way to torture his family further. 😖 The judge and her therapist and this are just a joke. I’m sure the judge felt some sort of kindness towards her being a woman in a powerful position. One was a doctor and the judge. Both have the ability to dictate other peoples lives. And look at how that turned out. I have a feeling that Shirley made sure she was pregnant. She probably kept some ’ thing‘ from Andrew, to ensure she would be impregnated. That in itself is sick. I wonder about this because she took the condoms. I have heard of women keeping used condoms to purposely impregnate themselves. But maybe I’m wrong. I feel so awful for Andrew’s family, and Poor baby Zachary. I don’t really have any words to express how really freaking horrible this is. I’m grateful that his family has fought for the rights of other children. I’m glad they decided to stay and fight for others, That shows so much resiliency. This is just awful and horrible. I hope the justice system in both America and Canada thinks about this case when they put children in the care of could be murderers. The children should be where they are safest, This is when reconciliation with the original parent is a horrible idea. They have to stop looking at that and looking at the safety of these kids. My heart goes out to his family and friends. This just breaks my heart like everyone else on here. 💔
@extofer
@extofer Месяц назад
This one of the most heartbreaking cases. I’ve seen Dear Zachary twice and I really hesitated to watch this video. But you did a great job telling this story and I believe it needs to be told for the sake of Zachary’s and Andrew’s legacies.
@kelseymekenzie999
@kelseymekenzie999 Месяц назад
This story breaks my heart every time. I don’t know how the parents/grandparents stayed so strong after losing them. 💔 😞
@VibrantLight709
@VibrantLight709 Месяц назад
Annie! I’ve requested this case to all my favorite RU-vidrs for years. So glad to see you covering it. I’m from St Johns, NL and lived this nightmare in real time. I still think of Zachary and Andrew 😢
@CJLOVE23
@CJLOVE23 Месяц назад
The sadness and rage I felt watching the documentary of this case was like no other. I was in a state of depression for like 3 days. This is the absolute worst case I’ve ever heard of!! Andrew’s parents are so strong 😢
@jasonfranklin3534
@jasonfranklin3534 Месяц назад
I just wanna say this was one of the most heart wrenching stories I’ve heard. Had me in tears for the grandparents. But thank you Mrs Annie for your both empathetic and direct prospective of stories like this. Keep telling their stories.
@shelbyday5522
@shelbyday5522 Месяц назад
Im so sick of evil people getting away with doing awful things, wiggling their way out of punishment, and then hurting more people... I choked back tears as I listened about baby Zachary.... My babies being safe and sound with me at home. I sometimes spiral thinking about all of the babies and young ones who don't have safety. The ones who are forced to grow ups way too quickly. The ones who don't get to grow up at all. It is utterly heartbreaking what these babies go through... Im so sorry baby Zachary---You are loved by so many.
@corablah9809
@corablah9809 Месяц назад
I feel the same way. It is terrifying the things that happen to our most vulnerable people that really need safety and protection 💔💔
@jillspillers5980
@jillspillers5980 Месяц назад
Oh, my God! It IS- it’s the “Dear Zachary” story!!! This is probably my favorite- yet thoroughly heartbreaking- documentary I’ve ever watched.
@Alma2525
@Alma2525 Месяц назад
The documentary on this case is beyond heartbreaking.
@Born2Bbearded
@Born2Bbearded Месяц назад
I also LOVED the documentary that the best friend made for Andrew’s parents “Dear Zachary” was super sad though
@vanessacummings3175
@vanessacummings3175 Месяц назад
My goodness…. This is just awful!!! 😢 Andrew’s parents are some of the strongest people to be able to focus on ways to remember Zachary and Andrew. They took their pain and grief and used it to help others. ❤
@aintshecool
@aintshecool 20 дней назад
I remember watching the documentary about this, Dear Zachary. Ugh. One the most gut-wrenching watches ever. I suggest everyone check it out. But the way Shirley was allowed to be awful at her job, barely show up to work, be manipulative to her bosses/co-workers (and still have a job), abuse her children, give up custody, be a stalker, a murderer, and still get special treatment is beyond amazing. Not a redeeming quality about this woman. She had access to the best help and she still went down this path. I wonder how she was raised, because this behavior doesn’t come out of nowhere. So sad for the grandparents most of all. I just cannot imagine the pain they went through.
