I'm not a fan of Charlye, but I feel like she deserved to stay, because it would have been really hypocritical of Robin to send her home, while she gave Chrystina so many chances when she flopped vocally, while Charlye never was in the bottom two, and she did well her performance. She needs to take this chance and try to get along with the other girls.
+Buddychigo They may have had some kind of chance with her. Without her, they were just another generic, typical group. But Robin Antin was in charge, so they were screwed from Day 1.
Charlye was gorgeous and talented but there was something phony about her. The way she said “wow I’m gonna be in the finale” sounded so caddy and fake. And the fact that she was the only one who couldn’t let go of her pettiness makes it clear why she didn’t make it.
Imo she was the least phony one there, she wasn't going to try to pretend to get along with two girls she didn't like/gel with and you can tell her heart wasn't in it anymore because of that With that being said it's kind of sad that she got that far and didn't at least attempt to
@fio29 She didnt care whether or not she faught with Natalie and chrystina, because she could care less if she was in the group. She knew that if she made the group, she would more than likely have to be stuck with natalie or chrystina.. No one would want to give up that opportunity, but if there were people like that in the group you didnt like, why even bother? Charlie just thought there was no use to be in a group with people that she would just be miserable with.
... or kept Nichole, Tiffany and Charlie cause they got along and are very talented and done another season to find 2 more girls to make it a five piece its really too bad the last five didnt get along cause the combo of the five really at face value looked and sounded great together.. to many egos going on here.. what shame
well i kinda dont blame charlie for not giving in on going along to get along. cause look at what happened to the final group first tiff left the group after only 2 years.. then nat and chris left. this group was doomed from the jump.. if i were robin whenever it reached this point i would have sent nat and chris home keep the other three had them come back for another season after auditioning more girls that will gel with a combination of the 3 left instead of rushing the judgement
I understood robin.. because all of these girls are talented.. for her was really hard to send home one of these girls.. At this point, in this competition, my fav always was Nichole and Natalie.. but girlicious now is such a excellent group with nat, chrys, tiff and nat.. :)
Watching this now, I'm much older and I can now see that Charlye was extremely jealous of Christina and Natalie. They are beautiful and had an edge to them that maybe she felt threatened by. Because let's be honest here, Cristina and Natalie never did anything mean to Charlye. Charlye was always the one upset at them and saying mean things to them. Even when Christina won the dance challenge with the guy, charlye was pissed and kept talking shit, but she needed to realize that all of th judges agreed she was the best! So direct your negative energy towards them, not Christina! 🙄 She was just bad energy and very jealous.
Natalie/ Chrystina started the cattiness off in the house by isolating themselves and mocking the other girls. Even though it worked out in the end, they only have themselves to blame for the tensions in the house
no.. i think it's because they have this special edition for ep7.. so no one eliminated tat week.. but they only got 10 weeks of airing time.. so they got to eliminate 2 gers in one of the week
luisreloade16 Tiffanie is a very very successful portrait artist now, Natalie got married and has kids, Nichole is in another group, Charlye is engaged but idk what she does for work
charlye is so mean. the reason she is so mean to chrystina and natalie is because deep down she didnt want to be in the group, she wanted to go back to college. so she needed to create an excuse not to be in the group. if she really wanted it, im sure she would make an effort to get on with natalie and chrystina. also i think robyn would have made the group with all five of them.
noo.....if that's how it went then there should be 4 girls at the finale, not 5 that episode when 2 girls left, they did that so they will have 10 episodes instead of 11