Seether - Broken ft. Amy Lee (REACTION!) 

Fun Fact: Shaun Morgan (lead singer) was dating Amy Lee. When they broke up, Amy Lee wrote “Call me When You’re Sober” about Shaun and it became one of Evanescence’s biggest hits.

Seether has a lot of really good songs. I think their cover of careless whisper is their best song but breakdown and rise above this are great too

i unapologetically LOVE THIS SONG. The orchestra... the build up... the delivery... sorry... Love it..

As a huge, long time Seether fan, I absolutely agree with so many here in the comments, PLEASE do not judge Seether based on this one song. They have so many songs that really showcase each members talents.Their live album is excellent as well.

It's not a copy, that's just his voice when he sings I love his voice

this song was overplayed to death, but it's a good one. the chemistry between the lead vocalist and amy is amazing (they were actually a couple for a while so that could've influenced it), and within the context it was at back then, it sure was a cut above most rock songs

They put out one of the best unplugged/acoustic albums I've ever heard in my life. That albums off limits for me because it just fucks me up. One Cold Night is full of amazing performances. Pick any of em if you are interested in getting in your feels fellas.

It's a bit premature to call anyone a copy after 1 song, let alone 1 verse. I think you will find that Seether has a much harder sound than Pearl Jam and those mentioned...what Seether is definitely, is Dark as fuck. Don't listen to Seether to cheer yourself up. honestly, if we gotta make comparisons, it would be a band like 3 days grace. The other thing... this song is absolutely moving...as moving as it gets. The two were a couple, so there is a back story. One thing I have always noticed about this song is its superb production quality. It simply sounds amazing... even on a phone as I listened. But getting back to Seether... they had great songs that I predict will begin to flood "classic rock" radio soon.... along with all the other great bands of that era. Listen to these songs, and you will see what I'm saying. Gasoline Fine again Remedy Driven under Rise above this Nobody praying for me The gift

Amy Lee is such a gem.

They do sound a lot like the other post-grunge acts, but they do it really well. Any other hit songs of theirs would be great for you to listen to if you liked this one. Remedy, Fake It, Country Song, Let You Down... Any of them.

They have some DARK and heavy songs. Better than Creed and Nickelback..closer to Nirvana or Staind. But they have their own thing.

"Words as Weapons" was definitely highly influenced by Tears for Fears "Mad World" , but its probably their best ballad type track.

Wow it's amazing how much each person can hear music differently> This to me doesn't sound anything like Creed or Nickleback lol

I haven’t actively listened to this song in more than a decade at this point, and listening again after so long…it’s an incredible song. As everyone else pointed out, this song was played out within a couple of months of its release. Definitely suffered from “Smells Like Teen Spirit” syndrome.

Please dont judge Seether from this song. They are heavy! Seether are one of my favourite bands. They still keep the Grunge alive.

Their voices together is special

If you knew the vocalist, you would know he isnt trying to copy anyone. Thats his voice. I think some comments saying "carbon copy" is unfair. Go listen to more music of theirs. IF you want to say carbon copy then all rap artists and hip hop should fall into the same thing. These guys write great melodies and hook and have some fantastic groove in a lot of their songs. Also if you want a hard hitting south african band, PLEASE GO CHECK OUT PESTROY!!!!!!!

Highly recommend you check out Driven Under by Seether... Boy, I was in a dark place when first heard that song, and it was on repeat for like 3 months 😂.

you guys should do more Seether, I think you will love them. This is the most mainstream song they have. Which was over played, but for a good reason.

Fine Again and their cover of Careless Whisper is a must listen, they have a lotta great songs👍🏽

Definitely explore more Seether. Good song. But they have plenty more to enjoy. Cheers.

Yeah, on this song I hear it. But, I'm not even a huge Seether fan and Shaun Morgan is NOT a copy cat. He is a very distinct voice if you listen to other stuff. He has a lower voice but without that slurring mumbly " Eddie Vedder" sound. And just FYI, the song is actually not about a girl he lost or a record company supplied hit. In an interview, Shaun said it is about his brother who committed suicide. He said he was talking to him one minute, walked in the other room and came back to find his brother had jumped out a window to his death. Again, I don't listen to Seether that often but they are kind of their own band. Yes, his voice is similar in this song, but they would have been the same if Creed and Pearl Jam never existed.

He doesnt sound like this on all their songs. Its just the feel of this one. Fake it. ROCKS!

Fine Again is a great one.

"Gasoline" is a solid representation of this band. Heavy riffs & vocals. Please give Clutch another go! "Electric worry" will put you in right direction. Early Clutch 😮 decades ahead of everything. Love ya guys!!

I would actually recommend their cover of Careless Whisper as their best. Remedy is good too.

Fine Again is my personal favorite of there’s. 🙌🏾

Most every band has to have a ballad. This is a great song but yall should check out FAKE IT by Seether. It rocks. Or remedy...or gasoline..you will change your mind's about being a clone.. I really took offense for yall calling em a Creed clone. I like creed but naaa.. come on man....lol

They have a lot of great songs and they're killer live. This song lost its appeal cause it was so overplayed lol

One of my favorite songs. Amy Lee's verse is the best part. ❤

Seether is one of my favorite bands, and I personally believe they are highly underrated. I don't consider them metal, but hard rock. They have a ton of bangers out there, and their acoustic versions are fire!

