As reports spread in Russia that opposition leader Aleksei Navalny had died, RFE/RL's @RadioSvoboda asked residents for their reactions in a street interview in Moscow. While some voiced intense grief, others were indifferent.
@@ZhovtoBlakytniy what do you mean? It's literally translates "I think..." Is the translation wrong? Is it more like "I think in russia everyone can be guilty, even if he fights for the right things"? or what? Because as it is translated it's the weirdest double-think I found in these translated interviews.
"Everyone who is against Russia is guilty, even if they are right" It's called FASCISM. EDIT: I'm sitting here with wine and cheese having a good laugh at all the Kremlin bots in the replies baited by my comment.
They are smarter then you, they know how to express themselves, they have it more freedom speech then US … you should watch Tucker Carlson shows about Russia….
@@MMorMM wtf? ar u srsly? what about "there are only two genders, that's biology" if u say that, u get fired, and even persecuted by some maniacs SJW - infantiles.
That comment struck me also. Some dictators think they are the state, if you're against them then you're against the state. When society accepts the leader as being the state, it's time for revolution or immigration to another country. RIP Navalny, you're a revolutionary, so sorry your countrymen don't share your vision.
@@Eiael exactly the point. many americans believe in the american exceptionalism, like this cant happen here. go read the 1935 book "It cant happen here"
Like those who watch FOX NEWS in the USA. Didn't Trump say Presidents should have immunity if they send Seal Team 6 after their political opponents? I seem to remember something like that. Maybe he learned it from Putin.
@@luke_skywanker7643 I don't watch much fox news, but what I've been watching recently on youtube has been high quality content to me so far. Unlike bbc, they don't stay on screen reading a sheet on top of the camera.
Putin is a DICTATOR...he changed the Russian Constitution to stay in office indefinitely. He has been in office for 24 YEARS!! He is running for another 6 years term...now that his opposition is no longer alive...guess he will win another 6 year term making his total time in office 30 YEARS!! Putin is worth somthing like $70 BILLION...some accounts say more. How does a govt offical make that much money ???!???!!?
@@englishmaninrussia how does it feel to have no integrity? EDIT: Since the goddamn YT doesn't let me reply to you properly, I'll do it here: My mom may be a h00ker, but she still doesn't sell @$$ as much as you do
very brave of the people who expressed sadness. I don't think many people outside of Russia understand how dangerous it is to hold views that don't align with the Russian government and that even voicing them in a Moscow street can have serious repercussions for them!
And I don't think that many brainwashed people outside of Russia, you included, understand that cherrypicked garbage like this video has nothing to do with the lives and opinions of real Russians who are mostly either completely indifferent to this or despise him as a criminal and a traitor, or that you can't really pull this "dangerous to voice an opinion in Russia" fairy tale when literally anybody in this "evil Russian dictatorship" was allowed to attend his funeral, which was public, and even the "evil Russian police" was there doing absolutely nothing to stop anyone from attending it. Quit watching western propaganda trash.
russian prisoner #1: "I am here because I criticized Igor Pushkin.'' russian prisoner #2: "I am here because I praised Igor Pushkin." russian prisoner #3: "I am Igor Pushkin.''
Как Иисус понёс свой крест. Что будет дальше увидим. То что стал мучеником - видит каждый, даже с пеленой в глазах. Он отдал свою жизнь за аас... Стоите ли вы её?
As a Russian, I still cry a lot every time I remember about his death. He was the bravest human. I feel like all of our bravery was in this man, and he gave it to us again and again. Unlike most of us he didn't have any lines between his faith and comfort of his life, he was giving away every piece of himself. He wasn't perfect, but he truly fought for his beliefs, for the good, for the love, against the fear. I know he wouldn't want it, but I physically feel my hands go down. Would give away a lot to make it un-happen
Typical nonsense from another victim of globalization. He is crying, you see. He cried for a criminal who was being puppeteered by the U.S. and who was not even a real oppositionist, but was simply collecting money from the western sources. You know, it’s a right time for Russua to introduce some kind of monitoring of the adequacy of citizens in order to identify useless infantiles who are trying to copy the West in everything, having only pictures and film ideas about it.
