Semhal Meles Zenawi: Reversal of the Ethiopian nation-state building process| Tigray crisis 

Like her father 😊

​@@hailewolde1816😂😅😂😅😂😅

what did she say ? Tplf's great tradition was knowledge production ? did she say knowledge production? what knowledge ? this destructive ethnic-politics or ethnic-federalism is one of their great knowledge ? is this destructive primordial politics one of their great knowledge ? Bro, this is not great knowledge ...this is rather great stupidity which puts Ethiopia and its people into this awful situation,mess and destruction!!! After all these mess and destruction, Tplfists never learn - very sad

ልብስዋን Articulate ብታረው አይሻልም ጡዚት😅

​@@wrapupthestorybetter if you can read more about what a knowledge production/management means?

what did she say ? Tplf's great tradition was knowledge production ? did she say knowledge production? what knowledge ? this destructive ethnic-politics or ethnic-federalism is one of their great knowledge ? is this destructive primordial politics one of their great knowledge ? Bro, this is not great knowledge ...this is rather great stupidity which puts Ethiopia and its people into this awful situation,mess and destruction!!! After all these mess and destruction, Tplfists never learn - very sad

​@@wrapupthestoryYou are stupid bro.

​@wrapupthestory ppl in Ethio will learn & work by their own language, have right to self administration, teach & show the culture & tradition.... That's irreversible never & that's center of our ancestors struggle cry, curse, wage war... Unitary system with one language , religious superiority & imperialism will never comeback thanks to Tplf

@@Joker-sp1ci ...what was z flag of z former governments ? Is it ልሙጥ as you call it or something else ?

😂😂😂 who is the psychoanalyst?

ahahahaaa.... you must b kidding ! critical thinker , what ??? what did she say ? Tplf's great tradition was knowledge production ? did she say knowledge production? what knowledge ? this destructive ethnic-politics or ethnic-federalism is one of their great knowledge ? is this destructive primordial politics one of their great knowledge ? Bro, this is not great knowledge ...this is rather great stupidity which puts Ethiopia and its people into this awful situation,mess and destruction!!! After all these mess and destruction, Tplfists never learn - very sad

Well said 😊

Agree 👍

You believe tigray as a country

@@genetbrhane7433 It’s up to the people of Tigray to decide. And the decision should be respected by all Ethiopians.

As a Tigrayan, the fact that our Ethiopian neighbours currently woke up and praise former PM Meles Zenawi shows the arrival of Jesus Christ. Haleluya Ameen.

what brilliant mind you are talking about ? what did she say ? Tplf's great tradition was knowledge production ? did she say knowledge production? what knowledge ? this destructive ethnic-politics or ethnic-federalism is one of their great knowledge ? is this destructive primordial politics one of their great knowledge ? Bro, this is not great knowledge ...this is rather great stupidity which puts Ethiopia and its people into this awful situation,mess and destruction!!! After all these mess and destruction, Tplfists never learn - very sad

What she said about Tplf is wright yes that is ture

🦵🦵🦵🧑‍🦽☠️⚰️💊⚰️☠️☠️

hero ?😂😂😂

You couldn't even keep the word-verb correlation and fathom her articulation to begin with, let alone to exacerbate a short come of this interview.

You don’t even know the meaning of the word~exacerbate,if you do you wouldn’t have used it the way you used it 🤷🏾‍♂️Exacerbate is not synonyms to criticize !

what did she say ? Tplf's great tradition was knowledge production ? did she say knowledge production? what knowledge ? this destructive ethnic-politics or ethnic-federalism is one of their great knowledge ? is this destructive primordial politics one of their great knowledge ? Bro, this is not great knowledge ...this is rather great stupidity which puts Ethiopia and its people into this awful situation,mess and destruction!!! After all these mess and destruction, Tplfists never learn - very sad

You miss another disaster situation in Tigray ! like her father done.

@@wrapupthestory she was talking about historiography within the context of the question about Tigrayan literature. Maybe actually try to listen and understand the interview before you start spewing nonsense?

​@@wrapupthestoryEthnic Federalism is stupidity?ask the ethnic people to actually say that. And by the way don't forget the economic knowledge production and practical successful experience of tplf

​@@TIGTIG-zthe Economic Groth which TPLF Made i can acknowledged IT , but Ethnic federalism i can repeat yes IT IS stupidity and If you can Not addmited IT as Tigrians what consequence IT brought , i doubt that you have mind 🤔 what Proof do you want to See morethan the mess what IS going Right now in Ethiopia, especially for Tigrians since 2020 ....

