@@diegooo283 I prefer wendy tone over ailee she uses too much heady mixed voice compared to wendy her heady mix is different from ailee since She is light lyric soprana
It actually scares me that people like Wendy and Taeyeon are ranked B+ at max by people who know what they’re talking about when it comes to vocals. Like, they blow me away enough as it is with their incredible vocals! And you mean to tell me that this is only slightly above average? I don’t think my mind could comprehend hearing an S+ tier vocalist!
i think a s+ vocalist may be an opera singer or a diva? in the idol field, wendy and taeyeon are among the best but when it comes to professional vocalist, they r b+ but it s still okay
What, if your English you’ve heard of Mariah Carey and Ariana Grande, two of the worlds best female vocalist with the largest supported and unsupported ranges in the world, this girls range isn’t even impressive, she’s just an above average singer in a dried out land of terrible singers and instagram models so she looks special
@@Bunnybunny5656 you’re right about Mariah in her prime but not Ariana her support ends at B4 Wendy is a much better vocalist than her and far from average
Thank you so much for doing an in depth analysis on Wendy! Her vocal color and how adaptable it is makes her my favorite vocalist in Kpop and I'm so glad I could see a technical analysis on her 😄
@@mowom6616 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-lRx5_rNiiRg.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-_9ZOk4t9Zmc.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-fCJI7kOROCY.html Those are the ones I remember atm I think there’s also some phrased ones in Why Can’t You Love Me.
wow! this is so thorough :) I enjoyed it a lot! Can you do one with Gfriend Yuju? especially how her lower register has improved so much in recent years, thanks so much!
"Slight nasality blocks consistent resonance" ; but why would she want to sound rounded and wide for every song? You have examples like BoA or Jessica who prefer a more soft and nasal sound, and that's not technically bad.
I think in jess and boa case is also influenced by their natural timbre so the nasality come naturally while on wendy we can clearly hear her tone when she speak but i could be wrong too
How would you analyze these 4th gen vocalists: Ningning - aespa Winter - aespa Monday - Weeekly Denise - Secret Number Bora - Cherry Bullet Haeyoon - Cherry Bullet Goeun - Purple Kiss Nayoung - Lightsum Chowon - Lightsum
@@YEOUN_channel Nayoung is Average and she’s a better technical vocalist than Haeyoon & Bora. Denise I think I wouldn’t give her B4 but I don’t know for sure haven’t checked enough.
@@zett1807 Does Nayoung improve or something,bcuz I rarely heard her singing😅 the last time i heard she sings she have problems such as throaty and too nasal. She also have inconsistencies I feel like putting Nayoung at top of weak to average instead of low average,bcuz she still have inconsistencies with her approach.
@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 Wendy is a whole tier higher ranked than in this video. Her vocals are A tier. Seulgi is C tier. Joy is D tier. Ain't no way Wendy a B+.
Hi! 😄 I just wanted to ask. Do you agree with this ranking? 1° Rosé 2° Miyeon 3° Yuqi 4° Jennie 5° Minnie 6° Jisoo 7° Soojin 8° Soyeon 9° Lisa 10° Shuhua First thing I want to say si that I'm conflicted about 2 placements. First is Miyeon and Yuqi. I heard that Yuqi has a better engagement, but is inconsistent while Miyeon is very little worse + is way more consistent. My second doubt is this ×Lisa x Soojin x Soyeon x Jisoo× placement. I heard many different opinions about Jisoo and that's why I'm very confused. I heard that she is around Lisa's level, but I personally disagree since even if she does have "the most problems" like throatiness, nasality and such things, I think that she has the best sense of technique and the best engagement among those 4 girls. She reminds me of Tzuyu of Twice. They're interchangeable for me.
Yup, I do. Miyeon above Yuqi seems good to be since she's less shallow too. I also don't see how some say Lisa>Jisoo. They're not even on the same level. Jisoo not having a proper technique is what made her regress and sound nasal and tense, but Lisa is by no means a vocalist. Her rapping technique helps her but no more than that.
@@mowom6616 I agree on the one with Jisoo! I saw someone saying she may be even below Lisa, but I disagree. She has issues, but she seems to have a "better technique" then Soyeon, Soojin or Lisa
how would you rank these western artists? 1) Rihanna 2) Lady Gaga 3) Selena Gomez 4) Miley Cyrus 5) Adele 6) Beyoncé 7) Halsey 8) Katy Perry 9) Dua Lipa 10) Ariana Grande 11) Demi Lovato 12) Mariah Carey 13) Christina Aguilera 14) Taylor Swift 15) Billie Eilish 16) Justin Bieber 17) Bruno Mars 18) Harry Styles 19) Ed Sheeran 20) Camila Cabello
Idk about the boys Mariah > Beyonce > Lady Gaga > Ariana >= Demi > Miley > Adele > Katy > Halsey = Camila >= Christina > Rihanna = Dua = Taylor > Selena > Billie
@@mowom6616 Miley should be higher, her lower range is a big boost and her mix is passable up to B4 I heard that she is a mezzo so its like a C#5 of a soprano, I would put Xtina higher than Hasley and Camila since she have better understanding and engagement of support despite the tension low in her mix, I think that its more like Katy>Adele if Katy really have somewhat developed Bb4-C5 area as I have been told, Mariah in her prime is the best here perhaps (not sure if its her or Bey) but she and Beyonce are not as good as they were in their prime now, I would place present Mariah below Gaga.
Hey! what tier would u put Kim Bora from Cherry Bullet in? Even tho I know nothing about vocals I think she's pretty amazing she can do whistle notes and This is my fab performance from her ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-6LfH4BJ6uQM.html
So in comparison to western artists she’s technically similar to ariana grande and demi lovato? i’ve seen some rank those 2 in the b tier like you with wendy so i’m curious on how the ranking match up
@@mowom6616 I assumed so, but i see so many people say that nobody in the kpop industry can sing better than ariana grande. What exactly do you think makes wendy better than both of them? I’m aware she doesn’t struggle with tongue tension as much as ariana but what else?
i saw coment on the other video, wendy slightly below kelly clarkson! (just by supported range/not counting the resonance quality) kelly : G3 - Eb5/E5 - G#5/A5 wendy : F#3/G3 - C#5/D5 - G#5/A5
@@fairy6245 wow so wendy is THAT good…and i see most people say she’s not better than Ariana. it’s always sounded off to me considering arianas lower register isn’t that great, meanwhile wendys registers are all decent
