As her mamamoo members once said wheein is the backbone of the group people don't pay attention to her alot its always the other 3 members coz she's a very low key person only the moo moo fans knows wheein is a hidden triple threat
@@aintnootherfan and she is a extremely talented painter, she plays the piano and can also drum and let’s not forget that she can also low key rap freestyle. This girl is freaking talented yet overlooked so much.
@@oliviamerkel4754 and height 😂😂 But she also has many credits more than a lot of kpop idols out there. She writes great songs but she just doesn't do it often. Let's just wait for her next solo, I bet it will be a self made album. KDH (ceo) said about 2 years ago that wheein wrote many songs in a week but he didn't want to add them to mamamoo's album and will probably keep them for her solo album
@@luminoury7840 moonbyul is least populer among general public, but most popular in the fandom . I would say wheein is 3rd. most popular kr gp - Hwasa > Solar > Wheein >/= Moonbyul most popular in fandom - Moonbyul >/= Solar > Wheein > Hwasa
Let’s show appreciation, not only to Mamamoo, but to their label. There are a lot of amazing singers in kpop, but their labels will only have them sing catchy songs that don’t showcase their vocals. Mamamoo’s music has great variety, you can often tell in which part of their career their songs came out. They the best vocals that I’ve ever heard from any kpop girl group❣️
Let's not praise their company (RBW) Too much... They stole many of Esna's songs when she was signed to them and basically forbidded her to peform solo songs
Rbw might have a great eye on catching and raising talents. But they need to learn some business because they suck!!! After 7 years they haven't approache the international market not even with one step! The girls are awesome and the most talented gg they can be crazy popular if it wasn't for rbw
@@mella9658 Well Dingga was on top of the charts in Japan and they have a great following in several Asian countries. That's international for one. They should definitely do more but to say not one step is a bit harsh
I was surprised because Wheein has some great notes in head voice in songs like Woo Hoo and My Star (though to my knowledge she never does the ladder notes live)
@@codyvanklompenberg6878 ikr. She showcases great whistle tones and head voice. I was even more surprised when he said that hwasa wins upper by a landslide
They've said that as well. Since RBW were saying early on: You need to show how talented you are, because you're not a stereotypical "Girl Group". Not to call other GG's not-talented, just that MMM shouldn't completely be put into that category
@@nah4266 I think that may just be a "you" interpretation... OP literally says they're the "best female vocal group" and have "three main vocalists." I don't think they're in any way negating all of their individual strengths, charms and talents, even if Wheein is *technically* the best vocalist by most objective standards. In fact, Wheein is actually probably the least popular and under-appreciated member, especially among non-moomoos 😅
@@k_airo ya I realised lmao I look too much into things sorry lol.. and no wheein is not under appreciated don't worry hahaha from debut to 2017 she was, but now definitely not😂😂
@@nah4266 i don't think the person tried to say something negative, i just think it was said that between the girls Wheein is the one who has more technique, even Mamamoo themselves said that Wheein is the back bone of Mamamoo
@@moonlightespt3818 umm I would disagree in that Wheein is known for techniques If you ever read how Korea introduces her, it's always like technical singer wheein or angelic voice wheein Solar is good in a lot of areas She has trained herself harder And she has lot of power But if we talk about technique it's wheein you can have your own opinions tho
@@wheeinvoila1695 She's only known for her technique in the kpop vocal technique invented definition lmaooo If we talk about technique it's solar you can your own preference towards wheein but technically is solar
@@moonlightespt3818 actually you're right Overall solar is technically stronger than wheein And that is why she's the lead vocal However if it comes to healthier techniques it'd be wheein
@@namithapremjith1714 I mean the subtitles ain't lying Cap means like false things basically lie No cap could mean like the right thing basically the opposite of lies
for me wheein also is the no. 1 on head voice, falsetto... u should hear decalcomanie adlibs, funky boy adlibs, woohoo adlibs and her solo songs for falsettos
I think the uploader based on real LIVE performance.. To be honest, I was also thinking the same same thing, but looking back at their performances, she tends to skip those parts a lot... Hwasa is more comfortable in these registry when it comes to live performances..
@@brunafonseca9848 I love the texture of her voice and how smokey it is. It has a lovely depth to it that adds a special kind of character that I don't get as much from the other girls ngl.
