SEUS PTGI HRR 2.1 vs 3.0 | Which Shader is Better?

Подписаться 83 тыс.

Просмотров 97 тыс.

50% 1

In this video I'll be comparing PTGI HRR 2.1 vs HRR 3.0 with Patrix 64x as a texture pack. Each shader has their own pros and cons, HRR 2.1 has better performance while 3.0 has better overall lighting, shadows, and other miscellaneous improvements. Which one do you prefer?
Join my Discord! ▶ / discord
Full playlist of all my Shaders VS Vanilla videos: • Shaders VS Vanilla Min...
Download links:
Minecraft - minecraft.net/...
Optifine - optifine.net/d...
SEUS PTGI - www.sonicether...
Patrix - / posts
Installation tutorial: • How to Install Stratum...
Music:
sadtoi, Akulta - Billie & Zanaho chll.to/c0f3e955
Vhsceral - Gimetime chll.to/c1d5b5db
Mama Aiuto - Beach Safari chll.to/b21b0009
My Desktop Specs:
- Ryzen 7 3700X + wraith rgb ▶ [amzn.to/37ENO01]
- RTX 3080 ▶ [amzn.to/3t9sQ2N]
- 32GB RAM ▶ [amzn.to/2N6vDaj]
- 1TB NVMe M.2 SSD for OS/Programs ▶ [amzn.to/3bDjbfd)
- 2x 1TB 870 EVO for everything else ▶ [amzn.to/30G6gCF]
- EVGA 650 GM ▶ [amzn.to/37Pi8W5]
- NR200P White ▶ [amzn.to/3rGf6wb]
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
#minecraft #raytracing #shaders

Опубликовано:

21 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 130

@Marshcar 2 года назад

Hi everyone! So I mainly use PTGI HRR 2.1 for my videos because of the better performance it provides over HRR 3.0, but I wanted to take a closer look at how the two shaders compare regardless of performance. I kept the settings the same on both the shaders to make this as fair of a comparison as possible although with some tweaking I'm sure you could get them to look more similar to each other especially in regards to exposure. Which one do you like more?

@Gigakid7 2 года назад

i like 3.0 more than the 2.1

@chatei_ 2 года назад

3.0 is better looking it looks like there's an ambient light but the 2.1 is more performant

@MrError3000YT Год назад

What texture pack do you use?

@minetrans_yt7912 2 года назад

i like 2.1 cuz of its performance and exposure, but, 3.0 has a more accurate ilumination and reflects, it also has a much larger shadow and ligth distance, which makes performance go down, but both look awesome

@Sir.Ralph260s 2 года назад

0:34 It looks like the real sea cinematic and that feature was awesome Keep It Up We'll Support You!

@Marshcar 2 года назад

Thank you :) I'll keep it up!

@Jualzew Год назад

This as if from other game

@Seraphim177 2 года назад

luckily you can adjust the shader in the settings. You can adjust the light intensity of the blocks, exposure, contrast, saturation, etc.

@Marshcar 2 года назад

This is true, I kept the same settings on both the shaders for a fair comparison but with some adjustments you could get them to look more like one another.

@cozy9794 2 года назад

0:24 3.0 shows a lot more contrast between the light and dark. Pretty cool shot 📸

@aivanosgg2269 Год назад

ray tracing has improved a lot since 2.1, the only things that i didn't like are the colder color grading and that little bit lower gamma in the exposure, but it's luckily customizable

@mintyemerald3935 2 года назад

Interesting I notices on the 3.0 higher highs and lower lows so I would use 2.1 for playability and 3.0 for show

@elitemaxtheman2217 2 года назад

I notice that the stairs will glow while the other seus shader doesn’t have that, strange

@blahajmybeloved 2 года назад

always wanted to play with shaders but never been able to since my bad pc, finally upgraded to a good cpu and 3070 cant wait to try out ptgi. looks amazing :D

@Marshcar Год назад

Nice! nothing like getting a new GPU

@Arig16 2 года назад

Me personally I like Sues Ptgi Hrr 3.0 better because of the crystal clear water and how colourful some rextures look with it. But thats just my opinion.

