Roy Keane & Jamie Carragher clash over their combined Liverpool 2020 and Man Utd 1999 XI | MNF 

Schmichael, irwin, van dijk, stam, neville , scholes, keane, giggs, beckham, cole, yorke

correct list peter s taa vvd stam roberston keane scholes beckham mane salah yorke 6/11 players make it, 442 traditional, and it's only team that assigns players to their most beneficial positions

Ali Dia as captain!

Pranav Ravichandran in a shite league

4-3-3 GK Schmeichel RB Neville CB Stam CB Van Dijk LB Irwin CM Scholes CM Keane CAM Salah LW Giggs RW Beckham ST Yorke

@@shahinuzzamanchowdhury5942 i find it very sad that people are not letting that go. his brother forgave him so i dont see why everyone else cant. holding onto anger is like drinking poison and expecting the other person to die.

Matt Thompson his brother never won the treble alongside him

lord hannibal because his brother is a better man than he is

@ lord hannibal - The fact his brother forgave him suggests his brother is a great man. Ryan remains what he was.

What the hell does that have to do with pickiing a best XI ?

Lol

chazza JJ ikr literally no one in Liverpool midfields makes it there all nothing compared to united midfielders

Hard to argue against Giggs if it was about their whole career but based on that season vs this season it has to be Mane.

@@lewismckenzie236 Exactly, roy is on about longevity, carra is about logic. Its silly to compare these 2 teams anyway. 20 yrs apart and different system.

@chazza JJ giggs is a great player on the pitch...off ....not so sure

He kind of lost the argument there lol

What an argument 😂

Giggs is so underrated man. Mané is incredible, but the way how Giggs played can't be compared to Mané.

@@putinusername just imagine if he played for England not Wales

Unfair to judge each Man U player by stats bcs Liverpool didn’t have to rotate so all the players got tonnes of apps whereas Man U rotations were necessary.

Dennis Irwin never gets the recognition he deserves.

Pele Maradona and Zidane? Really?!

Messi? Ronaldo? Fernandes?

Who tf is irwin 🤣

@@rsj6636 this shows your lack of football knowledge. Get out please

Boring.

Hahahaha!

hahahahahaha

😂😂😂

dublin boy no, not boring

@Michael Davis Yeah but it's different when someone else does it.

It's okay to slag off your own family. But when an outsider does it, it's war.

@Michael Davis He's fallen out with like three of them including Ferguson. That's hardly most.

Picks them purely on loyalty, not evidence 😂

Fez zer the prawn sandwich brigades, best ex man u by far. He picks team loyalty then carra more emotionally

I was surprised to laugh a few times at his comments as well, he definitely knows his stuff

@@racclng "I'd maybe stick Gary in there, coz he gets me tickets for Salford"

@Ricky Bowen nah, you replying to every comment is cringe just stfu

There are many colourful words to describe Roy Keane but I’ve never considered “reserved” to be one of them.

He tackled Alfie Haaland and ended his career on purpose because he wanted revenge. If that isn't stone hearted, I dunno what is

Ye but giggs is defo better than mane the way he played was the biggest factor the importance he was to the goals that were scored not by him much but he was a massive factor in the creation and i love mane myself but he still has lots to prove to be compared to giggs but mane will be a legend in the end of his career i can see it ps man u fan hope u understand the opinion

@@itzjohn1242 absolutely can see what you're saying...to be even start to compare is a massive accolade to Mane...if any real comparison is truly possible Mane has to get a bunch more seasons of greatness and trophies under his belt. I'm a massive Giggs fan (not just because we share birthdays) and as I've grown older I've dropped the silly thing where people can't appreciate each others players. I was always a fan of so many Man United players as a kid...Cantona one of my all timers because of the way he played the game and him as a man...so Mane, brilliant, but still a great work in progress! Take care my friend!