@fransinyard891
@fransinyard891 Месяц назад
In my opinion that judge needs to be charged & removed from the bench & disbarred! Much love and respect from Henderson Ga USA
@charlotterobb5435
@charlotterobb5435 Месяц назад
The documentary, Dear Zachary is one of the most heart wrenching documentaries I've ever seen. Well worth a watch, with lots of tissues.
@kellibug1970
@kellibug1970 22 дня назад
I cried so much watching this documentary. 😢
@jdweaver3331
@jdweaver3331 Месяц назад
I absolutely can’t believe no one saw her history with her other children and take Zachary away from her. I saw the documentary absolutely sad knowing what happened to baby Zachary
@katiehankins548
@katiehankins548 Месяц назад
Not me sobbing while washing the dishes. My heart is absolutely broken for this lovely couple. 💔 I cannot imagine the anger, heartbreak, and frustration they’ve dealt with. I’m glad their advocacy for change in the legal system on behalf of their child and grandchild has been successful. Who knows how many children these laws will save in the future.
@alicein1984
@alicein1984 Месяц назад
I don't know how I forgot about this case. Kate & David were cruelly taunted by Shirley while they were caring for Zachary while she was in jail. Put a picture up of her with their son she murdered...Kate & David are saints for dealing with her the way they did.
@lalag1695
@lalag1695 Месяц назад
Grandparents should have gone on the run with the baby. They were old and had nothing else to lose. Her final actions were a foregone conclusion and you could see it a mile away. So very sad and tragic.
@GigiRulesTheRoost
@GigiRulesTheRoost Месяц назад
Sweet little grandson and such a wonderful son David and Kate had. What misery they have had to deal with. I can't even imagine the pain. The documentary mentioned herein is very very good. Very very heartbreaking.
@Brandi_the_Baker
@Brandi_the_Baker Месяц назад
The judge should be held accountable for the death of baby Zachary! Period.
@smilingparrot
@smilingparrot Месяц назад
The documentary ‘Dear Zachary’ is amongst my favourites. I wanted to rewatch it the moment it ended. It is heart-wrenching, thought-provoking, and infuriating.
@judyharpur
@judyharpur Месяц назад
That judge needs to be sacked and have her take responsibility for her idiocy
@twinklemagic024
@twinklemagic024 8 дней назад
This story is a true representation of pure good vs pure evil. I’m so sorry for Andrew and Zachary’s family - their strength is awe inspiring. 💞
@haleaga
@haleaga Месяц назад
heart wrenching is an understatement, this is pure negligence from the judicial system.
@knitwitch914
@knitwitch914 Месяц назад
This story is in the most heartbreaking documentary I’ve ever seen. I was gutted by it so badly I couldn’t watch it again. I cried so hard.
@kellibug1970
@kellibug1970 22 дня назад
Same!!
@achristine80
@achristine80 Месяц назад
Judge immunity has become a HUGE problem is this country. So many criminals getting out on bond and committing the same or worse crimes recently. Can’t the Supreme Court decide whether they should be held accountable? “No one is above the law” is the most false slogan in our judicial system
@Heaven_v
@Heaven_v Месяц назад
Dear Zachary is my favorite documentary. That might be weird to say but it’s so sad and so raw. I love it because it does such a good job of not only showing the true horrors this family experienced but it also shows the immense love Andrew and Zacharys friends and family felt for them. I feel as if I mourned with them. I’m so happy you’re talking about this.
