Тёмный

Russian Myth of Invincibility 

Econ Lessons
Подписаться 20 тыс.
Просмотров 18 тыс.
50% 1

Deeply ingrained in the Russian psyche is a belief that they are impervious to external influences, which finds its roots in a selective interpretation of their history, particularly the 1940s. This belief prompts a fascinating thought experiment: Could a recurring geopolitical pattern exist in which Moscow is occupied every 200 years? And more importantly, when might the world anticipate a transformation of Moscow into a more democratic, peaceful Russia? This potential for change, for a more democratic and peaceful Russia, is a beacon of hope in our geopolitical landscape.

Опубликовано:

 

1 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 492   
@joetuktyyuktuk8635
@joetuktyyuktuk8635 5 месяцев назад
The worst failures of russia militarily, is usually when they try and exert their influence... such as the russo-Japanese war and their naval defeat is a prime example.
@nattygsbord
@nattygsbord 5 месяцев назад
I can also add the Swedish conquest of Moscow in 1610 where the Russians were forced to accept a Swedish King as the new ruler of their country. But since Gustavus Adolphus younger brother was only something like 8 years old did his mother protest much and refused to let him go to Russia to become King there. So negotiations got drawn out, and the tide of war shifted and Sweden was attacked from Denmark. So Sweden had to give up some of its peace demands. But Sweden never the less won the war. And Karelia and Ingria fell into Swedish hands and Russia lost all its access to the Baltic sea with the peace in Stolbova in 1617.
@SveaHovfel-qt6zb
@SveaHovfel-qt6zb 5 месяцев назад
Great. So Russia has no access to the Baltic Sea now? They do? What happened?
@ultraphitaro4834
@ultraphitaro4834 5 месяцев назад
In 1598, the last tsar of the Rurikids (Fedor I) died, civil war and famine began in Russia, as a result of which Russia lost 30% of the population and in some areas up to 50%. And at such a difficult moment for the country, the Poles-Lithuanians decided to invade Russia in 1609 and the Swedes in 1610. It was a completely unnecessary act of aggression. Russians remembered it and the Swedish Empire and the Polish-Lithuanian union were eventually collapsed in the wars with Russia.
@Alex-pd8zi
@Alex-pd8zi 5 месяцев назад
Then in 1648 Ukrainians rebelled and started demise of Poland and rise of Russian empire. Russian empire held Baltic from Swedish border to Kenigsberg. Then Ukrainians rebelled and Sobiets lost Baltics and Finland. Then Lenin was smart to add Soviet Ukrainebto the Union and Soviets won ww2 amd captured Baltics. Then Ukrainians decided to break free and Baltics joined NATO. Then Ukrainians kicked Russians turning 3 day special operation into 3+ year war and Finland join NATO. So now Russia controls tiny strip near Peterburg that NATO can spit over. And Kenigsberg where Russians are surrounded. Russian empire cannot exist without Ukraine.
@roberturbanczyk204
@roberturbanczyk204 5 месяцев назад
There was even a battle of Klushino over WHO will rule russia. Poles have beaten 7x bigger swedish-russian forces in less than few hours. Swedes at least tried to defend their positions. Whole situation ended with Żółkiewski occupying moscow for 2 years
@johnm7267
@johnm7267 5 месяцев назад
What is the point of all this? Are you trying to console yourself by saying Russia will be defeated? Practically every country in Europe has been defeated if you go back far enough.
@tanyaroberson9629
@tanyaroberson9629 5 месяцев назад
A helicopter in Moscow just blew up the other day. That must have been a little bit disconcerting to people there.
@johnm7267
@johnm7267 5 месяцев назад
What rubbish. Do you think similar things don’t happen elsewhere. A fatuous comment
@tanyaroberson9629
@tanyaroberson9629 5 месяцев назад
​@@johnm7267 Its in the Russian news and they arrested the people who torched the helicoptor now. And no it doesn't happen here, I'm in NZ.
@jarcadipane2849
@jarcadipane2849 5 месяцев назад
I understand that a helicopter just fell out of the sky here in the States the other day as well... It was definitely disconcerting to the people here..
@jarcadipane2849
@jarcadipane2849 5 месяцев назад
@@johnm7267 Pay them no mind. What has NZ brought to the world other than kiwi, wine and a obtuse "knowitalls"...
@tanyaroberson9629
@tanyaroberson9629 5 месяцев назад
@@jarcadipane2849 The one in Russia was set on fire by pro Ukraine activists.
@59jm24
@59jm24 5 месяцев назад
I think in modern times ,there are no foreign countries who would want Russia. We wish they would stay there and leave us alone.
@СергейКомисаров-т4ц
@СергейКомисаров-т4ц 5 месяцев назад
Russia cannot do anything without Kyiv’s permission.
@helgeschneider9069
@helgeschneider9069 5 месяцев назад
even Napoleon don't wanted russia. nobody want russia. but russians Like to live in the west
@johnm7267
@johnm7267 5 месяцев назад
Rubbish
@MrDosonhai
@MrDosonhai 5 месяцев назад
@@johnm7267 Care to elaborate? Give me one reason to go to Russia instead of any developed European country?
@maxinabo
@maxinabo 5 месяцев назад
@@MrDosonhai100% u have never visited Russia… Russia is far well off than many European states
@terryfox9344
@terryfox9344 5 месяцев назад
I believe that it time to give them a reminder of their history, The concept of Russian invincibility is a myth.
@Jakez408
@Jakez408 5 месяцев назад
You fascist p_g. Russia liberated Europe from the Nazis and won WW2
@tonyxfury
@tonyxfury 5 месяцев назад
Oh, trust me, Ukrainians been trying to do this for a while with no results. Since 2014 we had popular historical bloggers that were trying to educate average Russians via video chatting. Russians believe all foreign history is a lie, they don’t even read their own adequate historians and one of the reasons Russian invasion happened is because Russians are taught an illusionary history from school to universities, which is used as a tool of Russian imperialistic propaganda. Not to mention that anti-scientific schizophrenia is coming from Putin himself, a tzar of 140-millions of Putins. Unfortunately, Russia is incapable of changes while being an ignorant danger to the whole world.
