Тёмный

Replacement Theory Is Everywhere. Here’s Why. 

AJ+
Подписаться 2,2 млн
Просмотров 311 тыс.
50% 1

On May 14, an 18-year-old gunman opened fire at a Tops grocery store in Buffalo, NY, killing 10. All 10 were Black, something the gunman specifically sought out. As it was revealed shortly after, in his writings, he ascribed not only to white supremacist ideology, but identified himself as an “eco-fascist,” falling into not only a growing trend but also into something very uniquely American. The Replacement Theory has been in headlines since the Buffalo shooting and, while its been attributed to the current crop of the right in this country, it’s actually something that underpins much of U.S. history, as well as modern development work. In this episode of “Backspace,” Sana delves into the nefarious origins of the overpopulation myth, how the media continues to promote it, and how it doesn’t have any place in the conversation and coverage around the climate crisis.
#ReplacementTheory #Overpopulation #Climate
Subscribe for more videos: ajplus.co/subs...

Sign up for subtext, our newsletter about the people and movements driving change in our society: ajplus.co/ekdv4
Follow us on Instagram: / ajplus
Like us on Facebook: / ajplusenglish
Follow us on Twitter: / ajplus

Опубликовано:

 

15 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 3,7 тыс.   
@FRISHR
@FRISHR 2 года назад
We don't have an overpopulation problem, we have an overconsumption problem. The world has enough for everyone’s need, but not for everyone’s greed.
@luiso2166
@luiso2166 2 года назад
And underpopulation problem.
@KingOfDust
@KingOfDust 2 года назад
@@luiso2166 You don't need to exist.
@dgd865
@dgd865 2 года назад
I don't understand why people always need to upgrade their phone every time a new one comes out.
@GiRR007
@GiRR007 2 года назад
more like a waste problem as we waste alot of stuff that can actually be used such as food.
@andrewjones575
@andrewjones575 2 года назад
No, there's definitely too many people.
@elrey6154
@elrey6154 2 года назад
It baffles me that people think the world is over populated when it’s badly managed and living resources are then use to make profit for a select few
@DelainatheDisciple
@DelainatheDisciple 2 года назад
Right! When natural resources are privatized then of course we create struggle. No one has a right to their life, they must participate in the system just to afford some water.
@elrey6154
@elrey6154 2 года назад
@@DelainatheDisciple yes it’s horrible how this system works but we have to try and make small difference and empower one another for the better
@DelainatheDisciple
@DelainatheDisciple 2 года назад
@@elrey6154 we have to empower each other to stand up against mega corporations who commodify resources. The government should declare water free and we should come together for that.
@majorlazor5058
@majorlazor5058 2 года назад
Why does it baffle you? The western world is fed nonsense that poor countries are impoverished, because of their own doing, and the western world are successful because they are superior. Also we are taught the western world are the greatest contributors to improving the world.
@davidpeppers551
@davidpeppers551 2 года назад
...for the few" A good point and a reason for lots of waste and inefficiency. However, I don't believe that we can say for sure the world is or is not overpopulated. How exactly do you define that? If it means that you have more than that which could be indefinitely sustained far into the foreseeable future, then I would say we are overpopulated. All that waste and inefficiency IS how our populations live. A population can be in population overshoot for quite some time before is realized. By overshoot I mean the maximum number of a population which can be indefinitely sustained. Sometimes it takes generations for it to be realized. You can have a gradual decline after overshoot or a sudden collapse or varying degrees of both. The populations' use of resources will determine whether it is in overshoot or not. A wasteful population which quickly becomes less wasteful and less consumptive may move from overshoot into a sustainable place, provided it is done soon enough and rapidly emough. Perhaps the decline in average life expectancy in the US in recent years is a sign it is overpopulated, given the current living patterns. We have only one child and one car. I'd like to ve rid of the car, but how do I insure sufficient access to employment without it? I can only do so much to make my family more sustainable and less consumptive when society and its systems push us in the other direction. Now I'll have to go and mow the grass before the city gives us a fine. Don't worry, only my own energy to make the mower work. No gas, no electric, no emmissions during operation.
@JaceFalcon
@JaceFalcon Год назад
When your parents could afford a house on one income, but you can't. Of course.
@colinstewart1432
@colinstewart1432 5 месяцев назад
Ah yes, the great feminist lie using " women can have it all " to literally halve wages but double the tax base. Crafty.
@What-kw6ox
@What-kw6ox 2 года назад
I was in genetics 101 class and that morning an earthquake had killed a lot of people in India. I only knew this because the professor interjected the story in class. Not sure why, but I do recall him saying that it wasn’t a bad event, in fact it was good for population control. This was late 80’s, today that wouldn’t fly.
@dfaro8453
@dfaro8453 2 года назад
Nature has ways to control the population too. COVID killed millions, and more greater diseases will be occurring soon to slow our population.
@feynmanschwingere_mc2270
@feynmanschwingere_mc2270 2 года назад
Absolute sociopath. Typical anglo-saxon subconscious racism. I wonder if he would have said that had an earthquake killed 10,000 Canadians. If he's so worried about population control, perhaps he should have had no kids. See, problem fixed.
@raginbakin1430
@raginbakin1430 2 года назад
Yikes.
@deliciaford4343
@deliciaford4343 2 года назад
You want to get? What do abortion, rationing of meat,food etc. Have you not heard that the government said we could stand to lose a few people because the world is overpopulated? They count you and me in that equation EXCEPT THEMSELVES!!!🤔😳😊🤢🤮👿🖤
@deliciaford4343
@deliciaford4343 2 года назад
I meant the first sentence to read: You want to bet? Excuse my grammatical error. Thanks
@dilly-dally-mations6851
@dilly-dally-mations6851 Год назад
I worked at a grocery store and watched these people throw away day old food in the garbage. And homeless people would get arrested for digging in said garbage for said food
@scottcharney1091
@scottcharney1091 Год назад
Very true, but this video is, in part, disingenuous. There's some important stuff that they leave out: the desire to prevent people from being born into poverty, the desire to prevent people from being born into suffering of any type, the decline in total fertility rates we're seeing in most of the world, etc. I give thanks every day for my vasectomy.
@dansmith1661
@dansmith1661 Год назад
@@scottcharney1091 You are still producing carbon, take it a step further.
@damagecase13
@damagecase13 Год назад
​@@dansmith1661 👏🏻👏🏻
@rushikeshdongare4523
@rushikeshdongare4523 Год назад
“The Earth has enough resources for our need but not for our greed.” - Mahatma Gandhi
@George-mr8ix
@George-mr8ix 2 года назад
If you think that the problem is overpopulation and not big corporations, you need to revisit elementary school.
@rajeshkumarm6441
@rajeshkumarm6441 2 года назад
Both are problematic. More people chasing a fixed resource lead’s to racing to the bottom.
@BallyBoy95
@BallyBoy95 2 года назад
Big corporations want you to think overpopulation isn't a problem, as that expands their potential market and reduces the cost of labour. Both are problems pal, pitting one against the other is an odd thing to do.
@OverthinkingConde
@OverthinkingConde 2 года назад
Ok, but revisit elementary school for what? Since when in elementary school, or anywhere, do they teach about the reality of fabricated scarcity?
@bgiv2010
@bgiv2010 2 года назад
@@BallyBoy95 you misunderstand. Overpopulation isn't a problem but corporations are, regardless of their astroturfed campaigns. We don't necessarily want the opposite of what big corporations support. Yes they are trying to maximize profits but that doesn't mean that overpopulation is a problem just because they want us to think it isn't. We don't necessarily want more or fewer people. The point is that we should not support genocide.
@dionysusnow
@dionysusnow 2 года назад
it relative, you can't have a big corporation with a small population, but it's also not an ether / or , we can reduce the population and regulate big coporations at the same time, both need to be done.
@presterjohn1697
@presterjohn1697 2 года назад
Let's not forget the largest "forced sterilized" population on earth was in Puerto Rico and it was conducted by the US government with cooperation from the Catholic Church.
@essendossev362
@essendossev362 2 года назад
The US government were also forcibly sterilizing prisoners in the US, you know, many of whom are PoC who were the victims of targeted policies and policing.
@MH-be6hr
@MH-be6hr 2 года назад
No. This is shameless propaganda and utter faction. The Catholic Church pushes unlimited population growth at all costs as "virtue." Well, they can keep their "virtue!"
@manicpepsicola3431
@manicpepsicola3431 2 года назад
@Giovanni Garcia there are many ways to commit genocide and forced sterilization is one of them something that wasn't a tactic for the mass genocides you are referencing
@manicpepsicola3431
@manicpepsicola3431 2 года назад
@Giovanni Garcia someone being killed and someone forced into sterilization is a little different
@sarigachellissery
@sarigachellissery 2 года назад
Did you know that the forced sterilization is still going on in some rural areas in India even now.
@BobbySteelanus
@BobbySteelanus 6 месяцев назад
Save Europe
@Elijah.Ben.BENJAMIN54
@Elijah.Ben.BENJAMIN54 5 месяцев назад
You can't do anything 🤣😂
@BobbySteelanus
@BobbySteelanus 5 месяцев назад
@@Elijah.Ben.BENJAMIN54 he said as he posted his 3rd comment of the day
@xxcybertruckxx2805
@xxcybertruckxx2805 5 месяцев назад
@@BobbySteelanus save europe from what?
@xxcybertruckxx2805
@xxcybertruckxx2805 5 месяцев назад
@@BobbySteelanus there is no scientific proof to the critical race theory
@Lucille-vb3lp
@Lucille-vb3lp 20 дней назад
from?
@nightnyungwe5945
@nightnyungwe5945 2 года назад
Prince William also complained about population growth in Africa. Apparently, African population threatens the wildlife he so values. I don't think he thinks about animal life anywhere when he and his fellow toffs go hunting.
@TruthOverFear21
@TruthOverFear21 2 года назад
@@Interlocutor67 Then why wildlife keeps attacking white people. I never heard of any other race that keeps getting mauled or killed by animals then people like you. It seems that people like you are afraid of becoming an minority but in the population of the world, white people are the minority. Barely making 10% of the population. Leave other countries alone and deal with your own fears.
@Zeyede_Seyum
@Zeyede_Seyum 2 года назад
@@Interlocutor67 የሸርሙጣ ልጅ።
@HBToastedAlmond
@HBToastedAlmond 2 года назад
@@Interlocutor67 With that being said, if there was something unecessary to Africa or lets say on the planet, I will just flush the toilets over you Go tell your mama
@brazaniankamrazian104
@brazaniankamrazian104 2 года назад
lol right on. his dad and grandpa be the same. runs in the family except maybe w Harry?? Idk but lol that incestuous family needs to populate less themselves
@anbay771
@anbay771 2 года назад
Prince Williams ain't do it right, if you ask me 'Cause I was him, I would have married Kate and Ashley
@ankurchaudhary3515
@ankurchaudhary3515 2 года назад
So Marvel movie where the villain killed most of the people is based on the myth of population and less resources
@ShivamSharma-dq4pu
@ShivamSharma-dq4pu 2 года назад
exactly! the story gives insight of the mind of the story writer
@iviwemajola3167
@iviwemajola3167 2 года назад
Thanos was a G though. Even with his flaws.
@luiscastaneda5250
@luiscastaneda5250 2 года назад
@@iviwemajola3167 lmao Nihilism 🤣 is the beta/sigma male of philosophical thought .
@LocoGeorge123
@LocoGeorge123 2 года назад
@@luiscastaneda5250 people who throw out beta/sigma/alpha male labels makes me cringe like I’m being forced to watch the worst episodes of SNL
@shadebleu
@shadebleu 2 года назад
@@ShivamSharma-dq4pu That story was written in 60 years ago by Stan Lee.
