REBS FAB STASH - BATTLE OF THE QUILTING SUBSCRIPTION BOXES - Spring 2023- - March Box *SPOILERS* 

Oh and one more thing I just found out about that my kids have been enjoying making are quilted hearts for the "I found a quilted heart" project. They are just scrappy hearts that they can just go to town sewing and sew as many as they like. If you do a google search you can find out more about what they are for. I've done actual sewing projects with my kids before but this is probably the thing they have enjoyed the most so far because it requires the most just raw creativity and they don't have to focus on instructions. They can finish one in a few minutes and then pick more scraps and sew a completely different one. Plus it teaches them to be giving without the expectation of reward or recognition.

I agree with B+. I would make the projects. I had a bunch of flannel squares left over and my granddaughter had a blast making a simple throw sized quilt with them. Good practice for straight lines and allowed her creativity as she could choose from the pile and arrange them how she liked. She’s a bit younger than your Grand but she worked at it all day and we had a blast together.

Good morning! I learned to sew at 10 years old. I was making doll clothes. The girls and I discussed it, and we think you should ask if she has a project in mind. If not, we suggest a tote bag for her to keep her crochet supplies in or a zipper pouch. Those are good beginner projects with immediate gratification that she can use. As for the box, we give it a B. We like the wildflower quilt. It's different. There are 3 projects with most of what you need for them, and I like the way they are all organized in bags. The table runner and thread catcher aren't necessarily my taste, but the value is there for the price. Definitely a B.

How fun to have a sewing day with your grandchild! Pajama bottoms can be fun entry point. Love the idea of a zipper pouch! Stitches can be unpicked and you'll be there helping

My youngest son's favorite kind of day is when it is stormy and grey and oogie all day. Which, is good sewing weather. I like a nice sunshiny spring or fall day that isn't too hot, so I can run. I think a zipper pouch is a great idea for a 13 yo. The Iuka guild does a kids can sew day every year and we make rag quilts with them. Which is an achievable quilt for a kid. Have fun sewing with your granddaughter! I would give that box an A.

Simple tote bag - easy to customize; if she's comfortable, add patch pockets to the lining; later customize with decorative stitches. A zipper pouch or tote is something she can use right away to carry/store her crochet/craft supplies!

Your hair looks so pretty today! For your granddaughter I would talk to her and see what kinds of things she wants to make. She might be thinking garment sewing. Most people don't understand that quilting, bag making, and garment sewing are all separate hobbies. I would pick the project based on what she wants to dive into. Quilting: A small quilt, walling hanging, place mats, pot holders, ext. Bag making: A pencil pouch or wristlet. Something she can use. Garment sewing: A simple skirt. (Violette Field Thread is a pattern company with some gorgeous and mostly easy to sew clothing patterns).

Like others have said, I'd do a tote bag so she'll have a way to carry her art/craft supplies. You could do an inside zipper pocket as an easy intro to zippers. Have fun! That's so cool she wants to sew!

"A-" Great projects with gorgeous fabrics! Have fun with your Granddaughter♥♥

Love the curls!

I really liked this box. I enjoy getting projects in these boxes. It's a great break from working on quilts. The price is reasonable. I give this box an "A". I'll bet she can handle the zipper just fine. I think a couple smaller projects (tote bag, apron, zipper pouch, table runner for her bureau) to start so she has the satisfaction of finishing a couple things is best for starting. How fun, enjoy the time.

Love the idea of something useful like a zipper pouch. Even a dog collar. My girlfriends quilt shop has a box called thready geared towards that age

I think a simple patchwork totebag would be a great first project - that's what my daughter started with and she has used the bag for years! Have fun!

I like this box, it was well presented. For your granddaughter, what about string squares. They're quick and will help with her straight line stitching. Afterwards you can make them into pouches or bags

I like this box . I would definitely make the smaller projects and the quilt. Solid B for me too!

I liked this box, good variety. B You could start with an unlined zipper pouch, to get over the zipper installation, then add the lining in the next pouch. My very first project was a skirt with an elastic waist. Pajama pants are pretty fast and easy as well.

I love, love, love the lap quilt. Wildflowers are definitely my jam. A- from me.

I would wait on buttonholes and zippers until your granddaughter has a couple of projects successfully completed and is ready for more challenging skill-building items. Consider starting off with a simple project related to her other interests, such as a tote bag or drawstring bag she could use for her yarn-related projects, or a simple apron if she likes to cook. If she is more into clothing construction, check out the Simplicity learn-to-sew patterns (they have a very easy elastic waist skirt that is perfect for a beginner). It would be great if she could pick out her own fabric (maybe a fabric store field trip would be a good start, or shop your stash?)

