Тёмный

Rabbi David Wolpe on "The Portal", Episode  

Eric Weinstein
Подписаться 283 тыс.
Просмотров 108 тыс.
50% 1

Leading Conservative Rabbi David Wolpe drops by The Portal to chat with Eric to discuss what everyone might be getting wrong about the divide between religion and rationality by focusing on the existence or non-existence of god(s). Eric starts off with a gambit by asking the Rabbi what the question of god's existence might be crowding out and the conversation goes from there to unusual places (e.g. "Was Seinfeld secretly a course in Talmudic law with a laugh track?"). Subscribe to this channel and click the bell to make sure you are updated when the next episode of "The Portal" drops on RU-vid. And thanks for watching The Portal!

Опубликовано:

 

17 сен 2019

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 566   
@DEPARTMENTOFREDUNDANCYDEPT
@DEPARTMENTOFREDUNDANCYDEPT 3 года назад
I am an atheist and this is the best discussion of faith, values, religion, belief, skepticism, and every related topic that I have ever listened to. Compare the wisdom and insight expressed by these two men to the trite garbage spewed by EVERY TV evangelist and you will understand why I listened to this with intention and attention while every TV evangelist whom I have stumbled upon was revolting and disgusting within minutes and I could not tolerate for more than a few minutes. This is priceless. Thank you for posting this in this time of extreme intolerance and partisan bickering.
@DEPARTMENTOFREDUNDANCYDEPT
@DEPARTMENTOFREDUNDANCYDEPT 9 месяцев назад
@eblman5218 It seems that religion has played a significant part in the evolution of human society, most likely due to the "community" effect which creates solidarity and common goals. This effect has seemed to be positive overall, in spite of the many negative impacts religious extremism has had upon society. While religion brings people together, it also divides them, often violently. It is a terrible contradiction with which I have struggled for a lifetime. I simply found myself unable to believe as I grew into adulthood. The foundational stories seemed so childish and improbable. The worst effect of religion, in my opinion, is that it trains people to believe in nonsense unsupported by evidence, and this credulity spills over into all aspects of life, leaving people easy victims of hucksters and charlatans, both secular and religious.
@TheFlameoftheWest
@TheFlameoftheWest 3 года назад
A wonderful conversation
@jwelda1
@jwelda1 4 года назад
Maybe it’s just because it’s relatively small but so far this is one of the least toxic community’s on RU-vid. Mostly very thoughtful comments. Way to go people, your humanity is showing :)
@BoxRadishScissors
@BoxRadishScissors 4 года назад
Yes, my humanity, that's it! I'm definitely not four badgers stacked on top of one another in a trench coat.
@matthewchunk3689
@matthewchunk3689 4 года назад
judge judaism! (does the fortneit dance)
@dominickschrute3084
@dominickschrute3084 4 года назад
I thought this as well. I checked the comment section expecting massive amounts of anti-semitic tropes.
@khatharrmalkavian3306
@khatharrmalkavian3306 4 года назад
Trolling is a force which selects against worthless conversations. If people take time to feed trolls, it's because the trolls are more interesting than the conversation.
@downeybill
@downeybill 4 года назад
I was so tempted to reply with something toxic! instead I'll say, yeah let's keep it that way.
@618danielj
@618danielj 3 года назад
Absolutely fantastic podcast. One of my favorites this far. I do have to say that I agree with the Rabbi in his answer to Eric’s final question
@joelvilleneuve7037
@joelvilleneuve7037 4 года назад
5 minutes in and im already crazy impressed by the openness of this priest man
@EvaLasta
@EvaLasta 4 года назад
Hes a rabbi!
@Dextermoon1
@Dextermoon1 3 года назад
EvaLasta he definite is nothing close to a rabbi
@Adam-kx2tp
@Adam-kx2tp 3 года назад
Yeah he is a rabbi
@Dextermoon1
@Dextermoon1 3 года назад
Philip J. Fry nope, nothing even close to a rabbi
@Adam-kx2tp
@Adam-kx2tp 3 года назад
@@Dextermoon1 You already said that. Why not give your reason this time.
