Ranking Every Metallica Song [200 Subscribers Special!] 

Glad to inspire ya… great vid

i am very glad to see that the younger generation finally gives respect to load and reload after so many years. really incredibly underrated albums.

The balls on this kid to put the memory remains so high up, you my man you have serious courage

I would put The Thing That Should Not be waayyyy higher, I love it’s evil atmosphere. I love how you explain why you put each song in their respective rankings.

Broken, Beat And Scarred deserves way more love. That verse gets me pumped tf up. I admit the bridge section sucks, but those verses and choruses are awesome

Seeing someone pick the most underrated song as the number one makes me smile. Disposable Hereos is so good and my absolute favorite.

Hey guys, Screaming Suicide was just released so I’d like to update this list. Screaming Suicide would be around 50 - 60th place. Another update: If Darkness Had A Son was just released, and it’s going in 97th place. 6.5/10 honestly, sure it’s heavy, but way to repetitive. Also, I’m bumping up Shortest Straw to 19th place, really getting into that song, TTTSNB is now going to the 105th spot, and Lux Æterna is now in the top 60’s.

Yes! Finally someone showing Low Man's lyric some love. Underrated as hell. Its always been one of my all time favorites!

Some of your placements drive me insane while others I totaly agree with. Huge respect in both aspects, this is truely a unique and personal ranking

THIS IS LITERALLY THE FIRST PERSON I SAW RANKING DISPOSABLE HEROES AS NUMBER 1

Time to suffer seeing my favorite songs having a bad rating

Respect the video itself - a super ambitious project to rank EVERY song from one of the greatest bands of all time. For that, you have my respect - especially since you’re clearly younger. Love seeing people still showing this band the love they deserve. With that being said, this list is filled with some CRAZY takes. Disagreed with pretty much most of what is on here, but I guess that’s the beauty of the art. Keep it up big man.

My top 20: 1: Nothing Else Matters 2: Ride the Lightning 3: Orion 4: Blackened 5: For Whom the Bell Tolls 6: Bleeding Me 7: King Nothing 8: Ain't my B!tch 9: ...And Justice for All 10: Outlaw Torn 11: One 12: Creeping Death 13: Fade to Black 14 Welcome Home (Sanitarium) 15: Sad but True 16: Eye of the Beholder 17: Enter Sandman (This was also the first Metallica song I ever heard and the one that got me into Metallica) 18: Master of Puppets 19: The God that Failed 20: Wherever I May Roam

1. Master Of Puppets 2. Fade to Black 3. One 4. Nothing Else Matters 5. The Unforgiven 6. Creeping Death 7. Sad But True 8. Bleeding Me & The Outlaw Torn ( Love them equally, Bleeding Me slightly better) 9. The Day That Never Comes 10. The Unnamed Feeling ( I relate to this song a lot and I have a really deep connection with this song.) Honorable mentions Enter Sandman Seek and Destroy Wherever I May Roam Blackened Fixxxer

Prince Charming over Master of Puppets, Sad But True and The Unforgiven is wildddd

My top 5 1. Leper Messiah 2. Dyers Eve 3. For Whom The Bell Tolls 4. Harvester of Sorrow 5. Disposable Heroes

I loved this video, I've never seen a ranking like this. I enjoyed reading all your statements about each song, especially your brutal honesty to songs that people love. I was happy to see someone put songs like Metal Militia so high. I love how each song lasted longer towards the end, making the 1# pick more revealing to the viewer. Great video, keep up the great work!

The thing that should not be at 100 is criminal. That song is so underrated

seeing bleeding me 8th warms my fuckin heart. my favorite metallica song ever

YES, finally someone who shares my opinion that Disposable Heroes is the best Metallica song, great vid!

HEY! DONT U DARE DISRESPECT THE THING THAT SHOULD NOT BE, THAT SONG IS AN ABSOLUTE BANGER

Ronnie: The only song to have someone's name on it The House that Jack Built: And I took that personally

I still don't understand why nobody talks about the vocals in Hit The Lights

1. Fade to black 2. Disposable heroes 3. Blackened 4. Wherever I may roam 5. Damage inc 6. For whom the bell tolls 7. And justice for all 8. Orion 9. Nothing else maters 10. Unforgiven II 11. Enter sandman 12. Master of puppets 13. Battery 14. The day that never comes 15. To live is to die 16. Sanitarium 17. Creeping death 18. One 19. King nothing 20. Mama said 21. Metal militia 22. Trapped under ice 23. Shortest straw 24. Dyers eve 25. Four horseman 26. The unforgiven 27. Harvester of sorrow 28. Sad but true 29. Fuel 30. Fixxxer 31. Holier than thou 32. Unforgiven III 33. Through the never 34. The call of ktulu 35. Ride the lightning 36. Motorbreath 37. Ain’t my b*tch 38. Jump in the fire 39. Whiplash 40. Don’t tread on me

Cure is like the most underrated song

3:24 this should be classified as a crime. The fact that St. Anger songs are ranked higher than a song off of justice is pure evil. I’m also biased as hell because the shortest straw is my favourite song.