Just think about ur Country Eritrea 🇪🇷 they have more issues jeberti rashaida saho akele hamasen seraye etc lambadusa Sinai desert 😊 why don't u concern about this why paying waste time energy about something it's not the business of u Tigrai Ethiopia business politics belongs to the people of Tigrai not Kenya or Eritrea 😊

@@serenityshalom7387 her we go poison to spread and twisting to something else 😂

ERENA NIKDMIT MIS NAI TILYAN MESHENIT 😊😊BABENE ALORA KALAS SAKIT MARA FNISTRA KAMICHA ENDIAYAMO

@@realgamenotfree regardless Tigrai oromo amhara etc independent nation isn't ur business just think about Erena 😚

And why are you not talking about your Tigrai. Killing, robbing, rape, HiV, prostitution, drugs, kidnaping etc. And the couse of all the problems of Eritrea was was your people. But don't about Eritrea though your people are testing thier own medicine. One thing Eritrea need to do at this time is to build a wall so your ppl will not come to Eritrea.​@@serenityshalom7387

What was melese thought about Ethiopia? Which of his ideas you think wrong?

የትኛውንየመለስ አስተሳሰብ? ስለምን የሚያስበውን? የምትቃወመው ከምን የተነሳ ነው? ምክንያታዊ ሆነህ ነው?ወይስ ስሜታዊ? የትረጋገጠ በማስረጃ የተደገፈ (evidence-based argument) ኖሮህ ነው? የተማርክው: (ወይም: የተካንከው) እውቀትህ ምንድነው?? ማለቴ የመለስን አስተሳሰብ ለመቃወም ከህግ እውቀት ነው? ከኤኮኖሚክስ እውቀት ነው??...

@ 29:50 is all you need to hear

@@temesgenketi Alright, let's start by saying may he rest in peace. He was a strong leader, no doubt about it, but his vision for Ethiopia was seriously flawed. It's cost the country a huge price, and it's especially hurt the Tigrayan people. The whole idea of national unity his guys were talking about didn't really bring people together. It was more like stacking explosives that eventually blew up in everyone's face. Even for Tigray, his home region, he made some really bad calls. He was right there when they were writing the constitution, and he ended up giving Tigray less power because it was a minority vote. Anyone who knows Tigray's history would never do that. The crazy thing is, after he messed that up, he made sure the cabinet had equal voting power to hold his position, but Tigray still didn't get the attention it needed. His whole time in power, the stories they were spreading weren't good for Tigray in the long run. I mean, Tigray is mostly Orthodox Christian, right? They have a rich history of kings and their culture is really similar to Eritrea and Amhara. But his government went against all that. We could talk for hours about how he messed up the country in every way: social, political, economic, you name it.

@@rising1786 Alright, let's start by saying may he rest in peace. He was a strong leader, no doubt about it, but his vision for Ethiopia was seriously flawed. It's cost the country a huge price, and it's especially hurt the Tigrayan people. The whole idea of national unity his guys were talking about didn't really bring people together. It was more like stacking explosives that eventually blew up in everyone's face. Even for Tigray, his home region, he made some really bad calls. He was right there when they were writing the constitution, and he ended up giving Tigray less power because it was a minority vote. Anyone who knows Tigray's history would never do that. The crazy thing is, after he messed that up, he made sure the cabinet had equal voting power to hold his position, but Tigray still didn't get the attention it needed. His whole time in power, the stories they were spreading weren't good for Tigray in the long run. I mean, Tigray is mostly Orthodox Christian, right? They have a rich history of kings and their culture is really similar to Eritrea and Amhara. But his government went against all that. We could talk for hours about how he messed up the country in every way: social, political, economic, you name it.

She lacks discipline, using her dad influence , she could have been IMF director.

You kidding me, no Ethiopia

You said she is a star? TIGRIE KORKORO

No more in Ethiopian politics she can stay in her kilil.

@@Samteshome88worry about dr abiy

@@Samteshome88why should Ethiopian people not share thoughts and ideas? Good ideas don’t only come from one place.

Meles a dictator for 20 years from TPLF. he divided ethiopia into ethnic regions and its the respondable for what happens today in ethiopia. Ethiopians before abiy had ethnic groups on their identity card thats what meles did for dividing ethiopia. Ethiopians deserve what you have because you Will never speek up on your dictators. its a shame to call a Hero meles zenawi. He Is also the reason why ethiopia dont have access to the Sea and all deaths in badme's useless war against eritrea.

extraordinary person-Meles Zenawi ????? hahahahaaaaa.... His extraordinary stupidity puts Ethiopia ,and its people including its own community in chaos , mess, destruction ... what did she say ? Tplf's great tradition was knowledge production ? did she say knowledge production? what knowledge ? this destructive ethnic-politics or ethnic-federalism is one of their great knowledge ? is this destructive primordial politics one of their great knowledge ? Bro, this is not great knowledge ...this is rather great stupidity which puts Ethiopia and its people into this awful situation,mess and destruction!!! After all these mess and destruction, Tplfists never learn - very sad