@jeetee1204 2 года назад

Nice video, the transition betwen the 2 shader is nice

@bickroksgamingtrunk9614 2 года назад

2.1 is great for playing while 3.0 is more realistic

@EnderVerseMC 2 года назад

Fantastic video as usual! May I ask how did you manage to have your hand visible on replay mod clips?

@Marshcar 2 года назад

Thank you! For replay mod I just fly the camera up to my player and click on it, then in the recording my hand is there, Im actually not sure how to disable it anymore haha

@WorseThanZoink 2 года назад

When will I have a better pc to have this, Sonic ether is taking Minecraft to be more realistic than REAL LIFE

@Ezdine_G8261 2 года назад

these shaders are unbelievably easy to run

@WorseThanZoink 2 года назад

@@Ezdine_G8261 my last pc overheated, I was scared so I put it outside, a minute later it caught on fire and exploded. I'm telling the truth. ( I used the E9 version) and my mom got me a Gtx 1650 ( idk the old one but it's really bad ) and I'm never gonna play Minecraft with shaders again

@wcrcqdc2dvcr3c2rxr 2 года назад

This 3.0 version seems like a color correction and re-lighting patch

@SummitMC23 2 года назад

Love the videos Marsh 🌊

@Marshcar 2 года назад

Thanks :)

@Alex-gv9os 2 года назад

3.0 is insane. I love it

@MigsPen 2 года назад

Which is better optimized? Btw i really love the cinematics🔥🔥

@Marshcar 2 года назад

Thank you! Also by far 2.1 is better optimized

@Onaterdem 2 года назад

3.0 is too saturated for my taste. 2.1 feels just right, is very visible, etc.

@r1ftzy 2 года назад

Hrr 3 looks like the old ptgi e5 with more darker and realistic lighting

@JakubVymetal 2 года назад

interesting, would prefer hrr2 for overworld, but for underground hrr3 is so much cleaner

@lennat24 10 месяцев назад

Same for me.

@justineisele2387 Год назад

Would it be possible to see the settings you are using for both shader packs? Or at least for HRR3

@rudrasingh6354 2 года назад

3.0 is more realistic but 2.1 looks like it'll be usable for playing because of better visibility. Also better because you said 2.1 has more performance

@bilgisayarbilgisi183 2 года назад

Yes

@mdaffanislam 8 месяцев назад

Without shaders or mods Minecraft is perfecto 👌

@cripmusicongfrfr Год назад

Maaan, why can my computer run videos of it, but if I were to try an run the game, it'd catch on fire.

@G7ue 2 года назад

I don't like 3.0 personally. The torches are not bright enough, even when I max out the brightness in the shader settings. And sunlight feels more sterile. Not as warm and coasy as 2.1. I much prefer the look and brightness of 2.1, Which really sucks, because 2.1 doesn't work with the newer blocks and light sources. Both are practically unusable in caves for me because of that.

@samuelrodriguez6684 Год назад

Sonic Ether really took 2.1 and said "let's add HDR"

@Ezdine_G8261 2 года назад

I don't know really. from what I heard 3.0 is pretty damn problematic

@aural123 2 года назад

I think 2.1 is better look,the 3.0 colour is too realistic

@scoutgaming28 Год назад

my guy?

@omarabdelrahmanyassin8034 6 месяцев назад

🤓☝️

@LsdRaccoon 6 месяцев назад

Are you complaining that something looks too good?

@PutSumDirtInYaEye Год назад

I like 2.1 more because of underwater world is more bright

@neko-san5965 2 года назад

But what's that resource pack?

@match8bull303 Год назад

I cant wait to get enough money to afford seus and that physics mod to make ultimate better graphics than cyberpunk minecraft

@Premansh_tak 2 года назад

my specs is good like i7 9th gen 1050ti GTX it will run??

