Why would you think otherwise? Did you come to this video thinking it was an official, be all and end all list and no-one was allowed to say anything different?
KEA Best: metal militia Worst: no song Overrated: seek and destroy Underrated: motorbreath RTL Best: fade to black Worst: no song Overrated: no song Underrated: trapped under ice MOP Best: sanitarium Worst: no song Overrated: mop Underrated: leper messiah AJFA Best: blackened Worst: the frayed ends of sanity Overrated: no song Underrated: to live is to die Black album Best: unforgiven Worst: don't tread on me Overrated: nothing else matters / enter sandman Underrated: sad but true
no way the call of ktulu is the worst of all songs in ride the lightning. The instrumental is just so deep that there's no way you couldn't like it (ofc in my opinion)
@@TheRealBigChipz that one is a solo, trust. I play that song and kirk does that on the last frets, as a solo. I really think it is because James plays another thing
The call of Ktulu is their best instrumental by far, I don't see it getting a 3/10. Also MOP isn't a bad song, just overhyped. RTL (track) is pretty glossed over so It's cool to see it get a good rating but you are WAY to harsh when critisizing songs you find mediocre. If something is mediocre it should be in the 4-6 range anything above is good or very good anything under is bad or very bad.
@@TheRealBigChipz Then you have a different definition of mediocre. Mediocre as a word means average or doesn't stand out too much. Your version of mediocre seems to just mean pretty bad.
Least gate keeping metal head: only hates Master of Puppets because it got too much mainstream attention. Jokes aside, good video and I really enjoyed discovering new songs to listen to. Personally, I always just casually listened to Battery so I can get to the next track, Master of Puppets, but i recently gave battery another listen and it was truly an awe-inspiring song.
I don’t think Orion is overrated considering it was never highly rated in the first place I think you should have switched that with master of puppets for overrated and worst song because really while you might be sick of it it’s becauee you think it’s overrated and overplayed not because it’s a bad song it’s still one of their best songs but Orion you just plain don’t like it for what it is
Well lets give this a go shall we (gonna use 'least favourite' instead of 'worst' because most of the time I do still like the songs they're just overshined and also a song being overrated doesn't make it bad) ALSO JUST MY OPINION KEA PF - Phantom Lord LF - Jump In The Fire UR - No Remorse OR - Seek & Destroy RTL PF - For Whom The Bell Tolls LF - Escape UR - Escape (Everything else is thought of highly, while this is the weakest song its still better than what most think IMO) OR - Fight Fire With Fire (Only slightly) MOP PF - Welcome Home (Sanitarium) LF - Damage Inc UR - Leper Messiah OR - Master of Puppets? (Literally nothing on this album is so this all I got) AJFA PF - Blackened LF - The Shortest Straw UR - Frayed Ends of Sanity OR - Dyers Eve TBA PF - Of Wolf And Man LF - Don't Tread On Me UR - Through The Never OR - The Unforgiven (Worst of the trio but still a banger) Load PF - Bleeding Me LF - Poor Twisted Me UR - Ronnie OR - Until It Sleeps ReLoad PF - Prince Charming LF - Carpe Diem Baby UR - Where The Wild Things Are OR - The Memory Remains (Album version yes, live version no) Garage Inc PF - Astronomy LF - Free Speech For The Dumb UR - Tuesdays Gone OR - Genuinely I have no answer, I cannot think of one that is. St Anger PF - Dirty Window LF - Invisible Kid UR - Purify OR - Some Kind of Monster DM PF - That Was Just Your Life LF - The Judas Kiss UR - Suicide & Redemption OR - Cyanide HTSD PF - Atlas, Rise! LF - Murder One UR - Here Comes Revenge OR - Hardwired 72S PF - Room of Mirrors LF - Crown of Barbed Wire UR - Sleepwalk My Life Away OR - Inamorata (only slightly)
I don't know why everyone ignores That Was Just Your Life, such a masterpiece, so underrated. Well, at least 'Tallica played it live a couple of times, not like Astronomy.