Slither is a great song and no one will ever change my mind

I'm glad to see a disposable heroes fan 🤘

The House Jack Built! Now that one is underrated as f. One of my all time favs, like mixing Metallica with some Alice in Chains.

ajfa is one of the most underrated metallica songs

1. One 2. Nothing else matters 3. Blackened 4.Fuel 5.Dyers eve

Bad Seed, Low Man's Lyric, and Carpe Diem Baby are great! Love seeing them in the top 60; the Reload "filler" songs are slept on WAY too hard (Slither at the bottom is crazy, lol). I really like reading the small comments that go along with each song, it makes it a pretty engaging watch. Nice video!

Master of puppets, fade to black, and seek and destroy are my main complaints, W for putting Reload and Load higher though

Having House that Jack Built AND Outlaw Torn in top 20? I love that. Amazing.

This list tells me there are a lot different types of metallica fans out there!

You heard the S&M all within my hands? It does justice to the song.

fianlly some suicide and redemption love! underrated masterpiece! have you heard the extended solos version? it kicks ass

1 wherever I may roam 2 one 3 battery 4 the sortest straw 5 ride the lighting 6 Sad But True 7 Welcome home Sanitarium 8 ride the lighting 9 Whiplash 10 Seek And Destroy 11 for whom the bell tolls 12 Ant My bitch 13 The house that jack Built 14 Fuel 15 Blackened

Finally glad to see someone put ride the lightning high on a Metallica ranking list this video has great editing and skill I love it

That was just your life is probably one the best openers in Metallica’s discography

Nice bro! My favorite music is Disposable Heroes too 🤝🔥

Your preferences and your experiences and I respect it. Just do yourself a favor and revisit this list in 5, 10 and 20 years.

WHAT. It's a first time when i saw anyone who's rank Disposable heroes on 1st place

Yess Disposable is perfection

I have no idea but cure has always been one of my favorites

Orion is my personal favorite and you plced it at number 5. I like your list.

Damn bro. I'm shocked to see thing that should not be so low XD. But I'm glad that you gave love to a lot of the underrated songs. Cool and respectable list!

My top 10 (10 at top) 10: One 9: Battery 8: Wherever I May Roam 7: Master Of Puppets 6: …And Justice For All 5: Sad But True 4: For Whom The Bell Tolls 3: Blackened 2: Creeping Death 1: The Thing That Should Not Be

My personal favorites are 1. Creeping Death 2. For Whom The Bell Tolls 3. One 4. The Four Horsemen 5. Master of Puppets 6. Blackened 7. Battery 8. Wherever I May Roam 9. Sad But True 10. Fuel

One day in a few years time, I hope you put out a new vid with an updated ranking after having had some life experiences. I can definitely see my younger self not liking some of the songs that are now some of my favorites. Great vid kid! Also sorry for triple commenting, felt like I was watching a live video for a sec 😂

How did you put music under the vid? I am inspired might do my own version if I get some precious time

This is a damn good and inspiring list!

Seeing how a lot of people seem to be missing Creeping Death, it's at 11:42. You're welcome.

You Actually Put Seek And Destroy At 99 ?? That Song Is Legendary.

WHAT DID YOU DO TO MY BOY THE FOUR HORSEMAN! THEY MASSACRED MY BOY!

The positions both The Thing that Should Not Be and Shortest Straw received triggered me ☠️. Its just your opinion of course im not angry lol

Sweet Amber over Creeping Death and Blackened??

4:46 wrong, The House That Jack Built?????????

Great list, even if I would certainly place some songs differently. For example, the songs from the Black Album, Load and Reload and Hardwired... would be placed higher on my list. It's interesting how everyone feels and perceives songs differently.

MURDER ONE IS THE BEST SONG ON HARDWIRED THAT SONG IS AMAZING AND IT PAYS TRIBUTE TO A LEGEND

Probably the one list I've seen that would best resemble mine if I were to ever make one. Great ranking.

