Redeeming Knuckles - Analyzing What Sonic Frontiers Means for the Character of Knuckles the Echidna

Подписаться 12 тыс.

Просмотров 25 тыс.

50% 1

#knucklestheechidna #sonicfrontiers #sonicthehedgehog
You can support me on Patreon, follow me on Twitter, or join the channel Discord!
Patreon: / acecardgaming
Twitter: acecardgamingyt?l...
Discord: / discord
For a multitude of different reasons, Sonic Frontiers turned out to be a huge success! A more serious story, more ambitious game play, a renewed focus on the characters! But did this new focus work? Is the extended cast any more important by the end of Frontiers than they were by the end of Sonic Forces? Knuckles is one of the most well known characters in the Sonic the Hedgehog series, as well as one of its longest standing cast members! Becoming the original rival of Sonic the Hedgehog all the way back in 1994! Through the Death Egg saga, Perfect Chaos, the Ark incident with Shadow the Hedgehog, Neo Metal Sonic, The Time Eater, Infinite? Knuckles has been by Sonic's side through it all, but that last decade has been very tough for his character. So how does he fair in Sonic Frontiers? After such a long time of being either dumb, or completely inconsequential, is it even possible to redeem Knuckles the Echidna? There is a lot of rebuilding that needs to be done here to return our beloved Guardian to his former Glory! So let's analyze how Knuckles fit into the story of Sonic Frontiers, and how it might impact his character going forward! Ian Flynn has done a LOT of good for the IDW Sonic series, but does that transfer to his first time writing for the game series?
Don't forget to like and subscribe for more Sonic and general gaming content!
*Knuckles render was sourced at Sonic Channel!
sonic.sega.jp/SonicChannel/in...

Игры

Опубликовано:

30 июл 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 209

@BlueJGilbert Год назад

Knuckles needs a Metroidvania. His connection to the Chaos Emeralds gives him powers as he collects the emeralds one by one to take back Angel Island after being away for so long. Knuckles can lash himself about shirking his duties while also admitting the fun he had while he was away. His struggle to find a way to balance his duties while still enjoying life would make great drama.

@mayracordero382 Год назад

Knuckles is the best character and he's a great warrior and guardian of the master emerald!

@MrApex-xz2ge Год назад

This...PLEASE.

@MechaKnuckles Год назад

Tails got a Metroidvania and it was great.

@Canalbiruta Год назад

Uh more linear in the style of metroid 2, where you have to explore 7 inteconected zones looking for 1 emerald in each one? This sounds like an interesting game. Maybe adventure 1 power ups working like metroidvania style power ups aswell.

@_Tzer Год назад

@@MechaKnuckles yeah tails adventure was very interesting.

@Montymole_360 Год назад

I'm honestly not expecting any spin off games, but I'd love it if they did. Frontiers sets them up perfectly, with everybody wanting to go do their own thing after this adventure. And having character specific spin offs would be an ideal way to fully develop gameplay styles for each of them, without having to assign development time to anything else, so they'll actually be properly considered & fleshed out. From that point on, they'd have a base to work with to more easily integrate them into a mainline game without them feeling like half arsed secondary campaigns, like they have previously. Plus you can't tell me Knuckles doesn't just make perfect sense for an exploration based collectathon style game! Quite honestly, he fits the genre far more than Sonic himself does!

@ScorbunGame Год назад

Tails- Action JRPG style game Knuckles- Character action game Amy- Either a Tomb Raider style game or a more Mario esk 3D platformer

@rickyrackey7930 Год назад

I would personally like a noir-styled Shadow the Hedgehog game.

@yoshimasterleader Год назад

@@ScorbunGame For Tails I would love a 3D metroidvania game. Would work well for his knack for gadgets.

@lorddane4147 5 месяцев назад

@@rickyrackey7930 Not a bad idea. Especially if they pair Shadow with Team Chaotix given they are detectives.

@ChaosBloodNinja Год назад

When Knuckles was freed from Cyber Space and said it was like a nightmare it made me think "Well this just makes things worse for Tails who's still trapped" only for him to not seem all that fazed by it when you get to Chaos Island. But as you say considering Cyber Space was based on the individuals' memories, Knuckles experience might have been the worst of the bunch for that reason. It reminded me of how Generations started with Tails talking about what a terrifying experience being frozen by the Time Eater was but everyone else seems relatively fine when they're freed.

@Canalbiruta Год назад

I also like that tails' experience in the cyberspace was basically having to face the person he became and remember how badass he once was. I like that when we free him, he's firstly fine but slowly starts to crumble in self doubt till we get to the iconic "am i a burden to you?" scene. I know how it feels to be in a turmoil while trying to not appear like it, and tails in frontiers definitely felt that way.

@ChaosBloodNinja Год назад

@@Canalbiruta I'm replaying Chaos Island now and seeing Tails talk about getting confronted by another him makes me very hopeful for when the new playable characters content drops because it sounds like such a good sequence to get to experience firsthand as Tails.

