Scientist completely disagrees with Sadhguru on meditation and brain activity 

Yeah fb respect..

looks like they changed it

i took Mad Scientist not as an insult. but i can agree there are better ways of describing the scientist

The scientist has zero real intelligence.

Mad scientist is taken in context of mad for science and not as insult.

Right. Existence and reality will never be known but it's got an infinite of things to learn. Isn't that cool? These debates and all human districts of learning (spiritual, physics, science) are just trying their best. All is doing a good progress and that's awesome and something to be grateful about!

Extra ordinary claim requires extra ordinary evidence.

@@romilmahant2971 the problem is that for a large majority of people cannot handle it , if someone's pointing the moon & you don't focus on the moon but you give the significance to the finger that pointing the moon , that's the actual problem

🤯🤯🤯

Lol Chavada😂😂😂

Except for the fact he denied that basic fundaments of how science even works

Dude. Shut up. There is no profund sense of happiness, meaning or joy without spirit.

⁠​⁠@@kennyfernandez2866 he was speaking of tolerance and respect and the first thing you type is shut up? Ironically you supposedly understand better nature of happiness and joy right?

@@diegoipl Exactly. And it has nothing to do with tolerance. You are proving my point.

I'd wager they do... it is systemically destroyed by maintaining absolute control over their learning paths. Then of course, there is a lot more nuance to this than this oversimplified conclusion.

@@KamaleshwarMorjal I don't think you are simplifying anything. THAT is the core reason. To pretend that people are not in charge of their lives is precisely the negation of spirit. What else could it be?

This is also what I asked myself. I asked myself all the time: "What's his name?" Thank you so much.

The scientist's name is not even mentioned in the discription of the video!! Why is that so?

its almost like the one who uploaded the video is biased

@@jluque731 A debate must be impartial and no sudden conclusions should be made. A debate is is helpful to the audience in understanding the opinion and mindset of both the parties. But only if it's a healthy debate and people don't judge them soon and be neutral at all times

@@gameplayer-ii1cv i tried my very best to understand why you just told me this

There is no way to prove that even SG has experienced. He may bs'ing for all we know.

😂😂😂

😝

but he is also not saying things in air, he is explaining it with logic and reasons, how the processes are and etc.@@VivekVerma-zh2wk

@@ParulWadkar Bro he has list of bs* scientific theories...but he is definitely a good at arguing with weak minded. Any one with good knowledge and powerful intellect can Roger him easily.

There's no actual writings from him, just claims.

@@starchild2121 There are 1000s of his statements in trance state all recorded by scientists available in Book forms available in Amazon !!All on RECORD authenticated !!!

​@@starchild2121 yeah except for 15000 stenographic registered readings

I learned dirt is dangerous.

Types of meditation. Most people think meditation only one type. But samadhi is good enough.

Getting to Dharana, Dhyana, and Samadhi with anything object is the goal

That ancient come later and was told ancient

Nahhh….theres no such thing as absolute truth in buddhism….becuz emptiness is the absence of an absolute….so emptiness itself is empty of any absolute phenomena…..and fundamental ideology of both religion completely different (except for advaite vedanta)….hindus belive in an absolute truth(supreme being) or krishna……Buddhists dont belive in absolute truth(or god)

what is quantum reality ,people r using fancy words only here

Dont forget sai bhava who could vomit statues of gods.

​@@wildhunter2323 You only know about fake guru's, u will find the kinda ppl u search for

Yes. They are dumb because of their arrogance, only a few humble intellectual are able to appreciate the depth of indian knowledge system.

@@Santhosh-qp1hqLol Fake gurus ? You dont know a thing about spirituality then

What States Sanatan saints achieved.? Please Explain

The real reason why is because "spirituality" is b.s. .

This is what Federico Faggin (the physicist who invented the microprocessor) is trying to tell fellow scientists; that science and spirituality are two sides of the same thing and consciousness does not emerge from the brain. It is what is the substrate of the brain!

I think to better frame what you are saying is: this is why science can't reach reality. It has burdened itself to a certain bandwith and it can't go beyond. Only the mind can go into the mind.

T.his guru uses Jiddu Krishnamurti's insights. Often he forgets what he read

@@kanthan668 LET US NOT FORGET YOU DO NOT EXIST LET ME MAKE THIS CLEAR YOU DON'T EXIST......AND NEVER WILL...EXIST. YOU FORGET YOU DO NOT MATTER ANYMORE THAN THE NEXT WHEN CREATION DECIDES YOUR GONE YOUR GONE. ME MEANS MORE EXHAUST IS NEEDED TO BRING YOU ALL BACK INWARD MARRY THE FIRE AND WATER ..........