@@johngeorge1977 yeah m8 absolutely right atleast u know facts i am looking forward to next season united are looking like they can challenge next year and finally have the rivalry we have been missing

@@johngeorge1977 we need go all out to win the europa league because it wud be a great boost towards next yr

Lol I love u dude. I'm a man u fan

Both him and his son seems like a bit of tit.

They had a fight in a hotel or something

pastore perplexity virgin

3lake Skuxx fan channel I wish your mum was one too.

brilliant berbatov your 12 sisters don’t count mate

no point in including him if thats his logic lol

@Timothy Dexter he's 27... He's not that old lol

@Timothy Dexter give him the chance to play past 30 and we'll see

Mane is the best player in 2020

‘I got loyalty towards Giggs’’ that’s what his brother said then he shagged his wife

He’s never stopped being a captain.

I noticed how je said that here's, but has upped himself a bout before, & bashes players, esp liverpool & arsenal players

I think we can all agree that Roy Keane was far more than an average player, if he came in to the premier league now he’d probably be in the top 3 midfielders in the prem, top 7 or 8 in the world perhaps

@@mrsensible3560 That’s a lie lol

Describing himself as average is crazy, he was world class.. but yeah showed great humility.

@@obrianlewis3273 no even when Schmeichel played for Man utd him and Roy keane didn't like each other

@@liamjohnston5099 and Schmeichel played for Man City

They had a fight

Closest he's ever been to tears.

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

😂🤣🤣

I watched that bit about 5 times, Roy's reactions was pudit gold

Gigs scored in 21 years no player will ever be more consistent as gigs in premier legue

Legend and only he can pull off trolling & sarcasm in the same sentence

I'd love to have a beer with him Robbo and Whiteside.

dublin boy shush

haha brilliant

@@kevyarham Robbo and Whiteside?! You'd die by all accounts of those two.

😊

Timestamps? Ah jeez, really?

ThatGuysJokes

@@russian5470 I nearly broke Russian's leg

@@ottocooper4256 Otto Cooper want to be the star too often

A pity Saipan Roy wasn't so loyal to his country.

fr tho "you're putting mane instead of giggs? but i'm loyal to giggs" like that's an actual argument lol

What country? As long as Ireland is not an united island ... it will never be a country.

@@brians1902 so he doesn’t live in a country?

Roy is a always spot on

Badfan he’s talking about the man’s character. Character is what makes you a winner

People keep going on about Keane being honest too. No point in praising honesty when hes wrong. Hes picking players because hes biased and based on nostalgia. Schmeichel TAA VVD Stam Irwin Keane Scholes Beckham Salah Firmino Mane

Dion Byrne Beckham wasn’t a central midfielder so how does that work?

@@GhostofCTC He could easily play CM. Throw in Fabinho then if Beckham doesnt suit. Keane and Carra had Beckham in there.

Vandalle you have to think about it. Who has the pen? 🤣

Vandalle er, that's one way of looking at it... Keane is actually basing his on results, trophies, attitude, drive, and years of consistency To bin that team so a scouser can rub one out on air is pretty sad really

@@Treeesmith Yeah but they arent supposed to base it on years of consistency. It isnt 1995 - 1999 and 2014 - 2020. Its Just supposed to be based on the performances from one year (1999 and 2020)

@@danielross5931 ok then a full United 11 it is then... Treble winners Europe agaisnt Barca Inter Juventus Bayern Fa cup against Newcastle Chelsea Liverpool Arsenal.

Smudger but it has to be picked for a one off game. Of course the man united players achieved more in the careers! Will that still be true by the end of the current Liverpool players careers? Who knows. You have to go based off a one off game. If Liverpool had all those man united players in their prime Available for them this weekend, who would play?

Completely agree.

yes spot on. the point keane is making is "come back to me when they've won the treble".

Peter Francis still waiting 🤣.

Wasn’t comparing their careers they was comparing their seasons

Spot on John.

correct list alisson taa vvd stam roberston keane scholes beckham mane salah yorke 5/11 players make it, 442 traditional

DB9 saru Irwin has to make it over Robertson, agree with everything else though.

