Тёмный

Ryan Condal Interview with Elio and Linda 

Preston Jacobs
Подписаться 184 тыс.
Просмотров 32 тыс.
50% 1

Carmine and I sit down and talk about Ryan Condal's interview with Elio and Linda of Westeros.org. Recorded after Episode 6, which is why I say that Rhaenyra hasn't done anything too bad. Of course, in Episode 7, Rhaenyra is pretty evil.
/ prestonjacobs
Elio and Linda's interview with Ryan Condal
www.westeros.o...
▬▬▬▬ Follow Me on Social Media! ▬▬▬▬
/ prestonjacobssweetrobin
/ sweetrobin9000
windsofwinter.com
▬▬▬▬ Check Out These Videos! ▬▬▬▬
The Purple Wedding: • A Song of Ice and Fire...
A Frey in the Snow: • A Song of Ice and Fire...
The Deeper Dorne: • A Song of Ice and Fire...
▬▬▬▬ Information ▬▬▬▬
House of the Dragon is an American fantasy drama television series created by George R. R. Martin and Ryan J. Condal for HBO. It is a prequel to the television series Game of Thrones (2011-2019) and is based on Martin's 2018 novel Fire & Blood. Set two hundred years before the events of Game of Thrones the series chronicles the beginning of the end of House Targaryen, the events leading up to the Targaryen civil war, known as the "Dance of the Dragons", and the war itself. House of the Dragon received a straight-to-series order in October 2019 with casting beginning in July 2020 and principal photography beginning in April 2021 in the United Kingdom. The first season of the series is scheduled to premiere in 2022 and will consist of ten episodes.
#asongoficeandfire
#HOTD
#houseofthedragon
#gameofthrones

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

21 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 329   
@simcoe4045
@simcoe4045 Год назад
About the question of the Targaryens assimilating: Ruling classes don’t assimilate as quickly as regular immigrants do. The English kings spoke French until the 15th century. It makes sense for the Targaryens to still uphold some Valyrian traditions 100 years after the conquest.
@romulusnuma116
@romulusnuma116 Год назад
I disagree the Normands bought with them lots of French nobles which is the reason why they were able to continue speaking it Targaryens were mostly on their own
@edel5223
@edel5223 Год назад
also, dragons. valyrian is tied to their power
@simcoe4045
@simcoe4045 Год назад
@@romulusnuma116 Yes, the Targaryens were mostly on their own, which is why they mostly speak the common tongue. But it still makes sense for at least some of them to uphold some Valyrian traditions.
@romulusnuma116
@romulusnuma116 Год назад
@@edel5223 I don't think Valyrian is understood by dragons its like how pets will respond to commands
@jeannebouwman1970
@jeannebouwman1970 Год назад
@@romulusnuma116 dragons are said to be very intelligent, I wouldn't be surprised if they could understand valerian
@Longshanks1690
@Longshanks1690 Год назад
I generally want to agree with Preston’s point that Targaryen Incest was not nearly as normalised as we and post-Baratheon characters think it was, but there just seems to be too many examples of genuine love, or lust, between family members to discount it. The scion of their house, Aegon I, famously married Visenya for duty but Rhaenys for love, which he didn’t have to do. Bloodraven and Bittersteel fighting over a woman their whole lives who was their sister is probably the most famous example as no one told them they had to do that, they just did that naturally. At the same time, there’s Naerys and her brother Aemon the Dragonknight. And while they didn’t have sex like Aegon IV believed and Daeron II was legitimate, it still seems very likely that they were forbidden lovers who just couldn’t be together. Jaehaerys II and Shaera are probably the example that proves this point best as after Aegon V grew a distaste of the practise of incest, these two ruined two very politically strategic marriages for the Crown just to marry one another in a way that makes it sound like they were star crossed lovers who couldn’t bear to be apart from one another. Hell, even the most integrated to Westerosi religion and customs, Baelor The Blessed, locked his sisters in the Maidenvault so he wouldn’t be tempted by them. So if there isn’t something in the Valyrians which makes them more prone to Incest than other races, why did the king who believed more strongly in the Andal gods than any other Targaryen king still feel these urges? And there are many, many more examples than this one could cite. I really like the idea Preston is going for and that the Targaryens did feel the same taboo about Incest that most people did, but there are just too many examples from the text which say this just isn’t the case. There are too many characters who do feel this way about their siblings to discount them as simply political marriages like the Hapsburgs when many Targaryens explicitly create unnecessary political crises just to indulge their incestous desires.
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin Год назад
The love is stuff that is claimed by biased histories. We also know that politics, prophecy and dragon hatching are factors, which each seem much more logical than finding your sibling hot.
@robbypodobinski824
@robbypodobinski824 Год назад
Baelor found all his sisters hot so he locked them in a tower
@Longshanks1690
@Longshanks1690 Год назад
@@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin Aegon I aside, all of the examples I cited were after the Dance so dragonriding genes were not nearly as important as they were in the first century of Targaryen rule. Likewise, if they were motivated by long term planning in regards to politics or prophecy, why did they constantly fight each other, often motivated by the same rivalries that other people would have? It hardly seems consistent that they would want to intermarry because they were thinking about the future only to then kill their cousins in the present. Likewise, the histories are biased but they are not SO biased that they can straight up discount events that happened, otherwise we would have no textual evidence that Jaehaerys I and Alysane ever quarrelled at all. So clearly the events as described have _some_ legitimacy to them and as I said, there are simply too many examples of personal desire overcoming long term planning in the history of House Targaryen to discount what seems to be the certainty that they are simply more prone to Incest than other people. I want to agree with you as the idea that the Targaryen custom was actually cold and calculated to maintain dragonriding genes all along is a great and intriguing one, but there’s simply too much contradictory evidence of what these characters were actually like for that to hold up to scrutiny.
@burritoboi2422
@burritoboi2422 Год назад
@@Longshanks1690 This is a very good counter to Prestons theories. The fact that you sight 4-5 instances of Targaryens marrying/fighting/imprisoning each other for love/romance/lust after the dying of the dragons really lends credence that the dragon riding gene theory may not play as big a roll in the affairs of Targaryen marriages.
@Kavurcen
@Kavurcen Год назад
@@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin idk why we're talking abt all this when we have the Lannister twins textually in love with each other
@Kerrandrius
@Kerrandrius Год назад
The mermaid-horse is called a Hippocampus. It's a real mythological and heraldic character. Check wikipedia.
@mitch9347
@mitch9347 Год назад
Someone has done something right with this new series, feels much more ASOIAF than S5-8 of GoT.
@HickoryBill
@HickoryBill Год назад
Honestly it feels like having any color aside from grey or black or brown makes this feel aesthetically waaaaaaay closer to the book vision of westeros
@toprope_
@toprope_ Год назад
They seem to be almost done jumping around. They have about 2-3 years left of the Dance after this next time skip for episode 8. Feels like they’ve been focusing on the Targaryen’s inputs only, skipping over a lot of other families, because at this time the entire focus of the realm was on the people who had dragons.
@owbu
@owbu Год назад
Fun fact: Vomitoriums are just stadium doors. They did have a lot of those though.