Чувствую себя точно так же ! Я не могу держать себя в руках, вчера весь день следил за за тем. как пройдут похороны... Не могу сдержать слез, даже на работе. Руки опускаются сами по себе. Не верю что это когда то закончится, плакал когда увидел сколько людей пришло на последнюю встречу. Удачи и сил нам всем, я с тобой, не отчаивайся. ты не один, нас много, по крайней мере я буду в это верить. Still feel absolutely the same thing! I cant keep my feelings to myself, yesterday i spend all of my time following the news about funeral....Cant stop tears, even on the job. Hands just down by itself. Cant believe its will be over someday, i cryed after i saw how much people came to the last meet. Good luck and strength for all of us, im with you, dont give up, youre not alone, there are a lot of us, at least i will hope so
@@BERTOLET-if8ml Откуда вы все такие берётесь, инфантильные жертвы глобализации? Слёз они сдержать не могут, дескать. Как вообще физически можно быть такими? Никто из вас не способен назвать хоть что-то одно, хоть что-нибудь что сделал этот Навальный для России, кроме как клянчил донаты, всячески пытался дестабилизировать внутри обстановку. Даже настоящим оппозиционером не был, потому что никогда ничего конкретного не предлагал - сплошная болтовня и эфемерная абстракция про какую-то "свободу" непонятно от чего. И даже подростков привлекал к своим проплаченным акциям. Паразит с уголовным прошлым, находящийся на дотациях у Запада. Слёзы они по нему льют, смотрите-ка. Никакого критического и глобального мышления - всё повторяют кого-то. Ещё и на работу ходит в нашей стране, гляди-ка. Может пора уже переехать? Вы же все попсовые и прозападные, считающие что Россия немытая и убогая вся, зато вот таааам где-то хорошо и цивилизованно всё.
Not like the faces of western degenerates mutilated by overprescripted and/or recreationally used drugs, LGBT propaganda and mental gymnastics from trying to pretend that they're winning this war, right? Right, you clown?
Да, да. Мы все тут умираем. Идёшь по улице и смотришь как других ставят к стенке и прям у этой стенки и расстреливают... Как хорошо жить, к примеру, в Америке - вот где свобода слова, где не преследуют других за своё мнение, за критику власти и т.д.
В Америке преследования другого рода. Но факт в том что за репостики, митинги, пикеты никого не закрывают за выражение своего мнения. И уровень репрессий намного ниже. Если поднимается шумиха, то сразу начинается шевеление. В России же, в нашей Иркутской области во всех ИК и СИЗО пытают людей, десятками в тюрьмах и психотделениях погибают люди. Пишутся пачками обращения в прокуратуру и другие органы, а душегубов переводят на высшие должности, даже не наказывают. Так, для виду, найдут козла отпущения, а система продолжает существовать. Америка во многом похожа на Рассею. Тем, что везде присутствует интерес богатых, но политическая власть менее централизована и менее репрессивна. Это факт.
😂 Guy was a fucking Nazi!!! In a 2007 pro-gun rights video, Navalny said he wants to exterminate “flies and cockroaches” - while bearded Muslim men appear in cutaways. These days western liberals can’t stop Jacking off to Nazis like this. I’m honestly surprised they don’t like Donald Trump who is like the American Navalny!
"I think that everyone who is against Russia is guilty, even if they are right." If Navalny was "against Russia", he wouldn't have come back. He came back for the love of his country and his fellow Russians who live under the iron fist of dictator and war criminal Pootin.
I can't help wondering if some of the comments made on camera were purposefully vague. OTOH, Putin has successfully integrated his own image with Russia the state, so it is possible they meant "against Putin" when they said "against the state" as they are now merged.
LOL. Navalny was ultranationalist and fascist. 99% of Russians didn't give a fuck about him and don't give a fuck about him. "The whole world" is mourning for the CIA's asset, braindead westoids and literally nobody else.
