Is this meant to me? I do mean the end v2 is certified banger I just the first few times hated the song mostly with chromatic at fault but now I love it- as I said at my own video
People say Costume’s vocals are bad. I disagree I like his vocals. The End is so underrated, and I hope The End V2 is in the mod for the hotfix update.
Yes! Thallassophobia is one of the best songs imo. The instrumental combines with the vocals so well, and the organ part just sends shivers down my spine
Overall SUPER valid list. My only thing is that I would put last course a lot higher imo, maybe in the top 10, but overall solid list 16:08 also holy crap I didnt notice him back there lol
I just realised that in All-Stars Act 4 Ultra M mimicking not only voices, but also their song motives. For example, I recognized Omega's part (Act 2), Costume's part (The End), reference to Paranoia and Dark Forest. This is f**king genius.
Finally someone who, rightfully, thinks the Paranoia V3 reference is the best part of Paranoia. Like, I get the gf section is cool and all but the ending is so god damn hype.
If you didn't know, the entire 'area' that has songs involving Stanley and the dead Luigi are indeed based off of an analogue horror Mario 64 series called SM64: Classified Hope this helps =)
As someone whos fave song is thalassophobia, im so happy at the compliments and praise you gave to it, wish it were higher but glad to see someone appreciate a heavily underloved song
I allways in my headcanon is Alone is after All stars although I know the truth It just feels nicer Where gf and bf are still in the realm although they are dead still have fun. And try to comfort lugi I imagine lugi being more sad due to Ultra M's victory over the two as he may or could have been free
Really can't understand why you put demise and unbeatable so low just for being too fast while golden land,which is a fast song in its own right gets a placement higher than them
It's not being fast, it's being too fast, golden land keeps a good balance, listen to the end part of demise or the part with the level 1-2 it falls off pretty hard, and unbeatable is still top 10, that's not really low, I like the first section and don't like the other two, and act 4 is way too fast
@@DarkEntityTheoryas well as the song fitting the character's voice as well, unbeatable and demise have characters who would fit slower songs better. Mx has a really deep, slow sounding voice, sane with Mr. Sys with his deep growling voice
Just finished the video, here’s what I have to say The ranking itself was great, this is pretty much how I’d rank them except maybe racetraitors and powerdown (which I would put both higher) and swap paranoia and all stars My only issue is that the text went wayyy to fast almost making it impossible to read it without pausing. Overall a great video with great takes.
This is the... most different tier list i've seen, i completely disagree with ¾ of the lower-mid list but the top 10 is almost what i would have done, maybe just switch last course with golden land, paranoia with unbeatable and somari with overdue. Great video
6:52, I don't know if anyone said this yet, but so what Abandoned is actually a reference to is a small clip in one of the Mario 64 Classified videos, I don't remember which, where there's a shot of Luigi just crucified onto the shrine in Wet Dry World. But naw great tier list, agree with most of the takes Ngl.
Okay so im about 4 and a half minutes into the video, and doing apparition and nourishing blood was actually crazy, but the thassalophobia thing is hella underatted. Like the instrumental is amazing. I agree about 50% with you on this
my ranking of top 5 mario madness favourite songs 1.All stars(obviously), sounds like something churgney would make. Rating:100/10 2.Unbeatable, kinda mad you put it so low in your list but I can understand your opinion.Rating:99/10 3.Oh god no, this song is amazing, its quite underrated, it really shows how much nervous mario is, and with the sad part is my favourite part. Rating:70/10 4.Paronoia, a song about at series with only 2 parts shouldnt go this hard. Rating:50/10 5.Promotion, as a OK fan of the super mario analouge horror, I dont know why but this made like the anaoluge horror 10x more, its just that good, also this beat The End by 1%. Rating10/10 Banger video btw!