@JimRFF
@JimRFF Год назад
Thank you for being at least one other person who knows this... I always get pissed when people bring up vomitoriums because they DID exist but they were NOT "a place where people when to vomit," that's a misunderstanding of Latin... vomitorium was literally just the word for the aisle breaks in the bench rows in an area that led to entrances for each section to allow the rapid discharge *of people out from the arena* when the games were over
@KomodoDojo
@KomodoDojo Год назад
Yup Preston made a common gaff. But he’s not a Roman History guy so he gets a pass
@don_5283
@don_5283 Год назад
@@KomodoDojo I didn't take it as a gaffe. I took it as though he was speaking about the modern common (mis)conception, played straight. Maybe that's giving him too much credit. Not sure.
@Kavurcen
@Kavurcen Год назад
@@KomodoDojo he does kinda like to present himself as a Roman history guy tho, see his comments throughout this comment section
@KomodoDojo
@KomodoDojo Год назад
@@Kavurcen He has a high opinion of himself. You can be well-read but also ignorant. Preston speaks with confidence and conviction which is really effective in convincing people of an idea. So he’s wrong, it doesn’t in the end detract from his argument which is glorification in media. The idea of the vomitorium being something more than an architectural design is personified in western media as something else. It ironically is evidence of the argument of a fake representation of the past.
@mickmickymick6927
@mickmickymick6927 Год назад
For the record, the Prince of the UK Harry (so not the direct heir), went to a party where he dressed up as a Nazi officer. Certainly affected his reputation at the time.
@PiepMiau04
@PiepMiau04 Год назад
I was thinking of crown prince Rudolph of Austria. He slept around and infected his wife with a sexually transmitted disease.. causing her to be infertile and so she couldn't provide a male heir to the austrian throne.
@claytonschopfer8467
@claytonschopfer8467 Год назад
The assimilation conversation is super interesting. Preston is of course right that after 100 years any family would be super integrated into their new society, however I think it changes the situation being royalty and the most powerful people in the world. As the society around them begins to shape them, because of their position of power they also shape the cosiera around them and are able to isolate themselves and continue customs that others can’t. I think this is also why they speak Valyrian to the dragons and between each other at times. It’s too maintain their sense of elitism and supremacy of their family over others
@thibautnarme6402
@thibautnarme6402 Год назад
Well yes and not, Germanic upper class identity after the conquest of the West Roman Empire endured more than 100 years, because it was so large; They became the upper strata of they respective societies, not just their royal houses. Here we have 3 dozens or so of Valyrian characters in a sea of Westerosi nobility. So I'd imagine assimilation would be rather typical.
@rileyjevs
@rileyjevs Год назад
What are the chances that F&B v2 and a bunch of dunk and egg novellas come out before WINDS? I thinking quite high 🤔
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin Год назад
I would agree. They lead into shows.
@JPISME91
@JPISME91 Год назад
Honestly I’m very invested in the dunk and egg stories so It wouldn’t be the worst thing in the world.
@GabrielBelmont4727
@GabrielBelmont4727 Год назад
Can`t imagine him not releasing Blood and Fire next year or thereabouts.
@umwha
@umwha Год назад
25:00 - George thinking about making the Targaryens black. Yes, I think he was waxing poetic - but that literally coulndnt fit in the story because that would make Jon half-black and his identity couldnt be hidden.
@JPISME91
@JPISME91 Год назад
I REALLY liked Feast when I first read it. I’m not sure how it holds up overall though. The kingsmoot was one of the most gripping scenes of the entire series for me.
@jacksonross5941
@jacksonross5941 Год назад
it holds up very well, I agree with Preston that it's the most thematically coherent book out of the 5
@JPISME91
@JPISME91 Год назад
@@blaubeer8039 yeah idk how you can read Feast and think “damn, I wish we were in Meereen” lol
@Skatoony9
@Skatoony9 Год назад
I suppose, aside from some pacing problems, the issues with Feast aren't really issues with Feast, but problems with what came after. People had to wait five more years for the rest of the story, and even then ADWD ends on so many cliff hangers that it resolves almost nothing from AFFC or ADWD. If ADWD was released closer to AFFC and actually resolved plot lines that were supposed to be resolved over this arc of the story, it would be much easier to appreciate it.
@Skabanis
@Skabanis Год назад
There is one line with queen Cersei I laughed so hard I was crying. I reread it like 10 times just funny as hell.
@Skabanis
@Skabanis Год назад
Preston need a history lesson Caligula wasn’t depraved? Dude stfu
@SexySiren24
@SexySiren24 Год назад
I'd admit to laughing for 5 min straight at the thought of Prince William and Anne at a brothel, as fucked up as that may be.
@jedaye47
@jedaye47 Год назад
'Better Anne than Andrew'
@joeyeardley4002
@joeyeardley4002 Год назад
I can kind of see Charles and Margaret doing it
@microflamer4453
@microflamer4453 Год назад
"Condal probably hasn't read the Hedge Knight" Preston, Condal literally said he read it earlier in the interview
@aguglie441
@aguglie441 Год назад
Regarding the Velaryon sigil, it should be noted that in many cultures seahorses are more associated with dragons than horses. In Japanese seahorses are called Tatsu-no-otoshigo, which translates to Dragon’s bastard child (or evil spawn).
@AEDVINtus
@AEDVINtus Год назад
One thing I always thought was interesting about Blazonry is the posit that a lot of knight's armor may have been painted going into battle, and the reason we think most of them wore plain armor is the monks that collected the armor scrubbed the paint off to preserve it and that's how they painted pictures of the battles. Not entirely too sure if that's just an old historian wife's tale but I thought it was pretty cool. I know they found a Germanic ritter helmet with some very cool paintings on it, in addition to some other helms.
@nutyyyy
@nutyyyy Год назад
It's very complicated and varies by period and personal choice. Some armour was certainly painted, although it seems more common on lower end armours. Textile coverings are also popular in later periods. Jupons, coat armours, and surcoats were common in the 14th and early 15th centuries. Really, it just depends. Later on the in the late 15th and into the 16th century, things went crazy with embossing, etching, and other absolutely insane designs that look stunning. But certainly, plenty of Men at Arms would have worn white armour, i.e, polished and uncovered and this is mentioned. There was a huge variety though.
@AstraLuna-o9i
@AstraLuna-o9i Год назад
You have to remember that HBO is trying to win back the audience that D&D wrote the later seasons of GOT for, the normie fan that knows nothing about the books, or really care for Fantasy, and those people pushed GOT into being a huge cultural phenomenon. The people who think Danaerys name was Khaleesi and enjoy gratuitous sex, violence, and nonsensical battle scenes over dialogue scenes or character development scenes. So it’s no surprise that Condyl is basing the Targaryens off Hollywood renditions of Rome. Edit: To the people who think this a “strong woman YAS slay Queen show”, you are going to be sorely disappointed because everyone is in the Dance of Dragons are pretty shitty, despite their gender. Lol.
@addamsixx7915
@addamsixx7915 Год назад
Not addam velaryon
@aleksandarnikolov3182
@aleksandarnikolov3182 Год назад
@@addamsixx7915 Best boy Addam
@platypusbaybee7969
@platypusbaybee7969 Год назад
@@aleksandarnikolov3182 LOYAL
@HickoryBill
@HickoryBill Год назад
You’re wrong about the gladiator rings not being brutal. I had to read Galen’s writings for my history of science degree. Pretty much our entire early basis of anatomy is based on being able to cut up/attempt to fix dying or dead gladiators. It is some insanely brutal stuff.
@TheDelinear
@TheDelinear Год назад
There's brutal and then there's six-gladiators-die-per-show-brutal. The latter is just not sustainable.