Get real, brainwashed clown. Even in Russia barely anyone cares, let alone in the WHOLE WORLD. Turn off your pathetic western propaganda and try to look at the world with your own eyes. Your NY gayborhood getting state propaganda transmissions about his death demanding you to believe that anyone cares is not the whole world.
He is kind of right though. It depends on how you look at it. Don't think there is a "silent majority" inside Russia, who is afraid to speak against Putin's regime. Most Russians support Putin. Even under anti-Putin videos here on YT you can read about what people think of Navalny. If you are not a hardcore Z patriot, that means you are a foreign agent, a traitor, an enemy. It's sad but that's how it is. Don't expect Russians to protest or something.
You would have to be a very brave person in Russia to condemn what has happened to Navalny on camera. They know that it would mean 15 years in a Siberian Gulag. However, there are still some very brave people who will still do it.
Or it means they are freer to speak than you think (ie. Were told to think by your not at all controlled media). Whats the matter with you ppl beleiving what your govts tell you. They all lie. You stoopid or what ?
Hello from Moscow. Thousands of people came out in Moscow and in the regions to honor the memory of Alexei Navalny and lay flowers. The police prevented flowers from being laid and destroyed memorials and arrested many people over these few days. Alexey's body has not yet been returned to his family. Happy memory to the courageous man Alexei Navalny! We mourn for you! Your business will not be forgotten! We remember your words and your call - never give up! During the elections, on March 17 at 12:00, we will gather for a protest rally - Noon against Putin! The meeting places are your polling stations.
I just watched a RU-vid video titled, "Alexei Navalny Dies - Russians React To Death of Alexei Navalny" by a Brit who is traveling in Russia. This is his channel: "Sam's Russian Adventures" The Russians he talks to don't care. Two never heard of Navalny, who is like the Russian version of Trump.
@@NungurnerJettyI will also answer you. Drawing conclusions based on polling just a few people is very stupid. This is not a sample, this is not an exact indicator. If at least 100 people were interviewed, then this would already be an indicator. And then you must always remember that after such speeches on camera in support of the opposition, they will simply come to your home with an inspection, hang some kind of article on you and put you in prison. Not everyone risks saying what they think. Before you criticize people who are afraid to speak on camera, ask yourself, are you ready to go to prison for one word displeasing to the authorities?
@@adolapointe4922 Drawing conclusions based on polling just a few people is very stupid. This is not a sample, this is not an exact indicator. If at least 100 people were interviewed, then this would already be an indicator. And then you must always remember that after such speeches on camera in support of the opposition, they will simply come to your home with an inspection, hang some kind of article on you and put you in prison. Not everyone risks saying what they think. Before you criticize people who are afraid to speak on camera, ask yourself, are you ready to go to prison for one word displeasing to the authorities?
THOUSANDS of people? Don't talk nonsense! There were less than 100 people there! You have been consumed by propaganda... Come on, you've never even been to Russia and you don't even know where Ukraine is, but you allow yourself to carry such nonsense! I'm in shoke
I'm a bit surprised by this mourning for Navalny. As if everyone had forgotten that he supported the invasion of Georgia, he was always happy about "retaking our Crimea", and in his TV program he said that "we have slippers for cockroaches and weapons for Muslims." I understand that he became an opponent of the government, but that does not make him a hero.
@@dennis65 Assange is facing life imprisonment in the US for publishing thousands of classified military and diplomatic documents in 2010. They were provided by the US army whistleblower Chelsea Manning, had her sentence commuted by the former president Barack Obama and was released after seven years in prison. The Obama administration had decided not to proceed with charges against Assange, but they were revived during the Donald Trump presidency under the 1917 Espionage Act. Not sure how to feel about this one, as publishing classified military and diplomatic documents is clearly a crime and placing US national security at risk. A journalist should have free speech but not to reveal to the world classified secrets of the US. Navalny is a different person altogether. He was patriotic and brave, willing to die to help his country and people. I would not get the two men confused.