Honestly I agree with almost this entire video besides that i think So Cool is a bit better than you made it to be. Otherwise 10/10 vid my dude Also to everyone who thinks All-stars act 3 is triple trouble ITS THE MARIO 64 DS LINEUP HGSHSGSHG
The entirety of Classified Castle is based off of Greenio’s SM64 Classified series, which is a Mario 64 Analog Horror series, it’s great and I do suggest you give it a watch. For me there is not a song that I hate, I enjoy every song, obviously some over others, but all songs are great.
Im not sure if you already know but classified luigi is based on a frame of the classified series, in one of the videos, in a frame, you can actually see classified Luigi.
Having that whole entire heartfelt explanation about how good Overdue is and then the ranking notes just being "YO SOY LUIGI, MAMMA MIA LUIGI.EXE SOY AMIGO DEL MARIO MADNESS" is so good
This list is pretty good but the only thing I will complain about is that last course and I hate you are in top 20s. Both of these are in my top 5 I am upset about this but this is a underrated list
8:24 one thing i find crazy about oh god no, is that in the flp is that each instrument has their own pattern, and not just like one bassline either. No, every bassline in the entire song is in one pattern. This goes for strings, violins, and guitars too (and obviously vocals). For some reason this doesnt apply to the drums and trumpets. found it crazy that kennyL probably sat there for hours writing over 2 minutes worth of basslines in 1 pattern.
Nearing the ending of Unbeatable, i feel like it's more than fair that the song goes that fast, likewise with Demise, it's very obviously a chase sequence and its entire rhythm makes you almost panic yourself, with so many notes to keep up with its both adrenaline filled yet an amazing beat to get into, and as for the speed of unbeatable at the end, well, they're nintendo, why would they make it any easier to try and beat them?
My personal rankings for the songs are 28: So Cool 27: Demise 26: Thalassophobia 25: Race Traitors 24: Oh God No 23: No Hope 22: Apparition 21: Promotion 20: I Hate You 19: Dark Forest 18: Last Course 17: Nourishing Blood 16: The End 15: Golden Land 14: Day Out 13: Abandoned 12: Paranoia 11: Unbeatable 10: It's A Me 09: Bad Day 08: Power Down 07: Overdue 06: Dictator 05: No Party 04: All Stars 03: Mario sing and rythem 9 02: Alone 01: StarMan Slaughter
i dont know if its really possible to rank these in a way that everyone will be happy. which kinda adds to how good mario madness v2 was. Each song can be argued to be better than the other by..ANYONE. none really felt similar to the previous one (with the exceptions to the remastered songs. but they were remastered). each one had its own swing and its own tone. However i can agree with the first 5.
I didn't understand what he meant about Ultra M mimicking the other characters in All-Stars. Is it in his voice? Cause it doesn't seem to be in the chart?
I like this list, but i have one issue... In alone mario also says mario, not luigi as red states in his description that mario is apart of Luigi's depressive imagination
8:45 Also I know someone has said this in a video before, but... Mario sprites His idle It seems like he ''isn't putting much effort into killing Luigi'' or rather... ''he's not trying to kill Luigi outright, he's just defending himself, not being too strong, not too weak'' ''he's worried, he doesn't want to kill his brother, but he... has to'' ''he's worried, just worried'' And Luigi's sprites All It's as if he were trying to kill Mario, putting effort into the fight Because, he went through all the suffering of ''being a Player 2'' So seeing ''the Player 1'' (Mario) He will try HARD to kill him. I like that.