Very arrogant conclusions of the scientist

​@@atomatman3104😂 gotta love when you yell at someone on the internet(ALL CAPS WARRIORS INCOMING)🎉😂

For someone like sad guru who killed his wife and got away with it... 😂😂😂😂

I can, just try to know about concegrated temples, concegrated lingas, how concentration works and the science behind all the structures and geometry behind temples.

And learn about ancient yogis and their knowledge in geometry(shapes) , mandtra (frequency), tandric knowledges

Interesting, and I first noticed the insolence and attempts at sarcasm of the so-called mad scientist.

I don't know about being persuasive, but he used it to know are people attentive

It’s nice to see 2 people that don’t agree on the topic talk without arguing or yelling!

Yes hello what do you mean kerry 😂😂😂😂

Persuasive?says more about your perception.To ask is to give you and you alone the responsibility how you determine the sense in what was said. Lecturing is of the nature to dominate a topic...but giving you the opportunity to react yourself with all your abilities is absolutely respectful and not persuasive. No one said that your answer must not be disagreement....no one said you have to agree. There are people who want to force you to agreement by asking you in an intimidating way...but that is not the case in this instance. Discernment,plz!

I think it was intentional. They didn't want them talking over each other and interrupting.

The difference is that the scientist, wants to assume he has explanations for things he doesn't know.

@@YogaToSamadhiI agree I think this scientist was a little bit closed minded from what I saw (didn’t watch the whole video). He seems a little too skeptical and not open minded enough to try and understand something he has not experienced. He is a very “by the book” person which is kind of frustrating to deal with. On the opposite end Sadhguru with all his mystic prowess is completely off the books intelligence. These two are like polar opposites but both are respectable in their own way

Sadguru is only used to having yes men around. Here he is in the presence of a no- nonsence intelect so he cant get away with his half truths and bullshit. He utters so much irrelevant things showing his lack of formal education.

Thats what happens when you reach samadhi. You enter into union with both

@@AaronAceElam i completely disagree , the state of samadhi is when nothing material feels useful to you , you are in harmony and union with yourself with ecstatic eternal joy

Probably wasn't working defective set

Steven Pinker

@@Rent-A-Mind Steven Pinker is a great mind, it's disrespectful not to introduce him properly in the caption or description to this video.

@@tokman7 I understand but we really shouldn’t pay any mind to it at all if that’s the case. This is a repost from a random individual who loves sadhguru. I know s/he loves him because a quick glance at their channel shows me that there is a provocative name for every person talking with him. If RU-vid videos had no titles or description I bet we would listen to their words more and criticize a stinky title less. They could easily be writing the most provocative title to start these very discussions, bringing more attention to these attention seekers; driving us away from the reality of the video/message and slowly turning this degeneracy into a social norm. In our very criticism and repulsion of this “trend” we sow the seed of future negativity that trap the gullible and feeds the troll. Soon enough kids will be doing it, and they’ll grow up with this need for provocative social media content to gain more likes, more follows, and more dopamine hits; and just like that, they die without ever having lived We are more likely to click on “mad scientist disagrees with sadhguru” than (the original title in sadhguru’s channel) “Is consciousness a miracle | Harvard’s Cognitive Scientist Prof. Steven Pinker & Sadhguru.” I happen to have read a few books by Steven years ago and he was a great stepping stone that lead to my realization that he and many others like him have no idea what’s going on, none of us have the faintest idea, the best guesses are lies, but more importantly, science is by no means a basis for extrapolating into human values and beliefs. Watching this I couldn’t remember his name for the life of me because I had already been bamboozled, I was expecting a dimwitted intellectual and for a moment lost my awareness and focus, but I appreciate him enough, and listened intently enough to find the full and original video in just a few seconds to come out of there allot stronger and settled in my original beliefs.

@@tokman7 I understand but we really shouldn’t pay any mind to it at all if that’s the case. We have become accustomed to expect language and thoughts to offer explanations which they cannot give. It’s the names and labels themselves that are driving us away from the reality of the video which slowly turns this degeneracy into a social norm. In our very criticism and repulsion of this “trend” we sow the seed of future negativity that traps the gullible masses and feeds the troll. We are more likely to click on “mad scientist disagrees with sadhguru” than (the original title in sadhguru’s channel) “Is consciousness a miracle | Harvard’s Cognitive Scientist Prof. Steven Pinker & Sadhguru.”

@@tokman7 He will make his way into the hearts and minds of those ready and willing to search for it- I couldn’t remember his name but I knew where to look to find it. You will either learn something new or walk away much more settled and stronger in your original beliefs if you chew on these things that you disagree with. And that’s just like.. my opinion, maan 😂 🙏

Then u have no observation..

Truee

Red keeps you grounded. Is the first chakra color.

It’s available everywhere. Shit if u scared to look for some due to law, you could go get some cow dung throw it in your backyard and boom next day u have the tool u need. 😂 But it’s drugs u will say and go back to reading ur book 😂

Lol... will you be convinced if I were doing with your mom..?