This is one of my favorite songs by them. I think that his voice is pretty harsh and unique. I think they have a lot of really good songs and their cover of Careless Whisper is phenomenal .

Careless Whisper, Fine Again, Remedy, The Gift, Driven Under!

I love Seether. Please give some of his other stuff a try. The lead is very talented.

Fine Again is definitely my fab Seether song, but overall their entire discography is really solid

Queen Amy back on the channel!! Loving it!

"Fine Again" and "Rise Above This" were two of their biggest hits. Not a bad band for the early 2000's.

Seethers entire catalog rocks, They are a very good band!

One Cold Night is one of the best acoustical concerts I’ve heard . They also have a lot of killer songs on the first couple of cd’s that are not on the radio”Burrito Really an underrated band

Keeping the streak alive of new bands and wrong songs lol

Suggested songs: Gasoline, Haang on, Six Gun Quota, No Jesus Christ, Weak.

The early 00's had a dozen bands that sounded exactly like this. I honestly can't tell these guys apart from Chevelle, Default, Fuel, Cold, Puddle of Mudd, etc.

This song has always been the ultimate guilty-pleasure. I'm not a huge fan of Seether or Amy Lee (though they both have mad talent; they're simply not my thing), but damn this song is good. I'm glad you guys enjoyed this one. Amy Lee has a whole plethora of songs for you guys to dive into, should you happen to revisit this sound. I'm not quite as sure about Seether, though they definitely are among the better of the 'butt-rock' bands. I'm a big fan of their song "Remedy," for example (Though it is repetitive). I still think Scar Symmetry is right up your guys' alley. "Holographic Universe" has everything you guys would like. Hell, just melo-death, in general, is something you guys outta check out.

Seether are a really dope band. Their first 2 albums, “Diaclaimer” and “Karma and Effect” are phenomenal

Can't believe this is the first song suggested from this band. 👀

Nickelback is underrated....out of every 10 critics of Nickelback, 9 had their cd's and 8 had concert tix. Amy Lee could sing the phone book with her amazing voice

I still love Seether's Words as Weapons...

Seether has SO many great songs … Gasoline, Rise Above This, Fur Cue, Country Song…. The list goes on and on and on ! Plz react to more Seether 🤘🏼🤘🏼

The song Needles off of this same album is a banger, y'all would definitely enjoy it

FYI the Seether singer and Amy Lee dated. Apparently they split because of his alcohol problem and she wrote the song "Call Me When You're Sober" about him

I was teaching private music lessons back when this song was a hit and it actually inspired some of my electric guitar students to buy an acoustic!

354 million cant be wrong. Incredible song.

Seether goes hard. You absolutely need to give them another reaction (Dangerous, Remedy, Bruised and Bloodied)

He's got a lot different sounding songs. He's a great singer

Seether is South African ? Holy sht. Never knew that. Saw them in concert opening for audioslave. Awesome friggin band.

The greatest Seether song ever is "No Jesus Christ" IMHO. "The Gift" live acoustic is amazing too. Their cover of "Careless Whisper" is one of the best covers ever.

Seether’s first album was awesome.

Lead singer of Seether and Amy Lee dated for a bit. Then they did songs about each other after the break up, I believe Seether's was "Fake It" and Evanescence's was "Call Me When You're Sober"

I love this band. Everything song is so good.

I think y'all need to understand the difference between copying and being influenced by. This guy has been influenced by, but is not copying a particular style of singing. An example of copying would be Puddle of Mud, did their best to duplicate Eddie Vedder's style of singing. Many singers did, which is where this sound originated from not Scott Stapp from Creed who was also influenced by Vedder.

This is one of those that radio played to death and turned a lot of people off, but it's a legit great song and Amy Lee is the star on anything she's on.

BRO HOW I MISS THIS REACTION i love seether NOTHING BUT BANGERS 🔥🔥🔥🔥

You will never understand what this song meant to people between the ages of 25-35

Thrilled to see you guys do Seether. A top 5 favorite band of mine.

Carless Whisperer by Seether is a great cover! Probably the best I've heard.

Nobody is a bigger Pearl Jam fan than me, but I don't think Shaun Morgan is a copy of Eddie. Seether has their own unique sound that you'll hear on some of their harder rock songs.

Suggestions for Seether; 'Disseased', 'Pig', 'Breakdown', 'No Jesus Christ', 'Fur Cue', 'Hang On', 'Sold Me' are all great choices and if you want something to make comparisons with, Shawn Morgan's voice is great for covers. Check out there acoustic cover of 'Change' by the deftones. INCREDIBLE

I love the music, singing, and lyrics of this song. Especially, when going through a heartbreak 💔

I think it's hard to judge a particular band or vocalist based on one song. Seether arrived at the success they got to because over time, they developed a really unique style that was "just" close enough to grunge to catch a lot of the 90s grunge/alternative fans, but they also dipped their toes into the Nu-Metal genre when it was popping off. And the more songs you hear of theirs, Shaun Welgemoed's vocal style becomes extremely recognizable even among other bands that sound like Seether. Karma and Effect was a fantastic album. "The Gift" and "Remedy" are classics.