@@db9saru155 no.

@@db9saru155 Robertson ahahahahahaahahhahhah!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

@@db9saru155 schemical in net

tbf playing with them can entail a finer detail to how you perceive them in ways we can't really grasp. sure, keane isn't an eloquent thinker and he admits that, he uses his memory of playing with & comparing without structure to modern players but it doesn't mean carra's opinion is any better because he is trying to formulate it more. old head vs slightly less old head in reality id put both of them to shame no questions

lol to be fair to keane having played in one of the teams it does make it more difficult

​@@imedi Yeah it is but he has to try to be impartial though, im always fascinated by how rudimentary a thinker Keane is for someone who led such great football teams

@@ridaa6789 Makes perfect sense now why he failed as a manager.

I think much of Keane’s comments were a bit of a wind up towards the end. Smirking 😏 like a Cheshire Cat.

I agree with you. And to back up your point, I am in fact, currently on a Roy Keane highlights spree (his playing days, as well as punditry days!)

@Ricky Bowen 199 likes and you say cringe. What a fkn clown. What's cringe about appreciating someones class?

That's his job.

@@Xiphactinus 😂😂😂👌

If England had a Keane back in the 90s they would have been a different team and gone further

He always has that look in his eye that he’s analysing your opinion and if he doesn’t like it , a two footed tackle is coming your way 🤣

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Love Keane more and more every year

@illegit jesus that happened quickly........ is what we would say if he blew his load😂

Exactly what I was thinking last night

WarriorofSparta Ole will fix that, don't you worry

@@Treeesmith i believe in him, we need to get rid of a couple idiots, pogba, lingard, sanchez, sign a world class player or 2 and we're back up there

5th actually and closing on 4th.

Not a United fan, but aren't y'all playing well now? Two PL wins in a row and tore Club Brugge apart

😆

@IRISH LAD 🤣🤣🤣

@IRISH LAD if there's a god it's his work. Leeds aswell 😂😂😂

Well he is wrong because PSG were given the league with 5 points and Liverpool are 25 points ahead so yh we are probably going to win it

@@rich3905 probably worst thing that could happen to liverpool. If it's given to them before the season officially ends, they will have to listen to it for decades. Opposition fans will sing songs about it.

Blair101 Gotta love it great Tv 😂😂

So the loyalty he goes on about so much can be bought? Interesting

@@thedunyadoneya2628 it was a joke relax

Timestamp?

@@AliAhmed-oe4vc 14:30

Larry David 😂😂😂

Will you ever get cheryl back?

I thought this was a joke until he actually said it haha

@@thelonesoldier4518 I live it. No need for a replay.

@@marks8898 she's with Ted now.

:-) lol

They’d come 3rd

Nothing

hahahahaha

Davéjàvu stfu

amazing

@@trymencity6085 🤣

tbf playing with them can entail a finer detail to how you perceive them in ways we can't really grasp. sure, keane isn't an eloquent thinker and he admits that, he uses his memory of playing with & comparing without structure to modern players but it doesn't mean carra's opinion is any better because he is trying to formulate it more. old head vs slightly less old head in reality id put both of them to shame no questions, but it is simply that keane isn't the best person to be there to debate these topics. he isn't a critical thinker, but that doesn't necessitate he has bad opinions. a great player recognises great talent, it's quite simple. footballers like ronaldinho probably weren't great thinkers in this context but they speak the language of football by actually playing learn to respect legends, like myself. im a timeless tactician and you need to show some humility to those above you

That's like City Midfield vs Liverpool midfield

Character/mindset is very important though, u could be the most technically gifted player but if u havent got the right mindset, u wont last long, eg Adriano(brazilian), ben arfa(france)

Ironically that's what MU lacking the most this season.

It is a myth that modern players are more technical. They have higher levels of fitness because the game is moving faster but they do not control the ball in a technical fashion at all hence why english players do not look technical at all.

