Exactly 🤣 A few former contestants already said that the most of the judges already know who they're gonna choose. It would be easier if they already make a group, instead of making 90+ girls cry and feel like shit.
I’m always surprise when people bitch about Mnet editing, yees sometimes it’s outrageous, but y’all don’t complain about your local reality shows. Never saw someone complain about big brother being scripted.
Ya Ning trained so hard to hone her skills and talents to the point where she was even well known among the c-trainees but all because the producers forced her to say something mean to Yujin, all that went down the drain as people started cancelling her left and right and calling her names and discrediting her talents and pretty much making sure that she would never have a career or at least a peaceful career in S. Korea. She even revealed that they producers apparently gave her OPTIONS, yes she had OPTIONS and the "but you don't" one was the least harsh among them like-
omg how could you leave out the legendary moment of hyunjin and heejin on mixnine, the way they both confirmed how they planned to kick heejin out the team just to get more screentime was hilarious🤣🤣🤣
The Stray Kids show traumatized me because seeing Felix and especially Minho crying was unbearable... idk if it was scripted or not but I still can't watch it.
I knew the whole elimination situation was hella fake, but I'm not sure that the kids knew too, their crying was too convincing. My thoughts are that the agency planned this but didn't tell them, so that their reactions will be more raw.
I still cry watching it these days. I don’t think the kids were made aware of it, but it still was staged. On the other hand the company eliminated most trainees of this big whole ass group to end up with the 9 final members so I guess there was somehow a consent on debuting them together.
@@HopeeInk I also think that the kids did not know (at least those who were eliminated) because I saw Minho helding back to the last, tears were there in his eyes, but he was holding on and broke down and cried only when Chan hugged him ... But it was even worse to watch when he apologized with a meek gentle smile that he had let everyone down and could not pass. IT WAS A NIGHTMARE!
@@HopeeInk I think Chan might have known... I think he definitely discussed the lineup with JYPE during the show and knew, maybe not at the moment of eliminarion, but I'am sure that when JYP brought them back in, Chan had already known about it. Like... Chan wasn't even surprised back then, he seemed just glad and kinda relieved. As if something really hard and unpleasant was finally over. And someone said at that moment, either Han or Changbin "why didn't you tell us"? I think they meant Chan and the producers.
@@paladiana-maria8610 I have a strong feeling that people saying stuff like “boys knew, especially Chan since he’s a leader” - totally didn’t witnessed the reality show in real time in 2017. even If elimination was staged by the company, I’m pretty much sure boys didn’t know, cause you can’t stage such pain and boys to this day always talk about how hard of a time they had during eliminations and how lost they were. felix said he came back to the dorm thinking it was over for him. minho almost never cries and the fact that he did it there makes me realise how truly painful it was for him. all of us cried, we signed petitions and made a lot of hashtags to ask company to give them second chance, I personally thought that and fans love for the members was the reason why they gave it to them.
Lol... I'm in love with Somi... This girl is so good at spilling beans... And I love the fact she always agrees also what mistakes she do like for example in an interview she also revealed that it was a time in Produce 101 when she had Celebrity Disease!!.....Stanning Somi is a flexx.
I feel really bad about the Fu Yaning because I believed it happened for a long time girls planet was the first Mnet show that Ive seen and I really loved Yujin so I completely forgot about ALL the things I had heard about mnets editing and even when people told me it was fake I wasn't going to believe it it was very toxic of me and it was hard for me to admit it was fake because I didn't want to admit I was wrong 🤦♂ very dumb of me I genuinely believe Fu Yaning might have made it into Kep1er if it wouldn't have been for that
yaning is thriving as a soloist in china now and i became a fan during the show at least there's that she did gain fans that's pretty much the only bright side to her being on gp999 but it's better than nothing
Produce programs are extremely manipulated. Starship paid for Wonyoung's 1st place and everyone knows. There was no way she could have beaten Sakura and been in 1st place. It was impossible... But, the producers wouldn't let a Japanese be the center. P.S: and it worked out right... she became the center of the group and today she is one of the most well-known idols of the 4th generation. And let's face it, she pretty much pays the company bills... I mean her group.
@@josebenitez2945 :( it's sad I love Chaewon she really is one of the top most talented members in IZ*ONE but her popularity honestly did not go as high as for her debut in Produce. and Yuri too, amazing vocalist but no one paid attention to her. And possibly Minju and Yujin as their rankings were iffy...
@slayy~~ Well minju and yujin is kinda expected to debut because they are really popular during produce series. Even hyewon who were criticized for lacking is also very popular. And we all know, survival shows is more like a popularity competition.