@HickoryBill
@HickoryBill Год назад
@@TheDelinear hey im not arguing the tourney in hotd was way too brutal for westeros’ tourney standards, but the sentiment that the gladiatorial arenas and their brutality are largely myth is absolutely wrong. You can read the historical accounts of Roman’s throwing naked and unarmed men to battle lions. That’s not even the main show
@Gekokujo76
@Gekokujo76 Год назад
@@HickoryBill Exactly...see how the strawman turns into "six gladiators per battle!" hyperbole? The fights were brutal and there was plenty of death and blood. As you mention, there were Man Vs Beast(s) competitions.....the men being slaves and/or prisoners. The animals were brought from all over the empire...the more exotic the better...and COULD die in the first fight. Some arenas were filled with water and there were naval battles. "Gladiators" become a "True Scotsman" argument after a while. It IS true that most of the named "Gladiators" wouldnt be at much risk of dying...a Christian prisoner who has to battle lions....PROBABLY going to die.
@mschell8022
@mschell8022 Год назад
Hes not saying it "wasn't brutal", he is saying that the brutality depicted in most Hollywood shows about this era is unrealistic.
@Gekokujo76
@Gekokujo76 Год назад
@@mschell8022 And Id say he's doing the "Everybody but me thinks....-insert strawman" . We all know it when we see it, because every basic bitch does it. Hey Preston...what do you think of the wage gap, the decimation of Native people, the level of Fascism in America, if a woman can be a man if she wishes on a star, if Led Zeppelin is a good band, if we should celebrate Columbus day, or if gladiators actually REGULARLY died fighting in Arenas (all over Rome's vast empire)? We already know the answer to all of it....and the strawmen he would use....and the "1619" handbook he would get all of his fun facts from. He probably thinks Reagan used Springsteen's "Born In The USA" without even understanding what it was about! Basic Bitch Arguments that only are allowed to persist because these guys dont challenge themselves with people who dont hold their views....and surround themselves with callow yes men/Carmine.
@thedragondemands5186
@thedragondemands5186 Год назад
of course Ryan Condal read Dunk & Egg, he pitched a Dunk & Egg prequel in 2016
@beesheer3761
@beesheer3761 Год назад
Damn Preston deserved that interview!! Btw you guys are the best GOT/HOTD podcast by far!! Love you guys!!
@Phil_Burton
@Phil_Burton Год назад
I wouldn't use modern immigration to explain what's going on with the Targaryens. A much better analogy is the Normans who largely considered themselves French and used French as the court language in England for hundred of years after 1066. I think the show nails this with them still using what is basically a dead language in court that's not understood by anyone other than Maesters.
@jeannebouwman1970
@jeannebouwman1970 Год назад
High valerian isn't "basically a dead language" it's a lingua franca in Essos and a lot of free cities still speak the language. We know Tyrion has learned it, so a bunch of studious lords and all the maesters probably know it as well
@jeannebouwman1970
@jeannebouwman1970 Год назад
@@blaubeer8039 well 200 years after the fall of rome latin was still alive. tyrion does struggle to comunicate in the free cities, but he already has a leg up from the normal westerosi. latin was an academic language in europe for more than a millenium after the fall of rome
@user-vz1zc3fn7o
@user-vz1zc3fn7o Год назад
@@blaubeer8039 The majority of the population in the Free Cities would speak their local variant of Valyrian, but High Valyrian would likely still be well known by the elites and used as a diplomatic language.
@Phil_Burton
@Phil_Burton Год назад
@@jeannebouwman1970 I meant more like in Westeros but the historical analogy would be say in 800 AD Latin you'd learn in school is well on it's way to becoming Italian, French, Spanish etc and only really survives in written texts and monasteries, not as a commonly spoken language. The big point is that they are slowly becoming more and more Westerosi but are still kind of different than 99.5% of their subjects and keep up some district cultural practices like High Valyrian and incestual marriage and their own wedding rites etc etc
@pawejedral3371
@pawejedral3371 Год назад
I believe that the main problem with Rhaenyra's heirs being bastards and other cases of breaking the legal and social rules is that she is a princess of a rather fresh foreign dynasty with nuclear weapons (dragons). For anyone who is not a dragon raider, the law and institutions are only shield and hope that they won't go back to the times of conquest or Maegor the Cruel when Targaryen did whatever they wanted, because they have dragons, a power without match. For the most historical empires, after conquest there should come a time of cohabitation, law and compromises between conquered and conquerors, due to the inability to keep the conquering power and the threat of violence indefinitely. With dragons in the Westeros, we still have this staying threat without any chance of regular opposition from the smallfolk or the lords, so any rules and institutions (marriage, inheritance, punishments for the crimes, etc) and abiding them by Targaryen are crucial. They are all that difference this regime from straight-up bloody tyranny. And any rules-breaking Targaryen should be a scary and threatening thing to any inhabitant of Westeros or public order. The big problem with this interpretation which we see in a lot of materials - with Alicent being jealous, conservative bigot and brave free spirit you-go-girl Rhaenyra - is that Alicenta is regular person from good family, but with not such a great standing in westerosi society (she Is a daughter of the second son, woman) and Rhaenyra is an heir to the throne, from master-race of eugenic dragon riders, who believe themselves to be above other people (or even closer to goods) because they descent from the old slaving empire. Alicent don't have too much choice, structurally, than just abide the rules. Being the mother of a dragon rider or a Targaryen king is probably the highest and safest position someone like her can secure and the only situation in which she has a chance to not be defenseless snd afraid for her life if next targaryen noble decide that he wants to for example murder someone or burn a city. For her, situation in which her son was maimed without any consequences, by Rhaenyra nad Daemon kids. was probably a tipping point, because she again felt helpless. Not because she is not brave enough, not because she is not yass-slay-queen-rebel, but basically because she is not Targaryen. In the contrast - Rhaenyra, as heir and dragon raider, has probably the best, most independent position in 7 kingdoms, apart of her sex, because she has hierarchic advantage over almost anyone and also possibility to use ultimate nuclear dragon violence on the whim . Her misbehaving and rule breaking is not a sign of bravery, its more like Elon Musk or other privileged billionaire or politician flaunting that they don't have to follow rules. Or worse. Because of dragons.
@CorrectionUnknown
@CorrectionUnknown Год назад
You got way too much time on your hands.
@postpunk6947
@postpunk6947 Год назад
For me, the best example of QT's hyperviolence is definitely Grindhouse Deathproof and the theme of a guy killing people with a car. The design of the car itself and the fact that it is death proof, but only for the driver. And this crash scene with repeated shots of how the characters die one by one.
@MohamedRamadan-qi4hl
@MohamedRamadan-qi4hl Год назад
The gladiator games weren't the only blood games that were being played. There were many different types. Like gladiators killing slaves and criminals. Animals killing slaves and criminals. Animals killing each other. And don't get me started about the times they flooded the colosium to recreate naval battles
@armandopena4929
@armandopena4929 Год назад
I think the half horse sigil is meant to be a hippocampus, a creature from greek myth
@jaredbrady5566
@jaredbrady5566 Год назад
Feast is like Midnight Tides of the Malazan series. On your 1st readthrough it's at the bottom, but on re-reads it rockets to the top.
@YggdrasilAudio
@YggdrasilAudio Год назад
The horse on the Velaryon sigil is a hippocampus, and that is actually the symbol for A World Of Ice And Fire.