@kersh1735
@kersh1735 4 года назад
I honestly didn't think I'd be into this one. However, I find myself listening to it intently in the supermarket car park hoping the misses takes a bit longer with the car, as I'm pretty enthralled. Answered a few questions I've always had on religious jews and none religious Jews. Cool beans, cheers eric
@lesliesylvan
@lesliesylvan 4 года назад
Curious if you spoke to your wife about it?
@roughdraught153
@roughdraught153 4 года назад
There's an episode of Seinfeld about that one too!
@ericjesse3753
@ericjesse3753 2 года назад
you prolly dont give a damn but does anybody know of a tool to log back into an Instagram account?? I stupidly forgot the account password. I appreciate any assistance you can offer me
@kadenkaiden4958
@kadenkaiden4958 2 года назад
@Eric Jesse Instablaster ;)
@ericjesse3753
@ericjesse3753 2 года назад
@Kaden Kaiden Thanks so much for your reply. I got to the site thru google and im trying it out now. Takes a while so I will reply here later with my results.
@sterlingveil
@sterlingveil 4 года назад
The Rabbi mentioned an Asimov story. It's called "the last question" and it's will worth reading! Thanks for sharing this beautiful conversation!
@Sedurnas
@Sedurnas 4 года назад
Thanks for pointing me towards this!
@Jangel3995
@Jangel3995 2 года назад
That was my introduction to Asimov, thank you
@tensevo
@tensevo 4 года назад
26:00 "....Seinfeld the show was one of the greatest innovations in modern Judaism." It took a while but I knew there would be a gem in here. ..also there is Curb Your Enthusiasm.
@iskandariacordoba
@iskandariacordoba 4 года назад
I absolutley love The Weinstein Brothers.... Phenomenal conversation Eric! Thank you for this learning experience...
@roncox4048
@roncox4048 4 года назад
Im not especially religious but always really liked listening to Rabbi David
@tannerpinney3608
@tannerpinney3608 4 года назад
Such a beautiful talk, my father and I were talking about how amazing and robust and brilliant Jewish culture is, and how every culture could use such a robust structural integrity to call home. Thank you for providing great insight into just how nuanced and variable your culture is. Ive never felt as comfortable listening to a religious man speak as this dude right here! Thanks man, and keep em coming, we love you brotha!
@MitzvosGolem1
@MitzvosGolem1 4 года назад
We have dummies also
@pianomeister40
@pianomeister40 4 года назад
I listened to the whole thing twice. As an outsider, I am fascinated with Jewish culture and wisdom. Do more of this.
@thomasmeloche1159
@thomasmeloche1159 4 года назад
So did I.... and I may listen again on a long drive. Just an enjoyable talk!
@e1ementZero
@e1ementZero 4 года назад
Such a beautiful, enlightening conversation. It was a joy to listen to! Much respect and admiration to both of you. :)
@SamiulAlHossaini
@SamiulAlHossaini 4 года назад
I'm a frequent podcast listener, and this is now my favourite podcast channel! Eric produces so much high quality content! I'm sure this podcast channel will surpass Joe Rogan if the quality is maintained and the show is continued!!!!! 👌💐 Keep it up Eric 👍 we love you
@simonheaney8721
@simonheaney8721 4 года назад
Not likely
@simongraham2516
@simongraham2516 4 года назад
What a nice treat for the evening!
@itchykami
@itchykami 4 года назад
He has episode 6 on spotify
@valoriel4464
@valoriel4464 4 года назад
Wonderful! Have be excited to see another Portal episode. Thank you so much.
@lesliesylvan
@lesliesylvan 4 года назад
Valorie: check Eric's past videos.
@richardwilliamjohnson8566
@richardwilliamjohnson8566 4 года назад
As a non Jew this was an excellent and very informative podcast. Please keep doing these Eric!!
@marijaivic8320
@marijaivic8320 2 года назад
Fantastic interview, Thank you.
@Saral_Lekhi
@Saral_Lekhi 4 года назад
The power of a Proper conversation 🙏
@satchyan
@satchyan 4 года назад
Thank you for this interview, Eric. It answered a lot of my questions about Judaism. I now have a better understanding and have you and Rabbi Wolpe to thank.
@matt_grossman
@matt_grossman 4 года назад
I didn't realize how much I'd been craving intellectual conversation, I've watched all of the episodes multiple times!
