@@Blast-gp7zq yeah this person did mess up a few times but im pretty sure on the god speed parts of this song its impossible it more than tredecuples the keys several times during it and they failed him when it was pure slow elegance they don’t know music this dude did amazing for a impossible song
@@poopcat6947 Well, kids are cruel. However, unlike Sundowner, I am _very_ not in touch with my inner child, in fact, I would much rather toss a child in an industrial-sized furnace and feed the smoldering ashes to a pack of rabid dogs before even thinking about a child.
I absolutely love how the 10 year old judges are demanding that they “want more elegant” or “it’s too fast and spamming” and then the HOST THEMSELVES is wow’ing at the piece and BEGGING them to press the golden buzzer in chat.
Honestly people who respond with “I don’t remember asking” or something like that are the most annoying people on the planet, and it’s extremely childish to say that in an actual argument too. People are allowed to give their opinions without someone asking. If everyone had to ask for someone’s opinions before the person replies then conversations would last one sentence. You’re allowed to have an opinion that differs from someone and say it and then have a civilized debate without the other person being a man child and saying I don’t remember asking. People who say that just don’t have a good counter argument and they probably think that any person who disagrees with them on the internet is being mean to them. Please never say I don’t remember asking for your opinion unironically. In short, no one needs to ask for anyone to state or share their opinion about anything. It’s called human rights. People shouldn’t be told when or when not to talk in most situations, and people are allowed to talk without being asked. The person who says "who asked" literally dragged THEMSELVES into the conversation, so cant they just deal with what we say whether someone asked or not? and... Who in their right damn mind asks for opinions anyways? (Credit to "Alt 7", "TheFireInside" and the maker of this edited copypasta for helping me roast these unreasonable people. Feel free to copy this comment and any other comments you see that I have posted countering stupid sayings and arguments, nothing else by me but that).
Bro thats so good! and you're very talented since barely anyone can go as fast as you on piano like damn 0-0 anyways keep up the good work! you vids are awesome
The things I always hate about playing Piano in RGT, is that the judges are always way to quick to judge. Edit: People who don't get what I'm say is that, they press the buzzer to quickly and don't have patience
Bro, one of the songs I play a lot starts of with one note at a time in a succession, then before I can even play the good part, the judges vote. I legit started to just play starting from the good part aka the part they start liking it at. Now I forgot the beginning :/
if anything, i'd say the first half of the song is quite elegant elegant doesnt mean slow all the notes feel like they all belong and just carry your ears trough the first part, rush e is honestly made really well
I agree about elegant doesn’t mean slow. I mean, listen to Chopin’s Aeolian Harp etude! Fast af and still one of the most elegant and beautiful pieces ever! AND it’s same level if not harder than rush e. I mean this piece is really not that insanely difficult.
For rush e solo it's almost impossible but if u do the hard version I need 4 people so I'd recommend an easier song bc I'm learning fur elise and I've been learning piano for 3 months now and I'm trying the hard version of fur elise so if it trying to do rush e I wish u good luck
@@supermananimationsstudios8519 Dude, he got what he wanted, he's collected a 2 million views, what did you achieve? Literally NOTHING, your channel are empty as your brain. Honestly, if you are gonna judge someone lifestyle, be prepared to be attacked too.
1:14 as a pianist the fact that someone said “this is just fast and spamming” makes me angry. This is a masterpiece not spamming. I can barely play half the speed of this lol!
What makes it even funnier is that the best comeback she can make is "I didn't ask for your opinion" It's such a mid-tier comeback and it's funny that that's all she can come up with after being straight up denied.
Rush E composed by Andrew Wrangell takes more than 2 or more years to literally revise and play. Even the pianists that play La Campanella have a hard time playing Rush E. By far I can see that the OG Rush E is definetely unplayable by a human. But by far this is the best Rush E copy in ROBLOX. Edit: damn 1.1k likes in A few days
him: *playing rush e at insane speed* judge: nah him: *play fur elise* judge: REAL SHIT EDIT: holy shit 12K like !? i literally stole this comment from another video and change a few letter
What’s really infuriating is that the judges in the server probably have never heard of Rush E and all the backstory and humor behind it. Although I appreciate those who shut down Caila, I still feel very…annoyed Edit: Wow. I have never reached this many likes before
It’s ok if you never heard rush e before but what was outrageous was the fact that they didn’t know how difficult it was to play rush e and have the audacity to say it was too spammy and fast.