@deirdremcloughlin1380
@deirdremcloughlin1380 Месяц назад
The image of Andrew in the park lying there so alone is breaking my heart. I sincerly hope Kate and David and Andrews friends can continue to live in peace.
@MzBeckiiBabii
@MzBeckiiBabii Месяц назад
Dear Zachary is a beautiful tribute to a beautiful family that was torn apart by a monster and a horrible legal system. It is gut wrenching. I cried for days after watching it
@ZoeBurks
@ZoeBurks Месяц назад
I can't stop myself from saying 10 to life with Annie Elise...... Starts.... Right now in my head 😂❤ I watched a lot of her older videos and hearing that it's not in her newer videos has me saying it myself. Its like Bailey Sarian and her theme song😢❤
@AnnmarieKaye-t8k
@AnnmarieKaye-t8k Месяц назад
@@ZoeBurks I say it out loud my son always looks over at me when I do lol 🤣🤣🤣
@AnnmarieKaye-t8k
@AnnmarieKaye-t8k Месяц назад
@@ZoeBurks its the pause before it says starts right now with Annie Elise love it 💖
@TanyaLee-s3q
@TanyaLee-s3q Месяц назад
I miss that 😂😂
@muffin1538
@muffin1538 25 дней назад
i remember the first time i watched the documentary all those years ago. i had no context, no idea that halfway through zachary would die. really cemented this case in my mind. great video. her motive to me was pretty transparent; spite. jealousy drove every action she ever made, and she was pissed her baby loved his grandparents more than her. i don't remember the term for it but it's similar to when a husband takes the life of his wife and children and then himself---a lot of women will kill their kids to get back at their significant others as well.
@ashleyanddavidwhitehurst5728
@ashleyanddavidwhitehurst5728 Месяц назад
I've watched Dear Zachary a few times. It gets me so emotional as I am right now. Andrew and Zachary were such beautiful souls and his parents are some of the greatest people and I admire them so much. I don't know what I would have done in their situation. Sooo many people failed this family. Long Live Andrew and Zachary ❤❤
@isabelpark7650
@isabelpark7650 Месяц назад
This story is so unbelievable I can't belive it. It left me in tears as these poor souls were all failed so miserably.
@thaistulio1078
@thaistulio1078 Месяц назад
I can't believe this case. What was that judge thinking? This is the most unethical thing I've ever heard.
@cyankohler4115
@cyankohler4115 Месяц назад
I’ve been wrecked by this since I was 16 years old and watched the documentary 😭 those grandparents are seriously the strongest in the world.. 💔
@lawnmow3rg1rl
@lawnmow3rg1rl Месяц назад
Hi Annie! I'm from Nfld and remember this well. My parents lived in this town when this happened and it was quite shocking. THANK YOU for covering this! Shirley was a lunatic, my heart bleeds for Andrew and Zachary. ❤
@Iceaberg17
@Iceaberg17 Месяц назад
The judge needs to be REMOVED from the bench!!!
@mingdagreatest
@mingdagreatest Месяц назад
“Dear Zachary” was heart wrenching 🥺🥺
@wendywoobles
@wendywoobles Месяц назад
Great documentary, but oh my, I bawled watching this. I've seen this a few times 💔
@jillruben8924
@jillruben8924 Месяц назад
May I ask where I can watch this?
@LS-gy9bq
@LS-gy9bq Месяц назад
Yes I saw it years ago. Heart-wrenching is right.
@LS-gy9bq
@LS-gy9bq Месяц назад
​@@jillruben8924I can't remember where I originally saw it. I would do a Google search and ask where can I find dear Zachary movie. Then it can tell you what platforms still have it.
@kristabouse4379
@kristabouse4379 Месяц назад
​@@jillruben8924 someone said it's on Netflix
@rickjames7576
@rickjames7576 Месяц назад
I'm so SAD....she was such a sadistic MONSTER. She tortured every person that had the misfortune of coming across her path. The grandparents pain breaks my heart. This case.......