@PoliteAF
@PoliteAF 4 года назад
I didn't think that would be anywhere near as fascinating a conversation about religious and secular Jewish culture as it turned out. I don't care how long it takes the two of you to finish an episode of Seinfeld pausing every 30 seconds to make commentary. I will watch EVERY. SINGLE. MINUTE.
@anas.rashid
@anas.rashid 4 года назад
Love the podcast, just because of the shout-out to my cities. Listened to it while I was in Belgrade and missing my home Lahore!
@ekoe5484
@ekoe5484 4 года назад
thank you SO much for this. I am excited to hear more of your conversations.
@pawelgos75
@pawelgos75 4 года назад
It is so bizarre to listen to Jewish conversation in English and realise that some of what I considered polish words that my mum taught me are spoken here and might have yiddish root. Thank you Eric and thank you Rabbi for giving me a better window into our souls.
@guitarnutbolinuli5788
@guitarnutbolinuli5788 4 года назад
Great episode, maybe the most sensible, intelligent, thoughtful discussion about religion I've ever heard. Thanks Eric.
@royericksson9166
@royericksson9166 4 года назад
One of the best podcasts I have listened to
@fr.davidlewis7768
@fr.davidlewis7768 4 года назад
Yes, please. More of this. Absolutely have the good Rabbi back to talk about Seinfeld. I especially liked his stories about his congregation.
@xkc9689
@xkc9689 4 года назад
This was amazing, thank you
@618danielj
@618danielj 3 года назад
This was a fantastic conversation.. so much in here that applies to all of us
@InsolentMusicalPeasant
@InsolentMusicalPeasant 4 года назад
Thanks for much for these conversations. Really enjoy listening in on them.
@dougster571
@dougster571 4 года назад
Say it with me friends: What do we want? A consistent upload schedule!
@ryanballantyne1811
@ryanballantyne1811 4 года назад
Would be nice, but I wouldn't hold your breath.
@kreek22
@kreek22 4 года назад
A quality upload schedule is more important to me.
@JD..........
@JD.......... 4 года назад
Definitely the best portal to date! Both of you had excellent takes and responded to each other beautifully as well.
@andrewpotapenkoff7723
@andrewpotapenkoff7723 4 года назад
By some reason i am very happy that i found this channel. Eric, i'm grateful for your work, thank you.
@thomaskafafian2871
@thomaskafafian2871 4 года назад
I lived with my friend and his family, who was very Greek, for a few years. While I was living with them, I was taught I should sing and play my guitar at all family functions. They said it was because I wasn't any good at cooking. ;) Or in otherwords, everyone should bring what they are good at to the family table. Don't be afraid to share your skills with others everywhere you go. If we were all good at the same things we would have no need for community. All squirrels are good at finding nuts. People are not squirrels. Tradition is what we bring to the table. We don't want a homogenized society, no matter what people have been saying as of late. Keep spreading the truth.
@NandaKumar-lt3pn
@NandaKumar-lt3pn 4 года назад
So happy when I feel I learned something new. Portal, truly apt name!!
@JohnThinks
@JohnThinks 4 года назад
Wow, that ending. Amazing episode.
@anderswb
@anderswb 3 года назад
This discussion was utterly fascinating, thank you!
@batfink274
@batfink274 4 года назад
Well done gentleman, that was my favourite podcast ever, and i've seen/listened to hundreds over the last 15 years, thank you Eric for inviting Rabbi Wolpe on, you both really impressed me.
@mathewscannell2759
@mathewscannell2759 4 года назад
That was incredible!
@ShamanBuddhaDread
@ShamanBuddhaDread 4 года назад
Splendid conversation: thank you both.
@shader5410
@shader5410 3 года назад
David Wolpe is one the only theists i like to listen even tho I disagree with him.
@shane_was_taken
@shane_was_taken 4 года назад
This was an excellent conversation, and I learned much about Judaism in terms of the intersection between family, culture, spirituality that I had never realized before. The rabbi is a very pleasant speaker to listen to as well. Eric, a conversation that would be fascinating to hear would be one between you and Christopher Langan, with his Cognitive Theoretic Model of the Universe and how it may tie into the nature of reality in a more mathematical/physical way.