@Radhaun
@Radhaun 2 года назад
I think the "population control" argument really flies out the window when some, wealthy, countries make it extremely difficult for segments of their population to control their family sizes. Going so far as to deny sterilization to some and forcibly, coercively, or silently sterilize others.
@Sajirah
@Sajirah 2 года назад
I feel like this is the part that doesn’t get talked about enough. They tell people to have fewer kids, but it’s usually the brown people they direct that energy at. The moment young white people say they don’t want kids you get the opposite reaction where they tell them in a panic that they’re ‘too young’ to make that decision and whenever white women want to get sterilized (often even after they’ve already had children!) they’re denied and told that they’ll change their minds someday and that these doctors are ‘saving them from themselves’. Meanwhile, brown women have often routinely been given hysterectomies and sterilizations without their knowledge or consent in order to keep them from ‘breeding’. It just goes to show that they don’t actually care about population control as a whole, just that the ‘right’ kinds of people are breeding and the others are not.
@ruintheliarsschemes
@ruintheliarsschemes 2 года назад
The true agenda behind the veil over the world! Eugenics. Freedom and prosperity until these begin to serve to better the lives of the undesirables, then wham!!! fascism and hardliners step up. Unfortunately for the undesirables, they allowed those who deny them justice to control the narrative on their fight for dignity. Now they've been lumped in with gender confusion and other immoral causes. Thus allowing the self declared chosen to self righteously and stubbornly deny justice to the end even calling their unjust fight divine thus condemning many on both sides of the debate. Thus world will burn with fire
@grantwithers
@grantwithers 2 года назад
Which wealthy countries are controlling access to condoms and a gajillion birth control methods?
@GiRR007
@GiRR007 2 года назад
I mean if we are being honest its not as if humans reproduce asexually so people still do have full control over their family size.
@Dave102693
@Dave102693 2 года назад
@@grantwithers The US
@jessetorres8738
@jessetorres8738 2 года назад
When I was at Texas Christian University I had a sociology course where the professor (an Asian American male) defined "White Privilege" as not having more advantages in life, rather having fewer disadvantages/discriminations in life (so opposite of what it sounds like). Essentially, in our country's history, Caucasians (with few exceptions) have not faced the multiple generations oppression that most People Of Color (particularly African Americans) have faced, resulting in fewer disadvantages for them today. Sure, if you're a wealthy Caucasian, you are better off than all average/poor people in the U.S., but if you're a middle class Caucasian, you still have better chances to succeed in life because you don't have the systemic disadvantages that African, Asian, Hispanic, & Native Americans at a similar social class level have. Finally, when a non Caucasian does become successful in the U.S., it isn't because of "Reverse Discrimination" as some Caucasians argue, rather it's because they have managed to overcome the disadvantages that they faced that many of their Caucasian counterparts didn't have to face.
@lostvarius
@lostvarius 2 года назад
God I hate the term "causasian" hahaha you're right though
@Interlocutor67
@Interlocutor67 2 года назад
That was a colossal waste of miseducation. You would have been better off learning a skilled trade. Academics like that belong picking lettuce in chains.
@Euphoryaaa
@Euphoryaaa 2 года назад
@@lostvarius “Caucasian” is what people say when they’re too afraid to just say “white”
@maazkalim
@maazkalim 2 года назад
{PROVISIONAL: }I know that most of the folks here would rubbish this half-hour Special( longest duration of an episode in this series, so far) as just-another "[rich ]white people bAd" or mock it as one of those neolib overscrutiny as "mathmatics perpetuates Āryan supremacy" but as a.. ...Non-white cisman with presumably "Āryan" bloodline: This episode from my most-favourite series of this new journalism "channel" has compelled me to feel conflicted. I've gotten over my qualms, in spite of not being yet-another 'Anonymous Coward #_____' to concede that: This has made me feel very conflicted. As somebody who has contrarian scepticism of "[pop-]History" as a science, I have to confess that I leaned moderately towards "population control" solution, maybe subconsciously because of some conditioning covered in this episode but most consciously, because of the former. At the same time, I'm now shamefully shocked that the part which makes me disgusted at the OG Nāzīs the most: Exterminating "incurably sick"( gives me nausea!) people, instead of because they majorly targeted Jews( "Shoah"), upto the point of kick-starting Aktion T4 after "on-ground testing" on the former. But as my personal _mantra_ goes: Nothing non-theoretical across the cosmos can be binary. And that's why, while this episode is far from perfect( some of the books lying beside her!) - I am hopefully working to resolve this cognitive-dissonance. And I know I'm a _sucker_ for doing it, given the clear-majority won't.. But hey, that's just me. I'm somehow "easily persuaded" yet I have "enough of time and calm-mind" on my hands to process it through.
@ladybluelotus
@ladybluelotus 2 года назад
Thank you for sharing this explanation. It's valuable and much appreciated.
@IKEMENOsakaman
@IKEMENOsakaman 2 года назад
Can I just have the ability to work, go home to my family and to have a normal life without all this idiocy affecting my experience as a human being? 🙄 Hate is such a waste of time..
@brazaniankamrazian104
@brazaniankamrazian104 2 года назад
no buddy they don’t want us to live
@noname7271
@noname7271 2 года назад
Sorry no. We're living in late-stage capitalism. You're lucky you can still afford food and rent. What you want is a reasonable and sane world and our trash planet just isn't like that.
@lizbethartemis4886
@lizbethartemis4886 2 года назад
It is divide and conquer …
@brothergigawatt2116
@brothergigawatt2116 2 года назад
dont worry, when ww3 kicks off, america is going to get blown off of the planet, problem solved
@noname7271
@noname7271 2 года назад
@@brothergigawatt2116 American rot is a symptom of a larger global rot. We're all guilty and we're all going to pay as our paradise becomes an unlivable hell hole. The good news is that future sentient species will be cockroach-based, or whatever species will survive our stupidity and shamelessness.
@istp1967
@istp1967 Год назад
I've often said; an "environmental vandal" is just someone who wants to build a house by the beach, and a "conservationist" is just someone who already has a house by the beach!
@debclarke1746
@debclarke1746 Год назад
So true. 5 sisters 2 are wealthy. Two own holiday places by the beach
@Helelsonofdawn
@Helelsonofdawn Год назад
so gore bernie obama and clinton
@AvangionQ
@AvangionQ 2 года назад
You're describing eco-fascism. Well done, this is a topic rarely covered.
@The.Kyle.Scott.
@The.Kyle.Scott. 2 года назад
A road less traveled, perhaps unfortunately
@bossroth8201
@bossroth8201 2 года назад
@@The.Kyle.Scott. klaus Schwab is doing it well
@kristianhartlevjohansen3541
@kristianhartlevjohansen3541 2 года назад
@@The.Kyle.Scott. 74 mil fewer Americans would free up a good deal 🤪
@maryeverett2266
@maryeverett2266 2 года назад
It pretty much is economic fascism in the US now.
@the_kimchi_kommandant2603
@the_kimchi_kommandant2603 2 года назад
@@maryeverett2266 There is no institutionalized fascism in the US.
@trillionbones89
@trillionbones89 2 года назад
Believing "too many people" are the problem is correct, but not the people they are talking about. we have too many billionaires. we have enough food, drinking water and other ressources for 9+billion. poverty and pollution are a policy *choice*, not a product of overpopulation.
@UltraBoner
@UltraBoner 2 года назад
If poor people lack food and drinking water, do you think billionaires really eat or use much more water than an average person would?
@uprisingtv9291
@uprisingtv9291 2 года назад
Facts
@trillionbones89
@trillionbones89 2 года назад
@@UltraBoner don't play dumb.
@bonnierobinson8684
@bonnierobinson8684 2 года назад
The Environment needs to be cleaned up!
@gazthejaz8910
@gazthejaz8910 2 года назад
@@tomasmccauley569 there’s nothing wrong with having a big family, some cultures value big families and are social security in countries like in Africa or in India where there’s no government support
@JaceFalcon
@JaceFalcon Год назад
Telling people to use less, surrounded by hundreds of capitistically created nick nacks and books. Way more than I've ever had in my life. Good work.
@DavidS-gx1ok
@DavidS-gx1ok Год назад
That is her point
@java4653
@java4653 Год назад
"capitalistically created"....lol. Making & selling things is a human endeavor, not "capitalism". Business does not equal capitalism, whoever tells you otherwise is dangerously deluded. Capitalism is a political control system, not productivity. That's how lost folks are today thanks to RW propaganda. This is the part where somebody calls me a Commie....
@joemck74
@joemck74 Год назад
Books. They're called 'books'.
@DavidS-gx1ok
@DavidS-gx1ok Год назад
@@joemck74 CLUTTER, IN AGE OF DIGITIZATION, THEY ARE CALLED 'CLUTTER'.
@bradbell4022
@bradbell4022 Год назад
🤣FCUK Ha-Joon Chang and Ban Ki Moon! What has Korea ever done for us - except iMac screens and TV and that Netflix series! Name ONE thing other than those 3 things - 5 things...
@Darknamja
@Darknamja 2 года назад
This substantiates what I have always believed about the push for antiabortion laws in the US. 🤔
@ozzyhouston2535
@ozzyhouston2535 2 года назад
The push for antiabortion laws is often led by clergy who want to maximize the birth rate of their flocks.
@bonnierobinson8684
@bonnierobinson8684 2 года назад
Its mostly white women bring nex generation but black women bring new labor? This is against everything I believe in!
@odanemcdonald9874
@odanemcdonald9874 2 года назад
Exactly
@feynmanschwingere_mc2270
@feynmanschwingere_mc2270 2 года назад
Anti-abortion laws were pushed to artificially keep the white birth rate high.
@scottcharney1091
@scottcharney1091 Год назад
That, and the desire to punish people for having sex.
@arcady0
@arcady0 2 года назад
"Like a lot of bad ideas, the idea for [ insert anything here], came from an economist." - Yep. The moment the guy who's job was to figure out my taxes decided that made him qualified to talk about social policy, the world tanked. The idea that an economist is an expert on everything because he knows how money works is about as absurd as letting a dropout computer science engineer run a social science experiment... which... oops... I guess we're doing that one too.
@skankmcgank
@skankmcgank 2 года назад
Economics falls under sociology. An economist might try and suss out something about people in groups based on their spending and trading. They occasionally generate a useful concept, but they're only experts in measuring money and guessing how people think based off that.
@i_like_the_7
@i_like_the_7 2 года назад
Who is the dropped-out computer science engineer student running a social experiment?
@robnorman7305
@robnorman7305 2 года назад
B-g
@jose.montojah
@jose.montojah 2 года назад
We don't even need to redistribute between countries, if we just let go of the *C I T I E S* and adopt a more human-scaled development, we could listen to each other and take the good part. The yeast of hypocrisy and the yeast of Heron would have less influence over our humanity, if we just spread out from _New Babel_ and inhabit the planet, all together.
@phillipjiang1593
@phillipjiang1593 2 года назад
@@i_like_the_7 Meta.
@Makes_me_wonder
@Makes_me_wonder 2 года назад
The problem is not overpopulation but the population increasing faster than our ability to improve that population's well being.
@siddhartacrowley8759
@siddhartacrowley8759 Год назад
Cope
@matheusrocha8731
@matheusrocha8731 2 года назад
With a smaller population, we would have less mouths to feed, but also proportionaly less work force to feed people. So the food problem is not due to the size of the population, but due to inequality. Natural degradation also do not disapear by reducing the population. It would be only decelerated.