@Borgcow
@Borgcow Год назад
I’m guessing since he hasn’t mentioned Rhaenyra murdering that rando this was recorded before ep 7?
@postpunk6947
@postpunk6947 Год назад
I love every ASOIAF book, but Feast is my favorite too.
@logancarlile8895
@logancarlile8895 Год назад
33:45 just because there are rules about heraldry doesn’t mean that the escutcheon (not coat of arms or “sigil” as GRRM calls them, escutcheons were are the “shield” component of coats of arms without the supporters or achievements around it) didn’t break those rules all the time. Every culture has their own traditions which conflicted with each other and their own personal inclusions which could be seen as strange. Not to mention that at a certain point esutcheons were quartered so many times that you’d end up with ones like modern Spain’s today, which you can’t easily recall or draw without staring at it Same thing applies to flags, yes there *are* rules about how they *should* be designed, but any American who’s seen an atrocious town or state flag can tell you they aren’t always at all. Including “flawed” heraldry, imo, makes the setting more believable and also unique. Westeros isn’t 1:1 medieval Europe
@SupposeIRose
@SupposeIRose Год назад
So I went and read the interview and it pretty much was exactly how you reported on it here but the thing that stood out to me and I thought was really funny was the indication at the beginning that Linda was not there and that she just left after saying hello to Ryan "to look after our dog Lancelot" And given the way Linda has been ranting about the show and the casting of black people on Twitter, I just found that very funny
@ModernSynthesist
@ModernSynthesist Год назад
Thanks for this comment. Until I read it, my head canon understanding of Linda was kind of an "old man yells at clouds" level adversarial relationship to fans. But after your comment, I actually read her comments about Corlys, and Jesus christ that's a lot more racist than I expected and not ok.
@Kavurcen
@Kavurcen Год назад
The funniest thing about Linda is that she likes to do the whole "but muh faithful source material" thing that Rings of Power fans are obsessed with. Except, not only is GRRM not long dead like Tolkien, but she actually knows him, and has publicly admitted that he does not give a shit. I think his words per Linda were something to the effect of "get off Twitter." And GRRM himself has been repeatedly stoked about some differences between books and show, even in GOT, but especially in HOTD! See: his absolutely raving love of Considines Viserys. How far up your ass does your head need to be to play white knight for an an authors canon, against that authors own beliefs? Not to mention the suspicious silence on other issues. Black Corlys is a tragedy, of course. Silence on the funeral changed from Laenor's, an actual textual difference. Instead her issue is with Laenor surviving, which doesn't matter and a slim chance but plausible per book canon. She seems really mad the gay (+black) man didn't die, for no damn reason... hmmmmm.....
@ModernSynthesist
@ModernSynthesist Год назад
@@Kavurcen Noticed she also tastefully defended with the classic "I have many racialized friends/there are plenty of racialized actors I approve of in Got" when referencing Dornish characters.
@Kavurcen
@Kavurcen Год назад
@@ModernSynthesist lmfao of course..... which is extra funny bc in HOTD dornish just means vaguely swarthy, like Sicilian or Jewish
@Erick-tv8oq
@Erick-tv8oq Год назад
@@Kavurcen I thought the Velaryons being black was one of the best choices the show made. Not only does it help sell Valyria as an actual foreign empire (multiple "races" of people coming from multiple conquered nations, assimilating into the culture and eventually rising to positions of power), it also helps make the Velaryons feel visually distinct from the Targaryens (drives home how they are their own family), makes it easier to understand the conflict since we have more visual variety among the cast instead of 20 similar looking people with white wigs, and also gives the people who care about representation something more to like about the show. It makes sense in every way imo
@mitchbeenhakker7922
@mitchbeenhakker7922 Год назад
I know for sure Ryan has read the hedge knight, because that was Ryan’s first wish to do as a show
@gregoryjoseph7132
@gregoryjoseph7132 Год назад
hey i know itd take a little more trouble but if you guys are discussing an image such as a sigil, it would greatly enhance the viewing experience if you put it on screen.
@keirangrant1607
@keirangrant1607 Год назад
In WOIAF states that there was once a tourney at. Last Harth in which 18 men died. Ryan was probably more right than we gave him credit for
@SaudiHaramco
@SaudiHaramco Год назад
I'm sorry but ican't get over this lol the Velaryons being black just doesn't make sense no matter how you wanna twist it.. their purpose in the story is literally just that they are of the same ethnic group as the Targaryens. It's their one defining characteristic. Making the Valyrian ruling class multi-ethnic removes the whole point behind the "pure Valyrian blood" theme. George very purposefully writes the Targaryens as Valyrian-supremacists who believe that they are superior to others because of their race (and then of course demonstrates that they are infact not actually superior). This idea that you have characters that have ultimately racist motivations but at the same time you make their racism inclusive is just nonsense.
@James-pc9yv
@James-pc9yv Год назад
Condal does know about dunk & egg. He stated in an interview that George told him where the story is going to go.
@bloodyplebs
@bloodyplebs Год назад
Medieval Christians absolutely did not believe it was a good thing that Rome fell. If they did they wouldn’t have revived it in 800. Who is the most important theologian to medieval Christians, Augustine, who so loved the Roman Empire.
@Vmac1394
@Vmac1394 4 месяца назад
I've read Confessions and City of God and I never got the sense that Augustine loved the Roman Empire. He uses Roman history to illustrate his points and it often makes the Romans look quite bad. He criticizes events like the foundation myth with Romulus murdering his brother and the Rape of the Sabine Women. He points out that the Romans constantly backstab one another and that even the histories admit the only times the Romans ever had social unity was when they were in imminent danger of annihilation.
@bloodyplebs
@bloodyplebs 4 месяца назад
@@Vmac1394 Augustine criticizes pagan Rome. In the city of god he defends Christianity against pagan attacks that it was the cause of the sack of Rome in 410. Many pagans saw it as divine punishment for adopting Christianity. Augustine argues that no, Christianity is the reason for the empires success and paganism is not. Go back and read book 4. Augustine was a Roman who supported and loved the Roman Empire, a Christian Roman empire I might add.
@pinkyfull
@pinkyfull Год назад
14:30 Your conversations about assimilation are a little silly. You're comparing colonists with Rulers. The Targ's are rulers, and ruling classes have always had wildly divergent values than those they rule. Think about how long it took for Vikings to properly assimilate into British society, and other societies in Europe. Or Mongols in Russia. Or the Normans in England. It can take some time. And when considering fictional psychic dragon riders who take exceptionalism as part of their family character it is no surprise to me that they would have wildly different ideals than those that they rule.
@ludovicofabris5819
@ludovicofabris5819 Год назад
When Spielberg made "Temple of Doom" he rejected the elephant wranglers using their long sticks because he didn't see them use that in "The Jungle Book"... Hollywood historical imaging is even more powerful than hisory itself. I like to think those lewd tapestries were later removed by Baelor the Blessed.
@umwha
@umwha Год назад
26:00 - Having colonies all over the world actually dosent logically mean that entire noble families will be multiracial. There were not black noble houses in Rome, there were not black, indian, australian, or native american noble houses in europe, just because of colonisation.
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin Год назад
Valyria existed 5000 years. Rome controlled North Africa for a few hundred and European colonization was for a few hundred. There would be nothing illogical about a black Valyrian house.
