Тёмный

Red Japanese Maples - Bloodgood vs Atropurpureum: The winner will surprise you! 

The Bearded Bonsai
Подписаться 371
Просмотров 16 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

22 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 70   
@martinchamberlain542
@martinchamberlain542 10 месяцев назад
I live in the UK midlands and have had a medium sized Osakazuki in a pot for three years. After being a less than interesting green all summer, it became a blazing red in the autumn. It was stunning! My atropurpureum, however, has given me a steady variety of reds,, varying throughout the season. I absolutely love it.
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 10 месяцев назад
Same with my atro, highly underrated trees! I don't have Osakazuki... yet:)
@Nightowl-72
@Nightowl-72 11 месяцев назад
Recently moved to a house with a much larger garden and planted some maples I’ve had in pots for several years. This included a bloodgood and a atropurpureum. I love the atropurpureum and it’s definitely my favourite to date ❤️
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 11 месяцев назад
That's awesome, thanks for sharing! Such beautiful trees!
@1baboobaby
@1baboobaby Год назад
They contrast each other beautifully.
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai Год назад
I think so too!
@gamincogag
@gamincogag 4 месяца назад
I have 2 of the Atropurpureum. They hold their color well when planted in full sun. Doesn't get the sun leaf scorch. When the sun shines on them, the red is transparent and magical. They are slow growers though. Another nice feature is the red stem. Overall a beautiful JM. I also love my Bloodgood, can't beat its spring bloom.
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 3 месяца назад
Agreed!
@emT1223
@emT1223 7 месяцев назад
I would probably like them together. The atropurpureum in front of the Bloodgood.
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 7 месяцев назад
Agreed, that would look really good!
@MNH73
@MNH73 11 месяцев назад
I think these two trees are equally common in UK garden centres.
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 9 месяцев назад
That's very interesting, thank you!
@binzhou1371
@binzhou1371 5 месяцев назад
that is what i am looking for! Thanks!
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 5 месяцев назад
Awesome, you're welcome!
@ridvankarsi1926
@ridvankarsi1926 10 месяцев назад
I always thought that as well in the past. But there are reasons for it. Bloodgood has unique color and very though JM. It is very heat tolerant and takes direct sun pretty good. Other one will have hard time surviving same conditions as good as bloodgood is in the southern part of US.
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 7 месяцев назад
Yes, location will always play an important role. My best advice when choosing will always be, get them both! Haha
@MF-fc5vk
@MF-fc5vk Год назад
Planted an atro that size in my garden, great tree! ❤
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai Год назад
That's awesome!
@briangallagher3106
@briangallagher3106 4 месяца назад
Looking up through the foliage of a Bloodgood shines blood red. I love mine!! I have about 7/8 Acers. Orange dream is my favourite that I own.
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 3 месяца назад
I love looking up through the foliage. I have Orange Dream as well, beautiful tree!
@Matti6950
@Matti6950 6 месяцев назад
Is it me or does bloodgood grow faster? They often had 1.2 meter branches once they are in their speeding up growth process.
@TheCosmicDrama
@TheCosmicDrama Год назад
Bloodgood was my first Japanese maple. For me it was mostly just an availability thing. Bloodgood are easy to find. It’s hard to find any other cultivar honestly. I live in Western PA.
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai Год назад
Bloodgood was my first as well! If you'd like some recommendations for some awesome mail order nurseries, just let me know!
@kellymcy
@kellymcy 3 месяца назад
Are they all under full sun?
@TheCosmicDrama
@TheCosmicDrama 3 месяца назад
@@kellymcy my bloodgood is planted in the ground in full sun. It’s doing ok so far but I think it would do better if it got afternoon shade. The leaves take a beating in the hottest summer months.
@lelyluck
@lelyluck Год назад
I think if your going for red accent yeah Atro looks great, but I love the size of the leaves of the blood and I am a sucker for the dark almost black foliage. In the south the blood good is ever changing like a mood tree.
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai Год назад
That's really cool, I'd love to see some photos of how they are down there
@lelyluck
@lelyluck Год назад
@@thebeardedbonsai In spring they emerge the dark red/black color with in hot summer they turn dark green and in fall they are red RED just like the Atro.
@-Shockwave-
@-Shockwave- 11 месяцев назад
Last year i bought 2 Acer palmatum Atropurpureum well at least according to the cards on them...however after your video i see they are just the regular bloodgood's. Now i know why they did not turn bright red and stayed reddish brown, i was thinking maybe the soilmix or where they stood in the garden was wrong or something... The search for the right one continues.. You think you could trust the cards with the plants but nah....
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 11 месяцев назад
I will say there is a chance that they are indeed Atropurpureum, as there can be a huge variance from one tree to another since it isn't a specific cultivar.
@KoSLoW27
@KoSLoW27 11 месяцев назад
I think deshojo have more fluorescent red. It can be nice to compare atropurpureum and deshojo
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 11 месяцев назад