@johnhopkins6260 Pretty suboptimal time for Putin to have him killed, what with a generally well accepted (by those not invested in 'Ukraine') interview with Carlson still being talked about, with Russian troops entering the center of Adeevka, and with all the Western 'leaders' (and Julia Navalniy) in Munich so the press has easy access to their 'condemnations' and soundbites about how heroic he was.
Nawalny had the choice to stay in my country for refugee after poisoning. Instead he was willingly to get back to his home and being a brave man for his country. Putin on the other hand, is not able to live without fear and even more unable to live with that fear. So he wanted to get rid of the number one danger for his power. May Nawalnys soul and passion for his country not be wasted and for us an example of bravery
@maxicolas Kara-Murza went back as well. 25 years in jail for criticizing the war on Ukraine. My guess, Putin and the oligarchs are pissed off about his Magnitsky Act.
This may be an unprecedented opportunity. With the shock and outrage of the people of Russia, If Navalny's wife were to run, she would sweep to victory. I suggest that, if she does run, she should have the strongest protection possible, because Putin's rage will compel him to overreact and do his best to eliminate her, also. For her to appear so soon after the announcement of her husband's death shows great fortitude and how much she is determined to remove Putin and his gang from power. Slava Navalny!
He was a foolish man. Leave the politics to young men without families. He now leaves behind a young son, daughter, and wife and he didn't accomplish anything.
@@arumrunner I swear that 90% of Russian culture comes in the form of 'there's an old saying'. And then like only 25% of those saying actually hold water lol. They're just things people say to help themselves sleep at night.
“He’s partly to blame because he returned after finding out he’d been poisoned”. That statement took my breath away. Imagine living in a country where if you are opposed to the government, you are to blame for sticking around and “letting” it kill you.😢
The translation is not completely correct, the guy ment that he took on this danger by coming back. He didn't blame him, he said that Alexey was fighting for his country which is true.
@@Sergei_Ru I only listen to people that have had You Tube accounts for more than say, ONE WEEK....smh... Sorry, you created your You Tube account on Feb. 10, 2024 so you're just SOL and that makes you just another every day russian troll...or bot. In reality, I don't see much difference in the two!
Of course, can you blame them? If I were one of them and a reporter came up with a camera I’d question if they were one of state agents trying to get me to say something.
Navalny was a white-supremacist and so are his supporters. Entirely reasonable that she is "scared" and I hope that she remains "scared" as all white-supremacists should be.
@@britneyfanvideosfl Yes, Americans take their free speech for granted. Even in supposedly free countries like Britain you can be arrested for saying the wrong things.
No one in Russia takes Radio Liberty seriously. Navalny was not a weighty politician and did nothing but empty chatter. He told fairy tales to schoolchildren, organized collections of donations, and then went to Thailand with the whole family. At the same time, he did not have a job. It's funny to read the reactions of people from Western countries. The fact that a person has passed away is always a grief. Condolences to his loved ones. If we talk about politics, 95% of the population didn't give a damn about his empty chatter.
@@TheOtosana The hypocritical "social elite" at its finest. I heard this Sobchak achieved everything simply because she is the daughter of some influential official. And then there was this scandalous naked party. And all these stupid TV shows. In her subsequent apology, she herself admitted that she likes anything shocking and provocative. This was also covered in the Western media. Navalny was not even a real oppositionist, but simply a swindler who collected donations and tried in every possible way to destabilize the situation in the country. I can’t say that he was bought by the CIA (he’s too small a pawn for them), but most likely it was from some Western sources one way or another. That’s why they hyped it all up so much in the media, although Navalny never had any special influence. An ordinary adventurer with a criminal past. But his image can be used to continue churning out all these fables about some “dictator Putin” destroying precious Freedom. lol And his wife, instead of solving everything within her country, fled to the West to seek support there and tell stories about bad Putin and the totalitarian regime. How hypocritical everything is!
I wonder how you absorb Ukrainian propaganda. they even found out about the Muscovites, I think you don’t even have an idea what this word means, but since the Ukrainians say so, then it’s worth using this word
Firstly Navalny was a nobody who was died in jail fighting the his western bosses, there is so many resources in Russia everyone wants to control it, funny thing control.