I think the problem starts when ethnic federalism is proposed as a solution for the chronic problem of class difference and social injustice, a problem which the Ethiopian people are still suffering from. Ethnic based oppression was only coined in the 60's to better serve Socialist Ideologies in a country like Ethiopian which did not have enough working class (wezader) but needed a term that could mobilize the peasants giving them a credible cause into joining the revolution. The feudal rule oppressed the society in bases of class and not ethnic identity. This can be proven in where the Amhara rule oppressed its own pesants during their hegemony. The farmer suffered less from his national identity than systemic social and economic injustices. Now modern day elits are running around solving fake crisises. When TPLF/ EPRDF adopted this ideology in their modern day state building they opened hell's gate to ethnocentrism and twisted nationalism. Now when ever an "elite" fails to address its people's social and economic demands they all hide back in their "national identity crisis" bs. I stand with Meles in most of his economic reform policies and anti neoliberalism advocacies but federalism where in the name of ethnic autonomy regional states are given the right to land and cessation? Who asked for this? And the genius Abiy Ahmed did a remarkable job in turning the country around into a complete circus. TBH the Tigrayan people are better off without the leadership that got them in this clusterf*ck in the first place.

@@samuelkebede9536 I think the problem is not ethnic based regional autonomy politics. The real problem is when this ethnic federalism exists only on paper but in practice there is total hegemony of other ethnic groups by whoever is on the top. We have seen this with Meles and Ahmed Abey has not stray away from this practice. I don’t see elites in Ethiopia- the leaders don’t deserve to be dignified with this name. When you kill innocent civilians and bring the whole country to its knees economically, socially and politically examples Tigray, Oramia, Amhara region - the only description for this kind of leadership is thuggery and pillagers. Elites in other countries, look after their interests which lie in engaging in constructive politics not inhalation of its people like we have witnessed in Ethiopia. For the Somali region we have always lived in what you call hells-gate. We have been always been at the mercy of the military. They turned the whole region into barren land. During the Tigray-led government, even the president of the region was symbolic figure and the general was fully in charge. This was under pretext of security. Soldiers can shoot you without fear of any repercussions. There was no room for any development. Every Ethiopian leader will say ‘I am treating Somalis better than my precedent’. - this is the yardstick they use to rule us. This is wrong because the whole region’s population fate SHOULD NOT REST ON THE GOODWILL of a leader. Somalis are not employed in the Federal government departments. The few who are employed are not treated with that well. They are viewed as foreigners. Currently you will find all Ethiopian ethnic groups working in or doing business in the Somali region without any discrimination or hostility. Can Somalis work and do business in other regions? No they can’t except in Addis Ababa.

@asadabdulahi1257 Interesting outlook from Somalia's perspective. Interested in looking more into reason behind Somali's current state. What was the cause of the Jigjiga's 2018 unrest. What is the reason behind continuous border disputes with Oromia region. Why did Somalia fail short in securing power to influence the central government and maintain regional autonomy. Is it corrupt officials oppresing their own people, or is it ethnic based oppression coming from the federal part. If it's the latter, then why didn't the oppression stop when there was a change in regime? If the oppression continues, best believe it towards all regions in Ethiopia like Gambela, Benishangul, Afar, etc. and not just one specific group being targeted because of it's ethnic identity. Are there any political parties working towards resisting this oppression within or abroad? Are there any political parties with a clear manifesto? Just curious. These are just my opinions. Willing to be corrected.

@@samuelkebede9536 unfortunately it’s our experience and history with Ethiopia. The wars that have been raging on in Tigray, Amhara and Oramia regions for the last five years have been our experience under all the Ethiopian regimes. It only for the last five years that we did not see an active war in our region. I’m not saying things have been great in the rest of Ethiopia under previous governments but our case was one much horrendous and it was based on ethnic cleansing and under strict military rule. Our nominal regional leaders were imposed and selected from Addis Ababa. In every city was surrounded by military barracks. Soldiers killed with impunity and without fear of any repercussions.

At a personal level - my grandmother had eight boys - five of them were killed by Ethiopian soldiers. No one was put in jail. None of my uncles were involved in any activities against the government. My family would not be an exception. We are the norm. There is no family in the Somali region who have not lost family members to the Ethiopian military.

Ayee Hegdef/PP

@ 29:50 is all you need to hear

​@@ninaabay2140 😅😅😅 kondaf agame cenawi

@@eriblood803Seraki Manka Disti, Eritreans failed miserably and will continue to fail..

Finally a smart comment❤🇪🇹

' A replica ' 🤣🤣🤣

“Convince”?? Nobody should be convinced to serve, they should want to serve!

Ke Gonder😂

@@nonenone3420 አዎ #ከጎንደር።

ቂጥ አጣቢ typical አማራ

@@Toronto6 ሀቅ የማይገባህ በጭፍን ጥላቻ ያለህ መሰለኝ

@@Python20 ቲሽ ወሬ