My bias is Moonbyul Bias wrecker is Hwasa Then bias wreker's bias wrecker Wheein and then comes wonderful Solar Yet...from all of them my favorite singing voice is Hwasa's, there's this enchanting side about it... seductive yet sweet, high ranged, flexible and versatile voice. Her vocal potential is incredible whereas I think Wheein and Solar have reached the peak of their singing talent. Which is, incredible, both of them are extraordinary singers that deliver one of the best vocals in the history of singing, yet, in my opinion, Hwasa has only started to bloom. Meaning, there's no certainty how much her vocals can really develop. Nevermind Moonbyul...she hasn't even begun to show us just how flexible and skillful her singing can become, but I'm pretty sure she might even be as good as Wheein or even surpass her in terms of range and technicality (control) ☆
I think Wheein has a few instances where she’s explored some of the 6th octave with her head voice, but yeah Hwasa is realllyyy a good head voice user. They’re all so talented, and I’m sure they’ll continue to grow vocally!
I have been anxiously awaiting this. They are one of the most technically consistent groups i have ever seen! Also thank you so much for the tag but honestly you really shouldn’t have. Especially actually mentioning me in the video! You already did so much research that I barely provided any new clips. But thank you so much 😭 🙏 Also I’m very happy I was able to guess your favourite member early hehe 😌
I've saying that they all ace in vocal technique but Solar: +power Hwasa: +unique charisma Wheein: +extra control Moonbyul: rapper ace but also can sing really stable within her range
When I first listened to MAMAMOO, I couldn't even differentiate Wheein and Hwasa's voice in their records for some reason (their tone kinda sounds similar to me). With that, I didn't appreciate her enough, always focusing on the other members and their skills. But when I heard them perform 'I Miss You' on Queendom, it's like my ears opened for the very first time (???). I couldn't get over her smooth and silky voice. The way she sings makes it look effortless. Amazing singer, indeed!
That's technically a lot of people that are new to mamamoo. It also happened to me. She isn't noticed at first, like a hidden jam but once you notice her! That's it you can never wheeout!
I will predict that Wheein is going to be your favorite. I mean, you HAD to research about every single member for this video so you have most definitely WheeInned. And you know what they say, "Once you WheeIn, you can't WheeOut"
Everyone here is saying people overlook Wheein and I legit thought she would be the most loved member! (I am new to the fandom.) Like, girl can do every. single. thing. She sings (Incredibly. One of the best vocalists in K-pop I've seen.), dances (Best dancer in the group), plays instruments (Exceptional drummer, I would say), is hilarious and proficient at many, many other things. She is the epitome of 'Golden child'. How can you overlook THIS girl?!
@GAYATRI SAMUDRA My bias is Hwasa, actually. And how can Solar be overlooked when she's literally the second most popular member? Mind you I made this comment when I was VERY new to Mamamoo. I now know that Wheein is appreciated inside the fandom, but people do tend to overlook her outside of it. Given how talented she is, she definitely deserves better.
@GAYATRI SAMUDRA I, personally, have not seen any fanwars inside the Moomoo fandom (Thank god for that). I love all the members and think they're all amazing. However, I don't agree with you when you say that Solar is overlooked. Most people when new to Mamamoo, tend to go for either Hwasa or Solar. After spending some time getting to know the girls, they become Wheein biased (From what I have seen). I would say Byul is the most overlooked member, both inside and outside the fandom. And I think it's dumb to compare Solar and Wheein's vocals. They are both amazing and there isn't much of a gap between them technically. But maybe you had a different experience from me with Mamamoo.
Mamamoo really changed my prospective about kpop this girls can really sing actually they sing very good it’s so satisfying to my nonskilled ears and when you get to know their personality you just can’t let them go like never!
I really enjoy the little introductions you give to each member. It sounds so sophisticated and you really describe them accurately and so poetically haha. I love your passion and your expressiveness! Well done! I can tell this will be a great video already!
my guess RIGHT! your bias is wheein lol. everyone who have any music background mostly picked wheein as their favourite member cause how all rounder she is! but other member are super talented too! they even write their own song, and top of that moonbyul is the 2nd most credited female idol of all time that has 70 credited song at KOMCA (korean music credited association, i guess?)! if you wanna know lil bit of their personality, kindly check out "introducing mamamoo" vid by purple hawke in your own time:)
I have music background in instruments and absolutely agree Wheein's technique is the best out of all the members. But in terms of personality my bias is still moonbyul. Just a personal preference, love all 4 of them equally much
This is one of the most fair evaluations I've seen of their vocals. I will say that Moonbyul shines best in solo material where she can switch between singing and rapping and isn't fighting to be heard over the monster voices of her colleagues. Also, it's not talked about often but Moonbyul and Wheein have similar voices and often harmonize with each other. If you lower Wheein's voice it sounds exactly like Moonbyul's but the reverse isn't true 😂: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-0526iu9Q9FE.html
When I think of upper range I think of the cleopatra game where solar somehow eliminated herself in round one and moonbyul took out everyone including herself 🤣
Thank you so much for this, though I was expecting more of Moon Byul's singing clips especially her belt in Ten Nights and in their latest Immortal song appearance . Still, I'm happy that more people is now actually recognizing Wheein's talent. They're all super talented individually but as a group, they're the best for me ❤
Oh I wish you had more Moonbyul material to work with. She's released countless covers on the main official channel with most of them ballads and R&B tracks but its not your fault since your not familiar with them but you would have had more to say about her upper register. Appreciate the effort though
Wow they actually surprised me!!! Their voices are really enjoyable and freacking versatile!! I loved that High belts, low notes, rap, soft vocals, aggressive vocals, etc. they surprised me a lot! I saw a lot of people saying that them and Red Velvet are the best Kpop groups that exist right now, and I understand why now!!