@amirresali4109
@amirresali4109 2 года назад
As an American 🇺🇸 /Persian 🇮🇷, i see 100% truth in conversation, accurate info great podcast 🔥
@stephenjones796
@stephenjones796 4 года назад
Absolutely great dialogue Eric and Rabbi! I so look forward to every dialogue you allow me to follow.
@ToadalSimplicity
@ToadalSimplicity 4 года назад
Amazing episode, thank you both for having a discussion about these topics. I don't think I would have ever stumbled across Rabbi Wolpe otherwise, but I love that I did. More please!
@lesliesylvan
@lesliesylvan 4 года назад
Nor stumbled upon Eric, if not for his brother's experience at the Evergreen State debacle.
@thinkingpistol2000
@thinkingpistol2000 4 года назад
I love this podcast. Such valuable lines of thought, opposition, and collaboration simultaneously. Generosity without the free lunch.
@troythoden3438
@troythoden3438 4 года назад
Great podcast gentlemen. Very enjoyable dialogue between two thoughtful individuals.
@mdaniel202
@mdaniel202 4 года назад
Thank you both for a wonderful discussion I feel like getting so much ❤️
@andrewbautista7941
@andrewbautista7941 4 года назад
yey new episode! keep more coming!!
@wazzpqazzza
@wazzpqazzza 4 года назад
Eric, brah, love your stuff. You're perhaps my favourite living thinker and listening to you just chat with other interesting people is as good as rare candy goddamn. Super stoked you made the decision to host your own podcast, enjoying it a metric shitload so please don't stop, important conversation are yet to be had.
@GnarlyBolt
@GnarlyBolt 4 года назад
this is a fantastic conversation I'm loving it so much
@scottnorris9902
@scottnorris9902 4 года назад
Great discussion. Well done Eric thank you.
@dadman9799
@dadman9799 4 года назад
Only 30 minutes into this one and I would recommend it to anyone. I LOVE these types of conversations!!!
@guranajarhead
@guranajarhead 4 года назад
very hard day and its an absolute delight to come home to an episode of The Portal, thanks Eric!
@whatitdu6368
@whatitdu6368 4 года назад
My favorite so far, by a country mile.
@stop7556
@stop7556 4 года назад
As an atheist this is what I do respect and desire from religion. The ability of religion to empower mindfulness and gratefulness.
@Macheako
@Macheako 4 года назад
I dont understand, do you see Religion AS God, or like, Im trying to wrap my head around Athiests definition of Religion, cause its a pretty loosely used word lol When you talk about "When religion does....", just exactly WHAT is doing the "does" in that statement? Because Religion can mean a LOT of different things, cuz ya know....there's a lot of different "Religions". And just for reference Religion to me is merely the resultant cultural, and personal expression that adopting a faith brings. But I assure you, most religious talks Ive had with Christians, we dont EVER say what "Religion" does, we talk about what God, or Christ, or Humankind, or even Angels and Demons DO. Like, im saying theres an actual ACTOR in many of my "religious" thoughts. So i just cant wrap my head around most Atheists usage of the word Religion.
@stop7556
@stop7556 4 года назад
@@Macheako, I will speak for myself as I know some will call those with belief as religious but as I would define non militant atheist like myself. I define religion is a belief structure with an institution. For example a small town with a church who reads the bible and identifies as a sect of Christian but does not report to a higher bureaucratic structure. Then I would not instantly label them as religious. I would just identify them as a group with like minded belief. I guess similar to native american shamanism structure often not. Although yes that can go down the slide of cultism but my point is more so I enjoy when someone who has influence in a large religious structure is bringing the topic back from money power and fear. Feel free to criticize or clarify. I am not 100% certain if I have properly described my stance or view.
@shanemumma9123
@shanemumma9123 4 года назад
Wonderful episode! Thank you for allowing us to be a fly on the wall.
@97DarkSkull
@97DarkSkull 4 года назад
Damn Eric, You're killing it
@enzowilson345
@enzowilson345 4 года назад
Really enjoyed that, please keep going.
@wilfredz
@wilfredz 2 года назад
I've sat through an hour and a half of this podcast and I have no idea what these two are selling, however, I'm absolutely certain I'm paying retail for it.
@rometimed1382
@rometimed1382 4 года назад
Really enjoying these conversations and the podcast Eric. I hope to listen to a whole string of them while walking across Spain this spring.