@ellie-pi7nl 2 года назад

no lol

@Never_Gio 2 года назад

I feel like 3.0 is more for modern builds and cinematic showcases.

@mmoairdrop3165 10 месяцев назад

Are you having trouble seeing rain or snow drops when it rains or snows?

@ob3ythee.t.128 Год назад

Bro how do you get your game to run so smoothly on HRR 3.0, I have basically the same specs as you , I'm trying to use sodium to get my frames up and trying to adjust settings but alas I have not figured it out :(

@iconicstar7429 9 месяцев назад

This is an obvious and direct answer , everyone knows is the hrr 3.0

@SamyasaSwi 2 года назад

I think this is a good change, seus did always seem too green to me

@lucariothehorrorguy5641 Год назад

Seus V11 is also less green

@shadeddystopia4667 8 месяцев назад

The issue i have is theres alot of grittiness to it and textures/camera movements end up in this weird puffyness to it and idk how to fix

@robloxer23866 Год назад

after that the pc will BRRRRTTT

@Elijah1573 Год назад

I just wish HRR 3 Was updated to support AMD better I recently got a 6900XT and was so excited to try PTGI out only to find its extremely broken for AMD

@StarWarsNegsVerses Год назад

I can get both to run on my 6700xt oc edition, but there's a water "fuzzy" bug for me. Rather run kappa for amd.

@wasichupaaa 2 года назад

In my opinion hrr 3.0 is much softer / realistic

@HelixOrion Год назад

In darker places or where there is no strong light, 3.0 wins...

@Bran_Elite 2 года назад

Epico hermano

@doragonsureia7288 Год назад

unfortunately i have a "water lighting" bug in version 3.0 The block surfaces show a "underwater wave lighting" near the water, even 5 blocks above the water. I use minecraft 1.19.2, SEUS PTGI HRR 3.0

@cozymc3309 Год назад

It might just be the j compatibility with the version

@Yosu2 5 дней назад

Whats the resource pack your using?

@gormauslander 3 месяца назад

It looks...so much worse. Like they wanted to balance it to look more like modern raster pre-baked video game shaders, rather than look like an attempt to emulate real light behavior. What's the point of the RTX then?

@Seacat17 Год назад

It's so cool in videos until you start playing. Try to place a light in darkness and then break it. You'll be SHOCKED how bad it is. This is what we must compare.

@notarandom7 2 года назад

It's actually path tracing (which is a little more advanced than ray tracing but mostly the same)

@-_wanderer 2 года назад

Pathtracing is a type of raytracing

@notarandom7 2 года назад

@@-_wanderer I know. Pathtracing is a shortcut for Raytracing

@lukepitt5158 2 года назад

I would use HRR 3 but it makes stairs glow at night and weird flashing patterns on the floor at sunset

@BenSheriff Год назад

Yeah yeah same problem. Hrr 2.1 better...

@flaikyy 2 года назад

I don't know how you came to call yourself Marshcar but everyone knows you as fernfox and it should stay that way please don't change your name all the time I like the name fernfox and still don't know if you're english or german but please stick with the name fernfox

@puzzlepuddles6712 Год назад

SEUS shaders are always just so inexplicably NUTTY when it comes to sheer realism. everything from the lighting to the tones... this man gets down to business when someone tells him to make a realistically accurate shader, he MAKES it

@loafofbreadgaming2366 2 года назад

3.0

@NightMare_Productions 2 года назад

which version of minecraft is V3.0 for again, cuz in 1.18 it glitches badly

@cremacream8983 2 года назад

3.0 is more of a major update. Better darkness and saturation

@nocoreal 2 года назад

imagine with hdr 1000 and with those back leds for displays

@mrghostofficial_ 7 месяцев назад

Seus ptgi hrr 3 looks only better inside houses or buidling and in dark places

@Neil256 2 года назад

How are your jumps so smooth?