I wish Gonzalo Lira would receive the same amount of coverage in the news, a Chilean-American war commentator known for his critical views on the Zelensky regime and Russia-Ukraine conflict, passed away on January 11, 2024, in a hospital in Kharkiv, Ukraine. Lira's death followed an eight-month imprisonment on charges of ”justifying Russia's military actions in Ukraine”, sparking international controversy and raising questions about freedom of speech and human rights during wartime.
Dude... I might surprise you, but Ukraine is an even more corrupt and criminal to the bone country than Russia. I understand that all the media now say to love Ukraine and hate Russia, but these two boots are a match.
Lira is not receiving the same coverage in the news because 1) It isn’t actually certain he is dead, it is just an internet rumor. 2) He caused the deaths of hundreds of people during the battle of Kharkiv by sharing the location of anti-aircraft positions with Russian telegrams. 3) He isn’t actually American, he is (or was) Chilean with American parents. 4) He was a wanted rapist, which is why he was hiding out in Ukraine in the first place, and why he refused to leave the country despite being given multiple chances to do so by the Ukrainain authorities before his final arrest. 5) Lira is, or was, an abusive alcoholic and a homophobe. His "war coverage" consisted mostly of translating Wagner telegram channels to English and calling in to Ukrainian-leaning online shows to yell abuse at the hosts and accuse them of being gay. He also carried out a weeks-long harassment campaign against Lazerpig, the actually gay military history youtuber. As such he was hated by almost all of youtube besides his small audience of diaspora Russians, Serbs and national bolsheviks from the West.
@@hUCK- а где он ещё нужен был кроме России? Не нужно смуту наводить своими роликами. Большинству людей все равно. Навальный не сделал ничего, кроме своих провокационных роликов. Здоровая оппозиция это действия для благо людей. Где они были от него?
@@user-tx6db9tj4vyes he was paid to go back to Russia , get put in a penal colony, suffer and die leaving his family , who remain in danger. Do you not realise how dumb you sound?
Дружище, я коренной россиянин. Здесь в России все хорошо, Путину В. доверяют реально 80% точно. А вот Вам чего так интересен то этот Навальный? У Вас там есть Джулиан Ассанж, политический заключённый. И что ? Чего эту тему не развиваете? Или это другое?
@@alexanderpepkin4110What strikes me as odd is you ignoring all the people in Russia, despite the fear of dictator Putin, willing to stand up for Navalny. That’s what is very, very odd. 🤦🏻♂️😏
@@frenchimp Yes, you missed one unimportant thing, the poison with which he was poisoned does not exist in Russia, it exists only in 4 countries, the USA, the Czech Republic and two more European ones, I forget which ones.
They intentionaly used that person and this direct translation here. They've interviewed hundreds of people, but this is who they show. I don't think this translation suits at all. Wether it's the context or the way he says it, from my perspective as a russian speaker he meant "They're in the wrong to do so, even if there's some truth behind their actions" and not "They deserve a punishment, even if they're not in the wrong". This channel is biased. Liberal propaganda. Most Russians don't care about Navalny at all.
А если так: Все кто против Америки виноваты, даже если они правы. Так становится понятнее? Или подставьте любую другую страну, свою родину. Для большинства Россиян Навальный - всего лишь человек, стремящийся к власти, которого спонсировал Запад, это не секрет. А интересы большинства - это и есть демократия. И также перенесите это на свою страну. Представьте, что появится кандидат в президенты США, например, , которого спонсирует, например, Россия. Что сделает с ним власть? Как думаете?
The old man said "I think that everyone who is against Russia is guilty, even if they are right." The young man said "He fought for his country" and "may his family stay strong" I'm sure I know who I respect more, between that old guy and that young guy.
The old guy is most probably a tankie still salty about the fall of the Soviet Union to proud to see it crumbled under the weight of it's own corruption. Let's hope Putin's Russia will follow the same path.