Love your hair today!

I liked this box. A few cute and fast projects. I give it a B. ❤

A for me. Cute projects. Your hair looks beautiful today!

Great box I give it an A. I think the zipper bag is the way to go. Good luck!

Pillows are awesome for first project. And she can do alittle appliqué

Box- A-, Achieveable projects with the fabric included. These projects seem great for all level of sewists and can be made quickly. I'm shaving off a couple of points as the fabrics are scrap size if the fabrics weren't preferred. Nice box and good value overall.

I think a 13 year old would love a zipper pouch. I did a machine embroidery project that was a big hit with my grandson. we made cool lace up shoe characters from off with your threads pattern ( see Etsy store) he was the coolest kids at school. very hip.

I think a pillow. Kids love pillows for their beds

Holly : "Mother Nature knows what she's doing." ME: Mother Nature is going through "The change!"" LOL I hope you and your granddaughter have fun sewing- and my thought is perhaps a tote bag that she can use. It can be scaled up and down with pockets, etc. As far as your thought of a zipper pouch- it's perfect!

I loved this box! Fun projects. For your granddaughter a small table runner could be fun, although I love the idea of a bag. I have an almost 14 year old granddaughter. She just likes to mess around with fabric. Nothing really made as of yet!

Book cover, pin cushions are good starters.....

An easy project would be an open tote bag. Something she could use to carry some of her stuff to visit you!

Another box of Riley Blake fabrics!! I must say, this is my favorite box so far! I prefer smaller projects and getting more in a box! Nothing in this box made me want for more! I give this an A+. Holly, your hair is absolutely gorgeous!!! Have a thankful Thursday!

Pillow Case - PJ Pants - Drawstring Bag - Zipper bag - progression of skills and useful items.

Good box. I give it an A.💟🤗

If not a zipper pouch, which I think is a great idea, could be a little drawstring bag or (one with elastic instead and handles) or a cute tote bag with a front slip pocket. All sorts of possibilities! I think something that she can use and show off to her friends would be best.

I started my granddaughter off with a pillow case then we moved on to pajama bottoms. I don't think I would start with a zipper bag first until you can access how she is will sewing straight lines. Smaller peices and zippers can be challenging even to adults but once she gets the hang of it just see what she wants to make. Loved this box would give it a B.

Fabrics are nice. Probably the only thing I would do is the BOM. B

I like this box. Nice fabrics and good projects. Less "swag" in bags would be good, but at least it's a useable pen! This is also an A for me. I suggest a pillow, book bag, or start her own quilt, but a zipper pouch with your help is great!

This box was awesome. The flower garden pattern,really good. The rainbow table runner,,,WOW! Colors beautiful. Project - don't have a clue. Ask her. Colors,what she has in mind. NO ZIPPR. After I knew how to sew,notebook paper. Straight lines. Pillow with bunny or egg. Sewing on embilshments ,buttons ,Cottontails, basics. Finish in a day. I had to borrow a barbie doll to learn to sew her clothes.lol I hated dolls. Unless rgey were furry pets or baby doll. Soft squishy dolls

Hi Holly, I would start her with a tote bag. It’s how I got started and it’s immediately usable, I was so proud of mine! Lol! I think a zipper pouch to go with it would be fabulous! I think the box was an A box too, though I don’t like any of the fabrics!😂😂. I’m so picky!

I would start her with a draw string tote bag. That is one of the first projects 4-H have for the younger girls. Zippers might be to much for a first project. Also our state does quilting project and the first year is making a rail fence project in a lap size quilt. I like the box. This is one of the first projects that i have seen that I like them. I would give it a B.

Our first project many moons ago in high school was a simple purse or tote bag. Personally I’d save the zipper pouch for project two.

The reason home ec classes start with pillow cases or simple 5" patch pillows is for the student to learn the fundamentals..fabric prep, pressing , measuring, sewing machine mechanics, how to sew a straight line.. let her learn and become strong in the fundamentals and then u can move onto the 'fun projects'

My first project was an apron.

The first thing I ever made was a stuffed shark in the either grade. I helped my niece make a snoopy pillow when she was about 11.

Teen project - what about a throw pillow, no zipper style? Seems simple but useful and she can have it on her bed!