The voice one didn't shock me, because NCT's Taeyong ale has been through something like that. Company wanted him to have more of lower tone. The Somi one was really shocking tho as it was her own initiative.
i dont think cha eunwoo having to change his voice on camera is a big deal, i think even rm from bts revealed he trys to speak in a higher voice so the camera came pick up his voice more clearly, maybe eunwoo does it for the same reason so his voice is clearer on camera, just think of it as his customer service voice
Fu Yaning was done dirty. Mnet just used her for ratings then proceeded to dump her. If Fu Yaning made it to the finale lineup then it would've made sense as a redemption story arc. Yaning was talented enough to be in Kep1er and could've been a Chinese friend for Xiaoting.
Ah... FYN. The hate in the comments was nothing short of vitriolic during that time. But she got all the way up to the finals. And had just a few more things go her way, we would have seen Kep1er | FYN (she was next after SXT as the 2nd-most likely to debut CN member). Comeback story in Kpop reality if I've seen one.
@@euneiros That was never going to happen unfortunately, but yes you're correct. FYN and SRQ were very, VERY close to debuting. Much closer than people realize.
These agencies really did this to want viewer attention and make the fool out of them but what about idols they did alot of work to come this far and yet they do vote manipulating just to favor their fav one its not fair i really hope these company see idols hardwork and potential
The stray kids one is actually pretty hurtful considering how personal that survival show was compared to the bigger ones. This was a group likely told they're on the debut team for months prior, but that this was their final passing test to actually debut and/or in a worst case scenario a surprise final test (after they already had recorded hellevator). Not only that, they basically utilized personal doubts to basically make them fear more to motivate vs actual productive criticism. You can see Felix's confidence in Korean basically be nonexistent for quite a while after their debut (more so than normal for foreign idols) and there's argument to be made that LeeKnow "stepped back" in a sense and then worried for the backlash for being so "cold". I don't doubt they both grew from the experience and that the group gained trust in each other "against" the producers which helped later in face of any drama, but at the same time it wasn't exactly successful in making people think it was real. LeeKnow being dropped was kind of a "don't know why you would drop the veteran dancer, but I guess okay", but Felix being dropped was kind of a "there's so few actual basses in Korea??? let alone idol beauty types????" sort of a moment that it made it clear it was for marketing. It did well for the group long term perhaps, but it was definitely a high risk high reward sort of situation. LeeKnow could've easily left to become a trainee elsewhere considering his experience and Felix could've easily also never bloomed with such a confidence hit at that age/also left considering again a true bass is so hard to find. This of course isn't including the damage to the other members (though I guess it was good practice for when Woojin left).
I never understood the argument of Felix not speaking Korean well. Like you casted him literally 6 months ago, you know his capabilities. They deeply traumatized a kid for views and made him the butt of a joke in a nation he tries to enter. Never okay with it.
@@HopeeInk it really picked at something so personal and vaguely irrelevant to being an idol too. Like his pronounciations are good and you couldnt tell in song, and there's definitely a lot more foreign idols with less Korean ability debuting that time too (I mean I love Eric Nam but his Korean when he debuted too was weak af)
Alright No offence I love straykids and All But Them suddenly adding Minho and Felix Give me flashbacks to sixteen when Tzuyu and Momo got added to twice
I think it's sad they make people stage it, it should be more like Somi? She suggested it, the director agreed, it did create effect and the aftermath is funny. The other ones are just sad.
speaking in separate voices is something we all do lmao. i change mine, both pitch & volume, in different social situations. i’m guessing girls don’t do it that much?
I agree with the SKZ stuff it always gav me a Momo vibe. Once eliminated and then one of the most beloved member. It worked for Felix though but torturing CHan like that is the worst to me it they truly did not tell him
Lol eunwoo isnt the only one who has an "idol voice" they do it to stick with their debut image. Everyone in astro started with a high pitched voice to show their "energetic" and fresh vibe
Please Micheal Jackson himself talked in a fake voice in front of camera. He used a higher pitch, it’s said that the reason for it was to train his vocal cords 24/7 or at least every time he speaks. It’s normal in many cultures to adjust your pitch and tone depending on the social context.
They all compete for more screen time this show has literally 101 people running around so you do what you gotta do. I’m suprised that she didn’t start a fight with a real person, but rather fights the camera. I think this also speaks for her character
The idol school scandal was also very controversial . . . . it was reported by a former contestant that 8 out the 9 currents fromis_9 members had signed their contracts before shooting even began.
