Vanella Icecream but she has a VEVO for her professional recordings, she created a personal channel just to post this one roast and I hope she continues lol #onesetrecorder
I totally was thinking they'll eventually post a video reacting to a video that reacts to their video that contains them reacting to a video. Very Desus & Mero vs DJ Envy. But no histrionic baby Envy.
What I find most fascinating is that, of all the instruments 2set has roasted, the recorders are the ones coming out in force to respond. Meanwhile violas are just laughing along with the jokes lol.
People get a bit salty sometimes because of the jokes, but, well, it's understandable, because there's also people who think Twoset are insulting or made the video with that intention, but in reality they didn't, but I see this as the Jazz jokes, I am not a profesional Saxophonist but I am studying sax in jazz style, and I do get a little bit salty when people think that Jazz it's just playing wrong notes, but, I think the recorder players have their own reasons because they already are really critiqued, I see their reasons to respond but I also think they have to take it less seriously.
@@LinneRinne If anything, I would think people would have to agree that the "Jazz = wrong notes" is part of the general 20th century trend of "creativity = wrong notes", no? I mean, could anyone tell me with a straight face that atonal composers' music sounds more musical than Jazz? Maybe I'm naive about Jazz music, but early Jazz sounds just as musical as any other genre, while late Jazz sounds like a chromatic scale with holes in it.
@@ghollisjr You see, you're right, when experimental Jazz was created (not necessarily bad music but...sounds mostly like chromatic scale + random chords) people believed that was kinda just playing wrong notes or literally whatever you come out with, Jazz is obviously mostly improvisation and learning how to move between chords, rhythm, and many many scales with freedom to express yourself in a nice way, you have to make it sound good not just for yourself but for others at some point, because jazz naturally sounds nice, influential songs sound nice even if you don't like jazz, Coltrane, Parker, they sound really good, but after one point jazz became really hard enjoy not only because it was already kinda hard to understand, for example, songs like Giant Steps or some of the last Coltrane songs, but because experimental genres were born and they became really popular among jazz artists (80' to 2000) that got "bored" of the more "normal" jazz, this trend appeared, that "Jazz is kinda just wrong notes over some chords" and well, even thought artists like Joshua Redman or Wayne Shorter exist, it's like the recorder's being jugde before even knowing anything about them, a lot of people still think that jazz is like a disaster, like listening to Yoko Ono screaming in her songs (no offense to her).
@@LinneRinne That gets me curious: Is there some recent/new Jazz that you would recommend to a curious listener? I used to jam out to some Meshuggah so I'm fine with chaotic chords & melodies, so is there something that you would say is the pinnacle/icon of recent Jazz music?
@@ghollisjr I mean, not really like, a pinncale or icon to be honest, Jazz has been going kinda back to it's roots and the new Jazz it's kind of a mix which, is at least 60% early and classic jazz and 40% experimental, you can listen to Joshua Redman or Maceo Parker, they are awesome and mix a lot of stuff, also you can listen to Wayne Shorter, they all sound great and have their own personality they are, "recent icons" , and as a bonus my teacher it's one of the best saxophonists and Jazz composers from my country, his band is called "Retrasax" and in youtube you can find their jams and many events and songs, there's a 1 hour video from when they played for a radio (Letelier radio) which is really really good, and there's "Puntito", a song that my teacher composed for his middle son.
Not only is it comical genius, but it's also musically clever because she had to plan out the harmonies and coordinate fingers of two simultaneous voices. I never thought that a girl sticking two things in her nostrils would be such an attractive thing, but I guess anything's possible in 2020.
@@fairycupcakez And so the Leng Leng saga goes on........She was a prodigy at 6 months old and now a virtuoso of international repute.Shows you what the recorder and practice can do
I just love like how little she cares lmao she’s like the quiet student who the wrong person made fun of, and instead of an explosive reaction she just calmly made this
Two Set guys are hilarious...the recorder roast was just pure silliness...they WERE blown away by some of her reply, though, no doubt about it. Superbly answered, and with style, grace, and humor. Guarantee Two Set loved it. One of the other recorder responses said "they're not even trying"...Eddie said, "it's true, we weren't". I love it when channels fight clean (and silly). The one between some other recorder champions and Davey 504 was excellent, too. Bret also mentioned that he played with a professional recorder player in a concert and really enjoyed it...they were just funnin'...they have NO problem making fun of, and idiots out of, themselves, as well.