@godzillamegatron3590
@godzillamegatron3590 2 года назад
Technology can fill the gap if labor is needed to make food. But we are competition with other animals for food. That is why you got wildlife raiding your trash cans late at night.
@terrystevens3998
@terrystevens3998 2 года назад
@@godzillamegatron3590 if animals are eating what is in the trash that isn’t competing for food.. since we are not planning on eating it out of the trash.
@aoeu256
@aoeu256 2 года назад
We in the West work too many long hours that goes into the military. Why not work 33% fewer hours and spend the rest of the time socializing, reading books, watching documentaries, etc...
@KateeAngel
@KateeAngel 2 года назад
The problem is that one human species shouldn't take half of the world resources. So inequality, overconsumption and overpopulation are all problems
@matheusrocha8731
@matheusrocha8731 2 года назад
Yeah. What I wanted to say is that the food problem is not mainly due to the size of the population, and that natural degradation will only be decelerated if there is a reduction in the population, due to the technological needs. But that does not mean we should keep the population so big, take all earth resources for us and degrade so fast. The ideal would be to reduce population and also reduce the waste of resources through banning or combating planned obsolescence and the practice of d3stroying unsold products (for example, Amazon burns tons of unsold products weekly, including TVs and other expansive items, to avoid a reduction in the prices).
@twistedyogert
@twistedyogert 2 года назад
As someone who was born with Muscular Dystrophy, eugenics has always been a tricky subject. While I think it is wrong to deny someone the right to reproduce because of their skin color or national origin, I *don't* feel that its wrong to discourage people who carry genetic diseases from reproducing because life would be more difficult for their children.
@henriconfucius5559
@henriconfucius5559 2 года назад
My father had cancer of genetic causes, and I agree with you. We're not hating on people who carry genetic problems, the problem is the bad genes and not them as people. We *are* them.
@stinkfinga4918
@stinkfinga4918 Год назад
Eugenics is not a tricky subject. It's just a heavily uncomfortable subject that people don't wanna discuss. Like shit Iceland virtually eliminated Down's Syndrome through eugenics. Like bam, it aint happening there anymore, it's the rest of us who may be born with it or have a child suffer from it. Not them. Are they evil? Do they hate the disabled? Are they on a warpath across the planet to eliminate anyone with a cold? No. They were smart enough to treat themselves the same way we treat everything else and they're permanently better for it. Nothing tricky about that. What's tricky is accepting the fact that a lot of us have problems we'd rather not, and the way to prevent it from continuing is (possibly) sacrificing our lineage for the good of the species. If your kid has Downs, abort and try again. Confirmed effective. Another uncomfortable discussion is that we dismiss the practice of eugenics as evil while making a business out of suffering. How much money do we spend battling our genes? How much is an epipen running for these days? Insulin? Yay money!
@carlcarlington7317
@carlcarlington7317 Год назад
The problem is that eugenic policies creates an institution the can decide who can and can not bread and no institution can be trusted with such power. Any institution you try to put in charge of such decisions will be driven to use said power for their own goals, a democratic institution will fear monger and expand the ideal of who can’t bread in return for support from the population, a dictatorial system would expand its own power without the scrutiny of democratic processes, private companies would make decisions purely on what’s profitable with no concern for ethics, religious institution would make ethical decision based on unproven claims, even an ai would be influenced by the biases of those who coded it as we see today with facial recognition software
@rn6312
@rn6312 Год назад
At the end of the day it should still be their choice and before you'd even ask, my wife had MD and her & I chose not to. The key word there is "Chose".
@hugojames85
@hugojames85 Год назад
So why are you still alive, then, mate?
@alvaroxex
@alvaroxex Год назад
Hold the elite responsible.
@nunyabizness9955
@nunyabizness9955 Год назад
That would just be called anti semitic hate speech.
@marathiboi96
@marathiboi96 6 месяцев назад
@@nunyabizness9955 what if Someone said, the arab muslim elite could feed total muslim refugees but refuse to do so, would that be Islamophobic
@DanBlackRacing
@DanBlackRacing 6 месяцев назад
The Vanguard Group Black Rock Investments
@charpkun
@charpkun 2 года назад
The last little bit about how rich countries have an outsized contribution to pollution and overconsumption, i have really observed this coming from a south east asian nation and going to north america for higher education. There is almost a callous disregard of single use plastics and over packaging things in the name of hygiene and/or convenience. While i am not reversing it and putting the blame on them to solve the climate crisis on their own, i have long believed that the climate crisis is due to over production more the population or consumption issues. After all, how much goods are just perishing in supermarket shelves across the world, and unsold material goods, all for the sake of looking fully stocked? The problem is not that there is not enough food for everyone, its just it doesn't get to the mouths it could feed...
@nasaihyana
@nasaihyana Год назад
There is no climate crisis....did you not pic up the cues of the video....same goal different fake crisis to justify it
@scottcharney1091
@scottcharney1091 Год назад
Very true, but this video is, in part. disingenuous. There's some important stuff that they leave out: the desire to prevent people from being born into poverty, the desire to prevent people from being born into suffering of any type, the decline in total fertility rates we're seeing in most of the world, etc. I give thanks every day for my vasectomy.
@AlexKomnenos
@AlexKomnenos Год назад
Except for China and India have the worlds’ biggest carbon footprints. The West has significantly reduced its carbon footprint. Nations like China and India show up to climate meetings but virtually change nothing
@grapeshot
@grapeshot 2 года назад
The Kellogg cereal man, he was really into Eugenics also.
@grmpEqweer
@grmpEqweer 2 года назад
Yup. And against w@nking. What a bore.
@crystallinemushroom4803
@crystallinemushroom4803 2 года назад
male and female circumcision
@guybeleeve
@guybeleeve 2 года назад
Yeah, cornflakes are supposed to suppress sexual desires according to him.
@hxdtrwsuytfgbfr4428
@hxdtrwsuytfgbfr4428 2 года назад
Every sane and intelligent person is and was.
@crystallinemushroom4803
@crystallinemushroom4803 2 года назад
@@grmpEqweer and against various consensual relationships apparently
@nkoppa5332
@nkoppa5332 5 месяцев назад
becaue its true
@Elijah.Ben.BENJAMIN54
@Elijah.Ben.BENJAMIN54 5 месяцев назад
Yes and it's good😂🎉
@Limosethe
@Limosethe 5 месяцев назад
@@Elijah.Ben.BENJAMIN54 Get prepared Trump becoming president in 2025. Things are changing.
@rodolfogarcia_1
@rodolfogarcia_1 5 месяцев назад
@@LimosetheTrump if he wins the election can’t change anything if his party doesn’t control both Congress or the Senate.
@Limosethe
@Limosethe 5 месяцев назад
@@rodolfogarcia_1 His people can change the makeup of the senate or even restructure how laws and elections work.
@wademitchell3817
@wademitchell3817 2 года назад
Did you know that WWII Black veterans and descendants are STILL not allowed GI bill benefits? Can you imagine teaching WWII and GI Bill and not mentioning that 1 million Black veteran were excluded. There is a bill in the house and senate to change this. Authentic CRT seeks to uncover and remedy these inequities caused by systemic racism. .
@imrankh68
@imrankh68 2 года назад
Same with Hispanic veterans
@bonnierobinson8684
@bonnierobinson8684 2 года назад
These are people who don't want change!
@imrankh68
@imrankh68 2 года назад
@@bonnierobinson8684 and why would they. White supremacy is the system of benefits for the white race at a expense of the non-whites
@godzillamegatron3590
@godzillamegatron3590 2 года назад
@@imrankh68 Hispanic were not around in WW2. Hispanic label was created in 1980. They people who fell under their precieve racial make up
@imrankh68
@imrankh68 2 года назад
@@godzillamegatron3590 That's just semantics. There is a whole documentary about Hispanics or Latinos veterans systematically not getting their benefits.
@lewa3910
@lewa3910 2 года назад
Truly disgusting the number of people who believe overpopulation of people is real, and not overpopulation of monopolies, CEOs and billionaire leeches
@noname7271
@noname7271 2 года назад
We do have overpopulation. We have so many people on this planet that we're razing nature and helping create more diseases for ourselves. Whether or not you agree with me, doesn't matter. The global temperature is rising and will continue to rise. This planet will depopulate one way or another. This isn't sustainable. Fun fact: the total anthropogenic mass (human made stuff) is now more than all of nature combined. We passed nature in 2020 and we're still building more crap and filling more landfills with plastic.
@acecarson3792
@acecarson3792 2 года назад
Spoken as a true anarchist 👍
@Kioki1-x8p
@Kioki1-x8p 2 года назад
Corrupt rich media owners and businessmen are the reason racism, wars exist. They have it in their content, they encourage it. People like those ought to be put down for good.
@Gametophyte666
@Gametophyte666 2 года назад
Capitalists find the reality of climate change inconsistent with their beliefs so they pretend it isn't happening. Similarity, proponents of human progress seem compelled to deny the reality of overpopulation. What's the line? They hear what they want to hear and disregard the rest. Is it any wonder that there is no such thing as facts anymore?
@fredericklehoux7160
@fredericklehoux7160 2 года назад
I believe it's abolutely real but as nothing to do with replacement. We have evolved to have at least 5-6 kids in order for just a few to survive to adulthood and reproduce. Now, the vast majority of kids will live to adulthood. Reproduction is an instinctual drive, we need to be conscious about it.
@grahamsmith5396
@grahamsmith5396 2 года назад
White Americans/Europeans are scared that the descendants of the victims of European imperialism are now moving next door,"Hey Hanz and Franz,remember us? We just bought the flat next to you!"
@grahamsmith5396
@grahamsmith5396 Год назад
@Cooper Beckam 2+2=4. Has also been posted many times as well ,and it's still an fact,buddy!
@scottcharney1091
@scottcharney1091 Год назад
"We came here because you went there" is a slogan that appeared in the UK when Brits started complaining about migrants.
@everythingsfine1395
@everythingsfine1395 2 года назад
Soo the conclusion is life supports billion but not billionaires.
@ladybluelotus
@ladybluelotus 2 года назад
Thank you!
@wandererstraining
@wandererstraining 2 года назад
Wait wait wait... I was mostly on board, but when you say "shifting the attention away from the choices that you're making", you lose me, because shifting the burden to individual responsibility was exactly what fossil fuel companies did to shift the gaze away from themselves. The problem of climate change is much more of a systemic problem than an individual one. Not to say that our own choices make no difference, but those choices don't happen in a vacuum, they happen in the environment in which we live. Take for example personal transportation. The "individual choice" would be to use a vehicle that doesn't produce as much carbon emissions. A bike is a good example for that. But not everyone can use a bike. Bikes don't protect people from the elements, and it's often more difficult to carry a large number of items on a bike, as families regularly need. On top of that, in North America, in the US particularly, people live in car-centric areas that are inhospitable to walking, biking, or public transit. The individual solution would then seem to be that people need to buy electric cars. That's still a highly consumerist solution, that more can't afford than can, that still pollutes but in other ways. The real solution when it comes to transportation is a very well developed public transit system, and a redesign of cities and small towns to avoid sprawl and make distances manageable without owning a car.
@kaltwies
@kaltwies 2 года назад
I know how to power combustible engines that emit 100% clean exhaust in which the exhaust itself also creates a value added product (or second use). My process also purifies the water ways as I capture and store my initial energy source.
@wandererstraining
@wandererstraining 2 года назад
@@kaltwies Hydrogen motor?
@kaltwies
@kaltwies 2 года назад
@@wandererstraining compressed air from a trompe .
@wandererstraining
@wandererstraining 2 года назад
@@kaltwies What kind of fuel?