@jarcadipane2849
@jarcadipane2849 5 месяцев назад
Currently, they seem to be holding a few aces...
@lewisdoherty7621
@lewisdoherty7621 5 месяцев назад
I always thought a Russian speaker should take the music of the Soviet anthem and create new lyrics about free speech, democracy, the end of corruption, no FSB, liberty, etc. That would drive the Soviet leftovers crazy. They want to play that anthem, then people can sing what they want.
@ttcc5273
@ttcc5273 5 месяцев назад
That is an excellent idea! 👍❤️
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 5 месяцев назад
That would be wonderful, thank you.
@Defeat-Ruzzia--Delete-Putin
@Defeat-Ruzzia--Delete-Putin 5 месяцев назад
Wow--it should be the Volga Riverboat Song. Ee-ee-yuk, nyem. Ee-ee-yuk, nyem. Yee-ee sho, rrasazik, ee-ee-yuk, nyem. Blue and white--sky. Blue and white--sky. See the flag, waving high, blue and white--sky!
@lewisdoherty7621
@lewisdoherty7621 5 месяцев назад
@@Defeat-Ruzzia--Delete-Putin Maybe there should be words to several different songs and see what takes off. The only problem with that song is the cadence and tempo are designed to indicate the drudgery and exhaustion the Volga riverboat men feel. The white and blue flag is a great idea. It is the Russian flag with the red removed. Get rid of the Soviet leftover components, the red, and things will be fine.
@Defeat-Ruzzia--Delete-Putin
@Defeat-Ruzzia--Delete-Putin 5 месяцев назад
@@lewisdoherty7621 Interesting point. The Red Army Choir has an interesting performance of it. As a Finnish American, I can feel a little bit of the intimidation that a great powerful culture like Russia is able to project as superior over us little Finns. Except I am nearly 200 cm tall. Well, my point is that the song has an intimidating feel to it and could be repurposed to exert the powerful draw of democracy while showing that real freedom requires very hard work and is laborious, disappointing at times, but a sublime blessing. But you make a good point.
@BLMVDV
@BLMVDV 5 месяцев назад
You've already become a historian? Not a very sought-after economist, I guess. I wonder why? 😉
@ericsmith1453
@ericsmith1453 5 месяцев назад
Ok then lets see you collective westerners give it a go, and oh , good luck
@DIA1020-o8k
@DIA1020-o8k 5 месяцев назад
"Russia is a dwarf, I will bring her to her knees." Charles XII, XVIII century. Sweden has lost the status of a great power forever. "I will conquer backward Russia." Friedrich, the middle of the XVIII century. In 1759, the Russian army entered Berlin. "Russia is a colossus with feet of clay." Napoleon, XIX century. In 1814, the Russian army took Paris. "I will conquer the USSR by the end of the year." Hitler, XX century. In 1945, he committed suicide when the Soviet army entered Berlin. "Russia is just a regional power." Barack Obama, 2014 We are waiting...
@KuriosDiogenesJar
@KuriosDiogenesJar 5 месяцев назад
Russia is a sub zero outside toilet run by alcoholic men, who die young.
@raptorreaper
@raptorreaper 5 месяцев назад
Bro, are u drunk? Whats up with all this hate speech?
@turtle-frogs
@turtle-frogs 5 месяцев назад
Thanks, Mark. Russia definitely needs new management. 🇺🇦
@russvet
@russvet 5 месяцев назад
Себе не хотите поменять?
@bwellington3001
@bwellington3001 5 месяцев назад
Хотят, но кокаиновый диктатор запретил@@russvet
@johnm7267
@johnm7267 5 месяцев назад
Why? It is winning against Ukraine and NATO. You obviously have never been to Russia.
@lisasternenkind6467
@lisasternenkind6467 5 месяцев назад
SLAVA UKRAINI! 🇺🇦 🍻 🇩🇪
@MrVovenarg
@MrVovenarg 5 месяцев назад
not your business at all, don't you think?
@leiferiksson1785
@leiferiksson1785 5 месяцев назад
If they are safe, why are they so afraid of the west and nato?
@andrewplowman1002
@andrewplowman1002 5 месяцев назад
Well, Napoleon’s occupation of Moscow didn’t actually work out very well for him given the scorched earth tactics of his enemy and the oncoming winter.
@Aconitum_napellus
@Aconitum_napellus 5 месяцев назад
Not sure how you go about occupying a country that, ostensibly, is armed to the teeth with nukes. I'm not pro Russian, certainly not the Russian Federation, but I'm not sure we're being honest with ourselves about their capabilities.
@ettoreatalan8303
@ettoreatalan8303 5 месяцев назад
There are other countries that are armed to the teeth with nuclear weapons. Among them is a country that has invented nuclear weapons and occasionally acts as the world's policeman.
@JM-ym8mm
@JM-ym8mm 5 месяцев назад
Was he talking? I was taking in the sights when the video ended abruptly. Holy crap what a backdrop xD
@bennyboy5374
@bennyboy5374 5 месяцев назад
Before Poland took Moscow in July 1610 the Swedish General De La Gardie took Moscow from russian rebels in March 1610 which is the reason that some 5k Swedes fought on the Russian side at the battle of Klushino. So during same year two different countries occupied Moscow.
@hybridarmyoffreeworld
@hybridarmyoffreeworld 5 месяцев назад
EDIT FOR YOU : Muscovites
@TheJo201
@TheJo201 5 месяцев назад
Till today they Still Don’t Believe that They Lost The Cold War.
@dakansa
@dakansa 5 месяцев назад
We didn't and did in some way. Our elites sold out USSR. Yeltsin called G. Bush after signing the disband of USSR. We didn't loose the war, but lost the battle...