Grandpa is old, don't laugh at him. I also blame translation, since that's not what he meant obviously. This is liberal propaganda channel, so it was intentional
I have never listened to so many people scared to let themselves speak what they feel. I am listening to their sighs and their deep breaths. And their pauses in the middle of sentences. These people have been suppressed and then some. And what this does to humans is to squelch their imagination and creativity. So sad.
better stf your stinky mouth XD id like to hear you speak effortlessly in that cold. BTW i am here in moscow and only 1 person in my circle is mourning navalnyi. So no, we wont grieve, enough revolutions in our country
Dude, it`s fucking freezing outside, so they have to deep breathe. Take the gum out from your brains, you shall see the world with more diversity than one regular rule imposed to every situation
At the same time, in the same village of Kharp, for almost 17 years (since 2007), the maniac Pichushkin has been imprisoned for life, with 48 victims to his name. But for some reason in all these years he did not have any deterioration in his health. That's it. *Do you know what's scary? Nobody remembers the names of the victims, but the killers are on TV.*
The Western media are so saddened by Navalny's death that they completely forgot that an American journalist and a citizen of the United States of America died of torture in a Ukrainian prison a couple of weeks earlier. It looks like typical pro-Western propaganda, I wouldn't be surprised if the Americans killed Navalny. the version that Russia did this is so stupid and does not stand up to any critics, think for yourself, why Putin would kill Navalny, after the victory at Avdiivka (where 1,000 to 1,500 Ukrainian militants died (Ukrainian statistics)) and a month before the elections in Russia ? for what? what would it give Putin? so he could get rid of it at any moment, but for some reason it happened exactly when it was beneficial to the United States 🤔Very mysterious😂
Radio Free Europe is CIA's asset, Navalny was CIA's asset. Finding 1-3% of Russians who would say something positive about Navalny was definitely hard as fuck. Cudos to CIA.
''@Senna-xi1gr Thats an exaggeration if ever i heard one. Most of the world has never heard of him and right now more of the world is mourning the palastinian children and worrying about their own problems This is just news in Russia and the western media who will run it non stop hopeing it will dissrupt Russia and Putins elections. This is such good news for our western politicians right now.
This guy was just an agitatator puppet of the West with the job help them tear down Russia so they can get at the resources there. The idea is to divide Russia along ethnic lines to cause the feeling of "Being Russian" to be replaced by identity politics where people don't stand together for their nation. Also, I saw this guy doing nothing for his country in this video. Nothing. He does not have the skills to run Russia and make it successful. That is exactly what the West wants - an incompetent to run Russia into the ground. He was not poisoned. Get over it. Don't you think the Russians have enought poison to have killed him back then? Ridiculous! If you want messed up, go to America where the poverty rate was 7.4% in 2021, and now is 12.4%. That is 41,000,000 Americans below the poverty line and probably millions more just barely surviving. There are 16.000.000 illegals in the country. The crime and drugs are off the charts. Your leader cares about you all.
The last speaker was very interesting. I think the word he was searching for was "martyr" . Whether icon or martyr .... often they have more power as memories than they did when they were alive.
The woman who says that nobody will be sad about his murder is blind as a kitten. Millions of people in Russia are mourning him. It is a personal loss for many, many of us.
It's a wilful ignorance that I've seen in quite a few Russian interviews. Probably a coping mechanism. But the longer they kid themselves the harder it'll be to return to reality. It seems to me that many Russians try to spend their whole life living in a safe space in their head. It's understandable, but very alienating to outside observers.
The man who said “anyone who is against Russia is guilty, even if they are right” is a mindset growing like cancer in many countries now. It isn’t logical, but who cares about logic when our media spoonfeeds us lies and manipulation.
@juzhanin55 własna, średniowieczna droga-wschodniej zniewolonej,zezwierzęconej dziczy.Obrzydza mnie jak ta człowiekopodobna, prymitywna masa ugryjsko mongolska uważa się za Słowian...