@kreativeforce532
@kreativeforce532 2 года назад
Shifting the responsibility to the individual is the World Economic (resource distribution) Forums goal. I.e. white supremacist digital control via 6g, carbon credits, the internet of things, human computer integration (rfid, neuralink), id.me facial recognition and contact tracing. As long as non-whites are kept in an individualist mindset we will not see the shrinking white population's control mechanisms being sprung upon us so they can maintain power.
@jerryjones7293
@jerryjones7293 2 года назад
As a male of 77 years, I resist the pressure framed in the suggestion that seniors are burdens. Of course nobody is forever young. Do you remember "Logan's Run"?
@joejones9520
@joejones9520 2 года назад
people think infants, children, teens, adults, elderly are each a separate class of human being, almost like each category is a different species, not like it's stages of life every human goes thru. Very strange.
@hydrolito
@hydrolito 2 года назад
Death race 2000 was also similar the disabled and elderly were run over by cars.
@blabla903
@blabla903 7 месяцев назад
A boomer is in support of providing more help for boomers, color me shocked.
@davida.rodriguez8870
@davida.rodriguez8870 2 года назад
Because of this eugenics craze In 1937 the US imposed Law 116 onto Puerto Rico that legalized sterilization on the island under the belief that Puerto Rico was too overpopulated. The US government institutionally supported the spread of sterilization on the island by having health workers perform door-to-door visits, subsidizing the procedure, and by industrial employers on the island favoring sterilized women of childbearing age in their hiring process. Men were also sterilized. This happened during the years of 1937-1960. The Procter and Gamble family had ties to this. On another note Cornelius P. Rhoads an American pathologist, oncologist, and hospital administrator. (Recognized by Time Magazine and hospitals that bear his name) injected cancer into Puerto Ricans and experimented on them in the 1930's without their knowledge. He left a letter gloating how easy it was to kill Puerto Ricans... The The Rockefeller Foundation was to thank for this. Today these elitist and racist acts take on so many other forms as you stated. Thanks for this video. NEVER FORGET!
@brazaniankamrazian104
@brazaniankamrazian104 2 года назад
Yeah this is what I was saying in my comment! 🤙🏾🤙🏾This history is so prevalent and for so many of us it hits home bc our families have experienced these policies head on and were told it was for their benefit. What the Americans did in PR was and remains a crime they never atoned for
@Kioki1-x8p
@Kioki1-x8p 2 года назад
This explains why those non-mixed race European whites always try to harm Latinos or make a mockery out of Latin American people. They just want the properties and want to wipe out the people to make a new colony in such areas. They enjoy hurting innocent people.
@stepahead5944
@stepahead5944 2 года назад
Yes. They did the same to non-white populations within the continental US as well.
@stunner8481
@stunner8481 2 года назад
Reminiscent of the Tuskagee syphilis experiment
@Kioki1-x8p
@Kioki1-x8p 2 года назад
@@stunner8481 RU-vid is intentionally hiding your comment from view when I check a few seconds ago.
@Stephon723
@Stephon723 2 года назад
The 1st minute of this thing was tough to listen to. There aren't food shortages because there's not enough food or because there's too many people there are food shortages because greedy tyrants must maintain the status quo of haves & have nots in order to be in power over someone. We waste enough food in America every day to feed a country every month.
@andrewjones575
@andrewjones575 2 года назад
How do you suggest Ethiopia feed its 120m population which is rising at a ridiculous rate.
@Sinusoid-
@Sinusoid- 2 года назад
There’s a lot of food waste in nyc from restaurants. Much of that food is not spoiled at all.
@moonie1825
@moonie1825 2 года назад
@@Sinusoid- how are you going to get that food all the way to somalia?
@chriswatson1698
@chriswatson1698 2 года назад
@@moonie1825 The Somalians are in the process of moving to developed countries. And as fast as one moves to New York or elsewhere, his relatives back home replace him with two more babies: future refugees and migrants.
@scottcharney1091
@scottcharney1091 Год назад
All true, but this video is, in part, disingenuous. There's some important stuff that they leave out: the desire to prevent people from being born into poverty, the desire to prevent people from being born into suffering of any type, the decline in total fertility rates we're seeing in most of the world, etc. I give thanks every day for my vasectomy.
@blabla903
@blabla903 10 месяцев назад
She literally opens the video with "What if we killed everyone?"
@jeremyf6821
@jeremyf6821 11 месяцев назад
The minute you said “Asia, Latin America, and Africa” I knew this was going to be another blame the white person episode.
@Illumirage
@Illumirage 11 месяцев назад
Isn't that every video now?
@ianhansen6840
@ianhansen6840 6 месяцев назад
Ended well in the 30s when it was the "blame the Jewish people, " movement... What could possibly go wrong this time around?!
@debojitchatterjee5657
@debojitchatterjee5657 3 месяца назад
So, you don't think that a white supremacist ideology and myth should be challenged?
@s3npai0603
@s3npai0603 2 месяца назад
Maybe stop playing victim and take some responsibility for your life ahmed​@@debojitchatterjee5657
@s3npai0603
@s3npai0603 2 месяца назад
Maybe stop playing victim and take some responsibility for your life ahmed​@@debojitchatterjee5657
@petem3883
@petem3883 Год назад
We should move the entire population of subsaharan Africa to Israel.
@THINKincessantly
@THINKincessantly Год назад
Would help ISREELS GDP ….why not 😂
@fesyuki-kun2332
@fesyuki-kun2332 14 дней назад
I agree btw let's do it
@francinel8154
@francinel8154 Год назад
Interesting. One thing dough, normal that nordic countries are using more energy because it's...cold, no? As a Canadian Native and French I know that in both cases we use to live in ''mud houses'' or under ground houses I should say. We now have to heat our houses and we cannot simply live in huts or tents like in warm countries. Both parent are also working and life goes fast, running all the time, we need to produce, don't have time to make our own food from farming, hunting and gardening, we have to buy it, that's why we use so many plastics.
@skapunkoialternativeliving6522
@skapunkoialternativeliving6522 2 года назад
People having more kids in poor countries is not causing the problem it's greedy countries First World countries keeping all the food for themselves there's more than enough food to feed the whole planet instead we waste billions of food every day even in America by itself so imagine what the other countries are doing..
@the_stashiest
@the_stashiest 2 года назад
👍👍👍 and then they blame the victims of the Western-made poverty.
@skapunkoialternativeliving6522
@skapunkoialternativeliving6522 2 года назад
@@the_stashiest facts
@the_stashiest
@the_stashiest 2 года назад
@@skapunkoialternativeliving6522 also, interestingly enough, the number of children a family has can indeed correlate to their socioeconomic level. it is observed that poorer people tend to have more children. I would say it's because they cannot have a dignified life, and poverty can... kill. So in order for the family to survive, they basically have to play a gamble to see what child will survive into their adulthood. Infant mortality skyrockets when living conditions are austere. But it isn't the fault of developing countries for being poor. Looking at history, and at the material condition on the ground, it is self-evident that imperialism and colonialism *actively impeded* developing countries for centuries. And you know, abusers love to blame their victims.
@Kioki1-x8p
@Kioki1-x8p 2 года назад
@@the_stashiest Again, people that know what's good for them tend to have fewer kids. The issue here is that certain white countries facing infertility and demographics issue are trying to push an agenda which limits the births in non-white nations out of fear of being "out-numbered" by non-whites.
@fredericklehoux7160
@fredericklehoux7160 2 года назад
There's truth to that but without a solution. We grow enough food to feed everyone well but we use more of that food to feed pigs and chicken to eat them and their period. We can all talk endlessly about this but what is the solution? American are not gonna turn socialist vegan in a long long time, forcing them into making those choices is also out of the question based on their politican leaning. You'd need a civil war that could blow out of proportion outside the U.S That's unfortunately why i think tthe solution remain the same, You need to be strong and create your own wealth and thrive to seek for the top position, because nobody share and everyone isstill stuck in this unfair course for survival. We also talk as though corporation are the culprit here, sorry to say but the population that cash in buying goods and services to those corporations have a role in this too. they buy this meat without a second thought, should we see them as automatons without conscience that need to have decision made for them for a better world?? It won't happen in democratic free countries because it's against the tenants of these societies.
@archimedesbird3439
@archimedesbird3439 4 месяца назад
Because replacement is everywhere I can see it walking down the street
@marykayryan7891
@marykayryan7891 2 года назад
But, lastly, the birth rate should not be "lowered" by birth control given to poor and/or black and brown women. It should be lowered by improving the status and conditions of women everywhere. Then the birth rate will lower automatically and voluntarily.
@purplemystique8308
@purplemystique8308 2 года назад
Yes, that’s why most people in the wealthy and educated brackets have fewer children. If more women worldwide are given more education and employment opportunities, the population rates will go down.
@jacques.cousteau
@jacques.cousteau 2 года назад
No, it must be both. Give them birth control and push women to enter the workforce
@marykayryan7891
@marykayryan7891 2 года назад
@@purplemystique8308 Here, here. Turns out that women aren't really that crazy about having 12 kids and being forced to stay home with them and do nothing else--no matter what the religious male leaders say.
@purplemystique8308
@purplemystique8308 2 года назад
@@marykayryan7891 Right on! You should be a media spokesperson on this topic, but they won’t give rational people a chance to be heard
@marykayryan7891
@marykayryan7891 2 года назад
@@purplemystique8308 Thank you for your kind words.
@nightshade4186
@nightshade4186 Год назад
Because of basic math. If average western woman has only one child and at the same time millions of migrants every year, you are replaced.
@fesyuki-kun2332
@fesyuki-kun2332 14 дней назад
What math? Math of racism? Let's take an average of like 100k of migrants per month (that's overestimating even) now let's take an average birth rate of about 1 child per family and let's also account for the USA gigantic size and 300 million people count if only 10% of that is produces 1 child per month your math will be proving you wrong 30 million children and that's all theoretical Math is against you buddy you're attacking the wrong people
@Hawlkeye-e9p
@Hawlkeye-e9p 8 месяцев назад
This vid needs taken down. Every talking point is hirtoricly incorrect.
@sasentaiko
@sasentaiko 2 года назад
This ties together decades of “um, why do I feel uncomfortable right now” moments. I’ve been both in solidarity with and yet terrified of rich environmentalists since I was a kid. Yes, children can feel fear in response to the racist animosity of adults discussing policies that say, “there should be fewer kids like YOU.” It’s the chill in your bones that you feel every time someone-even a courageous young person like Greta Thunberg-says “the global south”. But we can’t just intuit the details, and that’s why I personally find this video essay / deep dive so valuable: I didn’t know how much is explicitly directed at India. Heartbreaking.
@KarlSnarks
@KarlSnarks 2 года назад
The "global south" is also vague and inaccurate. Australia is in the South but somehow does not count as the "global south", and Russia has a lower average income than India (if I'm not mistaken, but either way, relatively low) and is often without thought included in the "global north". With most low-income countries, I think it would be more accurate to call them overexploited nations, because it's honest and lays the responsibility with the ones who created and perpetuate the current global inequality.
@readmycomment3707
@readmycomment3707 2 года назад
@sasentaiko Cool. Now imagine the chills of being replaced in your own country.
@jontobin5942
@jontobin5942 2 года назад
@@readmycomment3707 Ok I imagined it. Cool story bruh. For white people in the U.S., It's imaginary.
@KarlSnarks
@KarlSnarks 2 года назад
@@readmycomment3707 I'm assuming you're refering to the white genocide conspiracy theory? Stop using shit ideas that were literally invented by the Nazis.
@ckooakley
@ckooakley 2 года назад
@@readmycomment3707 Replaced by whom? The Blacks?