Please give "Driven Under" by Seether a listen. Really good song!!

SEETHER IS AN AWESOME BAND.. THEY CHECK OFF ALOT OF THINGS YOU GUYS LIKE IN A BAND. LOTS OF SONGS YOU'LL ENJOY.. MY FAVORITES WOULD HAVE TO BE "The Gift" "Rise above this" "Tonight" "Driven Under" "Breakdown" "Fine Again" DEFINITLY CHECK THEM OUT..

Seether is an amazing band he's not trying to copy anyone your voice is your voice this particular song is on the slower side they have a lot of heavier stuff you should check out haters just like to talk s*** good music is good music

Amy Lee and the singer from Seether were a couple for a while. Seether has some great rocking songs. Please dive into them more.

If y'all want a complete 180 of this band you guys should listen to Because of Me or Pig

Amy Lee and Sean Morgan (Seethers singer) were in a relationship at this time. They broke up because of his alcoholism and she wrote Call Me When You're Sober about him, which is also an amazing song. They both are great. I like several songs from Seether, they had a lot of radio play over the 2000s and love all of Evanescence and Amy since they came out. Both bands are still going strong.

If Seether copied anyone it would be Nirvana. Early Seether (Saron Gas was their original band name) is very reminiscent of Kurt Cobain vocally. But this song is their big commercial hit. A lot of people in the comments are recommending their cover of Careless Whisper but it's just as overplayed as Broken. For some good Seether songs I'd recommend No Jesus Christ, 69 Tea, Fade Away, Eyes of the Devil, Needles, Driven Under... But if you go with their hits I would say Gasoline, Fake It, Remedy, Fine Again, Nobody Praying For Me would all be alright.

Seether rise above this, fine again are good songs to react to

I know everyone is spamming songs they want you to listen to, but the One Cold Night acoustic version of "Truth" is one of the best live performances I've ever heard.

" I can't tell if this is Creed or my man Eddie Vedder LOL !😂😂😂😂

I always remember them for their awesome metal Careless Whisper cover.

Seether is a phenomenal band. You won't hear bad talk about them like Creed or Nickelback. You're listening to their soft song recorded for a soundtrack. Gasoline, love her, Careless Whisper and Driven under are outstanding.

The complaint about sounding alike cracks me up as I sure did include them on my Men Who Sound Alike station on Pandora proudly. It goes from Pearl Jam to Lifehouse to Seether to Daughtry and on and on. The lead singers of all these groups are reminiscent of each other so it's hilarious to hear them back to back but yes, I still hear the unique features of their voices song to song

Seether is one of the better rock bands working today.... and the strings at the end of the song are epic

This song has definitely been playlist since jr high, mainly because of Amy Lee (grew up in Arkansas) but still a classic.

You guys need to do Halestorm! Lizzy Hale has a phenomenal voice!!! I am the fire is a great one to start with

Any of these by Seether: Breakdown, Rise Above This, Beg, Dead and Done, See You At the Bottom, Fine Again, or Gasoline

Great reaction as always. I am always blinded by my nostalgia/music I'm use to, you guys really hit the nail on the head every time. So true how a lot of bands sang like that.

You need to listen to more seether if you think this is a Copy. 🤘🤘 Rise above this, Save Today, Nobody Praying for Me are great selections.

Shaun (singer) and Amy Lee were knocking boots for a bit, it was only a matter of time before they sang a song together

It was Eddie Veder of Pearl Jam who started the sound or at the very least popularized it. Was very popular grunge sound in the early 90’s then got adopted and slightly altered with the nickelbacks, creeds, etc in the late 90’s early 00’s alt rock

Finally Seether!!! Been waiting a long time for this reaction

Did anyone mention the drama? After Shaun and Amy broke up, Shaun released “Fake it” as a dig on Amy and then Amy released “Call me when you’re sober”

I personally think seether has a lot of really good songs. I don't think they particularly copy anyone. I think they have a similar sound. I could say the same thing about 75% of all famous musicians. Seether , the gift is one of my favorite songs.

Amy Lee can do no wrong in my ears... Everessence is a force to be reckoned with (I'm a hardcore 66 year old boom bap brother)

Remedy is great, one of my favorites of theirs

Just do a Seether month. So many amazing songs.

This is my first video I've seen of your guys and shout out to MrLBoyd, Brad and Lex and CartierFamily for leading teh way and allowing you guys to copy, I mean follow! LOL

The duet aspect is what saves it for me.

Seether sound nothing like nickelback normally but this ballad is awesome. You should try Rise Above This. Amazing

Seether does an acoustic cover of Change in the House of Flies by Deftones, it's really amazing. The singer is great