@meziahdanieljolley8842
@meziahdanieljolley8842 5 месяцев назад
Why are you capitalizing every word?
@TheJo201
@TheJo201 5 месяцев назад
@@meziahdanieljolley8842 You Do Get Core of What My Statement Is About Right???
@saeed7099
@saeed7099 5 месяцев назад
@@meziahdanieljolley8842I find it odd that he didn’t simply capitalize every word. Some words are and some are not, as if he’s following some obscure rule in the English language
@HNH421
@HNH421 5 месяцев назад
@@saeed7099 yes i would write it such :- Even today They will "NOT Believe" that They "LOST the Cold War"
@nancyhope2205
@nancyhope2205 5 месяцев назад
Cheers. I enjoy your videos.
@chrisbryden8102
@chrisbryden8102 5 месяцев назад
The whole internet is now dumber for this video. For the love of god Russia isn’t the same then as it is now! 🤦‍♂️
@abysscat1729
@abysscat1729 5 месяцев назад
Prigozin?
@Aussie-Mocha
@Aussie-Mocha 5 месяцев назад
Sure 🤔👍🏻. I can come at that perspective. It really isn’t structured to last too much longer anyway so it’s just a matter of time. 🇺🇦✊🏻
@barcode6495
@barcode6495 5 месяцев назад
You are so much better than Peter Zehain
@smk4902
@smk4902 5 месяцев назад
No. They are the same. Peter Zeihan just knows how to make more money.
@nattygsbord
@nattygsbord 5 месяцев назад
To me it seems like Peter often changes his views 180 degrees. Sometimes in just a week
@maritaschweizer1117
@maritaschweizer1117 5 месяцев назад
It is not difficult to be better than Zeihan.
@dlmsarge8329
@dlmsarge8329 5 месяцев назад
Agreed. I'm pretty tired of Peter Zeihan's super confident and yet super vague pronouncements. I'm even more tired of lazy people who have him as a guest as a instant expert on every imaginable topic.
@mikesalvaggio20
@mikesalvaggio20 5 месяцев назад
Well this guy just slams Russia all day lol
@peterpomialowski1838
@peterpomialowski1838 5 месяцев назад
Russia has been an empire for 1000+ years. Are you drunk????
@Notrusbot
@Notrusbot 5 месяцев назад
​@@peterselo7707Kievan Rus is a period described by the Russian historian Maksimovich in 1837 to designate the time when the capital of Rus' was in Kyiv. nothing more, Kyiv was not an independent state at that time.
@russelldsyder1344
@russelldsyder1344 5 месяцев назад
Absolutely fantastic yet truthful observation!
@johnm7267
@johnm7267 5 месяцев назад
You believe anything you are told and obviously don’t do any research
@pillarwatch
@pillarwatch 5 месяцев назад
Tucked away in their arctic wasteland, hilarious.
@LemanoftheRussIV
@LemanoftheRussIV 5 месяцев назад
Attic wasteland or whatever lol 😂 made me chuckle.
@Klausi666
@Klausi666 5 месяцев назад
Such nonsense, how can russia be under occupation if mongols and asians used to live there for centuries ? Russians come from Novgorod which is build 859 prior to kiev and moscow. Napoleon never occupied moscow, russians burned down the city and left it before he arrived with his army, it was empty and burned down, this had massive psychological devestation on his mentality, he never believed someone would just destroy their own city. It was mostly wooden houses tho. Poles wer the first to attack moscow and russia but got defeated by cold and starvation.
@victorsmall7
@victorsmall7 5 месяцев назад
The fires in Moscow started after Napolen got installed in Moscow!
@Jakez408
@Jakez408 5 месяцев назад
Try and add up properly. Its been 212 years since Moscow was occupied. Soon after Russian Army entered Paris. So who conquered who?
@romanzavsegolov4925
@romanzavsegolov4925 4 месяца назад
Don't confuse Moscow with Russia, man. So some feodals fight over Moscow when it was basically a city-state, in times before America was found. French army reached Moscow in times when the capital was in St. Petersburg. Also Germans approached Moscow during early WWII. Look at the map. Moscow is huge, but it's a dot in comparison to Russia. And last two armies which approached moscow, after that lost their wars. So EU and NATO may try again, of course. But I would advise them against it. Russia is perfect in defence. It fights like macrophage - it lets you come close and eats you whole.
@Notrusbot
@Notrusbot 5 месяцев назад
An important fact that you missed in your beautiful theory is that the French were in Moscow for only 1 month, while Moscow was abandoned and they captured it. Moreover, the capital of the Russian Empire from 1710 was in St. Petersburg.
@cindyharris-sg5ef
@cindyharris-sg5ef 4 месяца назад
Great video. Enjoy listening to your perspective and your experiences
@DejanPesovic-t7x
@DejanPesovic-t7x 5 месяцев назад
Russians occupied Berlin three times, they occupied Paris. Americans occupied Kabul and had to flee from it. So this story is idiocy.😅😅
@crisdangerous1
@crisdangerous1 5 месяцев назад
So that is plan? Occoupying Moscow? Good luck!
@kubapuchar7069
@kubapuchar7069 5 месяцев назад
Man, stick to economy and do not talk about things you have no idea about.
@clockworker
@clockworker 5 месяцев назад
Yes, the way history is portrayed in Russia is very delusional, about Russia never surrendering and always being righteous. Some years ago they erected those museums "Russia, My History" in several cities, with the clear purpose of instilling their glossed over version of history into people's minds.
@Zanna_pr
@Zanna_pr 5 месяцев назад
а в Ваших городах есть подобные музеи? а Ваши власти что-то делают для того,чтобы подрастающее поколение гордились своей страной и своим народом? а у Вашего народа есть патриотические праздники, ежегодные и массовые?
