Shorts: The Depressed DMs Top 5 Intro D&D Modules 

Thanks!

Nice!

You could certainly argue that, and I wouldn't argue back :)

My favorite as well but you can easily make the argument for B1. The only real drawback for B4 is the DM needs to fill the inverted ziggurat if you want to continue to the actual Lost City. It will take a lot of fleshing out and for some DM's this is a boon and for others a bust.

@@swirvinbirds1971 Definitely a boon for me, I think that is part of what makes it great. B4 gives you a fantastic framework then lets you fill it in and figure it out yourself and personalize it. I also think by the time you get to that part of the adventure you know where you want to go with it. As for B1 that's really just a monster and treasure full in the blank, it doesn't require the same creativity. Though I have added a lot of cool things to B1 for example in room 24 I added a Mirror of life trapping(that only holds one person) with Melissa (Rogahns lover) trapped inside. She is helpful and can be released by smashing the mirror and she will join the party, you can also use her to tell where Rogahns and Zelligar went and perhaps connect it to a bigger campaign or another module.

@@BX-advocate actually my mistake I meant B2. Totally agree. 👍

@@swirvinbirds1971 I mean B2 is good and I do like it. However I unfortunately end up running it for every new group I start (which is also unfortunately a lot) and so I've gotten tired of it. Like I love it and it works so well to introduce people to the game especially old school but I want more exotic maybe pulp adventure but B2 is more classic medieval fantasy.Also people seem to be able to handle B2 better because most people aren't familiar with any fantasy other than Lord of The Ring, Game of Thrones or Harry Potter.

Nah bro, these are good for ALL D&D, if I had to start doing editions, we'd be here all week just listing them :)

Considering B2 had conversion at the end specifically for AD&D would support Scott's list.