People comparing the reaction of viola players and recorder players: the general population already know viola is a "real" professional instrument, while recorder players are much more likely to have to defend their instrument against the perception that recorders are just a cheap kids toy
Wait, what's a viola? Just kidding ;) Most of my non-musician friends don't know what a viola is. They also think the recorder is what our grade 3 teacher made us play and they think it's an awful sounding instrument (because we were not taught properly how to use it).
Most people "don't know" the viola exist, but they recognize it as a "real instrument" at sight because it looks like a violin. The bad part is about the recorder, because everyone thinks the recorder is bad and doesn't even takes talent. Making jokes about it doesn't help the general ignorance, it's joining them.
@@bozhang7727 Good point. But they should also make a video where she is actually interacting with them, maybe a recorder ling ling challenge or professional vs beginner, options are limitless.
One thing about it is that TwoSet already featured her and her recorder on their channel 2 years ago: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-S7Beb8geTNU.html
Dude I'm thankful TwoSetViolin caused this classical roast war, as someone who actually enjoyed playing the recorder for years (3rd-8th grade) when I was younger I am stoked to find out that there's people who play it REALLY damn well, and have professional success doing it. Also, she's 20, and has already released a UK Classical chart-topping album, while I, also 20, am commenting on a RU-vid video at 3:44am even though I have a final in 10 hours. Really puts things into perspective, you know?
This was brilliant! Funny and educational at the same time. I really wish Twoset will see this some day. The Jingle Bells at the end really got me... XD But I just got to add... One video making fun of recorder, and people are rushing to defend it everywhere...and meanwhile the same community is bashing violas left and right 24/7. Though I guess it's different, because viola, lol.
Also the viola is a much respected instrument, for recorder players it can be really tiring to have people making fun of them all the time. Talking from experience lol It's not offensive, it's just really tiring, and the "match" was so unfair it's kind of frustrating, specially coming from two profesional musicians. That said, I love these guys and I've been following them for a while, just wanted to make my point!
@@AngieGandalf6 exactly. Like I'm pretty sure everyone knows viola players aren't actually terrible, but the thing is some people might actually think recorders are childs instruments or they suck or something
@@AngieGandalf6 ...I'm sorry, but do you have any idea to what extent people make viola jokes in this community? Every. Single. Day. And many of them aren't even that funny but downright mean. Violas are shit/firewood/trash are pretty basic, that doesn't even make me react anymore, in any way. Memes about shooting people who say they like viola, about violists having deformed skulls, running to wash your hands after shaking hands with a violist... and yeah, it's in RL too. Every time I meet new people who are twosetters and tell them I play viola, guess what follows? So you're telling me "it can be really tiring"? Thank you, I know. I'm sorry about the outburst but I'm just so fed up with the situation. Perhaps people do know they're "only" jokes, but that doesn't mean they couldn't have a negative effect. I know at least one case personally who stopped playing viola because of the jokes (someone who was starting a new instrument). And new kids don't want to play viola anymore. Makes sense. At certain age you just don't want to beome the butt of all jokes. It warms my heart that you say viola is respected. That's not something I hear often these days.
@@violistontheroof Of course the viola is respected. Why does it exist? Because it stands for a purpose, and often, although the purpose is overlooked over the violin, it is still very important in bringing sections and music together.
love how bret and eddie make fun and how lucie reacts. Can't wait till bret and eddie do a tour again and invite her to do a piece together. :) Naturally some crazy piece involving bees or something like that :D
I'm just thinking that the range is the only thing I wouldn't agree with I think, because we are talking about multiple instruments of the same family then I guess you could count from the double bass to the violin in which the entire piano's range is almost covered. But thanks for the video!
Actually, recorder can cover until 3 octaves, checkout Sarah Jeffery video cover about it ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-z4tLQ09_YZE.html
It's still recorders, and different ones can even be used in one piece. It's like saying orchestral percussionists can only count one of their cymbals. Point is if you're a recorder player you will have all these in your arsenal, so your range is large. Doesn't really matter that the pieces of wood are separate.
@@askbask Well, in an actual performance you're not go and switch your instrument halfway through a piece would you, if there is a piece that's like that I'd be highly intrigued to see it
Guys, All of these music players were sisters and brothers! Lang Lang(the first brother) plays the piano, Ling Ling (the second sister) plays the violin, and Lung Lung(the third sister) plays the recorder. Now, we just have to wait for Long Long and Leng Leng to come!