@clockworker
@clockworker 5 месяцев назад
@@Zanna_pr Мне такого не нужно, у меня есть свои собственные достижения и оцениваю достижения других, независимо от паспорта или места рождения. Также предпочитаю точную, правдивую историю. Это гораздо полезнее.
@Zanna_pr
@Zanna_pr 5 месяцев назад
@@clockworker в Вас говорит эгоизм, Вы думаете только о себе: "я, мне".
@citrosoda5370
@citrosoda5370 5 месяцев назад
I don't really put much stock in the idea of predictable cyclical history, tbh.
@zoranbeader6441
@zoranbeader6441 5 месяцев назад
Why not? It's only slightly less reliable than the horoscope.
@Heater-v1.0.0
@Heater-v1.0.0 5 месяцев назад
It's a wonderful observation but I don't buy the cycle idea. Sounds a bit mystical, or correlation does not prove causation or some such. My take on it is that sure many have gone to Russia and taken Moscow but then found that it's a very shitty place to be. Most of Russia is a cold, dark, swamp with no access to the sea. My wacky idea is born out by the fact that Russians always seem to be trying to get out of there themselves!
@jarcadipane2849
@jarcadipane2849 5 месяцев назад
Indeed. History can rhyme, but does not usually repeat itself exactly unless there are extreme conditions..
@kirstenberg4869
@kirstenberg4869 5 месяцев назад
Hi Mark, As you write yourself: More importantly, when can the world expect Russia to undergo a transformation and become more peaceful and democratic? Yes do you have an estimate? Do you think it's now or next year or when? This war in Ukraine is a source of constant anxiety and sadness 😞
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 5 месяцев назад
I can not predict the future; I can only be hopeful. No person in the world can predict the future, as there are too many currents in time. However, I think in the next two years, there will be a radical change in Moscow, as the economy can not sustain itself. I might do a more detailed video on this.
@kirstenberg4869
@kirstenberg4869 5 месяцев назад
@@EconLessons Yes please, do so and thanks 😀
@hififlipper
@hififlipper 5 месяцев назад
It is religion that made Russians believe in god like leaders. If a 3 yo ask me what happened I'd say: Prince Charles takes Ukraine from Moscow Patriach and the Pope watches in yeallousy calling for peace.
@smk4902
@smk4902 5 месяцев назад
Mark are you sure you want to make this argument.? You just proved Putin's argument that Russia is always the victim of a foreign aggression.
@Notrusbot
@Notrusbot 5 месяцев назад
one of the most favorite moments in propaganda - the enemy is weak, but the enemy is strong😂
@ZemplinTemplar
@ZemplinTemplar 5 месяцев назад
Mark, you are a national treasure. :-) Thank you for every single video. Excellent work.
@SveaHovfel-qt6zb
@SveaHovfel-qt6zb 5 месяцев назад
Four questions to you: 1: Why would anyone want to occupy that arctic wasteland, as you call it? 2: After all those occupations. Who's in charge of Russia right now? 3: With the history of western occupations in mind. Why would the Russians not be cautious about the west. 4: With the history of western aggresion in mind. Would the Russians not be wise to prepare for-, and try to avoid for the next one?
@HR_8035_YEA
@HR_8035_YEA 5 месяцев назад
Until now Russia has lived in peace with the West since the collapse of the Soviet Union. No-one in their right mind is going to try and invade a country with thousands of nuclear weapons. The West sought peace by investing in Russia and helping it rebuild its energy infrastructure. Russia has attacked Ukraine and keeps saying it's a war on the West. It's clear they are the aggressor. Invading multiple neighbours over the past 20 is a strange way to claim Russia is a peaceful country. You are supporting attempted genocide and war crimes. Give it up already.
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 5 месяцев назад
Maybe it will be the White Blue White Russian flag.
@SveaHovfel-qt6zb
@SveaHovfel-qt6zb 5 месяцев назад
@@EconLessons Thanks
@Tyler-wl8kq
@Tyler-wl8kq 5 месяцев назад
Russia is rushing for a cliff called the hermit nation, North Korea anyone?
@ozymandias5130
@ozymandias5130 5 месяцев назад
This dude is blocking people from commenting. Highly dishonest and hateful individual.
@nattygsbord
@nattygsbord 5 месяцев назад
Nope. RU-vid blocks comments. I cannot even post "hateful comments" on my own channel without youtube deleting them for me without my permission. And russian trolls have a defealt setting to delete my comments when I respond to them.
@ozymandias5130
@ozymandias5130 5 месяцев назад
@@nattygsbord I didn't say deleting, I said blocking, as you can still comment, but noone else will see it. And it's not YT, it's the channel owner.
@borisradman9935
@borisradman9935 5 месяцев назад
Regarding the idea that removing despotism and tyranny improves the world, I would advise to review that. I would say that the way governments are is under influence of how the citizens are like and what consequences they create.
@sebanavarro4459
@sebanavarro4459 5 месяцев назад
Errr guys. I think u forgot about nukes… boom, boom You know?
@eteiei1456
@eteiei1456 5 месяцев назад
Ah, those nukes that Russia was going to use if Ukraine striked "new Russian regions"? Or those which nad to repel Ukrainian attacks on the internationally recognized territory of Russia? Well, in case of occupation it would be no less than the third boom that didn't happen.
@zoranbeader6441
@zoranbeader6441 5 месяцев назад
​@@eteiei1456 Russia fighting a winning war and Russia losing a war and getting invaded are two very different scenarios.
@eteiei1456
@eteiei1456 5 месяцев назад
@@zoranbeader6441 Russians saying they'll use nukes if A happens (and not doing it), use nukes if B happens (and not doing it), use nukes if C happens (and not doing it) is the same scenario as them saying they'll use nukes if D happens.