@umwha
@umwha Год назад
@@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin I guess if it existed for 5 times longer than the longest empire known in the real world, then anything is possible. However I do point out that Valyria the country was founded 5,000 years ago, so the imperial stage would begin later in its history. However, all we do know about the people of Valyria is that they were so obsessed with blood purity they married siblings. Therefore I really dont see them ever interbeeding with the people from the conquered territories, or even countencing the ascention of nonvalyrian race people to a noble status. I could well imagine Valyrians having sex with slaves, and then over a few centuries there would be a good chance that some people born as slaves would posess dragon riding capabilities, which may allow them to earn status in Valyria and become noble. That means that this population of people who have a non-valyrian phenotype but do have dragon-genes and therefore become noble would have a mixed race appearence (since the slave population would be extremely multiracial) and would not look as clearly and homogenously african as the Velaryons do in the show. The real world analogy of this is the Coloreds of south africa. However, the Coloreds of SA only started to gain standing in SA after the British abolished slavery. But give it 5000 years and anything could happen. Come to think of it, Valyria didnt have a colony anywhere where black people live. On the wiki it says that Summer Isles were 'raided by slavers' from Valyria, I suppose that's sufficient. Really, the possibly Valyrian descended house they should have made black is the Hightowers, since the Hightowers were the kings of Old Town, which was apparently founded specifically as a trade port with the Summer Islanders, Valyria and Old Ghis. Old town would logically have an increased black presence historically due to this regular trade, whereas Driftmark would never see any trade or travel of the black summer islanders, making it unlikely that their looks would be preserved for this long, unless they practised more extreme incest than the Targaryens.
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin Год назад
@@umwha Dude, the Basilisk Isles were part of Valyria for thousands of years. And we only hear that Targaryens worried about blood purity (perhaps because they were dragon riders). Clearly the other Valyrians didn't care that much as they married into the people of the Free Cities. You're really trying hard to have a problem with something.
@umwha
@umwha Год назад
​@@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin Correct me if I'm wrong but we've never heard what the indigenous population of Basilisk isles look like - of if there is an indigenous population at all. Additionally, there do not seem to be any native humans on Sothoryos, only Brindled Men. All black people on known planetos must ancestrally come from the Summer Isles.
@Tremere
@Tremere Год назад
@@umwha Dude don't question what is clearly an ESG-influenced casting choice, or Preston will passive-aggressively call you an anti-sjw robot in his next video. Funny how "anti-wokers" are unthinking bots while Preston and Carmine are more than happy to insult and name-call their own viewers for having the gall to express an opinion that goes against their worldview
@dimedisciple5144
@dimedisciple5144 Год назад
Is this a snippet of a podcast or something? Or does Carmine always want to end them turbo early. This was a hair over 35 minutes and I could listen to an hour podcast of y’all easily. Or maybe Preston had the new baby to tend to….? I dunno, point being is to make them longer guys. Good stuff.
@OfficialRedTeamReview
@OfficialRedTeamReview Год назад
Snippet of a longer one that I've cut up into pieces. Oh and I don't "turbo end" anything early, my dude. Both of us have lives and can't really do a long form 3 hour podcast like Rogan does.
@dimedisciple5144
@dimedisciple5144 Год назад
@@OfficialRedTeamReview Maybe you can’t, but it’d be cooler if you did. And you totally love to end, my brutha from anotha mutha. Where is the full podcast? I’m subbed on the app.
@gogozeppeli9267
@gogozeppeli9267 Год назад
@@OfficialRedTeamReview 3 hours? Fuck no i have shit to do pls keep it 30 min to 1 hour...not everyone is as bored as that other dude 🤣
@OfficialRedTeamReview
@OfficialRedTeamReview Год назад
@@gogozeppeli9267 good man
@gokbay3057
@gokbay3057 Год назад
5:05 "the Barbarians" also weren't savages. A good chunk had been citizens even (Odoacer, who famously deposed the last Western Roman Emperor was an officer of the Roman Army for 6 years before overthrowing Romulus Agustulus).
@nadias.mariano2196
@nadias.mariano2196 Год назад
I don't agree that all the characters are grey or horrible. Corlys and Rhaenys are nice people. Rhaenyra children are good and kind boys, the same for Baela and Rhaena. Helaena is innocent and sweet. In season two: Daeron is THE nice person in the story. Adam is the most honorable in all Fire and Blood. Netles and Benjicot cried after battle. There is also Cregan Stark, Aly Black, and other minor characters.
@gudmundursteinar
@gudmundursteinar Год назад
The Roman Empire converted to Christianity and the most christianized bit was the one that survived for 1000 more years. The Barbarians WERE CHRISTIAN. It's important not to forget that. What killed the Western Roman Empire was an inability to collect taxes combined with the loss of the graine provinces in North Africa to the vandals, this killed the grain dole and ended social cohesion in italy. The lack of money meant that the empire had to pay it's army in land and not coin so in effect they established multiple "barbarian" kingdoms, the Ostrogoths, the Visigoths, the Franks, the Burgundians ect. At some point the General Controlling Rome and the leader of it's armies realized that he didn't control any areas outside Italy directly so he simply realized that it wasn't an empire anymore and sent the regalia to Constantinopel. The Eastern Roman Empire spent the next 200 years trying to reassert control and did everywhere except France and Britain. This attempt basically ended with a combination of a civil war, persian invasion and avar invasion.
@piggy201
@piggy201 Год назад
Talking about ancient myths and misconceptions, vomitorium isnt a place to vomit, it's a mass exit area out of a building. Like a Colosseum, which isn't called Colosseum, but Flavian Amphitheatre. Colosseum is the place where it is built, bcs it used to be populated by big statues (colosses).
@MohamedRamadan-qi4hl
@MohamedRamadan-qi4hl Год назад
He was wrong about how bloody games in colosseum were. Gladiators didn't commonly kill each other. But gladiator games were hardly the only games there. There were games were gladiators killing criminals and slaves. Animals killing slaves and criminals and animals killing each other.
@piggy201
@piggy201 Год назад
@@MohamedRamadan-qi4hl I did not dispute any of those things. Just adding about the vomitorium thing
@BronzFury
@BronzFury Год назад
This is a fairly small subject you guys cover in this but just to clear matters up it seems fairly obvious that Targaryens seem almost magically or perhaps pheromonally attracted to one another. This is illustrated multiple times, from Jaehaerys and Alysanne getting married against the wishes of their mother, to King Egg's kids Jaehaerys and Shaera hooking up despite the wishes of Egg and their mother Betha Blackwood. This could also maybe explain why Jon and Dany may perhaps find themselves somewhat magnetized towards one another when they meet (along with them just being very attractive people). So, I think saying "oh, Alyssa and Baelon probably weren't into each other" even though by all accounts they very much were because brothers and sisters just aren't as a rule is a little ignorant of the reality the author is trying to illustrate.
@malicewonder8345
@malicewonder8345 Год назад
They gave the Velaryons the fictional sea-horse (a hippocampus) as sigil, instead of the real animal. Some of the real medieval families had similar figures in their coats-of-arms.
@eversor10
@eversor10 Год назад
Bartimos Lord of the Crab Rave 🦀 CONFIRMED
@TheDelinear
@TheDelinear Год назад
It's very telling that these people complaining about the women getting the best characters are *actually* just complaining about women getting as much screen time as they do.
