yes i i know they just debuted i ain’t stupid & i said “based on the skills they’ve shown SO FAR” the selective literacy of kpop stans is smth not of god
Just curious, what are these evaluations based on? Like for example, does a “Strong” stage presence rating mean that person is better than most of their peers on that category? Does an “Excellent” rating mean top tier?
@@yoonrisworld8678 Yeah but my point is that I dont think some of their skills in those categories are that strong compared to other 4th gen groups, but if you say everyone is strong making ratings kinda loses its point?
@@zrf4944 it’s not compared to anyone it’s just in general you either have stage presence or you don’t. But stage presence is smth your can work on and improve
I disagree.. I usually notice Hyein & Danielle.. They dance very well.. Not much of Haerin or Hanni.. They only look pretty, but not strong stage presence.
Ma girl Haerin have already caught my attention with her big cat eyes, beautiful voice and mysterious aura. I actually like that she's not too extra with her facial expressions, she does it in a very natural way, her fancams are relaxing I would say. I think she only needs more confidence. Give her few years and you will see the difference. All the members are already so good considering how young they are. Seriously NewJeans are so close to perfection.
True! Haerin caught my first as well (even tho i thought Hyein is gonna be my ult bias). Haerin is on center (delivered perfectly well) and always stable with facial expressions. Never did I ever thought she's actually an introvert 🥺🤍 im shoookt!
But even though I love them, haerin when they debuted looks lost onstage. Hyein and Minji also. Only Danielle and Hanni were making different facial expressions and looked very comfortable... It's changed and they have improved immensely but that was the majority opinion when they debuted seeing their debut stages. Smiling winking also is part of showing presence... No need to put down who smile onstage. If you are nervous it gets to your head and people forget smiling etc... So it's a valid opinion for that time
@@hannis_personal_phoneStage precence doesn’t always need to be about dance. You’ll need to have the facial expressions, strong movements and more. I think she’s pretty good at sp.
im not refering to the dance she does have stage presence but its average but i can see that shes improving as i wrote that comment 3 weeks ago. Hope that helps clear that up 😊@@emmafrancis5199
i’m really impressed with the production of new jeans, it might seem like them not being stellar in the rap category is a diss but in reality it feels like a relief 😭 a lot of groups that debut have rap lines with mediocre rappers bc they think every song needs a rap to go viral, when in reality they DONT! and that’s okay bc you see how far newjeans have come ❤ much success to them, i hope they win rookie of the year award
Hey you guys, don't be blind on Hyein's vocal, you will see the talents of Hyein in"it is live" ditto ver, her vocal can't be described by words, she is so talented and also her stage presence is excellent ❗❗
She is kinda weak in SP. look at her perfo in hype boy, she sings the chorus but her expressions are pretty basic. does not smile much, her eyes stay the same and her overall facials just bland. you can compare it to other members
@@Daisy-qd2cf She is shy compared to the other, i think it’s mainly because she did not have much work pre debut while other had tv shows, fashion shows, dance cover etc.
Yes, it shouldn't be. But for some cases, it is. Have you ever heard there's visual line or visual member in kpop groups? Because visual has been a position.
@@meenaverma4973 ik but FOR ME visual isn't a talent..If you can sing, dance, rap (like other things except visual) then you're talented. Visual is just about beauty (who fit KBS the most, not a talent or posi, But they just take it as position).
this is so biased and wrong 💀 there is no rap parts so why is haerin "weak" while hanni is "average"? if you want to praise hanni and danielle you can do that without bringing the others down. haerin is vocally excellent main dancer amazing stage presence centre visual and ace of the group. you can't change my mind.
@@joshchanhonest2787 compared to hanni, dani and haerin… she still considerably right there along with them not to mention shes only 14 and her voice still has to mature so shes probs gonna sound 10x better once she gets their age with all the training hybe does with their artist vocal wise. so uhh yea ig lol. def not just “ok” but probs is to you💀
Haerin dance style is closer to my ideal but tbh I love how flowy Hyein is like DOES SHE EVEN HAVE BONES??? Both got excellent execution for isolation but Hyein is more prominent. Ngl their voices are my favorite. Haerin and Hyein caught my attention since the beginning tho 😻
@@lilyrics_ idk which video you refer, sometimes I do think so. But she's less stiff than the others, at least it doesn't look awkward cuz she got the groove. It's still their debut era, so they have so much room to improve but they already got the talent so I look forward to it!
Hyein vocals are amazing. She’s a main vocalist and her voice blends in so well. And her rapping and and dancing are amazing! She’s mainly known for her rapping
Honestly, after watching a few of their live singing. Hyein vocals is exactly the same as the one in their recorded songs. she didn't even have to try too hard, and she is only 14 which means her voice is not matured yet (mature voice is around 18+ age) but to be able to not make a mistake in singing is already a great thing for someone their age
@@billythecat she caught my attention first, I like her vibe, aura and personality and she appeared to be the most beautiful for me although they are all pretty except from that her voice and dancing skills is also amazing. 💗
no thats not minjis charm tho shes amazing at rapping and dancing but she has a husky voice and as an ex-trainee i know that vocals is not her strong point.(im not trying to hate on minji btw 😊)@@emmafrancis5199
Although Haerin's SP is weak, but she still attract my eyes a lot, there's sth mysterious in her and i love it. I love all of them. They are the first Kpop group i like all members
It is funny that people evaluate idols based on an imaginary or subjective concept like stage presence although most viewers are not professionals. Who has stage presence? Who can be evaluated by stage presence although there are only a few idols who show stage presence. There is no official center in this group, and each member performs on both center and side. If you just watch one person, her presence becomes larger than others.