Yeah, Deshojo is probably brighter in the spring time. Thanks for watching!
@F_C...
@F_C... 11 месяцев назад
I agree with you but my understanding is that atropurpureum is a classification for any red Japanese maple and when a maple isn't a named cultivar it is referred to by its subspecies classification. That said, bloodgood is also an atropurpureum because it is red, but it was a cultivar because it was unique. Despite not being a cultivar, your atropurpureum has likely been selected for its color and ability to hold that color long into the year. It is not necessarily unique enough to be named though as there are many seedlings that carry the same red color. Honestly bloodgood isn't unique anymore either but at one time it was the gold standard for red maples.
@F_C...
@F_C... 11 месяцев назад
Still good thought-provoking content on j maples. Makes for a good discussion.
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 11 месяцев назад
You are correct! I love the subspecies and feel like they are massively overlooked due to the large number of named cultivars. I just wanted to showcase one of them and show how nice an unnamed variety cam be. Thanks so much for watching and commenting!!
@johnnylegrange5861
@johnnylegrange5861 Год назад
Love the red on the Atro!
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai Год назад
Me too, it's sp bright and vivid!
@TheBubbas22
@TheBubbas22 4 месяца назад
Bloodgood all day. Survived my crazy area. In and out of teens in winter and 100 plus with no rain in direct sunlight in summer. Just got a red dragon last week. Fingers crossed!
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 4 месяца назад
Those are all good ones!
@gamincogag
@gamincogag 4 месяца назад
I have bloodgood, Acer Atropurpureum and the Red Dragon. The Red Dragon holds its color in summer and is extremely sun tolerant. No leaf scotch whatsoever. It is said to be slow growing but mine coming out of winter, grew a lot and I was praying it stopped .You picked a good one, mulch and water it well the first year.
@DH-yj7bx
@DH-yj7bx Год назад
If you want red and small leaves spend a little more to get a shin Deshojo
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai Год назад
I have a Deshojo and they go green in the summer.
@EvanFan89
@EvanFan89 4 месяца назад
Can you show a comparise in May or September?
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 4 месяца назад
Definitely! Like a spring and falll color?
@EvanFan89
@EvanFan89 4 месяца назад
@@thebeardedbonsai yes. I bought a tree yesterday but im not sure if its the Bloodgood or Atropurpureum. Seems like they are similar actually?? Maybe in July like this video the Bloodgood turns darker violet than in Spring? And in Autumn more lighter red again?
@kevinhollis2204
@kevinhollis2204 8 месяцев назад
Sorry Bloodgood is my favorite hands down. The other one is ok but I love the dark foliage of the bloodgood
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 8 месяцев назад
Hey, no need to apologize! I enjoy Bloodgood too, just isn't my favorite. Thank you for watching and commenting!
@jilllawrence5174
@jilllawrence5174 Год назад
I love both of them the blood good does have blood coloured veins
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai Год назад
Me too! I just love the brighter red a little more. Would definitely recommend both!
@PyroNL91
@PyroNL91 4 месяца назад
If you like red also get Acer Palmatum Shaina!
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 4 месяца назад
I have one! They are great!
@ArceBiz
@ArceBiz Год назад
and the difference in growth rate?
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai Год назад
I'll have to let you know after I observe them more. I believe Atropurpureum is pretty vigorous.
@ArceBiz
@ArceBiz Год назад
but I think that the Atropurpureum has longer internodes
@Dailyvideodrop
@Dailyvideodrop 4 месяца назад
I fully agree never liked blood good I avoided them
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai 4 месяца назад
That's the great thing about these trees, so many varieties for so many preferences!
@gamincogag
@gamincogag 4 месяца назад
They are all beautiful. No need to compare.
@ryanodell417
@ryanodell417 Год назад
atro. takes the cake 🎉
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai Год назад
Agreed, the red is amazing!
@ryanodell417
@ryanodell417 Год назад
@@thebeardedbonsai thanks for the comparison, I found a place to buy a bunch of 2-3 year old atro. seedlings, that i’m now going to pull the trigger on.
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai Год назад
​@ryanodell417 that's awesome! Can I ask where?
@ryanodell417
@ryanodell417 Год назад
@@thebeardedbonsai Scenic hill farm nursery, is the name. they ship bare root, so i like to order from them fall through spring. i found them on the shop app.
@paulastafford1642
@paulastafford1642 Год назад
You want to spend 8 minutes comparing reds? Really?
@thebeardedbonsai
@thebeardedbonsai Год назад
Thanks for watching Paula!
@Tomedu2021
@Tomedu2021 11 месяцев назад
Why not?
@lesjack137
@lesjack137 10 месяцев назад
Sounds like time well spent to me.
@martinchamberlain542
@martinchamberlain542 10 месяцев назад
Absolutely.
@keithk1799
@keithk1799 6 месяцев назад
It's educational! You don't need to watch!
Далее
Our entire Japanese maple collection
19:33
Просмотров 19 тыс.
Ozoda - Lada (Official Music Video)
06:07
Просмотров 3,4 млн
Unique deep painful back massage for Lisa #chiropractor
00:11
Крутой фокус + секрет! #shorts
00:10
Emperor 1 Japanese maple
2:27
Просмотров 6 тыс.
Projects with Young Maples
26:41
Просмотров 496 тыс.
Heat Tolerant Japanese Maples ~ Part 1
19:50
Просмотров 44 тыс.
Japanese Maples: Root Rot - Prevent Diagnose Cure!
17:22
Ozoda - Lada (Official Music Video)
06:07
Просмотров 3,4 млн