@MachineCode0
@MachineCode0 Год назад
Yeah it's sometimes a legitimate criticism, but absolutely doesn't apply to fire and blood. It's the age old irony of opposed ideologies when taken to extremes ending up mirroring each other. The extreme woke and the extreme anti woke basically sound the same, make most of the same logical fallacies and jump at ghosts and imagined slights the same way, you can basically just word swap them for eachother they are so interchangeable.
@princememphis7726
@princememphis7726 Год назад
I hate to break it to preston but incest is still very prevalent amongst extremely country people
@Gekokujo76
@Gekokujo76 Год назад
Liking A Feast For Crows is only surprising to anybody if you read it before that content happened in the tv show. The downside was that we were removed from most of the "main characters" and were introduced to new characters and storylines. If you have the context of the show, the book provides so much more information and context...plus a great idea of who Brienne already is. If you are reading from book to book with no context, you have a head full of ideas and theories that arent even touched on by the content of AFFC. If youve already seen the show, the Arya content in Braavos (whether it pays off later in the books) is such a HUGE improvement over what we get in the show.
@peterv1054
@peterv1054 Год назад
The Velaryons being black doesn't make any sense. Valyria had colonies, yes, but Velaryons aren't from the colonies, they are valyrian. They have common ancestry with Targaryens. Given that whites and blacks have tens of thousands, if not hunderds of thousands of years of different ancestry, there is no way black Valyrians can exist. Also I'm pretty confident that Velaryons and Targaryens interbred before Rhaenys and Corlys, so even if you accept the impossible premise of black Valyrians, they wouldn't be pure black Velaryons and pure white Targaryens. This critique is completely independent of the "anti SJW" critique (which is valid to some extent too).
@Aliexei
@Aliexei Год назад
The Numenor queen isn't an antagonist. Are you even watching the series? She joined her forces with Galadriel and they together kicked ass of those male orcs and their patriarch Adar along side Milf who's got that black elf all hot and heavy.
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin Год назад
Eventually. The comments were made when she was still the antagonist.
@enespanolporfavor6263
@enespanolporfavor6263 Год назад
@@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin The queen regent being an impediment to Galadriel immediately getting what she wanted in no way meant she wouldn't be a girlboss. The situation was framed more like 2 superheroes getting into arguments before teaming up. It's almost as though the people you were attempting to dunk on with your comment were actually right in their prediction how things would go based on present-day Hollywood's track record.
@Kingedwardiii2003
@Kingedwardiii2003 Год назад
I’m sorry Preston but you have no idea what you’re talking about in terms of the Roman Empire. Are you telling me that the Eastern Roman Empire which a lot of Targ symbolism is based on wasn’t decedent just because it was Christian? Have you read any first hand accounts from the church fathers like Saint Augustine who described Carthage as the most decedent city he lived in? Where sex was apart of religious worship for certain deities?
@MachineCode0
@MachineCode0 Год назад
His central point was that whatever the case the 'depravity' had nothing to do with the fall of the western empire. That reason became a pop culture meme in the modern era after being popularised by the later western church and continued by early modern historians. He finds the continued use of the visual shorthand in the 21st century amusing because it's so out of date. As do I actually.
@cianf1888
@cianf1888 Год назад
Is Preston projecting his own values on to Baelon and Alyssa? Dammit Preston I was rooting for you
@huxley1559
@huxley1559 Год назад
Not that far into the vid but doesn't he (and many more asoiaf creators) pretty much do it all the time?
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin Год назад
@@blaubeer8039 I am more concerned with the textual evidence about Targaryen consideration of dragons and prophecy. Targs in love is not a very compelling reason for me.
@ClaireYunFarronXIII
@ClaireYunFarronXIII Год назад
I wish it was you who got to interview Ryan Condal, Preston.
@Frznwhrlpll
@Frznwhrlpll Год назад
The current velaryon sigil is basically a capricorn
@poenpotzu2865
@poenpotzu2865 Год назад
My personal ranking: 1. Feast for Crows 2. Storm of Swords 3. Hedge Knight 4. Mystery Knight 5. Sworn Sword 6. Clash of Kings 7. Game of Thrones 8. Dance of Dragons
@saverna1
@saverna1 Год назад
Some friends and I were chatting about the incest tendency for Targaryens. We think the biological tendency to not want to screw your close relatives may be "resessive" in dragonriders, and that the two traits might be closely tied together, hence the "keep the blood pure" goal of producing heirs and dragonriders. I understand being squicked out by the casualness of the incest. I can see living as a Targaryen as kind of like being an Apex predator, anything goes of you want it, social guidelines are set by others and do not apply to you. Imagine being an actual physical Dragon among puny men, and the god complex that would give you.
@umwha
@umwha Год назад
33:00 - Really interesting about sigils. All I can say is that in the UK, there have been many times Ive seen a host of shields with sigils on, as they adorn many public buildings. I find many of the designs small, indistinct, and hard to identify from far away. Most sigils seem to be halved or quartered, and in each quarter has another typical symbol of a repeated pattern of symbols. Would be very hard to see from far away. The same symbols are used over again, or mashed togehter, into artistic abominations, with multiple animals around a crest which itself is quarered, with a crown held by doves, and a heart pierced with an arrow, and a banner with a latin quote on it - Thats just a typical crest XD.
@jl453k2
@jl453k2 Год назад
This is a later development of heraldry, when it started in the 12th and 13th centuries they were usually single designs that were easy to see. Quartering came later and was a way to show you ancestry off, by the 19th century it’s ridiculous, the best example is George Nugent Temple-Grenville, it’s utterly ridiculous.
@Theodosius_fan
@Theodosius_fan Год назад
Does Ryan think that ASOIAF is supposed to represent Rome not the middle ages?
@Flammewar
@Flammewar Год назад
I‘m a bit confused by Prestons remarks about Rome. They only changed like 100 years before the fall to Christianity but they are already around for 1100 years. I don’t really see why this means that they weren’t decadent. Edit. Thank you for your answers. It’s much clearer now.
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin Год назад
Yes, and it was a quick change. The state religion was Christianity by 380. Edward Gibbon actually caused quite a ruckus claiming that Christianity led to Rome's downfall rather than decadence and polytheism.