@SlashCraftJack Год назад

In Sonic X's (Subbed) Shadow had to take off his limiters just to *barely* defeat him in an episode of Season 3. It was downright criminal that the dub version cut out the part about the limiters.

@KingGoji54 Год назад

Wait, so is knuckles stronger than shadow?

@teamdarkfan317 Год назад

@@KingGoji54 no in sonic x he is SLIGHTLY stronger than knuckles as he, ya know won

@KingGoji54 Год назад

@@teamdarkfan317 Its cool that knuckles is *basically* as strong as Shadow, cuz Knuckles is really underrated

@Abner-gu3ve 2 месяца назад

@@KingGoji54Knuckles is not as strong as Shadow apart from physical strength. Let’s not get ahead of ourselves. It Shadow took his rings off more often, he’d demolish most characters, Knuckles included

@Theunholyborn Месяц назад

@@Abner-gu3veLet's not sell Him short either, remember the limiters also keep Shadow from just imploding. He's the result of science and genetic engineering. Knuckles is just raw strength and without ever using chaos Emeralds has taken down people. And hit Sonic OUT of Super form. Not to mention there was like a comic run where some evil force got ahold of his body and used it to take down most of the cast and a comic cover was literally just soulless bodies and a deformed Knuckles looming in front of them.

@KnucklesTheEchidna. Год назад

The only reason why they said only hedgehogs can go "Super" is because they knew if I went Super then the story would have been over and done with in the Fronters prologue. The Titans wouldn't have been able to survive past me. Straight body bags. 💪🏾🤨💪🏾

@aquariaredgrave2087 Год назад

8:30 I do remember Sage saying: "He should know what the Kocos are, why is he helping them?" I'm not sure if she said this on Ares Island but if she were talking about Knuckles that would make so much sense now to me :D Awesome Job btw! You drew my attention to certain aspects and stuff I didn't realize until now :D

@wuba5456 Год назад

Let's go! I feel like Knuckles has been done good lately honestly. Hoping Shadow gets the same treatment but trying to enjoy what we do have for now haha

@edikanessien8602 Год назад

Since Knuckles got the same treatment let’s hope Shadow gets the same in frontiers and live action shows and movies. Prime own is different because it is a damn video game and knuckles voice in prime if I show you,You will not want to watch Sonic prime and Shadow’s voice is knuckles voice not the voice for Shadow we were expecting

@emmeownelan2076 Год назад

It all depends if Iizuka lets him do what he does best. If Ian's got full creative freedom with the characters, I trust even Shadow will be a great character again. If Iizuka and his mandates are in play, then I'm expecting more meta era shitty writing

@winterv.4715 Год назад

@@emmeownelan2076 this looks to be the case. Prime Season 2 Ep 1’s shadow made me remember why he was my favourite as a kid. Hope to see this type of writing translate in future games and ESPECIALLY the idw comics

@Mr.Ahmad285 8 месяцев назад

@@edikanessien8602 shadow is not in frontiers, you think shadow must be in all game to made a masterpiece.

@DewMan31 Год назад

I think like how the knuckles short foreshadows the fact that the Chao are descended from the Coco by having a Chao trying to grab a Coco face from rubble. Something many of us probably didn't think much about. Idk.

@adelarodrigue3721 Год назад

Knuckles will always be my favorite character and best character too un my heart

@gregtom3272 Год назад

also i did not just enjoy knuckles characterisation in sonic frontiers , i was glad that they treated the way they did in this game which regardless of missed opportunities , it respected what his character supposed to be , given that i watched the second movie and enjoyed it and his characterisation , so the game had a lot to prove to continue this momentum

@liamphibia Год назад

"Do you think Knuckles will get his own spin-off?" To answer your question, Mark... YES! I mean, the red echidna is gonna get his own *TV* series on Paramount+ coming this year with Idris Elba reprising.

@AceCardGaming Год назад

Can’t wait for that! But imagine a game too 😉

@christopherford39 Год назад

Oh yeah, I have been so caught up with Frontiers I forgot Knuckles was getting a TV series

@thedawgduane3294 Год назад

Gonna go on a bit of a tangent here, but I really appreciate passionate fans like you Mark. People like you always reassure me that there are genuine fans out there who care about the well being of the Sonic franchise. And I dare even say, get inspired to make up my own stories with the characters as well as artwork! Never let go of that optimism Mark. After all, we Sonic fans gotta stick together!

@kingkirby1394 Год назад

Ngl I actually am content calling this new era: The movie era as some people have been calling it because ever since the first sonic movie, sega really has been regaining confidence with the brand outside of the comics and I couldn’t be happier

@Icepiq72 Год назад

When I played the game, I noticed the theme of every character trying an adventure on their own and I knew Flynn was setting up for these guys to get their own games. I hope the friend group sticks around through those games though because it wouldn’t feel complete with the full dynamic. Really excited for Sega’s future!