@theLionsDenSTL
@theLionsDenSTL Год назад
This video is a classic example of miss direction and scope creep. She begins talking about population vs resources and ends talking about race. The discussion about population and resources can be had without ever talking about race.
@JohnSmith-it6hj
@JohnSmith-it6hj 6 месяцев назад
if something is happening how can it be a theory?
@NextToToddliness
@NextToToddliness 2 года назад
We don't have a population crisis; we have a resource management crisis. I've always said the rarest commodity in the universe is imagination. We have so many opportunities to imagine solutions to problems, but the biggest hurdle is Capitalism. Resource Disparity is the crux of Supply & Demand. Sadly, capitalism equals convenience, and you'll be hardpressed to get people to relinquish them.
@Teutathis
@Teutathis 2 года назад
There's a population crisis aswell, it's just not global and highly localized to a very specific set of countries. X amount of land is needed to feed and house X amount of people. Then you have to consider the need for fresh drinking water, emissions, fisheries etc. The way overpopulation is solved currently is through migration but this is not a sustainable solution that is highly unlikely to be accepted in the long run when the effects it has had on Europe is being considered.
@tuckerbugeater
@tuckerbugeater 2 года назад
There are no solutions, only trade offs. Capitalism feeds wants. You can't force people to want something different. That will inevitably implode as it's always done.
@tuckerbugeater
@tuckerbugeater 2 года назад
@@Teutathis Try doing that without mass war and death. LOL. You stupid morons are going to kill more than climate change. Depopulation is called DEPRESSION. Try innovation in a depression.
@j0seph5
@j0seph5 2 года назад
100%, it all starts with capitalism
@scottcharney1091
@scottcharney1091 Год назад
True, but this video is, in part, disingenuous. There's some important stuff that they leave out: the desire to prevent people from being born into poverty, the desire to prevent people from being born into suffering of any type, the decline in total fertility rates we're seeing in most of the world, etc. I give thanks every day for my vasectomy.
@Kioki1-x8p
@Kioki1-x8p 2 года назад
How are under-developed or developing nations being blamed for Western industrialization era? They're the largest carbon emission violators around!
@UltraBoner
@UltraBoner 2 года назад
Under developed and developed nations don't have lower carbon emissions due to being more virtuous or because their better stewards of the environment, they're still doing everything they can to catch up or flee to the countries that are.
@Kioki1-x8p
@Kioki1-x8p 2 года назад
@@UltraBoner Absurd logic with a hint of racism. First of all, it's a well known fact that US, UK, Europe, Australia, New Zealand have a far larger footprint than developing or under-developed nations. I find it absurd that the harbingers of the climate disaster are now playing innocent!
@Kioki1-x8p
@Kioki1-x8p 2 года назад
@@UltraBoner Let's be honest here, which corporate organizations were pushing obvious lead poisoning into the environment for profits? Search up "tetraethyl lead Thomas Midgley.
@UltraBoner
@UltraBoner 2 года назад
@@Kioki1-x8p ah yes, the countries people are dying to live in
@Kioki1-x8p
@Kioki1-x8p 2 года назад
@@UltraBoner Speak for yourself, America, Australia, Canada, New Zealand are not white countries by origin.
@ivandinsmore6217
@ivandinsmore6217 2 года назад
The lesson from this video: If there needs to be population control, it needs to begin with rich Americans.
@fesyuki-kun2332
@fesyuki-kun2332 14 дней назад
Begin and end with rich americans overusing natural resources for profits and pleasure
@kranzonguam
@kranzonguam 2 года назад
👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼 Thank you for making this! I first had to confront American eugenics in college in the 1980s. It still amazes me how misunderstood and far reaching it is. Spreading understanding of how much is based on this is so needed, so we can move beyond it!
@slevinchannel7589
@slevinchannel7589 2 года назад
Try 'Telltale' and 'Telltale Fireside Chat' for more INfo.
@manfredconnor3194
@manfredconnor3194 2 года назад
Really? You think this is still going on? You think that planned parenthood is some kind of eugenic program or what?
@Social_Pugatory
@Social_Pugatory 2 года назад
Let’s not forget how early American Racist pseudoscience and Eugenicists helped inspire the holocaust.
@manfredconnor3194
@manfredconnor3194 2 года назад
@@Social_Pugatory So what is the message here? America bad then = America bad now? Therefore America bad? That is what it sounds like you are saying? Is that what you meant?
@kamranrowshandel6395
@kamranrowshandel6395 2 года назад
Is there any doubt that your shtick is that you try to get everyone to agree that mankind needs superpowers to push these "American racists" into the dirt forever and make sure they're never spoken of again, and that by doing so, you're keeping India the way it was when Hinduism was invented, and that's why everyone beefs with you guys?
@advaithpillai
@advaithpillai 2 года назад
BRAVO!!! This has been the best video on this channel so far. Identifying the problem, analyzing it and then presenting alternative solutions after pointing out the flaws in the existing approaches. Thought provoking stuff ***On a more personal note, over the past few years I always thought the content on this channel and Sanaa were more sympathetic towards the Muslim demographic and their issues, which would invariably cause a prejudice in my mind against it. But on reading the comment section and introspection, I realized that maybe my bias while thinking was also part of the problem and now I am in an ongoing process, trying not jump to conclusions or judge too quickly. THANK YOU for challenging me to do so ( For context, I am nominal Hindu citizen of India and I think the example of disastrous population control initiatives here is not talked about enough. Thank you once again for bringing it up on this global forum. Keep up the great work you all ) ***
@haraldkoch4446
@haraldkoch4446 2 года назад
Joking about Nazism isn't funny.
@karsan6018
@karsan6018 2 года назад
Add a little bit of truth to make your agenda taste more palatable. This channel is clearly playing the famous Victim card. No humans are same. But this channel conveniently clubs all white people to the worst examples. But all muslims are different. Not all they are saying is wrong. But only what they choose to address and how they choose to address it speaks volumes about them. These are mainly 2 wrongs that don't make right.
@saimbhat6243
@saimbhat6243 2 года назад
No pooijeet the bais was in your mind. And it most probably comes from cow juices.
@scottcharney1091
@scottcharney1091 Год назад
The word is "biased," not "bias." Anyway, you're right, but this video is, in part, disingenuous. There's some important stuff that they leave out: the desire to prevent people from being born into poverty, the desire to prevent people from being born into suffering of any type, the decline in total fertility rates we're seeing in most of the world, etc. I give thanks every day for my vasectomy.
@1525boy
@1525boy 11 месяцев назад
@@saimbhat6243Or it could come from Pork fat 🐖🐷 Abdul. Allah au Akbar 🕋☪️🇵🇰!!!
@JayBrown-xs9ps
@JayBrown-xs9ps Год назад
Bikes, buses, and trains. Moving to this lifestyle would kill half of the problem. (but nobody wants to hear that)
@wallenbergphoto
@wallenbergphoto 2 года назад
The problem with this story is.. and what she forgot to mention... 1. We are an animal, that is outside the balance of nature. We all use to lunch recources from natural world that belongs to our share world and out animal friends, and Forrest's. 2. Birth control is more about health (and she didn't go into what health is a big spectrum) and again our general footprint NOT carbon, but water, minerals, chemicals. 3. Capitalism struggles that everyone must be and will be in the same positions for eg. The US which has come along way read (H. Rosling) those is aöl normal I'm capitalism that in my mind is a horrific political system for the inviroment itself. When people in the US has 3 cars per person why should it not be the right of an Indian person to have it too? You get the math. And of course it's totally wrong that a US person should have it to start with. 4. Water crisis is a real thing today, private companies out billions into buying up water because today / not before science know! Water recources will be more valuable then oil in the coming 100 years. Even today some places in south America people pay more for water then house rent. 5. It's all easy math under a capitalistic system that is what she doesn't take up, "everyones free right to make as much money and use as much recources that can, because it's their rights". It's simple math whatever idiot eugenics did before, that was plain hocus pocus. It's also about women's rights with birth control to not be enslaved at home, no education, left out of sociaty etc. This is a well studied subject. But remember, for every person born their are thousands of threes cut down, million of gallons of fresh water destroyed band millions of animals pushed out, eaten and killed.
@fesyuki-kun2332
@fesyuki-kun2332 14 дней назад
AMAZING you proved that you are someone with a brain good job seriously
@daodeyao1106
@daodeyao1106 2 года назад
brilliant presentation look forward to an episode that focuses on the military impact on the climate crisis that includes super fund military base pollution and destruction of people and resources, refugees, corporate control of poor populations causing internecine war, etc.
@maazkalim
@maazkalim 2 года назад
The DOJ would be successful before that, my "doomy gloomy" prediction tells.
@maazkalim
@maazkalim 2 года назад
Uh-huh, "@@thesultanofveracity9943"?!?
@maazkalim
@maazkalim 2 года назад
Well.. That demographic change is why the U S of A has managed to remain the Superpower of this one-&-only Planet. Also.. Those whom you define as “Indians”, are not entirety indigenous to India - either. But given the indescribably atrocious "Manifest Destiny" humbug, I guess the parallel fits.
@maazkalim
@maazkalim 2 года назад
Of course it would be hard for you to concede. Nevertheless.. The "development"/"progress"( fluffy words for: Industrialisation) has come the most from immigration, such as US winning the nuclear arms race( "Manhattan Project").
@haraldkoch4446
@haraldkoch4446 2 года назад
I suspect as a child you had nothing.
@cpxh7703
@cpxh7703 Год назад
No one should have the right to determine which people to live or die.
@THINKincessantly
@THINKincessantly Год назад
Ghengis Khan disagrees
@StudSnob
@StudSnob 3 месяца назад
We should have the right to determine which people reproduce tho. Otherwise, the dumb people will outnumber the smart ones.
@henrybleisch9025
@henrybleisch9025 2 года назад
I really like this story. The truth is there plenty of resources to feed an provide for basic needs of people. The real problem is how we are constantly using "economy" as an excuse to be wasteful and the systemic excess of the insanely rich and powerful. The "foot print" of waste alone is enough to easily feed provide for at least 2/3 more people i would estimate from things ive seen. The problem is how systemic and cultural the nature of solving the problem is. You cant just ask or even tell people who flat out avoid or ignore facts to change. Also the laws wont change because the same people are rewarded for creating the problem are having the most control how voting to change problems is done. People will say its a failure of democracy but how is it even a democratic process if people aren't even properly educated and allowed to change important rules for the common good? I dont think that means give up but for the people who do want to change things the strategy must be different to reaching people in ways that are defined more by exciting pop culture the media they just ignore out of boredom.
@cjohnson3836
@cjohnson3836 2 года назад
The problem isn't feeding people. Carrying capacity of any species population is dictated by the limiting resource. The limiting resource for humans is the (carbon) climate buffer. And that is very much running out.
@henrybleisch9025
@henrybleisch9025 2 года назад
@@cjohnson3836 by carbon do you mean a specific type of carbon or usage of such? I agree with you in a sense because as human civilization has grown to a point to depend on certain things and style of living but i would say needing and wanting are to very different things. Cultures of the past believe more heavily in ways we now have forgotten and taken for granted. The culture of people saying they need things they merely want has definitely taken a toll on supply and demand as a whole but its definitely not sustainable and leads to changes and a break down what was and often is the norm. People think they need technology and i really do feel a lot of technology helps but its not exactly the solution often it can lead to people wanting using and wasting more then would likely need others if there cultural perspective was that of being sustainable 1st. The earth and the biomes on it change mostly due to human acts they will and are changing to accommodate there life not ours. The new biomes immerge will find balance even despite a self destructive nature of species that Cannot. Its my prediction that humans will struggle until we find that finer balance with the biomes interact with technology will and can help but cant overwhelming replace what is far beyond its capabilities and humans should create cultures that are freer from strife and likely given them better happiness and quality of life as a result.
