Thanks for sharing such a beautiful song with us. I'm certain that both Robin and Barry were missing Mo so very much here. Those shared leads were just amazing and everyone who experienced this live performance, including Charles, William and Harry, didn't realize just how blessed they were at the time. Continue to RIP precious Robin and Mo. 😢🙏
Robin's singing is phenomenal. If you want to hear my favorite of Robin singing this song, check out the acoustic version: "Flowers in our garden (Robin Gibb to love somebody acoustic)"
This is so raw, I feel the emotions from them both after losing Maurice. It must be so hard trying not to show these feelings to the world. They dont have to hide them as it comes thru their music and so powerful. They have helped me in my lows & highs. They have been there since the '70. Love & miss you all. Thanks for these ledgends. Mary from Sth Australia
Totalmente Impresionante y Hermosa La Voz de Robin, Maravillosa, Potente, Llena de Sentimiento. Casi a capela hace la introducción y no necesita la música para llenar perfectamente ese enorme espacio y auditorio. Solo su Voz, esa Voz increíble e inolvidable. Y luce muy guapo mi adorado Robin ❤❤❤
@@BGWhispererso every time someone compliments Robin, you're obligated to turn it into a Barry compliment? How dare anyone compliment him and not Barry. Good grief you're childish.
Suena maravillosa,mejor que la version de Barry, tu eres fans de Barry y nl ves las diferencias vocales, aquii Robini canta como siempre, excelente, son voces distintas pero tu y tu amiga dirmpre entrarn para insultar a Robin, de manera macabra, que murio de cancer consumido por su ego y solo porque nadie lo queria, que era una persona desagradable, eso escribieeron tu y tu amiga en otro video, donde Barry csnta esta csncion y yo somo puse que hsbia sido escrita por Barry y Robin, ahi conenzaron los insultos hacia Robin y con que odio! @@kthor
Absolutely mesmerizing rendition of one of the Bee Gees best hits that brings Maurice back to the stage with them in the minds of us long time admirers. May Barry enjoy many more years as a performer and spokesperson of the immortal fame of Bee Gees. 🥰
@@BGWhispereragain? Just can't let someone compliment Robin without dropping Barry's name? PS you missed a couple of a comments here complimenting Robin. Quick, go find them and add some Barry praise or negativity about Robin.
Nosso eterno ❤❤Robin maravilhoso ❤❤Aí vem Barry outro maravilhoso ❤❤o que dizer dessas duas feras, infelizmente uma se foi ❤❤❤❤Amo eternamente Bee Gees 👏👏
Both beautiful Barry and beautiful Robin whom I am sure at the time were truly missing beautiful Maurice. That performance was packed with raw emotion.
Que penita sentí por Robin se le notaba lo malito que estaba, su voz ya no era la misma 😢, aún así acompañó a Barry, aunque aún no se sabía nada de su enfermedad sólo él sabía la realidad de su estado de salud, Barry se dió cuenta de lo mal que estaba antes de ponerse grave, él siempre soportó su enfermedad en silencio, Dios lo tenga en gloria, lo mismo que a Mo. QDDG 🌹🙏🌹.Barry siempre guapo y divino. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
@@tuboto9 - Anyone who is THAT thin is not healthy. Personally, being scrawny has never been a problem for me. His gastrointestinal malformation, the same one that killed his twin, was no doubt bothering him for a while. He had been having abdominal pain for a long time and ignored it and he was unable to eat, not to mention severe depression over the loss of his twin. His strict vegan diet was very unhealthy for him due to his undiagnosed health issues. That is not healthy person.
Robin, como está lindo , nessav apresentação! Voz unica, incomparável, essa canção é lindíssima, já o vi cantar essa ,canção, sem os irmãos, como o Maurice, fez falta para os irmãos, e para os fãs. Obrigada Bee Gees, por tudo o que fizeram pela música, e pior nos , seus admiradores. Robin, meu querido, sinto sua falta, saudades de você. Descanse em paz, você, e Maurice..Nós te amamos muito! Beijos 💋 💋 💋 meu bem com muito amor! Ate um dia!
It sure seemed that way didn't it. That raw emotion. Was this the first time they performed together after Mo passed? Had to be so rough... On them both... Yet therapeutic in a way also. 💔💔💔
@@Александра-с6ю2ь - If this is horrible the simplest solution is don't watch it. Robin was called the "Pavarotti of pop" (David Leaf music critic), the best voice of his generation (Paul Gambaccini music critic) and praised by his peers like Elton John who actually tried to mimic him doing "August October". BARRY said "He has one of the best voices I ever heard, better than mine and he sings without any effort." (*Source - Daily Mirror 1969 and this was said in fact during their split), Roger Daltry of the Who said "He sings as though his heart is on the outside", BARRY'S friend David English "He had the best white soul voice of his generation". Of course what the hell would BARRY himself and so many others know compared to an expert like yourself. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. ☺"Antics" have nothing to do with talent. Barry was just having another hissy fit....you know Barry, the brother that was fighting with all three of his brothers when they died. I guess all three must have been terrible people.