‘Good lad, from a good family, great character’

False modesty. He knows he was a great.

@phosphorescent wave Indeed, say what you like about Roy, he has never been a bragger. He just calls it as he sees it when it comes to others.

He was average in terms of natural ability. There is obviously a lot more to football than just that however.

@@johnroyal4520 Agreed. Roy's class came from his work rate and his attitude - 100% full on, in every game, every season.

@@guttersnippeesmithers3905 you dickhead

And yet he still chose Schmeichel. Shows his honesty

@@GobbleWobble123 TBF, choosing Schmeichel is an easy decision.

@@sushil.k.s84 if you dont like someone, its easy to not be able to look past that

@@aediasse that's keano

aediasse Agree ! That was uncalled for

.

4-3-3 has been around since 1950s but yeah i get what u mean it's more regular now

If I was a manager now I'd still play 4-4-2 just as a nice balance

wow thanks for that magnificent breakdown, i would never have been able to understand diffrrence between 4-3-3 and 4-4-2 lolss

@Ricky Bowen no

dude was head bleeding at finals if i'm not mistaken and still kept playing

He was a true captain. He still defends his teammates 20 years on. I can imagine how much everyone in that team loved each other as brothers almost

Very humble, but he carried the entire team with his influence and leadership.

They were both biased. Roy was just very honest about it.

He was just having a laugh

Yep, that Roy, and dam I love him!

Whole segment was pointless when one of the players is from one of the teams in discussion and the other isn’t.

Tbf they shouldnt have brought keane for this.....because i would be biased when it comes to my mates.....

Ben Phillipson I would to tbf

It was stupid really and I felt the same

Incredulous he was

Ben Phillipson carra is honest and fair. Something Keane cant comprehend

IRISH LAD integrity is not strong with some of you

I like chocolate milk and that's not up for debate.

It’s non existent nowadays unfortunately...

Bang on but not just footballers, all walks of life

Spoken like every knob lucky enough to never have seen war, but stupid enough to fancy it.

@@ViolentFEAR I don't think you get his point

@@ViolentFEAR Says Mister ViolentFEAR haha

@Ricky Bowen not really but ok

@Ricky Bowen nothing worse than people that don’t know what cringe means

Bart Homme is there a reason he doesn’t like Peter?

@@MCee97 maybe because he played for city?

He was talking about a fight when drinking 😂

@@MCee97 in his book he talks about Schmeical whining about having to give up the captaincy when Keane came back from injury

Except for trent and vvd poor Gary Neville lol.

gary neville was actually a terrible footballer

Roy over rating Gary neville so bad

DB9 saru no he wasnt

DB9 saru clearly know nothing about football. So can’t take you serious

@Ricky Bowen any links ?

😂😂😂 Roy Keane wouldn’t risk it, that’s like saying yall knock out Tony Adams just ain’t happening 😂😂😂😂

Got to give it to Keane plays the hard man until he met jon Walters

not roy's style....he'll walk out and quit instead.

Then have a beer with black eyes afterwards

He getting red card

Gotta love Roy

😂

Signs yes you do

@@hayden990 No you dont. At least half of Ireland despises him for walking out on World Cup.

As good as united were then,would they have been able to cope with the fitness and speed of this liverpool team?

robbie g racism

@@mouha9981 If only you actually experienced racism, it would be good for you

@@mouha9981 Racism? Ffs...

@@mouha9981?

How is that racism

Carn5haun 85 so true, the mans a great

He was a great great player and captain most important player in the United team in his whole career there. Dragged United through so so many games

mad respect for his loyalty for past teammates

He kicked a ball around for a living, hardly the battle of the Somme

phil hems do you not actually remember Roy Keane as a united player? The guy was an absolute warrior

VinMan this has absolutely killed me 🤣

Love this 🤣🤣🤣

Timestamp?