You've clearly never played Sad but True on the drums, that shit is extremely fun to play also I agree with you on Jump In The Fire, King Nothing and The End of the Line
IN MY OPINION kill em all best metal militia worst seek and destroy overrated the four horsemen/seek and destroy underrated anesthesia/motorbreath ride the lighting best fight fire with fire worst trapped under ice (sorry) overrated creeping death underrated escape master of puppets best sanitarium worst tttsnb (sorry, i sont so love this song) overrated mop underrated leper messiah/damage inc and justice for all best dyers eve (my fav metallica song) worst the shortest straw (not bad, just drag sometimes) SO overrated harvester of sorrow underrated (omg) to live is to die/eye of the beholder/dyers eve black album best the struggle within worst nothing else matters/wherever i may roam overrated nothing else matters/ enter sandman/ wherever i may roam underrated holier than thou/the struggle within load best the outlaw torn worst idk overrated until it sleeps (a bit overrated) underrated (there are too many underrated songs) but most underrated: cure/poor twisted me reload best prince charming worst idk overrated as well fuel underrated (like load) but most underrated: slither st anger best purify (yeah) worst idk overrated frantic/st anger underrated (like load and reload) but most underrated: purify death magnetic best my apocalypse worst the judas kiss/all nightmare long overrated all nightmare long underrated teotl htsd best spit out the bone worst manunkind (still underrated) overrated halo on fire underrated/overlooked confusion 72 seasons best room of mirrors worst if darkness had a son overrated idk underrated idk im tired
I would put Leper Messiah in the underrated category but Disposable Heroes is also awesome. This list is great. You have good taste and I love that you’re saying your opinion
“It’s just a bass solo” yet a song like Eruption is seen as legendary? Anastasia is just Eruption but for bass, which arguably makes it cooler bc usually Bass’ are just the backing instrument Edit: I saw Orion as the most overrated on MoP, it’s clear this video is just bait
This is an interesting list. Some of your takes I disagree with, but I still respect your opinions. Here’s mine off of each album: KEA B - Whiplash, W - Anesthesia (Pulling Teeth), U - Phantom Lord, O - Seek & Destroy RTL (hard because I like all the songs) B - Fade to Black, W - Escape, U - Fight Fire With Fire, O - For Whom The Bell Tolls MOP (same here) B - Disposable Heroes, W - The Thing That Should Not Be, U - Orion, O - Master of Puppets AJFA (Favorite Album) B - One, W - Eye of the Beholder, U - The Frayed Ends of Sanity, O - Harvester of Sorrow M/TBA B - Nothing Else Matters (Favorite Metallica Song), W - Don’t Tread on Me, U - Through the Never, O - Enter Sandman L B - The Outlaw Torn, W - Poor Twisted Me, U - The House Jack Built, O - Hero of the Day RL B - Fixxxer, W - Slither, U - Low Man’s Lyric, O - The Memory Remains S&M (I like both original songs) B - No Leaf Clover, W - -Human SA B - Sweet Amber, W - Purify (Worst Metallica song), U - The Unnamed Feeling, O - St Anger DM B - Suicide & Redemption, W - Broken, Beat & Scarred, U - All Nightmare Long, O - The Judas Kiss BM B - Rebel of Babylon, W - Hell and Back, U - Just a Bullet Away, O - Hate Train HWTSD B - Spit Out the Bone, W - Am I Savage?, U - Halo on Fire, O - Here Comes Revenge 72S B - Inamorata, W - Crown of Barbed Wire, U - Room of Mirrors, O - If Darkness Had a Son
@@TheRealBigChipz yeah thanks, sometimes it’s hard to make these lists because there are many Metallica songs I really like but some I like better than others. As for The Outlaw Torn, it was a gradual process getting into it but it’s now one of my favorite Metallica songs along with the other members of the titanic Load-Reload trio, Bleeding Me and Fixxxer
@@TheRealBigChipz I think overall Reload is better, I like both albums but there’s a few songs that I dislike on either of them. Personally I enjoy most of the other albums better but Load and Reload are fine nonetheless
Damn it. I never got so angry at one of this videos. There's always someone with just shit opinions. I guess everybody has rights to be wrong, right? It was interesting to watch anyway, fair analysis. I liked it, good job.
Even with all the shocks I had with this list, Prince Charming being the best on Reload is exactly what I say! Finally someone understands this song is way too underrated.🤘
I respect your opinion but with 1 question. When you rated mop as the worst song you constructed your opinion on it being overused and ur sick of hearing it. I think in rating videos like this you rly should make the impression of the song on its riffs. Chorus. Bridge. Solo. Speed. Its irrelevant when compared to the popularity and use of the song.
i would say that seek & destroy is most overrated on kea, it's pretty mid. creeping death is better than rtl because of how weak rtl verse is. agree that mop puppets is overrated, because it's sped up it has different sound than other songs on the album. one is a masterpiece and is easily the best song on the album. also, what is the problem with instrumental tracks? the only weak instrumental is anestesia, others are very cool
Justice title track being the worst baffles me. I love that song so much. I think it’s the best on that album personally. Also the hate for the house jack built is insane.
The intro to "and justice for all" is lazy and feels like a cop out? I cannot even put into words how unfathomable this sentence is. My brain hurts. What the hell could it be "copping out" of? It's a complex intro with lots of harmonies and changes, and a guy goes "yeah this is lazy." Have you ever played it on guitar? Doesn't exactly play like a lazy intro lol.