What are your thoughts on the 1982 demos?, great vid btw

And justice for all finally gets justice in it's placement

I Respect your selection bro. By the way, what You think the versión of All Within My Hands of S&M2? & The covers of Helping Hands 2? (Thin Lizzy & UFO)

My top 10 would have to be 1. One 2. Sad But True 3. The Unforgiven II 4. The Unforgiven 5. Dyers Eve 6. Blackened 7. King Nothing 8. Seek and Destroy 9. Inamorata 10. Trapped Under Ice

Imo,dont tread on me is the best track in the black album

me personally i'd put all these songs on #1

I’ve got a BIG issue with TTTSNB’s placement. Heaviest song they ever wrote, should be way higher. Otherwise good list

You have some very based takes here my good sir, keep it up 🤘

I really disagree with a lot of this list, but who cares! It's great that you're brave enough to put yourself out there!

The four Horsemen at 72 💀💀, also good video, I'm glad to know that I'm not the only one in these generations that likes metal

102: im gonna make you get up that song more

great video man. might snatch this idea for green day... with proper credit, of course

Loved the video but dude really the thing that should not be is so gooooooooood imo it should be to 15

That was Just Your Life is definitively top 5 material

Seeing St. Anger above Shortest Straw hurts

My top 10: One Creeping Death AJFA Master Of Puppets Blackened Battery All Nightmare Long Fight Fire With Fire The Unforgiven III Hero Of The Day

Your editing is sooo smooth. I create similar content and trying to get better. Great job bro

I can get behind this, cause I kinda just assumed a lot of songs on Load, Reload and St Anger sucked based on how people rank albums. After listening to them all myself, I definitely now know that all albums have absolute bangers. Quick Top 5 off my head: 5. Welcome Home (Sanitarium) - Another beautifully crafted song, love the slow build up, outstanding vocals and that second half slaps 4. Blackened - The riffs in this song are gorgeous, vocals energetic, solo great, everything about it is true blue classic thrash 3. The Call of Ktulu - Love the beautifully rough sound of this song and structurally its sublime, always feels like its building and rising at just the right times 2. Atlas, Rise! - That main riff is my favourite single part of any song ever, just top quality headbang material and I love the rest of the song too 1. For Whom the Bell Tolls - its a mood song for me but when i'm in the mood I'm in the MOOD, such a perfectly crafted song Honourable mentions: Mercyful Fate - My 3rd favourite song played by them but its a cover so wont put in in the list, but everything about it is beautiful especially the Curse of the Pharaohs bit Room of Mirrors - The albums not been out long enough for a decisive choice from me yet, but holy fuck I love this song, the riff get you pumped up, vocals exceptional (especially that last 'set me freeeeeeeeeeee yeah yeah' bit and that harmony bit towards the end is the thing of dreams.

If you think the thing that should not be is bad you just arent mature enough to apreciate it, i agree its not the best song from the 80s but its still better than every song after load imo.

Fade To Black should be top 10, MINIMUM, but overall, a solid list

Seek & Destroy would be at least top #2 on my rank. A good fight with Ride to be the top 1. But it's good to see songs like Outlaw, Fixxxer, Bleeding and Unforgiven ll on top.

Slither gets too much hate, it's groovy as hell

Gotta love the high ranking on sweet amber

I just saw the rest of the list, you are just crazy lmao

7:40 Finally, this song needs more respect!

EXTREMELY HOT TAKE: The chorus for Purify is the best chorus on St. Anger. FIGHT ME. I DARE YOU.

I may not agree with all of your picks but I love how you weren't afraid to show your opinion, I'm a bit of a sucker for their older stuff though 😅, not that I dislike everything after the black lack album, there are some pretty decent songs of both death magnetic and hardwired. Here's my top 5 (These could all change however) 5) Fade to black 4) Orion 3) For whom the bell tolls 2) The call of kuthulu 1) One Edit: Changed a few spots around

My personal top 10: 1: Blackened 2: No leaf clover 3: Mama said 4: Until it sleeps 5: Fade to black 6: Leper messiah 7: Creeping Death 8: That was just your life 9: Puppets 10: 🔔

Bleeding me would probably be top spot for me but glad you put it and halo on fire in top 10 both awesome. Just my opinion but I could never really get into fixxxer, carpe diem and where the wild things are are my leat favourite from reload.

Good vid man! You deserve more views

dont mess with us invisible kid fans there are four of us

end of the line is very good song bro

Very interesting list to say the least

Good placing for metal millitia

Good work on this list, but I gotta say, please listen to The Four Horsemen with a clean slate, it could be way higher!

Seek and destroy that low?! Damn im surprised, but i understand why you think its overrated and i kinda agree, but still, why'd you disrespect seek and destroy like that XD

My Apocalypse has gotta be my favorite. Don’t really have a ranking for the rest of the songs, but Death Magnetic/Beyond Magnetic are my favorites from Metallica.

if blackened was a bit faster it would be perfection to me but i just put the speed to 1.7 i think and it’s perfection

Seek and destroy is number 3 on my list, trying really hard to respect your opinion