@@cityinsect He isn't annoyed at the fact the judges don't know, he's annoyed at the fact that the judges are heavily criticizing a piece that they don't even know how to play, nor how hard it is to play
Just wanted to say from Calla's statement "I want more elegant" I can instantly tell theyve never played piano or any instrument for that matter a day in their life, you do not define music by elegance but merely by pleasure.
‘I don’t care my food was made by a world famous chef it has cyanide in it’ ‘Of course I’ll eat the food from this garbage can, it’s the healthiest thing ever and it tastes great’
@@pair4409 an analogy. Basically, not eating something from a really good person because of a teeny tiny unpleasant substance (in this case, cyanide), but instead opting a worse route because of none of that unpleasant substance.
It’s funny how the judges think it’s “spamming” and that they want it more elegant when being able to do rush e on the piano is really hard but doing it on a computer and in roblox is even harder and then the host is begging them to press the golden buzzer
The fact that some judges were like : "This is spamming" and "it has to be more elegant" Is just... Wow- That was literally RUSH E.. It's supposed to be fast, and it's not spamming. It's TALENT that it was done ON PC.
When I saw them say that, I just thought of some random 5 year old kid with a massive ego fixing his tie while making the most over the top face imaginable
"No sorry." "This is way to fast and spamming." "I want more elegant." "I didn't ask for your opinion." This judge is not only a clown, but the whole circus.
How could you say that???? The circus industry is filled with many hard workers who try their best to make people smile and bring joy into the world. Don’t compare that judge to them!
roblox player : Literally plays an international masterpiece that takes skill to play on a piano, let alone a computer roblox's got talent: This is too fast, spamming and not elegant enough.
@@tsuukkii Yeah I agree. That is why computers will never replace people in the music field and other art forms. The humanity is what makes it what it is. No matter how advanced a computer will eventually be, it won’t be as good as a real person.
@@tsuukkii i am an osu player and a pianist and i think that tremolos are much easier on computer due to how little effort you have to put in to press a key.
@@Tariqblox1 thats somewhat wrong, it really depends on what the piece is, some songs are harder on virtual piano and some are harder on real piano, but keep in, on virtual piano you can't play black and white keys at the same exact time (since you need to press shift for black keys)
@@CIO-Anims so being know as a jealous contrarian liar until you post your rendition is not a good enough motivation for you? well sorry but that’s all your gona get.
@@Spirit_Imagination Still caila is a hypocrite. Caila: I didn't ask for your opinion. Also Caila few seconds later: *shares an opinion tHiS iS tOO fASt aND sPAmMiNG*
@@szadol77 no I know but the way the comment had it seemed like they were confused on why they would say "I didn't ask for your opinion" if nobody said an opinion but her when someone did have an opinion is all I'm saying. I TOTALLY agree they were a hypocrite
The host is the only one that had heard of rush e but he was the only one that could press the golden buzzer is sad Yet he still won is extremely impressive Edit: AYO I forgot I posted this comment it got 635 likes the most I ever got on a comment :)))
y’all gotta stop acting like the judges aren’t fucking 7 years old on kindles and watch roblox role plays on youtube. They can’t comprehend much of anything lmao, trying to get a good review on a fucking roblox judging game is impossible
As much as I love Roblox, its filled with children that can't comprehend. Also the game being pretty much a roleplay game, it's pretty much impossible even if it's filled with like 14up cause there are trolls n stuff.
Exactly bro. Nothing is professional. In PTFS or Roblox flight sim. Kids take off on the taxi place smashing into the terminal . Makes my blood boil but it is Roblox.
Calla: “This is way to fast and spamming” Rush E: “ *Yeah because it’s the hardest song to ever play on a piano and have over thousands of notes, of course it’s spammy and fast* ” The other judge:” *We do not care, we only want performance* “
i love how the judges in this game have absolutely no clue what they're doing important thing to note though. if the judge has shit internet, or a shit computer, the piano will play as if every key is being pressed at once every couple of seconds, so it'll sound bad to them. Caila was probably running her game at 2,000 ping.
Judging from her chat, it looked like she was on mobile with the actually correct grammar but no punctuation. Makes sense since she's probably around 10.