This is why my Russian grandfather left Russia at 15 and walked to Greece, got a job, got married and moved to Australia, went back and forth between Greece and Australia but never went back to Russia, never spoke to, or of, any family and friends. He just said it’s a soulless country where people will stab their own grandmother for a shot of vodka and to stay far away from it 💯
100% truth. My mother and grandmother spend 5 years on Syberian "holiday" founded by Stalin and my granddad was shot by Russians in Katyn forest.I was living my early years in the city with russian army 60 meters from my backyard.Not much changed in Russia , ex communists are the bosses of big russian mafia doing what they only want.Just like Putin do.@@lanaconin5704
@@lanaconin5704 if your grandfather had not run back and forth, but had the courage and desire to do at least something for her freedom in his country, maybe Navalny would be alive.
@@Sergei_Ru На самом деле, это очень печально. Возможно, за пределами России о величии и героизме Навального знали даже больше, чем знало даже большинство россиян. Я надеюсь, что его героизм и сила не забыты, а его честь будет жить в дыхании и жизнях других людей, которые надеются на лучшую жизнь там.
В этом всё и дело. Он у вас на западе очень сильно популярен, не так как в России. Этот факт очень сильно настораживает россиян и дискредитрует его репутацию в России.
О нем весь мир говорит не просто так, все прекрасно знают кто он такой, чертов купленный опозиционер, только Такер выпустил интервью с Путиным и сразу же умер Навальный, смешно же xD Совсем не наталкивает не на какие мысли да?
@@Elite2Delete Мысли любые могут быть, никого они не интересуют и ни на что они не влияют. Факты важны, и никто кроме догадок и домыслов ничего не может предложить. Политика - это грязь. Нечего об нее мараться по чем зря.
@@sharkytales1769 но факт остается фактом, подавляющему большинству людей плевать на Навального, особенно тем кто лично пережил 90е и как живется сейчас, для меня Навальный кусок дерьма и он заслужил своей судьбы
"…everyone who is against Russia is guilty, even if they are right"…. it sounds like a line taken from George Orwell "1984"… so shocking but also very revealing about the mindset of people who have been experiencing tyranny for decades. R.I.P. Navalny. I hope his bravery will inspire many… I hope the nightmare of Putin and his people will end soon.
Navalny was a Nazi homophobe. That's kinda funny that West make a hero out of him and keep denying that they support Nazis in Ukraine. The guy like him would be canceled and forgotten in the West, yet in Russia it is somehow ok. Reminds me how Brits forbid to sell drugs in their country but forced China to allow it.
In the usa. When he would have tried to put down the presidency. Hopefylly he woyuld be in.jail also....think......he knew the danger. 41 times the germans tried to get rid of.adolf. sofie scholl. Graf von Staufenberg...etc....also....was soll.das es ist wie es ist...now,all this media whining....the.ignorance is terrible.....painful.....selfrightshes.....stupid ....and more,suffering will take place....and Harris has no clue...she is into civil rights. And anti sem. For her and her husband. Makes sense... it takes a special person to have a worldwide view. Mr BIDEN fights stilp worldwar 2...the Nazis...trump. is ill...so day by day
It’s very strange that Navalny died a month before the presidential elections will take place in Russia and immediately after an interview with Tucker Carlson, who called for friendship with Russia. Isn’t it also strange that Yulia Navalnaya turned out to be at the Munich Security Conference on that day an hour after her husband's death she gave a speech on stage, not even holding back a tear. By the way, the poisoning of the Skripals in Britain also occurred right before the Russian presidential election.
Recently I was down near El Paso on a business trip, talking to a Homeland Security border agent. She told me they're seeing more & more Russians (and Ukrainians) slipping over the southern border to avoid the draft in their country. She states that unlike most of the people jumping our border, many of these draft-age men are highly educated, students or skilled workers and a few are professional people.(lawyers, doctors etc.) These are the very people Russia needs to fix their country.
@@user-gp3nx1np1o Да, конечно, в Украину нужно отправлять серьезных преступников, потому что многие реально мыслящие люди избегают "костной мельницы", которую создал Путин. Так что у государственных головорезов еще много "работы".