Mamamoo members have some of the best vocals in the whole K-Pop industry as you were able to see for yourself. These girls REALLY deserve more attention. Just a suggestion: Blackjacks form a very big fandom even after disbandment and they remain loyal to anyone who talks about 2NE1 so you should do them next, I'm sure you would receive a few lots of new views 👀
He would get a lot of hate from Bom's fanboys/girls. They aĺl think highly of her as a vocalist when technically Minzy is the best vocalist of the group.
It’s always cool to see how they objectively compare to each other. I wish Moonbyul had been allowed to focus on singing as much as she originally wanted to. But of course, her rapping is amazing and we love her for it.
Wheein is amazing, I love her so much and she's my bias. She's definitely the backbone of the group and an ace of kpop, being the best vocalist and best dancer of Mamamoo
Even though I completely agree that Hwasa comes first regarding upper range, I believe you should check Wheein's whistle note in Woo Hoo! I believe that makes it easier to untie
The cleaning and control of WheeIn + the passion and great interpretation of Hwasa for me are the best combinations. I like that they recognize Hwasa as a singer because lately they only label her as the sexy or stage presence girl.
maybe you can refer some of moonbyul's vocal from her solo works like eclipse, absence, her christmas songs (snow; 3 days before christmas), solo song covers, and many others. you know, my bias is also wheein, but i'd like to consider moonbyul as one of the best singer out there, since she keeps progressing her vocal skill through her entire carrier.
RV doesn't have extensive live performances outside of music shows where they sing without backtrack vocals unlike MMM..MMM builts their career around all these live performances. So maybe it would be hard for him to analyse due to the lack of materials..
@@laramiaizz I don't think so, there are quite a lot of performances of RV singing in dance practice rooms, wendy who does insta lives singing joy who also has quite a good amount of covers and seulgi who also has quite a few. Irene and yeri would be the problem.
You said MoonByul is the only Rapper in Mamamoo, and that isn't true. Hwa Sa is also a Rapper, but her role of Rapper has just minimized in the group. Also MoonByul is a trained vocalist, and came in as a vocalist, it's just RBW, had too many vocalist, and had her move to the role of Rapper.
What I love about Mamamoo is that the members are each so vocally competent, that it's hard for me to have one bias. Plus they each bring something so different, but they harmonise so well! Solar, Moonbyul, Wheein and Hwasa are powerful soloists, but are even more powerful when they sing together, it's breathtaking ❤
They are so good! For lows, I don't think that there's a difference between the three. Their lows are average, with support down to G#3/A3 and their projection could be better. For belting, I agree that Hwasa is the 3rd one, as she is much more inconsistent that both Wheein and Solar. Some of her best opened notes aren't in this video tho. Solar and Wheein are very different, and it's a really close battle in belting. I'd say that Solar is a bit more consistent with openneses, as Wheein can get a little nasal, but Wheein performs better above C#5. I always thought that Wheein's upper belts are beautiful, it's a shame she doesn't go for them a lot. Solar's two first C#5s were actually resonant. They were pushed just like every 5th octave note from her. I agree with the agilty, although the differences between the three, are again, small. That run from Wheein(the pink dress) wasn't good at all.. For the upper range, I think Wheein is a bit more relaxed than Solar. So Wheein>=Solar>>Hwasa. It's amazing that all of them are able to resonant at least up to C5! It's rare to see that in a girl group.