@randominternetguyoffical
@randominternetguyoffical Год назад
Hes saying Ryan wanted to bring "Roman decadence", which he clarifies is largely myth. He actually goes into some of the interpretations of Romes history from later writers in Europe. If you read about Roman history tho you'll note that the idea of decedance was actually invented by Romans sudo historians quite a while before the western half of the empire fell. Interestingly you can actually read the writings of some Romans who criticize this idea that Rome is or has become embroiled in decadence and it has brought the Empire to its knees.. again they're writing about this perceived decadence like hundreds years before the Empire falls (as I recall, im not a Rome expert tho so I'd still recommend looking it up more) A lot of it has to do with a perceived loss of social power to other groups who had long since been integrated into Roman society. (You probably recall the senatorial debate about allowing Gaelic citizens to come live in Rome and partake in the Roman government. I forget the emperor's name but he was pretty historically literate and he argued that Rome had been integrating people into its society for a long time and so it wasn't a mark of decline or Barbarian encouraging to do so) The writers in the Roman times who spoke of the decadence and decline also spoke of the alleged loss of power of the paterfamilias in the family, which was really important in traditional Roman life and something seen as a sign of womanly overreach and social decadence) Like proto incel red pilled behavior there I suppose 😂
@MohamedRamadan-qi4hl
@MohamedRamadan-qi4hl Год назад
@@randominternetguyoffical the emperor you are talking about is Claudius
@nublord365
@nublord365 Год назад
it's gonna be super easy to downvote me for this, but regarding the Velaryons being portrayed by people of color, I would want to know how Preston reconciles this with how intermarried the Targaryens and Velaryons are at this point in the story? How do they look so different when Aegon I's mother was a Velaryon, and there are several intermarriages between then and the time of King Viserys I
@VelkanKiador
@VelkanKiador Год назад
I do have thoughts about the two legged four legged dragon on the banners. First thing to keep in mind is that in medieval times there wasn't a printing press nor the internett, so standardized designs for heraldry and banners was basically impossible. Like lets say there is a sigil with a black hand on a bloody field, simple enough to design. But then things start getting a bit messy, which hand is it? Left or Right? Is the hand in a fist or not? What are the length of the fingers? When you say the background is a bloody field is it just red or a mix of red and green? Since there is no printing press you had to craft the banners and heraldry by hand, and even if you had a group of artists with a unified idea of what it should look like you will still have subtle differences in style. And since there is no internett to search what the flag should look like you have vastly different designs over bigger distances. So in conclusion, who gives a shit about the number of legs the dragon banner has? Remember that not everyone gets to see a dragon, maybe most of the artists designing the logo. Of course some would have 4, heck I imagine in places where there aren't dragons there might be a lot more dragon banners where they have four legs. Heck by the start of Game of Thrones dragons have been gone for generations. Of course there are gonna be four legged designs.
@CulinVlau
@CulinVlau Год назад
The three heads on the Targaryen sigil have a symbolic meaning. What meaning do 4 legs have? Still waiting on Condal to give an in-universe explanation.
@Schabiq
@Schabiq Год назад
please no more carmine of red team review
@dummyaccount4036
@dummyaccount4036 Год назад
They've been collaborating longer than not since 2017 and if it wasn't for Carmine we wouldn't get nearly half of the content we've gotten so cry harder lol
@Schabiq
@Schabiq Год назад
@@dummyaccount4036 ngl i would rather not have that content
@OfficialRedTeamReview
@OfficialRedTeamReview Год назад
@plan man damn that sucks 🤡
@louisroy4911
@louisroy4911 Год назад
I don’t really get the no good guy complaint. Maybe it’s just me, but I feel I don’t need to be cheering for or identifying to a good guy to appreciate entertainement.
@louisroy4911
@louisroy4911 Год назад
And judging by the number of fictions and documentaries on serial killers and psychopaths and their popularity, it seems to me a lot of people don’t care about having an obvious good guy character
@tjosiahhaynes
@tjosiahhaynes Год назад
In a valley girl accent: "UM, IT'S ACTUALLY VOMITORIA! WITH AN A!" I'm kidding, but i couldn't help myself.
@Jonjzi
@Jonjzi Год назад
When you look at Elden Ring there are a couple characters with "fire-giant" ancestory who have dark skin and red hair, kind of like a Ganondorf type look. When I saw those characteristics I figured that's what George was thinking about when he imagined dark valyrians.
@TheCinamanic
@TheCinamanic Год назад
Imho PJ should just try to simply utter sentences. All that wells, umms and pauses are so annoying and btw it doesn't show how thoughtful he is. It just come out as arrogant. Those abandoned sentences are hard to listen to. Good theorist tho.
@brookesy348
@brookesy348 Год назад
19:25 I really felt like you danced around the original point here, one of the strangest Preston answers i have heard. Something is off here. Not about main characters or likeability or good. It was energy, aptitude and masculinity he was referring to.
@brookesy348
@brookesy348 Год назад
Howrver I can see why you answered the way you did
@RAWNERVZ
@RAWNERVZ Год назад
I'm not going to quote a professor Vernon Bogdard or claim like I even got the last name spelled right but to quote paraphrase 'anything that is tempting in this world is offered to a prince of Wales'
@Clothy22
@Clothy22 Год назад
Isn’t House Baratheon technically a Valyrian house?
@7Nebulae7
@7Nebulae7 Год назад
They didn't originate from Valyria as far as I know, they just married some Targaryens along the line.
@franbalcal
@franbalcal Год назад
plot twist Bartimos Celtigar will be played by an actor of asian descent.
@anthonyseghetti8468
@anthonyseghetti8468 Год назад
I love it when Preston slips into his "Chad" voice.
@jacebales2951
@jacebales2951 Год назад
Very interesting. Feast is my favorite too even though almost everyone puts it at the bottom when ranking the books 🤣...
@gokbay3057
@gokbay3057 Год назад
30:00 A half horse half sea creature/fish is what a Seahorse means, heraldically (real seahorses are described as "Hippocampus", which yeah, is kind of backwards). Description being "a seahorse" is not proof one way or the other that it is a natural or a myhological seahorse.
@virginwrists4960
@virginwrists4960 Год назад
Preston have you ever talked about Martin's synopsis letter and also Martins writing speed in the 90s
@solomonrivers5639
@solomonrivers5639 Год назад
My second (and last) post on r/asoiaf was on my love for AFfC. You would have thought I had explained the flaws of net neutrality. Also, “A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms” audiobook is read by Harry Lloyd (Viserys) and is well worth your time. Sometimes you can find it on RU-vid or, better yet, PJ’s audible link
@BanjoSick
@BanjoSick Год назад
Hey Preston, keep to Martin. Your comments on RoP are not well informed. Really like your Martin content, though.
@Alpha1200
@Alpha1200 Год назад
For me from favourite to least favourite probably: 1. A Storm of Sword 2. A Dance with Dragons 3. A Feast for Crows 4. A Game of Thrones 5. A Clash of Kings
@cltuxunink
@cltuxunink Год назад
feel like they made the valeryons black to make the bastard stuff stand out more. probably just wanted to be able to cast a more diverse cast too plus the white dreads look sick
@unstoppableExodia
@unstoppableExodia Год назад
Love the way presto low key threw some shade on the British monarchy by calling them out for being useless 😂 Instant thumbs up for this video
@mmcat2863
@mmcat2863 Год назад
The Qing Dynasty/ Manchu never truly integrated with Chinese society (after almost 300 years), neither did the mongols
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin Год назад
Well, that's arguable, but it's a bit different when there are thousands of your own people around you haven't really moved very far. The Targs are a handful of people, isolated.
@Kavurcen
@Kavurcen Год назад
@@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin sure, but they also have giant flying fire breathing reminders that they are Different from Everyone and it's pretty reasonable to assume that would influence their perspective on assimilation versus cultural independence
@MachineCode0
@MachineCode0 Год назад
@@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin As some other people pointed out elsewhere, the Ptolemaic dynasty of Egypt are probably a better parallel. I'm no expert but my understanding is that they didn't really integrate at all with the native Egyptian people, spoke a different language and considered themselves 'other', at least for a few centuries.
@nogodsnomasters7669
@nogodsnomasters7669 Год назад
I listen to Feast and Dance over and over
@RAWNERVZ
@RAWNERVZ Год назад
According to a documentary they make Prince William seem like he was very close to making some of those mistakes but had some decent people watching his back I guess but interesting analogy
@TheCbot88
@TheCbot88 Год назад
A clash of kings is great… So the first two seasons on hotd is just incest? I’m glad I skipped it. It’s too much. Also my baby’s mother totally has purple eyes.
