to everyone saying it's still in minor: just because there are more minor chords in this rendition, it does not make the entire song minor. the original had tons of major chords but was still minor. this is a very good edit!
the original's tonic was C. It uses the notes C D E F F# G A B, making it major, or lydian at a push. this rendition takes the original song and puts it into C sharp minor im pretty sure
It’s got a kinda uncanny vibe to it to where the slightly happy tone is out of place in the context of everything else in the song. Like something’s off but you don’t know what
what kind of quantum disaster have you created by calling a song thats originally in a major key a minor key song and then turning it into a minor key song but calling it a major key
Video that really shows the wide range of emotions that different chords can have based on the context, I expected this song to be happier in a major key cuz usually major keys are happier but this feels worse, the same sadness but with no catarsis and an ugly menacing vibe
All I Need is about someone you love but the other one doesn't feel the same This major key makes it sound like he made something evil to make the other one love him
Well the original is already in C major. The bass hook is just a basic C9 chord. The song opens with C major and resolves on C major. For Radiohead it's harmonically very, very straightforward and direct
I think it's actually C Lydian because it uses a sharp 4th (F#). Online sources are saying E minor which uses the same notes as C Lydian, but as you said, it starts and ends on a C chord so it's probably a C key. But not major!
I think the original is actually more in a G major world, because de C doesn't feel resolved at all to me, just sounds like hanging on the IV, feeling uneasy and unresolved. I love that effect. Also loved this version very much!
holy fuck why is this kinda better than the original i wish radiohead did it in major they'd do even more justice to it and make it sound perfect damnnn
Strange and fascinating things about music: In a major key it sounds darker, I would even say sinister. Less sweet, more bitter. Less exciting and poignant perhaps. And the strangest thing: to me it sounds more Radiohead than the original!
Like the real version is him feeling the exciting exuberance and hope that comes with feeling that you've finally found the person who is the answer to your life. This version is him drunk and miserable 5 years later, laying on his kitchen floor after yet another fight with the same woman. He still feels that way about her. She no longer feels that way about him and it's near the end of their relationship. But he's still holding on...clinging to how he felt.
Its a C Maj chord but the key is C Lydian or GMaj if you want. The F# its part of Thom's melody. Really one could make a Major and a minor version of this tune and it World sound different to the original
@@franciscoojeda11 well, yeah technically. i just wanted to get across the point that the tonic is C, and it is largely based around just chords from C major, making it pretty much major already
@jemjem I'm incredibly bothered that so many people in the comments do not understand this. I think if George Orwell were alive today to watch this video and read the comments he would immediately demand that his publisher amend Nineteen Eighty-Four so that Winston Smith gets tortured with rats in Room 101 to get him to admit that All I Need is in a minor key
That’s because the original is in e minor, but the bass can easily fit in C Major since it resolves on C making it sound sort of Majorish but the song still has an f# making it in e minor. But this edit switches it to a Major key meaning e Major. Many of the notes in C Major are sharpened in E Major, including the C. Now the bass line resolves on c# which is the minor key with the same notes as e Major making the bass sound more like minor and the melody more like Major. While the original song has a bass that sounds more in Major and the melody more in minor.
This edit is fantastic in any case, but I’ve seen at least ten different claims in the comments as to what chord the original is in (divided equally between minors and majors)… does anyone actually really know?
What software was used to do this? I like the idea of writing something in a minor key, running it through a process, and seeing what comes out, because it sounds interestingly wonky in certain places