@rickyrackey7930 Год назад

My idea for the games Amy goes on an adventure with Cream and Sticks to spread love and passion around the world Knuckles travels to exotic and ancient locations that have more detail about his history while Sonic guards the Master Emerald for him Tails takes on a powerful villain without the help of Sonic and achieves a Super form in the final battle.

@Icepiq72 Год назад

@@rickyrackey7930 SEGA would never let Tails have a super form but we can only dream

@rickyrackey7930 Год назад

@@Icepiq72 Doesn’t Tails’ story sound like SSJ2 Gohan?

@Icepiq72 Год назад

@@rickyrackey7930 I have no idea what you just said

@rickyrackey7930 Год назад

@@Icepiq72 It’s something from Dragon Ball Z.

@lightningbolt4481 Год назад

Frontiers really helped bring back a lot of character to the main classic cast. I do hope at least, they do the same with the adventure to 06 characters.

@someoneyoudontknow3257 Год назад

No Sonic story is perfect, but this is the best we've had in so long. It's like the meta era never happened and the characterisation started in Sonic Adventure never ended and these characters just kept growing and I love it.

@justinalicea1590 Год назад

It was so good that I honestly thought Sonic Frontiers was going to be placed as a post Adventure game on the timeline, though that was answered when modern villains were mentioned.

@KazShiro Год назад

@@justinalicea1590 With that placement later than generations it makes the meta Era feel like filler in comparison

@mayracordero382 Год назад

I love knuckles and he's one of the best characters and this is the best video about him plus I'm excited to hear idris elba as knuckles again in the live-action spin-off series!

@PetrolHeadMotorsport Год назад

I'd think it would be nice if Knuckles were the leader of a group for a change (either the Chaotix, Bean, Bark and Knack, or maybe even Tangle and Whisper) what the gameplay might look like, idk, but it would be nice if there were times in the game where it built the universe or some of the groundwork for it, while also delving into the individual backstories or story building for Knuckles and his travel companions.

@53Spawn Год назад

The last time we got direct Knux focus was Dark Brotherhood. Love to see him getting more of an emotional highlight in Frontiers.

@foxoninetails_ Год назад

There's a lot about how this series has progressed over time that I thought I wanted them to just throw away. Retcon the nonsense out, start fresh with a soft reboot, and pretend the Colors era never happened... especially Forces. But Frontiers managed to change my mind. Flynn treated these characters with so much respect for their history, and rather than simply throw away the past 13 years in favor of a better story the easy way, he chose to work with what he was given and actually redeem it instead of discarding it. Seeing Tails acknowledge how dependent and cowardly he'd become and start to heal, seeing Amy actually exist outside of obsessing over Sonic, and especially seeing Knuckles finally be stoic instead of stupid again... it makes me feel like the series' dark ages were worth it. I'll probably never like most of that era's storytelling, but Frontiers showed me that it doesn't have to be ignored for the series to return to form.

@rickyrackey7930 Год назад

What if Sonic became more jokey and comedic because he is scared of showing weakness to his friends.

@superthorc6894 Год назад

He’s tougher than the rest The best Tougher than leather

@pokeli2728 6 месяцев назад

3:55 We know knuckles wasn't playable in Frontiers. *The Final Horizon has entered the chat*

@DragonStar524 3 месяца назад

Im so glad Ian Flynn wrote the script for Sonic Frontiers. He gets all these charcaters. And he GETS. THEM. RIGHT.

@spartanq7781 Год назад

Despite not doing anything tangible Knuckles and Tails were saved by Frontiers. Ian should have been gotten hired as the writer. He already vastly improved the writing quality. It helps that gameplay wise Frontiers is really good as well.

@Gum_underthe_desk Год назад

If knuckles got a spin off, i'd want it to be a Free Roam Beat Em Up/Treasure Hunting platformer. Make Knuckles a Fierce Warrior and Treasure Hunter like in the Sonic Film from 1998.

@smokywreck Год назад

I liked Sonic Forces because I was hopeful to seeing Knuckles as a leader. I'm from the sonic adventure era and believed that they characterised him well. Only to see Knuckles be a background drop with Amy doing most of the things. I'm glad Sonic Frontier took the time to make each area about each characters and their relationship with Sonic. It really helped deeper flesh them and the kind of interractions they have. See better what they values are and how they deal with their thoughts. I just hope they keep those characterisation as I really liked how they fleshed them, brought back some past characterisation and kept it in a way that new and old fan can recognise the character.

