Great list and I agree with bloodborne placement. So many bosses are straight trash or mid with the dlc saving the day. I would personally put Sekiro over Elden ring as I found Elden ring fell off hard in the late game with a bunch of bosses being subpar or straight bad like Elden beast, fire giant and godskin while areas like mountain tops and the difficulty spikes were just weird. Still fantastic but I genuinely have no complaints with Sekiro other than duo ape boss. Closest game of the bunch to being flawless while also having the fastest and most fun gameplay.
DS1 is always gonna be my number one game in the series. the world and lore is just too good. but with that being said, I can't disagree with your points lol good video man
Really great video, Elden Ring deserves the number 1 spot, best legacy dungeons, best combat (exclude Sekiro), best bosses, best environmental variety, best OST (highly subjective), best build variety, and it's an open-world too which propels Miyazaki's design philosophy to the stratosphere albeit with some flaws ofc, Miyazaki did say the DLC will have richer & more condensed points of interests per area which will further improve ER's open-world. My list from worst to best: DS2, Demon Souls, DS1, Sekiro, DS3, BB, ER.
I played every souls games for more than ten years and many, many, many, many times and I disagree. Dark Souls 3 is the best. Better than Bloodborne and Elden Ring. I didn't like ds3 that much but the more you come back to it, the more you realize how good the level design is and that is one of the best strenghts of soulsgames.