@logandembesky2400
@logandembesky2400 4 года назад
Ever since you announced the show on Joe Rogan's podcast I have been super pumped for every episode of the portal. This one is of no exception. Thanks Eric and thank you Rabbi David Wolpe. Great Job looking forward to the next one.
@musharrafdog
@musharrafdog 4 года назад
Had only seen Wolpe in the context of Hitchens so was not expecting to enjoy this as much as I did. Thank you, Eric and David.
@ASTRALSECRET
@ASTRALSECRET 4 года назад
Thank you... Many things to ponder on
@robertdressler2850
@robertdressler2850 3 года назад
Brilliant. Forcing me to think and deal with questions and statements that I have successfully avoided, 'thank you
@oO-_-_-_-Oo
@oO-_-_-_-Oo 2 года назад
Lex Fridman brought me here. Glad he did too this was fantastic.
@hobobluesclown7337
@hobobluesclown7337 4 года назад
It took me awhile to get to this episode... what worthwhile could a rabbi have to say to a physicist? Always the fool-this was an incredible conversation and emphasizes everything I respect about religious thinking despite everything I do not. Plus I got to hear, “the struggle to give meaning to meaning,” which I have tucked snugly into my breast pocket.
@leedufour
@leedufour 4 года назад
Thank you both.
@Gunbei2
@Gunbei2 4 года назад
This was a fascinating and deep conversation. I've always enjoyed Rabbi Wolpe in the History Channel episodes on the Bible. This was a lot of fun. I'll have to watch this over several times.
@jbsweeney1077
@jbsweeney1077 4 года назад
51:10 "God answers sharp and sudden on some prayers, And thrusts the thing we have prayed for in our face, A gauntlet with a gift in it" - Elizabeth Barrett Browning
@andrewjackson7014
@andrewjackson7014 4 года назад
Thank you!! I was wondering who rabbi Wolpe was quoting and you provided the answer. I salute you!!
@thegimel
@thegimel 4 года назад
Wonderful conversation. Keep the portal open Eric, the rest are on the way!
@andrewjackson7014
@andrewjackson7014 4 года назад
Amazing podcast!! If this is an indication of the quality of debate on the Portal, bring it on!! Not a dull second in the whole show. Thank you to all concerned.
@zalen_Offical
@zalen_Offical 4 года назад
Really enjoy this podcast good work 👍
@michaelscott70
@michaelscott70 3 года назад
This was a great, intellectually stimulating conversation. I’d love to see David and other religious leaders on the podcast more often.
@JimyLynn
@JimyLynn 4 года назад
My new favorite podcast.
@annecampbell8931
@annecampbell8931 4 года назад
Superb podcast. Thank you both.
@charleswilson8897
@charleswilson8897 3 года назад
1:12:40 - And this is why I am following The Portal.
@winfriedbauer2280
@winfriedbauer2280 4 года назад
Always enjoyed the debates between the Rabbi and Christopher Hitchens... Could always see the respect between the two men!
@winfriedbauer2280
@winfriedbauer2280 4 года назад
Amazing conversation! Thanks!
@francykitty
@francykitty 4 года назад
Thanks for this 🙏
@TonGolem
@TonGolem 4 года назад
Just a beautiful conversation between two intelligent and wise men. And I say this as an atheist.
@angelatakano6072
@angelatakano6072 2 года назад
Thank you Rabbi for your faith and message to believers like me, and so sad that an extremely smart scientist cannot see how mysterious our own existence is
@danellwein8679
@danellwein8679 4 года назад
thanks for this … really enjoy your podcasts … and the guests that you have on … you and Lex are my favorite people to listen to …
@leedufour
@leedufour 4 года назад
Thanks Rabbi and Eric.
@piffpete420
@piffpete420 4 года назад
Eric “the courage to stand alone” Weinstein
@cryptocred5754
@cryptocred5754 2 года назад
Eric “the guy who lets negative comments affect him” Weinstein Wish he’d let go of that so that we can have more of his thoughts through word form
@bluebottle4
@bluebottle4 4 года назад
Did not expect a mention of cities I lived in as a kid, Lahore and Karachi. Listening to this from Sydney and wanna thank Eric for getting into some of the tensions that I have grappled with myself at a very personal level. I wish he could keep Rabi a bit longer and delve a bit deeper, but Kudos to Rabi for his stamina. Such an honest and humble religious figure, deriving his opinions and understandings from an understanding of the text of his tradition. He was respectful of science and other philosophies and recognised his limitations as a human as he mentioned towards the end. I wonder how fascinating would it be, if Eric could find a similar figure from Islamic world who is able to talk openly and freely without a fear of the loudest mob.