@@Александра-с6ю2ь - I've encountered you before. You are very hateful. Can you not just say you didn't like him and leave it at that without the insults?....and you repeat it OVER AND OVER. Did you not read what BARRY said? Notice that was a QUOTE. Mo said the same. Their mother said "Robin had a beautiful voice. When he sang it gave me chills". All of them must have been dreamers too, LOL. If you "didn't look any further" how do you know what "antics" he did on this video? None.Have a Merry Christmas Grinch. 🤪🙄
@@susieq9801muy buena respuesta, esta señora es fans de Barry y siempre entra a criticar a Robin, ha dicho cosas monstruosas de el, que el cancer ll mato por ser una mala persona, y wue murio solo!😢😢 es muy triste! Adoro a Robin y aqui csnta muy bien, al final se le ve tan feliz!❤❤❤
@@estelacobas4416 - None of the brothers were perfect. Saying vicious things about a dead man is pathetic. Robin died a prolonged terrible death but people still find a need to attack him. He worked for many good causes that I doubt they even know about and was nominated for a knighthood but died before it was bestowed. His life was music and he carried on bravely until he couldn't any longer. Barry is a musical icon although not without his bad points but if someone points them out they are labelled as haters or liars....no just truth tellers. I don't hate Barry but by pointing out some bad things he did they say I must hate him. Notice when I post things I use quotes and sources. They do not.
Maravillosa, sentimental e inolvidable melodía; la bailábamos en un ladrillito en los años 70's. Es una canción que me hace recordar tiempos muy gratos, plenos de alegría... Luís, Venezuela
Bee-yoo-ti-ful! It sounded like a total tribute to Maurice. I love Barry’s strong, distinct, take-charge return after letting Robin get more involved in the tribute. And he looked really sharp in that suit.
@T Wariner LETTING him ? What's your source for that? And not because you THINK that's how it went down. I can equally say it was Robin who "let" Barry be part of HIS tribute to Mo, if not actually having facts about anything is the basis for comments like yours.
Well, this rendition just proved that Robin was right when he thought he should be the lead more. Robin taking the lead on the 1st verse made this song even more spectacular; should have always been done this way.
Robin’s voice isn’t as good for the original song and that’s a fact. Barry’s is. This song will always be Barry’s and there’s no song of Barry’s that any Barry fan or more neutral fan would say Robin should’ve sang over him. But this version was a nice addition. I view it as a tribute to Maurice by both his brothers. It was good of Barry to give Robin the first part BECAUSE Robin should be involved in the tribute to Maurice. And then Barry came in strong and got it going, as if saying, “I got this.” It was in good hands once again. And no, it shouldn’t have been done like this any other time. This was an exception.
@@BGWhispererffs you can't even just stfu and leave a tribute to their dead brother, and especially Rob's twin, alone and NOT turn it into a crap on Robin and his voice comment? Pathetic.
Barry was at odds with all three brothers when they died including congenial Mo and Barry's supposed "twin" Andy. Were Mo, Andy and Robin ALL to blame?
@@susieq9801What do you think? Andy was a nightmare. Barry resorted to tough love in a phone call and regretted it afterward, saying that wasn’t him. Are you questioning Barry’s and Andy’s close relationship? Devilish of you. They were the best of friends, and Andy hero-worshipped Barry. I’m sure Andy is sitting there in heaven with nothing but love for his dear brother. Who knows what went on with Barry and Mo. Do you know? I don’t think so. So maybe you should keep quiet. Barry and Maurice always had a good relationship. Maurice always chose to stay with Barry. They were just going through a rough patch, and I’m sure if they haven’t already worked it out they will on the other side. Maurice, too, always looked at Barry with such love and respect. Robin and Barry always had a complicated relationship. I think Barry’s description of Robin as a fair-weather friend about sums it up. At the end Robin had done something that hurt Barry deeply. We can only assume that was the straw that broke the camel’s back. I think Barry had complicated feelings about Robin long after he was gone. But I’m sure Barry and Robin will have a good talk someday and there may be some changes and new perspectives there. I know Barry’s worked very hard to forgive all his brothers. Most likely especially Robin. The fact that Barry had to forgive them may answer your question. According to Barry’s brothers Barry is kind, gentle, compassionate, a peacekeeper, and multi-talented, among other things. What does that tell you about Barry? Please take your hard-on of hate and leave Barry alone. You really like to kick a good man when he’s down. The Barry hate with you is always strong. 🐍 🥾
@@BGWhisperer - You really like to kick a good man when he's down". Well, you kick a man who is really down, six feet under. In spite of your claims, I repeat, I do NOT hate Barry but I do think he's far from the sainted being you think. They were all complicated individuals in a complicated familial relationship.
Your dead ones will live. Isaiah 26:19 As the last enemy, death is to be brought to nothing. 1 Corinthians 15:26 For the living are conscious that they will die; but as for the dead, they are conscious of nothing at all Ecclesiastes 9:5 Your dead ones will live. A corpse of mine-they will rise up. Awake and cry out joyfully, YOU residents in the dust! For your dew is as the dew of mallows, and the earth itself will let even those impotent in death drop in birth. Isaiah 26:19 "Do not marvel at this, because the hour is coming in which all those in the memorial tombs will hear his voice and come out" John 5:28,29 Jesus said to her: “I am the resurrection and the life. He that faith in me, even though he dies, will come to life; and everyone that is living and faith in me will never die at all. Do you believe this?” She said to him: “Yes, Lord; I have believed that you are the Christ the Son of God, the One coming into the world. John 11:25-27 But when this which is mortal puts on immortality, then the saying will take place that is written: “Death is swallowed up forever.” “Death, where is your victory? Death, where is your sting?” The sting producing death is sin, but the power for sin is the Law. But thanks to God, for he gives us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ! 1 Corinthians 15:54-57 And he will wipe out every tear from their eyes, and death will be no more, neither will mourning nor outcry nor pain be anymore. The former things have passed away.” And the One seated on the throne said: “Look! I am making all things new.” Also, he says: “Write, because these words are faithful and true.” Revelation 21:4, 5