@finestcacophony9296 Год назад

Loved everything about knuckles The amazing course correction knuckles got has given me hope for Shadow

@MarzOnline92 Год назад

I've said this many times over the years and on other channel's comment sections. We need a Knuckles the Echidna spin-off game. The gameplay mechanics can be a mixture of his treasure-hunting gameplay from SA 1 & 2 with action/adventure style combat & free-roaming. It'll have an Indiana Jones feel to it. The story would be a prequel taking place sometime after the events of SA1. Knuckles meets Rogue the Bat for the first time as one of the main antagonists trying to take the master emerald as well as a brand new gang of bandits doing so separately. While Rogue Knuckles, and the bandits fight over the emerald, the fight causes the emerald to shatter into pieces and and the pieces scatter all around the Island. Knuckles has to find all the pieces before either Rogue or the Bandits do. During the search, Knuckles will have to fend off Bandit members, Rogue herself as well as other creatures native to the island. Maybe the emerald shards caused some of the little critters to mutate into bigger beasts and go on a rampage. Maybe The bandits Knuckles beats up drops gear that he wears in order to help him further along in the game. Maybe one of items dropped is a familiar-looking safari hat and Knuckles wears for the rest of the game. I think that would be a fantastic concept for a Knuckles solo game. Any thoughts from you on this concept?

@_Tzer Год назад

if the twitter takeover is anything to go by Shadow is back. Judging from the fact that sonic was calmer more like his adventure self during not as interruptive adhd random. Shadow was also more calmer less like when he had an identity crisis during his own game more calm collected like during 06. The characterization during the takeover seems to imply as such anyways.

@realsalu634 Год назад

The 2 things i want are the other secondary characters (Shadow,Silver, Rouge, Blaze) given some attention in game, and Sonic being given actual emotions

@AceCardGaming Год назад

All of those need to return! At least Sonic has some more emotional range in Frontiers. Beats the hell out of his 10 years of jokey goofball.

@realsalu634 Год назад

@@AceCardGaming Yes, the weird thing is that even in the comics, Sonic can cry and feel sad, just in game he can't

@edikanessien8602 Год назад

I will like to see those characters whether in frontiers dlc or Sonic frontiers 2

@bowserbreaker2515 Год назад

@@realsalu634 When? That story with Mecha Sonic weren't actually Sonic's tears.

@crimsonzone8984 Год назад

I'm down for sonic crying out of fear from bodies of water or when being forced into slow things. Just not out of grief, or that would be out of character for him. I want shadow to play the important role of facing off against hidden antagonists like in 06 and rivals. Omega would fit well in frontiers. Especially with the combat, then it would really be like DMC or any teen rating combat game. I'm not sure about rouge, though. Doing treasure hunting and spy missions are good enough. I also think that rouge's strength should be compared to knuckles in a way as how batman is comparable to superman. I just don't buy rouge being as strong as knuckles. I would prefer Blaze to only be included in the sonic rush games, and not be in sonic's dimension like she belongs in it. She's the sonic of her dimension. That royal fire cat needs more world building and more characters like marine. The same would go for silver. But unlike blaze, silver actually lives in sonic's dimension and he would just be called out via time capsule or anything that would cause him to travel to sonic's timeline. But he needs to show much impact when he's in the present. And he should not be nerfed. Silver can just be weak to darkness, but that's it. If silver feels too overpowered then he should just remain in his timeline with people or foes that are just as OP as him.

@one2many370 Год назад

I have listened to several people discuss Knuckles' depiction in this game, and surprisingly, you're the very first I've heard discuss how odd (and mildly hypocritical) it is for him to claim Sonic is "too trusting." Especially on how it represents growth in his character. Good on you for that.

@ElsanneJ Год назад

Your pure appreciation for Knuckles made me sub. Good analysis. There's just something about that charcater trope of an "honourable, badass, stoic warrior" who's a bit a dork with a a pinch of that "fish-out-of-water" cluelessness/naivete. It's a delight that he's now on his character writing redemption arc, and it'll be crazy to think what future games will do with the set-up gotten from Frontiers. (Now he's _officially_ allowed to leave M.E. and go do some stuff on his own without seeming out of character.) Meanwhile we've got the upcoming liveaction series so Knuckles fans will be eating. :)

@exar5262 2 месяца назад

as a Knuckles fan, i'm really relieved to see how Knuckles was written in Sonic Frontiers, and i can confidently say that is one of the many reasons it's my favorite recent sonic game. i do hope Knuckles gets his own spin-off game, too! actually i hope Tails and Amy do as well. the ending of Frontiers would be the perfect set-up for it. one of the top comments have said it better than i can say without committing plagiarism. honestly ever since the 2nd Sonic Movie, the team's writers have been treating Knuckles with all the respect he deserves after so long and finally tossing Boom Knuckles to the side to bring our old non-chuckler back!! i really hope it keeps going this direction, as it seems to be with Sonic Frontiers and also TailsTube.

@TheBlur182 Год назад

You're my favorite channel ever. Great video. You're speaking words out of my brain. Are you my brother ?

@AceCardGaming Год назад

Maybe!

@smileyface81mc77 Год назад

What an awesome video!! Eggman and Knux got video essays, so you plan on doing one for Amy and Tails, too? Maybe the hedgehog himself? Eh, whatever you do, I love this new positive outlook on the series, and I’m so glad Frontiers could give that to you.