@zixy_script 2 года назад

Hrr 3.0 is better is a new version

@hectorjuncal2312 Год назад

And where are the 3.0? at the web i can only see the SEUS PTGI E12 , the e11, seus renewed and SEUS PTGI HRR Test 2.1

@Wedge_The_Almighty Год назад

Press on the ‘OLDER VERSIONS’ Link and it will take you to his patreon. First result is PTGI HRR 3.0

@flaikyy 2 года назад

ich weiß nicht wie du dazu kommst dich Marshcar zu nennen aber alle leute kennen dich unter fernfox und so sollte es am besten bleiben bitte ändere dein namen nicht die ganze zeit ich mag denn namen fernfox und weiß immernoch nicht ob du english oder deutsch bist aber bitte bleib beim namen fernfox

@OliveOil01 Год назад

Is seus ptgi used for Java or bedrock I’m assuming Java because Java gets the mass majority of the coolest looking things but i have seen some nice bedrock ones

@lennat24 10 месяцев назад

It's created for java. But I saw a comment that someone used it also for bedrock. He meant that it worked fine for him.

@spite8431 2 года назад

Its clearly 3.0

@Jannis001 2 года назад

Whats the texture pack used in this video?

@Marshcar 2 года назад

Patrix 64x

@flaikyy 2 года назад

and 3.0 is better

@flakooo Год назад

How do you get them to run with good frames

@milocavaliere8828 10 месяцев назад

what texture pack are u using here?

@itplay.s 2 года назад

Do a Iris vs Optifine video with the new Iris beta in their Discord server for PBR Support to see how close it gets to Optifine Obviously with fps counter

@Marshcar 2 года назад

Good idea! I'll add this to my upload queue :)

@BADI_QT9 7 месяцев назад

Ptgi hhr 2.1 is looking natural than 3.0

@arcticwolf0811 3 месяца назад

Has anyone checked if Sues PTGI HRR 2.1 is compatible with Distant Horizons?

@Marshcar 2 месяца назад

It isn’t yet sadly

@edgarprotsko1558 6 месяцев назад

How to activate foliage animation in seus 3 ?

@nocoreal 2 года назад

now show 3.0 first then 2.1 so i can give an unbiased review

@ShiPiX Год назад

i get blackscreen with hrr 3 and super noisy reflections with hrr 2.1

@edgarprotsko1558 6 месяцев назад

Whats the trees and grass mods?

@hometest8603 Год назад

i have an RTX 3060, what settings should i use on HHR3 for a 60 fps average gameplay? (im getting 30s on 2k and i dont know how to fix)

@Marshcar Год назад

What render distance / resolution are you using?

@hometest8603 Год назад

@@Marshcar 2k resolution 8 render distance because of cpu limitations

@shitsheet7277 Год назад

@@hometest8603 play 1080

@floatingnecc4842 2 года назад

wait when did you change your name? I couldn't find you for a bit

@Marshcar 2 года назад

Just a couple months ago, glad you were able to find me again! If you search up fernfox I still come up

@HumanGamer 2 года назад

What is the texture pack?

@milchi5122 Год назад

I have an urgent question. Im playing with ptgi hrr 3.0. it looks fantastic. however now that im playing 1.19, frog lights dont seem to be recognized as a light block (yet?). Does anybody have the same issue, or do you know if a newer version is in the works to fix this? looking forward for any reply

@lennat24 10 месяцев назад

You can try another texture pack.

@CharthusWayne 2 года назад

In HRR 3.0 I cant tell the difference between real life and that

@dronko-fire-blaster 2 года назад

cool but my computer might best in to flames

@KingFartsMan 2 года назад

Bro wut is your pc made of !!! (It doesn't even lag a bit)

@teamtitanium5012 9 месяцев назад

does the hrr 3 work for 1.20

@AJ_Zen 8 месяцев назад

Drops the game to 10-15 fps

@alenmack3471 Год назад

Honestly, BSL and Chocapic13 are way better. Why? Because the creators of those shaders didn’t make them for money. Sonic Ether is extorting money from younger Minecraft players. That’s fucked up. Mods and shaders should be free. That’s the entire point of modding games. They’re literally free DLC made by random people on the internet.