@kristaquin
@kristaquin Месяц назад
"Andrew was like super outgoing, he was friendly, people just like loved him, his looks matched his personality...he was always smiling" *shows picture of a boy with dead-pan serious face* The dialogue continues to say: "Truly the life of the party" 😂
@laughingcorrpseholly4136
@laughingcorrpseholly4136 Месяц назад
😂😂😂
@annieelise
@annieelise Месяц назад
Hey - I like to consider myself the life of the party, but I have permanent RBF. 😂
@lindseyjohnson9478
@lindseyjohnson9478 Месяц назад
@@annieelise yaaaaaaaas, Annie 🤣👏 me too, girl! It happens 😅
@sonjaotwell5439
@sonjaotwell5439 Месяц назад
You need to watch the documentary. He was so well-loved and had so many friends, they held memorials for him in 3 cities.
@OhCeCelia
@OhCeCelia Месяц назад
​@@annieeliseHa! Same! I don't even know I'm looking like that😂
@Mands244
@Mands244 Месяц назад
She did it for three reasons, to avoid prison, frame new guy and to take Zachary away from the grandparents. I knew a woman like this and unfortunately she's not been brought to justice yet. Hopefully one day something will happen that will bring more evidence to light and she will pay for her crimes
@Karebearkerri
@Karebearkerri Месяц назад
The way you say Newfoundland as a Canadian I couldn’t help but laugh 😂
@sraewill
@sraewill Месяц назад
I'm not even Canadian and I shuddered a little😂
@MissVanessaHendren
@MissVanessaHendren Месяц назад
I came to the comments to say the same thing lol
@pennysweet1
@pennysweet1 Месяц назад
How do you pronounce it? 😂
@jesscoffinlevelone
@jesscoffinlevelone Месяц назад
New-fun-land lol. I'm from there. 😂
@MissVanessaHendren
@MissVanessaHendren Месяц назад
@pennysweet1 you would think it would be pronounced New-Found-Land, since that's how it's spelt... but it's more like New-Fund-Land or New-Fund-Lund (I've heard it pronounced like this with the local Newfy accent the most)
@miriamfonseca9659
@miriamfonseca9659 Месяц назад
That is so heartbreaking! I think it is one of the worst cases I have seen on the channel. The justice system completely failed 😢😢
@jill9405
@jill9405 Месяц назад
Good morning 10 to lifers!! Everyone needs a friend like Clarke. He knew something was wrong with meeting Shirley. Even his coworkers knew Andrew not showing up for work was unusual. Shirley is a walking red flag. Andrew’s parents are so strong I don’t have kids, I can’t imagine how emotionally draining it was to deal with their son being murdered and also have your grandson’s life taken by the same woman who took their sons life. Why was the judge not disbarred? She should have been reprimanded the first time she interfered with the case? There were so many things that angered/ frustrated me, I don’t know how Andrew’s family and friends were able to try and hold it together. There is no excuse for how the case was handled. I am glad some good came from this pain; I think Andrew would be proud of his legacy.
@AlexandraDingbat
@AlexandraDingbat Месяц назад
Good morning 🌄 ❤
@jamalkramer3067
@jamalkramer3067 28 дней назад
I’ve been WAITING forever for someone to finally cover this tragic story!! Thank you! ❤
@hajfrank710
@hajfrank710 Месяц назад
This documentary probably hit me harder than any I’ve ever seen. I think about it so often.
@TheSHTFFarm
@TheSHTFFarm Месяц назад
Same 😢
@nickiea3015
@nickiea3015 Месяц назад
The support for his family is beautiful 😭 his friends making schedule! Amazing
@ashleyana7084
@ashleyana7084 Месяц назад
I've never cried so much watching a documentary, as I did with dear Zachary. This case is HAUNTING
@deeluu905
@deeluu905 29 дней назад
The strength and courage of the grandparents is beyond a miracle. God truly was carrying them through. Bless their souls.