My list (because I got pissed off with the one on this vid) Kill em All: Motorbreath in fact is underrated for me, but I consider hit the lights a bit overrated, like I prefer Motorbreath and metal militia way more than Hit the Lights tbh... List of songs: (based from my most to least favorite) 1-Whiplash 2-Motorbreath 3-the 4 Horseman 4-Anesthesia 5-Metal Militia 6-jump in the fire 7-Seek and Destroy 8-Hit the Lights 9-No Remorse 10-Phantom Lord Ride the lightning: Creeping Death is extremely underrated, probably it is the best written song by Metallica even to nowadays. And most overrated I must say...nah, none songs in this masterpiece are underrated, let's skip this one in therms of overrated tracks ok? My list of songs: 1-Creeping Death 2-For Whom the Bell Tools 3-Fight fire with Fire 4-Fade in Black 5-Ride the Lightning 6-The call of Cthulhu 7-Trapped Under Ice 8-Escape (this album is soo good that not even the worst song is bad, it still is awesome!) Master of Puppets: Disposable Heroes! That song is extreemely underrated, probably the most kick ass song ever written by Metallica! And most overrated... it's hard to say but I think that Battery is a snitch overrated, even if it is still awesome, there is better kick ass songs in this album like Damage Inc and Disposable Heroes... List of songs: 1-Disposable Heroes 2-Master of Puppets 3-Welcome Home (Sanitarium) 4-Damage Inc 5-Orion 6-Leper Messiah 7-Battery 8-The Thing that Should not be (you know the album is damn good when even the worst song is still quite of an banger!) And Justice for All: definitely the most underrated is To Live is to Die, what an great homenage to our big boy Cliff! Most overrated is hard but I quite could say....hmm...this might be an hot take but I say Harvester of a Sorrow, not bad by any means but I am not an huge fan of it... List of songs: 1-Dyers Eve 2-And Justice for All 3-To live is to Die 4-One 5-Blackened 6-Harvester of Sorrow 7-Eye of the Beholder 8-Frayed ends of Sanity 9-Thw Shortest Straw (still an decent song though a bit boring for my taste...) Black Album: most underrated song is for me Whatever I Mean Roam, that song should be the top single for this album! Most overrated is quite obvious, Enter Sandman, great song but damn, aged like milk because of the radio airplay and the many times this song appears on films and media... List of songs: 1-Sad but True 2-Whatever I Mean Roam 3-The Unforgiven 4-Nothing Else Matters 5-Of Wolf and Man 6-The God that Failed 7-Enter Sandman 8-Holier than Thou 9-Through the Never 10-My Friend of Misery 11-Don't tread on me! 12-The Struggle Within I will make an update bringing the rest of Metallica discography sometime...
Thanks, I really enjoyed watching this. Of course, I had to add a dislike to it, but BigChipz knows why, he for sure expected that and will not take an offence because of that :) Stay metal \m/
I don’t mean to be a hater, but Disposable Heroes is one of their most overrated songs so I don’t know where you’re coming from, I still like the song though. And I also agree with your take on One.
Ik everyone can have their own opinions, but sorry i think this one is terrible... especially hardwired.... calling moth the most overrated track and not even mentioning that spit out the bone isnt underrated (it needs more attention yes but it isnt underrated), halo on fire is the underrated track imo but again to each their own (wont forgive you for calling moth a 1.8)
I love the main riff of The Call of Ktulu, but you are right to put it has the worst song, 1. it would sound waaay better without distorsion, 2. The song is unnecessarily long, 3. The solos are just, idk, soulless. (In my opinion)
T I was really hoping that as the video progressed, it would be good, but when I saw that call of chutulu was bad, I respect but I definitely don't share your opinion
THE BEST SONG ON ST. ANGER IS PURIFY THE BEST SONG ON DEATH MAGNETIC IS THE UNFORGIVEN 3 THE BEST SONG ON HARDWIRED IS MURDER ONE THE BEST SONG ON 72 SEASONS IS CROWN OF BARBED WIRE
I don't understand why ppl get mad about this list! I don't agree with everything but it's his opinion, not ours plus he gets to the point on why the songs are the best/worst; overrated/underrated. I've personally never liked Pulling Teeth and there are so many comments in my videos saying "you hate Cliff Burton" or "hating Anesthesia is a crime" which is extremely outrageous and wrong. It's very overrated since it mostly lacks instruments and even tho the composition isn't that bad, it's the bass tone that sounds ugly to me. Poor Twisted Me is the worst IMO, followed by Slither and Shoot Me Again. MOP is indeed overhyped but I'd still give it a 9/10.
Escape is the worst Metallica song from the early stage, even Metallica admits that. Track was written by force to "have some shit for radio". I couldn't tolerate you saying One is overrated, But when you wrote Sad But True is overrated, I had to close your video... that's how subjective opinion matters to the world... XD
Great video but I just don’t understand the votes. Example: don’t tread on me. If you give 2.4 you can’t say it’s mediocre. 2,4 is very very bad. Same goes for creeping death. 6/10 is not great. It means that the song is ok. Whatever, it’s always cool to see new lists!