@AceCardGaming Год назад

Definitely more of this type of video on the way! 😁

@rickyrackey7930 Год назад

@@AceCardGaming Can you imagine if Tails unlocks his super form to beat a villain Sonic himself can’t beat. This would literally be SSJ2 Gohan levels of epic.

@AceCardGaming Год назад

Dude, you could sell me any scenario if you compare it to Gohan! 😅

@gustavolobo2001 Год назад

Man, I hope the DLC makes him justice, this is a big step up in characterization.

@sharax777 Год назад

Fantastic video and analysis as usual! So glad Knuckles got treated right at last! Looking forward to your next vid!

@TJAdkirson Год назад

I was definitely a fan of Knuckles characterization in Frontiers. The bro moments had me worried about the shippers, as I felt they'd read into it. I really enjoyed that they made him into a history buff in the game. Makes me want to see him pursue archeology. A lot of people already view him as a treasure hunter, and that wouldn't be too far from it. Perhaps they could even give him his Cowboy hat for a spinoff. I really think he'd fit in a beat'em'up 3D platformer.

@Fluorite-Fox Год назад

I burst out laughing the first time I saw sonic making sassy faces at Knuckles and both of them grinning in a goofy way🤣

@AceCardGaming Год назад

Same 😅

@numetalOverlord Год назад

Always a joy to see you in my recommended

@favourobot66 11 месяцев назад

I ENJOY IT [...and the video]. I finally got to see the Echidna himself Thanks

@_knucklehead Год назад

This analysis is amazing! I didn’t even look that deep into Knuckles telling Sonic that “he was too trusting.” It genuinely shows his development in Sonic Frontiers. Seriously excited for the DLC!

@AceCardGaming Год назад

Glad you enjoyed it! Bring on the DLC! I just hope it’s got some depth to it. 🙂

@_knucklehead Год назад

@@AceCardGaming Same here! Keep rocking, dude!

@spencerevans7915 Год назад

@@AceCardGaming and as I u understand that you wished Knuckles was playable, you'll definitely get your wish from the DLC and of course see even more character depth done right for Knuckles.

@AceCardGaming Год назад

Let’s hope so!

@edikanessien8602 Год назад

I’m excited for the knuckles dlc playable in frontiers hoping after frontiers where knuckles said it will be a good time to get back to my island at least for a while.we could see knuckles doing his own thing

@DragonStar524 Год назад

It's actually a breath of fresh air to see the stoic, compassionate and introspective, bruiser Knuckles we were introduced to so long ago.

@michaeleverett1376 11 месяцев назад

I can't wait to see how his combat will work in update 3.

@CoolBeanSoup Год назад

It would be cool to see Knuckles, Tails, and Amy being in there own spin-off games. I know Knuckles and Tails have had they're own spin-off games, except for Amy. Speaking of these characters, Sega did confirmed DLC for Sonic Frontiers. First one adding music and photo mode, 2nd DLC adding something for Sonic's birthday and some new Koco and new challenges, and in the 3rd DLC Knuckles, Tails, and Amy will be playable! Plus, a new story as well. My guess is that this new story will probably focus on these characters while they were stuck in cyberspace. Or something. Whatever it is, I'm looking forward to playing these characters. :)

@adelarodrigue3721 Год назад

Me too knuckles been my favorite for a long time deserved his respect and hugs and cuddle and cookies and grape he is awesome and badass and it is not his fault he been trick by eggman since he been on angel Island for a long time with nobody with him no friends no family no one just guardian the master emerald or I wish people can stop criticize call him stupid and dumb and native he isn't any of that he is smart as well. And beside it is the writers fault who made him dumb and the butt of the joke in the first place they should made his characteristics better but no I am happy he getting the respect and redemption he deserves and I am happy they are still knuckles fans out th3y the love they red echidna that we know in love in our hearts.

@CozyOrSomething Год назад

14:34 *"Only male hedgehogs can go Super, MY ASS."* -Literally Everyone

@BreetonBoi Год назад

Really enjoyed this! Love to see that Knuckles is finally back

@justinalicea1590 Год назад

Hopefully the success of this video and the Eggman video will encourage you to do the rest of the cast as well! Amy might be weakest of the remaining three, as I'm including Sonic as well due to his greater maturity for this game, but at least Tails deserves a video as well, given that he himself calls out his own inconsistency.

@AceCardGaming Год назад

I’m hoping to cover everyone. Just a matter of time! 🙂

@lala-jd6em Год назад

We’ll be waiting 😂 I’m super excited for the Amy one!

@crimsonzone8984 Год назад

@@lala-jd6emso did you know? Amy used to be capable of supernatural abilities like inflicting curses, invisibility, predicting faith and where a certain person is. Her pico pico hammer was even stated to be magical in sonic the fighters, and that's the game where that hammer originated. Nowadays, she just seemed as physically capable as knuckles and hardly shows anything paranormal or magical in sonic prime or in idw. It would great if amy gets to use those abilities again in the frontiers dlc.