VinMan pishing myself laughing 😂

people only started paying attention to stats after messi and ronaldo. when comparing zidane and ronaldinho you never said 'well ronaldinho scored more goals this season so therefor he's better.'

Aye Giggs played left side midfield in a 442 for the majority of his career, very different to the role of a modern winger

That and neither Salah or Mane are actual wingers

Comparing the stats to Ginolas makes Giggs look worse. He had 13 g+a for Spurs in the league, more than 25% of the goals they scored while finishing 11th. Giggs had 4 goals and 1 assist for the champions who scored 80. Overmars scored 6 and assisted 13 in the league in the same season for Arsenal, from roughly the same position. There's more of a reliance on wingers to score now sure, but they've always been creators. Giggs is also generally massively overrated, but that's a different story.

@@BigDoniel i remember a 35-36yo giggsy mansplaining football to inter's players. i don't think he is overrated. and i think giggsy would be better than mane in this liverpool team, which lacks creativity compared to some other big teams

Got too big for his boots though hence why fergie fucked him of

That's actually a good idea for a folder

You have a video folder

@@tadhgokeeffe310 yes he does, is there an issue there?

Not a single player from ‘99 would make the current Liverpool team. Not fit enough. A few pints after the game doesn’t cut it any more.

@@phreffable shut up

@@phreffable your logic is stupid, your telling me you wouldn't take a prime Maradona or Pele with their abilitys and today's techniques and fitness applied to them because that's the way you have to look at. Not say I wouldn't take George best because he liked a few shandy drugs and women any other way off applying logic to these teams becomes irrelevant otherwise and is a pointless discussion.

@@phreffable beckham,keane stam actually would have walk in that squad easily

@@phreffable Stam, Becks, Irwin, and Cole/Yorke arguably.. You could argue for Gomez as he's got so much more pace than Stam ever had, which suits today's game who tends to play with high backlines, it's not like United's defence was that solid as well on that season. 37 goals conceded.. While the midtable teams weren't as solid as today. Cole/Yorke vs Firmino.. It only depends on your preference tbh. Goalscorer, or an all-round player who can involve himself in a game without the needs of scoring a goal. Alisson on top of Schmeichel. Again,, 37 goals conceded. And alisson is way more skilled than Peter ever was. Could start a break with his throws and kicks as well as he's got some accuracy in his pass. Alisson all day. Maybe Scholes is the only certain one. But other than that, not so sure. Mane over Giggs anyday as well.

He murmured towards the end 9:52

*googles "obdurate"*... *writes it on back of hand to throw into earliest possible conversation.*

Sam Jennings Keanes logic was legit, carragher just a fan boy

Love Roy's no nonsense demeanour, always looks like he's about to punch somebody, not a guy you'd mess with!

haha highly entertaining

The 1999 United team is 10x better than the Liverpool team

what a pointless exercise this combined XI becomes when stubborn people are brought to debate.

Adam I wouldn’t say they are ten times better. That’s just hyperbole and bias talking. It’s a fools errand trying to pick the best players from two different teams, playing two different systems and over 20 years apart. But I’m a fool so this is what I picked in the Sky Sports poll they did. I’m a Liverpool fan by the way. 433 Schemichael Alexander Arnold Stam Van Dijk Irwin Scholes Henderson (don’t hate me) Keane Mane Cole Giggs Honestly though, apart from the ‘keeper, TAA,Stam, Van Dijk, Scholes, Keane and Mane, I’d easily be convinced to swap all the other players.

Stanetti Els Henderson 🤣🤣 fair play though. Personally I don't think this side can be compared to the 90s United, different era and different tactics. You can't win a few trophies and suddenly be touted as the best of all time. If Liverpool dominate the next 5 years I'll change my tune but time will tell

the way they overhyped this liverpool team that have won only one prem title is way too much

People only put giggs because of his career not off that individual season and mane was better than giggs stats prove it and so do my eyes

@@rhysmahoney7805 cant really compare Giggs and mane. Giggs was a natural winger who didn't spend as much time in the opposition box like mane. His main priority was to assist and not shoot when he wants.