@craigchristie404
@craigchristie404 5 месяцев назад
Really appreciate the insights you share with us. Thanks
@Dragonfly-sr5uw
@Dragonfly-sr5uw 5 месяцев назад
Good to see you again. ✋
@ChorltonBrook
@ChorltonBrook 4 месяца назад
Moscow was founded by the Horde as a tax/tribute collection hub. (Moscow means muddy river & the Kremlin means fortress on a hill in the Tartar language)
@hybridarmyoffreeworld
@hybridarmyoffreeworld 5 месяцев назад
Moscow horde SUCKS AT WAT, ITS war record : - 1856 defeated by Britain and France 1905 defeated by Japan 1917 defeated by Germany 1920 defeated by Poland, Finland, Estonia and all Baltic states 1939 defeated by Finland 1969 defeated by China 1989 defeated by Afghanistan 1989 defeated in the Cold War. 1996 defeated by Chechnya 2022 defeated by Ukraine WW2 won USA/Britain , meanwhile Stalin's officers were shot or sent to the Gulags. Millions went to the Gulags, including Solzhenitsyn Moscow's only victories come from invading smaller countries :- a) Hungary 1956 b) Czechoslovakia 1968 c) Moldova 1992 d) Georgia 2008
@A.B376
@A.B376 5 месяцев назад
Ww2 I don't agree, the Soviets were the ones who contributed the most
@hybridarmyoffreeworld
@hybridarmyoffreeworld 5 месяцев назад
@@A.B376 BBC: "What was your rank, soldier?" Average putin´s conscript: "I think the judge called it First Degree Murder, Armed Robbery and Sexual Assault ...and the medic told me that I am HIV and TBC positive. That's why I got this job: I passed all the tests."
@jimsummers487
@jimsummers487 5 месяцев назад
Russia concurred DJT
@johnpasquale7095
@johnpasquale7095 5 месяцев назад
@hybridarmyoffreeworld Russia can be described by what a famous football coach once said, "you are what your record says you are"
@mattd6200
@mattd6200 5 месяцев назад
There is a big difference between Russia and the world then and now. In the world, territory changed hands liberally until 1945. Also, today's Russia has nukes.
@tihlsteinig2465
@tihlsteinig2465 5 месяцев назад
And wich Empirie is there tuday? Occupation is not wictory. And you speak nonsense.
@jarcadipane2849
@jarcadipane2849 5 месяцев назад
I think Moscow keeps coming back though.. It is not wise to improperly evaluate your neighbors/ opponents.
@gnice8765
@gnice8765 5 месяцев назад
Mark I'm gonna try to keep it simple this time. You remember the Cuban missile crisis? (Before my time) Cuba is 90 miles of the coast and shares land borders with no one. Ukraine shares a 1426 mile land border with Russia. I hope we can agree up to here. Now its 60+ years later and we still punish the cubans. Now try to imagine that it was canada and not cuba. Canada wouldnt exist.
@djordjelezajic8435
@djordjelezajic8435 5 месяцев назад
Every Empire starts to crumble once it's interest payments on national debt are higher than it' s military budget. Russian foreign debt is just over $ 360 billions, or so. The United States of America has to pay close to $1 trillion in order to service it' s foreign debt. Since BRICS nations just started to form their organization as the answer to G7, and therefore US dollar will have less and less significance as the reserve currency with which international transactions are settled, retty soon the funny Monopoly money that Washington prints at will and in abundance will be worth less. Much less. And once the inflation " hits the fan" , we will see how many dual citizens will decide to seek greener pastures, so to speak.
@goranzivanovic111
@goranzivanovic111 5 месяцев назад
You forgot that after every occupation Russia liberated themselves, reformed and became stronger and bigger. Someone mentioned in comments they have lost the cold war - Soviet Union did collapse but they had control for 45 years of east Berlin and half of Europe. They withdrew they troops from Europe peacfuly as it was too expensive to feed, cloth and equip troops in foreign lands, they reformed, modernised and grow up infrastructuraly and economicaly after that move and probably now they feel strong enough again for war campaigns as we see in Ukraine. Also to mention that significant changes of power in Russia for example from monarchy to communism led to a first world war, later to second, but communism prevailed until 1990, then collapsed and then Putin came into power since 1998 to today which is nearly 30 years on. Russia don't stand for democratic values like West but rather to authocratic rule and we see that for centuries, long lasting rulers whether good or bad but by the Russians themselves wishing and voting for that. Don't bother to change that rather accept it and make everlasting peace with that and them.
@denisbessette7219
@denisbessette7219 5 месяцев назад
Mark, I have looked all over for your name, the correct spelling, so I can search for your videos. Also, who is the young man in the photo in the circle? Are you hiding out in FL backlands, off the grid, growing your own food and saving your children from public education? If you are still teaching, your classes must be awesome and interesting!
@johnnyk7480
@johnnyk7480 3 месяца назад
Sir can u speak about the Vietnamese dong currency? It’s a commie state like China but its economy is doing well relative to other developing economies. Thanks
@marcus_ohreallyus
@marcus_ohreallyus 5 месяцев назад
Trends are great, but you forgot one variable. Nuclear weapons.
@razorsedgegottiline6131
@razorsedgegottiline6131 5 месяцев назад
The Soviet Union never collapsed. Many polticians in the western world studied at the Lenin institute in Moscow. Read " new lies for old " by Anatoliyn Golitsyn.
@Rob-fx2dw
@Rob-fx2dw 5 месяцев назад
The reason that Russia was not occupied by another countrey in the 1940's was that it was saved from occupation by the Allies supporting it with millions of gallons of high octane gasolene, millions of tons of food and hundresds of thousands of vehicles, tanks and aircraft as well as intelligence and the strategic bombing of the Allies which decreased the axis powers to wage war.
@gabrielbucur5327
@gabrielbucur5327 5 месяцев назад
When you speak of russian, I expect to be white ortodox people, right?