@Nobodyshere1105 4 месяца назад

Is it okay for me to hope these characters will have their own games with side characters we haven't seen in a while?

@szkraft220 Год назад

GOOD VIDEOOOOOOOOO GOOD VIDEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO you dont dissapoint!!!! The onyl thing that you prolly got wrong is that this isnt a TONE setter for the future of the series as everything else, sure, the stories will aim to take themselves more seriously, but the mellow tone is specific to THIS game i am PRETTY sure which im excited about cuz i wanna see them in game form on an exciting adventure, i wanna see more of amy's peppyness in a game!! aah! is gonna be good

@FirestoneAnimation 10 месяцев назад

Knux going from a naive warrior to a dumb*ss to a more grounded warrior who actually learned from his past was something that made me wonder if I was dreaming or not. Knowing it was legit, I felt happy. I honestly do hope we get spinoffs of each character.

@Ponch126 Год назад

Compared to everything from 2010-2017 (I mean that as 2017 was the last time a mainline series Sonic game was released) the story for Frontiers was far more heavily focused on than that of previous games that had either little, to quite literally none (Looking at you Generations). The game set out to prove itself that Sonic team (if given enough time) can properly write a story with those who genuinely have passion for the franchise, and not those who have only learned about it through Wikipedia.

@lofthestars2088 Год назад

Ares Island was my favevourit Also I am so sad/mad that the IDW Comics are not available in Germany.

@AceCardGaming Год назад

I import them in Ireland. So few book/comic shops here now that I have no choice. 😔

@maas1208 Год назад

@@AceCardGaming You can get them digitally

@AceCardGaming Год назад

Yeah, that’s how I’ve been reading them so far. But I always like to own a physical copy of stuff.

@sadie4230 Год назад

I love Knuckles so much and how he’s been treated recently makes me so happy ❤️❤️

@madengineerkyouma Год назад

Knuckles the Chuckler

@lks19 Год назад

and there're people who still rejected Ian trying to fix the characters. I think I'll never fully understand the Sonic fandom.

@gregtom3272 Год назад

you know , i wonder some times why people felt upset regarding knuckles in the boom era regarding how he was portrayed in the tv show , like i get how any one feel that way regarding the character in the rise of lyric game , but come on , i always thought that this is a tv show , so it's not like the character got ruined just because they do him dirty in some thing out side the games , and it's really some thing that can not do ANY THING TO the character perception in the eyes of fans , yes the games did not help any way but eventually we got frontiers and it was worth the wait

@justinc.5591 Год назад

0:35 I definitely misread that dialogue from Knuckles at first. 😂

@RossPetersMusic Год назад

I was really glad to see what they did with Knuckles in Frontiers. That and Sonic Movie 2 actually redeemed him for me. The way he acted from the ending of Forces right up to the end of the Metal Virus saga left a really bad taste in my mouth about Knuckles. The way that when the Resistance was over and became the Restoration he just up and left, then all but refused to help during the Metal Virus outbreak until he pretty much had no choice too, and even then he wasn't happy about it. Frontiers gave me hope for Knuckles again, something I've been waiting to have for a long time now. 🙂

@michelledust5787 Год назад

Great Analysis!!! I'm so happy to see Knuckles make his long awaited come back! Sonic Frontiers wasn't perfect but at least it actually tried with it's characters.

@olsendesravines5657 Год назад

6:28 if sonic is a founding member than Steven from Steven universe is the CEO

@AceCardGaming Год назад

I hear Goku is in HR… 😉

@BlackFlash09 Год назад

I would love spin-off games for each of Sonic's friends in Frontiers. And I look forward to the DLC where they will be playable.

@rickyrackey7930 Год назад

Shadow deserves a second chance in a solo game. Maybe a Noir styled Team Dark Game.

@havenisthebest99 Год назад

Since I first got into Sonic back during the late dark ages, the original trio(Sonic, Tails and Knuckles), were always the bestest of friends in my eyes. When I learned about the Classic games during my elementary school years, I was intrigued and curious about the deeper lore that took place before the events of the Classic games. Frontiers was the game that finally got the Sonic fanbase in agreement with a good game for the first time since 2011 and while it has it’s issues, this is the first time since Black Knight where there was a Sonic I didn’t want to climb into the tv and strangle the daylights out of. The Meta Era in my opinion is the true dark age of the series as it’s filled with missed potential, sidelining of popular characters, terrible story, terrible dialogue, cookie cutter at best gameplay and just a glorious amount of fear at failure following 06.

@_Tzer Год назад

Not playable in frontiers yet. Forces had UGH episode shadow this does mean there is potential for dlc focusing on side characters.

@_Tzer Год назад

I don't remember anything about chronicles but i do remember something being knuckles related in it. And the fact that it recanonized super knuckles after that whole 06 and heroes debacle with frontiers doubling down saying hey super knuckles still can be a thing.