@MH-be6hr
@MH-be6hr 2 года назад
Meaning you want everyone to live a miserable, ascetic, minimalistic lifestyle, as long as everyone is equal.
@henrybleisch9025
@henrybleisch9025 2 года назад
@@MH-be6hr no but displined ones people dont need to stress out over junk they dont need. In the end does it make people happy or just spoiled distracted and under educated to meet a better sense of happiness that is sustainable for most if not all there lives... The solution to most problems is that not distractions and giving in to addictions.
@henrybleisch9025
@henrybleisch9025 2 года назад
@@MH-be6hr plus i think we all know total equality is at all possible we have to balance even in even our own diversity so we can have stable civilizations. What i am really suggesting is a finer balance...
@et8893
@et8893 2 года назад
My math teacher for the last 3 years of my schooling always talked about how over population was false and the numbers provided to us never added up in real world scenarios. She would always talk about Info in Info out Models. If you put into your model only the data you want then you will get out exactly what you want from your modelling. The models provided are biased and are designed to energize the push to their agenda. Remember the original COV-ID-19 Model that turned out to be over exaggerated but had the exact reaction wanted, realized. Which was FEAR. I love my math teacher. She always said for us to study the data and to search for the data that was NOT put in...... As I get older I am realizing that all this is not about over population but about population control. There is a huge difference between the two.
@WilliamSantos-cv8rr
@WilliamSantos-cv8rr Год назад
Congratullations!! You had a great teacher.
@stratoleft
@stratoleft Год назад
@@WilliamSantos-cv8rr OK. That, and the fact the sana saeed critter in this video is a straight up transvestite. 😆🙅‍♀
@chriswatson1698
@chriswatson1698 Год назад
Your maths teacher is some kind of capitalist who wants more consumers. He is wrong. And people don't just want food, do they?
@1Humanoid
@1Humanoid Год назад
@@stratoleft aaahhhh So what you 🤡
@1Humanoid
@1Humanoid Год назад
@@chriswatson1698 She not a He. Read 📚 . WoW how did you get Capitalist from the above. She does Math. And the Math shows we are NOT overpopulated but very badly managed. Bad people management Bad food management Bad polution management Bad immigration management We are not overpopulated we are just very badly managed by greed, indifference, racism, poor judgement, selfish intentions etc etc. Capitalism dosent even come into the picture. Its bad management and nothing else..... Educate yourself rather than regurgitating what others say.
@brastmonkey
@brastmonkey Год назад
Interesting video AJ+. This presentation really makes you think about government mandated medical campaigns. Especially the sterilization story from India. After watching this I’m sure there is no way corporate entities could be involved in those campaigns or have their own agendas. I feel confident that these organizations would be truthful and honest with their intentions and have no ulterior motives. There is no way a private corporate health entity would use the guise of something like global health to advance its own agenda.
@Jay-lj8tb
@Jay-lj8tb Год назад
Never would they do that
@ronny1375
@ronny1375 Год назад
Big pharma live by the slogan what would Jesus do?
@femalesupremacistoverlord6800
Indeed, I think you took the right message from this video.
@piktormusic2538
@piktormusic2538 Год назад
Oh brother. All suspicion and belief, no credible evidence.
@Psychospheres
@Psychospheres Год назад
Careful though, a lot anti-vaxxers use that reverse-psychology to justify their ignorance.
@blueberryhill6948
@blueberryhill6948 2 года назад
This replacement theory is sickening
@eliyahubenysrael6272
@eliyahubenysrael6272 2 года назад
Its as old as whiteness.
@waynegretzky8679
@waynegretzky8679 2 года назад
its true
@christurner6330
@christurner6330 2 года назад
@@eliyahubenysrael6272 ?????????
@hxdtrwsuytfgbfr4428
@hxdtrwsuytfgbfr4428 2 года назад
@@eliyahubenysrael6272 do you ever wonder why everyone hates Jews and persecuted them for thousands of years ? Parasite
@Chudsmash777
@Chudsmash777 Год назад
@@waynegretzky8679 We are being replaced in the west.
@Spock_Rogers
@Spock_Rogers 2 года назад
The population has doubled in my lifetime and is growing exponentially. The planet, however, is not getting any bigger.
@hangingthief
@hangingthief 2 года назад
very glad to see this brought up, conservationists still havent stopped forcing indigenous people out of their 'parks' btw, i am very concerned with wildlife conservation and the rights of the rural poor so it hurts me
@scottcharney1091
@scottcharney1091 Год назад
True, but this video is, in part. disingenuous. There's some important stuff that they leave out: the desire to prevent people from being born into poverty, the desire to prevent people from being born into suffering of any type, the decline in total fertility rates we're seeing in most of the world, etc. I give thanks every day for my vasectomy.
@purest_evil
@purest_evil 9 месяцев назад
​@@scottcharney1091I give thanks to your vasectomy too, another sucker off the game board
@elfboi523
@elfboi523 2 года назад
Of course it it the rich who tell us we need fewer people. Fewer people is not a bad idea, but there is another much better idea: No more rich people, just all the resources for everybody.
@elfboi523
@elfboi523 2 года назад
While the world is not overpopulated yet, with our numbers rising and our agriculture slowly failing because the way it works today just isn't sustainable, we can see that we might reach a point where global famine becomes inevitable. However, with a global socialist economy that distributes resources according to need instead of according to wealth, that point lies far ahead in the future, and when it is reached, at we will all suffer together, and every family will share the pain of losing loved ones- The meltdown of global civilisation along with the capitalist economy is very likely, I don't think we will avoid it if it is still possible today. Eating the rich might be the only option we have if we want to survive-
@idealicfool
@idealicfool 2 года назад
nothing wrong with rich people. the issue is the people who own the rich people that make move to stamp out potential for legislation to better the lives of people and to empower them and instead to enslave them.
@elfboi523
@elfboi523 2 года назад
@@idealicfool I think that every kind of system in which rich people exist is flawed. in order for rich people to exist in the first place, a lot of other people need to be poor. If we want to end poverty, we also need to end obscene wealth. Just shift everybody towards the middle.
@idealicfool
@idealicfool 2 года назад
@@elfboi523 which is basically what I just said. Checks and balances in place to prevent people from controlling or owning to much of specific areas.
@bonnierobinson8684
@bonnierobinson8684 2 года назад
Read a tale of two cities!
@fightingblindly
@fightingblindly 2 года назад
You're literally telling me Bangladesh and India would not benefit from birth control, lol.
@adonisfp1
@adonisfp1 Год назад
Overpopulation is not a myth. We do need to have family planning, but by choice, and we have to be very careful to make sure family planning is not driven by eugenics. It is a difficult line to towe, but I witnessed how significantly my family's quality of life improved thanks to my parents' choice to only have 3 children, were as my grandparents' generation had on average more than 5 children. Ignoring either the dangers of eugenics or the dangers of overpopulation are equally dangerous.
@benazeddine5255
@benazeddine5255 2 года назад
Thx Sana for another myth busting analysis/video that put to rest the trope of "Too many people in Africa-Asia-Central/South America are causing climate change and depletion of resources" 🙏
@jeffbrunswick5511
@jeffbrunswick5511 2 года назад
Who the hell is even saying that? This channel is disgusting racist hate. Are Arabs the defenders of the Africans? Then why are you still enslaving them in the 21st century? How can you talk about gunmen in the USA when there are suicide bombers all over the Middle East and a war raging in Yemen?
@benazeddine5255
@benazeddine5255 2 года назад
@@jeffbrunswick5511 What is your point, beside ranting about an Arabic name, you know nothing about?
@KateeAngel
@KateeAngel 2 года назад
In reality if you compare population density then Asia yes is overpopulated, but the next is Europe. And Africa and Latin America actually have low population densities compared with global
@benazeddine5255
@benazeddine5255 2 года назад
@@KateeAngel Yes. In Asia, India & China account for a population totalling about 2,8 billions people. The concentration is in or near the coastal areas. If China finds a way to solve the desertification problem (West- North West) and win the fight, the population density there will be resolved, by people moving to the new territories. For India, Pakistan and Bangladesh, the situation is totally different. The resources are limited and first they have to lift the population out of poverty, improve the infrastructure and conditions of living of millions before pretending to any conquest/conversion of new territories, to habitable/productive ones, within their boundaries, so the concentration of people in big cities can be alleviated. South America is blessed with huge empty space for agriculture development and spreading the population, except mountainous Chile and Peru.
@jeffbrunswick5511
@jeffbrunswick5511 2 года назад
@@KateeAngel So what is your point? Some places are overpopulated, but it's only fair if the entire world is equally overpopulated? All of the world's rainforests and coral reefs can be obliterated, just so long as the % of white people is lower? Let pollution around the world run rampant to the point that our planet is not habitable any more and our entire species goes extinct, just so long as the world is more Islamic and brown first, everything is cool yeah? You need to stop watching Al Jazeera, it's making you dumb.
@nicksouza7070
@nicksouza7070 2 года назад
This needs serious fact checking
@fesyuki-kun2332
@fesyuki-kun2332 14 дней назад
Go read and fact cheek yourself you're not a toddler
@RobertWWD
@RobertWWD Месяц назад
It’s not a theory. The Great Replacement happened a century ago in London England but unfortunately the great replacement was misunderstood that lead to hysteria.
@fesyuki-kun2332
@fesyuki-kun2332 14 дней назад
May you source your opinion?
@RobertWWD
@RobertWWD 14 дней назад
@@fesyuki-kun2332 It’s not my opinion it’s a historical event that happened a century ago. A genocide in London lead to the replacement theory.
@fesyuki-kun2332
@fesyuki-kun2332 14 дней назад
@@RobertWWD source it or talk about it in more details
@scottpeterson7500
@scottpeterson7500 2 года назад
America alone throws away enough food to feed all the people currently suffering malnutrition or food insecurity 🤔
@Illumirage
@Illumirage 11 месяцев назад
Here's why: cuz its true
@DeSpectator
@DeSpectator 11 месяцев назад
Get a life bozo how many times are gonna comment the same sheet in different vids
@AmirShafeek
@AmirShafeek 10 месяцев назад
​@DeSpectator I'm saying seen him on three vids
@Illumirage
@Illumirage 10 месяцев назад
​@@AmirShafeekstalker
@AmirShafeek
@AmirShafeek 10 месяцев назад
@@Illumirage ofc I'm gonna stalk what's being replaced
@Illumirage
@Illumirage 10 месяцев назад
@@AmirShafeek that doesn't make sense and you seem incredibly racist
@iart2838
@iart2838 2 года назад
What's so illogical about overpopulation? It's math. You can afford to feed 2 kids but not 8. Bingo.
@Saltine_the_clown
@Saltine_the_clown 2 года назад
70% of Canada's growth last year was through immigration. We cannot simply pretend that this is not going to drive up the demand for housing. Let's also talk about the carbon footprint of immigration.
@Naoconsigometer1nome
@Naoconsigometer1nome 2 года назад
and me thinking i would never give credit to canada for doing a good thing in its history :o
@fesyuki-kun2332
@fesyuki-kun2332 14 дней назад
The housing crisis is a capitalistic one privatised means higher prices for more profit and cut downs so they save up and get even more problems And fun fact btw there are many researches conducted that immigrants are most likely to involve themselves in greener programs and waste less resources because of their backgrounds and their food is more organic because of their culture Your point again?