Yknow I feel like for the mimics they’d reference their song in some way here an example for the ending mimics: peach.exe and yoshi.exe: 🎶this “starman slaughter”🎶 Mr L:🎶has long since been “overdue”🎶 Dj hallyboo:🎶this is “no party”🎶 Sh Mario:🎶I am the “dictator”🎶 Devil Mario: 🎶there’s “no hope” for you anymore🎶 Beta Luigi:🎶your “alone” without your girlfriend so🎶 Mr sys:🎶can’t you see we’re unbeatable,”undefeatable”🎶 Stanley:🎶so its time to end your silly “promotion”🎶 Wario head:🎶this time there’s no “apparition”🎶 Turmoil:🎶your the “last course”🎶
You did Hallyboo absolutely despicable, that ranking plus YOU NOT EVEN BOTHERING TO LEARN HIS NAME WHEN ITS SAID MULTIPLE TIMES IN THE SONG BOTH IN THE FIRST PART THAT YOU HAVE TO LOOK AT BEFORE PLAYING AND THE DESCRIPTION IS INSANE
6:49 also I discovered that it is based on a clip from one of the videos/tapes from the series ''SM64 Classified'' in one of the videos/tapes (I forgot which one it was), for a few seconds you can see this Luigi in the statue, there in Wet-Dry World Maybe it has this mysterious vibe because ''we don't know much about him'' besides the fact that... well... it was either Luigi who drowned in those ''flooded basement-thing of the castle'' (seen in another video that I also forgot), or some other (and, 7:18 yes, Stanley-boi is based also on SM64 Classified, a kinda cool SM64 analog-horror or something like that series, basically, ALL of this ''Classified Castle'' is based on that series, The End is based on a final screen seen in one of the episodes, and also in a very unknown Spanish creepypasta called Mario Murder or Mario Asesino, I forgot the name Abandoned was based on that few-second clip I mentioned, and Promotion on one of the main guys in the thing, the aforementioned, Stanley)
6:45 Not to be like “um actually 🤓” but Abandoned Luigi is from the same source as Promo Mario! Super Mario 64: Classified, which is very cool and can be found here on RU-vid! Great list by the way. First person I’ve ever seen say that So Cool and Race Traitors aren’t the worst songs ever made. Also YOU ACTUALLY RESPECT THE END? HECK YEAH. Also glad to see I’m not the only one who likes the first part of Unbeatable best!
my ranking 1-unbeatable 2-paranoia 3-all stars 4-dark florest 5-demise 6-starman slaughter 7-overdue 8-hate you 9-dictator 10-nourishing bl00d 11-aparation 12-It is me 13-mario sing and game rhytma 9 14-race traidor 15-no Party 16-oh god no 17-day out 18-golden land 19-promotio 20-Abandoned 21-powerdown 22-last coursed 23-alone 24-no hope 25-the end 26-bad day 27-thalassophobia 28-so cool If you get here then you could like this comment if you want
FINALLY SOMEONE WHO RECOGNIZE GOLDEN LAND V2 AND HOW AMAZING IT IS Bro this song is so amazing i swear, crazy how ppl think v1 is better. Not saying v1 is bad tho, but its not that unique as v2.
I personally think they both have their tradeoffs. V2 is obviously just plain amazing but V1's nostalgia factor really makes it a daring opponent. I love them both.
Ill explain abandoned and promotion better in case Abandoned is luigi in the series after drowning, haunting mario. Meanwhile in promotion, its not exactly a faker segment, Stanley's a separate entity from mario
Not a bad list, though there are multiple songs I'd argue should be higher/lower. Personally my top 3 (in no particular order) are Starman Slaugher, Demise & Unbeatable.
Great tier list, good points for different songs and not biased like other tier list. Good job 👍 ( one problem I got is overdue. Can’t enjoy the song after hearing the retake of this and fix’s the main problem I had with it )
The retake does have a overall stronger vibe to it, however the original overall has better parts when it is good, it's just the whole middle section that isn't done well,
Out of the few rankings I've seen, this is one of the most different ones from my own. I have So cool in an ironic 2nd place, with my first and third place spots being Unbeatable and Demise respectively. I also have Promotion at the bottom. I'd highly recommend you check out THE END retake by FriedFrick. It released yesterday and improves upon THE END by a lot.
I'd say it's a crime how low "No party" and "Nourishing Blood" are, but I realized that those songs are specifically right up my alley, so fair enough.