@adelarodrigue3721 Год назад

Knuckles is awesome and badass And epic and cooler is my favorite character and best character

@kaplooeygames8515 Год назад

One scene that stood out was one of the "Extra Story" bits where Knuckles talks about ancient architecture (or something, I don't remember exactly). Just that he...knows stuff. He's not dumb, he has knowledge, not on everything, but he knows what he knows and doesn't know nothing. This comment makes no sense

@AceCardGaming Год назад

No, I get it. I referenced the scene you mentioned in the video. 🙂

@UltimateTS64 Год назад

Me when the dlc with all the characters and extra story wasn't mentioned 😭. But on a serious note, great video as always

@AceCardGaming Год назад

I understand there will be DLC with more playable characters, but we don’t know how in depth they will be or what they will involve yet. And they still weren’t part of the base experience. Glad you enjoyed the video though. 🙂

@UltimateTS64 Год назад

@@AceCardGaming true, I guess I was just expecting a breif mention of it, kinda like what you said, something around the lines of we don't know what's in store, but at least having him be playable is a step in the right direction. It's not a huge deal, just where my mind was at

@JohnTK Год назад

I swear to god if the IDW writing crew doesn't come back to write the next game in the franchise I'm gonna loose it.

@adelarodrigue3721 Год назад

Knuckles Deserves respect andhe is best character i can wish to see more ships for knuckles and maybe a knuckles harem store's too

@saloz9483 Год назад

My favorite character is knuckles and I'm happy he was done so much better in frontiers. No longer a super idiot.

@FierySDY2023 Год назад

Frontiers was EPIC overall Ares Island with Knuckles was easily the best because of knuckles going back to how he used to be before boom and it just felt too short because it was that good please sega, bring back this brochem and knuckles back 🥹

@God-xd1wr Год назад

You can tell who in the fandom doesn’t have a brother when they call Sonic and Knuckles gay.

@AegixDrakan Год назад

You know, I really liked most of the "Meta era" games (Not Forces, though) and found them to be better than the Dreamcast era... *BUT* I fully agree with you that Knuckles has been done dirty ever since Sonic Rush turned him into "Am Angry! Must! Punch! ROCKS!!!" and I'm glad he's gotten a fair shake for the first time in over a decade. It's good to have him back again. :D

@lukeevans2717 Год назад

Now the big question will be can they fix shadow and have team dark potentially be a bigger part in the future but it makes me think after that game to be hopeful especially with someone who knows sonic games in charge

@ApexPredator1000 Год назад

A Knuckles spin-off game, for me, would need to focus on fast-paced brawls (akin to the prologue animation) with lots of combos, chaos powers, and environmental destruction. But also lots of exploration and puzzle solving in the context of exploring archaeological sites. Appearances and team-ups of other members of the cast in a similar manner to Shadow's game, but more meaningful interactions would be good too. And of course it's the perfect opportunity to reintroduce Super Knuckles. I would definitely like non-Eggman villains though - a shame SEGA can't use Enerjak or Dr Finitevus, as those were some of the best concepts to come out of the archie comics... Either way, the franchise could really use more recurring villains - another aspect of the comics I loved. A Knuckles game series would be brilliant for wider lore building in the franchise. Although there's a lot of other spinoffs I'd like to see too (Detective Adventure Chaotix game, Rift Apart Styled Silver & Blaze game with the return of Eggman NEGA as antagonist, and another Shadow the Hedgehog or team dark attempt with hopes they'll finally return to greatness!)

@rickyrackey7930 Год назад

My idea for the story is that Knuckles fulfills his dream of traveling the world while Sonic volunteers to guard the Master Emerald for him. He battles various new bandits including Mecha Knuckles MK 2. Sense Mecha Sonic from S3&K is built for brute force rather than speed, Mecha Knuckles’ strength will be insane.

@mattsplain Год назад

I'm excited that he's gonna be playable in the DLC

@jacobandreas5912 Год назад

I honestly feel a good way they could do a spin off game for knuckles would be something like the ps4 Spider man Series. Where he mostly goes on little adventures, helping people out, etc. The big man's out and hopefully going to see the world that he's missed out on for a plethora of years now. Yes, there could also be times where he has to go back to Angel Island, but I'd hope they plan it where it doesn't feel like it's crammed in there.

@ClashBluelight Год назад

There were actually two S3&K references in the Super Sonic cutscene with Knuckles. He references his super form, and Super Sonic flinches away from Knuckles' punch. That's a reference to the fact that Knuckles is the only guy capable of hurting Super Sonic without the use of the emeralds or something similarly powerful.

@sometf2player752 Год назад

12:44 for now yes but he along with tails and Amy will be playable in frontiers soon

@phantomJ67 Год назад

Goku is CEO of Every Enemy Is A Potential Friend INC.

@crimsonzone8984 Год назад

I hope knuckles plays well in the frontiers dlc. Make him(base form) fight enemies that are atleast near the level of the titan bosses.