@kammynlogymom
@kammynlogymom Месяц назад
Judge and psychiatrist should be held accountable. Shirley was a psychopath! Manipulative, probably narcissistic , crazy loon who didn’t need to be around the general public ESPECIALLY a little innocent baby. And have custody??? What was and is wrong with our justice system? It’s so frustrating, I can’t even comprehend what everyone in this situation had to be thinking. Blows my mind, truly.
@boomstickcritique902
@boomstickcritique902 Месяц назад
She was definitely banging her psychiatrist no way that dude bailed her out and spent all that on her for no reason. The judge though I think was just stupid and was manipulated by the psycho because the judge was stupid. The fact someone who killed her child's father for no reason could even have custody makes no sense at all.
@Rinnioy
@Rinnioy Месяц назад
Agree 👍
@kellibug1970
@kellibug1970 22 дня назад
This is the SADDEST story that I have EVER heard.
@mystica97
@mystica97 Месяц назад
Dear Zachary was the hardest documentary/ movie that I've ever watched. I cried for hours for this poor family. I will never understand how this judge wasn't held responsible for her role in the baby's death. It was literally a nightmare in real life.
@demolitionlover77
@demolitionlover77 Месяц назад
Same, I was enraged on behalf of the grandparents and sickened by the behavior of the Judge and the Canadian legal system
@calebbearup4282
@calebbearup4282 Месяц назад
A perfect example of why vigilante justice is an important aspect of any healthy society
@erinlchapman61925
@erinlchapman61925 Месяц назад
What happened to the judge? Are these idiots ever punished? Shes gonna burn in hell but earthly justice should be done as well
@Jenngail22
@Jenngail22 18 дней назад
This happened near my town in St. John's Newfoundland Canada. Remember this sadly. I actually just applied too MUN. This was a big case here. See! I keep preaching how frigging bad our Justice system is here in Canada! This ain't the first time a judge here has let a murderer out on bail! Shirley was a narcissist to the extreme.
@mjandt7087
@mjandt7087 Месяц назад
This case makes me want to rage on that crazy B. How absolutely heartbreaking… judge should be held responsible. My heart aches for them. Son and grandson… wtaff
@jessicamasonfobert
@jessicamasonfobert Месяц назад
Love binge watching you when I’m doing housework’s or putting kids to bed! You’re one of the very few RU-vidrs that give so much detail as well as do much respect for the victims and their families.
@spootmelove8016
@spootmelove8016 Месяц назад
Omg!!!! Finally someone is talking about this! I saw the documentary "Dear Zachary " over 10 years ago and it still affects me 😢😢
@rhyker9597
@rhyker9597 26 дней назад
I’m Canadian and this case was so heartbreaking remembering it in real time. Zachary was so loved by his grandparents and Andrew’s friends it was devastating that his life was taken by that deranged psychopath that gave birth to him(won’t call her a mother). The film “Dear Zachary” is so well done I was in literal flood of tears while watching. It starts as a love letter to Zachary to tell him about the father he never knew and ends as a scathing review of everything that went wrong with the legal system that failed Zachary and caused his death. I cannot recommend the film highly enough. RIP Andrew and Zachary 😭
Далее
True Crime Evidence Room | "48 Hours" Full Episodes
2:05:51
Ванька пошел!!!! 🥰
00:18
Просмотров 200 тыс.
Kristin Smart: Arrests Made After Nearly 25 Years!
1:07:20
Kingborough Council  Live Stream
2:59:08
Просмотров 1,4 тыс.
The Craziest Interrogation You'll Ever See
3:27:42
Просмотров 31 млн
Headteacher murdered by her husband
56:49
Просмотров 51 тыс.
When Mean Girls Become Murderers
1:01:33
Просмотров 9 млн