As a TwoSet fan, I will freely admit that their violin-recorder comparison was funny, but unfair. I am glad to see a response such as this to the video. Great work!
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS. I did know that the recorder was a real instrument, and I'm honestly a little puzzled why it has mostly disappeared from the literature since the classical era. However, I did not know about you. You are a fine person and a fine musician. Thank you for sharing your gift with the world for the last 20+ years.
Nice reaction but there is another thing a lot better than the reaction: the reaction made Lucie Horsch make her own channel (other than the VEVO-channel). Subscribed and waiting for more content :) In our family we listen lots of recorder music because I play and my daughter plays. I love the way you play, Lucie! Thank you for this video, the other videos in RU-vid and the cds you have made. Hope you start uploading videos in this channel soon.
LUCIE I CAN'T BELIEVE YOU DID THIS IT IS AMAZING 🤩🤩🤩 I hope Brett and Eddy see this :) :) Also....I saw you when you were in Canada and you're my hero!
Lovely lady, as a person who has played flute and oboe for many years, I have nothing but the utmost respect for you. That was wonderful! I'm so impressed. :) What a wonderful roas- I mean "review" for Twoset. :D
THANK YOU SOOOO MUCH!! I'm a French recorder player and I'm sick of all those peoples how think that the recorder is shit! NO, THE RECOREDER IS NOT SHIT, AND THE RECORDER (can) BE DIFFICULT! Thank you so much!
I used to love violin. Thanks to you now I'm in love with recorder as well. And I'm gonna bring my motto in gaming: "Every hero is OP, depends on who plays it." Now, it becomes: "Every instrument is OP, depends on who plays it." ;)
Lucie Horsch is one of my favorite people and one of my favorite musicians. I love that when TwoSet tried to make her instrument seem like an embarrassing toy, she didn't get upset and list all the great music for recorder, she responded point-by-point showing how the recorder is every bit as capable as the violin. (To be frank, IMO, at it's very best, played by a true master like Hilary Hahn or Itzhak Perlman, nothing can match the violin. But TwoSet, capable though they are, are not that.) Meanwhile, on her own channel, we can hear a lot of great recorder music, brilliantly played.
Fantastic response! I loved your video and it made me laugh. Twoset have accidentally (maybe deliberately?) set the world on a path to recorder education!
Oh, I loved this. Sarah Jeffery also made a response video and I loved that as well. People say it was only a joke but I didn't really get much fun out of it.
OMG!!! You're absolutely amazing!!!! Following. You all are contributing for popularization of the classics acoustics instruments. Greating from Brazil.
SLAYYYY!!! And I like how you modified the video to include their reaction to you brandishing your reputation in your original reaction video! Nice touch! They gotta go bite the dust!
UGH Syrinx on tenor that was amazing ;n; Not to mention how awesome the whole video is. Good on you!!! Especially using Twoset watching you in the Reputation part!
Absolutely legendary Lucie! I've watched some of your performances ever since I saw you on that first TwoSet video. You are the recorder goddess! So glad you did this to show us the true capabilities of this beautiful instrument...and, of course, to roast TwoSet! Really hope you do more videos.
Your playing is magnificent! You have all the musicality of a true musician, the technique, and the love❤️🇨🇦 as a fellow musician , trombone player, I too have several models🧐 of high quality. Lol tbone flex.
I found out about her not because of this video, but since all her videos have a comment about this I came here to watch it and it was the funniest thing I've watched in a long time. Good job, girl
As a violin player, I love it :-) (and I also love their reaction to your video :-D). Actually a really learned a lot about what you can do with that instrument. Though for good measure, you also should have "played" the violin :-D
Haha Nope, thanks. If there's an instrument that sounds more torturous in a beginner's hands than a recorder, it's violin. Lucie wouldn't want to scare her potential subscribers away.
Yes yes yes ! Mad props to the woman who created a channel for the single purpose of roasting these guys ! Go recorder community ! Show them what we're made of !
Came here from TwoSet (got there from Davie504, being a bassist myself) and man, I'm having a BLAST on these "picking at each other" thing musicians are having, we get to know so many awesome instruments, techniques and musicians. You got my sub, and hope you guys keep roasting each other
