The thing I love about Lzzy is that when she sings this, you hear the anger of it, whereas with Amy is the sadness of the song. They're both talented vocalists and give the song two completely tones.
A much as I love Lzzy I didn’t enjoy it at first, now I completely get it. With Amy you hear the sadness. With Lzzy you hear the pure anger and a bit of sadness to Both brilliant though, they’ve actually performed together before.
Here’s how i see it. Amy is the the type that when she sings, she feels the pain of the song and it’s more of a heartbroken type of emotion. When Lzzy sings this, she’s the type that sings from the “I’m pissed off you hurt me” emotion. Both are great, i think i lean more on Lzzy just because i choose aggression over sadness.
@@Melymel2305 Matter of opinion - I also prefer the Amy Lee version of this, though Izzy did an interesting "different but good" take on it. Kinda like the original "Sounds of Silence" vs the Disturbed cover, or the original "Turn The Page" vs the Metallica cover.
Idk how much or anything it may have to do with it but Amy was in a very tumultuous relationship with him due to his heroin abuse and she struggled with him and his addiction but alas the addiction won. It was with a very heavy heart that Amy finally chose herself over her relationship with him and I'm sure that came through in her music and that song.
Just was sent this video because my wife and I are in the background (I am the Marine)! Lizzy chilled with us a bit and she was great! Seether is one of my favorite bands and it was awesome to meet them and watch them perform up close!
I think both Amy and Lzzy have two different and beautiful approaches to the song. Neither one is really better than the other but both are truly awesome.
I don't know Lzzy the person, rockstar Lzzy wouldn't be broken the same way Amy might. It's more like this to the music. " broken...Are You kidding.... you must be high, you must be high!"
Agree and if we're being honest when you go thru a particularly bad break up you go back and forth between mad and sad so I think it's appealing both ways.
Lizzy puts every ounce of her being into her vocals. This is currently the best version of the female part of the song I've ever heard live.. Amy Lee you rock and we love you too bits.
Damn girl..She literally healed him singing that passionate and powerful. You may not feel the understanding and energy between them over there, the feels, why he smiled at her. She song that powerful feeling his pain, knowing what this song means to him. She connected with his soul on stage and screamed her heart out for him. This is so cool.
Yes clean studio version OR at least someone needs to take this & redo the sound so not as much feedback & reverb.... terrible quality... im spoiled what can I say? My phone records better quality 😢
I would totally listen to this version over the original if it was on Apple Music. Lzzy destroyed this song. I like her anger more than Amy’s sadness in this song
Like Frank Sinatra, Elvis Presley and many others, she did it her way? Click here 2c4 yourself => ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Zf-fORxQvW0.html
@Ned Kelly why is she compared to Amy Lee..?..... Because Amy Lee is who originally sang this song. Of course people are going to compare this person with the original artist.
To the guy that’s a marine, I’m an Englishman and I’ve just discovered Halestorm. They’re amazing. And thank you for keeping people safe from harm. You deserve a great life. Good luck to you in all you do.
The studio version was just Seether, not guests. There WAS an "official" Seether + Amy Lee video version, from when the two were dating (and before the messy breakup).
To everyone saying Lzzy is using the wrong emotion for the song: this song is about being broken and in a relationship. Everyone has their own experience of what this means to them. Lzzy Hale has an entirely fiercer energy than the more somber Amy Lee, just listen to the difference between Evanescence and Halestorm. Lzzy rocked the shit out of this and it kicked ass.
Ryan Foster Honest question: is Lzzy "impressive" because she screams and does the whole raspy thing with her voice? Other than the screaming and rasping, I can't find anything remotely outstanding about her voice :/
It's a song by Seether. Rock song. It's about broken love but she makes it that much more of a rock song :) I take it kind of as her looking on the bright side of a bad situation.
How is she underrated? She was labeled as the top of female lead hard rock/ metal bands? She's great but not underrated one bit. I think overrated due to metal not getting the recognition it deserves
@@thomasharris1670 I think underrated in the sense of popularity. There's a lot of people out there who don't know her or Halestorm. At least not extensively. And she deserves all of it.
"See Lzzy, this duet originally worked very much because he sang like a hard rocker and Amy sang like an Angel, so there was balance." Lzzy: "Yeah, I'ma rock HARDER"
Wow a lot of you people are clueless - You cannot compare the way Amy and Lzzy sing - of course it will sound different. Saying Lzzy cant sing just makes you even more clueless. She has a lot more power in her voice - Amy leans more towards the ballad type of rock.
I love Lzzy Hale's attitude, voice, outfit she's a goddess man, and most important if music gives you chills, that's it that's what makes you feel alive 3:46 holy moly
her voice and amy’s voice are two of the only ones who make me FEEL SO MUCH. i can be brought to tears or shivers in like 30secs of either of them singing. it’s crazy
You can just tell how powerful someone's voice is by how far away they hold the mic from their face. Holy shit, lzzy has such an amazingly powerful voice.
This is my favourite version, because its got emotion, grit, rocking awesomeness and realness! The lyrics rule above all but holy s@@t the movement n emotion is unreal
Reminds me of how Amy sang Shatter Me with Lindsay Stirling on the second half of the Synthesis tour. Then you have Amy singing Break In with Halestorm and them covering Heavy by Linkin Park. I’m happy Amy and Lzzy are good friends 😭
ShadowofFlames InaforestbeneathEarth i don't really listen to Seether, i just know this song cuz of Amy Lee, and then i watched this video for Lzzy... why, should I? you recommend?
Amy is definitely the better choice for this song but Lzzy still kicks ass! She's so amazing live and she's so talented! Three times in the past year I've seen them live and I won't stop until they do!
Lizzy is true rocker ....u can hear her heart in every song...when she does covers she chews them up an makes them hers.,.she is a balls 2 da wall rockstar 100 percent...gives me hope for the future of rock...thankulizzy ...keep on keepn on!!!
Wow, I was looking up the Mongolian band The Hu because I recently wanted to hear some alternative music. I stumbled upon The Hu featuring Izzy Hale (RU-vid vid Song of Woman) and my GOD can this woman sing!!!!!!! A lot of heart and soul in her voice. What a rocker!
An amazing take on this song, no fcks given. I love the raw anger. Refreshing compared to the sorrowful original. This one brings about a sense of hope. Well done.
I saw them do this in Norfolk VA probably 15 yrs ago. It was Seether, Shinedown, Flyleaf, and Halestorm. Phenomenal show. Halestorm was working their merch table. Everyone was great and eager to chat. I've been hooked on Halestorm ever since.
even though a lot of people are saying lzzy sings it better and even though this is the same song, for me lzzy and amy should not be compared because each has its type and for me these are 2 differant songs.
I quite like Lzzy Hale doing this song. She seems to throw a lot of passion and pain into it. Seems right for the song. Amy Lee's version is the more sorrowful side of it so both are awesome.
This is definitely not the only time Lzzy has been on stage with Seether to perform this song. Obviously, Shaun and the gang didn't have a problem the way she sang it. I know opinions are like assholes, everyone's got one and they usually stink. So just spray some febreeze and deal with the "upstaging" or "wrong emotion" or whatever the hell other complaint you'd like to give. If Shaun (the songwriter) didn't have a problem with how his song was being interpreted by his female lead vocal counterpart, he'd send her ass kicking rocks.