A nice box with lots of projects. The only one I might make is the Block of the Month and that would involve a commitment to the box so probably not.❤

I would start with a tote bag. Zippers can be the next project

I am a member of a quilt guild and we have a few little girls who are also members around 5 and 6 years old they started with a baby quilt made of 5 inch charm pack and a boarder nothing fancy about the quilt for leaning.

Ok, box C......not much fabric again for the price. Great presentation, as always.

B plus. I don’t care to work with just tonal or blender fabric. But if that’s your thing it’s a great value.

I liked the different projects, but I didn’t like it being the black of the month idea. That means I have to continue getting the boxes to finish project. I give it a B+

Cute patterns and fabulous material. I give it an A. I would be happy if I received this box. Obviously she must have something in mind. Ask her. Makes me think of my granddaughter, she wanted to make a skirt.

I love the pattern full of flowers. I would suggest a useful project for your granddaughter like a simple tote bag, or a headband… something she can use and share with friends… she will love sewing forever and she’ll always remember that you introduced her in this creative world. Thank you for sharing.

I liked this box…B I would recommend a tote that she can use for just able anything. Zippers still scare me😁

Pajama pants, but I would take some of the ideas and give her a choice.

New to you Love you information. I’m really wanting to get a box. So you do have awesome informative

Great quality! Cute spring pattern! The price is a bit high for scraps….B

Rebs Fab Stash is always overflowing with loot. It's organized well and appears to be a good value. However, it is not a box I would subscribe to. It feels dated, and projects are not my jam. Grade B. My 3rd child, he is 12, is starting to sew in school. He has done a little sewing at home with me. He has the interest to do more. We have made 2 small cat pillows. He has made a stuffed animal, and they are starting an apron at school. My kids all did aprons and have made animals. Girls love bags, so good thought and reasoning!! A tie blanket is always fun too. No it's not sewing but it's quality time. Keep us posted! Happy Thursday ❤️

Pretty good box, lots of projects and patterns, but not my cup of tea style wise. B+ for me. As to Granddaughter project, while zippers aren't hard, it might be a little intimidating for a first outing. How about a basic tote bag she can keep her yarn and stuff in? Maybe with a strap long enough to wear over her shoulder or cross body?

I love this box. Easy to complete projects with great directions. I’m not interested in the projects that take a long time and lots of extras to complete. Love the BOM! I’d used the thread catcher too. An A from me.

B+ for me

The block of the month is cute! I vote C to be honest there's too many table runners lately in subscription boxes! Not really enough fabric to justify the cost to me.

My first sewing project was a tote bag. Second was a three pocket apron with a casing for the ties. Zippers came when we sewed dresses in the second quarter. Sewing scraps and strips together is fun to get familiar with the machine. Enjoy.

5 B+

I have not taught anyone to sew. I would start with the basics. How to thread the machine, how to install the bobbin. How to change the needle. What tools and equipment are used and how. Then I would have her just practice lines on scrap fabric. When she is ready to start a project, start with something easy. Ask her what she would like to make. It will help build up her confidence. If she is looking for lessons, maybe she has something in mind.

You know what her abilities are... go with your gut... tote bag, beach bag, zipper pouch

Does your granddaughter have a favorite animal? You could have all the pieces cut and ready and do a very simple piece block, cats and dogs have some simple pieces. Just a suggestion.

B+ for the box, not my jam, but it was good.

Start her on a cute pincushion. If she decides she likes sewing, she's going to need one. Since she made it, it might mean a lot to her. If she decides sewing is not her jam, she can always gift it to Grandma!

You didn't mention if she had used a sewing machine or not before. A 9 patch potholder for baking, a themed pillow for reading, a tote bag to carry projects, a snap pouch to carry inside her tote. The snap is using a metal carpenters retractable measurement tape. Then a zipper pouch. By the time she does all the projects she should be comfortable with a sewing machine to tackle the zipper. You will have to let all of us know what she made. This could be an on going activity for both of you. Who knows maybe a quilt one day. Have a great day with your granddaughter.

Please add me to the giveaway. Mabey find out what kind of sewing she wants to do… clothing, Misc projects, or quilting and start there. A small trip around the world quilt with 4-5 inch blocks would be nice.

Does she cook? I think an apron is a great beginner project.

Nice box, just not my interests. Fabrics were bright and pretty. Would give it a B-.

I think you should charge 1/2 price +shipping for the boxes you don't keep..

Not my cup of tea😢