@andrii31415
@andrii31415 5 месяцев назад
None of reformatting helped with the "master-slave" mindset muskovites have. While the cycle is there, their moral framework of "success is degrading your lesser" and "the bigger - the stronger" etc seems to be inherent
@jouniosmala9921
@jouniosmala9921 5 месяцев назад
Nope. The leaders don't think Moscow is untouchable. They think, eventually someone will attack and they need lots of buffer before Moscow. That's the Reason they want to conquer, Baltics, Slovakia, Romania and everything east from that.
@heetheet75
@heetheet75 5 месяцев назад
Nobody wants to invade russia, it's a craphole. If they would stay in their own country there would be no problem. You don't need a buffer when you have nukes. And you don't deserve a buffer either, no country does. It's sickening that they think they're entitled to this, filthy imperialists.
@jarcadipane2849
@jarcadipane2849 5 месяцев назад
Communism certainly does not lend itself to cohesiveness. Political repression amongst other things certainly doesnt spur development amongst the population as a whole.
@shaneb315
@shaneb315 5 месяцев назад
Nobody from the west wants to occupy Moscow in this day and age . However , as unlikey as it is , if one had to name a nation with a desire to take Russian territory it once held in the far east which incorporates regions as far as Vladivostok - China comes to mind . In coming years , should Russia experience severe economic decline , perhaps they might ask China for significant assistance and in doing so open the door to greater Chinese influence inside Russia to such an extent that perhaps Chinese influence could grow in strength to eventual control of political power in Moscow . The Chinese are closely watching Russian agressive actions in Ukraine... A weakened Russia as a result of sanctions and economic collapse and potential miltitary failure in Ukraine might result in the Kremlin leaning on their " friends " to provide aid and support when nobody else is willing to assist .
@auroraborealis1670
@auroraborealis1670 5 месяцев назад
Its not about winning or losing. Ask people where they want to live and rise their children. Russia is n 1 choice. In Russia people dont waste time on western keyboard warriors. Deal with it. American dream is a nightmare and you are done.
@jarcadipane2849
@jarcadipane2849 5 месяцев назад
None of this guy's assertions are backed by any facts or logical reasoning ..
@Petros-e6n
@Petros-e6n 5 месяцев назад
Dont talk stupid ok,back then there was no nukes,now they can fix the world do u feel me😊
@Sam-sv4yy
@Sam-sv4yy 5 месяцев назад
ruZZians are the most funny copers ever
@allansmith3837
@allansmith3837 5 месяцев назад
Lmao 😂 same shit here in Britain but it doesn't take hundreds off years. Get yourself an agent you should be on stage.
@C1rnobyl
@C1rnobyl 5 месяцев назад
The one achilles heel to thia argument is something they didn't have back then: Nuclear weapons.
@AndersJohnsson-d1t
@AndersJohnsson-d1t 5 месяцев назад
1610 sweden occupied Moskva
@bigodbiel5285
@bigodbiel5285 5 месяцев назад
Actually two cycles: 40 years and 200 years.
@sparkyfromel
@sparkyfromel 4 месяца назад
All true but it didn't brought much luck to the invaders
@jonathanstein5049
@jonathanstein5049 5 месяцев назад
Expect the Chinese will be running the show soon.
@zipperpillow
@zipperpillow 4 месяца назад
The Mongols rolled them in the 1230's.
@Alan_Watkin
@Alan_Watkin 5 месяцев назад
i never bothered learning to drive, so i mostly only believe in bi-cycles 😁🙄😛
@stepan.vz000
@stepan.vz000 5 месяцев назад
я правильно розумію, чувак відмазує окупантів? lol
@nemosthlm
@nemosthlm 5 месяцев назад
You are growing man.
@reinokarvinen8845
@reinokarvinen8845 5 месяцев назад
swedes been to moscow as well. something about supporting a new tsar
@arnesbeganovic
@arnesbeganovic 5 месяцев назад
And that is exactly the reason why they attacked Ukraine. They want their border to be further away from Moscow. Lets remember Operation Barbarossa where German forces entered deep into soviet territory, which in today's terms are Ukraine, Poland, Baltic countries and just small parts of today's Russia. German forces were well equipped, trained and organized but still did not reach Moscow. Main reason: they started further away than Napoleon forces. And that is the reason why they entered Ukraine, and plan to attack other former soviet countries. People know that deep inside and that's the reason why they support Putin. Yes, 200 years have passed and Moscow was supposed to be conquered by Hitler, but he did not make it. Now Putin wants that kind of security.
@MagMar-kv9ne
@MagMar-kv9ne 5 месяцев назад
Yeah that is the Zeihan Argument. But it is flawed. Putin did not wage War because the little toad feels insecure. He does it for regime security, because he fears democracy and liberty. That is the Vlad Vexler Counter Argument. Sprinkled with a little imperial russian Agenda, Putin wants not to secure his borders but to topple the west, because he fears rule of law and accountability. And he should. Putin does not want to a democratic Ukraine near his borders, cause he fears the Democracy virus.
@occamraiser
@occamraiser 5 месяцев назад
Why does an economist feel the need to post videos on the history of Moscow?
@bigolboomerbelly4348
@bigolboomerbelly4348 5 месяцев назад
11b 4del russian record in war is 68-146.
@ozymandias5130
@ozymandias5130 5 месяцев назад
Times have changed and the Empire of Lies is not safe from retribution behind the ocean. While their stranglehold on Europe and many other countries still persists, they know they have bitten a larger piece than they can swallow this time. The beast is choking, wriggling in agony.
@DIA1020-o8k
@DIA1020-o8k 5 месяцев назад
You hate Russia and Russians. You don't understand this story and you don't want to understand it. What happened to the Golden Horde? Under Ivan the Terrible, the Kazan, Astrakhan and Siberian khanates became part of Russia. Almost 400 years have passed between the Mongol conquest and the invasion of the Poles, not 200. You are confusing dates and events. The Poles entered Moscow because of the betrayal of the boyars. But soon the people's militia expelled the Poles from Moscow, a new Romanov dynasty ascended the throne, and under them Russia became an empire. General Kutuzov surrendered Moscow to the French in 1812, withdrawing troops but retaining the army, and in 1814 the Russian army entered Paris. In 1945, a Soviet soldier raised a flag over the Reichstag in Berlin. Do you expect the West to occupy Moscow? Gorbachev and Yeltsin betrayed the country, and American advisers were sitting in the Kremlin. But they were kicked out. Russia has been reborn.