@@sheedo1999 different times thats how wingers play now but as of now mane is a better winger because he can assists score and is much funner to watch because he runs past players

@@rhysmahoney7805 Mane is not a Winger but an inside forward. There is a huge difference between those two. Also Giggs was really really good at dribbling past players. Mane's main objective is scoring goals and we can agree that he is very good at it.

He is a true Irish man indeed

@@oscaro3977 We all have that cheeky grin in our locker haha

@Ricky Bowen lol he definitely ain't, United fans get way too excited

For me maybe in 10 years Alexander-Arnold will be in the team over Gary Neville in rightback but now Neville has that position

@Cool Dude Lol. Sure kid, whatever.

12:46 Jamie regretting that😂😂

Just waiting for the next matchday on sky sports

x iTzShuBBz should add Troy Deeny and Adrian 😂😂😂😂

@Yung Lsg Going Invisible is nothing compared to a treble or even a double

Ciaran McCullough especially if done the Arsenal way

Ragnar loooooolllll

lololololol

Tell that to he's brother

*Laughs in Rhodri*

"Had"

Best comment👌

Marsellus Wallace 🤣🤣🤣

She cant be your girlfriend if you didn't know that it was going to be that time🙆🏿‍♂️🤦🏿‍♂️

😂

That clip needs to be made into a meme 😂, somebody get it done!

Yeah, that’s why it’s stupid to compare this Liverpool team to the man utd team of 99. It’s an insult to compare this one season wonder of a team to a team that had almost 15 years of dominance in Europe.

@@relentero8547 England*

@@saidhruv7018 they had dominance in England but also in Europe.

Yeah, they’re comparing 2019/20 and 1998/99 not the players themeselves.

@@relentero8547 dominance in europe? they won one european cup, same as this liverpool team...

And Inter which had Ronaldo and a very good team. Not to mention that after 9 games against those amazing teams they ended up unbeaten.

Liverpool won the league against the best team points wise the premier league has ever seen (centurions) don’t try to make idiotic excuses for Liverpool’s greats success it’s honestly embarrassing

@@louismiller8603 That’s an idiotic argument. The quality of competition was much higher in 1999 compared to 2019, so teams with such high points aren’t particularly impressive

I would not try to talk sense to United fans, waste of time.

Craig Derbyshire he’s just another gypsy who was allowed to kick talented players thanks to British rubbish culture. Vieira at age only 20 showed him how a true talented CM should be. Way more sophisticated & class in Patrick’s game. Now that’s a TOP TOP PLAYER. LEGEND

@@DR-uq4hn they all feared Keane, he was the best mid fielder on the planet.

Rafi David: Such nonsense! Keane was the best midfield player in the world in his position at the time at defending mid player. He could go forward also. Twice the player Vieira was. Remember the match at Highbury when Keane (who was supposed to be too old and injured that time)won man of the match and Utd win 4 v 2. He also scored 2 goals against Arsenal in their prime when Utd won 2 v 1.

@@seanomaolain4150 don't forget he made viera crap his pants before the match in the tunnel as well mate.

Paul Saul According to whom? If it’s by British media then no point even to bother since they always overrated their own. Best in the world ahead of Zidane, Figo, Rui Costa, Albertini, Redondo, Vieira,Makalele,Deschamps,Petit,Seedorf,Davids,Emerson,Gilberto Silva..ect. Are you kidding me? Please 🙄

The Bolge I know van dijk but not van dyk

Van dijk , mane Trent , and Salah , No question about it ,

Zak0 Van Dijk only one who makes it, crossing merchant doesn’t get it, Yorke and Cole> salah and mane

james timmy YORKE , WHO TF IS HE LMAO ,

Zak0 that’s just dumb, if you don’t know who he is then I know your either 10 years old or you know nothing about football, or both, so in that case stop speaking