@danieltaylor885
@danieltaylor885 4 года назад
always great conversations, well structured and executed, never a dull moment.
@__-on8rk
@__-on8rk 4 года назад
I'm an orthodox Jew, and I always wanted to hear a more detailed approach to conservative and reform, thank you! Very informative.
@sd-uf1ls
@sd-uf1ls 4 года назад
I've never commented before on a video but I felt like I had to. Huge fan of Eric's, but I had to clarify the point about Islam and the interpretation of the Quran. While Eric was correct on the 4 schools, what he failed to realize was that these schools exist precisely because there are differing interpretations of the Quran. As David clarified, the Torah is not inherently self explanatory as is the case with the Quran. Great convo though!
@alexcatchpole
@alexcatchpole 4 года назад
The portal is out and out the best pod cast ! Thabks Eric
@poltergeistfm
@poltergeistfm 4 года назад
i see a new portal episode and i give a thumbs up in advance.
@oscarbrienzo3244
@oscarbrienzo3244 4 года назад
This has been on the Castbox app for 2 and a half weeks as well as his next episode with Jocko Willink. For all of you fans out there.. :)
@gregorywitcher5618
@gregorywitcher5618 4 года назад
Bless you.
@harmonicresonanceproject
@harmonicresonanceproject 4 года назад
Thanks for the heads up, I wasn't aware of Castbox. Gonna try it out.
@gg-pv3ie
@gg-pv3ie 4 года назад
Its also on spotify
@cryptouncle6630
@cryptouncle6630 4 года назад
I do not know what Castbox is. But I know this; no one can cast Jocko into a box unless he wants to. Not even Chuck Norris!
@TigburtJones
@TigburtJones 4 года назад
Thank you Eric! I shared this on my Facebook to my tribe (not Tigburt Jones) They’re a group of entrepreneurs, i hope they jump on board!
@werdmaster
@werdmaster 4 года назад
I cant stop falling in love with this podcast
@mrmarvellous5378
@mrmarvellous5378 4 года назад
As a Roman Catholic, turned Athiest, turned Pantheist I found this conversation informative and respectful as against some of the confrontational believers vs atheist debates, well done Rabbi Wolpe and Mr Weinstein.
@CunningOfReason
@CunningOfReason 4 года назад
Mr Marvellous Stopp watching porn.
@sohamchakraborty4996
@sohamchakraborty4996 4 года назад
Lots of love from Calcutta. It was wonderful hearing that Eric's wife has roots back to the Calcutta Jews!
@johnnywatkins
@johnnywatkins 4 года назад
Fantastic conversation i have a lot to think about
@leeleeleelee420
@leeleeleelee420 4 года назад
utterly amazing talk
@JohnMcGrathManInShed
@JohnMcGrathManInShed 4 года назад
Another great conversation!
@lukecunningham8793
@lukecunningham8793 4 года назад
Anyone know where I can find the intro/outro music? It's so beautiful. Inspiring. Meditative.
Далее
Rabbi David Wolpe: March 23, 2023
20:42
Просмотров 3,4 тыс.
ATEEZ(에이티즈) - 'WORK' Official MV
03:15
Просмотров 14 млн
New Gadgets! Bycycle 4.0 🚲 #shorts
00:14
Просмотров 4,9 млн
У каждого есть такой друг😂
00:31
"God" | Sermon by Rabbi David Wolpe
13:56
Просмотров 3,4 тыс.
Steven Pinker and David Wolpe
1:30:31
Просмотров 10 тыс.
"Aging: Autumn Leaves" | Rabbi David Wolpe
17:48
Просмотров 4,1 тыс.
Why Arizona Is Becoming A Hotbed For Tech
20:35
Просмотров 1,4 млн
ATEEZ(에이티즈) - 'WORK' Official MV
03:15
Просмотров 14 млн