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 5 месяцев назад
I love Russians, they are children of God as we all are and all equal. I do not like their despotism and aggression. The Darkness that rules them is making the geopolitical and economic landscape something that is not to be respected or loved.
@DIA1020-o8k
@DIA1020-o8k 5 месяцев назад
@@EconLessons And then what about the USA? Or is it something else? Don't you see a log in your eye? How many countries have you plunged into chaos and poverty? How many people have been killed? Get away from our borders and stop destabilizing countries near our borders. We turned out to be too much for you, the path is to admit it. And how we live in our country, we will decide for ourselves. We are not you, we are others and we will decide our own fate.
@BLMVDV
@BLMVDV 5 месяцев назад
@@EconLessons You literally have a resentment or envy toward Russians.
@davidwright5094
@davidwright5094 5 месяцев назад
@@DIA1020-o8k "how we live in our country, we will decide for ourselves" You have no mandate at all for such an assertion. Neither do Putin nor Peskov etc. *Who exactly* among all those inside Russia's borders do you include within your *"we"* ? And how can these of your "we" decide anything at all while under such extensive and increasing restrictions on speech, and subject to such increasingly draconian punishments for violating them? -- All imposed by a minuscule minority, visiting armed force upon an unarmed population; and with said minority clearly terrified of both debate, and credibly audited elections?
@DIA1020-o8k
@DIA1020-o8k 5 месяцев назад
@@davidwright5094 I have the right to say that - I am a citizen of Russia. And 80 percent of the country's population came to the presidential elections and voted for Putin. But no one in NATO has such a right - you are not citizens of Russia. And it's up to us to decide how we live. Putin said it right: teach your wife how to cook cabbage soup. Putin is the president legitimately elected by the CITIZENS of RUSSIA. And I don't care that the US and the EU didn't recognize the election results. It's none of your business, take care of the elections in the United States, the election campaign there is "super-democratic." Are civilians dying? Are you talking about the population of Donbass? Which has been dying since 2014. Where were you when the Ukrainian Nazis burned 40 people alive in the House of Trade Unions in Odessa? And your whole democratic world is silent! And what do you know about the Gorlovka Madonna? And about the Alley of Angels? Probably nothing, your democratic press doesn't write about it.
@pascoett
@pascoett 5 месяцев назад
They are driven by fear. There are several concepts at stake: the danger of the technological advanced West since Charles of Sweden, later Napoleon and then the Germans. Imagine being only saved by the weather and some friends far away. The other danger comes from the steppe people and from East Asia. It could be the Mongolians, the Tatars, the Chinese, the Japanese and the Turks. For a while, the Soviet Union was the progressive culture and place of literature, music and art. Modern Russia has no appeal because they look weak and poor in comparison to even India and the central Asian countries. But at least they are determined and the West is not. The West cannot sacrifice: not blood and also not money. The Ukrainians will do everything but without our strong commitment, they are doomed. Putin plays Frederik the Great, whose only hope was the death of the Tsar which eventually happened and he survived with all his conquests. Hitler hoped for the end of the coalition but it proved to be too strong, while his own consisted of unreliable allies like Italians, Hungarians, Finns, Romanians and Bulgarians. Napoleon hoped for a similar wonder. Putin’s hope is on Donald Trump who dislikes Ukraine and doesn’t trust them. I think he will get away with 2-3 provinces and the Crimea in 2025.
@nattygsbord
@nattygsbord 5 месяцев назад
Putin reminds me of his own favorite Tsar Nicholas who started the Crimean war despite Russias backwardness and despite England and France was the richest high technological industrial superpowers of their age. And the reason why Tsar Nicholas and Tsar Putin believed in victory was the same. The west was decadent, materialistic, lazy, too comfortable, individualistic, unwilling to sacrifice blood and sweat, and unmanly. While Russia was manly, stubborn, brave, they were used to hardships, they were patriotic and understood the meaning of self-sacrifice for the greater good. It was believed that those virtues would compensate for russias technological, economical and manpower disadvantage. But Putin despite his love for history have failed to see that he is not the first one to have this faulty belief that wars could be won only by superior morality. Tsar Nicholas lost the Crimean war for Russia. Hundreds of thousands of people died for nothing for this childish man that had some silly fantasies about being a succesful conqueror King. Russia lost that war. Japan in World war 2 thought that the superior Japanese soldier would beat the industrial might of the decadent, comfortable, westerners that were unwilling to die for their country or for anything. But Japan had their asses kicked and lost the war anyways. And this was despite the Japanese undoubtably were fanatical and literarly fought til the last man and never surrendered, and japanese soldiers continued to fight for the emperor even decades after the war had ended on some remote pacific islands. So if not even fanatical Japanese bushido warriors could defeat the industrial might of the west, or German military professionalism. Then do I hold no doubt that russia will lose its future wars against the west. The russian soldier is less willing to fight than his western counterparts and more willing to surrender. And the lack of industrial might is even worse than that Germany had against USA. And nor do russia hold any manpower advantage like it had in previous world wars. Russias hopes and dreams are unrealistic. Putin just do the same mistake as previous Tsars. And russia will pay a high price for this for many decades to come.
@yuriykorenyak2351
@yuriykorenyak2351 5 месяцев назад
This time, Moscow needs to stop to exist
@barcode6495
@barcode6495 5 месяцев назад
artic waste land. Canada is in the sane location north of parallen 49
@toby9999
@toby9999 5 месяцев назад
Yet Canada is more successful economically and in pretty much every other way that matters to its citizens, as is Norway, Finland, and Sweden. Ruzzia is a corrupt poverty stricken dump.