@dx3cannons
@dx3cannons Год назад
I hate that Linda and Elio act like the ASOIAF gatekeepers and ultimate authorization of the I.P.
@OfficialRedTeamReview
@OfficialRedTeamReview Год назад
This is incorrect. As someone who does asoiaf content and knows just about everyone in this community, they are the least "gatekeeper"-ish people around when it comes to this. And this is coming from someone who isn't a fan of them but yeah your comment is just not true compared to the other actual gatekeepers in this community.
@dx3cannons
@dx3cannons Год назад
@@OfficialRedTeamReview thanks for the insight. They’ve just said and done some things that really rubbed me the wrong way. But I’m going to trust you on this.
@OfficialRedTeamReview
@OfficialRedTeamReview Год назад
@@dx3cannons It's mostly Linda and her idiotic takes. I'll always dislike her for spoiling the Stannis story in the show because she got upset
@danielcharman9550
@danielcharman9550 Год назад
Its odd to invoke Roman Colosseum brutality in a world based on Chivalric values in the Middle ages. Its why that scene was so jarring.
@7Nebulae7
@7Nebulae7 Год назад
Alicent is definitely not pro incest, so why did she allow her own children to marry each other? Because she didn't want Rhaenyra's child marrying Helaena? Wouldn't it have been more beneficial to strenghten alliances with other houses by marrying into them?
@Theodosius_fan
@Theodosius_fan Год назад
People also take the fact that women sleeping around being less acceptable than men doing it, to mean that men could just sleep around in the middle ages. That was really not the case
@Ulyssestnt
@Ulyssestnt Год назад
@preston Jacobs ,the decadence myth was absolutely bunk. But the Romans DID have a lot of pornographic art to be fair;)
@PaulWHall
@PaulWHall Год назад
I’d disagree on it being absolute bunk. I think there’s a prime case to be made that the Crisis of the Third Century was brought on partially through decadence, especially with Commodus’s rule directly preceding it, and that the Crisis is what truly doomed Rome. After all, by the time Christianity had become the state religion, western Rome was quite different than what we think of in regards to The Roman Empire: de-urbanization, decentralization, the slave based economy moving into what was basically proto-feudalism, the marginalization of Central Italy in favor of Northern Italy (Rome had become just another city by that point, with cities like Milan and Ravenna being more important and oftentimes capitals), etc. This all being said, the idea of post-Crisis Rome being decadent is nonsense. Christian Rome was a relatively pious realm, and its eastern half lived on (and often flourished) for another thousand years.
@Ulyssestnt
@Ulyssestnt Год назад
@@PaulWHall Are we not applying our modern cultural standards to a pre modern society here though? I mean,it's understandable to the degree the Roman empire was a first attempt at modern society as Mary Beard puts it.
@Alpha1200
@Alpha1200 Год назад
9:00 - It's funny, for a very long time I didn't read Dunk & Egg because I thought they were comics. Eventually I learned that there were also regular written versions and I then bought "A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms" and I absolutely loved it.
@boykomladenov262
@boykomladenov262 Год назад
Hey Preston dude...if I'm not mistaken, but isn't exactly prince William who take pictures with SS uniform 🤔
@Xob_Driesestig
@Xob_Driesestig Год назад
I must’ve seen hundreds of hours of your and carmines videos, and despite you both having a pokemon themed profile picture in the podcast, I’ve yet to hear you say a single word about pokemon. Are you ever going to talk about it?
@AnthonyA0424
@AnthonyA0424 Год назад
I love you guys
@LNawka
@LNawka Год назад
Sibling's attraction is observed quite often in deeply dysfunctional families. It may be said that beeing part of the royal/dragon family doesn't help in this area. Imagine you are a dragonrider and only your family has dragons. In your world there's constant abuse. So how to cope? When we find ourselves attracted to our siblings, we might make sense of our attraction in terms of the most logical category available (superior dragonraiders/dragons) and feel that what is desired is sex with another dragonrider. Another similar person in similar situation. Tricks on the mind: attraction/love/power/safety. The incest taboo and it's limitations is a vast and interesting topic.
@MohamedRamadan-qi4hl
@MohamedRamadan-qi4hl Год назад
Sorry do you have proff that sibling attraction in dysfunctional families?
@LNawka
@LNawka Год назад
@@MohamedRamadan-qi4hl my response vanished, mayby bc I edited too many times and added links. Sorry for that. Try googling for example article: Etiological Risk Factors for Sibling Incest: Data From an Anonymous Computer-Assisted Self-Interview Karen Griffee, Sam Swindell, Stephen L. O’Keefe, Sandra S. Stroebel, Keith W. Beard, Shih-Ya Kuo, and Walter Stroup
@MohamedRamadan-qi4hl
@MohamedRamadan-qi4hl Год назад
@@LNawka thanks. I will look into it
@taylorgayhart9497
@taylorgayhart9497 Год назад
Wait I’m super confused why the uncle/niece pairing is supposed to be weird in story, when there are non-Targ Westerosi who married an aunt or uncle. Just off the top of my head there were two Stark girls married to their uncles, and that’s not even mentioning the dozens of first cousins which is only a step away from aunt/uncle. Otto suggested Rhaenyra marry her HALF BROTHER, how is uncle worse than HALF BROTHER?!?! Lol it just bothers me when in world rules don’t stay consistent. Like it’s weird for us, but should be standard in story!! Also, Preston says that marrying Alicent made the Targs more religious… huh? How? She herself is self righteous and judgmental, but she doesn’t cause the Targs to be more religious, and the incest continues on for decades. And again, it was her father who suggested Rhaenyra marry her brother!!!!!!! The whole point of people objecting to the incest is that it’s an excuse when they think an alliance will be too powerful.
@7Nebulae7
@7Nebulae7 Год назад
I think the whole incest thing is very fuzzy in the show. Young Alicent is clearly disturbed by the "weird Targaryen customs", when speaking about Daemon banging Rhaenyra. But then she goes and marries her own children to each other? Ofc it's possible that she just grew customed to the Targ incest thing over the years, but it still must clash pretty badly with her religion (Faith of the seven).
@honeywine3166
@honeywine3166 Год назад
If the Velaryons were back, GRRM would have pointed it out in TWOIAF or fire and blood. It would be a very distinguishing feature that separates them from the other westerosi houses
@mschell8022
@mschell8022 Год назад
George is pretty clear in a LOT of interviews that Westeros under Targaryen rule isn't supposed to be a depiction of Rome, its Medieval era Europe. Valyria is his closest Rome-insert..
@sblack4951
@sblack4951 Год назад
oh wow!!! can we have elio and linda on a podcast with you? or even a live? to ask various questions ??
@sfcSpidey
@sfcSpidey Год назад
I think making the strongs black would make more sense but I’ve liked the velaryons so far
Далее
Rusiya Prezidenti Vladimir Putin Bakıdadır
00:32
Просмотров 291 тыс.
КТО ЛЮБИТ ГРИБЫ?? #shorts
00:24
Просмотров 883 тыс.
Victarion Was Going to Die? Changes to Feast/Dance
42:33
The Enemy Within featuring showrunner Ryan Condal
45:01
House of the Dragon theories with Glidus
3:46:47
Просмотров 1,9 млн
I'll do it for you!
0:37
Просмотров 2,6 млн
ДЕЛАЛИ ПОД СЕБЯ
0:33
Просмотров 6 млн