@rabbitazteca23
@rabbitazteca23 2 года назад
arent birth rates actually decreasing globally? Japan, for one, is in danger if its native population doesn't have enough kids to offset the aging population
@moksha6202
@moksha6202 2 года назад
Thats been going on for 20 some years. Some nations are underpopulated but the world as a whole is overpopulated.
@idealicfool
@idealicfool 2 года назад
​@@moksha6202 which is where I dont understand her showing Bill Gates talking about population because in that very same video he says as those in lesser developed countries are brought up to level with those in developed countries, the need or desire to have multiple children to help the family will decrease as quality of life improves resulting in people having less children and having them at an older age as they give consideration to their children's futures instead of just trying to get through tomorrow.
@vylbird8014
@vylbird8014 2 года назад
Globally, population growth continues. But many countries would be falling in population if not for immigration, including the US and most of Europe. Japan is falling overall because they have an exceptionally low immigration rate. If the pattern followed by individual countries is shared by the world as a whole, population will eventually start to fall - but not for a long time. It's hard to say when, but somewhere in the region of a century, give or take a few decades. A falling population creates new problems - current economic systems are predicated upon unending growth, and population growth is part of that. Even pensions are essentially ponzi schemes - if there are too many retirees drawing pensions out in proportion to the working population paying in, the pension scheme just runs out of money.
@atlastobin7837
@atlastobin7837 Год назад
I don't care, I am having 5 kids, at least. Intelligent people need to step up and spread their genes. We have nuclear power, 3D printing, recycling and asteroid mining, we don't need less people, we need better, smarter people who can fix problems, high IQ individuals.
@xuan5469
@xuan5469 Год назад
hmmm i definitely think eugenics and ecofascism is a problem however, i also do think overpopulation is an issue as well--the lack of planning, proper distribution, etc. IS still a valid problem to consider when thinking about if we as a species can support the number of people that we bring into this world, and not just the amount of resources that we have mined from the planet. i know many people who are born into this world as a way to save/force marriages, to satisfy cultural expectations, really all sorts of reasons other than being ready to give to a new child's development. i don't think this is a thing unique to any one culture, it's a human one.
@Sinaeb
@Sinaeb 2 года назад
Elon Musk is also spewing that. If anyone had no idea who he is Always has been a conman.
@Tribuneoftheplebs
@Tribuneoftheplebs 2 года назад
He tweeted about supporting coups in Bolivia so the US can control their lithium resources. Elon Musk is a white nationalist and a sexual predator.
@wj3186
@wj3186 2 года назад
He's a creeper
@Zeyede_Seyum
@Zeyede_Seyum 2 года назад
And he's African American 😏
@the_stashiest
@the_stashiest 2 года назад
@@Zeyede_Seyum oh god, not this.
@moksha6202
@moksha6202 2 года назад
He is a good inventor, but I would not seek any other advice from him. Build products and shut up ! He likes to think he is a subject matter expert on all matters !
@THINKincessantly
@THINKincessantly Год назад
They HAD to cover it eventually. And those Rabbis , boy they have not done themselves any favors by being overconfident and brash about their hatred for Europeans
@d.bcooper2271
@d.bcooper2271 Год назад
Indeed, those who disbelieve spend their wealth to avert [people] from the way of Allāh. So they will spend it; then it will be for them a [source of] regret; then they will be overcome. And those who have disbelieved - unto Hell they will be gathered. 8:36
@nicstroud
@nicstroud 2 года назад
Provide liberty and education to a country's female population and lower birth rates happen naturally. Despite this video's narrative, over population is a very real problem and does affect climate change. However, the main contributors aren't in India and are definitely not in Africa. No, cut the population of America and Europe in half and I'm sure we would see a noticeable change in greenhouse gas, pollution, deforestation, etc, etc.
@lonniedobbins1195
@lonniedobbins1195 2 года назад
Africa doesn't have a population problem. It has infrastructure problems, theft of resources problems, poor government problems. *Africa Don't Create The CO2 And Nuclear Radiation That Threatens All Life On Earth!* *NEITHER DOES ITS PEOPLE!* REJECTION OF SOLUTIONS, SCIENCE, AND LOGIC FOR FINANCIAL GAIN IS THE #1 PROBLEM AND REASONS WHY We're in this spiral of extinction.
@superafrikanmedialabs8237
@superafrikanmedialabs8237 2 года назад
Good the less Europeans the better!!!!
@redsqrds3980
@redsqrds3980 2 года назад
You're just full of propaganda
@GalacticNovaOverlord
@GalacticNovaOverlord 2 года назад
Eh, as long as you keep the capitalist behemoths in power, nothing will change. They will only switch countries.
@reforest4fertility
@reforest4fertility 2 года назад
A solution: Reforest using a Federal Jobs Guarantee. This does replace habitat, replaces the source of fresh water to abundance levels all the way inland (look up hydrology), replaces nature's carbon sink, preventing carbon from running off into the ocean where it devastatingly acidifies & is melting the polar caps from below thru ocean convection. So strategic reforesting would start from where forests already exist, working outward from there, but to help the oceans would reforest coastal regions & riparian zones around riversides.
@dionysusnow
@dionysusnow 2 года назад
The superior method of reforestation is to just leave the land alone, no manpower required.
@reforest4fertility
@reforest4fertility 2 года назад
@@dionysusnow Apparently you're in the deep south (re Northern Hemisphere) or your mind has "gone south", as they used to say. We don't have 4 seasons to grow up northway here, more like 2 or slightly less. There is a good way of doing it. Mycorrhize the root-wads from as local source as possible. Replace the native diversity, or with a diversity of what will take. It does take stewardship. Where i live the forests are totally unmanaged & a complete mess. So much of what would commence reforestation would be transplanting smaller trees out into open space adjacent to existing forest as part of selection logging that doesn't highgrade.
@reforest4fertility
@reforest4fertility 2 года назад
@@dionysusnow Plus, what you say was true a long time ago, but you-who, here we are now.
@reforest4fertility
@reforest4fertility 2 года назад
@@dionysusnow In addition, i must ask, how can you say that with all the current clearcut logging, so They're hardly "just leaving the land alone". When "manpower" is used in the other direction, donchya think humanepower is needed to counter?
@contenderforfaith
@contenderforfaith 4 месяца назад
OPEN YOUR EYES! STOP FORNICATION!
@guylindquist338
@guylindquist338 3 месяца назад
Why? Because it's obvious that it is happening.
@RheinAmacher
@RheinAmacher 3 месяца назад
For the third world countries, just don't come to America, we're full already.
@robinjohnsam2578
@robinjohnsam2578 2 месяца назад
The first immigrant from your family immigrated to usa because european countries were third world at that time. Immigrants are contributing huge to america..be respectful to them irrespective of their skin color.
@AndreiGromit
@AndreiGromit 2 года назад
Also, the moment the article goes to Hitler and Eugenics, which are two of the "West's" most recent historic blunders, is when I get that this article wants me to be outraged, automatically agree to everything the article says, and basically understand less about the real issue: the question of population pressure on the environment.
@AndreiGromit
@AndreiGromit 2 года назад
@Kay Kronicals @Kay Kronicals I understand your point of view and I agree with it. I just think the article does not put this point of view across, although perhaps towards the end. The article focuses on the painting the former colonial powers and the US as the bad guy, and their abuses are not news. I wanted the article to support its message with more information and less opinion.
@GalacticNovaOverlord
@GalacticNovaOverlord 2 года назад
@@AndreiGromit The west is the biggest threat to human existence- the capitalist system the control and have spread around the world (the U.S. empire specifically). I don't understand where there's disagreement with that, what propaganda have you been fed?
@fesyuki-kun2332
@fesyuki-kun2332 14 дней назад
So basically you're saying that we should hide the historic use of such ideologies just to make people like you more critical and happy then why don't I ask you a simple question Who is more of a problem? The poor people that because they're poor they're a burden on society or the extra rich we steal everything to make themselves more richer? There's only one right answer btw
@jakobforslin6301
@jakobforslin6301 Год назад
Basically: consume less, educate yourself more, aim for quality rather than quantity when it comes to family. End of story.
@turkicunion1996
@turkicunion1996 2 года назад
People should keep reproducing. Us and Europe need to decrease emissions. India uses like 9 million barrels of oil per day. While Us uses 19.9 million barrels a day.India should use 80.6 million barrels a day considering Usa is a quarter of its population.
@ladybluelotus
@ladybluelotus 2 года назад
Precisely!
@turkicunion1996
@turkicunion1996 2 года назад
@@ladybluelotus yes.
@Kioki1-x8p
@Kioki1-x8p 2 года назад
@@turkicunion1996 Or we can just strip the US and European world order and find a better solution for a more prosperous world.
@turkicunion1996
@turkicunion1996 2 года назад
@@Kioki1-x8p seems to be a great idea
@UltraBoner
@UltraBoner 2 года назад
If India was as rich as the U.S. they'd use more than 80 million barrels a day.
@the-original-ghost
@the-original-ghost 2 года назад
Help me to understand how that if you can't feed yourself and your partner,why would you bring a child into that life?
@rumplestilskinsmum5094
@rumplestilskinsmum5094 2 года назад
I asked that same question when I was 13 in 1974 - World population was at 3.5 billion and the first "Famine Aid" for Biafra was on TV. Still asking the same question now 2022 I see !
@the-original-ghost
@the-original-ghost 2 года назад
@@rumplestilskinsmum5094 what I find truly amazing is that we can go into outer space but we can't get water and and the means for agriculture to places that need it.There is no excuse for it and we need to do better!
@dualscreengrant
@dualscreengrant Год назад
People should adopt more. There are Christians who think it's sinful when married couples don't have biological children. There's a stigma about adoptive parents that shouldn't exist. People say "Oh, so you have adopted kids. That means that they're not your real kids." My cousin and her husband have a beautiful family. They adopted a girl who has chronic health problems, and she might otherwise not be alive today. But people still say "their *adopted* daughter" with a condescending tone. Why don't people say "Their daughter"? My cousin and her husband did something positive to help someone in need, and people don't recognize them as real parents.
@Limosethe
@Limosethe 5 месяцев назад
Why does it feel like the W population is dwindling?
@keyes858
@keyes858 4 месяца назад
Because you are being fed constant propaganda
@Limosethe
@Limosethe 4 месяца назад
@@keyes858 No, it's because I can see it whenever I go outdoors.
@keyes858
@keyes858 4 месяца назад
@@Limosethe Where do you think all the white people are going? Are they being kidnapped?
@rn6312
@rn6312 3 месяца назад
"No, it's because I can see it whenever I go outdoors." Total logical fallacy
@Limosethe
@Limosethe 3 месяца назад
@@rn6312 Cool, but no one asked, cupcake
@guillermoelnino
@guillermoelnino 9 месяцев назад
Y ou know who's being replaced and why.
@vickygraham2444
@vickygraham2444 Год назад
child, kid, baby... these are all names given after birth. What about the 400,000+ kids in the foster system? What about the kids being killed in school? What about the kids that don't have enough to eat? Plenty of actual kids out there that need help. Let women live their lives and make the best choices for them. Spend your energy on helping actual children.
@tejasam1
@tejasam1 2 года назад
Unconditional right to stop our own life whenever we want, for all adults
@hydrolito
@hydrolito 2 года назад
No one is stopping you from jumping off a high bridge.
@b8akaratn
@b8akaratn 2 года назад
I don't think anyone has perfected the knowing-but-patient eyeroll as good as Ms. Sana -- THANK YOU FOR ALL OF THIS
@slevinchannel7589
@slevinchannel7589 2 года назад
Know 'Second Thought'?