@KuriosDiogenesJar
@KuriosDiogenesJar 5 месяцев назад
Canada has a far higher life expectancy than Russia.
@Klausi666
@Klausi666 5 месяцев назад
complete nonsense, canada is great country full of resources and friendly amazing people, just incompetent goverment. same as russia.
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 5 месяцев назад
Canada is wonderful, because the people are free and peaceful.
@bigolboomerbelly4348
@bigolboomerbelly4348 5 месяцев назад
That waste Land is rich in resources big time
@paperandmedals8316
@paperandmedals8316 5 месяцев назад
I view Mark’s opinion absolutely opposite of what he said. Russia knows it’s vulnerable ,hence Putin using the west as the great invading threat of its time. The great patriotic war is only 2nd to Christmas for holidays. . If anything Russia sees itself as enduring and is a formidable force if invaded by any of its 9 weak geographies that can enable a force to March or drive through. It anything Mark makes Putin’s case for first mover tactical aggression. Unfortunately Russia is not strategically capable of addressing Russia’s true enemy, China and the Chinese desire for Russian natural assets.
@nattygsbord
@nattygsbord 5 месяцев назад
I think russian propaganda is just full of contradictions. First it says that west is weak and that russia easily outproduce the west in artillery ammunition, and that the west have no military stockpiles and is laughably weak. And then all of a sudden Russia turns around 180 degrees and says that the west is a great aggressive threat towards russia that wants to steal their resources. Even if the western armies are so weak that even Germany have less artillery ammunition than for a 2 week fighting with russia. So I say this: Get your own story straight for F*** sake.
@toncoumans6985
@toncoumans6985 5 месяцев назад
I can't get your last name. Is it Mark Fearnaught?
@bigolboomerbelly4348
@bigolboomerbelly4348 5 месяцев назад
Biernat
@jacquesoosthuizen765
@jacquesoosthuizen765 5 месяцев назад
But it always returns to the russians.
@jordanjohnanderson
@jordanjohnanderson 5 месяцев назад
Did you intend to upload this on April 1? I can't believe what I've just listened to. "Russians feel they are impervious to external influences". Do you know how Lenin got to Petrograd in 1917? Russia's one of the most invaded countries in history. The most devastating invasion ever, almost resulting in their complete annihilation, happened in living memory. If someone pressed me to name what I thought the most common geopolitical trait of Russia was, in all it's historical incarnations, the one constant I would say would be their paranoia about their largely undefendable borders. Good video, otherwise.
@ttcc5273
@ttcc5273 5 месяцев назад
Guaranteeing immunity for the official acts of a President is a Pandora’s Box of nightmares. A rotten apple from the tree of Monarchy.
@MikeD-qx1kr
@MikeD-qx1kr 5 месяцев назад
Great stuff! Ima follower. You have a garden in the woods? No sun needed?
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 5 месяцев назад
Since it is Florida even in the woods sun comes through. I have things growing everywhere. Thanks fellow gardener Mike.
@calripson
@calripson 5 месяцев назад
Keep trying
@MrRedeye33
@MrRedeye33 5 месяцев назад
Moscow, USA. has a nice ring to it.
@mikek9488
@mikek9488 5 месяцев назад
You can already visit Moscow, Idaho, home of the University of Idaho.
@daniellarson3068
@daniellarson3068 5 месяцев назад
It's in Idaho.
@sashole1
@sashole1 5 месяцев назад
Which one? There're seven cities called "Moscow" in the USA: in ID, MO, TX, PA, TN, IA, KS, OH. Plus, there are Moscow Mills in MO and Moscow Township in MI.
@johnpasquale7095
@johnpasquale7095 5 месяцев назад
@@sashole1 Don't sleep on Moscow ME.
@sashole1
@sashole1 5 месяцев назад
@@johnpasquale7095 Sorry, I've indeed missed this one.
@helgeschneider9069
@helgeschneider9069 5 месяцев назад
and Germany would have occuppied moskov, If russia would have Not the Support of us
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 5 месяцев назад
Lend lease saved Russia
@nattygsbord
@nattygsbord 5 месяцев назад
Germany did defeat russia in 1917
@jatufin
@jatufin 5 месяцев назад
Finnish troops called their commander Jacob de la Gardie "Lazy Jack" because the Moscow campaign lasted years and years and years. They eventually conquered the city in 1610. After them came the Polish. It's a bit murky, I'm not exactly sure who fought who and who were allies. edit: To make clear: That time the Finns were of course part of the Swedish army.
@eric_a_
@eric_a_ 5 месяцев назад
Where did the Mongols conquer? They conquered much of that land around Kiev in the Kievan Rus land that made up much of today's Ukraine, Belarus, and Russia west of the Volga River, where modern-day Moscow is located
@ЮрійТележинський-й8ь
@ЮрійТележинський-й8ь 5 месяцев назад
🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
@johnm7267
@johnm7267 5 месяцев назад
What is the point of all this? Is it to pour cold water on Russias ability to defend itself? Like Russia fighting with shovels. If you think Moscow is going to be taken soon you are mistaken
@Bac4-qu6qg7sk4v
@Bac4-qu6qg7sk4v 4 месяца назад
Right...Pootie is defending itself just as Saddam was when he defensively invaded Kuwait or when the Austrian painter launched at Poland 🤣
Далее
Noam Chomsky - Why Does the U.S. Support Israel?
7:41
Baltic Independence at 100
1:03:11
Просмотров 60 тыс.
4. Peter the Great
45:43
Просмотров 128 тыс.
China: The Economy That Stopped
9:38
Просмотров 19 тыс.
20 Car Innovations That DID NOT Stand the Test of Time
21:03
USA vs Russia in an Economic City Comparison
18:23
Просмотров 13 тыс.