Ok but what if Yaning could’ve went on to become a Kep1er memeber and that fake tension ruined her chances. That’s the problem with fake fights and shitty editing these are survival shows where voting is a factor purposely tainting a specific members reputation can cause irreparable damage to their potential careers. Like yes I expect some staging and whatnot but it still gives me the ick.
they evil-edited Yaning, Zing Qiao, Cai Bing, & Ruiqi coz all of them were threats to their Korean favorites, they only need one Chinese member and that was Xiaoting. And if you think Xiaoting wasn't evil edited then you're wrong, they made her a lousy dancer during their "How You Like That" performance where she was the center. They made Xiaoting feel that she was not enough for a main dancer & center position. MNET also used Yurina for the XiaoRina clout and then throw her off the bus by changing the rules in the final voting. It was pretty obvious coz if they won't change the rules, then there is a possibility that 4 or 5 Chinese members and 3 Japanese members will make the cut, and either Xiaoting or Yurina will become the center
@@lenolands oh definitely. With the tense relationship between Korea and China right now, it seemed unlikely that there would be many “foreign” members. They did the Chinese contestants very dirty,
Mnet also didnt air the part where somin being a irresponsible brat, they include it in the upcoming clip, but not in the actual airing clip. They air another contestant instead. I am surprised no one saw it and never discuss it.
I hate how they staged Felix and Lee Know leaving Stray Kids. That is not ok in no shape or form and was probably really traumatizing for all of the members. Felix got revenge by being the most popular member when they debuted lol.
Even if JYP has done for more viewers attention in Stray Kids survival show, then its obvious that boys didn't know about the staged program. If some think that Skz members also know about it before, then hell yeah Skz deserves an Award of acting from rookie time. Because when I watched the show I never felt anywhere that all the boys are acting, still today I watched it repeatedly again still I found their reactions in elimination time are emotional and genuine.
The Pritz one doesn't even fit since it wasn't "staged". Also thank you for posting numerous shots of the Japanese rising sun flag on Korean Liberation Day.
Bro SM also made Taeyong use a lower tone while talking and recording even though Taeyong had a lighter and breathier tone. Taeyong talked about it himself and said how the trainers ordered him to use lower tone and huskier pitch and how he had to practice talking like that for so long. U can notice it in the first few years of NCT's recordings and shows. I'm glad that he now has liberty to use his own voice and pitch and that's also evident in the recordings
"We Go Up! But you don't" I feel sorry for Fuyaning who received a lot of hate because of this. She's an all rounder and maybe debuting in kep1er is not for her. I'm glad that she debut her solo now in china
i'm very sure that the skz show was scripted at least to a certain degree and they were never planning on actually eliminating minho and felix, but i do believe that the members weren't aware of that at the time. Their reactions just feel too sad and actually shocked to me. but then again we can never really know what these companies are doing
What happened to the Stray Kids survival (which I watched during that time) is happening now with HYBE's The Howling. It feels fake and too scripted, giving the members anxiety.
No hate at all, I didn't watch The Howling I only saw some parts when a streamer reacted and tbh its nowhere near the skz survival show. I don't blame the participants but skz show was based on making a song, performance, battles and also interactive content (if u take out the traumatizing parts) but with the moderner shows it feels like they put the members on a forced interaction to make weird things that the show gets more attention... to me it's just boys with dreams and prolly also good talents (which weren't promoted enough in the show from what I saw) auditioning but the show is not what they expected and they get anxious bcz it's not what they prepared for. Idk it's just the directors and editors making the interactions extremely awkward. And yeah as u said it comes of as scripted and it's not even funny like who had the idea to make a boy uncomfortable by making him meow like a cat which doesn't sound nowhere near like a cat just for the sake of going viral???
6:40 im never going to shut up about x1 they deserved to continue their activities just like izone, they should've disbandaed both groups then, not just one
We can't tell if it was staged or not but the kids obviously didn't know did you see how raw their emotions were?they cried even lee know who never cries did also Felix was called back the next day or something
@@stays4514 i'm not saying that everything was staged, i'm saying thatit felt like jyp had planned their 9 member debut since the start but he didn't tell the members (i could be wrong, after all it's just a speculation)
@@mini6811 yes I agree with you I think jyp knew they would debut as 9 memebers cause they already released hellevator mv but he didn't tell them🤷♀️but we can't be so sure you know
Imma be real honest I DO NOT see the resemblance with the imperial flag and flag that pritz used.I rewatcg3dbthat part several times even screenshot it and I DONT see the difference