@stratoleft
@stratoleft Год назад
@@slevinchannel7589 The sana saeed critter in this video ain't no "Ms." anything. It's a straight up transvestite. A far cry from these guys here in the looks dept., though. 😆 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-qE0HL3bCm_o.html
@scottcharney1091
@scottcharney1091 Год назад
Ok, but she's smug and, in part, disingenuous. There's some important stuff that they leave out: the desire to prevent people from being born into poverty, the desire to prevent people from being born into suffering of any type, the decline in total fertility rates we're seeing in most of the world, etc.
@classical421
@classical421 2 года назад
This is and incredible presentation. It made me reflect on a lot of things that I had not considered beforehand. It's also challenged some truths I had considered to be "absolute"
@Bambotb
@Bambotb 2 года назад
Replacement is definitely true
@classical421
@classical421 2 года назад
@@Bambotb It's like you didn't even watch the video.
@simonechaddha3459
@simonechaddha3459 2 года назад
@@Bambotb are you for real?
@sizor3ds
@sizor3ds 2 года назад
@@Bambotb found the Nazi
@corneliuscapitalinus845
@corneliuscapitalinus845 2 года назад
@classical I didn't actually hear anywhere in the video a refutation of replacement. It goes into the history of eugenic thinking and how American Progressivism was inseparably tied in with such notions and how some of these notions linger today in respectable thought, aswell as ecofascism, but no refutation of replacement.
@prieten49
@prieten49 Год назад
Yes, Malthus and Paul Ehrlich come off looking pretty unprescient in this documentary. But we shouldn't forget that significant scientific advances came along at opportune moments to "pull our chestnuts out of the fire." The mechanization of agriculture and the introduction of chemical fertilizers and pesticides starting with the industrial revolution made it possible to feed a much larger population. The Green Revolution brought about new crops that were far more productive and helped India right when it most needed them. Modern biotechnology including transgenic and cisgenic organisms has also led to significant advances in productivity and hold much promise for improved crop nutrition. Will science continue to be able to pull our chestnuts out of the fire forever? That probably won't be necessary as world population growth is slowing. I am alarmed though by the intense hostility towards modern biotechnology being displayed especially by so-called progressive organizations. Forcing the world to go back to or, in the case of developing countries, to continue primitive "organic" agricultural methods is a surefire recipe for famine.
@greenleaf1635
@greenleaf1635 2 года назад
It's the richest on this planet who are responsible for the majority of the environmental issues and it's the poorest who get the bill presented.
@scottcharney1091
@scottcharney1091 Год назад
Thus, we need fewer of the perpetrators and fewer of the victims.
@petitio_principii
@petitio_principii 2 года назад
"Theory" gives it a veneer of intellectual respectability it doesn't deserve. Call it "bigoted fears of populational change."
@enceladus2263
@enceladus2263 2 года назад
There’s nothing wrong with fearing a major demographic shift. In one persons lifetime the United States will have gone from almost 90% white to less than 50%. There are major cultural consequences to this. No one would celebrate this change in any other non-white country.
@crackedhammer4612
@crackedhammer4612 2 года назад
No, because the great replacement is true.
@obie2013
@obie2013 Год назад
why would you not fear population change, if india became half chinese in less than a century they should be fearful, its completely understandable why indians would be upset so why shouldn’t whites who are the people that founded countries like australia america and canada and are becoming less and less of a majority. Even in Britain its only 80 percent white (their native country) where as a country like chine only has 0.03 percent foreign born people
@scottcharney1091
@scottcharney1091 Год назад
Not really. This video is, in part, disingenuous. There's some important stuff that they leave out: the desire to prevent people from being born into poverty, the desire to prevent people from being born into suffering of any type, the decline in total fertility rates we're seeing in most of the world, etc. I give thanks every day for my vasectomy.
@SylvainDuford
@SylvainDuford 2 года назад
You're assuming that people in rich countries will voluntarily greatly reduce their consumption habits and carbon footprint. You're also assuming that people in poor countries will not do everything they can to come out of poverty and adopt lifestyles closer to that of the rich. I contend that neither of these two things will happen, so overpopulation, is , in fact, a problem. As long as we have population growth and economic growth, it will be very hard to solve climate change. The proof of that is that despite all the advances in energy efficiency and investment in green energy, carbon emissions per capita are still going up. I do not have the solution, but growth within a finite system is a problem, no matter how you slice it.
@MilitanT07
@MilitanT07 2 года назад
Sure then vow for limiting the white population since they consume the most.
@divyanshusingh7124
@divyanshusingh7124 Год назад
As an Indian scholar of social studies I would like to clear one thing about our sterilization program. The reason why many liberal people of the congress party were for family planning and paid special attention to Lower class Indians; OBCs, Muslims, SCs, STs, is because their fertility rate was much higher than upper class and upper caste Indians, often reaching to more than 5 in many areas. The Indian policy at the time was not driven by the goal of eugenics. While racism and casteism was prevalent and would have made family planning more appealing to many people, it was never a priority of the policy makers. India was a country starving most of the time until that point. Unemployment was and is still a big problem in the country. That was a time when policy making wasn't as advanced as it is today. It would have been possible to provide resources with certain policies but that seemed impossible to everyone. Family planning was forced to elites as well. In the service conduct rules for IAS, IES, ESE and other government officers, restrictions were imposed on the number of children one could have. Additionally, fines were placed which were (and are) followed. And most importantly, lack of family planning by certain regions of the country has created a big problem in Indian polity. This has to do with the distribution of seats for our parliament. Southern States promoted family planning and their population dropped. Their level of development increased at a much faster rate than the rest of the country. But this meant that Northern States which did not implement family planning policy to the same level resulted in increase of population. This meant that if seats were redistributed according to population of each state then sincere southern states would have faced a penalty for being good at their job. As a result of this conflict, Indian state wise seat distribution has not changed since the year 1961 and is not likely to change until 2031 at least. The policy of mass sterilization, barbaric by today's standards, still finds support amongst Indians. Yes Human rights were violated and you would be correct to blame the elite and Americans for it. Still, you must understand that the policy was supported by the masses at the time.
@archstanton5973
@archstanton5973 2 года назад
I was describing to a sibling about how I had recently read about how MURCA! consumed somewhere in the neighborhood of 25% the world's entire resources. However, it was the TIME of WHEN I spoke to him about this: it was the latter 1980s when I had already graduated college and had been working for a coupla years and was researching about where I was going to go to grad school so I remember that it was around 1988. For those too young to know, but in the 1980s China was a NOTHING on the economic blip and instead it was Japan that was the economic firecracker. So when I had that discussion with the sibling I was making the argument that if MURCA! with its then 200 million population was consuming 25% of the worlds resources IN THE 1980s *what about if and when the "developing world" "catches up economic consumption-wise" with MURCA!?* Now remember in the 1980s IMPOVERISHED China was an absolute nothing of concern to anyone and was on NOBODY's radar. Now over 3 decades later China consumes and emits twice that of MURCA!: but, BUT this is based on China having more than 4 times the population of MURCA! AND is BY FAR the world's largest - BY FAR - manufacturing nation on the globe. *And ON A PER CAPITAL BASIS, China still only consumes 1/4 that of MURCA! AGAIN ON A PER CAPITA BASIS.* *So what happens when China reaches 1/2 or 2/3rds the PER CAPITA of MURCA!? Then is MURCA! and China both together going to be consuming over 50% of earth's resources JUST BETWEEN THE TWO?? THAT DOESN'T LEAVE MUCH WIGGLE ROOM FOR THE OTHER 50%!* *IMPOVERISHED India RIGHT NOW already consumes and emits just 1/2 of what MURCA! consumes BUT WITH FOUR TIMES THE POPULATION and consumes 1/4th of what China consumes WITH A NEAR EQUAL POPULATION. What happens IF India reaches consumption and emission levels of MURCA!?* *The numbers just don't add up for the earth's resources.*
@feynmanschwingere_mc2270
@feynmanschwingere_mc2270 2 года назад
Excellent post. That's why socialism is inevitable. Marx was a visionary. He saw the future. He knew where capitalism, with it's rationalizations about "scarcity" and 'optimal pricing' and 'equilibrium' and 'factors of production," was going. Monopolies would form and eventually it would be a race to the bottom. And that's exactly what we are seeing now. We have a climate crisis as we speak and: India, Brazil, Nigeria and other huge populations are just NOW starting to modernize their energy infrastructure to optimize their political economies. By 2045, the problem will be so gargantuan we will likely be in crisis. Funny, they never mention how the MURCA!? (hahaha, i laughed out loud reading your excellent post) capitalists used indentured servitude (i.e. NOT the free market) and slavery (i.e. NOT the free market) to build the country. So they built their country not by "laissez faire" mercantilism, but through good old slavery just like the old empires of antiquity (well, some of them at least). And what did China do? Take the best elements of central planning/Lenin-style communism and mixed it with a hybrid form of state-sanctioned capitalism. China is more or less the worlds most important economy, even more so than America. The problem is the entire field of economics is sociopathic: maximize utility for every individual; maximize profits for firms; screw the environment and call it a "negative externality" (firms just dump the waste in the lake/river/sea/ocean, destroy the environment - the ocean is acidifying at a spectacular rate - and then bribe politicians to run interference for them). What happens when EVERY individual wants to maximize their utility in some game-theoretic optimization scheme? What happens when EVERY firm wants to maximize profit? Infinite growth leads to barrenness. We need a more sustainable model and that will inevitably be some iteration of socialism. Too many people too feed, not enough resources to go around (and Billionaires hoarding everything while crying poor). Socialism is the cure (and no, I do not advocate for a heavily centralized Lenin-style bureacracy, but some form of anarcho-syndicalism). Capitalism will either innovate (thanks to government funding, i.e. "socialism" which, for instance, gave us the internet) or it will have to move over for more sustainable model. The "greed is good" philosophy has to end. We can innovate our way out of hell (and that's what will happen when the ice caps melt...hell on earth mixed with extreme winters colder than anything we've ever experience in modernity).
@archstanton5973
@archstanton5973 2 года назад
@@feynmanschwingere_mc2270 : *I messed up with that "China + MURCA! NUMBERS" BECAUSE I FAILED TO ADD INTO THE EQUATION OF EUROPE.*
@scottcharney1091
@scottcharney1091 Год назад
True, but please stop shouting.
@korypedersen9768
@korypedersen9768 2 года назад
Holy moly this video is big. Absolutely incredible job, Sana. Gonna bookmark this one for sure.
@scottcharney1091
@scottcharney1091 Год назад
True, but this video is, in part, disingenuous. There's some important stuff that they leave out: the desire to prevent people from being born into poverty, the desire to prevent people from being born into suffering of any type, the decline in total fertility rates we're seeing in most of the world, etc. I give thanks every day for my vasectomy.
Далее
How To Start A War And Get Away With It
17:04
Просмотров 350 тыс.
УГОСТИЛ БЕЛКУ МОРОЖЕНЫМ#cat #cats
00:14
MINECRAFT CREPPER EXPLODES SHARK PUPPET!
00:15
Просмотров 7 млн
Noam Chomsky - Why Does the U.S. Support Israel?
7:41
"I was forced into adoption because I'm Black"
14:59
Просмотров 67 тыс.
How The Threat Of China Was Made In The USA
24:05
Просмотров 653 тыс.
How Britain Used India To Replace Slave Labor
11:57
Просмотров 812 тыс.
Texas Conservatives Fear “Takeover” By Immigrants
17:55
How Korea’s Sex Trade Was Built For U.S. Soldiers
14:59
Why Israel Matters to Americans
19:56
Просмотров 866 тыс.
The Great Replacement Theory Explained
24:31
Просмотров 1,3 млн