@@user-gp3nx1np1o xDDDD Да-да. И алкашей с зеками тоже из тюрем не вынуждают контракты подписывать. Живите дальше со своими фантазиями и розовыми понями в голове. Выборы пройдут, получите повесточку
This is what we become under a dictatorship. Compromised in our opinions. The passion gone. Acceptance the rule. We are facing that here. Bless your hearts. From a country girl in the struggling to be the UNITED states of America.
Please don't "AMEN" a vile, white supremacist who thought immigrants are "cockroaches". That's who Navalny was and time you informed yourself before sending out virtue signals.
You could tell that many were afraid to say what they really felt. Some even made comments that felt as if said to appease Putin. For sure, the government will be reviewing this taping. Such is life under a dictator.
Not realy. I know some liberal people. They speak their mind openly everywhere, including social media. At some point sh*tting on the RU government was a trendy thing to do. You could ride a taxi to work and hear all about how Putin is bad, open any social media and read about how bad he is there as well. I was liberal myself at some point. But now that has changed. People who do the crime and protest illegaly, they deserve the time. Liberals forget that Navalny used to gather people legaly at first, but as he began to radicalize the masses, and started to gather people illegaly, he got what he wanted - a retaliation, which justified his hate based movement. He was never realy popular tho. Amongst some students maybe, but that's it.
The Ukrainians killed an American journalist, Gonzalo Lira, in their prison. My (USA) government didn't lift a finger to save him. He was thrown in prison by the dictator Zelensky because he was critical of Ukraine's policies.
These people are quite brave to give these answers. You can see the strong emotions and hesitations in some of them. I hope they are safe and not getting knocks on their doors.
"Getting knocks on their doors"? What a delusional world you're living in 😂 Nobody cares here in Russia how people in the streets answer to the reporters until they, for example, trade state sectrets or send money to support ukraninan nazi.
I don't understand the amount of wilful ignorance and arrogance by some citizens around the world, it makes me not so surprised that atrocities throughout history have happened because the populations were so easily manipulated and ready to just lay low and accept the status quo. When government critics are so clearly set against, falsely imprisoned and likely tortured to death, and the average person seems glad or indifferent, you can see how simple it is for democracy and society to fall to ruin.
0:42 No, he WILL be missed. He IS missed. Not only by that old lady, by me, by his family, but by millions of russian people. I`m crying for two days already. I`m devastated and scared so much. Poor, poor Aleksei....
Out of fear and distrust, too few Russians have the courage to stand up for a better future. So, they grimace in what looks like a public grin out of fear and shame. “If the soul is left in darkness, sins will be committed. The guilty one is not he who commits the sin, but the one who causes the darkness.” - Victor Hugo, Les Misérables.
Or perhaps Russians value their culture and security more than they value the promise of western freedom. I suspect many Russians look at America and American cities and Western Europe and say “if that’s your better future you can have it, we don’t want it”.
I had great respect for Navalny. He was very brave. As an American, I extend my deepest sympathy to his family and all those who supported him, even if quietly. Rest In Peace Navalny. You fought til the end.
@@Sergei_RuSo...YOU created this You Tube account SEVEN days ago....OK, whatever troll! BTW, Freedom isn't meddling...it's free, as in speech...as in autonomy. You can't even mention it or you're "meddling"? You know what IS meddling? Russia invading Ukraine. Now, that IS meddling in another's affairs...smh...
@@Sergei_Ru Translated, "Hey, American, don’t meddle in our affairs with your “democracy and freedom”, we don’t want to end up like Syria or Iraq... " :*( Не могу сказать, что не понаслышке понимаю, как вы живете в России. Я никогда не был там. Однако я понимаю, что значит жить в страхе. Это ужасная трагедия в жизни, которая может затронуть ваше сердце и душу. Я надеюсь на вас, что где бы вы ни находились, вы чувствуете, что у вас есть свобода прожить свою жизнь так, как вы хотите, что вы испытываете настоящую радость и что вы живете каждый день без страха и с миром в своем сердце. Дай Бог здоровья Вам и всем, кто Вас окружает.