Eben Alexander and many others have changed from being materialists to spiritual after own experience. No one can believe anything only self experience will convince these people.

Even this meditation selling overhyped guru is fake😂😂

@@littleripples213 of course he is fake. Show me a non fake spiritual guy.

We all r ❤ world 🌎 🤲

Exactly

Steven Pinker

@@tokman7 thanks 😊

well you should start reading books then and not philosophy cause that is equally garbage .

Also blind money

Without mind how do you meditate?

@@RAJABABU-mc8rm Intellect becomes equanimous, i.e. Samadhi.

@@RAJABABU-mc8rm meditate means doing nothing with our mind or body, mind doesn't exist in reality it is our making

How do you go beyond the physical if you're using physical processes to get there i.e. the brain (which is a physical system)

J GOO DOOKIE

Clickbait 🤦🏻‍♂️❤️🌌🌠

And what has someone accomplished with not so constricted field . What have they grasped ? What have they grasped that they cant share it with the world but only boast about it . Ah peace love unity is that all .

​​@@truepeacefromviolence9581 bro somethings are important to be realised by the person on his own , realising it on your own not only helps you to make yourself better but also opens your mind by finding things step by step on your own this helps you to be able to understand it better in your own way.... people like satguru are trying to give you himts but even if he tried to explain it you ,you wouldn't understand as you have never experienced those things .... yoga is something that help you to go deep within you and experience things that you can't understand and helps you to find out who you are .......... I hope this helps 🙏

​@@truepeacefromviolence9581the truth.

This is ISHA cut😅

@@anythingmatters9764 lets not do a disservice. the audience should see the full video to gain context.

always bur sadguru is not a spiritual person he says he would not listen to god cause he knaws it better he says his "enlightment" came out of nothing... he`s a joke real spiritual leaders donn`t drive mercedes benz... the list goes on just look how his wife died, and ask yourself why he burned her before someone else came... live a good life but don`t follow a false leader you came to earth to make your own expirience otherwise your soul does not grow love and peace

Not everything is a battle.

Theres no sprituality without science

​@@knallbertkrach9263do u even know what spiritualty is? Don't say some bullshit without knowledge about it

​@@knallbertkrach9263 what you say doesn't sound Spiritual.

😂😂😂

When science cannot explain some things ,sprituality and religion have good market. Sprituality doesn't explained anything correctly.

What science cannot explain today it will explain it tomorrow. Spirituality and religion is a distraction from progress by poets and criminal prophets who have no experience in engineering and software which is the true spiritual realm. .

Learn science.Realize spirituality while learning

what nonsense

Yes! I have had too many experiences that prove that as true. Took a remote viewing class. Miracles happened. Lay-people drawing the target with amazing accuracy.

Mk ultra.

Well he looks mad though..

Yes like he stuck his finger in a light socket 😅

What you experience is the byproduct of brain activity which can be mesuared . If you feel angry , sad , calm , anxious these are because of chemical reaction which can be measured . We still have long way to go but its not immeasurable

Sad guru

Are you saying that a physicist who understands and ruminates on the nature of reality does not understand this snake oil salesman's pseudo-esoteric talks?

No he’s not. He’s a charlatan getting rich off spirituality. He is speaking to his audience of idiots.

yeah super narcissistic it seems

@@iminalert9289 No, he is just speaking from his perception of reality. You can see only the scientist was making faces cuz he is too identified with the limited data that he has.

@@rvind000 That is true . But can you tell me the difference between the perception of the reality of a delusional person and a normal one ? Or one who just wanna make fool of people for no reason except to have power which someone now has plenty .

Level of consciousness called Snake Oil

How do you know he is fake

“Yes but nor should we make up stuff for which we have no reason to believe it exists!” I think you should keep this in mind as well

@@Yash-972 even sadhguru doesn't exist for many people in the world that doesn't mean he is not alive

@@IAMrajasekhar I am pretty sure that's not what he meant when he said that. Yes what you said is true but the problem is when people start making things up for things they don't know if it exists. Like let's instead of saying we are not sure how this universe came into existence, they say oh well god created this universe, well that's stupid and that's what the scientist was trying to say, people here assume god exists to bring meaning to things they don't understand. There is no empirical way to measure something like God, and science doesn't bothers with the fact if it's exists or not because it works on empirical evidence not on stories or assumptions.

reality is materialistic right ? . lol

⁠@@wildhunter2323The fact that spirituality exists proves there is more to this reality than physical

@@DFlint who proved spiritually's existence

@@DFlint yeah spiritualilty exists up in yo butt.... thats why only you know it exists, right??.

@@AashishPandey-ls1rc And what makes you sure that reality is materilistic? The deepest cause for this is probably what your society taught you to be true and now you think "ItS AlL ThErE Is"