Can I ask a question? If Hwasa has better lows, agility and HV, why is Solar a better vocalist overall? I get that she has better belts but she seems less well rounded
@@liz2668 well none of the three have good or impressive agility so that’s already something we shouldn’t look at the most but Solar is very consistent with her support and resonance up to C#. Hwasa can get inconsistent even lower than C5 due to being fatigued or having too much tension, the hv part is meh because they all have underdeveloped upper registers
@@izonexbae well the 3 of them doesn't use Head Voice at all, they mostly use Falsetto for their Upper Register. I think Wheein recently been using/developing her Head Voice but it's a rumor that I just stumbled on. But for now, if we ranked them for their Falsetto capability, I personally think that Hwasa > Wheein > Solar ( > Greater than) ( < Less than)
i agree with almost everything except the head voice part, hwasa is really good but its still unhealthy compared to wheein’s incredibly well supported and clear head voice and falsettos, she is a master at this, i think u should check out more of wheein’s head voice/falsetto compilation, that was the thing that got me like she does it soooo effortlessly and its still soooo clear and well supported she is so good at this, in the kpop industry absolutely no one can beat her at this
I mean, I knew wheein was the vocal queen of the group but this video shows it more clearly lol AND she's my bias too, like Leigh in little mix.... U really has a great taste 😜💕
I love #Mamamoo just hearing them touch the sky, Hwasa's sexy voice, Wheein's sweet voice, Solar's powerful voice and Moonbyul's elegant voice and rap, they are the Vocal Queens
When I got into K-pop 4 years ago, I checked out so many girl groups and I tried to like so many of them. Until I finally got to Mamamoo and I felt like I found the love of my life. Not only are they the vocal queens, but their songs, creative freedom, stage presence and personalities make them shine so brightly.
12:10 Actually, a vocal coach who is known for how his trustworthy and sometimes harsh critiques really praised this. He said "Her voice is actually not that volumnuos compare to other girls and she is not a natural talent but she sweat blood for this. I can assure you that. The girl in the blue (Wheein) is more of a natural talent with a great voice. The girl in the red (Hwasa) is like that too but the girl in yellow (Solar) worked so hard. She is definetly the most hardworking one of them. Normally you cant belt this "E" sounds easily. She puts all she has. Uses diyaphram, leans forward, open mouth and holds the note crystal clear."
Once you Wheein you can’t Wheeout! I’m surprised you didn’t talk more about their harmonizes! They’re insane when they sing together and I feel that’s where Wheein, the back bone of the group, truly showcases her musically and pitch. Also, Wheein can reach whistle notes.
Yes I knew it would be wheein, she holds the group vocaly that's what their ceo & solar said many times befor, what makes her even more amazing her talk voice is so different from her singing voice and her low register is so beautiful like a wind
@@aeri_taylors-version yea right! i just hope he uses jessica's solo stuff because im so tired of hearing sones who know nothing about technique downgrade her so much like she stopped singing in 2014 😓
@@null6955 i mean, jessica lost much passion in singing and directed it to other stuff (fashion) and fyi, all of jessica's best vocal moments can be found in her career as snsd member
@@Lucas-or1ic just because she hasn't gotten better doesnt mean shes gotten worse. Her lost passion isnt just bc she has other interests, its bc anytime she makes a comeback sm suppresses her work and influences music shows to cancel her performances, which happened both on her debut and her 10th anniversary. Which is why we have to rely on fancams to see her sing. And she still sounds incredible. But people act like sooyoung and tiffany are now better because they have no understanding on what it means to have good technique. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-m1omgwZ-MjM.html
@@null6955 yeah, it's good to hear from jessica, im not updated with snsd for years now so im not updated with everything they do yeah, she hasn't gotten worse but she retains the same technique tiffany didn't improve i agree with that, she just have better choices in her song and approach sooyoung did actually improved but it's not massive, she still didnt have grounded support in her voice
Thank you for making mamamoo version😭😭 and this video makes me wanna rewatch immortal songs performances even though i watched them at least twice monthly already🤣
I don't know much about high notes/falsettos but I personally think Wheein is better than Hwasa since she can use her head voice well and hit whistle notes easily.
MAMAMOO - MY CON World Tour (USA) May 16 - UBS Arena at Belmont Park (New York) May 18 - CFG Bank Arena (Baltimore, MD) May 20 - State Farm Arena (Atlanta, GA) May 22 - Bridgestone Arena (Nashville, TN) May 24 - Dickies Arena (Fort Worth, TX) May 27 - Wintrust Arena (Chicago, IL) May 31 - Desert Diamond Arena (Glendale, AZ) June 2 - Oakland Arena (Oakland, CA) June 4 - Kia Forum (Los Angeles, CA) Don't miss your chance to experience Mamamoo's superior live vocals firsthand!
This is a really interesting vid to watch. I absolutely adore these girls and as a wheein bias her voice just takes me into cloud nine. It's so so effortless I love it. But what i like about mamamoo the most is that even tho wheein is considered the best technically, solar and hwasa shine in other departments so each vocalist brings something new to the table. Not to mention moonbyuls insane skill in rapping. They're a group full of aces for sure