@ScorbunGame Год назад

I would say that isolating the characters in Cyberspace was the writers way of forcing themselves to ask a key question, "if given time for introspection, what answers would these characters come to with Sonic's help?" Amy realizes she wants to spread as much love as she can in the world. Knuckles sees just how much his duty has left him isolated from the world and how deep down he never really wanted the life that was forced on him. Tails sees how much of his potential is being wasted due to clinging on Sonic for protection. All of them now have the resolve to break their own stagnation because they were put into a situation where they had no choice but to reflect on themselves.

@zozo2354 Год назад

Just a heads up apparently the roadmap frontiers is going to add playable knuckles and tails, and I think Amy but don't quote me on that

@AceCardGaming Год назад

Yeah, I’m looking forward to it. It’s just a shame the game was so pushed for time that this wasn’t part of the base experience.

@zozo2354 Год назад

@@AceCardGamingthe curse of all sonic games tbh

@dkins8 Год назад

I’d love to see a knuckles prequel spin off but maybe that’s just me

@inversewheel3558 Год назад

Knuckles is confirmed to be playable in fronteirs as a dlc in late 2023 and I can’t wait to see where they go with him in it

@Alejandro333777 Год назад

10:12 facts 😊

@DLxxx Год назад

5:13 Yeah, that's a pretty forgivable excuse for the terrible facial animation, lol. You can tell they were trying (which is good), but man, was Sonic Team out of practice 😆

@RosheenQuynh Год назад

I kinda want a treasure hunting/beat 'em up game for Knux. That's all I can think of, or I'm just too tired to think of something else 😅

@rickyrackey7930 Год назад

My idea of the story follows Knuckles traveling the world while Sonic volunteers to guard the Master Emerald while he’s gone.

@RosheenQuynh Год назад

@@rickyrackey7930 I don't know if Sonic could stand in one spot that long 🤔

@rickyrackey7930 Год назад

@@RosheenQuynh That would be interesting to se though. Someone as free as the wind doing an important strict task for a couple days.

@RosheenQuynh Год назад

@@rickyrackey7930 I guess. I feel like he'd lose his mind. What would he do to suppress the inner turmoil?

@rickyrackey7930 Год назад

@@RosheenQuynh I can imagine the ending following Knuckles returning back to the island and seeing Sonic in a miserable and grumpy state for being introverted for a couple days. It would be a funny ending.

@johanstenfelt1206 Год назад

Hm, how very interesting, it’s good that Knuckles’ Character is finally put back to a good direction, let’s just hope that SEGA follows-up upon it. Honestly, it’s going to be interesting regardless to see where these Characters and the Franchise are going to go now after Frontiers, I hope they doesn’t screw it up again. By the way, have you heard that Knuckles and the other Cyber Prisoners are apparently going to be playable in a DLC?

@AceCardGaming Год назад

I did hear that! I of course hope there will be some story depth in their DLCs but I won’t take that for granted.

@johanstenfelt1206 Год назад

@@AceCardGaming I can see what you mean, i would like that too, I guess we’ll see if they can stay consistent with the quality.

@gleamingroses2952 Год назад

Knuckles has been restored to his former glory and can't wait to see how the DLC treats him. I like what Frontiers did with Knuckles, Tails and Eggman. They were easily the highlights in terms of characterization, Knuckles was my favorite by far. I just wish the same could be said for my favorite character. lol

@Less_human72 Год назад

i never understood why they take the super form from the others characters, they want more games and toys to sell so why not give diferent colors (because super form OBLY)

@johntee9691 Год назад

My problem with frontiers' story is that the cutscenes are muscularly short. The scene of him and Sonic talking about his future is like, 30 seconds long so it feels kinda out of nowhere, unlike Tails in Chaos where the whole thing is about his insecurities, Knux only opens up about needing to go out and live at the very end of Ares. I still love the new direction for him and the rest of the cast as it finally presents a change in the status quo, but I think that for him, it could've been a little better paced.

@33pandagamer Год назад

I have waited so long for them to bring good story telling back. I really hope this game was not a fluke.

@misterniceguy429 Год назад

Do you think Shade would have been a good companion for Knuckles. He could have had some company while he’s guarding the Master Emerald. If only Shade, Emperor Ix, the Nocturnus Clan, and Sonic Chronicles as a whole wasn’t erased from the Sonic universe.

@funnature8679 Год назад

I think knuckles guarding the master emerald is entrusted by the sentient being who cares about it and what it protects.

@XX-sp3tt Год назад

10:08 Screw Ken Penders for retconning Shade out of existence.

@SorceressRose Год назад

Honestly? Sonic Free Riders to Sonic Forces is where we really see the worst of writing the Sonic series has had for years. While Sonic Boom gave him an entirely new character, he was more of brawn over brains character for comedic effect, which was a big stray from how he was originally best portrayed. I never seen Knuckles as dumb. Yeah, he was gullible, what did you expect from a character that had barely any outside contact until he met Eggman. Frontiers was the best back to form of writing we had for him and I love it!