Refutation upon Abu Taymiyyah Al-Jeylani on the matter of voting! | Shaykh Muqbil Bin Hādī Al-Wadi’i 

Abu Taymiyyah conveys the opinions of major scholars regarding this issue, it’s fine to disagree and take the position of Shayhk Muqbil May Allah have mercy on him. However to make the picture of any person place a X on it saying that Shayhk Muqbil is refuting him when in reality this is a refutation is of an opinion and not a person, makes it clear you have more of an issue with Abu Taymiyyah then the opinion conveyed. If you have an issue with the brother, it is from his rights you speak to him and reach out to him and hear him out Publicly posting a video showing his face crossed out is taking away from his honour which you will be asked about on the day of judgment. I don’t know your intentions as that is for Allah and yourself to know but your actions seem far genuine.

May Allah reward brother Abu taymiyah, so much khair from him

So where was the refutation on Abu taymiyyah? He just conveyed the fatawaa of the ulema if you are so bold write on ur title "refutation on ibn baz and ibn uthaymeen" Ok we respect sh muqbils opinion but this doesn't mean we disregard the ulema with their ijtihadaat رحمهم الله

Why do you add 'Shaykh' in quotations, for Shaykh Ibn jebreen and Barrak.

Jazakoum Allahou khayran

Sheikh Al Albani sheikh Wasiullah sheikh Abdul muhsin al abbad and many other scholars stated this is permissible for lesser of the 2 evils. Whilst I’m More inclined that it’s haram you can’t just refute Abu Taymiyyah (not that I Take from him) based on this.

It’s odd how you make this video as if it’s a refutation of Abu Taymiyyah when the ulamaa have stated this, if you wanted to state the opinion you believe is correct don’t single out Abu Taymiyyah rather make general video about this opinion.

This has nothing to do with Abu Taymiyah even though he’s on a dodgy path. STOP TRYING TO SEEK CLOUT.

Good point from sheikh muqbil to be honest Its rare tho to see mistakes from the 3 big sheikhs of before wow

In india the lok sabha elections 2024 jamiat ahle hadees hind had also permitted muslims to vote

Just a beneficial reminder to those looking at the comments - blind following any scholar is Haram, we only follow opinions which are in accordance with the evidences, no matter how big the scholar is

Just a question, as you are refuting ustad Abu Taymiyyah, have you reached out to him to advise him maybe in private so perhaps he may make a public tawbah? And the 3 giant scholars of this era (may Allah have mercy) who took this opinion are having by the help of Allah far reaching impact than ustad abu taymiyyah (may Allah preserve and bless), so why put the caption be like that? If really you want to guide the people?

Ibn Baz, ibn Uthaymeen, Luhaydaan, ibn Jibreen(who's a giant with or without your acknowledgement) vs Muqbil Al Wadi'i Thats all your "refutation" is

Any chance you can do a direct video to correct the brother rather than doing this as there is already so much fitnah in the ummah we dont need more, we cant even fight or refute a yahoodi and we fighting amongst ourselves.

Is it correct to say that voting is shirk? Like is it shirk in and of itself? Or not?

Brother this is not the right way of living your life. You should find a better path than this. May Allah bless you.

Lol everything has to be tailor as a refutation lol smh. Like what about labelling it clarifying a issue

To all these blind followers here pretending to be salafis who take the incorrect fatwa of a sunni scholar as if the fatwa is a hujjah in and of itself over the reality of the situation based upon daleel, fear Allaah ta'ala and make tawbah and accept the truth. Voting will not help Islam, Islam is not aided by sonething clearly haram and imitating the disbelievers. The issue of voting is not ijtihaadi. Jeylani is another confused camera lover who used to be with truth on this issue and others like tasweer but then went astray because of going back to the lands of kufr and sitting with ahl al bidah. May Allaah Almighty guide him. ⚠️Voting is no longer considered Ijtihaadi: Our Shaykh: Abu Hamza Hassan bin Muhammed Ba Shu'ayb, may Allah preserve him and may Allah continue to delight us with his knowledge, said: [Question] Are those who permit participating in parliamentary elections, declared innovators and misguided after being advised and given clarification? And what's the reply to the following statement: "The subject of voting is not from the subjects where the opposer is declared misguided, rather it's from the topics which are Ijtihaadi, and those that are known for good and Sunnah have given fataawa permitting it, the likes of 'Allaamah Ibn Baaz, and Al-'Utheymeen." [Answer] These were old fataawa of theirs, after which the harms of voting became clear, and our Shaykh, Shaykh Muqbil after this point said that the subject of voting is not considered Ijtihaadi. Rather today it became a distinguished sign of the people of bigoted partisanship, Wallaahul-Musta'aan. Source: Telegram channel of the Shaikh ___ Translated by: Abu 'Abdirrahman 'Abdullaah bin Ahmed Ash-Shingaani may Allah forgive him, his parents, his Mashaayikh, and the Muslims